We've seen a lot of depiction of the future of food in space in sci-fi. People eat food in space every day. But with future Moon base missions and trips to Mars, food will have to evolve as well. Which way will it go? Finding out in this interview.
00:00 Intro 02:06 Who did space food best 05:35 What food will martian missions have 13:41 Setting up a greenhouse 34:01 Future missions 44:09 Current obsessions
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Agronomist Tor Blomquist discusses the systemic challenges of food production for long-term space habitation. He argues that space farming must move beyond simple biological experiments to integrate production, processing, and psychological needs, emphasizing that sustainable colonies require a holistic approach to nutrition and radiation protection.
If you've watched enough science fiction, you know that food is still a requirement in our
human future. Now, obviously, when you have things like Star Trek, where they have a replicator,
then you just make whatever you want. And that's, you know, it's magic. But there are some shows
that try to tackle this realistically. Think about the Martian, where he is making potatoes,
growing potatoes in Regolith with poop. Or think about the Ganymede station in the Expanse,
where they're growing food in greenhouses. What does the future of food in space
realistically look like? What are the requirements? What are the what are some of the,
the sort of hidden showstoppers that perhaps you're not thinking about when we think about
the future of humanity eating a healthy food in space. Food is such a big part
of of how we live our daily lives. It is our sustenance, but it is also a source of happiness.
And that one of those creature comforts that we're going to require if we're going to want to
live and work maybe permanently in space. My guest today is Tor Blomquist. He's an agronomist
and PhD candidate at the German Aerospace Center. He and his colleagues recently wrote the first
paper in what is going to be an ongoing series into the future of food production in space.
What are the current methodologies that you use now? And what will things move towards in
the future when you consider some of the sort of unique requirements of space?
And there are a lot of gotchas. I mean, there is the radiation, which is going to take a lot of
the kinds of greenhouses that you imagine right off the table. But there are some food safety
concerns that are going to be pretty hard to get away from. And we have literally no research into
this at all. And so there's a lot of challenges for us to be able to get to that future of being
able to just like, eat a salad on the moon that Tor has been thinking about. All right, so enjoy
this interview. Tor, I'm sure you've seen as much science fiction as I have, especially as it relates
to, you know, people growing things in space and trying to live off the land in space. Does anybody
do this? Well, do you think I mean, we've seen potatoes in the Martian, we've seen
sort of the economy in the expanse. Who does a good job of recreating what the future of
space food might look like? I actually don't know, because this
future of space food is still so uncertain. But I would say that a lot of people have
the various different ideas of what space food is and could be as normal with food in general,
actually. And I think the most the best kind of depictions of that is the most real ones. So I
would say actually, like, if you go really, really, really far into the future, the expanse
might be actually be onto something because they're actually growing real food. Then you've
seen the people with the pills and the stuff. And this is the things that we that that's the
things that we know are not going to work. But one thing that actually comes back if you don't
look at like, what solutions they have for food is actually how often they talk about food. So
even in sci fi movies, and in general, you always talk about food, it's something that is close to
us. We think about it all the time. And if we don't like to cook it, we always think about food.
It's just a part of us. And it's such a deep rooted cultural and emotional thing.
Yeah, it's but I mean, I mean, I think that when you look at the unique constraints of say
weightlessness, or I mean, so there was a paper that I read that crushed me for the better part
of a couple of months, where they were talking about the amount of UV radiation and and cosmic
radiation and solar radiation that would be coming through a greenhouse on Mars, and it would kill
the plants that yes, that right. So you can't have a greenhouse on Mars or Ganymede or whatever
that, that suddenly this whole idea was like, I just watched for all mankind, and they had a
greenhouse where they were growing corn. And you're just like, Nope, you don't get that.
Right. And it's almost true. Like, we we still plants can can withstand a whole lot more radiation
than humans can. And they actually, in fact, like a little bit more. But it's it's one of
these first research questions that we actually have to ask ourselves, before we attempt doing
anything is like how much can plants actually survive in like outside of the vanilla belt
in deep space radiation, we have no clue. And this is something that that we really,
really need to test before we start even talking about implementing larger scale systems.
So yeah, you're definitely on something there.
Yeah, I mean, the Chinese had, they grew a couple of little seeds on the moon in one of their
missions. And that's like as far as we've gone at this point, right?
So we actually we need to essentially everything we did in lower orbit, we need to redo again
on the lunar surface. So like, can yeast survive? How does it affect them? Who can,
you know, plant cells survive? And how does it affect them can plant grow and so on. And
then you know, you come to the hazards and these kind of things that are associated with,
with everything as well. So there's there's so many questions to answer. So we need access
to the moon as fast as possible, essentially.
