📰 Go to https://ground.news/drbrian to see through media bias and become a smarter news consumer. Subscribe through my link for 40% off unlimited access this month.
Getting it right is the hallmark of any great scientist. And when we don’t, we should be able to say we were wrong.
In part 2 of debunking all the claims Terrence Howard made on the Joe Rogan Experience, I start by first apologizing for misrepresenting the number of patents Howard has.
Even though he doesn’t have the 97 patents he claimed to have, he does hold quite a few, contrary to my earlier assertions.
But this episode is not all sunshine and rainbows. I actually go through 17 different newfound complaints about that conversation.
This video will go through each one of those points, and we'll even take a deep dive into one of Eric Weinstein's favorite hobby horses, peer review.
Tune in!
Key Takeaways:
00:00 Intro 00:32 Apology for errors about Howard's patents 02:49 Overview of Howard's actual patent portfolio 07:22 Importance of precise scientific communication 14:23 Is there north and south in space? 15:06 Ground News 18:00 Penrose stairs, scientific collaboration, quantum entanglement 22:16 The role of patents in science 24:38 The relationship between photons and electrons 27:26 Critique of Howard's scientific claims 33:46 Defense of peer review in science 46:14 Potential innovations in scientific publishing
I was wrong about Terrence Howard and
this video is my apology to that great
actor based on a conversation he and I
have had since his appearance alongside
Eric Weinstein on The Joe Rogan
Experience but this video is not all
sunshine and rainbows I actually go
through 17 different Newfound complaints
about that otherwise Monumental 4-Hour
conversation this video will go through
each one of those points and we'll even
take a deep dive in one of Eric
Weinstein's favorite hobby horses which
is peer review you won't want to miss it
that's coming up at the end let's go
before we get to the graveling and
please for forgiveness I want to make
sure that you've either seen the entire
conversation with Eric Joe and Terren or
you watched my part one analysis of it
part one took issue with four different
aspects of terrence's claims including
the fact that 1 * 1 equals 2 that
gravity needs to be destroyed that the
periodic table is not what we think it
is and most importantly that he has 97
patents to his name and that's where my
error lies after my part one video which
you can find up here Terren reached out
through Eric to correct my errors he
actually showed me that I had made many
mistakes about his patent repertoire and
I want to analyze those as well because
I think getting it right is the most
important Hallmark of a scientist and a
scientist should be able to say when he
or she is wrong and that includes
amateurs like Terrence but it also
applies to the dangerous rise in
anti-science sentiment that's being
promulgated by figures in the culture
like Candace Owens Tucker Carlson and
many more we won't talk about those
characters today let's start with the
apology in my last video I said in
terrence's case he applied for it in
2010 and has a number you can find it on
Google of the patent application but
then it shows it as abandoned in the
year 2013 so he was not granted a actual
patent number for his technology so that
segment was about the 97 patents teren
claims he has now it's certainly true he
has nowhere near 97 granted Pat
he might not even have 97 patent
applications including those that have
been abandoned rejected or granted
immediately after part one I got a
message from Terren via Eric and we've
been communicating ever since he sent me
a link to all the all of his patents
while it's true that he had abandoned
the patent for virtual reality as shown
in 2013 as I indicated there are several
patents issued not just in America but
in other countries again nowhere near 97
and I think it's important for Terren if
you're listening and I hope you are out
there to always be accurate and if you
make a mistake as I'm doing now admit
when you made a mistake it's not so
painful I've made many blunders and
you're not in Bad Company either Galileo
made blunders and even the great Albert
Einstein so I went through a list and I
linked the list of terence's patents on
my website you can find at briank
king.com
you can find all of his patent portfolio
folio his repertoire of patents it's
incredibly extensive what I'm going to
do now is summarize these patents and
their patent Publications there's a
difference again between a granted
patent a patent application patent
pending Utility Patent design patent
these are all incredibly important
things but you can easily access these
in my conversation in part one many of
his patents focus on aesthetic
functionality rather than technical
Innovation but the smaller subset that
I'm interested in in describing today
involves the structural Frameworks of an
unconventional propulsion system there's
also a a novel invention which he has
patented which has an actual patent
number involving an electric Arc device
where these Concepts although they're
not necessarily implemented right now it
is interesting to stimulate the
imagination and to stake out future
intellectual property claims again
people like Elon Musk claim they don't
even patent stuff anymore because it's
basically lawyer bait it just attracts
attention legal attention of terrance's
many granted patents nowhere near 97
they appear under the name Terren dashen
Howard or t Howard or t dashen Howard
there are about 50 Publications or so
and they date back to 2013 you can find
them also on a website called justia but
there are effectively 11 of those that
are patent applications those aren't
granted and even if they're shown patent
pending they're not recognized
officially in any jurisdiction 23 are
design patents that primarily relate to
representing shapes as he's indicated in
the video with Eric and Joe and in a
Solo episode with Joe as well 11 are
granted patents that aren't designed
patents so those are potentially of
monetary and Technical usage two of
these are for a gun where the explosion
doesn't come from gunpowder or chemical
ignition but come from an electric spark
an arc that causes a chemical gas
expansion and there are others for GM
metric structures such as the famous
Lynch pin which Terren devises as a
framework for building a drone a
hexacopter many bladed drone and some of
them are through the functional building
blocks of different shapes materials
that could be made from but to my know's
haven't been ever employed in actual
devices that's fine again I was wrong I
said he didn't have any granted patents
these are granted official patents again
there's at least 11 of them in the
document that I've Linked In this video
and description below but also in the in
correspondence that teren and I have had
now since that time we've communicated
that we've had a mutual desire to get
together and discuss his technology and
also show him my two patents and how
they work and why they didn't bring me a
single scent of remuneration but that's
not a reason to not go through with
patents in the first place so again
Terren maypa I think it's important to
acknowledge when you get something wrong
but it's also important to be accurate
so in our conversations I hope we'll
discuss the different ways that we we
can both improve how we communicate the
importance of patents in the
intellectual landscape that surrounds us
it's important for us all to do our due
diligence okay now on to the rest of the
episode this episode was fascinating in
part because it was a conversation that
it seemed that all three of them wanted
to have Joe as much as Eric and Terrence
Joe at the very beginning points out
that it should all be about ideas and in
