We're used to look for life on exoplanets. But what if we're looking in the wrong place? Can life exist without a planet? Finding out in this interview.
00:00 Intro 00:59 Life on Earth 03:57 Life without a planet 27:32 Finding life with no planet 35:50 Terraforming Mars 35:50 Current obsessions 42:00 Bonus part and more interviews
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
the search for life in the universe has
been focused on thinking about planets
both planets in the solar system as well
as exoplanets around the universe that
you know we know that life formed here
on planet Earth and so it makes sense
the low hanging fruit is other planets
but does life really need a planet could
you have a situation where life is able
to create some of the basic pressure
temperature and the chemical
combinations to be able to survive
outside of a planet and if so how would
we recognize it and how would we search
for it so my guest today is Dr Robin
woodsworth he's a professor of planetary
science at Harvard he has a new paper
that talks about searching for life
forms in the universe that are outside
of planetary habitats and sort of how
life could actually handle all of those
issues and how we might be able to find
them so enjoy this fascinating
conversation with Dr Robin woodsworth
Robin what benefits is life getting from
a planet like the Earth for
free benefits for free uh great question
so we we live in this wonderful place
where we have a source of free energy
which is the sun uh it's been steadily
burning for billions of years we have
liquid water which is essential for Life
as we know it for carbon based life and
Earth has this amazing ability to
recycle
key volatiles and so so carbon dioxide
in the atmosphere for example is is kept
regulated we think by um PL tectonics
which is um uh driving material into
into The Mantel and then outgassing of
CO2 from volcanoes and um we think that
that's that's something which operates
over time with a negative feedback to to
keep climate stable and it's not
something we see on other planets in the
solar system at all so uh this kind of
combination of of um free energy from
the Sun liquid water and and uh cycling
processes in the planet that keep
volatiles fresh if you like those are to
me kind of the three key things that are
that are most important but we also get
like atmospheric pressure we get uh
reasonable temperatures I mean there's a
whole bunch of gravity sure yeah so uh
the pressure the pressure is important
and the temperature important you
because they give you liquid water and
I'm you could imagine situations I guess
where um
there's there's water but it's so hot
that proteins unfold or DNA becomes
unstable or something like that but by
and large when you've got conditions
that give you liquid water it's there's
most likely going to be a type of life
that it's going to be able to survive
there and so that's the key thing that
the atmospheric pressure gives us and
actually it's a kind of interesting
unsolved question why Earth has a one
bar atmosphere and not something else we
know it's because of the nitrogen that's
present there but we actually don't have
a good theory of why why nitrogen levels
are what they are in the atmosphere yeah
that that's absolutely critical um and
um the the temperature regulation yeah
that's one of the key things in uh in
plantry um habitability generally and
then the third one you mentioned
presence of gravity um that's probably I
mean that's profound in plant Evolution
because um even if you if you shift
Gravity by a fairly small amount so if
you go from Earth to to Mars for example
Mars is a planet that in many respects
it's quite earthlike um you know it has
it also has water but mostly in the form
of ice it uh has other volatiles present
but because its gravity is that little
bit lower it's lost atmosphere over time
it's shut down play tectonics and so the
these things these kind of secondary
effects that we think are really
important for for keeping life present
those maybe they were there in the
beginning for Mars but they they shut
down pretty
quickly um and you know radiation
protection I mean there's there's so
many of these of these benefits and and
so it's you know it's understandable
that astrobiologists have thought about
searching for life on planet but you've
got a new paper where you're wondering
could you get life without the planet uh
so what like what are you
suggesting yeah so um I mean first of of
all it's kind of the sensible thing to
do right to say we want to look for
planets that are earthlike elsewhere
because that that's what we know and in
a way that the central problem of
astrobiology is that we have one example
of an inhabited planet and so we have to
base everything off of that um but our
aim in this paper was to extend things a
little bit and and and to to kind of say
if we um relax some of our assumptions
what might life elsewhere start to look
like and in particular one of the things
we were interested in is life outside
planetary gravity Wells and so we we do
have examples of life outside uh Earth
gravity well because of course we humans
have gone into space we have the
International Space Station and we're
capable of generating habitable bubbles
out there but but we do it through what
we see is our intelligence our ability
to use and and generate technology and