Right? Yeah. Okay, great. You recently wrote a paper sort of synthesizing a lot of what we've
learned so far, and then trying to make some predictions about the kind of research that
needs to be done for us to be able to get better answers if we do want to live in space for longer
periods of time. So what were you kind of looking to answer with your research?
So that research paper you read is the first of a series that is actually about to come.
And what that one did is essentially define the system boundary. So it's about that we,
the problem lies in that a lot of people look into production only. So they're like,
can we grow plants? And can we grow something else, but they never really, they kind of judge
the implementation based on if they can actually grow these plants or not. And another problem is
a lot of people focus on something called biogenitive life support systems, which is
essentially if take physicochemical life support systems, exchange them into biology, essentially
how the ecosystem on earth works, plants produce oxygen, sequester carbon, and so on. And that
focus sadly goes into like, what can produce the most oxygen, so it doesn't, it's no longer about
food. So essentially, what I wanted to emphasize was that if we're talking about having some kind
of hybrid food system with prepackaged and produced food, or if we're going towards an
autonomous food system, regardless of the scales that we're thinking about, so the same rules,
we have to think of it from an actual food systems perspective. So that would be not just caring for
the primary production function, but also all of the downstream functions that comes with that,
the interactions in between them, and also some of the human elements that actually
kind of help shape how the system actually looks like. Essentially, arguing that whenever
we design our ground test demonstrators, for instance, instead of just being purely plant
test beds, they should have a full system mindset to implement and integrate everything that we can
in there to see essentially what emergent properties may arise from it, how we can design
for robustness, and ultimately the attributes of resilience,
to kind of frame the system boundary regardless of the scale of the system itself.
I mean, so give me a sense, though, like you've got four Martian explorers on the first
permanently inhabited base on Mars. They're setting up to eat their meal, and how do you
sort of, you know, you're talking about these sort of like constraints and boundaries and
downstream and, you know, blah, blah, blah. Like, what is making up their meal?
So, and let's say, point out if they would not live out of prepackaged food, because I still
think if it's for astronauts, they're most likely going to have a larger, in reality, like a large
amount of their food is going to be prepackaged from Earth.
Right.
But let's say for fun that it's not going to be, and they're going to start, like,
implementing food production. So the majority would be plants. It's the most ready kind of
thing that we have. We have done most experiments on plants, and it's also the most acceptable to
us. They contain a lot of micronutrients, like ready-to-eat crops, so that's all that we have.
They have freshness, variation, and so on. So it's essentially the most acceptable
thing that we humans can eat. If you start to implement, like,
algae bioreactors and force-feed people with algae mush, you're going to have starving astronauts.
They're going to die after three days because, like, they don't want to eat that, you know?
Go and try duckweed, like, you know, it's so stupid. It's not food. So essentially,
just because it contains nutrients doesn't make it food, right? So they need to have,
and then it depends, like, are they going to be autonomous or not? So are these four
astronauts going to have a whole autonomous food system? That means that they will all,
four astronauts, work total overtime, I guess, and not essentially have time for any of the
exploration tasks that they're there to do in the first place. But if they would, I mean,
they would have to grow staple crops as well. They would have to get a fat source from somewhere.
And as soon as you start implementing these kind of things, you start looking at more and more
downstream functions that you need to have. So you need to be able to process these crops. Actually,
even ready-to-eat crops would have a processing step, like you have cutting, you have washing,
you have maybe non-thermal sterilization where you sanitize the crops, you have storage that
you need to implement. There's a whole lot of infrastructure, actually. And then you need to
grow enough variety for people not to get bored by it. I mean, if you say your favorite food,
you can't eat that for the whole week. I love lasagna, but I made so much of it on Monday,
and I'm already tired of it. So we need variety. It's like any human being, essentially. And then,
especially if you're up in space, I mean, could you imagine? It's not like you're going to have
that much inspiration or influence from the outside environment that could kind of satisfy
you. We have trees to look at, plants, and different things, human beings. There's a lot
of impressions from everywhere, but if you're in a dark and desolated place, that must be a lot
harder. So that comes from food, essentially. Right. So you sort of see, say we've got these
four astronauts, they've arrived. They brought a whole bunch of prepackaged food that's probably
going to supply the vast majority of their calories. It's going to have the lasagna,
and if they get bored of that, they eat the burrito. And they'll have enough prepackaged
food that is shelf-stable and can withstand the duration of, say, I mean, it's going to be like
a two-year mission. And do we even know the answer to that question, that you can make shelf-stable
food that can withstand that radiation environment and not totally lose its nutrients over the course
of that duration? So that's the problem with prepackaged food, is that it's not shelf-stable
forever. And I think currently it's just like one and a half years, something like that. And
a Martian mission, as you say, it's three years. We're looking at three years for there and back.
