David Kipping on Exomoons and the Fermi Paradox

Dr Brian Keating
330 followers
114 Video Views·Jan 5, 2025
welcome back to into the impossible with
your host Brian keading today we're
going to Journey Through the Galaxy and
even beyond our solar system with a
phenomenal educator thinker and
scientist David Kipping a professor at
Columbia and host of the cool worlds Lab
podcast and YouTube channels with nearly
1 million subscribers and close to 100
million views David's a renowned
exoplanet Hunter an author of numerous
groundbreaking papers on a subject he
basically invented exom mov moons we
uncover his quest for Kepler 1708 bi a
giant Moon candidate orbiting a distant
world and we'll explore how our moon and
exomoons may help solve the fine-tuning
puzzle of extraterrestrial life Dave is
a remarkable mind and you'll discover
how basing Frameworks birth to death
ratio rates and ecological models can
converge to challenge our understanding
of life in the cosmos buckle up for an
enthralling conversation on exomoon a
biogenesis and the fmy Paradox and learn
from David one of the most renowned
educators of our time why your future
Cosmic perspective may cause you to see
our moon in a very different light let's
go welcome everybody to what promises to
be an out of this world experience a
journey through the cosmos through life
through meaning and through the origin
of it all uh and I'm joined with uh a
real uh you know kind of distant friend
we just met Professor David Kipping at
Columbia University host of The Cool
World's laboratory podcast and and on
podcast platforms obviously on YouTube
as well uh phenomenal Channel big
inspiration and he's out today to give a
fascinating colloquium at the newly
formed UCSD astronomy Department welcome
David honestly it's a I've been watching
your podcast for a long time and I've
been really looking forward to visiting
and getting to talk to you about this so
we' been the you know number one guest
after Elon every wants to say Elon I had
him on for 10 minutes that's a h bar
come on right well uh you're here today
to talk about something I find really
fascinating uh which is moons and the
exom moons which is you know kind of
even one step before I mean when I
started graduate school there were no
exoplanets known for sure just around
the time the first ones were discovered
and now we're talking about EXO moons
and I want to talk about life especially
today so important to you know us as a
as a species to contemplate if we're
alone if we're not as Arthur C Clark the
namesake of this podcast who coined the
term into the impossible said both
outcomes are equally terrifying right I
want to ask you the following question
if we knew for short if God Mother
Nature Gaia your your Chancellor I don't
know if they came and said to you David
there's no life on exoplanets is it
still worth studying is it still a topic
worth studying yeah I think I think
studying exoplanets uh one major
motivation is is indeed to look for life
but it's not the only motivation for
sure and I'm going to steal from my
graduate student Alex teacher who who
used this phrase a lot he said there two
types of astronomers those who want to
understand the mechanics of how the
universe works like what are the rul
Rules by which the universe
fundamentally plays out and I think
maybe you might fall into that category
and there's maybe astronomers more like
myself who are who are primarily driven
by this question of are we alone that's
that's the itch that we've had since we
were children trying to want to answer
now if we ruled out still that there was
life anywhere in the universe which by
the way is kind of an absurd proposition
but I I'll play with your idea but it is
it is obviously it's it's almost
impossible to prove an absence that's
kind of an interesting philosophical
aspect of this whole search is is the
idea of us being alone even a valid
scientific hypothesis because it's
unfalsifiable you know that's an
interesting question to ask I think but
let's just say we played the game that
we we did get to that point there's
still all the questions we might ask
that still on that more mechanical
aspect of how do planets form how do
they evolve how do they change what is
the chemistry of different worlds what
are the rules by which this whole
universe plays out if we wanted to make
a simulation of you know a simulated
universe first one day we need to know
how how the rules of physics play out
and build these things so just
understanding our story I mean when we
try to understand why did the big bang
happen or how did galaxies form we're
not doing it because we're driven by the
question of life we're doing it because
we want to understand the story of the
universe and planets are just as much of
an equal part of that story as a galaxy
is as a super massive star is so I would
say if you take that away it just puts
us on the same footing as all of the
questions in astronomy me but the fact
we have that on top is just like this
giant extra Cherry that you put there it
is really fascinating I mean it's the
top one or two questions I always get
you know ask my guests what's the most
interesting thing in the universe even
those that don't study astronomy and
it's you know how did the universe come
to be and and the second one or the
first one for some people I assume you
is uh yeah is are we alone is there life
elsewhere what's fascinating about what
you do is you you really are thinking
you know four moves ahead you know
you're thinking about the role that
moons might play and in um you know
appreciation for you coming out I
actually brought a piece of the Moon the
Earth's moon this is actually for you it
is a fragment of the Earth's Moon which
is not delivered by the astronauts NASA
if you're listening it's a felony it's a
class one felony actually get moon rocks
from uh from the Apollo program but this
was delivered by gravity so a meteor hit
the moon destroyed some you made a
crater or two and then that debris
floated out and eventually congeal
that's for you you oh I he that's really
I'm on thank you so much I gave one to
Joe Rogan and uh I think he smoked it I
haven't s any Since U anyway um but my
question is you know knowing that the
moon plays a crucial role at least in
life on earth and the hypothesis in
which it Formed is is sort of coming
together we had James Arnold was a
professor here one of the founding
Apollo scientists who worked on the
mission the the question of you know the
the role that giant collisions play in
the formation of moons and then the role
the moons play in life can you walk us
through that and how probable it might
be or improb that such an event would
occur on the moons that you study yeah I
mean there's this idea of how the moon
formed that has kind of become canonical
at this point but still people are
legitimately questioning it that's one
thing I like about science is that
nothing's ever set in stone but the
canonical idea is that there was this
m-sized object that crashed into the
Earth we normally give it the name Thea
and uh it's interesting to us where that
marized planet actually came from itself
I mean there were the solar system was
in the process of forming planets turns
out when you look at the you know you
simulate these collisions you can't have
these collisions happen too dramatically
to with too much kinetic energy
otherwise you it's too destructive and
you can actually end up destroying both
bodies so we have a fairly gentle impact
so one of the ideas is that Thea may
have formed in the same orbit of the
Earth At One AU from the Sun but it
formed in one of the Trojan points in a
horseshoe orbit so this means it's kind
of uh librating around this horseshoe
position and if it's more than about 10%
the mass of the Earth any object there
its librations will kind of compound and
build larger and larger and So
eventually this wobbling got so big that
it it basically grazed and struck the
Earth and that impact was still
extremely energetic it largely vaporized
Thea but it left the the Earth which
would have been larger in the past it
