Lecture 55- Failure Analysis of PH Aluminium Alloy: Improper Heat Treatment

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 20, 2024
[Music]
[Music]
hello I welcome you all in this
presentation related with the subject
failure analysis and
prevention and we will be talking about
the failure analysis of the
precipitation hardenable aluminium Al
components and you know that uh the
strength in these Allis is primarily
imparted through the precipitation
hardening heat
treatment
and if the heat treatment is not done
properly due to the inappropriate
selection of the heat treatment process
parameters then uh we end up with the
undesirable micro structure and so the
mechanical properties which in turn
adversely affects the performance of the
component uh during the service okay so
initially in this presentation we'll try
to talk about the basic approach of the
heat treatment heat treatment and the
principles related with that
precipitation hardening uh heat
treatment of the common aluminium Alloys
and uh then we'll try to see how the
heat treatment process parameters affect
the micro structure and mechanical
properties and thereafter we'll try to
take up one case study related with the
precipitation hardenable aluminium alloy
component which failed prematurely and
so investigation was undertaken to uh
find out what led uh to the failure okay
so let us start with this presentation
uh so we'll be talking about first the
what are the heatable aluminum Eloise
their aluminum are classified based on
the composition and also based on the
way by which these are produced like
cast aluminium Elise and the rot
aluminium Elise so then in each category
we have the heat treatable and non heat
treatable aluminium elois also so what
are the common heat treatable aluminu
wise means which respond to the heat
treatment with the change of micro
structure and which in turn affects the
mechanical properties the need of the
heat treatment of aluminum allo because
the certain aluminum Alloys in ASAS
condition do not offer the desired
properties so when they are subjected to
the precipitation hardening then they
result in the significant Improvement
apart from that like many uh times the
aluminum all component processed through
the common manufacturing process like
casting or farming or welding then uh it
is required to relieve the residual
stresses and so stress relieving heat
treatment may also be needed in these
aluminum all apart from controlling the
micro structure to achieve the desired
set of mechanical properties so what is
the basic principle of the heat
treatment and the common steps which are
used in the two most common heat
treatments like T4 and T6 for
precipitation horable aluminum wise then
we'll be taking up one case study on
failure of the aluminium components due
to the faulty heat treatment and the
relevant findings and the
observations so as far as the heal
aluminum allo is conern so let us see
that this list what it shows that this
is the classification of the rot
aluminium
Alloys okay which is most commonly used
cast aluminum Alloys are used for a
selected category selected applications
okay so the rot aluminum Alloys like the
1,000 series is used for the pure
aluminium okay having the aluminium more
than 99% or more the 2,000 series
aluminum Alloys are dedicated to the
aluminium copper Alloys which may have
other allying elements like aluminium
copper and
magnesium okay then 3,000 series is for
aluminium magnesium Alloys 4,000 series
is basically the cast aluminum Alise
series which is preferably used for
making the components through the
casting route okay so but these
aluminium silicon Alloys can have the
copper and magnet magium and when these
elements are added these make the cast
aluminum silicon Ali also heat
treatable okay they respond to the heat
treatment uh then 5,000 series is
basically the aluminium magnesium magnes
aloy having the aluminium magnesium and
magnes these are basically work
hardenable aluminium
Alloys okay work hardenable aluminium
Alloys 6,000 series having the aluminium
magnesium iicon these are the heatable
aluminum Alloys and the AL 7,000 series
is also heat treatable aluminium alloy
Series so though those which are wred so
8,000 series is dedicated for aluminium
with the other elements like aluminium
lithium and likewise 9,000 Series is
unused so if you see here those which
are highlighted in red these are heat
treatable aluminium Alloys and even in
in case of the 4,000 series aluminium
when we have copper and magnesium then
these also respond to the heat treatment
so these are can also be classified as a
heat treatable aluminum especially when
the in the presence of these two aling
elements okay so this is about the heat
the entire classification of the rot
aluminum and the most common treatable
aluminium Alois are like aluminium
copper magnesium that's 20 000 series
and these are the two most common
aluminium Alloys like 2024 and
20114 similarly aluminium magnesium and
silicon this is a 6,000 series aluminium
looy and in this series we have 6061 is
one of the most commonly used aluminium
aloy and
6063 similarly in aluminium zinc
magnesium aluminium Alloys we have the
two most common it is a 7,000 series and
having like
7075 and 739 these are the other two
common aluminium ly of the aluminium
zinc magnesium series most of these
heatable aluminium ly offer the
advantage of the
high strength to weight
ratio so because of this feature these
are extensively used in