So the idea also, because it's a lot of food, I think it's like, you know, roughly like 2.4 kilos
per person per day. So it ends up in like 10, 12 metric tons of food. So the idea that NASA has
of that plan is to launch it ahead of time. And that requires a five-year shelf life. So it's
just like one of their plans that put that requirements on it. And you need to have,
you know, even if you find one food that can have a shelf life of five years, you still need to
find about, you know, 534 others. So it's sad because there's a small group of people working
on at NASA with the prepackaged food, and I can't imagine like how much they have to do.
And they need help in general just to improve packaging and all that kind of fun stuff.
But in order to kind of add some inherent redundancy to the food system, but also kind
of plan for these upcoming long duration missions to the moon and Mars, we are looking into how we
can actually produce food. Right. And then that was sort of the second part of this, I think,
is that then they're going to set up some kind of greenhouse. And, you know, we talked about this
earlier on, you're probably not going to have the greenhouse that you imagine. So you're going to
have something more like what they have in Antarctica. And I think, can you explain the
system that's in Antarctica right now run by the European Space Agency?
So it's not run by the European Space Agency. So I think you're referring to Eden ISS, right?
Yeah, there's a facility, I don't know, maybe ESA is producing press releases from it because I'm,
you know, I've been reporting on, you know, the largest tomato yield in this facility in
things like that. So it's like a can filled with LED lights and hydroponics.
So you might refer to, I mean, I think like ESA is also like stationed at the French station. I
can't remember. But you might be referring to what we have been busy with at DLR for the past,
like since 2015 or something, was the Eden ISS plant production module. So that was outside
Neumayr station, so the German Antarctic station. And it was stationed there for about five years
or something like that. So it's essentially a large container that is completely closed off
to the outside environment and works as, so it's not a greenhouse. A greenhouse is glass,
essentially. So like, if you think about the greenhouse effect, that's what you're referring
to. But this is controlled environmental agriculture. So using lights and nutrient
solutions in order for the plants to grow hydroponically. So essentially you either
spray the roots or you dip the roots in a nutrient solution called fertigation. And
then you use LED lights for them to grow. And we tested this successfully in Antarctica for
about five years. And it was actually, it's not the environment that you can think would be the
hurdle, but it's isolation. Like, Antarctica is crazy. You have a window of about a month or so
when you can actually go there. And then it's still not sure because they don't have airports,
so the planes are flying. And then they might need to turn back because of cloudy weather or
something like that. Then you have boats that also just come once a year with supplies and
a few people. And then a few people stay for like a month and then the rest go back. And
the overwinters are there for 14 months. It's like 10 of them. So there were a lot of good
experiments regarding not only like plant growth, but also like the human factor behind it. How it
is to actually eat fresh food all of a sudden. And how that affected people psychologically,
nutritionally, and many, many other things. But also, from a hardware perspective too,
it's not like we can run down to the hardware store because it's quite far.
There is none. So if something happens, you're screwed. So that's also the mental thing
that people in Antarctica get, is that sense of solitude that if something happens, I'm dead.
And that's something that I can never understand because I've never been there. I can just kind of
try to comprehend what it feels like. But that makes it such a good analog place for this.
It does feel like almost your job, you know, previous to doing this job for the German Space
Agency, you were a chef. And your job is to sort of give people happiness beyond sustenance. Like
sustenance, you can just eat the duckweed. But to actually deliver them happiness,
you're actually coming up with meals, you're designing things that you hope are going to make
them improve their lives. And that really, you know, I sort of, I watch television shows like
Alone, which is actually set on my island, Vancouver Island, where people go and they
spend several months by themselves trying to sort of withstand it. They go crazy because they're
alone, and they're having to find their food, and they're eating limpets off of the beach and
stuff, and they go bananas. And that we need to deliver those human comforts. And one of those
is going to be food. That's sort of the secret to a happy astronaut is going to be through their
stomach. I think, I wouldn't be surprised. No, but it is. I mean, we can already see it
on the ISS. Like, it started even like back in the days when they started to have these tubes and
space food, right? Astronauts wouldn't eat it, because it was simply just too boring. It didn't
taste anything like it. So the space would have to develop and develop a lot. And even now kind
of resembles like ordinary food. It's just like, there's still a problem with variety and the taste
of the food. And the fact that like, I've heard also that, you know, after their food nowadays
are like military rations, and that is not good. And so, you know, like they don't eat it. So they
come back malnourished, and this is what happens. But also, I mean, if you want to, an interesting
part too is that food, we like food for so many reasons, but if you want to get an actual
physiological reason of why we need to eat good food too, is that the smell that we have and the
it works like a priming process. So when you smell something good, you start to salivate,
and your whole metabolic system starts to get activated. And if you look at something that's
completely utterly disgusting, your body's not going to accept it. So, you know, these processes
don't start necessarily, so you don't actually properly process the food. So it's, you know,
we need that for that reason as well. But food is social, it's emotional, it's cultural,
it's extremely important for us as human beings, for all of those reasons.
