That well-intentioned screen time limit you set for your child? It might actually be making screens more desirable. This video dives into the science behind this paradox and reveals what actually works.
The insights are based on a fascinating study by Michal Maimaran and Yuval Salant called "The effect of limited availability on children's consumption, engagement, and choice behavior".
The revealing LEGO Experiment from the study:
Researchers gave two groups of four- to five-year-old children LEGOs to play with.
- Group 1 was given a 10-minute time limit.
- Group 2 was given no time limit at all.
The stunning result: The children with the time limit played significantly longer. They averaged 494 seconds of playtime, while the group with no limit played for only 390 seconds. The restriction itself increased their engagement and desire for the activity.
So, what are better strategies than constant time limits? This video explores alternatives grounded in psychology:
Curate Their Environment: Proactively manage which devices and apps are available in the first place.
Foster Positive Alternatives: Create engaging offline activities that naturally compete with screen time.
Use Natural Consequences: Link the end of screen time to a logical next event rather than an arbitrary timer.
Collaborate on a Plan: Create a media usage schedule with your child to foster autonomy and self-regulation.
Source: Maimaran, M., & Salant, Y. (2019). The effect of limited availability on children's consumption, engagement, and choice behavior. Judgment and Decision Making, 14(1), 72-79.
About the Author: Eskil Burck is a psychological advisor and textbook author. He teaches psychology for Kalaidos University of Applied Sciences (Zurich). His psychology podcast "psychologie-lernen.de" consistently ranked #1 on iTunes in the "Education" category. His books "Angst - was hilft wirklich ...?", "Das manipulierte Gehirn" and "Neue Psychologie der Beeinflussung" became Amazon bestsellers. Even in his spare time, he enjoys reading studies...😅🙈 For more information, visit: www.learningpsychology.net
but only 10 minutes.
[Music]
Many parents set time limits for
activities they regard as problematic.
So for example, they say, well, you may
only watch 1 hour of television or you
may only play 30 minutes of video games
or you get only 20 minutes of tablet
time. But what's the psychological
effect of that? There is an interesting
study published in 2019 in which four to
five year old children were told by an
experimental, well let's play Legos.
Here are some Legos for you. And then
they were shown some Lego stones which
were nothing special, just the usual
ones. So no high-tech spaceship or
something like that, just normal Lego
stones. Then the experimentter said,
"Well, when you're finished with
playing, just come to my table." But in
one group, the experimental said at this
point, well, I'm sorry, but you can only
play for 10 minutes. So, in one group,
there was this time limit. What were the
results? In the group with the time
limit, the children were playing on
average 27%
longer. So, somehow this time limit had
made playing with Legos more
interesting. And the psychological
mechanism that is probably at work here
is reactance. Humans like their freedom
and we really don't like it if our
freedom gets limited. And as soon as our
freedom gets limited, people show
reactance. They show behavior to gain
back their freedom. And of course, it's
very often used in marketing when we are
told, well, there's only one item left
in stock. This is the last product that
is left. then we really want to have
this last product. And it's quite
similar with children who get told,
well, you may only play for 20 minutes
with the PlayStation or you may only
watch TV for 1 hour. Then they really
wanted more. But of course, this is
problematic because this is just the
opposite that parents want to reach. We
don't want that they want to watch TV
even more because what are they going to
do as soon as we leave the house? Of
course, they will just do what they were
told they may not do.
But what's the solution? Should you
really no longer set time limits? Well,
of course not. If you have all these
temptations at home, like a TV, like a
PlayStation, like tablets, smartphones,
etc., then a time limit is still better
than saying, well, you can play 10, 12
hours with these things. No, social
media and all that is too tempting. it's
too well programmed to catch the
attention. So in this case, time limits
are still better. But a much better
solution might be that you don't have
these temptations at home to begin with.
So it really might be better to have no
PlayStation or no television and
especially not in the room of your kids
or to give your children no smartphone
or no tablet up to a specific age like
for example 12. I know it's a tough
decision and you might say, "Well, but
they will be begging me to get them a
smartphone." Yes, they will. But what's
even worse is when they have the
smartphone, all these little wars with
your child, you will have because of the
smartphone and the smartphone use. This
will be much more trouble. And if you
say, "Well, this is too hard." There
might be an interesting compromise which
technology offers and those are
children's safety modes on those
devices. So you can decide which apps
your child will be able to use. So maybe
an app for drawing or an app for writing
or in calculator. And then you might
also say well but you may only use those
apps for 20 minutes per day. That's it
for today. I hope you found this episode
helpful. If you want to know more about
psychological science, you may want to
take a look at the website or at the
books. But if you go to the website,
don't stay longer than 10 minutes.
[Music]
[Music]