automotive and fabricate or
manufacturing the aircraft component
where lightweighting is
important okay in automobile sector and
in uh aircrafts where the lightweight is
important for increasing the fuel
efficiency increasing the payload uh the
weight is important so the structural
members are made
of the heatable aluminium Alloys like
2024 6061 7075
okay and these heat treatment heat
treatable alumin wise if given proper
heat treatment then the strength offered
by them is extremely well so what is the
basic principle of the precipitation
hardening aluminium Allis is this like
say this is the regular Matrix
of uh the uh uh of the aluminium okay
say uh it is having few incomplete plane
of atoms like
dislocations okay here and there so in
these incomplete plane of atoms move
under the externally applied stresses
easily and which in turn result in the
deformation this incomplete plane of
atom is called
dislocations so how easily dislocations
are able to move that in turn results
the plastic deoration eventually the
dislocation movement resulting in the
plastic deformation and how easily it is
happening that will determine the
strength or eeld strength of the
material so if the dislocation movement
is resisted then the stress required to
cause the plastic deformation
increases and that is what is achieved
through the development of fine
precipitates so when these fine
precipitates come across the moving
dislocation the the movement of
dislocations is resisted and that in
turn increases the yield strength and
that is why what we say basically we try
to realize the fine
precipitates
fine well
distributed
precipitates so in The Matrix if the
fine well distributed precipitates are
present then these will frequently be
coming across the moving dislocations to
enhance the E
strength okay this is the mechanism of
the precipitation hardening okay so if
the size of these precipitates
increases then this reduces the in yield
strength in PH precipitation hardening
aluminum aloise if we due to one or
other reason if we get coarse
precipitates then this will be reducing
the eeld strength and hardness okay so
efforts are always made to produce the
fine precipitates okay for Peak
hardening and higher eeld strength
another possibility is that these
precipitates are localized say these
precipitates are localized only at the
grain
boundary okay then these will not be
causing segregated precipitates will
also not be causing much of the increas
in yeld strength so the well distributed
and fine precipitates actually help in
improving the yield strength and
hardness significantly so how it is
realized so for that we follow a typical
heat treatment cycle
which involves heating first to the high
temperature okay then holding at that
temperature for some
time okay and then again quenching very
rapidly okay then after cooling it after
quenching it at low temperature again it
is
reheated and then it is kept at that
temperature for some time followed by
normal air cooling okay so these are the
steps so the first step where heating to
the high temperature this is called
solutionizing
temperature idea behind this is let us
heat the aluminum to the high
temperature precipitation Hing aluminium
Eloise to the high temperature so that
the homogeneous solid solution
homogeneous solid solution of that
aluminum can be made okay uh so if there
are Alvine elements they will get
dissolved and they will form the
homogeneous solid solution and how long
it is to be kept so this the holding
time or soaking time you can say as a
solutionizing
time solutionizing time this again will
depend upon the size of component and
the grain size the components made by
the casting process they need longer
solutionizing time as compared to those
which are made by the rot uh means the
deformation based approaches that will
be because that will be offering the
finer grain structure so if the
component being subjected to the
precipitation hardening if it is having
fine grain structure then it will take
shorter time to form the homogeneous
solid solution as compared to the case
when the structure is coed that will
need longer time so once we have got the
homogeneous solid solution it is
subjected to The Next Step that is
quenching so this quenching results in
the super saturated solid solution super
saturated solid solution means alling
Elements which are present in The Matrix
in the homogeneous osmetic State at a
high temperature when they are subjected
to the rapid cooling they get trapped
they don't get time to diffuse out even
if their solubility is less than the
maximum solubility that they can
accommodate okay that is why they result
in the super saturated solid solution
once the super saturated solid solution
is formed then on reheating again for
the Aging purpose
these aling elements which were super
saturated these starts appearing as a
precipitates okay so aging happens in
two ways aging can be done even at the
room temperature that will be termed as
a natural aging and if the reheating is
done to the high temperature then it
will be termed as artificial aing
artificial aging takes a shorter time
maybe 2 to 6 hours or 8 hours but
natural aging may take longer time time
maybe uh like 24 hours or 7 days like
that so natural aging takes longer time
to develop the precipitates and achieve
the desired maximum strength but
artificial aging since it happens at a
higher temperature so great diffusion
activity will be leading to the quick
