#JWST#JamesWebbSpaceTelescope#BenShapiroReacts In July NASA released the first images and data from the James Webb Space Telescope. Here's my discussion with @Ben Shapiro on this treasure trove of data including:
Carina Nebula. The Carina Nebula is one of the largest and brightest nebulae in the sky, located approximately 7,600 light-years away in the southern constellation Carina. Nebulae are stellar nurseries where stars form. The Carina Nebula is home to many massive stars, several times larger than the Sun.
WASP-96 b (spectrum). WASP-96 b is a giant planet outside our solar system, composed mainly of gas. The planet, located nearly 1,150 light-years from Earth, orbits its star every 3.4 days. It has about half the mass of Jupiter, and its discovery was announced in 2014.
Southern Ring Nebula. The Southern Ring, or “Eight-Burst” nebula, is a planetary nebula – an expanding cloud of gas, surrounding a dying star. It is nearly half a light-year in diameter and is located approximately 2,000 light years away from Earth.
Stephan’s Quintet: About 290 million light-years away, Stephan’s Quintet is located in the constellation Pegasus. It is notable for being the first compact galaxy group ever discovered in 1877. Four of the five galaxies within the quintet are locked in a cosmic dance of repeated close encounters.
Don't miss my exclusive LIVE Q & A with JWST Project Scientist, and Nobel Prize winner, John Mather! https://youtu.be/vC77uaWYd44
Please join my mailing list to get the latest news in the Universe and win cool prizes like meteorites, books, and more! briankeating.com/list 📝
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
Joining us on the line is Professor Brian Keating, cosmologist at the University of California,
San Diego, which means he studies the stars. He's not a cosmetologist, which is like a person who
does makeup. He's also the author of the bestselling memoir, Losing the Nobel Prize.
His latest book is his newest book, Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner.
Brian, thanks so much for joining the show. Great to talk to you.
Yeah, it's good to see you again, Ben.
So let's talk about this amazing stuff that we are getting now from the Webb Telescope. So first
of all, what is the Webb Telescope and why should we care other than it makes pretty pictures?
Well, it does a lot more than that. It's a $10 billion investment, probably the most complicated
object human beings have ever shot off into space. And it's located a million miles away
from Earth. It's actually four times the distance to the moon. And its job is really to peer back
almost to the beginning of time, not quite to the beginning of time. That's my domain.
They're not allowed to go back all the way to the beginning, but they're allowed to look at,
and their goal is to look at, the earliest structures that ever formed in the universe.
That's one major topic, to look at galaxies, the first stars that formed, to see if the edifice on
which all of modern science stands upon, which is based on our origin of the universe, if there is
good, solid framework for it. And also in so doing, these photons, these particles of light,
traverse the universe and they encode the properties of the universe as it's evolved
since the origin of time, including relatively nearby objects by our standards, things that are
only a few thousand light years away. And those are called exoplanets. Those are other planets,
perhaps just like the Earth, that could potentially harbor forms of life. And that's,
you know, what if they have a competitor podcast to you, Ben? So we want to make sure that everyone
out there is fully apprised of all the latest happenings. So this telescope is really a
culmination of decades of work. It's way over budget, way over time, but it really does what
nothing else can do, which is to peer back and give us a glimpse into our cosmic origins.
So Brian, I watched a video where you're talking about this telescope, and obviously you've spent
your life making telescopes and monitoring telescopes. So what amount of complexity went
into this? And also, I mean, how high was the risk here? Because this is out in the middle
of nowhere. If something is broken on this thing, you're basically screwed and you just
sent $10 billion worth of hardware into just space for no reason. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. This had so
many, what we call single point failure risks where any one individual problem could compromise
the whole $10 billion mission, whether that could be blowing up on the launch pad or not being able,
this telescope is so big and so wide, it could not be launched in its final configuration and
had to be unfolded and unpacked like origami. And I have some animations on my YouTube channel of
that process. And that is a technological hurdle, not just because you're building something in
space with no astronauts nearby to service it. As you said, it's thousands of times farther away
than the Hubble. The Hubble Space Telescope is actually closer to us than you and I are right
now. And in other words, the Hubble space is only 250 miles above the earth. This is, you know,
this is a million miles away. So no chance of repair, no service stations out there in space.