so uh one way you could pose the
question is to say we know that
sufficiently complex life can generate
habitability elsewhere how complex does
life really need to be in order to do
that if you had life that was
non-sentient what kind of minimal
physical structures could it generate
elsewhere that that could allow
habitability so that was that was the
opening point for our paper if you like
yeah and and that line in the paper kind
of blew my mind I was sort of thinking
about that and you're like you know
we're always talking about how we've
we've never found any life outside of
Earth but in fact we have we we've seen
astronauts waving from the Moon and so
we did it we we were able to look at the
Moon uh with our cameras and spot the
presence of life and so we are capable
of finding life in other places than
planet Earth now of course it was just
us all along but still uh you know I
think that that line has been has been
already crossed so but obviously it's an
interesting starting point to say okay
well like we know clearly a complex life
form with a sufficient technology stack
and a motivation and will to do this was
able to pull off at least temporarily
not being on on planet Earth and
now let's sort of downgrade the the
complexity or the sophistication of the
organisms that are doing this can we
still have some form of life out
there yeah right and it's kind of I mean
the paper is laying out some of the
first mathematical calculations of this
stuff so it's as much a road map as a as
an entire uh fleshed out idea for for um
what this sort of life might look like
but the way we focused it was to say
first of all we're going to we're going
to do carbon based life we're not going
to make this all completely General
types we're going to assume that it's
carbon based so it needs liquid water
and we're going to start with what the
requirements are we kind of touched on
that already so um you need free energy
you need liquid water you need some
source of building blocks which in the
case of carbon-based life is uh the
so-called chops elements so carbon
hydrogen oxygen phosphorus nitrogen
sulfur maybe I missed one there but
there's kind of essential elements that
um you see in many places in the solar
system like meteorites for example they
they tend to be present and so we're
saying we're saying those need to be
present you need free energy and um from
there what kind of biological systems
can uh can allow those habitability
criteria to operate and so we already
talked a little bit about pressure and
temperature so um if you have a uh
biological structure so so looking at
the probability the the looking at the
properties of uh known um
biomaterials what kind of pressures
would you need to sustain and what kind
of things could you do to to regulate
temperature and kind of to our surprise
it turned out that just using no and
biomaterials all of the requirements of
habitability can be satisfied beyond
Earth wow so so give me a sense of of
what this might look like uh what would
be a an an earth life form that could be
actually maintaining
a suitable environment for itself just
out in space so the concept we we
developed was this uh idea of a living
habitat so if you have a structure which
has a wall that um prevents volatile
loss that stabilizes liquid water and
allows enough sunlight through to get
photos photosynthesis occurring on the
inside then um you could you could have
something which was either uh in in deep
space or attached to the surface of an
icy Moon or something like that and uh
if it's capable of regenerating wall
material over time and uh consuming raw
materials then you at that point have a
living organism essentially it can grow
it can replenish itself and um in in the
concept we looked at we were assuming
that you need sunlight in order to
photosynthesize possibly you could use
chemical energy but uh sunlight is
preferable because that's a a much
larger total source and so you can
imagine habitat of um arbitrary size
that um exist in space and and and grow
through time and um most importantly for
the purposes of astrobiology they
wouldn't necessarily be constrained to
the habitable zone or even to the
gravity Wells of planets at all so this
has implications for how we think about
bios signature detection for example but
like I'm imagining from Star Trek I'm
imagining when they fought the space
amoeba and you've got this you know big
Blobby life form out in out in space I
mean is that on the right track is there
is there an analogy even down on Earth
where you've got some kind of life form
that is collected into a concentration
that has surrounded itself with some
kind of of membrane that is allowing it
to maintain an environment that is
different from what the the outer
environment is trying to do to it yeah
two two great thoughts there so first of
all there's definitely analogies with
sci-fi and you know in Academia we're
inspired by sci-fi all the time and
there's been thoughts in this direction
that that go way back if you if you look
into the literature there's people like
Dyson and even silovsky that speculated
on this without really doing any
calculations but but just propose that
this sort of thing might be possible but
so um analogies on Earth so the
interesting thing on earth is that um we
don't see that many examples of plants