precipitates desired for hardening
purpose okay so these are the three
steps one is the solutionizing
then
quenching and then
aging aging can be artificial or it can
be natural so this is what happens like
say in the face diagram we can
understand this so this is a one for
typical aluminium copper aloy in x- AIS
it is showing the copper content in y
AIS it is showing the temperature this
particular line is the Solus line which
indicates the solubility of copper in
aluminium as a function of temperature
okay so what we do say this is a
particular aluminium copper Aly when it
is heated then at this temperature it
will be completely saturated with this
kind of the aluminium with this kind of
copper content on further heating it
will be completely dissolving and will
be forming the homogeneous solid
solution okay and so you'll be having
basically Alpha aluminium with the
dissolved copper
okay once the homogeneous solid solution
of the aluminum copper is formed we do
the rapid cooling again back to the room
temperature this is called
quenching on quenching we form the super
saturated solid solution okay so the
first the aluminum copper L is heated we
get the solid solution and then on
quenching we get the super saturated
solid solution and when during the Aging
what happens that these three different
El will be forming the three different
types of the
precipitates okay so aluminium copper
Ali during the Aging what did after
quenching during the Aging it will be
resulting in GP Zone formation and then
the aluminium copper magnesium phase the
s des and S phases and then aluminium
magnesium silicon phase there beta des
and beta phase andum zinc magnesium GMA
des and Gamma
precipitates okay these cipitates are
supposed to contribute towards the
strength so depending upon the Alvi
composition during the Aging the
different types of the precipitates will
be developed okay so if you see this
this solv line can be used for different
Al compositions it will indicate how
much heating should be done so the
basically the phase
diagram okay phase diagram of that Al Al
um inium and that particular ly okay use
its pH diagram to
identify how much temperature it needs
to form the homogeneous solid solution
and above that we try to heat so for
this composition will be Heat this is
the solvus line then above this we will
be selecting say 30 40° Cen higher than
that temperature for solutionizing
purpose higher the temperature rapid
will be the solutionizing shorter time
it will take okay then it will quenched
simply to form the super saturated solid
solution thereafter reheating can be
done or there cannot be any heat
depending upon the Ali aling elements
say aluminium copper magnesium and
aluminium magnesium silicon Ali these
are usually subjected to the artificial
azing but aluminium zinc magnesium also
responds very nicely very quickly to the
Natural aging which means the aluminum
zinc magnesium can simply subjected to
the solutionizing rapid cooling followed
by putting at the room temperature so
that it is naturally aged okay so
depending upon the L composition we can
use the natural aging or the artificial
aging so these are the steps related the
precipitation hardening uh heat
treatment okay this is what it shows
that what happens during the Aging okay
so this diagram will more clearly show
like when we use the low temperature low
temperature for aging that there is a
increase in hardness is very gradual it
takes long actually so this may be in
days or weeks to achieve the desired
strength okay at low temperature this 30
40 50 100° Centigrade but when we use
high temperature aging happens very
quickly okay and then it will be
reaching to the peak hardness level
rapidly when we use the higher
temperature for aging okay so this is
one aspect this diagram shows the two
things one is the Aging must be done for
the optimum time depending upon the
temperature okay if we use low
temperature for artificial Asing it
takes long to get the maximum hardness
and strength while if the high
temperature is used for artificial aging
then it takes less time okay but for
each aging temperature there is an
specific value of the Aging time
corresponding to the peak hardness or
Peak strength okay either side of that
like if the Aging time is less for a
given temperature then strength and
hardness will be low and if the Aging
time is longer again the strength starts
decreasing okay so the conditions of
temperature and time corresponding to
the maximum strength
that is called Peak hardening is to be
identified and established if it is not
so due to any reason if it is underaged
or overaged then strength that will be
getting that will be reduced okay so
this will be happening in both the cases
whether we use low temperature or high
temperature aging okay this is the
underaged situation this is overaged
situation and both over and underaged
will be leading to the reduced strength
why because
when we use under aging conditions then
our precipitation is incomplete means we
don't produce enough precipitates and on
the other hand when we use the
conditions corresponding to the over
aging means there will be
cooning of precipitates and Grains so
this cooning of precipitate and grain
again starts compromising the hardness
and the strength that is why it is very
very important to use the optimum time
for given aging temperature for Peak
hardness how the hardness and strength
is imparted that is what we can see in
the XIs in the x-axis we have aging time
