Nodachi VS Katana - Comparative Video

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 27, 2024
The katana is characterized by its distinctive appearance: a curved, single-edged blade with a circular or squared guard and long grip to accommodate two hands.
Comparative weapons and armors series.
Well, welcome back and today we're going to talk about the katana versus the nodachi.
Hello everyone, welcome back to my channel, this is the Metatron speaking and goodness
gracious I've got a lot of series going on at the moment but it's not a problem, I can
take it, I can dig it, I'm enjoying this and these series have been rather, like this specific
series about comparative weapons and comparative armors is going quite well so I'm happy to
continue it and soon I will be buying a nagamaki so we will have a lot more comparative videos,
we will have both these sort of academical intellectual videos where we speculate and
talk but we will also have actual practical videos of, for example, nodachi versus nagamaki,
that's going to be an amazing video.
I'm not sure when I can get the nagamaki because of course my purchase of the nagamaki is dependent
on the Patreon support that I receive from donations but at the moment it's going well
so I think it shouldn't take too long until I reach the necessary amount to actually order
a nagamaki.
It's going to be good.
Alright, so right on topic, differences between katana and nodachi, well first of all I think
it's quite obvious and it goes without saying that with a nodachi you would have a huge
reach advantage but I think sometimes we underestimate what that means.
I mean think about it, my nodachi is particularly long, there are some styles in Japan and I've
talked about this, like nodachi styles in Japan which use slightly shorter nodachi but
the one I have, if I put it on the ground, you can see it's basically as tall as me.
So of course that means 175cm basically, that's my height, 176cm, it depends on the shoes
I'm wearing.
Now I'm not wearing shoes so this is why this is basically as tall as me.
It's a very long weapon.
If we compare it with a katana, just to give you an idea, let's see if I can get in the
shot without hitting the ceiling.
So we are talking almost twice as long, almost twice as long.
Now this is not the difference between a shorter sword and a longer sword, this is the difference
between a sword and a polearm.
Given the nodachi doesn't always handle as a polearm, sometimes it can be used in a similar
way but most of the times it has its own way of being used, depending on the style.
I myself noticed that it is rather more effective, in my opinion, to use the nodachi from a jodan
no kamae.
I find that to be much better because of the extra mass this weapon has on its blade.
It's rather difficult to use with any other kamae.
Maybe in waku it could still be utilised quite well but in my experience I found it much
more comfortable to use it in a specialised way, like for example some certain kenjutsu
styles do, rather than trying to force katana usage into a weapon that handles in a completely
different way.
But what are some other advantages and disadvantages of wielding a katana over wielding a nodachi
and vice versa?
Well I think it's quite obvious that with a katana you are quicker to strike but if
you use the nodachi from the jodan no kamae you actually use the weapon's momentum and
you use the weapon's extra mass to gain speed and acceleration.
So every time I've tried sparring a little bit with this nodachi with my friend, and
when I say my friend I mean my friend Salvo, I think you know him by now, he's been appearing
on my channel constantly, particularly on the Historical Street Vlogger series on Saturdays,
he often fights with me, spars with me and I will actually start making some of this
content available on YouTube eventually.
But the idea is every time we try this we notice that if I come, for example if I am
a samurai and I'm wielding this, the nodachi, let me put the katana down for a moment, and
I'm wielding this beast here, and I am just, let me show you, I'm a samurai and I'm running
towards you, holding the weapon in a jodan no kamae, which now I can't even do properly
because of the ceiling so you'll have to excuse me there, but if I run towards you this way
the speed I will have to actually deliver a full attack is not that slower than a katana,
it becomes slower when I try to do other things, like for example even some thrusts or some
other kinds of cutting, but cutting from a jodan no kamae can be, they can be quite quick
themselves, what's difficult is to recover from those, so if I fully commit to a blow
from a jodan no kamae slash from a jodan no kamae with a nodachi and I miss, that's going
to be problematic, because recovering and putting yourself again in a guard position
it's not easy, but it's not impossible and with training I think you could speed up that
process as well.
But what's interesting is defence against a katana and defence against a nodachi, we
often imagine that, for example there are many ways of course to defend from an attack,
a sword attack towards you, but if you think of just simply putting your sword like this
to intercept a cutting motion coming towards you, well if the opponent is wielding a nodachi
you don't want to do that, we have tested this with my friend and what happens is, let
me explain it to you but let me put the beast down for a moment, I gave my friend a full
helmet to protect his head and then he just stayed like this and I told him just stay
as strong as you can and then I smashed my nodachi on top of his katana.