fact he echoed a very famous sentiment
by none the Noel Laureate Marie C when
he said the following if think really
care about these ideas though what they
should do is talk about the ideas it's
the personal attacks that are attached
to the ideas by people that want to be
taken seriously it the whole thing
up cuz like either you're correct or
you're incorrect tell me what you think
is right and then you tell me what you
think is right let's work this out but
this personal attach if you're talking
about something as complex as the things
that you discussed on this podcast
there's no room for Bullit r k said that
now is the time to be focused on ideas
rather than people when you focus on
people there's a tendency to make ad
homm attacks and get sidetracked by the
personalities and personal attacks that
you may want to make or you may feel and
perceive being me and Joe Points this
out very effectively this can ensure a
respectful dialogue and I think this has
been incredibly helpful something like
20 or 30 million people have seen Terren
and Terren and Joe and Eric having
conversations just in the last month
it's really captivated the landscape I
even had a conversation with Piers
Morgan along with Tom Bilu and my friend
Eric Weinstein that video got over a
million views in just one day so people
are really interested in this now is the
time to be less curious about people and
more curious about ideas now this is not
always easy as a scientist because
sometimes you have to balance your anger
and frustration with a narrative that's
getting out perhaps when I'm making a
debunking video or making a video
critical of some iracy Theory that's
hard to keep that balance between ideas
and avoiding ad hominum attacks
especially since sometimes the ideas
that I'm criticizing come from people
themselves that are accusing me or my
colleagues of committing intellectual
malas so that's really hard to reconcile
but I'll try my best and continue to
Endeavor to do better the second topic
today is about math and the complex
relationship between the number zero
which Terren has a great deal of
difficulty the boys discuss logarithms
exponential functions and in highlights
how this property that Terren seems to
ascribe to the number one or the number
two or the square root of it as I
hopefully have debunked thoroughly in
part one this concept that the number
two is a rational number I went through
in two different ways explaining how the
number two the square root of two rather
is a irrational but it's also not
rational so I proved it from both
directions not myself originally but
showing you how it's done in the
literature dating back to the time of
euklid so equally interesting is the
number zero and as Eric points out he
goes through what's called set theory or
naive set set theory Paul H's great book
he talks about the fact that all zeros
are equivalent the number of bananas
buried underneath the South Pole is
equal to the number of fruit flies that
are currently on Jupiter's moon IO these
are both zero and so all things are zero
can be identified which means that
there's only one number zero there's
only one set of zero Elements which then
allows you to get the number one right
there's only one set of all things that
have zero elements so now you have the
number one you have the number zero now
you can start adding them together and
get the properties of the number system
that we know and love of the integers
once you have the integers you can say
what are quotients or rational numbers
once you have the rational numbers you
can say what are not rational numbers so
you can build up all of mathematics so
zero is incredibly important if I change
the word itself to the word zero which
you're going to say there is no zero why
do I say there's no zero because you
have well this this why I keep trying to
get back to what I understand par is
underlying metaph I'm saying that there
to to say zero zero is supposed to
represent no thing nothing whatsoever
but they have zero as a number set up as
a number but to say no thing your brain
creates a chemical structure even in
saying nothing so there is what I'm
saying philosophically difference
there's a difference between the empty
set and empty set that's the difference
right so there is a zero but to multiply
something by by the nothing to multiply
something by
nothing don't they have to be
dimensionally equal to an order to
multiply like you can't multiply a human
by an ant because they're not
dimensionally equal so the empty set is
an incredibly interesting topic and let
me know in the comments if you'd like me
to do a deep dive into pure mathematics
Seth theory is the foundation of all of
mathematical logic which then provides
the tree of knowledge at which all of
physics will grow out of and then from
physics comes chemistry biology
political science and everything else so
understanding zero and its vital role is
essential for grasping any mathematical
theories from the most Elementary to the
most advanced the gentleman then
discussed dimensional equality and
multiplication this they have great
tension over so what is the importance
of dimensional compatibility so when you
take when you've heard you can't compare
apples and oranges what we're really
saying is that units must match but when
you multiply integers there are no units
so units have no place in the
multiplication of the integer or any
number in fact you can't exponentiate a
number with units you can't take the
logarithm of a number with units so it's
nonsensical to multiply unrelated
Dimensions as Terence then goes into and
he talks about well you know you take a
dollar and you multiply by a dollar and
then he starts talking about the need
for dimensional coherence which then
Segways into Fiat money and then
sideways into Bitcoin and and other
things that can't be printed this is a
real distraction Terren you're just
wrong about 1 * 1 equaling two there's
no way around it all of mathematics is
based on it your paycheck for your
wonderful acting gets based upon this
it's totally something you should really
give up it really doesn't have relevance
and it doesn't have any application to
anything to do with your technology your
patents or anything more that you may be
considering that Eric seems to think has
great great applicability potentially
such as things like the Lynch pit which
I don't fully understand and I'm looking
forward to you explaining it to me when
we get together in person the boys then
get into The Ether the Luminous ether
this is incredibly important to me
because the ether was effectively
disproven it was a concept believed in
the 1800s by Maxwell and others to
support electromagnetic waves in vacuum
they couldn't understand how that was
possible all waves go through media like
water or air how could it be possible
that light a wave that Maxwell proved
could go through a vacuum without some
substance underneath it so they proposed
The Ether this was then invalidated at
my alma moer Case Western Reserve
University the Michaelson Morley
experiment it proved that you never got
a additive speed of light due to the
Earth's motion with respect to the
stationary ether which it would have to
be in order to get be compatible with
supporting electromagnetic waves that
Maxwell himself had discovered so
Maxwell was incredibly right and he was
a genius but he was wrong that you
needed to have a wave supporting medium
like The Ether this was thoroughly
disproven it's a foundation of
Relativity and it's a foundation of
Loren and Varian violation which is a
key Cornerstone of my research in the
cosmic micro background more about that
in a future video point five the
necessity of clear scientific
definitions the boys then get into a
stressful conversation about the precise
meaning of scientific discourse and