would have been you know a super Earth
essentially at this point it stripped
some of that upper mantle away that
upper mantle then formed the moon and
that's why the moon doesn't really have
a significant core it's primarily just
essentially mantle like material from
the earth we also know from the Apollo
rocks that it has the same oxygen
isotope ratio as Earth rocks that's how
we know it really know this used to be a
part of the earth that's right went up
to the moon and now it's come back down
to where it belongs back on the earth so
this impact was um you know it has lots
of interesting coincidences like it has
to have this this the type object has to
be just the right Mass has to be a
grazing impact not too hard and also
just the right angle if you change the
angle you can actually destroy both
bodies as well so a lot of people have
tried to simulate these realizations of
this impact but it it raised the obvious
question as to he and does that happen
and that's one of the qu that's one of
the reasons we want to look for exing is
to hopefully fill out that question and
the presence of a large Moon does seem
to have some benefits by that large
impact is thought for instance you may
have stripped off a lot of that thick
upper lithosphere that was forming on
the Earth
and had that not had happened rather
than having like a roughly 10 km crust
around the earth it could be 100 km
crust and that would be so thick that
you wouldn't be able to have plate
tectonics you would form a stagnant lid
which is what Venus has and things do
not go well for Venus we just St so you
know you can't have carbon recycling you
can't have the Nitro things like this so
you would end losing subduction and the
ability of the earth to recycle
materials which seems kind of crucial
for the longevity of a biosphere right
right so that seems a you know a
possible I mean this is speculative
because we can't really redo the
experiment but I think it's a reasonable
argument we also know the moon has a
large tidal influence on the earth it
would have raised very large tides on
the early Earth it used to be a lot
closer to us than it is today probably
would have formed how big probably like
maybe 50 times larger in the sky I would
have guessed you it be much much closer
like 10,000 miles away but I'd guess it'
be 30 if I was going to do the math cuz
it's 60 Earth radi away from us and it
formed about two or R that's the RO the
RO limit around the earth so can be
about 30 times larger in the sky and it
would have created these large large
tides and when the land and continents
first formed these Tides would have
covered the entire land continent with
with these with with these tides for a
period of time and so it's thought that
could be conducive to the emergence of
life because one of the possible places
that life could have formed is these
Little Rock pools that you know where
essentially concentrate chemistry
through the process of evaporation you
get you get these Organics ing there so
that could be maybe where life began and
then finally a third reason to think a
moon is useful is the stabilization of
the Earth's Tilt which is the the thing
actually people normally would start
with in this AR of three um but yeah
that's been shown in a paper by jacqu
lascar I think it was 1993 in a famous
nature paper very well cited and he
showed that you know if you were to take
the Moon away and evolve the Earth's
obliquity uh because of the influence of
Jupiter and the other Gast D planets it
would cause the Earth's obliquity to
wander over millions of years and so um
you would end up with periods of time
where the you know the North Pole was
essentially points at the Sun and then 6
months later the South Pole was pointed
the sun it would give you a very
different climate you could imagine
maybe simple life persisting but
agriculture a civilization maybe complex
land life might be harder to imagine
first of all let me compliment you
further because your writing is sort of
unique for me as an outsider in this
field in that it's incredibly accessible
to you know simple experiment
okay uh so one of the Frameworks that I
you know can kind of translate from you
know when I went to Paris for the first
time I you know I couldn't speak French
despite four years of of of of high
school French and I remember coming out
of the metro and seeing a kid and he was
playing with his dog and he was calling
the dog and the dog was do I was like
that dog knows a lot more French than I
do uh but I I said I'm gonna read pan
because you know I understand relativity
and I'm gonna I'm going to get this
right you know so I can translate your
work on basian Frameworks into my
language as a ol well I got it from
cosmologist I I taught I learned basian
statistics from cosmologist I I think a
lot of the early basian stuff came from
your past guest and my past guest Adam
Ree and their team they kind of
pioneered that at we kind of neglect the
influence that they had in the Supernova
type 1 asearch but I I influenced by you
and inspired by you I decided to do a
little basian framework and of course I
I utilize my my research assistant her
name is chat gbt and I I asked the
following question if uh we we know that
the Moon and even a Mars Rock which I
have which when you come next time or I
come out to visit you nothing bring the
Mars Rock uh a good reason to visit
again just keep swag well there's one
more piece of Swag I'm about to give you
so we know that the that you know this
you know rock came from from the Moon
and other rocks Came From Mars given the
fact that that occurs in that direction
certainly occurs in the reverse
Direction namely that the Earth has been
bombarded by objects like this this is
your second gift let me before I give it
to you so these are of course meteorites
which I collect uh this one's from
Argentina and I do give these out to any
member of the audience in the um in the
USA has a.edu email address and I give
them out to other people too at Brian
king.com
or list I'll give it to you our students
you'll get someone VI so this material
came from uh from space but the inverse
process where Earth gets bombarded and
its material goes onto Mars uh that
surely has occurred even over the period
of the bombardment periods that that you
know much more about than I do and
during the period of time in which Earth
had on it you've talked in recent videos
about how you know fac and how vital and
how rapid life could have originated on
Earth even if it was brought from
elsewhere so that means for billions of
years Earth and Mars have been
exchanging material and in particular
life and we know that extreme files from
you know past guest and friend I'm sure
you know Jill Tarter life finds a way
you know as Jeff gber said in in the
Jurassic part I'm asking the following
question uh or ask chat TBT I get what's
the probability that you wouldn't find
Life on Mars just given that life exists
on Earth we're in very similar orbits
both habitable zones roughly right I as
and it's actually it's it's it seemed to
be fairly problem and obviously you're
going to do a much better analysis than
I do but what do you make of that
argument is it possible is it not
possible to say that we should see we
should be able to use this to constrain
a little bit of the prior on How likely
life is to evolve once there is life in
a solar system does that question make
sense or is it yeah so I know it's not
going to be like of course you can't
prove the negative as you said but
doesn't it give us some you know basian
Credence value narrowing what is the
probability that Mars does not have life
and that life would have um shared a
common ancestry with with Earth yes it's
stipulate that life originated on Earth
and then it's made its way through Pence
spia which is you know sounds dirty but
it's not uh Fred ho who used to come to
this very office to visit Jeff verage
the question is yeah so that if life is
so you know easy to spread and and so uh
so rapidly proceeding given that we've
exchang you know we've been sending care
packages to Mars for three and a half
billion years with life on it um so what
