A few years ago, many researchers were in agreement: By far the most important requirement for education and vocational success is a high mental capacity (intelligence). However, even the best intelligence tests can not explain all variance in life success. Every once in a while a highly intelligent student gets dropped out of the education system without finishing (underachiever), whereas another student who scored below average in an intelligence test, ends up with a fantastic academic career (overachiever). Recent studies (e.g. Duckworth & Seligman, 2005; Moffitt et al 2011) suggest that such "irregularities" mainly come about due to the factor of self-control (also: self-discipline, perseverance). Amazingly, in some studies self-discipline proved to be a better predictor than intelligence...
Keywords: self-control - self-discipline - grit - perseverance - psychology - intelligence - underachiever - overachiever - predictor - grade point average - delay of gratification - marshmallow experiment - Duckworth - Seligman - Moffitt - New Zealand - physical health - income - risk behaviour - single parent child rearing - financial struggles - Poropat - Big Five - agreeableness - extraversion - neuroticism - Openness - conscientousness - academic performance - motivation - brain - educational psychology
Hello and welcome back to the world of
psychology
Is self-control more important than intelligence?
many psychologists
love their intelligence tests because they are so economic they cost only small amounts of money and
only small amounts of time
Nevertheless, they are really good predictors for academic success
For example your grade point average
But they are also good predictors for success at the workplace
so
Based on a test with a duration of maybe 40 minutes
One hour or one and a half hour
You can say you can predict well
This boy or this girl has good chances for a successful
academic career
but
Even though
Probability is on your side for this prediction
We all know cases in which highly intelligent students
Don't make it
They are what we call
Underachiever based on their intelligence. We would expect better grades more success
But for any reason they just don't make it and on the other hand
There are overachiever students who make it even though we wouldn't expect it
so obviously
intelligence is not everything and
Another really
Important factor may be an even more important factor than intelligence is
self-control or
You might call it
self-discipline
perseverance grit
which for sure isn't exactly the same as
motivation because many people are motivated to stop smoking to exercise more or
to study more
But after a week or two they quit
They were really motivated
but what they lack is
self-control one of the most important studies in this research field was published by
Angela Duckworth and Martin Seligman in
2005 in the well-known journal
psychological science the title
Self-discipline outdoes IQ in predicting academic performance of
adolescents
so based on their study results, they claimed that self-discipline is
Not just as important as IQ
but it even outdoes IQ in predicting academic performance and this
Might have been provocative because up to this study
Intelligence was regarded as the most important predictor for academic performance
But let's take a look at what they did. They conducted two studies with two
consecutive
cohorts of eighth grade students in the first study they had
148th graders and in the second study they had
164 eighth graders and all they did was to assess
self-control by
Asking their parents their teachers, but also by asking the pupils
themselves and they also conducted delay of
gratification tasks
You probably heard about Walter Mischel's
marshmallow
experiments
These experiments are so interesting that the whole next episode will be on this topic in
short
You present the kids a marshmallow or another sweet, which it really likes and
You say well, you can either have one marshmallow
right now or
You wait
Until I come back because I have to do something else or you wait until I come back
Then you can have two marshmallows. You can decide for whatever you want. It's your decision
I have to go now
I'll be back in some minutes and then you leave the room and you watch what the kid is going to do
Walter Mischel observed that
Four-year-old children that succeed to wait
to delay the gratification
showed higher academic and social functioning
More than a decade later
So the delay of gratification test is also a good
measurement of
self-control and in the study of Duckworth and Seligman there were on the one hand
Hypothetical delay of gratification tasks in
which the pupils were presented scenarios and they had to decide well in this case would I go for the
Instant gratification or would I wait for the bigger reward?