that Thermo regulate to regulate their
own temperature they do exist you you
get um certain species that at um
certain times of the year they will
expand energy to to warm themselves up
but uh it's kind of a niche thing and we
certainly haven't seen life evolve for
example to to so that you have plants
growing over Arctic regions where they
locally Elevate temperature and uh
generate habitability there but so I
mean I think the The Stance we were
taking with the paper is that you
shouldn't uh rule out something a
pathway for life just cuz it hasn't
happened on Earth yet and so um the
scenario the specific scenario we put
forward is a possibility for how this
could emerge on other planets is say you
have a planet which is losing its
atmosphere through time and that the the
atmospheric pressure is Getting Thinner
it's harder for organisms to survive and
you would then have a strong
evolutionary pressure to locally
regulate temperature and pressure and so
um although we don't see a ton of
examples of this type of behavior on
Earth today there there are some cases
and um there's no reason to believe that
biology couldn't take different Pathways
in different circumstances so we think
that you should this shouldn't be ruled
out at all I mean I think about my
compost pile which has U you know
bacteria inside of it and and when you
throw new material in or when you start
a new pile it heats up phenomenally I
mean compes piles can light on fire if
they're big enough and and and you've
got this chemical you know as long as
there is the raw material available for
the bacteria then it can continue to
maintain the temperature of the pile to
the point that it even starts to move
away from the places where it's just you
know it's either dyed and and or you
know and you're sort of constantly
maintaining the temperature to something
that that it's happy with and and I know
like if you know once it gets started
the pile would be really cold but then
it'll sort of increase the temperature
to the point that now the rest of the
bacteria kicks in and can really enjoy
this en environment and that really
feels like something that is you know
obviously it's not cut off it's not
surrounded by a
membrane but is getting to some kind of
level of temperature regulation sure
yeah and there's other cool examples
like um Saharan silver ants for example
they have tiny hairs on their exterior
their exoskeleton that um allows them to
survive in temperatures that no other
arthopods can can tolerate and so they
move move across the Sands of the Sahara
at um very high temperatures I think
it's up to like 40 uh 45 Celsius or so
and uh using using a form of thermo
regulation that they've evolved from
from scratch essentially right but but
we're not seeing
them on mass changing the environment in
the Sahara
Desert to better match what they would
prefer as opposed to they've theyve
evolved a way of dealing with a high
temperature as opposed to changing the
environment itself around that's right
absolutely although in a broader sense
it's definitely true that that life and
the environment of Earth has co-evolved
and of course the most famous example is
the great oxidation event so Earth was
an anoxic world and then um you have
oxygen generating cyanobacteria that
emerge and they begin to to produce
oxygen and eventually change the the
properties of the entire atmosphere and
that's actually a mass extinction event
when that happens it it it kills off all
these Aria that were happily surviving
in anoxic conditions before but in doing
so they create this environment where
you can you can have um respiration
that's on a much larger scale that's
giving rise to to large organisms that
that then over time changes the whole
nature of the biosphere and so we
definitely see Co evolution of Earth in
the environment that's a well
established concept and I guess what
we're saying here is that let's let's
consider this in ways that affect
temperature and go beyond planetary
gravity Wells and
uh I would argue there's no physical or
chemical reasons why uh life can't
survive in much more extreme
environments than we've seen on Earth so
far so I want to go through some of the
sort of specifics that you mentioned in
the paper like pressure for example um
you know like what are the what are the
ranges of pressure that that life could
withstand yeah so um a lot of a lot of
the work that's done on on thinking
about generating habitats in space is
kind of naturally focus on humans but we
humans are very finicky and and uh have
a pressure range of survival that's very
very narrow compared to a lot of other
organisms so it turns out if you're if
you're uh looking for survival of um
bacteria or algae or plants um they can
tolerate much much lower pressures and
so just you've got to stabilize liquid
water so you have to get above uh well
if you want to be precise you have to
get above 611 pascals at uh at the
freezing point of water and and as
temperature goes up you need to sustain
higher pressures but we're not talking
about a lot we're talking about um a few
kilopascals to about 10 kilopascals
which for context is like up to 10% of
the pressure on Earth today so more than
Mars but but less than earth right more
than Mars Mars um in least uh in a
equilibrium sense can't have uh stable
surface liquid water but not pressures