the fact that we don't see Life on Mars
at least yet we haven't searched all of
it but we don't see obvious
technological it can we not set a bound
on the prior that uh of how difficult it
is to kick off life on another planet
yes so I think yeah if you if you were
to prove a negative on Mars then there's
two interesting consequences one it's it
would basically mean yeah okay sure
maybe
panspermia um even between two
neighboring planets is not a very
efficient process of this taking place
and I think there's lots of credible
reasons why one might be skeptical of
that being effective these rocks don't
necessarily do a direct route right it's
not you know if you if you fly on you
know Starship or something maybe it'll
be like an 18mon trip from Earth to Mars
which is about as fast as we can go but
you wouldn't but that's you know a
coordinated Hoffman transfer orbit you
wouldn't expect that a random Rock
knocked off would necessarily follow
such an efficient path so I I don't know
what the typical term would be but I can
imagine these rocks spending millions of
years out in the abyss before they
eventually make their way to one of
these planets and then the question is
how long could a a Spore of Life truly
survive in in the vacuum of space now
we've exposed things like tardigrades
and bacterial spores to the vacuum of
space and they have survived days weeks
I think even months in the vacuum of
space and be reanimated I I don't think
we can do the experiment where you
simulate what a million years of that of
that environment would be like for such
a such an entity so I think it's an open
question as to whether it's really
plausible and of course if you go really
long if you go to billions of years like
potassium which is a key part of you
know a lot of uh chemistry decays on a
1.3 billion year halflife so a lot of
your elements will actually start to you
know and carbon yeah has a 6,000 years
at Carbon 13 so you know some of your uh
actual elements if you're if you're just
hanging out for a long time would
actually start to degrade so that there
must be a time scale which no matter how
well adapted you are for space and it's
kind of obviously these things did not
evolve to be well suited for space
they're just Hardy there must be a time
scale over which they cannot survive
that journey and so I guess the real
question would be how long do these
rocks typically spend in the environment
of space and then what fraction of those
then can survive the impact which is
going to be another you know extreme
event for the rock to experience and for
any life forms to experience that are
attached to it and then once it's done
both of those things it then has to
actually have you know metabolism and a
food source and uh the ability to to
respirate and and to survive on that
planet so I think there's several steps
there where you need like three Miracles
almost to happen I'm using it kind of
playfully a little bit there but you
need three things which are not
obviously easy to happen to take place
and it maybe I maybe those things take
place quite frequently we didn't have no
evidence to support that um and I think
uh I could very well believe that this
process is not particularly common I
think one of the things I've been most
fascinated about with panspermia which
has changed record a little bit is with
um like om mua and these Interstellar
asteroids that we now like Boris of as
well that we recently detected and they
are super intriguing because we used to
think the idea of interstellar pans
spermia was an incredibly remote and
implausible thing to consider and then
with mua we're realizing actually the
rate of interstellar Interlopers is
orders of magnitude higher than we
previously thought reasonable and that
really opens the door because you know
if om MO is flying through the solar
system some of those omal probably hit
the earth in the past and they could
have transferred life from an entirely
different solar system which could have
had a five billion year Head Start RNA
right so and that's intriguing and and I
know folks have you know tried to rewind
the clock of um there was a paper I
talked about in one of my videos on Luca
the lowest Universal common ancestor
which existed 4.2 billion years ago they
were able to date it to and the Earth
only really had oceans 4.4 billion years
ago so within 200 million years you
don't just have Luca they show that
there's a strong evidence that there was
an entire biosphere at this point there
was a higher there was a colony and many
many interacting uh genomes that were
going under horizontal Gene transfer
with each other so was there was not
just one single thing even then and so
it does seem almost implausibly fast how
life got started and panspermia be
Interstellar or from maybe from Mars it
certainly removed some of that tension a
little bit it makes it may be easier to
believe how such a complex organism
could have evolved so quickly so it's
very intriguing so in your recent uh you
recent paper on these what a 70 cool
giant exoplanets and their possible Moon
surveys so that was a paper will link to
it exomoon survey of 70 cool giant exop
planets and the new candidate Kepler
1708 sb1 just rings off the the tongue
yeah exactly yeah don't don't judge a
both by it's cever so talk about that
what what was the you know kind of
science behind it how did you obtain you
know time and data and what is the
methodology and specific techniques that
you and don't be afraid you know my
podcast maybe I'll say is the brightest
in the Multiverse so don't be afraid to
get super super deep into the technology
of what you using and how you did it you
know I've been looking for Moons for
like 15 years now in my career it's been
you know something I'm well known for
and it's you know it's haunted me to try
and do this search I have to stop you
say something like that I have to stop
what what is about moons that are so
fascinating to you is it AR Moon did you
have some experience with with our moon
or yeah to betro I got really fascinated
into this because almost by chance I
think you obviously when I was a kid uh
space and the planets were fascinating
like many kids to me and I remember
having this annual of the book of all
the planets and all the moons and just
being astonished by you know these
photos from Galileo and Voyager of these
Distant Worlds that were so alien and so
different you look at a picture of
Europa or Kalisto or you know Saturn and
you're just like wow like this is real
this is really out there in our own
backyard so I think you know for me it's
always been obvious that moons were kind
of the most diverse and terrestrial like
and that made them more interesting to
me but yeah I kind of stumbled into
moons a little bit by chance and that
was really because I was writing a paper
on the um the transit I was calculating
the transit duration so how long does it
take a planet to Transit its star and I
was trying to come with a closed form
solution for this problem it's just a
geometry problem that I'd made the first
attempt of doing this with an Ecentric
orbit before then everyone had just a
circular orbit which seemed reasonable
because the plants in the solar system
were mostly circular everyone assumed
exop plants would be the same way but we
were starting to get hints that actually
exop plants quite Ecentric so I I
generalized the calculation and then I
think the referee asked me or maybe I
was thinking in my head at some point
like what could make this calculation be
wrong like where would where would the
one of my assumptions be false and one
of the assumptions was you know that
this klarian orbit one way to get a
non-aryan orbit would be if something
was wobbling it and so that's where I
started down this path of thinking about
the moons and how that would change
things and that got me excited because
whenever you you know find a way to
basically prove your IDE is wrong that
becomes a way of detecting that thing
and so I started down this path and I
just that's really I have to PA you
again you're giving me too many good