and hardness in y- axis so initially the
GP Jones contribute towards the strength
gunar priston these are the kind of
phases which are precipitates which are
formed in the beginning these are very
fine okay and then the gp2
zone is formed and then we achieve the
peak hardness at say 130° C for
aluminium copper Alloys and then we get
the condition of over aging when we use
the higher temperature of Aging again we
get the increasing this the peak
hardness is achieved earlier and then
over aging starts okay so it is
important that aging is done especially
artificial aging is done for Optimum
combination of the Aging temperature and
time both Under and Over aging will
result in the reduced strength of the
aluminium aloy subjected to the
precipitation hardening aluminium copper
magnesium aloy this is one of the most
common series of the precipitation
hardenable aluminium Alloys which is
used extensively for for making the
aircraft components and also wherever
the weight is extremely important so for
having the high strength to weight ratio
so because of its good corrosion
resistance and good strength so these
are extensively used so these are the
few common Alloys related with the 2,000
series aluminum alloy like
2014 2024
2036 228 uh two8 and 2011 0 so what
these Elis say that uh say the 20114
will have the higher composition of the
copper and lower of the Magnesium but on
the other hand 2024 will have higher
copper and higher concentration of the
mg as well for other Al aluminium copper
magnesium elois these constituent of
proportion or weight percentage of these
elements copper and the Magnesium is
lower and accordingly so this just the
Magnesium the ranges of magnesium and
copper contained in common aluminium
copper alwi 2036 208 and 2011 0 apart
from like
2014 and
2024 okay we'll be taking up one case
study related with this aluminum alloy
that is why I talked little more so 214
is one of the typical aluminium copper
aloy say having the higher concentration
of the copper and lesser concentration
of the magnesium and what it shows the
fine precipitates okay in the metrix of
the aluminium and what it shows that
different aluminium grains Okay so we
can see that aluminium grains are there
and with the fine precipitates of
aluminium and copper so that is evident
also from the uh this
x-ray uh defraction analysis of the
2014 aluminium Aly
and typical strength of the this ly is
like say
407 is the ultimate strength
358 is the eeld strength and ductility
uh in terms of percentage elongation is
10.2 on so this is reasonably a good
strength and the ductility metal what
happens when these Alvis are subjected
to the heat treatment so that is what we
can see when the aluminium
silicon and uh the mg subjected to the
casting which kind of structure we get
so these are the like say the four
different types of the micro structures
this is for the very low silicon content
4% silicon 8% silicon 12%
silicon and then we have 16% silicon and
20% silicon what it is showing that when
the content of silicon is less than the
UT tactic then it is termed as the hypo
utac aluminium silicon ly and it
primarily has the alpha aluminium with
the UT tactic mixture of aluminium
silicon at the grain boundaries okay so
with the increasing silicon the
proportion of the utac is increasing
that's what we can see here okay 4 to 8
and 8 to 12 up to this the TIC
proportion is increasing and Alpha
aluminium proportion is decreasing on
further increasing the Silicon content
beyond the Hy beyond the utaic
composition means that is the hyper
tic system hyper tic aluminum silicon
aloy what we get presence of the
additional phases in form of the primary
silicon particles in the Matrix of the
alpha aluminium and UT tactic mixture so
in the hyper tic aluminium Alvis we have
Alpha aluminium uh we we have primary
silicon and we have Tic so these three
constituents while in case of the hypo
utcc systems basically we have Alpha
aluminium in hypo Tic and tic only there
is no primary silicon for eutactic
hypotactic system so that is the case of
this one two and also in three this is
the TIC or hypo tic aluminum silicon ly
okay this is one aspect that the
constituents change with the change of
silicon content okay apart from that
what we can see in all these cases we
see the dendritic structure dendrites of
the alpha aluminium alloy okay and in
the ENT dendritic region we have the TIC
mixture in the inter so this dark phase
that is in the inter dtic zone is
basically the eutactic
mixture okay so this is a typical cast
structure thing but when this Al is
subjected to the T6 heat treatment means
the it is exposed to the solutionizing
followed by quenching and then
aging uh so artificial aging basically
because this is T6 so what it results
all eutactic silicon is broken down
eutactic is broken down into the fine
spherical shape mixture gra dendritic
structure is also broken down and we
have the aluminium Matrix okay so what
is happening after the heat treatment
there is a complete modification we get
the aluminium
Matrix and f a spherical
shape uh eutactic
silicon particles which are well
distributed so this modification is
expected to enhance the hardness enhance
the strength and also ductility okay so
what it shows that increasing the
solutionizing
temperature basically increases the you
see as compared to the s cast system it
results in the higher hardness this is
one this is attributed to the
precipitation hardening and also within