that require strong material uh
properties and so one of the things we
did in the paper was to go through KN
and biomaterials and look at what their
strengths were and it uh turns out with
even a thin uh layer of most
biomaterials you could easily sustain
those pressure differences to to
stabilize water so hard to achieve at
all right so so there are there are
materials that creatures on Earth can
create cell structures that are because
you've got that lower pressure
requirement you're not having to have
something that's really strong against
the vacuum of space it can be a very
like how
thin so um looking at some common
bioplastics you could talk you about
layers millimeters
thick um and then there's other there's
other things you have to worry about so
volatile loss is one it's not just that
you want to keep the water stable you
have to avoid it being lost to space and
so
um you you probably want your layer to
be a little bit thicker in order to make
sure the water wasn't out gassing at the
same time but uh we're talking about
about um thin layers that are achievable
knowing with with known materials and
then temperature um I mean I know that
when you're out in space even on the
surface of the Moon you're actually it's
hot that that you are it's hot and it's
very very cold right it's very very cold
but if you were in Eternal sunlight it
would actually be almost too hot here
where the Earth is right yeah and the
kind of the line of thinking we went
down um it it turns out that it's
probably better to be a bit further away
than the earth and so um as you get a
little further out you you the um
equilibrium temperature which is the the
temperature that you get if you say
energy in equals energy out so you're
you're getting your energy from the Sun
and you're doing thermal radiation to
space uh that balance gives you
equilibrium temperature um if you get
beyond Earth's orbits say Mars or the
asteroid belt that equilibrium
temperature drops well below the
freezing point of water but um because
there are several ways you can you can
have a greenhouse effect a solid state
greenhouse effect over a material layer
uh it's kind of better to have the the
outer temperature cold and then warm
temperatures only on the inside than to
have to deal with uh kind of shielding
like you mentioned of temp get getting
baked out in on the moon or uh going
even closer in and so um because I think
generally it's
it's easier to get hold of volatiles if
you're a bit further out it it's
preferable to be at orbits a bit further
away than Earth although there's
certainly ways you can increase
reflection to uh to lower temperature on
the moon or on places like that as well
but it I mean it really starts to sound
like the asteroid belt when you know we
get into the next question which is
access to elements access to the raw
material I mean if your source of energy
is the sun that's also keeping you at
Aon reable temperature you've you you're
you're building this membrane that's a
couple of millimeters thick to surround
your resources you're out in the
asteroid belt now you've got access to
water you've got access to uh other
volatiles and other elements is that you
know do we think that we can get a
concentration of the sorts of elements
that are required for life to find a way
right yeah well I mean there's a lot of
material out there and um we think there
may be some on the moon as well there's
there's a debate going on right now
about how much volatiles there actually
are and the you have these permanently
shadowed craters at the poles of the
Moon that that um may be a good place to
look for volatiles and there's the
growing commercial interest in those but
um we know once you get to the asteroid
belt that uh there will be abundant
sources not just of um uh not just of
Rocky material but um carbon uh water
all these other essential uh compounds
for Life as We Know It And so that makes
it a logical place to think about if
you're if you're thinking about in the
solar system at least what these kind of
habitats would would look like and how
they would operate but but also like a
lot of the interesting rare elements
things that maybe were present on the
earth in large quantities but have sunk
down to the core and they're
inaccessible by life those things are
probably more readily available you've
got asteroids grinding into each other
smashing up turning into powder and
you've got this you know iridium is
available to
to your to your microbial life forms or
or whatever right or phosphorus or the
kinds of chemicals that maybe are more
of a rate limiting step here on Earth
those things might be even more
prevalent in places like the asteroid
belt or or you know farther out yeah
yeah right and and I mean some of that
is is material uh going to the core
getting gravitationally differentiated
if you like but some of it's just that
uh the the atmosphere and ocean is
oxidized as well and so if you look at
some of the key components that life
requires that it is it reminds you of um
an ocean that that's doesn't have any
Oxygen present and so you you have uh
these chemical compounds like iron and
malanum present that aren't so much in
in the modern ocean because when life
first appeared the conditions there
chemically speaking were just very
different and you're right the asteroid
belt none of that processing or at least