nuggets here so I was off to to kind of
double click on things that are of
interest to Young scientific researchers
and what what David just explained you
know as a general principle when you see
a flaw you know I would say a flaw can
lead to a new law and that's exactly
what you did I mean with the Earth is an
anomaly as I understand and our solar
system certainly it's the only planet
with one moon right and so you're
thinking there could be some wobble
there could be some and that could come
from the the fact that like most stars
maybe most planets have multiple moons
yeah exactly I mean and it's really just
an extension I mean there's and the plan
there's a looking for a flaw in your
theory to pick up on that piece of like
this is a new thing we can look for but
then there's also analogizing so you can
take the analogy of okay we are
detecting lots of planets by looking at
wobbling stars that was the Prime
primary method at the time people were
detecting planets and so this is really
just an extension of that it's saying
well let's just take that same principle
and apply it on a smaller scale and see
what see what falls out so yeah there's
the there's you know I I really love
talking to colleagues in other fields
and other disciplines cosmologists but
also you know totally other disciplines
like chemistry and biology because you
you hear about the way they are thinking
about problems and you see so often in
science that the the way problems are
solved are transferable maybe you change
the scale maybe you shift an axis but
it's it's a lot of the same things being
discovered multiple times with which are
really just mirrors of each other so
yeah I took that I took that idea and
kind of ran with it and I think
personally I just realized it wasn't I
was you know I liked moons a lot but I
really just liked new ideas primarily
and I realized at the time that I had a
choice I had kind of a fork in the road
I could either keep working on new ideas
I do keep working on new ideas but I
could just totally leave the moons
behind and just let other people figure
it out or I felt like I had a head start
start you know you're in a race to find
the first whatever and by virtue of all
this modeling work I did I knew I was
probably the person you know it sounds a
little bit cocky but I knew at the time
I was probably the most I probably
thought about X me harder than anyone
else and so I had an intellectual Head
Start start and so if anyone was going
to do it I probably had an advantage I
had an ace of my sleeve to pull that off
so I thought yeah and it's a bit of a
risk and I remember a colleague saying
to me I remember at a cocktail party a
professor an esteemed professor at MIT
said to me um um David why are you doing
this like why don't you look for hot
Jupiters they're everywhere they're
really easy to find like you can write
so many papers why why are you trying to
look for for moons you're not going to
publish any papers and I knew rationally
what he was saying made sense from a
career perspective but it just didn't
excite me to do something that had been
done a hundred times over just wasn't as
exciting as doing something that had
never been done that fresh snow you know
it's like going out to the past and
you've got two tracks you've got the
heavily plowed track and you've got
fresh snow I'm going down the fresh it's
so funny because I I make this point in
my in my first book about Galileo so he
didn't invent the telescope we know that
he had an incredible amount of success
like you I'm going to compare you to
Galileo with moons as well he
discovering the moons of Jupiter which
he decided to name after his funding
agency he was he was smart but when he
discovered it he realized if I make
these telescopes and give them away or
even sell them I'm gonna be out of
business you know I won't be able to
make all the discoveries on the fresh
snow as as David just spoke about so
instead he published the instruction
manual without the equipment so it's
kind of the opposite of what we do now
now we put out an iPhone no instruction
manuals needed but he put out the idious
nuntius and that just showed what you
can see if only you had it and he even
denied it to Kepler he didn't let him
use it so it's again it's a very
brilliant thing to do as a scientist to
see when you can make a new contribution
even if your older you know gray-haired
colleagues uh don't recommend it you
know right so this is a way that you can
make progress being the first has an
monopolistic Advantage sometimes so how
do you know when you've seen the and
Exelon for example yeah so in this in
this maybe to come back to this Pap the
way the way we are looking I mean
there's many ways to look but the way I
think is the most plausible way of
getting a success is to look for
transiting moons so transiting planets
is the most successful method we have
setting planets as capar yeah this is
things like the NASA cap Mission and
before that there was this European
mission called C there's also many
groundbased surveys called like wasp
hatet trays before that so there's a
whole bunch of these surveys likeing for
planets where we're using that same
technique and we're piggybacking off
that success because a they've already
taken huge amounts of data so we don't
have to build an exom immune telescope
the data has already been taken in all
these in all these telescopes and B we
know this technique is incredibly
precise so the smallest exoplanet
detected is about the size of the moon
transiting a star so we know moon-sized
planets are detectable with this method
and if a planet has a moon then as it
transits in front of the star it causes
of course this dip in light a very tiny
diping light and if there is a moon it
will cause next to it either before or
just after or maybe on right on top if
you're unlucky but it will cause an
extra dip in light and it's that extra
dip we look for and obviously that extra
dip will be uh transient in its location
that makes it a little bit harder I mean
with a with a transiting Planet once
you've got the period you know exactly
pretty much where it's going to be every
time so you go to the telescope you can
really predict and dial in exactly what
it's going to be and you can stack all
your data and you know get this kind of
binning effect to build up your signal
to noise we can't do that with XM we
can't stack data in the same way and so
um that has been one of the challenges
of looking for this uh type of signal
and of course also it's a very small
signal I mean you look at the moons in
the solar system the biggest moon is
gamed and ganim I think is about 2%
roughly the mass of the Earth so uh it's
about 40% the size of the Earth but you
know even though that sounds good 04 the
transit signal goes as 04 squar because
it goes as the as the square of the
radius
so yeah that that's a that's a small
0.16 that's a very small signal for us
to try and grab what are some of the
systematic or biases that you have do
you have a bias effect that you're more
sensitive to Shorter period rotations or
or you know of of the moons yeah
generally moons which are far away from
their Planet are best for us all things
being equals I keep the mass equal the
size equal everything else they only if
you just change the distance the further
away it is the better uh there's two
reasons why one I mean there's really
two signals that we looking for one is
the sigma which I wrote about during my
PhD thesis which is this wobble and
that's what really inspired me into this
journey of EXO moons and yeah the the
moon will gravitationally tug on the
planet and so as Kepler showed things
don't you know and really Newton showed
more rigorously things don't orbit a a
single point they orbit a Common Center
of mass and so the planet will undergo
this slight oscillation around that
Center of mass and that wobble will
cause the times of transit to slightly
vary so we call these Transit timing
variations or ttvs for the Earth Moon
system it's about 2 and a half minutes
so I always think this is kind of fun
like an alien seeing the Earth Transit