And so when I think about sort of what they're doing in Antarctica, you're essentially getting
a fresh salad. You're getting greens, mustards, maybe tomato, like, I'm not sure how far they
were able, how complicated food they were able to make in the greenhouse. How interesting a meal
could you make with what you pull out of the greenhouse? And when I say greenhouse, is that
the right name? Do you call it a greenhouse? Do you call it a green facility?
I call it a plant production module because a greenhouse is technically with glass windows.
Yeah, no, I know, but it's such a terrible name, a plant production module.
But it's like, it's a Controlled Environmental Agriculture, or CA,
or you could call it plant production facility or something like that. I don't know.
Yeah, I don't like that. We need a better name. I'm calling it the greenhouse,
even though there is no glass.
Yeah, but it's so many people calling it greenhouse, even though it's wrong. So you're
not the only one. And so yeah, I mean, like we grew quite a lot, or we, I wasn't there, but
my team grew quite a lot of things, actually. And it was not only lettuce, it was herbs,
it was tomatoes, it was cucumbers, it was even like kohlrabi, it was a lot of crucifers,
radishes, you name it, like a lot of green stuff. So you could produce a lot of interesting salads
from it. So there was a whole lot of variety. Then the problem was to take care of it and not
let it go bad. And yeah, so it depends on the structure you have of your food supply to like
how much you need. And this is something that I'm trying to bring up as well. It's like,
how far do we want to take this? Like, do we want to have a fully autonomous food system where
everyone can you can satisfy like 100% of your diet? Or do we rely on half of it being prepackaged
and just like add the greens for some freshness and variability? And that's an unanswered question
that we have too. It depends on so many factors. I mean, I've got to assume that there's a balance,
that if you take protein and carbohydrates, then you can use what you grow in the greenhouse,
the controlled plant facility, the plant complex, the plant matrix, anyway, that you can
make it tasty. And so it's, you're not looking to drive calories from your grow place. You are
just trying to improve mental fitness, mental health.
Yeah, exactly. It's extremely important. And also, I mean, those kinds of plants are easier
to grow too. They satisfy the micronutrients. And those are the first ones to go in space or
in long term, because if you think about it, antioxidants, what do they do? Well, they do
protect your body from oxidation and the plant nutrients themselves. So we need those. And
those are also the first to go when they get oxidized by radiation. So if we can produce
those, that's a big thing. So I want to think about methodologies. In Antarctica, you have
access to soil. You are, as you said, you're either doing it hydroponically or you are
spraying the roots, which is, I've gone on a whole YouTube rabbit hole just on this,
that you can build these little sprayers and you put your plants on it. It's very cool.
You can do it easily at home, actually. It's super simple.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But it comes with the risks of its own. The sprayers stop
working for one second, and then your plant roots dry out, and then the plant is dead.
It introduces a ton of risk. You get any disease vectors into your system and you are spreading
them at rapid speed across all of your plants. So what about the regolith? Can you grow things
in the regolith? There has been a
mutual understanding from the whole space world, essentially, that we are not going to waste any
research money on regolith. And it is simply like, we don't need it. We have hydroponics
or areoponics or any type of that. And it works. It functions very easily and flawlessly. Regolith
contains a lot of heavy metals, corrosive stuff, stuff that you would never, ever want near your
food. It's one of the, like, NASA spends so much money keeping regolith outside of the habitats.
So, like, we're never going to bring them inside. So we don't need it. And honestly,
if we want soil, it's much easier to create soil because we're going to
produce so much inedible, you know, plant mass. So that we also need to kind of recycle in some
way or throw away or something. There's a whole lot of problems coming with recirculation of
nutrients. But, you know, you might have, if you need soil, you might as well plan on actually
creating soil. But regolith is never going to be close to food. That will be one of the biggest
hazards. Yeah. And so would it be, like, essentially, if you did want to go the soil
route, you'd be growing in pure compost? Pretty much, yeah. Yeah, exactly. That's
interesting. Or you transfer a peat or something. But yeah, you could actually do it from compost,
but you don't need soil. And if you want soil or need it, I mean, you're also going to introduce
new food safety hazards and start poking at regulations in space that we have never thought
about before. But it is much easier and better, probably, to do it from the inedible plant matter
and from the, like, fertilizer that you produce yourself and so on.