But in the second study there also was a real delay of gratification task
They were given an envelope with one dollar
really a lot of money and
they were told well, you can take the dollar now or
You wait one week and you hand me the closed envelope and you will get
sensational two dollars
So this was how they assessed self-control a really broad assessment of self-control
In the second study
they also conducted an
Intelligence test which was the 40 minute lasting school ability test
requiring verbal
quantitative and
figural reasoning and
To find out what is the better predictor IQ or self-control all they had to do was to correlate
Self-discipline and
intelligence
with
the grade point average of the pupils and
What they found was really remarkable
because in this study
self-discipline was really a much better predictor for grade point average and
also for selection to high school and
As they also correlated
self-discipline with homework hours the time of day when homework was begun and
television hours
they were also able to give an
explanation for their results
Because they found well, this is not too surprising that pupils with higher self-discipline
started
homework more early
They spent more hours doing homework and
They watched clearly less TV
So this might be some of the underlying mechanisms
These results were really impressive
Nevertheless, there are some things to keep in mind. First of all
Self-discipline in this study was assessed really well broad and extensive
Intelligence on the other hand was assessed with a 40 minute intelligence test, which is okay, but
But you have to know that usually
the longer the test is
the more reliable the test is so maybe if they chose a
two hour intelligence test
They would have assessed intelligence more exact and this would have
Increased the correlation between intelligence and grade point average
another reason that might have led to an underestimation of the
IQ grade point average correlation might have been
the low variation of intelligence in their sample of eighth graders
In fact, the variance of intelligence in their sample was smaller
Than what is usually found in the general population and
If the variance is small
the covariance the correlation
Cannot become really high. So this might have led to an underestimation of
the correlation between IQ and grade point average
nevertheless, if you statistically
normalize the variance of IQ
the correlation between grade point average and intelligence still remained smaller than the
correlation between self-discipline and
grade point average
another point of
criticism you can put forward is
the assessment of
self-discipline via
questionnaires
Because the pupils themselves
Just like their parents and their teachers they all
know the grades of the pupil and
When asked to report the self-discipline, they might have taken the grades
into account
So for example, you ask the pupil. Well, do you have self-discipline?
Then the pupil thinks about his or her situation
Thinks about well at home. I'm not that disciplined. I
should tidy up my room and
Also at school. I'm probably not that disciplined because my grades aren't that good
So no, I'm not that disciplined if this information
Influences the self-report or the teacher and parent report then it's no wonder that there is a correlation between
The self-discipline score and the grade point average
So probably in this study self-discipline was a little bit
Overestimated whereas intelligence was a little bit
underestimated
Taken together and if we take these points of criticism into account
Self-discipline might be an equally good predictor as
Intelligence
more evidence for the
Importance of self-control not only for academic success, but also for life success in general
for example for physical health or income
derives from one of the biggest
Longitudinal studies that were ever conducted in this study about
1,000 children
were
Scientifically accompanied beginning at the day of their birth in the year
1972
until now
so they are still coming to the labs to be checked and
What makes this study really unique is that they have such a small drop-out rate
usually if you conduct a
Longitudinal study you have the big problem that
after 30 years
Many participants have left the country and are no longer available
but this study was conducted in Dunedin, New Zealand and
As you know all around New Zealand. There's ocean everywhere
Besides New Zealand isn't the worst country to live
So the urge to move is not that strong and
If people left the country in this study, they were paid the flight by the researchers
so you can see it's been a really expensive and well done study and
the results of this study are
really interesting in
2011
some of these
Interesting study results were published by Terry Moffitt and her
research team and
What they did was they gathered self-control ratings by parents teachers
but later also by friends
across the ages of three five seven nine and
eleven so they got one self-control score for childhood
which they
correlated with
outcomes of life success at age
32 and
even after controlling for IQ and
social economic status
Which were correlated with the self-control score even after controlling for these
Childhood self-control was a good predictor for physical health
Substance dependence
income financial struggles
single parent child rearing and
Criminal conviction at age
32
For children rate is high in self-control. The probability to live in poverty was
three times lower
similar sizes of effect were observed for health problems and
for crime conviction
another interesting observation of this study was that
children with poor self-control
Were making more mistakes in adolescence
Which in turn resulted in quote
snares
That trapped them in harmful lifestyles
So the problem of low self-control in adolescence is
You start smoking
you become dependent of other substances like alcohol or
you become father or mother without a
sufficient financial base and
These decisions can make it really hard for you in the long run
So interventions
Aiming on improving self-control should take place in adolescence or even earlier
In order to show you that quite different lines of research have
come to
similar results
I want to present to you a really gigantic
Study from the psychology of personality
In this research field the most influential model up to now is the so-called five factor model
or big five factor model and these five factors of personality
are
Agreeableness
How good do you get along with other people?
Conscientiousness
Are you going to do what you promised to do?
emotional stability or
neuroticism
Do you worry about everything what people might think about you?
Extroversion do you like to be in the middle of attention and openness?
Do you like new experiences?
Or do you prefer to stay at home in your bed
Where it's so cozy
of course
scientists want to know which of these factors
Are important for life success, for example for academic success
And to investigate this question
Poropat
Conducted a meta-analysis of the five factor model of personality
and academic performance
And published the results in 2009
in the journal psychological bulletin
the only one personality factor
In all these studies and they had cumulative
sample sizes that ranged to over
70,000 participants the only one personality factor
That correlated with academic performance
Meaningfully was
Conscientiousness
Are you going to do what you promise to do? Are you going to do what you decided to do?
and
obviously, it's the personality factor, which is
closely
related to
self-control
and of course for employers, this is a really important information because
when looking for job applicants
You should not only be interested in their intelligence
but
also in their reliability
And of course, you should also look for other aspects like social compatibility, etc
And with these words I say goodbye
See you next time