do you think there's no possibility for
alien life in the
universe I think it's I didn't say it's
no probability I think the probability
is very low and I can explain why yeah
please so um have you ever heard of the
Drake equation yes yeah so the Drake
equation is essentially a
parameterization of our of our ignorance
about certain things in the in the
universe and we've kind of checked off
seven of the terms and the eight terms
of the Drake equation thanks to new
technology thanks to new telescopes how
many stars have planets around on them
how many total but there's a couple
terms in there the lifetime of a
civilization and a certain fraction of
how much that Civilization can dedicate
its energy or what have you towards
broadcasting its presence right so for
us to know that they exist they have to
exist they have to have made technology
for us for them to exist and when they
have to exist in the first place so how
many of such objects are that's what the
Drake equations uh really
parameterizing um now I propose that you
should be able to do the following thing
if there's life in the universe just
life slime mold I don't care what it is
you should be able to set limits on it
in the following sense and the and I'm
what I'm going to do is do a rucu ad
absurdum I'm going to prove I'm going to
motivate hopefully I can't prove but I'm
going to motivate the illogic or of of
suspecting that they're extraterrestrial
intelligent civilization okay here it
goes I told let me just tell you um my
colleagues discovered that there's a
planet and it's around a star that's
just like our sun and it's next to
another planet and that planet's full of
life and the other planet's almost
identical to that planet it's it's
almost the same size it has a day the
same age the same length as the day of
the planet that has just rotten with
life it's crawling with Kardashians and
slime molds and whatever right so it's
out there just like us yeah I said to
you Joe what do you think the odds are
that those two neighboring planets that
there's no reason physically they
shouldn't both be identical what are the
odds that the other one should not have
life what would you say with the same
environment the same uh solar system
environment same properties rocky planet
had liquid water it has an atmosphere it
has a magnetic field you know has all
sorts of things I would think it would
be more likely that it would have life
very likely it would be extremely likely
okay now let me tell you that that
planet exists it's called Mars and I
brought you a piece of it here okay this
is a fragment okay so this goes in order
of expense okay so this um this I give
these things I give away that big
meteorite is a present for you thank you
um this is a piece of Mars This I only
give to you I don't have one for Jamie
that's an actual piece of Mars that's an
actual piece of Mars so from an asteroid
so what happened was uh the Earth gets
hit by meteors right all the time and uh
but so did all the other planets
Sometimes some of that material from
Mars gets impact imagine something that
big that Jamie showed before slamming
into it's going to eject from the
surface of Mars that's going to orbit in
the Clouds of Mars eventually going to
get outside the atmosphere of Mars that
the impact is great enough carrying some
of the debris the surface the crust of
Mars Etc and that will then percolate
throughout the solar system for tens of
millions of years perhaps until the
Earth smashes into it and it lands in
this case it landed in Africa that was
recovered from Africa um that little
third of a gram is a slice off a bigger
chunk okay um and not only does that
piece of Mars doesn't have any signature
of light on it and we've been to Mars
we've stuck probes into Mars we have a
helicopter freaking helicopter flying
around on Mars right now it's insane um
we don't see anything now that doesn't
mean that life didn't exist there before
it doesn't mean that if we don't fly
into a lava cave there won't be but it
does it not say something this is called
panspermia something that sounds dirty
but it's no I know the term yeah so so
we exchange material and actually sir
Fred Hoy the guy who came up with the
idea for the name the Big Bang uh he
actually believed in the steady state
model he believed that's how life was
Seated on Earth the fact is that we've
been exchanging material for literally
billions of years from when the Earth
was you know just bacteria and Mars was
flowing with water we know Mars was was
rich with now the fact that we don't see
any is that proof it never had absolute
and not but I'm just saying it's a piece
of evidence and that evidence is very
hard to come by right it's hard to prove
a negative right it's hard to say that
like Mars definitely never had life can
I stop you there yeah how much detection
do we have I mean how much technology is
currently on Mars that's looking at
signs of life there've been probes since
you know Viking and and so forth how
many of them are capable of detecting
signs of life other than like physical
all of them have had some capability for
precursors to life in other words some
have been able to detect water some have
had spectrometers that could detect
gases how many of them are landed uh
probably 15 or 20 and Mars is what is it
how much smaller than Earth it's about
yeah it's a little bigger than the moon
but a a lot it seems like a lot of space
that we didn't detect things on or
didn't even right it but isn't that the
converse of the usual argument that I
hear there's there's 100 billion stars
in the Milky Way um many of them are
like the sun there's 100 billion
galaxies or more like the Milky Way so
it's 100 billion squared the universe is
13.8 billion years old so what are the
odds so usually asers will say will'll
do calculations uh a following way
instead of like asking what's the
probability of of that um you know for
example I've I've been to Antarctica
twice I've been to the South Pole which
is you would just be bored out of your
mind probably because all it is is like
going out into the middle of the Pacific
Ocean and freezing it there's nothing to
do there the coast of Antartica is
really cool so this is a rock from there
they have like volcanoes there that's
not for you but that one I got to take
back cuz that cost me 50,000 that cost
you the taxpayer $50,000 but this you
can keep this is from from the south
Pole's gift shop Joe that's a patch in
the United States we have such cool
freaking scientists man our country in
the world um I just I heard something I
was like I wonder if Joe knows this um
it's totally random but just like how
cool is freaking signs it's pretty cool
do you know they can measure I'll get
back to your question in just a second
they measure like the stress levels of
whales and they can use the stress of
whales to determine if like the Soviets
are or Russ are testing bombs under
under the ocean floor like what the hell
I heard this talk recently woman
studying whale ear wax so whales don't
have ears like ours that stick out and
they would not be good for like swimming
around right there's a lot of friction
but they have like these vestigial
things because they like evolve from
wolves like I always thought like stuff
came out of the water and that whales
evolved into wolves no no they think
that wolves turned into whales really
yes wolves yes I don't know this Jamie
has because I am a total ignoramus but
this is a going Theory whales evolved
from wol so like most mammals they have
ears those ears have been covered over
and what happens to a whale is that it
retains ear wax and the ear there's ear
wax in the whale the whale doesn't hear
with its ears it hears through its
Jawbone uh and that reverberates and
that's how it sens it sound but it still
has vestigial ear wax they sample the
ear wax of dead whales and they can
measure how much cortisol the stress
hormone is in the whale and they know
the migratory patterns of the
whale science and they do some of this
research in anartica so anyway that's
really fascinating but we're kind of
getting off topic I I want to understand
how you can look at all of the variables
that are possible in terms of the
composition of planets in terms of
temperature in in terms of also
different kinds of environments for life
that we haven't encountered yet but
could be real different kinds of life
things that are very very alien to what
we perceive of as carbon based life
forms I just don't