the sun would sometimes see the Earth
Transit 2 and a half minutes earlier and
sometimes 2 and a half minutes glater
because of the moon so they would know
the moon was there that's actually a
pretty decent signal yet more I think
you know I'm probably the only person
who thinks this but when we do our sort
of calendar of like when January New
Year's Eve like when does the when does
the clock strike 12 we should really
account for that two and a half
minutes yeah Moon wi we should look at
where the moon phase is and adjust the
the time so yeah maybe I'll do a New
Year's party where we'll we'll as ay and
correct for that that bar Centric motion
so yeah this effect is is in there and
then the other effect we look for is
just the dip itself which I talked about
the dip of the Moon blocking out
Starlight that so they give us different
things the dip gives us the size of the
Moon physically how big it is and the
wobble gives us the mass so once you've
got mass and size or radius then you can
figure out the bolt composition the
density figure if it's icy Moon Rocky
Moon things like that's kind of the hope
so yeah we took this this sample of 70
exoplanets and we just scanned through
them looking for these signals and this
the reason why we did 70 there 5,000
exop plays out there like why why do
these 70 it's a very pretty small subset
we concluded they were pretty much the
most likely to to give us a success
because they are really far from their
star and they're really big so they
basically the most jupiter-like things
that we have and yes earthlike planets
could have moons but we can barely
detect the Earths anyway in fact keer
found zero true Earth twins it's
basically just impossible for Earth for
ke's precision to find true Earth twins
but Jupiter's we have plenty of those so
uh what plenty we have about 70 so we
figured that would be a nice sample to
go after and amongst that 70 we looked
for all of these effects and we had this
one object which uh really stood out and
looked like potentially the real deal
kep 17 that's 1708 b-i and you talk
about it as a good scientist should you
know as still a waiting confirmation or
needing what would confirmation come
from we don't know a Kepler right now so
what are you looking forward to in the
future for confirmation potentially for
a particular object to confirm it we
would probably need jbst to look at this
object unfortunately or another Capital
you could just build another cap I
supposed to do it we wrote a paper that
actually proved that Hubble was not
sensitive enough to detect it which is
surprising cu is a bigger mirror it's
2.4 M Capo is 1 meter but the difference
is the systematics so Hubble is an orbit
of the earth and thus it is corrupted
the data is polluted by many systematics
such as thermal cycling various sort of
instrumental effects with these infr
detectors which which creep in whereas
uh Kepler is an optical CCD so it's a
much simpler instrument doesn't have any
spectrograph or anything on board so
it's like it's just a la bucket super
simple and so you get really really
precise data and it does it for 200 ,000
Stars simultaneously so therefore you
can use those other 200,000 stars to
decorrelate and clean your data so you
can do a really nice job with kep data
so it's kind of amazing like Kepler
actually is more precise for that for
that object at least than than Hubble
would be so yeah we would need to go
back with J team we have two exoman
candidates that we have proposed in lure
so far and both cases you would probably
need to go back with one of these super
siiz telescopes and you would want to
see the transit of of the Moon the the
ground based terrestrial teles SCS like
the G uh giant mellan or are you saying
space TS I think you probably I mean do
from the ground is hard because both of
these objects they they take so long to
Transit their star so the transit is I
think around about 20 hours wow so you
just can't do that unless you're in the
North Pole the South Pole right you
can't get a night that's that long so
yeah one of the reasons why we use space
is because we can observe from more than
a rotation period of the Earth the jst
data that we collected in October was 60
hours you mean you can't do a 60 hour
time series from from the no way all
right about what what was it like to use
jwst I mean you're one of the you know
there more people in the NBA than have
actually gotten good said sorry j so
yeah so talk about that that process and
and what you gleaned from it that you
know was complimentary or or perhaps um
you know uh in a way better than some of
the previous data sets that you had
actually it's um an honor to get to use
this fantastic facility um it it's a
huge responsibility in a way because
it's 10 billion
that that taxpayers have spent I would
say it's $10 billion to to build it to
operate it's a billion dollar right
right and then of course that's not even
counting the launch cost which the
Europe I think the Europeans or the
Canadians ate that launch cost so yeah
it's it's an expensive machine it me
it's kind of like going to CERN right
and having full control over the large
hatron collider to do whatever you want
for 60 hours it's kind of ridiculous
like and not like you're Bona I mean
you're one of the most uh you highly
cited recognized astronomers in the
world and they don't know who you are
when you propose right it's it's like
double blind or triple blind it's double
blind I suspect they can figure it out
because well we the target we proposed
for this is a NE this is not one of
those two previous XM candidates and
that was strategic both of those xun
candidates are Neptune siiz moons around
super Jupiters and the reaction we got
from the community was basically BS like
how could you have they just couldn't
believe that you could make a moon that
big was even though theorists are very
creative and have shown you could make
moons that big you know in retroactively
hey Cosmic explorers are you ready for
some astronomical trivia did you know
there are only 88 official
constellations and there hasn't been a
new one since 1930 after all but I have
over 900 asterisms that's right
asterisms are tiny collections of stars
not big enough or grand enough to be a
constellation but just as meaningful to
me and you can leave one of your own a
five-star asterism whether you're
listening on Apple pug or Spotify when
you go to Apple podcast just open our
show scroll down to ratings and review
and tap the five star button leave your
thoughts as well and the review and on
Spotify you can do the same you can even
give feedback comments on the show and
watch in video format as well and you
can do me a great huge and fast free
favor by tapping on a rating of your own
and leaving me that beautiful five-star
gleaming asterism that will make Orion's
Belt shine with Envy now back to the
episode but there was no prediction of
such a moon and neither was there
prediction of hot Jupiters correct
that's that's that' be exactly my
response but you know you just have to
we proposed several times with Hubble to
go after those Moon canet and
persistently we were rejected and not
only rejected but ranked very very low
in in the rankings they just really
hated our proposal so we we realized we
had to change strategy and so instead of
going after those two controversial Moon
candidates I don't think they're
controversial by the way but but I have
to concede that there is controversy
around them we went after a fresh fresh
planet and this planet was a planet I I
actually discovered myself back in I
think 2018 and it's called Kepler
167e and it I guess you know the best
way to think about is it is the most
Jupiter likee exoplanet we have found
transiting another star I would make
that claim it is within 1% the mass of
Jupiter within 10% the radius of Jupiter
it's on a circular orbit it's on a 3year
period so it's about 2 2 2 and a half AU
from it start
and it has a multiplan system and its
orbit is perfectly circular it's on the
exterior of of three or four rocky
plants on the inside so it really just
looks like you know this is as close to