And so this had to work, it had to work the right time, the first time and with no opportunity for
repair. And it also had to be unfolded and the mirrors aligned to a precision less than the
diameter of a human hair. And so that is just astounding accomplishment. And there were many
times when it could have been canceled and it could have been. And some astronomers, rightfully,
I have to, you know, mention it. Some astronomers didn't think they should continue with it because
it did kind of swallow NASA's budget. But now that it's out there, you know, you forgot about the
birthing pains of the baby. And now it's doing this phenomenal science as of just this week.
So what is the sort of program for the telescope? How long is it supposed to sit out there before it
is out of range or degrades or does it sort of stay in? How does it stay out there? How do we
communicate with it? And what do we expect to get from it in terms of data?
Yeah, so it's pretty amazing. It's not orbiting like the moon orbits around the earth and the
earth orbits around the sun. This object is orbiting around a blank piece of space. It's
basically trailing behind the sun, earth and moon by a distance of, as I said, a million miles away
from the earth. So it's kind of this amazing point in space called the Lagrange point for you
aficionados out there. I know your audience is the second smartest in the universe, except for my
audience. And this object has to maintain that precision called station keeping for hopefully
two decades or more. There's really almost no limitation on its lifetime. It's shielded from
the brutal conditions of space by this very thin mylar balloon like material. And that blocks enough
light and heat that it can remain cold. These cameras are not seeing light like you and I are
looking at each other right now. They're seeing infrared radiation, which is slightly longer
wavelength, which is not visible to the human eye. So it's revealing things that Hubble could
not see. And it will do so for two decades. So you've obviously had a rich amount of time to
study these photos. I mean, you've had you've had all of like 24 hours to look at these photos.
So explain the secrets of the universe. What exactly has been confirmed here? I mean,
obviously, they've talked about the curvature of space time and the sort of confirmation of
Einsteinian theories of relativity. But what are some of the earliest things that we've learned?
Yeah, it's interesting. So yeah, of course, the data just came out a few hours ago in the time
we're talking. But we kind of had a hint at what they would be looking at. And of course, Hubble's
been up for a long for 30 years now. And so it was able to kind of provide a finder scope view of
what these objects would look like. Again, different wavelengths, different science.
So what these five images that they released really do portend for the future of this of this
is quite astounding. We'll be able to look at the effects of gravity on distant objects. And gravity
is the most pervasive force in the universe. It's the one I use as an excuse why I don't go to the
gym for the last 30 years. But this but gravity is the most dominant force. And yet it's the
weakest force. You don't think about that when you're at the gym pumping iron, but but it's
actually the weakest force. So therefore, it can have the longest range. It can reach out across
the entirety of the universe and affect the properties of massive clusters and stars. And
what we're most interested in, I think, with Webb are really two or three different main topics. One
is the effects on the early universe. How did the early universe assemble the star which came first,
the star or the galaxy? In other words, how do we know what the elemental building blocks are of
astronomy? We actually don't have a great idea for that. What is the nature of dark matter and
energy? Dark matter and dark energy then make up 95% of the universe's mass and energy. And we have
no clue whatsoever what they are. And then the third thing that many people are really interested
in, and I kind of aped you and did a Brian Keating reacts video, you know, there was less, you know,
woke tears, and there weren't so many lives of tick tock on it. But But nevertheless, I did a
reaction to what I'm most interested in, is the search for life in the universe, because I'm
actually a life pessimist, I don't believe that there's life elsewhere in the universe. But no
one would be more thrilled than I to discover that there is life in the universe. And what what web
can do and when it released just a tantalizing hint of an object that we know doesn't have life
on it. It's an object, you know, something like half the size of Jupiter, the planet Jupiter.
And it's cruising around a star every three days. So it's getting pretty toasty, a little toastier
than than down there in Florida. But But the object has so much so strong atmospheric lines
that can actually demonstrate the properties of water. And many scientists think that water is a
necessary ingredient, not sufficient, but necessary ingredient for life to be supported. Again, I'm not
so sanguine that there is life in the universe, there's zero evidence for life elsewhere in the
universe. But that would make me the most surprised and excited to find out that it's true. And so web
has this unique ability that even my powerful telescopes that my colleagues and I are building,
we have no ability to do that. So web is unique in that sense.
Brian Keating, he of course, is the author of losing the Nobel Prize and his latest book is
think like a Nobel Prize winner. Brian, thanks so much for the insight on this stuff. It really is
amazing and fascinating. And if you're a religious person, it confirms your belief that there is a
God in the universe. If you're not religious, then you know, science is cool. Brian really
appreciate the time. Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.