Well, that's interesting to me, though, that, I mean, from the nutrient standpoint,
you're essentially delivering the nutrients in bags from Earth, right? And then that is going
to be perfectly shelf-stable. And then when you're ready to plant, you add whatever, you titrate in
the right amount of whatever the nutrients are, and then that gets sprayed on the plant roots,
and then that grows the plants, and then the plants grow. You are pulling carbon dioxide
from the Martian atmosphere, I'm assuming, harvesting the plants, and you're building up this
recycling. Do you think you could decrease, like, do you think through recycling it could be
less reliant on sending those bags of nutrients from Earth?
Yeah, so this is also a research question that is current. And I might add, we're most likely
not going to use the Martian atmosphere for anything. It's all going to be closed, and we
produce carbon dioxide ourselves. But we actually need to collect that carbon dioxide as well,
because the plants also need much more of it.
Right, so it's actually like a waste gas, you kind of need to minimize the carbon dioxide.
Exactly, we need to circulate the carbon dioxide as well. And also, as soon as you harvest those
plants, they actually start to produce carbon dioxide and consume oxygen. So it goes the
same way. But what you were asking, essentially, is how can we improve the circulation of
the resources that we have, and maybe reintroduce the nutrients again into the plant production.
And we can. And this is also a trade-off that we have to look at, because you need a whole
lot of hardware and processes to actually be able to recirculate these nutrients back into
the hydroponic system. Because also what you want is essentially the nutrients in its elemental form.
Because that's what the plants take up. So this is also why if you use organic fertilizer,
it's going to take some time for it to break down into its elemental form before the plants can
actually utilize it. But anyways, that takes up a whole lot of processes. They're also not
necessarily food safe. And this is also a big question mark terrestrially at places as well.
And in space, we have yet to have standards and regulations for these kind of things. Right now,
it's just like any good microbe is a dead microbe, you can't have anything. So as the
regulations are, we can't have food production in space. So this is also something that we need to
go through and look at and change. How is a very good question, but it's something that we're also
trying to see how we can do essentially. A better route might actually be to just incinerate it.
You have a bunch of inedible plant material, and then you just put it in an incinerator,
you get nitrogen gas and carbon dioxide and some minerals and that might be the easier route.
Yeah, I know you can buy like, for your kitchen, you can buy like a little incinerator for your
food scraps that, you know, for me, I have lots of property, I can just pile my food scraps up
in a pile and then come back a year later, and I've got compost that I can put on the garden.
But I think with the astronauts, I mean, you're looking at the poop potatoes as well,
and there is no more efficient way to transfer human diseases than by spreading waste on plants
and then letting them grow and incorporate them. So, you know, both the human waste and the plant,
you know, all of that has got to go through some kind of incineration process to sterilize it
before you then can reintroduce it as a way of growing your plants.
Exactly, or like a biological process. Like, for instance, you can create biogas and you can use
the digest that you get from it, which is a pretty good fertilizer, but then you need to also convert
that into something that you can put in hydroponically. So this is also an argument,
too, for like, maybe that we could produce soil or something like that, for sure. I'm
on either side of the argument, but it's just... Right, but even if you can come up with the
powder that you are then reintroducing through your aquaponic system, right, hydroponic system,
yeah, your hydroponic system into the plants, then that's, you know, then you can cut back
by 50% or 75% the bags of fertilizer that are being sent from Earth.
The problem is that the more circular you want to become, the more hardware you have to launch.
Because also, eventually, if you're looking at a fully circular system,
it's going to be so much stuff that you need and so many processes. So eventually, you stand there
with all of these different systems and even have, most likely, even an aquaponic system with fish.
Because that would be very efficient. And oysters and stuff that really filters water and so on.
That would be really cool. But then you have a food system that requires at least 10, 15 full-time
workers. Then you're starting to get away from the reason why you're there from the start.
So that becomes a problem again. But it's interesting to me, because I think that's
people's instinctual idea for how this must go. You talk about the people who are like,
we really want to build a city on Mars. That that chain of 15 machines,
people and their machines, each one performs a very specific function. This one collects the
material. This one renders it. This one turns it into the powder. This one mixes the powder in with
the fluids at the right quantity. This one harvests, blah, blah, blah. So either you have
shelf-stable food in giant bags that arrive, and it is dead simple. You cut a bag open, you eat it,
you throw the waste away. Right? Done. And then on the flip side is that you're trying to
live as much as possible in this closed-circle environment. And yet, that is what must be done
for long-term, fully sustainable habitability on a planet like Mars or a place like the Moon.
Yeah, exactly.
Finding that balance point in between.