the type of processing has happened it
hasn't happened in the same way and so
uh there's far more elements available
there and then what about things like
gravity yeah well um gravity is good if
you want to rain an atmosphere when you
don't have any kind of Shield or
membrane over it but um if if it's um
possible to have a a biologically
generated barrier that retains volatiles
and keeps liquid water on the inside
then I'm not sure you really need a
gravitational well anymore so it becomes
a different way of thinking about life
and um it's it's strange to think about
because there's been so much focus on on
planets as um environments for Life
maybe icy moons if you push to uh the
sort of lower um lower extreme but um
yeah and I don't see in theory why a
gravity well would be required for for
these kind of life forms to survive and
you know one of the killers for Humanity
trying to explore the solar system is
the radiation but I mean water makes a
terrific uh protection against space
radiation right yeah well I mean humans
suffer we suffer quite a bit without
gravity as well right I mean because
we're these organisms that evolves on
land in an atmosphere we really don't do
very well when we're in microgravity for
long periods but simple forms of life
don't really care about that and the
radiation for humans is is a big deal we
um a lot of concern about that for for
human Mars missions for example but
again if you have if you have simpler
types of life then um the the radiation
environment is just not going to be as
big of a problem I don't think so the
impression that I got in in reading the
paper was that like one of the big
challenges is this ongoing balance
you've got the ultraviolet radiation
that is hitting the outer membrane of
this life form uh this Colony I don't
know what it is and it is degrading it
and so it needs to be able to replenish
it at a rate that matches the loss
thanks to the radiation as well as the
the ultraviolet radiation does that you
know does everything kind of hinge on
that I mean yeah but only in the sense
it hinges on it for anything we can
imagine constructing right I mean it's a
property of biological systems that
stuff degrades and you've got to
replenish it through time but it's a
property of industrial materials as well
I mean the solar panels that we use on
spacecraft they degrade Through Time
in in Mission planning you have to
project your solar power through time
how it's going to change because those
solar cells are degrading and and plan
your mission accordingly and so if we
buil some kind of industrial presence in
space and we're manufacturing solar
panels you'd have to take into account
the fact that they're going to degrade
and would need to be replaced as well
and so it's just kind of an innate uh
part of how uh self-generating systems
work that that um stuff gets broken down
and then needs to be recy
and um if it's if it's industrial
there's a certain way of approaching
that but if it's biological then uh you
you would want to recycle it in the same
kind of way as biology does on Earth
today and actually I mean it turns out
that the biolog is much better at
recycling in general than than uh we've
been with our Industrial Products so far
and so one of the things I find exciting
about this research direction is it's a
way to think about uh more Clos Loop
systems where you could you could have
components that get recycled and
regenerated and so you're not creating
endless waste as you as you build new
stuff because you have a part of the
system which recycles it as you go along
but I mean I think you know here on
Earth if you do have say ultraviolet
radiation that's degrading the the
atmosphere and you're getting this
breakup of particles it's still being
trapped by the gravity and so some
industrious life fir can grab the pieces
and use free energy and put them back
together again but in the weightlessness
of of space as you get this degradation
you're going to get your particles your
molecules uh floating away off into the
cosmos not where you know pushed by the
solar wind and so then it's about how
can you get an input that matches the
output right that's absolutely right and
I think one of the things we identified
in the paper is that if you're thinking
really long term for habitability
outside gravity Wells volatile loss is
is a is a problem and something you've
got to think about and that's true not
just for the kind of habitats we're
imagining but for human habitats or more
kind of
conventional uh like industrial
structures in Space the same the same
issues are going to apply that said for
for um what's getting lost a lot depends
on the property of the barrier and um
generally speaking if you have light
elements that are on the outside so
hydrogen in particular if photons come
in and they they split sort of an oxygen
hydrogen bond for example that hyd is
going to get lost and escape and that'll
be the end of it but if you have um
materials that are um not hydrogen
bearing or or in like sort of silicon
oxides for example like more um less
less volatile uh materials then what
gets lost will to to space that the rate
of it will dramatically decrease and so
uh a lot depends on the Material Science
and in the paper we kind of sketched out
how that might work but um it's a it's
it's sort of a road map and I think