being accurate in your words and saying
things like super symmetry as Terrence
does and then Eric corrects him and what
that meaning is as a term of art making
analogies between things say an MMA
commentary that Joe did I thought that
was brilliant I actually had a similar
concept of how to explain things when I
talked to Joe back in August of 2023 but
the clarity is so important to get
things right if we don't have a common
lexicon if we don't have a Common
Language and it's not just semantics
when you're trying to co-op the name of
something you're actually trying to
subvert the ideas for which it was
originally conveyed and I think that
that's important again Terence if you're
watching I hope you are please try to
get it right use the right terminology
only in that way can we have a
conversation which isn't muddled and
weighed down by imprecision in our
language the guys then get into a
discussion about north and south and the
highest density and the lowest density
and the north always seek
a higher position the south is always
this is absolutely incorrect there's
nothing accurate about this there's no
North and South in space if you went
into space and turned your head upside
down there's no North or South it's a
convention I've been to the South Pole I
bet Terren hasn't been there yet it
would be fun for him to visit there
someday uh but uh you go to the North
and South Pole it doesn't feel any
different than going to the North Pole
or being in the northern hemisphere
there's nothing intrinsic about North
and South either in magnets or in the
rotation of planets there are some
planets that don't even orbit the same
way the Earth does so we again have to
be careful not to mix up things that
comport with our biases of being say in
the northern hemisphere scientific
advances are often frightening as well
as exciting an example of this is Elon
musk's new neuralink a brain computer
interface designed to assist paralyzed
patients in controlling technology with
their thoughts while this technology
holds immense promise for restoring
movement and communication ethical
concerns linger around safety privacy
and the potential long-term effects
despite the controversy neuralink is
planning upcoming trials in more and
more patients aiming for high single
digits by the end of the year if
successful this could Mark a significant
step towards revolutionizing human
computer interaction I love staying
upto-date on news especially related to
science technology and artificial
intelligence and with the rapid speed of
today's news cycle it's crucial to stay
informed and Trust where you're getting
your information I'm excited I found
this story about neural link on ground
news ground news is a website and app
that I use every day it gathers articles
from around 50,000 news sources all over
the world in an unbiased way that can
help you read between the lines of the
standard mainstream media bias it helps
you break through of algorithms and Echo
Chambers and filter bubbles you can
check them out at ground.
news/ drbryan let me show you why I love
ground news right right away in the
nuring story you can see that 47 news
outlets have reported on the story of
these 47 Outlets 35% of them lean to the
left politically 35% come from the
center and only 31% lean right you can
see the reliability of the outlets
covering the story this is unique it
also shows who owns the outlets
reporting on the story The majority 32%
are from independent news outlets ground
news also makes it easy to compare
headlines to see how bias might
influence the framing and shape our
understanding of the issues I found it
hugely fascinating that the left tends
to focus on the detailed technical
issues and improvements highlighting the
long-term goals while the center
emphasizes musk's intentions to give
people superpowers surprisingly the
right leaning media coverage underscores
Assurance is made that the implant
doesn't harm the brain and focuses more
on the Technology's potential benefits
you can't get this type of news analysis
anywhere else the news isn't going to
report on itself but ground news does
with ground news you get a deeper
understanding of the complexity and
Nuance of different issues by seeing it
from all different sides and identifying
media narratives to get this go to
ground.
newsdr Briant Dr Brant to stay fully
informed on breaking news and see
through media bias you'll become a
smarter news consumer And subscribe to
my link for 40% off unlimited access
with their Vantage plan the same plan I
use by subscribing you're directly
supporting an independent platform for
news and supporting the show as well
they then get into a description of
Science and geometry talking about
terence's intriguing geometrical
interpretations they talk about the
Penrose staircase and Roger's been on
this show many times no Borat so Roger
Penrose describing things like the
Penrose staircase and homi which is an
advanced mathematical subject don't have
time to get into but handedness
chirality which play a huge role in
physics as well as mathematics so
understanding our complicated scientific
laws sometimes these artwork these
pieces of Art and perhaps that's what
Eric's saying is the is the underlying
importance of the lynchpin is that like
the penro staircase nobody goes out and
builds a penro staircase you can't build
a penro staircase in fact in three
dimensions but uh it's important to
explore perhaps the influence of
artistic ideas on mathematical
structures and how they may then perhaps
prove if nothing else useful for
Fruitful scientific analogies the boys
get into scientific collaboration
talking about how you cooperate a
scientist having mutual respect for
another I thought those was quite
beautiful TMZ asked you a question about
they said do I have anything going on
and I was like yeah me and um Eric
Weinstein I said Weinstein Stein I said
Weinstein cuz Brian Keaton said
Weinstein he said
Weinstein he not Weinstein yeah yeah so
it's Weinstein so keing said Weinstein
is that what you're saying he said no he
said Weinstein so I thought I said
Weinstein but I didn't know if that was
just a joke or a play on things
sensitive after Harvey here the guys are
talking about holography Joe brings up
this two Photon state of triangled
photons and I wanted to take you through
this cool little experiment although I
didn't quite see the relevance to the
conversation I it's important to bring
it to your attention because I think
it's such a cool interesting experiment
that was recently published in nature
magazine which is what the boys were
talking about it's about an interesting
Effect called quantum entanglement and
it involves a cool new way to take
pictures of light particles which we
call photons and I want to break it down
for you in relatively simple terms it's
very complex paper obviously published
in nature under peer review and that's
sign posting for later we're going to
get into peer review and how important
it is for working scientists like me and
what Eric thinks is all the pitfalls and
downfalls that peer review has brought
to our understanding of science so
scientists in the nature paper are using
pairs of entangled photons that can be
used for secure Communications and other
types of precise measurements you've
undoubtly heard about cryptography and
Quantum Computing well there's a type of
quantum Computing doesn't use ultra cold
cubits it uses entangled photons and
room temperature environments which is
much more convenient than cooling things
down to a few millikelvin as we do in
our lab for our Quantum cosmology
sensors the problem is it's usually very
hard and slow to figure out exactly what
these pairs look like when they're
entangled and explain how they behave so
what these researchers did is come up
with a clever new method called Boton