Jupiter as we could really hope for and
so our intuition and our claim was if
anything's going to have a series of
exomoons it's going to be this guy and
not only should this thing really really
have exomoons unless we totally don't
understand how moons form because both
Saturn and Jupiter have a whole ton of
these things but not only that but we
really should tect them and so we showed
with the simulator of the James web data
that if you take the the Galan Moon
system named after our gentleman here
and inject it into the fake data there
he is 400 years just over 400 years ago
he he discovered the first means so
we're trying to you know carry on his
legacy yeah that Kalisto and ganam we
should be able to detect Areo Europa a
little bit too close remember we talked
about things too closer harder so we
probably couldn't get IO and Europa at
least not yet with with with the current
data but but we think that yeah Kalisto
and ganam we really should detect to 95%
um of injections we get one of those
moons back so that was our confidence
right 95% retrieval rate so that was our
pitch and I think three other teams
actually pitch do the same thing and so
yeah they are all blind um but I I would
hope I haven't seen any of the proposals
that as was legitimately the best and I
think that's because we did a huge
amount of that injection recovery work
of really proving the whole end to M
simulation of what we think can get and
how we would analyze the data and I
think that's where you get to pull out
your ace cards right because I've been
doing this for 15 years so I I know all
the tricks right and I think you can
show that off I think that's probably
why I would guess a review would know it
was me because there's not there's not a
huge number of xming people it's another
benefit of being Monopoly power yeah and
I I talk about some cool world and
people prob know that X skipping kind of
goes together a little bit at this point
yeah I suspect they probably nearest me
but in principle the double blind that
is there to um yeah stop biases against
you know race or gender or seniority um
and so you know that's I'm all in favor
of that makes the process actually kind
of easier for us in terms of preparing
that proposal and uh yeah we got the
time we observed in end of October I
think it was um over Halloween we were
observing like 27th to the 31st pretty
much it was 60 hours of data so that's a
profound thing you're looking up at the
sky obviously you can't see Jo but you
can kind of roughly see where it would
be in the sky and you can think to
yourself like it's actually kind of
profan found that right now there is
that little tiny telescope out there big
by human standers but tiny compared to
the cosmos that is you know1 billion
dollars of human effort and labor and I
am I am pouring all of my hopes and
Destiny into into what it's going to
find right now others observing it's a
strange thought to go to sleep at night
thinking that and so the first thing we
did we did a reaction video we didn't we
haven't put on cords yet we'll probably
eventually show it you know we we have
this sort of plan as as cool as
listeners know that we don't want to
sort of live um uh yeah we don't want to
do live updates at every little Minish
of of things in the analysis as we're
doing it because it's when I'm working
on science I want to keep my I want to
be very objective and focused and I
think as much as I love social media it
can be a distraction when you're really
focused on a scientific goal of trying
to give people what they want or what
they hope to see and as objective as can
try to be we all are human and we can
all be seduced by that so I don't want
to get even risk getting pulled into
that uh into that game so I made the
conscious decision that yeah we'll try
and keep um you know video logs and
things of what's Happening MH but we'll
show that at the end once we know we the
way what the answer is so the reaction
video we shot was getting the data for
the first time and uh you know we Ben
was plotting the light curve and I could
see the point there's like there's like
a million points because we take an
image every 1.6 Seconds of this star
right over 60 hours there's a huge
number of points hundreds thousands of
data points and so you can see this like
plot populating and with and it's flat
flat flat flat flat flat flat and we're
like oh God Is there is there going to
be a planet there and then suddenly it
dips down and we're like oh thank God at
least the planet is we we didn't screw
that up because you could blame Kepler
yeah you blame Mis it right You' got a
threeyear orbit and you have to hit that
60 hour right in the nail what if you
slightly miscalculated right that would
that's kind of the um the impostor
syndrome fear that you have but like
maybe I screwed up this like very simple
calculation and wasted 10 billion calor
the man yeah
exactly so unfortunately it's only a
fraction of it um you mentioned the you
know kind of that the the Dual you know
uh mission that you're on which is which
is obviously you know primarily as a
scientist Professor researcher uh but
also this this secondary Mission which
is of huge importance probably reaches
more people um you know than the you
know even the highest site count paper
that you have which is quite High um how
do you balance that my feeling is that I
I am more strident probably than you
might be but you know it's kind I'm a
born New Yorker not a transplant
immigrant New Yorker like yourself but
that's that I I think we scientists have
a moral obligation to communicate what
we do in terms that the public can
understand um and we should do that
frequently because any other person you
know the the carpenter who fixes the
door in this office if he were to come
in I said what are you doing said oh you
can't understand what I'm doing like I'm
doing something so specializ took so
much training and you want me just to do
this no no no he'd be fired right so how
do you react to that uh a lot of you
know our fellow youtubeers like Saina
Hassen Felder uh was a good friend you
know she said no scientists should do
what they do stay in the lab if they
want to do it they can do it I say
you're denying somebody the opportunity
to give back to you know pay a moral
debt in some sense but also it's really
fun to do it and it's good for the
students and it's good for the you know
scientists to get exposure to it but
what are your thoughts I mean do you
think we should you know it should be
part of your jst Grant yeah you should
have some budget not just you but you're
already doing it so pring to the choir
how do you react to that yeah I I think
there's two aspects there when I before
I directly answer your question I'll
sort of talk about my motivation for
doing the channel um I sometimes got
frustrated reading scientific articles
or YouTube videos or whatever it was or
podcasts that were secondhand material
right so I want to hear about the Human
Genome Project or something but rather
than hearing from the scientists and
directly you hear about it from you know
a skill journalist but it's still um
you've gone through a middleman you've
had some kind of Chinese Whispers kind
of taking place you the game of
telephone as they say um and so I I got
frustrated with that because I wanted to
hear directly from the people in the
trenches what was happening and what it
was like and so when I started my
channel that was my inspiration was I
wanted to provide people uh The Voice
from scientists themselves I think it's
important that that people hear from the
scientists themselves else how how else
could the public have trust in what
we're doing um if we're always detached
and removed from them with several
layers of protection in between I mean
you know what it's like with YouTube the
audience builds a relationship with you
by by watching and they get to know that
you know your doubts and your skepticism
and your uh beliefs and they get to feel
a sort of level of trust that this
person is credible and they're going to
speak out when they see something wrong
and they're going to um tell you the way