there's a lot more research that that
could be done in that area so I mean
let's imagine that we explored the solar
system and found one of these
things what would it what would it look
like I mean it would be incredible but
um you would not want to you can't rule
out anything right um I think um the way
the way I imagine these things is um if
it's if there's photosynthesis then if
it's earth like they're going to use the
same uh the same color ranges so I mean
it would be green um there would there
would be kind of a membrane on the
exterior that would be diffusing so
there would be a kind of haziness to it
probably and then um the scale of the
things um we tried to do some
calculations about um what the optimal
scale might be and we came up with a
number of a few hundred meters and the
argument is that um if they're really
small then there's too much surface area
to volume so they'll they'll lose
volatiles too quickly but if they're
really big then light is no longer
getting into the interior and there's
this huge interior space that isn't
being used for photosynthesis and so
sort of tens to hundreds of meters is
about the scale that uh if it was if it
was using earth-based photosynthesis
that uh you would expect them to be on
and you could imagine that either being
free floating or or stuck to the surface
of an icy moon or
asteroid right um and I think that gave
us a bit of a hint on how we might be
able to detect them that if we've get
this uh you know if it's got say using
um like if it's using energy from the
Sun to do
photosynthesis then that gives you a
certain spec you know part of the
infrared the red Edge right that you
could get this reflection of the of the
of the light from this life form like if
you looked at it in different
wavelengths would it appear very obvious
in in infrared right yeah I think it's a
fascinating possibility to consider an
extra solar system if you were looking
either on planets outside the habitable
zone or maybe just sort of scattered
light from some from some diffuse region
in an asteroid belt or something like
that would you be able to detect this
this red Ed Edge feature which in the
past has been put forward for earthlike
planets as a way to detect vegetation I
think it's going to be a fun thing to to
follow up on that to to see what that
might look like of course that's it's
very different from how we think about
traditional bio signatures but I mean my
my thinking on this is that particularly
when we're in this time where these big
Next Generation facilities like the
habitable worlds Observatory they
they're in the planning stages right now
I think Now's the Time to be thinking
outside the box and considering a whole
range of possible bio signatures because
we again we've got this one example of
Life as We Know It On Earth and
the possibilities to my mind are much
much wider than that yeah that would be
just absolutely incredible if we turn
the habitable worlds Observatory or even
James web in the solar system we find
this really interesting signature this
red Edge infrared here in the solar
system in the asteroid belt and and that
goes well maybe we should go and take a
look at that and we can find I don't
know Blobs of biofilm on the outside of
some asteroid which is life finding a
way um does it now now you talked a bit
about about maybe the role that silicon
and other elements might play and
obviously you know you're focusing on
carbon based life forms but we have life
on Earth that does use some amount of
silicon but not as part of its kind of
core life process use it as a
exoskeleton things like that and so how
could we see other elements get involved
that's right right yeah we we have life
on Earth today which I mean silicon
based is probably the wrong word because
as you say it's not using silicon in its
DNA or anything like that but uh diatoms
in the ocean for example they they
construct uh uh shells or exoskeletons
which are silicon based and there's um
silica sponges there's many other
examples of organisms that that um use
silicon for for various biological
purposes and so um they're um
like life is very creative it's it's
found multiple ways to use elements that
are in its surroundings for for
different purposes and um to my mind
that's why it's not a wild stretch to
imagine even if you're just saying life
has to be carbon based as a starting
point you can still imagine ways you
could you could get structures that used
other elements and and um allows allowed
them to to generate habitability without
relying just on carbon and you're making
this assumption that the the form of
energy is going to be say sunlight but
there are possible forms of chemical
energy things like we have the deep sea
hydrothermal vents you know who knows
what other kinds of sources of you know
I can imagine radioactivity at some
point sure yeah um you know have you
thought about like how that would sort
of change the
calculations yeah and I mean so so these
things are why we're really interested
in Europa and Enceladus as as places to
look for life for example cuz
uh in icy moons the the the ice layer is
so thick that solar photons are never
going to get through but you could have
um chemical energy gradients that that
that allow life to keep going and you
could absolutely imagine this sort of
thing operating for free FL floating