digital Hol graphy to effectively take
pictures if you will of these Photon
pairs much faster and more accurately
than before interrogating their state
without destroying them maintaining
their entanglement now holography you've
seen Holograms under credit cards it's
basically gives the illusion of a
three-dimensional volume from just a
two-dimensional surface the credit card
is two-dimensional but it looks like the
Eagle's flying in three dimensions so
that's the principle of holography and
an applies and black holes as well where
you get all the information about them
information contained within the volume
of the black from just its
two-dimensional surface the researchers
use a special camera that could detect
single photons and look at how the
photon pairs interfere with each other
kind of like the way that water waves
make patterns when they interfere and
they meet they tested their method by
creating different shapes of light like
Swirls and using the new technique to
take pictures of the photon pairs
created by this light this new way of
taking Quantum pictures can help
scientists do better Quantum experiments
and maybe even lead to new types of
Imaging that use Quantum Light
properties so by inventing a super fast
accurate camera they took pictures of
things so weird and small we couldn't
see them before now I'm not sure why Joe
Rogan brought this up on the
conversation except that it's really
cool it wasn't relevant to Terence
Howard or Eric Weinstein it's one of the
cool things that Joe likes to show as I
experienced when I was on this podcast
okay now we get to the good stuff the
role of patents in science Eric got
extremely mad every time Terren would
bring up his patents as you see here
even though I've got the 97 patent and
all does you cannot patent science they
took away our ability to earn a living
from doing science right you can do
technology and patent it but you can't P
you cannot patent fundamental
mathematics and physics so let's explore
the complicated relationship between
science and patents and examine how
patents can protect Innovation while
sometimes stifling openness and
collaboration ultimately the recognition
within the scientific Community often
outweighs the protective values of
patents as I said Elon Musk calls
patents lawy
now why is that an Undiscovered job well
because they gave me the patents no no
no you got to stop that with the patents
I don't give a I did the patents
because they I have watched so many
people come and take somebody's work so
it it was just it was a protection we
we've covered the patents okay my my
claim is that what you discovered is a
little bit like even
temperament
now even temperament is a lie right you
know about even temper yes yes going up
to 440 instead of
432 keep rcking it keep ret tucking it
back together they keep it's an attempt
to modulate or keep keep everything
start right back at the beginning and
avoid the Pythagorean comma avoid the
necessary expansion okay now now we're
talking the Pythagorean comma they clear
up misunderstandings about confusion
between ideas in the scientific
Community they emphasize the need for
precise communication and a willingness
to understand differing perspectives to
maintain scientific integrity and
progress however we have to hold people
that are amateurs like Terren to the
same high standards as ordinary
practicing scientists like me and I
think that's something that's lacking
from the exuberance that Eric and teren
show for novel ideas so when we reflect
on past things like The Ether and other
things they did influence modern physics
even though they were wrong God forbid
Twitter was around when Maxwell invented
the laws of electromagnetics he wouldn't
have had any following after he tweeted
out The lumeris Ether is comprised of
gears and pulleys and whirlpools so
sometimes you have to reevaluate the the
history of physics but it's important
not to follow the mistakes of the past
so Marilyn Monroe Sydney Sydney Crawford
have this Left Right asymmetry to them
that thing is like the weak Force it's
the only thing that can detect this
difference between left and right and
the weak force is the thing that
prohibits a normal mass that forces us
into a higs mass through something
called a yukawa coupling so that's the
whole reason that it's in that thing is
is it's a crazy Hail Mary to save all of
physics because normally if if the world
were left right asymmetric to De beta
Decay the thing that causes a neutron to
Decay into a proton and emit an electron
and an anti-electron neutr in the
process that process is the thing that
denies us mass and we would be at the
speed of light and we would all zip off
and opposite directions but for the hick
field and that process is the radiative
process that's the process I call
magnetism that
de that tears apart that rarify that
which was concentrically drwn together
through electricity here they explore
the relationship between photons and
electrons the lesson talks about how
derivatives and functions integrate
nobody really thinks about electrons the
way that Eric talks about them as square
roots of different objects they are in
the direct operators which we can show
on the screen and direct matrices and
the direct equation which is
relativistic Quant mechanics which was
the first to really explore how it was
possible for us to use a version of the
schinger equation of a quantum
mechanical equation with a a planks
constant within it to describe
relativity in a self-consistent way so
that particles couldn't move fast than
the speed of light such that the objects
were contained in the mass shell of
ordinary electrons and and that also LED
inevitably to the invention of what are
called dra Spinners so dra showed that
in contrast to the complex Vector of
shorting R equation he had to actually
make a 4x4 complex Matrix he had to
actually have multiple matrices but the
matrices are all 4x4 matrices where the
bottom two elements of the of the column
Vector were reserved for the positron a
form of antimatter which by the way dur
originally thought the anti-particle of
the electron was the proton he couldn't
obviously be more wrong he soon realized
that was incorrect and then soon after
Carl Anderson found the positron
actually existed so that was antimatter
it comes effectively from the adoption
of these matrices which do have a
obviously a square root of a square root
type character which if terance were
right we wouldn't have their right
properties take the square root of two
and it's not equ and it's equal to one
uh these wouldn't be able to maintain
the properties of antimatter so there
are lots of consequences of terence's
mathematical ideas none of which are
born out in reality in experimental
physics or in this segment where Eric
talks about how to think about integrals
derivatives electrons and positrons I
say that this right here like nothing in
the universe the universe does nothing
for a single motive everything has
multiple purposes and accomplishes
multiple things this becoming the the
geometry of hydrogen or the very first
visible element is as a result of all of
those forces pushing on it but the f um
no yeah I can use another hit yeah I can
use another hit it's called explainer
juice
yes yeah so thank you thank you thank
both of you so if we start with this as
as electricity then we want to go to the
very first phase from it the first thing
that happens to it is it decays the
first line of Decay and that first line
of Decay is literally just putting on
two magnetic fields they get back to
talking about hydrogen and the first
line of the Decay and angles of
incidents and things like that and these
are just again Concepts that have no
applicability in modern physics or even
ancient physics there's no lines of
Decay these things don't make any sense