And then we also have the, there's another uncertainty, which is essentially how do
rockets develop during this time? Because we're not going to have a fully, people,
long-duration missions on Mars for a while. So in that time, will we get nuclear-powered rockets
that can get there a lot faster? So if we do, what is it to say that we are not going to do
our exploration outposts on Mars similar to that we do on Antarctica, where once a year,
they come with a bunch of frozen foods, and then we have a plant production facility,
and then they just send the trash back? And that could be a possibility, too. We have no idea.
Yeah, I can't imagine them sending the trash back. I can imagine them piling the trash up very
carefully into separated heaps that will then, some future group will go,
now we're going to dig into the giant pile of astronaut poop that's sitting there.
But I can't imagine them wanting to send that poop back to Earth.
I think that's what a lot of the regulations look like, because I don't think you can
loot space, so I don't think you can just throw something up.
Yeah, I'm sure they'll, I mean, there are bags of poop on the Moon, so it's been done.
So then based on your research, so far, where would you, you know, if you were put in charge,
and you were trying to figure out how to direct our research to make future exploration a more
humane process where people can eat food that they enjoy, and striking that balance,
because we sort of really talked about this is all give and take, it's all about balances.
Where do you think that we know the least about that we should really progress our research?
So this is, I'm going to give you a half-long answer. So this is something that we've been
thinking about a lot, and I also discovered this, so about two years ago, I got invited to be a
judge for the NASA Deep Space Food Challenge, and I started talking more with the team behind that,
and all of the people over there, and we also decided that there is not, people don't necessarily
have an idea of where this would be implemented, or when this would be implemented. Some people
have ideas that are so far off in the future, it's just not feasible at all, and some people
are very confused behind, like, is it Moon or low-Earth orbit, and so on. So we, and some people
have these really also strange ideas where they just are so buried deep in their own little silo,
and so we were saying, like, hey, we need to create an organization that kind of brings
together the whole global sphere of space food people, and that will help us also create this
common strategic objective, essentially. So we did, and it's been very successful,
called the Deep Space Food Consortium, and right now, we're also in the process of actually
starting to actually write a roadmap, because there is no roadmap, and the roadmaps just exist
from the agencies. So the problem with the agencies that exist is essentially, some of
these roadmaps are essentially them trying to motivate their own research, why it should be
funded, you know, so there's not a truly independent roadmap that is purely based on,
like, what do we need and when do we need it. And that roadmap also needs to be developed
together with the terrestrial industry, because we can't succeed without their knowledge.
There's so much knowledge of both, like, implementation and literally anything food-wise
from the terrestrial agri-food sector, and if we can also align with them and create joint
research agendas with the terrestrial sector, then we can also better create these spin-offs and
provide value to the things that we do terrestrially. So this is something that we
really, really have to do together with them, actually. But to go back to space, then,
what we need to essentially is, we need to start doing research on the lunar surface,
pretty much immediately. And you can think of this as in, like, different phases. So,
say that phase one is the fundamental research phase. This is when we do all the fundamental
research, like, do plants, like, do yeast cells grow here? How is it to grow plants and so on?
And we create readiness levels accordingly. And then you have an applied research phase,
where you start to test more, like, kind of like the current system on the ISS,
where they grow plants in the veggie system. And then, you know, you start having, like,
an early demonstration phase, where you kind of, like, demonstrate technologies.
And not only from then, you can go over to, like, early production and kind of continue
from there to see where you are. And then the most missing things that we need, actually,
before we can go to demonstration, essentially, is food safety. Like, we have no way to monitor
and verify food safety. So even now, when they grow plants on the space station, they have to
kind of, like, send them back to Earth to test them before they can get a confirmation that they
can eat them. And even then, they sanitize it between pros and wipes. So, like, each leaf goes
behind, like, between a wipe and a little baggie. And that's not sustainable. Like, you know,
you can't do that with a whole...
No, I can imagine that's tough.
Yeah, exactly. You're going to do that with, like, a thousand plants. Good luck. So, yeah. And so,
these are the things that we really, really need to solve. And from there, too, we need to help
change the whole, like, standards and regulations format for it. Because, I mean, as you know, like,
the current space regulations are not made for food production. And they're written for
the prepackaged food. And so, we need to look into that. We need to come up with a whole new
space standard, essentially, for it.
It's interesting. I mean, you think about things like E. coli. The problem is we, the humans,
are bringing that stuff with us. That you can't get rid of the E. coli. It's there on our human
bodies all the time. And it's just looking for the right environment on the station. Same with
botulism, all this kind of stuff, right? Like, all of this stuff is coming along for the ride. And
then the question is, will we make the right environment for it to thrive?
I mean, the space environment is the right... That's also, like, a fun thing, right? Like,
you have this, essentially, like, in the space station, like, microgravity environment where
they also produce faster.
Oh, interesting.
Yeah. And it's humid. And you don't necessarily get, like, the water away from the leaves
properly and everywhere.