life elsewhere too we didn't look at
that in too much detail in the paper and
part of the reason was that um solar
photons are such a good source of energy
that if you can get access to them then
that that's going to dominate uh but if
you had radioactivity if you if you had
chemical gradients then in a sense that
would make things even easier because
you could then have a planet that was
just completely encapsulated in some um
thick ice layer that that would keep uh
liquid water in the middle and it could
is actually been papers before hour one
on on this idea that you could have then
have these planets that were completely
free floating in in the galaxy and um
hard for us to detect with u current
technology but they they could have
little biospheres on them underneath the
ice and just be wandering around in the
in in the universe and we'd be none the
wiser yeah yeah yeah I'm really
fascinated by this idea of of rogue
planets we we think about the the
journey that it might take us to get to
the nearest star system whatever
4.3 light years to get to proximum centu
well in fact there could very well be
rogue planets halfway there that we
could use as these stepping stones and
in fact they could be places where there
there could the there could be more life
in the in the universe than we can even
comprehend it's just we will never be
able to find it um so once you sort of
put your mind into this very kind of
creative out of the- boox thinking and
you think about some of these you know
you mentioned the the diomes that use
silicon you know you I'm sure that
you've got to have this process where
you like hear about some kind of
biological um process that's going on
interestes in chemistry and think about
its applic or there some interesting
things that life is doing here on Earth
that you think boy that would be really
valuable in a free floating space in me
of a
colony yeah it was a fun paper to write
for that reason because you know I'm a
physicist by training so I'm it's not
like I studied biology at undergrad or
anything but you you read things and and
you you talk to people and you you kind
of realize that there's there's
interesting links that could be made and
so you kind of end up teaching yourself
about about um different processes as
you go along and I'm just always blown
away at how diverse life on Earth is and
how creative it is as well it's come up
with all these amazing ways of of uh
just like surviving in its environment
and and and dealing with challenges and
it may it makes it a very fun area to
research because you you always learning
things as you go along yeah yeah um
Robin what are you obsessed with right
now oh uh so my my mainstream research
is planetary science most of what my
group does is understanding the uh
climate evolution of Mars and Venus and
Earth over billions of years and also
looking at the possible climates of
exoplanets and so I'm really really
excited to understand what uh possible
bios signatures we could have on
exoplanets what kind of uh things we
should look for in in Mars's past
climate and so we we're planning to uh
continue a lot on that um on the more
closely linked to to um what we've just
been talking about I guess I'm I'm
pretty obsessed by the question of what
the future of life in space looks like
and and that um touches a lot on what
we've been talking about but we've been
talking about a lot about biology in
space there's other Visions where maybe
we mainly use robotics in space and and
the the um role of biology or even
humans is like become smaller and we we
just focus on Automation and so just
this question of what the future of life
in space will will be like I find that
fascinating uh I don't think I know yet
exactly what what it's going to be but
uh once you start thinking about it it
it's it's it's kind of hard to stop I
mean my sort of answer to the fmy
Paradox hinges on this on this idea of
robotic life in in space that yeah it's
really hard for human Humanity for human
beings for you know us meet robots to go
to space but robots they love being in
space they don't have any of these
problems with pressure and temperature
and and and they're much more resilient
to radiation and they don't mind
weightlessness and any of that kind of
stuff and really it's the question is
can you get the robot to do the kinds of
things that that life has evolved over
over billions years self-replication
being able to draw in your resources
from your environment be able to create
and that's that idea of these vono
probes that that you send a robot out to
the asteroid belt it finds all the raw
materials it requires crunches out spits
out a copy of itself you know they wave
goodbye and then they head off an
opposite directions Across the Universe
and eventually within 10 million years
or so you have your robots have arrived
at every single planet in the entire
Milky Way and so where are all the alien
you know I don't really wonder where all
the aliens are I wonder where all the
alien robots are sure and yeah and like
they but if they're robots that have
advanced to such an extent that they're
self-replicating I mean that is a form
of life then as well right and so um we
we we touched on this very briefly in
the paper I didn't say tons more about
it because I think I don't know what the
answer is yet
but is there kind of a future that