to me as a physicist and so talking
about things in terms of using protected
language as Eric talks about super
symmetry as Terrence did and he came
down on it is like using the wrong
terminology for reverse chokehold in MMA
that Joe's familiar with but again these
aren't really mainstream things and I
think it's also quite you know
misleading to show that these things of
line of Decay and so forth we have very
well tested objects uh uh in particle
physics we understand baited Decay we
understand the weak nuclear force we
understand the Quark model which
explains also the predictions of proton
stability these are all things that I
don't understand uh where Terren is
coming from another attack that came
about was terrence's attack on David
Tong and effectively what he was doing
and even with Neil degrass Tyson when he
sent him his Manifesto he was giving him
in a homework assignment I get this all
the time here's a 30 page email uh
here's my Theory of Everything Professor
keing I'll share the Nobel Prize with
you just go through that's assigning me
a tenear professor a homework assignment
and if I did that for every single
person I wouldn't be able to do the job
that I'm paid to do which is to teach
physics to undergraduates and to do
research in cosmology not to say that
there couldn't be some possible
breakthrough but there's no track record
it's very hard to assess just imagine if
a if a six-year-old just you kept
getting emails and kept getting handed
30 pages of homework assignments from
six-year-olds about different topics
that's in your field you're a lawyer
you're a doctor you're an artist you
work as a uh as a countertop installer
and you got something from all these
people that have new ideas and saying
you're completely wrong what you're
doing is wrong you're selling cars the
wrong way Joe you need to fix the way
you sell cars here's a 30 page man if
you did that all the time you wouldn't
have time to actually do your job so you
often use a shortcut which is to look at
people's track record what's their
pedigree where do they come from what's
their education are they purely
self-taught you would definitely take
that into account if you went to a
drywall installer and they come to you
and say I'm fully self-taught I've never
done it before I've got a new idea of
doing drywall would you let them work on
your house guarantee you you wouldn't so
why should it be any different when
people come to me with scientific
proposals manifestos and theories of
everything should I spend that time or
should I do the job that I'm actually
paid to do okay you have to balance that
and it's very hard to do but especially
with people like Teran who get so much
attention from their Fame it's hard to
ignore them and then they get even more
attention when they say that that people
are excluding them like David Tong or
like Neil degrass Tyson and we'll come
back to Neil degrass Tyson and his sort
of polite blowoff of Terren in just a
bit so they can throw you aside and then
they can take every right thing that you
did and put it under their own name
that's why I patented that's why I
patented everything before doing it
because I thought that might be the case
cuz I went to somebody at MIT and I
showed him the wave conjugations um um I
can't remember his name um cuz it's a
small community we all know each other
um I I I will remember his name by the
time I'm done but he but he said oh I've
seen these before and I was like no you
would no you haven't because if you had
seen them I wouldn't have the patents
all these things about patents well I
don't think it's something you can
really ignore if you say that his
credibility is doubtful because he
claims he has 97 Pats when he in fact
has about 11 as far as I can tell I see
a person struggling for answers where
there might not be any and to get
credibility and to give false hope
rather than maybe condemning the ideas
and dismissing them so Eric talks about
there being some babies in the bath
water that Terrence is talking about I
can't find those babies not to say they
don't exist and maybe when I talk to
Terrence I'll I'll understand it I know
Eric and Terren have spent a lot of time
together but again when you keep hearing
about things the influence of patents
the influence of these these outlandish
ideas like the Walter Russell uh
periodic table which has elements that
don't exist like coronium and and leptum
and all sorts of things it really shows
the self-educated nature of people like
Tern but this is all to be praised in
comparison at least to people like
Candace Owens who will say things like
science is Pagan or NASA is Pagan
because she doesn't believe that the
dinosaurs were killed by a giant meteor
it's just it's just nuts so there's a
huge difference between Candace Owens
and Terence Howard and we discussed that
on the Piers Morgan show which we'll
have a link to a conversation that I had
with Piers Morgan and Tom Bilo and Eric
Weinstein again when they get into the
Walter Russell the harmonica tones with
you and we talked about that already in
part one I'm not going to go through it
again except to address the need for
clear and precise communication we
really need to use the right terminology
You can disagree with the with the
findings or the data or the or the
methodology but you can't like go back
to to recoop the names of different
items and even maybe it is the case that
ter means something different by
multiplication for him multiplication
means addition I mean if you did that
fine then 1 time one in his language
does mean two and in fact in ring
algebra you can actually obtain that
with a multiplication like operator that
is called addition but again is that
fruitful should we should we redefine
things like addition the number zero the
number infinity it's all sort of a big
intellectual waste of time now I come to
the good stuff where do I disagree with
Eric well it has to do with peer review
and Eric makes a distinction between
peer review and expert review let's go
through a couple different things peer
revieww expert review proposal
refereeing all these things should be
encouraging Innovation testing
replication there's other types of
analysis that can be used to assess the
validity of scientific claims open
review transparent review they all have
different pluses and minuses let's go
through them Eric clearly is against
what we call peer review and he has a
great deal of information to back that
up but I claim what his and we'll go
through that information but I claim
what he's doing is sometimes very
harmful to physicists like me that he's
seeking to gain more attention remember
he's saying that we deserve more money
more security less bureaucracy less Dei
so he's harming in some sense the people
that he's often trying to help so I
pointed out in a tweet response to him
that there's many many journals in his
field of physics which is what he's
operating in now he's most known right
now in the intellectual landscape for
his geometric Unity Theory which hasn't
been submitted for peer review and
that's important obviously I listed a
bunch of journals from the reviews of
modern physics to nature physics to
physics reports annual review of
astronomy and astrophysics all these
journals have huge impact factors the
impact factor being the average number
of times typical number of times that a
paper in those journals gets cited now
for many authors they might get a paper
cited once or twice Eric and others have
claimed that you know citations are just
a way to Curry academic favor to get
tenure and get funding that's really not
uh not the case not my experience as a
professional physicist again AR not a
professional physicist he's not he's a
he's a mathematician working in the
field of finance and other things he's
not publishing he's not in a university