It's the perfect temperature.
Exactly. It's the perfect environment. So, you know. But you have also, like, there was a paper
that came out recently about the whole microbiome of the ice that is quite interesting.
Yeah. Yeah. I've reported on a couple of these.
Far from sterile.
Yes. Far from sterile is a great way to describe it. That it is kind of like a moldy locker room.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah. Yeah. And so, it's interesting, though. I mean, what you're sort of identifying is it
feels like... It's sort of similar to this idea of, like, long-term habitation in space. You know,
people like Elon Musk. We want to live on... We want to build a city on Mars. And you say,
okay, fine. Can the human body survive on Mars for longer than about two years? And the answer
is we have no idea. We have no idea. And, you know, can the human body gestate? Can you actually...
Is it, like, a crime against humanity to have a baby on Mars? We have no idea.
So... And it sounds to me, like, from your perspective, same thing with plants. Like,
will they even work outside of the... Right? Out of the... Is the amount of... Because you
can build a sea can and build on the surface of the moon, but it's still going to get bombarded
with cosmic rays. So... And will the cosmic rays kill it? And so, are you going to have to
put a meter of regolith between your growing can and space itself?
That's an engineering challenge on top of it, right?
That becomes an architectural issue. And that's also, like, being discussed as well. So this is
also why we always have to work together. Like, the whole thing about compartmentalization,
it's so stupid. We have to bridge all these silos and really just, like, work together,
everyone. And the same thing, like, I'm going to publish a paper soon, too, on essentially the
interfaces between the food production system and ECLSS. Like, how all of the things that the
food system actually produces, from just VOCs to just increased humidity, power, heat, and also
how essentially all of the bacterial hazards become, like, airborne bacterial hazards and
waste water and so many things.
Yeah, yeah.
That I can list forever.
What is the, you were one of the judges on the space food challenge. So what is the best space
food that you think has been designed so far? What's the meal that you're like, I could eat this,
even at home?
Oh, you mean from, like, pre-packaged food or?
I mean, you know, a meal that has been designed for astronauts to eat that you think is genuinely
delicious.
So, I mean, I have never tried the astronaut food that the astronauts eat, the pre-packaged
stuff. And the space food challenge was actually not on pre-packaged, so it was more in production.
And even though I think, like, the pre-packaged people also need their own little challenge,
especially, like, packaging material and stuff. But from a production perspective, I mean, it's
plants and anything you can make, like, kind of normal is good. And, I mean, they do have,
they had relatively normal food on the ISS, too. And they make their own little weird
combinations as well.
Yeah, I remember there was a video from Chris Hadfield making a burrito.
Right.
On the station.
Yeah, because you can't have crumbs, so you can't necessarily have normal bread. So
tortillas are the go-to. And then there's a whole lot of literature also, like, describing
food fights and so on. That sounds so fun, throwing food at each other.
In zero gravity, yeah. And then you're just contributing to the...
Tortilla frisbees. I mean, yeah, I would be perfect astronauts. That's the only thing I would do.
Tor, what are you obsessed with right now?
Right now, I'm obsessed with... Outside from work, I mean, as normal, I'm always obsessed
with food and drinking good wine. But I recently have become obsessed with splitboarding.
Splitboarding? What is that?
Yes, it's a snowboard that you split so that you can tour up. So you take the bindings,
and you split the board, and then you attach them like skis, and then you have skins underneath,
and then you walk up the mountain. I've been snowshoeing my whole life, and I don't know why
I haven't bought a splitboard. So I'm obsessive over it and researching that every day instead
of working. Okay, hold on a second. I live on a mountain. It's snowy in the wintertime.
And I've got some snowshoes and cross-country skis, but now I'm intrigued. I've done snowboarding
in the past. So you have separate skis, or like two little snowboards, which sounds like skis to
me, but I'm assuming they're different than skis. Yeah, I mean, take a snowboard and saw it in half
lengthwise, and then you can split it. So you have little connectors that connect the boards
that it's attached, and that's the whole snowboard when you go down. And do you change the orientation
of the bindings then? Yes, exactly. So the bindings are special. So you detach the bindings,
and you put them on each ski that it becomes, and it's loose in the back, so you can walk like this.
And then you walk up like touring skis. It becomes touring skis. Right, right, right.
And so you are going uphill on them like touring skis, and then when you're ready to ride back
down, you turn the bindings, and then that, I guess, connects the board together so that it's
a rigid snowboard, and you can ride regular, goofy, and then head down the hill back home.