it really is and that that's very fresh
and I think there's a real appeal and
desire for that I think that's why many
such as yourself and other YouTubers
have been so successful with what
they're doing in terms of the moral
obligation to do that work um maybe I'm
sort of in between you and saim in that
sense um I would say that any large
organization or team I agree does have
an obligation to share their results and
talk about it but I don't believe that
necessarily every single scientist in
the team should do that work um there
are some
brilliant scientists and grad students I
can think of who are very very good at
doing that detailed technical
calculation work but maybe they're just
very introverts and they do not do well
when put in front of a camera and yes
you can you know train people and and
help them in that Journey but there are
some people who just really don't want
to do that and why should they when the
other person in the team is excelling at
that thing so I think as long as we have
representatives from uh from the from
fields and from teams and from
disciplines then we're serving that that
goal of trying to share and by having
podcasts especially that's a
particularly great way because then you
can really bring in people who maybe
aren't maybe I'm not in that category of
Hope but not as skilled at science
communication as usual but you as the
host can kind of guide them through it
to make it a more organic and engaging
experience the most popular you know
videos are with you know people I I
totally out of the you know some
extremely you know accomplished
brilliant theoretical physicist who
studies extra dimensions and graviton
you know uh in Wormhole it's just like
no one's going to understand that but
they they really Shine the audience
really takes to it they my sense is
there's there's a thirst for it and and
part of the reason is because and I
don't think they should you know every
grad student should be on YouTube but I
was thinking more of blogs and and just
you know but public speaking is a very
valuable skill you know as well as I do
that you know there's more to being a
professor than just being smart right
there's marketing their sale I mean
Galileo is a master of this like he he
sold his products he sold his his books
but he was also very uh very wise and
and and knowledgeable and cunning in
some ways one of the things that that
really appeals to to me about YouTube is
that it's two it you know we write a
paper yeah the ref two referees you know
might read it if we're lucky uh I've
refereed nature papers where I'm the
only referee it's crazy but on YouTube
we have our favorite you know section
the comment section so uh it's a two-way
Avenue where they really feel like they
can communicate with people I feel like
that is a service that we you know we we
do owe to the extent that we have the
privilege of a platform to to extend to
but yeah the other aspect that's I want
to touch on is um I know if interested
to hear your thoughts on this is the
asymmetry it kind of creates when you
become a successful public Communicator
of science as I think yeah we we both
have had some success in that degree and
it creates an what can be obviously is
like the lowest level like jealousy and
envy amongst your colleagues for the
fact that you get to have this larger
platform so if I write a paper uh we did
it in our last video our research videos
never do as well by the way they NE they
I never never make a research video L
people going to be interested in them
when I talk about you know the universe
or something but it's it's part of our
brand that we always have that authentic
connection to real research science but
it's it's an incredible advantage that I
have if you think about it so every
paper I get I write in my team we could
in principle at least have 100,000
people uh hear about it and that's just
like by normal astronomy that's
ridiculous cuz as you said like maybe
two people would normally hear about the
paper and so I do maybe I overthink it
too much but I worry about the fact I'm
creating like an unfair playing field
for myself by having that advantage and
also it comes with responsibilities of
um being critical so if I want to be
critical of someone else's work which is
part of the course in Academia right
that's how Academia works is science
works by criticizing by skepticism and
by building upon other ideas and
iterating right that that's how science
work works but if you do that on a
platform where you bring in hundreds of
thousands of people every day the
scientists who you are criticizing maybe
not unreasonably will feel very
victimized by that process and I've had
that I've experienced that I've had
academics write to me really like very
upset and offended emails um and might
want to ask me to take down a video yeah
yeah and and then and then yeah how do
you deal with that what's the that
that's where I struggle a little bit as
a community no you're right I mean it is
it is sort of this outsized you know
magnifying glass which is so funny
because you know if you told your your
20-year-old self you know whatever 20 20
years ago you that you'd be a podcaster
you'd be a UT what is this like it
didn't exist right um and let alone also
as a professor you knew what that was
but you know it's a privilege to have it
and I I guess the the the you know all
we can hope is that we we should be
allowed you know one of my friends talks
about an accuracy budget like you should
be able to talk in public and not be
expected to be Wikipedia or chat GPT and
that yeah you might get some of your
colleagues things maybe not 100% perfect
I was talking about luk quantum gravity
or whatever but I'm talking about it
with my expertise which is as an
experimentalist you are looking at as a
theorist in general and you can assess
things even if it's outside your field
especially all the more so if it's
inside your field I think to be I think
for every it's it's like I think
everyone should have a budget of of how
many complaint emails they write to
Airlines but also how many compliment or
you know emails or or you know
chocolates that they give to Steward
stewards whatever they call them there
hosts because you know I think if it's
only one way it it does present sort of
a buy so if you're only critical and you
never you never raise anyone up you just
push people down and similarly if I only
Champion my students and my research
it's kind of backhanded way of
complimenting me so I I do try to to
highlight people in my collaboration who
think they're the most brilliant people
I get to spend my life with you know
large part of my day with rather but I I
think you know we should we shouldn't we
shouldn't feel so much pressure that we
shouldn't be able to talk about it a
because you're getting attention to
their work and you're not criticizing it
you're not doing ad attacks I mean I've
seen those videos that you do they're
fabulous and they they bring in a whole
host of people that would otherwise be
be completely ignorant of again what
their tax dollars are supporting I mean
again the awesome responsibility that
you felt when you're wielding this 10
billion that was paid for by taxpayers
in different countries and and I'm at a
public university but you're at a
private still you get Public Funding so
I think I I think it's good to think
that way and the last thing I'll say
about it is it's good for the students
and the scientists to learn how to
communicate to do a little bit of what
we do as salesmanship and saleswoman
whatever you want to call it we we have
to be convincing we have to make an
argument we have to have a certain
amount of Charisma but yes not abuse it
certainly not and I don't feel like
we're in that field there are people
that do a lot of clickbait like I I told
you I had Neil degrass Tyson on this and
I asked my comment section as I asked
for you uh you know what kind of
questions you know that they want you to
uh answer and it's all about your stance
on woke Pon I'm just kidding but on Neil
it was yeah it was like when is he GNA
get you know apologize for being so what