he's not a tene track faculty it's fine
to do what he's doing the Practical
impacts of publishing in these journals
all of which I've either published in or
refereed for along with the proposal
referee process and other things in
Academia that we have to do to give
recommendations for things like Awards
promotions tenure those require experts
and referees they're usually supposed to
be external you don't want my PhD
advisor to give me a letter of
recommendation for a proposal or for a
grant request that's just not fair to
other people and in fact a lot of times
The Proposal review now is done blindly
you don't even know who's applying and
the people that submit the proposals
they don't know who's refereeing it so
it's double blond think about the bias
there how are you actually going to
penalize someone if you don't know who
wrote the journal or you didn't know who
wrote the Grant application so let's go
through some of the claims that Eric
Maks and trace the history and of peer
review from its Origins to its current
role and then discussion examines how
peer review has influenced the quality
and progression of scientific research
and its limitations and the challenges
it faces in the era of modern science
Eric and I did battle about this on
Piers Morgan you can find that link
above again and I made an analogy that
you know to say that you criticize a
professor who doesn't understand the
history of peer review which I do
understand the history of peer review
but error claiming I don't and claiming
others certainly don't I don't think
it's actually relevant to how any modern
science is done I don't think any of my
GR students who are brilliant or work in
fields related to what I do or Eric does
have any idea the history of it and yet
they're churning out some of the highest
quality papers and results that I claim
Eric and I can't even match peer review
doesn't really begin in physics uh and
in The Sciences really until the 60s and
much more the 70s the whole idea of peer
review is to keep the L the the the
people who don't do science for a living
or medicine for a living out of the
review process Eric I'm sorry to say my
academic gener genealogy goes back 17
Generations every single one of those
people including my students I'm now in
my third generation I have graduate
students that have their own graduate
students they've all been through peer
review we didn't have pergamin press and
Robert Maxwell that that is true
Einstein published all almost all of his
famous papers they were done by peer
rreview so I'm trying to be humble here
and I think Eric should be too so to say
that they are not really doing science
because they don't understand the
history of peer review I think that's
quite frankly nonsense but peers were
always used in some sense to judge
scientific replication when cernus came
up with the Revolutions of the Heavenly
spheres he was using observation which
then he published actually he published
on the day he died um Galileo used that
information Kepler used that information
eventually Galileo's final book The
discourse would be published by elvir in
the Netherlands now that would later be
the same Journal house publishing house
that would purchase pergamon press the
same press that Eric quite accurately
points out was owned by Robert Maxwell
the father of galain Maxwell the
disgraced uh partner in crime of Jeffrey
Epstein I did actually again post this
on Twitter about how the greatest some
of the greatest Publications in modern
history were peer-reviewed including
some of the Titanic contributions of
Richard feeman with his co-advisor John
archal Wheeler and reviews of modern
physics in 1945 this outlined Fan's path
integr method hugely influential and
also in part part responsible for fan
diagrams or how they're actually applied
and later responsible for his Nobel
Prize Einstein's papers which which had
it not been peer-reviewed would have
caused him some great pain because it
was the claim that he had made
originally 1936 in a paper that he
submitted it was rejected because he
claimed that gravitational waves were
completely non-real phenomena that could
never be detected and the referees
pointed out be they experts or editors
and asked to do it they was still
refereed and it wasn't allowed to be
published until he revised it and when
he revised it he showed that he was
wrong he also was wrong in his original
theory of general relativity in the
prediction of the the deflection of
Starlight by the sun these things were
improved upon correspondence and
consultation with peers and other
experts there's many many examples of
this all the journals nowadays are
peer-reviewed a lot of them are blind
peer reviewed again I'm St sticking to
physics because that's my field of
expertise but it's also a field where
I've done reviews I've done reviews for
these articles and I've submitted over
200 articles have my name on it as
either author primary author in some
cases or or contributing author in terms
of also millions of dollars of funding
that my colleagues and I have obtained
thanks to the expert referee review
system which is a form of peer review so
it started informally back in the 17th
century beginning of the Scientific
Revolution the very first journals
they're very different than we have now
but they share some common DNA the Royal
Society of London was founded in 1660
and it played a pivotal role in
developing modern scientific journal
with its philosophical transactions
which started in 1665 that journal is
considered the first scientific journal
but peer review wasn't really part of
the process but in fact also it wasn't
only the way that you would get
recognition by publishing something
written although most books obviously
the books by Kepler Galileo cernus those
are Publications they did get editing
they did get review in some cases and
establishing the claims of priority and
scientific claims like that of Galileo
showing the moons of Jupiter the craters
on the moon as he observed them through
his telescope and even things that were
cryptically explained Galileo did not
believe that what he could see with his
eyes through a telescope when he looked
at the planet Saturn so he made a
cryptic almost puzzle he would say
things like the highest planet is
threefold to establish priority in his
claim without actually coming out and
saying what the truth was that planet
Saturn had these rings around it he
actually couldn't resolve the Rings but
he wanted to get some credit just in
case he turned out to be right that it
was a three-fold planet which it's not
by the 20th century the peer review
process became quite formalized physical
review the primary journal in my field
became very much the standard in the mid
1900 but even before that you would get
articles reviewed by a couple of friends
of the editor uh typically again that's
a form of peer review it's to say that
it has no history in science is just
outright wrong but after World War II in
the 1940s and 50s the rapid expansion of
scientific research and the increase in
the number of Publications necessitated
a more rigorous evaluation process peer
review evolves to ensure the quality
Integrity of scientific literature which
is a core part of science you can't say
that science can be done without
replication if you can't reproduce it
it's just nonsense and there's a lot of
science that Eric and others point out
is not reproducible because it makes no
predictions or it makes predictions that
can't be tested now now it is true as
Eric asserts that Robert Maxwell a
British media Mogul played a huge and
controversial role in the development of
scientific publishing but it's not quite
as big as Eric makes it out to be and it
does dovetail nicely into certain
theories about Maxwell and and Epstein
and how he got his money and all the