Exactly. That sounds great. Yeah, I'm going to check it. Now, I'm obsessed. Yeah, I mean,
you're Canadian, you said. Yeah, yeah, yeah, no, I live on a ski hill. Oh, really? I mean,
damn, okay. Yeah, yeah. Then there you go. Yeah, I live on the flanks of a ski hill, and we get,
we, you know, some years, I mean, it's a deactivated ski hill, so it was once. Even better,
because then you have powder. I mean, that's what you're looking for, right? Or at least I am.
That's exactly it. Yeah, you want the powder. Exactly. And so it is a bit of a pain to get up
into it, but that's typically what we'll do is sort of before the ski, before the season opens,
we'll take our snowboards, climb up, and it's just such a pain. You do that, like,
oh yeah, I'm going to take the first couple of weeks before ski season opens, and we're just
going to go hit that powder, and you do one day of that, and you're like, I'm going to wait for
a ski lift now. So having a way to be able to actually get up that feels more like cross-country
skis, that sounds terrific. Yeah, exactly. It does, and it is. So, I mean, you zigzag up, so it's not
like just uphill, you know, and it's great. And I've been exploring more of the Scandinavian north
now too, so it's more like, you know, it's the arctic alpine environment, it's just amazing.
And being from Sweden, I should have been exploring more of that than I have, so
it's going to be my winter activities from now on. Yeah, yeah. It's funny for me,
my sort of access into the forest, typically I wait for it to get snow-free, and then all the
love to sort of think about ways to get out into that when there's tons of snow. Yeah, exactly,
because that's what it becomes. It's not just about the descent, it's also about the whole
adventure that you have when you're climbing up. You're far away from the lift system,
and you're just climbing up some mountain somewhere, and everything is amazing and
beautiful, and it's so silent, and you just have you and your friends in nature, and avalanches.
Yes, yeah. Yeah, we're not too bad. We've got a couple of places to get avalanches, it's not that
bad here. Our mountains aren't that high on Vancouver Island, but no, that all sounds great.
Well, Tor, thank you so much for taking the time to chat. I look forward to having a meal
with you on the moon sometime. Oh, certainly. I'll send you an invitation directly.
Yeah, all right, that sounds great. Good luck. Good luck with your work. I hope you enjoyed this
interview with Tor Blomquist. I'm going to give you some final thoughts, but first,
I'd like to thank our patrons. Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Pedretti, Brian Bode,
Caridin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Baylock, Darkfinger, David Gilton, and David Matz.
Enthraller Reading and Math for Toddlers, Eric Lindstrom, Evan Dot Probe, James Clark,
Jeremy Mattern, Jim Burke, Jordan Young, Josh Schultz, Marcel Switz, Michael Purcell,
Nordspace, onestepforanimals.org. Please follow my nephew at vbrick6994, Ren Kaidu, Richard Williams,
Sean Sargent, Stephen Van La Monley, Team 49, Taleslopes Canada, Vlad Sheplin, Wolfgang Klotz,
and Zeldaborg Galactic Defender who support us at the master of the universe level. And all our
patrons, all your support means the universe to us. So I hope you enjoyed this conversation with
Tor. I have these moments where I am reading papers about, for example, the one that I
mentioned in the interview that really kind of crushed me. Like, oh, you can't have a greenhouse,
there's too much radiation, it'll kill all the plants. So and in fact, you probably can't even
just have a production facility in a sea container, you're going to get a lot of cosmic radiation,
you're going to need to put this under a meter of regolith, then that brings in architectural
issues that you know, how do you find this regolith, dig it up, pile it over your container,
like that's challenging. And yet these might be the levels that we need to get to. You're looking
at the production of carbon dioxide, the microgravity, will plants grow in one third
gravity and one sixth gravity, what are going to be the downsides of that? And, and so when you,
when you think we hear people saying, Oh, I want to go to I want to live on Mars, I want to I want
to set up a colony on Mars, there should be this part of your brain that thinks about the long list
of unsolved problems that are critical to human health, that if we don't get these right,
then people die. And so then there is no colony because everybody's dead, because they made a
perfect breeding ground for E. coli, and they all died. And so we need to solve all these problems.
And if that work is not done, then that colony is not possible. These places are not ready.
And that and so we need to have those steps taken to know that we're on the right track.
And you can kind of like wake me up when somebody has grown plants on the moon,
wake me up when somebody has grown plants on Mars, that's when you can start to say,
okay, we're now moving in the right direction, that some of these ideal science fiction dreams
are starting to become a reality. And until then, you can kind of discount them and go,
we haven't thought this through yet, get back to you when you have. And I think that's really
valuable for for you to sort of manage your expectations and and sort of try and balance
the dream against the reality of where we stand right now. But it's all fascinating to me. I
enjoy these kinds of, you know, the gritty details, the laundry list, the to do list, the Gantt charts,
the things that need to be done to make other things possible. And this all just scratches
that itch for me. Alright, we'll see you next time.