What happened is that he couldn't make it, the extra mass of the weapon forced, not only
my weapon hit, I just went past and broke completely his guard, but his weapon hit him
as well, it was like a double hit, it was like completely, so it's a weapon that you
need to perform other kinds of counters, you need a completely different way of defending
yourself, like other ways which exist, like trying to put the strength of the opponent,
the force of the opponent away from you, otherwise it's just not going to work, we do see some
of these techniques sometimes in Kenjutsu styles where they just block and perhaps they
just retaliate but against the nodachi you're going to have to reconsider your tactical
choices in combat. So this is definitely an advantage of the nodachi, it's difficult to
block, you need to be really good at blocking because when the attack comes in full force
with the extra mass it has, it's going to smash into you. Also there is the whole psychological
aspect of the nodachi, I mean the nodachi is an imposing weapon and you have to imagine
for example two samurai in feudal Japan and they're going to have a duel, one wields a
katana, one wields a nodachi, the one with the nodachi, the one with the katana needs
to have a very strong psychological calmness, you know the mushin sort of, because otherwise
when you see someone coming, running towards you with this beast, it's scary, it can be
scary, so it does have a psychological factor and we shouldn't imagine, although some samurai
were masters of calmness and everything, yeah I'm sure some were, the whole zen buddhist
situation and idea behind combat, but not everyone was and imagine for example if you
were on the battlefield because the nodachi was a battlefield weapon and you were a nashigaru
and perhaps you lost your polearm and now you've got your backup weapon which is a katana
and you see a samurai in full armor running towards you with a nodachi, that's going to
because there still are advantages, again as we said it's quicker to use, it's easier
to use, so clearly for a katana wielder a good idea would be to attack first because
if the nodachi guy attacks first then your defense needs to be flawless because you need
to dodge basically, if you don't dodge and you just try to block that's going to be a
huge problem, but it's not that easy, you know I'll just dodge him, it depends if the
guy is a master and knows how to use the nodachi, it might not be that simple, it might
not be as simple as you would imagine to actually dodge his attacks which could be multiple
attacks anyways. So anticipation might be key, but of course you need to be really good
at this, you need to be really good, so again I think anticipation probably while dodging,
so you like, you know you manage to do a draw cut, cut him here but also get out of the
way, otherwise you know his attack is still coming, it's still going to land, so yes maybe
you cut him open but he's going to open your head in two. Preventive attack, timing and
speed are going to be key. Alternatively another possibility could be to tire your opponent
down a little bit, like try to avoid him dodging, that could be a possibility because again
I have wielded the nodachi and it does tire you down, again not because it has whatever
extreme weight, it doesn't, it doesn't weigh more than two kilos, so it's not like a lot
heavier than the katana but the whole mass is towards the blade, so it's really tough
to recover, it forces your muscles to function in a different way and it does tire you down.
So that could be a possibility, tire him down so he slows down and then you go in with a
quick fast attack with your katana. So here is the question, if I were to go, having experienced
both katana and nodachi, if I were to go to a mortal combat, to a real life-to-death duel,
which one would I wield? Much has to do with a whole lot of factors, for example I myself
feel more comfortable wielding a katana but I have done three years of kendo and I've
only had a nodachi for six months, well not even that, maybe five months, I'm not sure.
So of course I haven't practiced as much so I think it's rather natural that I feel more
at ease using a katana, it's just, it's easier for me to do that. But perhaps with practice
I might get used to the nodachi, in fact I have to say that when I first started wielding
a nodachi it felt like, wow this weapon is badass but I would never want to use this
one in a real combat situation because it's just too unwieldy. But with time I started,
you know, the weapon started growing on me, I'm starting to understand how the weapon
functions and what muscles and what stances work better and I started exploring the weapon
so I imagine that with time if I were to practice constantly using a nodachi I might become
quite efficient at using one and so could have a samurai of Yudo Japan. So at the moment
I would choose a katana over a nodachi but that's probably just because I haven't practiced
much so perhaps I will answer back, I will get back to this question if you give me another
six months so I can keep on practicing and see if I actually manage to start liking this
weapon more than an actual katana. Secondly, in a armoured duel, so if I was fighting against
a samurai in full armour and I was also wearing full armour, which one would I use? Well first
of all I would use a kanabo but if the kanabo was not available then I would still choose
the katana, why? Because yes, the extra mass of the nodachi might be good if you smash
it against the helmet of your opponent because perhaps it might stun him but on the other
hand it's quite thin, the blade, so it wouldn't achieve as much as a kanabo would, for example.
Whereas with the katana what I would try doing, it being easier to handle, I would try thrusting
and try to find those areas such as the, you know, thrusting in the throat, thrusting under
the armpit, which would be rather difficult to do with a nodachi so definitely not for
armoured combat. For that a katana would be a better choice and perhaps even a tanto. Like
if I really was having to fight a samurai and we were exchanging blows, I might switch into
a tanto and go for actual hand-to-hand combat, jujutsu, put him on the ground and stick the
tanto in his throat underneath his menpo. If he's wearing one, if he's not wearing one,
then it would be even better but, you know, that sort of precision strike, that sort of,
the sort of precision you need in armoured combat, the nodachi would not be a good choice.
Definitely a kanabo would be if you really want to go for devastating attacks. If not,
a tanto would be a good choice in my humble opinion. Last but not least, what is my opinion
on what Miyamoto Musashi says in the Wind Scroll? Because in the Wind Scroll, as I have made a video
about it, Miyamoto Musashi does talk about extra long swords and I believe he's meaning,
he's talking about nodachi. Now, he's not particularly fond on those. I think that's
quite clear from what we can read but I don't totally agree. I mean, I understand why and at
the end of the day he's dual wielding anyways so for him it wouldn't really make sense to
wield a nodachi because you can't dual wield with a nodachi so I can understand the tactical choice
there. On the other hand, I do see some positive aspects in a nodachi which he doesn't seem to see
so I don't 100% agree with what he says. At this moment, I would still agree with him that I would
go for a katana in a duel rather than a nodachi so the extra length and the extra range I gain
with a nodachi is at the expenses of other very important aspects of duelling and combat and
actually controlling and operating your weapon so at the moment I don't see an actual balance
in what I gain against what I lose. But again, I still need to practice with it so we will get
back to this in a few months and we'll see if my opinion has changed on the Japanese nodachi.
Alright noble ones, I hope that you enjoyed this video. If you did, please remember thumbs up and
subscribe to my channel for more content from the Metatron. If you like this series, please
consider sharing it with your friends on your social networks. So as I was saying, quite a lot
of series at the moment. I've got the Youkai series on Japanese folklore. I've got this weapons and
armors, comparative weapons and comparative armors series. I've got the Saturday historical
street vlogger series. But of course, if you have other things that you'd like me to talk about,
please feel free to let me know in the comments below because some of these series were indeed
inspired by some of your comments. Thank you very much for watching and remember, the Metatron has
spread his wings. Sarabah!