evil things that he did in the 1950s and
60s Maxwell founded pergam and press
which published numerous scientific
journals back then it doesn't publish
things now Maxwell's business acument
and aggressive marketing strategies
significantly expanded the reach of the
scientific journals he didn't invent
peer review but his influence did help
the publishing industry standardize it
now is that a bad thing to have peer
rreview standardized yes sometimes bad
people can do good I actually don't know
much about Maxwell I'm sure you guys can
correct me in the comments down below
and how ignorant I am but the peerreview
process was a long-standing before now
Eric points out there was a huge influx
of money interest and and perhaps uh
scientific standards being
instrumentalized by the National
Institutes of Health NIH now the NIH is
almost 150 years old and it's the key
funding Agency for biomedical reseearch
I have no familiarity with NIH grants
I've never had one I don't work in that
field but in getting grants for NIH from
NIH medical biomedical it revise heavily
on peer review both in the fact that
many many Journal articles have to be
peer-reviewed but also the proposals
were peer-reviewed or peer refereed by
other biomedical scientists doctors Etc
and of course there's been a huge
problem in the late 20th century and
early 21st century things like the
replication crisis packing stories like
90% of all scientific papers are wrong a
lot of that comes from biomedical
science which is not Eric's field and
it's not my field and so I think it is a
little bit of a red herring it's true
that in the six 1960s government
agencies began to provide substantial
funding for scientific research and that
required a new and robust peer review
system to allocate resources effectively
and peerreview became a critical
component of the funding ensuring that
taxpayer money was spent on high quality
impactful research now of course you'll
say well there was money sent to the
Wuhan Institute of iology and that was
Government funding and that was sent by
people within the NIH system like
Collins and fat okay so that's all true
so do you want your research into the
drug that you're giving your daughter do
you want that to be completely tested in
a biased conflicted and uh perhaps
non-transparent opaque system or do you
want there to be at least some guard
rails on the system that allocates money
which then become scientific papers
research and eventually technology and
eventually drugs and technology that you
use in your body I certainly wouldn't
want to live in a world that doesn't
have peer review or referee review or
external review in 1965 the NIH made a
significant change to the peer review
process this was intended to standardize
how grants were evaluated and these were
meant really in reaction to the large
increase in volume and complexity of
those Grant proposals now Eric claims
the pergamon Press established a a
scenario where you had to get all these
journals or else you had an incomplete
Library Etc again completely irrelevant
for Fields like astronomy and physics
which is the field that he is now a part
of as am I and other words there three
four journals as I mentioned their top
10 impact factor ones I've all refereed
or submitted journals to them they
weren't part of Maxwell's Journal they
weren't part of pergam and press they
weren't even in the biomedical Sciences
so let's separate those two but it is
true they had a more systematic and
structured peer review process is that a
bad thing I don't think so remember Eric
is saying that peerreview is effectively
destroying science and it was
intentionally done so as he said
verbatim in the conversation with Joe
Rogan the peer review thing got woven in
so that people think that the scientific
method in peer review are effectively
the same thing where one is an unwanted
infection from the biological biomedical
Universe which had peer review much
longer than everything else either it
was his intention or that's been its
result I just don't agree the scoring
proposals then became had sections that
were based on scientific Merit
Innovation and potential impact there
were some problems that came about in
the 1990s and 2000s where then you had
have broader impact statements even in
my field like physics and they brought
in things like sociology into into the
National Science Foundation and we we've
talked about that and I have a good
conversation with John scrne coming up
on the podcast as well discussing how
that came about in order to kind of glom
on to the stem Revolution there are also
things like advisory councils which
considered broader issues such as public
health which Eric claims not a science
again the two-tier system helped to
ensure that both scientific excellence
and societal needs were considered again
you can debate whether this is the best
way to do it but should the public not
have its voice heard and have its kind
of best interest recognized by other
stakeholders it is a stakeholder it's
funding these agencies and are they
responsible and by what means do you
rank and assess you have two
applications from two different people
let's say they're both blind submitted
how do you appraise them you just ask a
single editor Eric claims that having
expert reviewers like him and he goes
through he says I'm not your peer
terance I'm an expert I'm giving you an
Elite review that's impractical for most
cases to have Eric Weinstein review
every single NIH Grant or NSF Grant or
publication in nature or science it's
just not practical so we have peers and
it's actually part of our educational
system I teach my students my posts how
do you referee a paper how do you take
things into account what's fair to say
what's not fair to say how do you do it
dispassionately how do you avoid
conflicts of interests citing your own
research scooping them stealing their
information and applying for another
proposal under your own name after
rejecting that we'll get to that those
things have happened so the feedback
helps researchers understand the
strengths and weaknesses of their
proposals and the proposals of people
who's worked their refereeing as well
it's part of our educational process to
say it has no place or it's dangerous or
it's damaging or it's destructive to
science is just not true and it's not
fair to colleagues that I work with my
students and even myself quite frankly
these NH reforms had a huge impact on
how government grants were awarded and
it does impact science in the United
States again it's not relevant to the
physics that Eric and Terren and I are
discussing so to bring it up I know it's
one of the things that Eric loves talk
about but again knowing this history of
the NIH and how it caused created
different standards for funded research
and formalized peer review does that
lead you to suspect in any way that peer
review is damaging or dangerous or do
you believe that it's actually crucial
for a scientist a physicist to
understand the role of pergam press the
NIH 1965 welfare act that these things
are important for physicist working on
gauge theories or working on lorensen
variance violation are trying to ensure
the objectivity in their own research to
not know the history it's like the old
joke about how scientists need
historians of science the way that birds
need ornithologist it's of course
interesting and if you're a Renaissance
person like Eric it's something of great
interest and import but to the actual
work a day scientist he or she doesn't
need to necessarily know that in order
to create research and write a
publication that can be followed
methodically followed that's transparent
and accountable when he or she submits
it to either their their disseration
committee or to a journal for
publication so that another competitor