for a given uh heat solutionizing
temperature increasing solutionizing
temperature increases the hardness and
as compared to the cost aluminum also
you will compare then you'll get the
higher hardness for a given
solutionizing temperature if we try to
see the increase effect of the Silicon
content then this will also show that
the hardness is increasing in each band
increase of silicon content increases
the hardness and increasing
solutionizing temperature also increases
the hardness because of the effective
solutionizing followed by precipitation
hardening similarly as compared to the
uh like say in as compared to the s cast
system that is this blank the hardness
is lowest
okay but certainly it is increasing with
the Silicon content on the other hand if
we do the Aging at the different
temperatures then the effectiveness of
the Aging
increases and we get the more effective
strain precipitation hardening and
therefore we get the increasing hardness
with the increasing aging temperature
okay so this is what is reflected also
in a strength not just in hardness for
any ly increasing the solutionizing
temperature increases the strength okay
uh similarly increasing the Aging
temperature also increases the strength
for each category of the aluminum aloy
except this for the higher level okay
for this hyper utac in tic systems there
is a continuous increase of the strength
so now we'll take up one case study here
in this case study what we'll try to see
like a filis of the bike component which
is made of the precipitation hard
Neville aluminium ly it's a structural
members which which takes the load
during the operation during the use and
this component of the bike failed
prematurely within 6 months of service
so when investigation was undertaken and
investigation revealed that material
composition is as a specified so there
is no problem as far as the material
composion is concerned design is also
checked and it was found that it is as
per the recommendation so that part is
also clear visual examination of the
failed component showed that the
fracture occurred from the section where
there was a change of cross-section so
obviously there would have been a fillet
or some kind of the when there is a
change of cross-section so obviously the
stresses tend to get localized in that
zone mechanical property studies showed
the lower e strength of 340 as compared
to the specified one 4 100 so what it is
suggesting that material is of the lower
yield strength than the specified one
micro structure on the other hand
revealed the coarse grain structure and
Co
precipitates so this is indicating the
possibility of the overaging of heatable
or heated aluminium 202 20114 aluminium
Aly okay so because overaging means the
lower strength than the specified one
course grains and course precipitates
suggest the possibility of the
overaging and no defect whatsoever was
found during the NDT so this suggest
that there is no such problem of the
soundness of the component of course
there would have been some stress Rises
and stress concentration due to the
section where change in cross-section
was taken place and that resulted that
promoted or triggered the fracture okay
due to the weakness due to the lower
eeld strength of the material further
investigation suggested the normal
operation no abnormal operation or no
repairs whatever it would have been of
that structural member maintenance in
this case was not applicable because
this was a structural member of simple B
stereoscopy and Sam suggested The dimple
fracture with the significant
deformation so means material is ductile
but of the lower he strength and that is
why it showed the dimple fra
and when the strength was compared with
the new one it was found that strength
is actually lower than as compared to
the new one which is still not in use or
those which have been doing very well uh
for long so when all these observations
were analyzed it was found that aluminum
component failed due to the improper
heat treatment due to the over aging uh
which could be primarily due to the like
say improper aging condition
that resulted in the lower strength due
to the co grain structure so for as the
possible recommendations are concerned
like say implement the suitable design
changes in the area where the stress
localization is expected to be taking
place because the failure occurred from
the section where there was a change of
cross-section so give the proper fillet
or relocate or redesign in such a way
that the stress localization doesn't
happen there also ensure that proper
strength is achieved through the proper
optimization or establishment of the T6
heat treatment because this suggested
the possibility of the overaging as it
was Apparent from the coarse grain of
the alpha aluminium and coarse
precipitates that resulted in the lower
strength and which in turn resulted in
the resulted the fracture of the
component uh so that's all in the
today's presentation I will summarize
this presentation in this presentation
basically I've talked about the common
heated will aluminum allise what is the
underlying principle of the
precipitation hardening and what are the
important parameters related to the
precipitation Harding and how those are
designed and optimized and then we have
taken up one case study related with the
the bike component made of the
precipitation hardal aluminum ly
204 and what led to the failure that was
established thank you for your attention
[Music]
a
[Music]