involves organisms that are neither
robots nor biological life but something
in between and have the properties of
self-replication and evolution but uh
can can survive in space much better
than we can and uh like there's there's
been of course several studies of of
what V Norman probes might look like but
I think that um we still only have a
rough sense of of what once you get to
that level of technological advancement
what what that's going to be like so um
yeah very very interesting questions
yeah yeah I mean I just if but it feels
like we are on the cusp of this that
that we're starting to launch 3D
printers into space we're starting to
consider asteroid mining we're starting
to consider uh what it'll take to to
create self-
sustaining habitats on on other worlds
and and we could very well I feel like
within a century we'll get to a place
where we can have a robot make a copy of
a robot yeah and it's driven by the
physics right I mean the rocket equation
tells us
that it's kind of a bad idea to
construct a system where you're
constantly shuttling loads and loads of
Mass from place to place because you
just have to use loads of propellant to
do that and so there's going to be this
really strong drive towards local
replication local construction of stuff
that you need and and that's going to
once we get to the point where there
there's a long-term presence Beyond low
earth orbit that's going to drive
technology fast in that direction I
think yeah yeah yeah that's really
interesting I hadn't really thought
about that that that that because the
financial incentives are aligned with us
getting uh that replication that
insitute resource
utilization well for us to nail that
technology that that that and it it will
only become profitable once we have not
you know dialed in that technology
that's where we're going to inevitably
go because until then it's just too
expensive to send a rocket to an
asteroid to collect samples and bring
them back home to I don't know build our
Electronics no you build them in space
uh material that you find in space and
that that that all of the cost pressure
is going to be driving us towards
getting better and better at at
completing more of our technology
replication stack out in space totally I
think it's going to be hard to avoid and
I mean right now we we're very driven by
science and so we want Focus like Mars
sample return for example which is
incredibly important and uh it was going
to tell us a wealth about the evolution
of Mars when we can do it that's a we
want the samples back because of their
scientific value but um if you're
thinking about about having a permanent
presence somewhere and you you're making
stuff that you need for for um just
keeping your habitat going or whatever
else then yeah you're going to want to
make it locally awesome well Robin thank
you so much for taking the time to chat
with me today and good luck with your
research let let me know when you find a
a space amoeba
thanks will
too now Robin and his team had a similar
but unrelated piece of research that
came out a couple of years ago which was
how you could use aerogel as a method of
terraforming a place like Mars aerogel
is one of the best insulators that
Humanity has ever come up with it's this
sort of uh solid Cloud solid smoke that
you can trap air in but light can pass
through it and it can provide this
really great way of uh increasing the
temperature locally and that you could
imagine a a way to increase temperature
on Mars in Regional areas to make it
more habitable make liquid water be able
to form things like that so I've got an
extended conversation with Robin over on
my patreon that you can hear that
conversation it's completely free you
just have to follow us on patreon and
then you can get access to that
additional conversation as well as all
of the other conversations that I have
on the channel now I'm going to give you
some final thoughts but first I'd like
to thank our patrons thanks to Abe
Kingston Adam Schaefer andream gross
barake Roofing David Gilton and David
matz Dennis alberie Dustin cable James
Clark Jeremy mden Jim Burke Jordan young
Josh Schultz Paul robok Sean Sergeant
spiders swap. Stephen fer Munley and
Vlad chiplin who support us at the
master of the universe level and all our
patrons all your support means the
universe to us so you can see there is a
theme to the recent interviews that I'm
doing right now and these are about sort
of a biogenesis and how life can find a
way in really interesting places in the
universe and you know I'm really
fascinated and obsessed with this topic
right now and so I've done a couple of
recent interviews just in the last
couple of days and there are some more
interviews coming out that sort of
follow this theme about how we just
think about life itself in the universe
and what you know is there some kind of
underlying way that life will tend to
organize as we think about life as we
don't know it as well as life as we know
it so I'm going to put some links into
the show notes down below of some other
interviews that I've done that are on
this topic and so if you're really
interested in how life got formed here
on Earth about how we might search for
it across the universe how do
astrobiologists think about bio
signatures uh you should definitely
check out those other interviews all
right we'll see you next time