team can challenge them and go through
their methodology and hopefully
replicate it and if not then we have a
big problem and that should be retracted
and I agree we should have a budget I've
actually claimed this in my first book
losing the Nobel prize get it here in
the link below that we should reserve
some amount of funding maybe 10% of the
budget for retracting claims that we
make that turn out to be wrong because
to this day I get people that come up to
me and say oh you invented bicep well
that was the experiment that discovered
inflationary gravitational waves no we
were disproven we made an incorrect
claim we're still trying to do that
great result but it was wrong so but it
was on the front page of the New York
Times we made the announcement and then
when the retraction came it came six
months later on page B17 of the Saturday
edition that nobody reads so it's
important to to reserve some of your
budget some of your attention for
scientific ethics
to be promulgated we do need to reserve
some budget for ascertaining and
correcting ourselves when we're wrong as
I did at the beginning of this video I
was wrong about Terence Howard having no
patents he has at least 11 and nowhere
near 97 but at least 11 and I was wrong
May a culpa that's part of science peer
review certainly has a role to play
they're now an explosion of journals
that would make Robert Maxwell roll in
his grave or in Hell or I don't know
where he is right now but Open Access
journals which made the Articles freely
available to the public has been a
GameChanger for science allowing
scientists in Nigeria to access work we
do in San Diego having double blind
single blind and Open Access journals
are huge Innovations now they're not
perfect I always say peer review is the
worst system except for all the others
and yes there are predatory journals and
pay to play journals journals that have
published things that are obviously put
out by chat GPT in fact it says I'm a
large language model and it says that in
the abstract of the journal I saw and
some of those have percolated up to you
know journals that sound kind of similar
to to uh very high quality journals you
know the the um astrological Journal
sounds a lot like the astronomical
Journal but these situations do
highlight the ethical concerns that
scientists usually do ignore now there
have been notable examples where
scientists effectively were either
harmed by the peer review process
manipulated by it and most famously uh
two gentlemen Gallow and montaner with
the HIV virus the human imuno deficiency
virus in the early 80s Robert Gallow and
Luke moner both claimed the discovery of
the HIV virus the virus responsible for
the disease AIDS The Mont paper was
submitted to science it was delayed and
criticized in review after a long time
Gallow published his own findings
leading to a higher profile paper that
he had and a huge dispute over the
originality and priority of their
Discovery the information had sometime
to leak out there's questions that
Gallow discovered first who discovered
it first they eventually both shared the
credit but the controversy highlighted
the potential ethical issues due to the
timeliness or lack thereof of peerreview
in the publication process one thing
that I've thought about a lot lately is
uh peer review using things like
blockchain technology where you could
publish something like Galileo instead
of publishing the highest planet is
three-fold he could publish it on a
blockchain with some wallet that each
scientist would get and then he doesn't
have to necessarily expose it to public
review or peer review even or
competition until he's fully mined the
data of its content so finally we come
to the question of whether or not
Terrence Howard's ideas were blown off
by Neil degrass Tyson they talk about
this at the end when Eric talks about
the Elite review versus the peer review
and it's true that if you don't have a
edu email address or actually that's not
fully truec a lot of the biomed
Innovations come from corporations they
can get published quite easily peer
review hasn't destroyed science it's
better than ever the main journals in
Eric's field have never been diluted and
are stronger than ever physical review
the journal Nature the journal science
the astrophysical journal and many other
top quality Publications where we go to
get our credit because this is what we
do Eric again is saying physicist need
more money now he wants to take away not
only the fact that we have very little
compensation financially but that we the
main mechanism of granting credit to a
scientist and that we derive our stature
from is from citations AG IND Dees
That's The Way of the World okay just
like a batting average for a baseball
player is one way to judge them it's not
holis ISC they may be a great Fielder
they may be a great uh spark in the in
the in the clubhouse but that's one of
the ways that we use and to use it and
say it's basically affecting the
sciencethe Aesthetics is actually not
fair to scientist again we have to look
holistically at what is best for science
as a whole and I know I'm not an expert
in any other field other than physics
and astronomy and the type of
engineering work that I do so to say
that it needs to be abolished because
it's causing such great damage I think
is overstating the claim so I hope
you've enjoyed this conversation where I
went through the scientific process
claims that Terrence made apologize for
errors when I've made them in the past I
think that's part about being a good
scientist and I've always tried to
exemplify to Young scientists that I
know of my huge amount of my audience
are scientists young and old about why
these things are important the stakes in
this discussion are extremely high The
credibility of science is at stake and I
think discussing things like that aren't
quite frankly very frequently discussed
such as peer review it's history the
importance of knowing peer review is
history his how referees work how
Proposal review works these are
incredibly important topics that are
usually glossed under the rug and I'm
sure this video won't get as many views
as I would if I said you know Terence
Howard's
bat whatever and G off as uh other
people have done and criticized him I
don't think that's fair and I do hope to
engage with him in person uh sometime
later this year so let's stay critical
and informed and the complexities of all
these topics of patents of peerreview of
revolutionary disc discoveries and
claims of co-opting language and being
precise in our language but also having
comedey and having worthwhile
discussions with respect admiration and
not just assaulting people's characters
with ad homm attacks let's advocate for
transparency fair and thorough
evaluation processes insights it's
spending your money people that if
you're paying taxes which I assume you
all are because you're all law abiding
citizens so it's your money you have a
responsibility for it and we scientists
have a responsibility to explain things
in terms you can understand and hold us
to those standards please stay tuned to
this channel for more I'm done with
Terence Howard Joe Rogan and Eric
Weinstein for now uh until we meet up at
my Iron Man like L laboratory lir or his
lair and I do hope to continue to
provide you the deepest dives into these
topics they're not just esoteric boring
things of no importance they actually
are critical to the underpinning of
society without a robust scientific
process without a scientific method
without Publications without a community
of replication and transparency Society
is at state so let me know below what do
you think of this video what sorts of
topics societal and otherwise you want
me to take on next and click here for a
link to a playlist of the greatest hits
of Eric Weinstein into the impossible