and I'm like I'm not going to ask him
like that's not fair I could ask him we
did get into it I mean I did ask him
stuff about gender and his feel but I
want yeah I want him to express his his
opinion Elon Musk you know going after I
mean imagine like you feel this pressure
going after you know we just academics
right imagine Elon Musk is like going
after you and saying you got this
because of the X Y and Z I think the
more you can use it to highlight science
to be a champion of science we're all
inspired by other scientists we stand on
the shoulders of giants and I think what
you do is just so commendable because
it's it's it's well done I was joking
you know like people expect if the
lightss off or the video's off like
we're doing a Netflix special you do
Netflix I mean I legitimately thought
some of your videos were in a in a
studio or I mean it's so the the quality
the attention to detail and then on top
of that the rigor of science it's no
wonder why it's become so popular you're
almost done a million I know you asked
me about the the green screen side D
because I have these videos ask like is
that green screen like no that's just
that's just Bok yeah someone says like
oh your hair do you what what do they
use to color your hair I'm like nothing
yet you know it's like it's it's a big S
uh so one of the comments that I had and
I we have to run to lunch with our
colleagues in a few minutes but uh I
want to ask my Pat final four questions
but uh one of the questions came from a
listener and I always solicit questions
on my YouTube channel Twitter X you can
find both of us on those platforms is
about will the upcoming missions Jupiter
icy moons a juice Mission the uh Europa
Clipper will those be informative at all
to your research or are they just kind
of be interesting to you as a as a as an
astronomer as a scientist as a as a
human yeah I think it's kind of in
between those two obviously the the kind
of information that you Clipper will uh
catch which is in the early
2030s is going to be incredibly detailed
compared to what we get for EXO moons
right so for EXO moons I think all we
can really realistically hope to measure
is their Mass their radius their orbit
the basic properties that we often have
for exop Planet as well we are starting
well we have already collected the at
atmospheric data of many exoplanets and
I think we could expect to do similarly
for large exomoons in the future if
these Neptune size moons are real they
certainly would be quite suitable for
that
um but with Europa Clipper I mean you
are you are taking images of sort of uh
metus scale potentially with these close
flybys where you can see individual
fragments of ice blocks you know moving
and moving around there's absolutely no
way that that is um comparable to what
we can do nor does it give us a huge
amount of influence into our
observations because that's all just
lost in the noise I mean that kind of
level of detail but I do think it
informs us in terms of you if we see an
IXO Moon and we could probably tell that
because of the mass and the radius like
okay this is likely something that looks
consistent with Europa then we could
look at the detailed information we have
of Europa and say okay some of the
predictions would be maybe You' get a
plume for instance now again Inus in
particular has these large plumes quite
often yeah and so that's interesting
because if you scale that up a little
bit and simly iio often has these
volcanic outbursts if you just scale
those up by a factor of two or three
imagine a super ey a super Enceladus
then we might start to have a chance of
detecting those phenomena those plumes
as they come out would create a cloud
that we could detect spectroscopically
so I think we can Again by analogy say
like yeah that what's happening there
isn't detectable with our observations
but we can imagine a way of scan it up
that we could get it oh fascinating yeah
so that that's another way of you know
leveraging tools from another it doesn't
sound like it but as you said Kepler
just had a photometer it didn't have
spectrometer imagine if it had you know
spe you know spectroscopy ability again
your your dictate of of of kind of
looking for tools from other dimensions
and even though to layers doesn't sound
like another spect recipes is different
from you know astronomy or you know the
RM from photometry than you know
chemistry is from uh from gardening or
whatever uh David we're running out of
time I always like to ask one final
question inspired by the namesake of
this podcast arthor C Clark who said the
following he said the only way of
determining the limits of the possible
is to go beyond them into the impossible
I like to use that as a vehicle jumping
off point we have a lot of young people
listening if you could go back spend 20
minutes with your younger self
20-year-old self what would you tell him
to give him the courage to go into the
impossible as you've done I think maybe
stop messing around so much what do you
mean when I was young I think I was um a
little bit well I I was a naughty kid at
school that's for sure I I misbehaved a
lot I was not a very studious child and
I didn't really get serious about my
academic studies until I was sort of
like maybe 1819 and so yeah I M around a
lot and I kind of yeah I do regret that
a little bit that I you I feel like when
you're young your brain is a sponge and
I wish I was more well read and and
using that opportunity to just ingest as
much as I could I was reading the
biography of Isaac new and on the uh on
the plane ride over and it was talking
about how at age 24 you know during the
plague he basically invented all of
modern physics you know for like the
classic classical modern physics and I
was thinking like wow when I was 24
I was I was no nowhere near that level
of seriousness this guy was like you
know and when he was a child he was
already you know building water Mills in
rivers and things at like age you know
11 12 to see how water flows and was
studying it very detailed and so yeah I
kind of wish I'd um I'd applied myself a
bit more I regret I regret those though
you know how much I think it's important
to have fun and to mess around but you
know I like I think I think aror Schwarz
has said this want that every time
you're partying you're horsing around
just remember there's someone out there
who is working their butt off to try and
get ahead of you and it is you know when
you look at graduate school applications
now and getting into Ivy League schools
it is so compatitive that you really
have to um you know I feel an enormous
sympathy for students who are applying
to these schools these days um but you
really do need to have that kind of not
all all your time but a fraction of your
time you need to be applied and thinking
about your future in a more serious way
than I think I did and I think I would
be probably more uh academically
well-rounded uh had I had I done so so
yeah I kind of regret that a little bit
but um at the end of the day you are who
you are and you can't go back in time
and change things so it is what it is
certainly had much of a negative impact
on your career today and I always point
out you don't want to emulate Newton too
much because he died a virgin and that
was his he called that his biggest
accomplishment we'll talk about that
next time David King thank you so much
for coming on the podcast uh brief we
have a million other questions for me
and for my audience we'll do a part two
when you're out here again I'd love to
have you back and I'm really looking
forward to clo him today I'm going to be
super nerded out and uh I just love I
love diving deep into other fields and
and you're thank you so much for what
you do for sciencey it's great and I
hope to get you on my podcast when you
come to New York a deal January yeah
thanks a lot thank you if you enjoyed
this interview I know you're going to
love my conversation on how Kepler
discovered 5,000 exoplanets with Jason
Stefan one of the leaders of the Kepler
Mission and its subsequent data analysis
and see you next week on into the
impossible
