Lecture 53- Failure Analysis of Steel: Improper Heat Treatment

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 20, 2024
Hello, I welcome you all in this presentation related with the subject failure analysis
and prevention.
And you know we are talking about the failure analysis of the steel components, in this
particular presentation we are talking about what if the heat treatment is not done properly,
then how the failures of the steel components can occur.
So initially we will be talking about the basics related to the heat treatment and the
way by which things can go wrong, if the incorrect the approach or the process or the parameter
is selected.
So here this presentation primarily includes the heat treatment of a steel, where we will
be talking about the scope and the purpose and the structure property relationship means
how to adjust and regulate the structures for the desired combination of the properties
is realized and then how the iron carbon diagram and continuous cooling transformation diagram
are related with the heat treatment and how these two diagrams form the strong basis for
designing the heat treatment.
And then we will be talking about the basic principles of few heat treatments, which will
include like normalizing, annealing, hardening, then tempering, austempering, martempering.
So through these diagrams we will try to quickly present the basic aspects and then we will
be talking about case study, where in the failure of a component due to the faulty heat
treatment has taken place.
So and the relevant the failure analysis observations and findings will be presented.
So you know that the steels are the steel is an alloy of the iron and carbon particularly
and other alloying elements are added to achieve the desired set of properties in case of the
alloy steels.
So when only carbon content is controlled, then we call it as a carbon steel or plain
carbon steel.
The steels offer a very unique benefit in terms of the property alteration that by changing
the certain phases, we can achieve a variety of the properties, which can range from very
soft and low hardness, high ductility to the high hardness and the low ductility or low
ductness.
So depending upon the requirement of application, we try to adjust the suitable microstructure
or microstructure of a steel suitably so that we can achieve the desired set of properties.
So this is what is achieved effectively and easily through the heat treatments.
So heat treatment of the steel component is done for multiple purposes.
One of the amongst those is like to achieve the desired mechanical properties.
So the goal may be to have the desired high hardness for wear resistance applications.
So abrasion and adhesive wear resistance is extremely good or a goal may be to have the
high toughness.
So we may go for like the fine grained structures with the moderate set of mechanical properties
to have the high toughness and that will be offering you increased resistance to the crack
nucleation and its growth.
So depending upon the requirement, we can go for a variety of combination of mechanical
properties and that is achieved through the suitable heat treatment of steel.
We know that the components because of the structural changes experience a lot of change
in mechanical properties when subjected to the heat treatment.
So there are two aspects like the high temperature, dimensional stability and high temperature
and mechanical properties you see.
So depending upon the requirement what is done exposure to the component at the manufacturing
stage is given in such a way that the component has the desired set of the structures as per
the application temperature.
So that is what is done basically to have the desired mechanical properties even at
higher temperature and likewise for the dimensional stability.
So the high temperature exposure is given actually for that purpose.
Then we know that during the manufacturing process like casting, forming, welding lot
of residual stresses are induced and these residual stresses tend to adversely affect
the mechanical performance.
So if the residual tensile stresses develop, then they compromise with the like tensile
load carrying capacity and the fatigue resistance under the tensile loading.
So efforts are made to neutralize the effect of these residual stresses by inducing the
residual compressive stresses okay.
So what is done, if the residual tensile stresses have been developed, then their magnitude
is reduced through the heat treatment.
So that is called a stress relieving treatment.
Alternately what we can do also like if the component is not having any residual stresses,
then we can make efforts to induce the residual compressive stress okay.
So to enhance the performance under the tensile loading or under the fatigue conditions subjected
to a tensile loading okay.
So there are both possibilities, one either residual tensile stresses are minimized or
eliminated through the suitable stress relieving treatment okay or suitable heat treatment
is done so that the residual compressive stresses are induced okay.
If that is achieved, then our performance of our component is enhanced and sometimes
even the improvement in machinability of the high carbon steel is also achieved, especially
in case of the hyper-eutectoid steels where we have the thick layer of the cementite.
So the thick layer of the cementite adversely affects the machinability.
So to improve the machinability of hyper-eutectoid steels, the spheroidizing heat treatment helps
in improving the machining.
If the heat treatment is being done is not of proper type or is not done under the appropriate
conditions of high temperature exposure for sufficient time followed by the control cooling,
then it will lead to the compromise in the set of properties that we are expecting okay.
So the heat treatment can also be done after the manufacturing and repairs to avoid any
undesirable effects which have been introduced in course of the manufacturing or to achieve
the desired set of the microstructure and mechanical properties in the component after
the manufacturing and repair okay.
So the thing is this here, this is the iron carbon diagram.
These are the two diagrams basically, iron carbon diagram and this is the diagram which
shows that the temperature and time relationship for dissolving the various constituents to
form the homogeneous austenite okay for the heat treatment.
So if we see in the x-axis we have carbon and y-axis we have the temperature and this
diagram iron carbon diagram shows this is the curtailed one means not full range of
the iron carbon diagram has been shown.
So what it shows this is the upper critical temperature line and this is the lower critical
temperature line corresponding to say 727 degree centigrade.
So upper critical temperature changes with the carbon content that is what we can see
it is for 0% carbon it is 910 and then it keeps on decreasing and reaches to 727 for
about eutectoid composition corresponding to say 0.8% and then again it starts increasing
with the further increase of carbon content and these are the various phases.
So when the heating is done between the upper and lower critical temperatures then it is
called intercritical temperature heating okay.
Usually for normal heat treatment processes like annealing, normalizing and quenching
or even for austempering and maltempering heating is done above the upper critical temperature
which is say 30 to 40 or 50 degree centigrade above the upper critical temperature.
So that all soft phases like ferrite, pearlite or other constituents if they are present
they can be dissolved and homogeneous austenite is found.
Austenite being a metastable phase on subsequently on the cooling depending on the cooling conditions
it forms the variety of phases.
So desired phase is obtained through the controlled cooling in the subsequent stages but that
can be done only if all the soft phases and other constituents have been dissolved and
homogeneous austenitic state has been achieved okay.
In addition to these heat treatments where heating is done above the upper critical temperature
say upper critical temperature plus 30 to 50 or 40 degree centigrade above this for
achieving the homogeneous austenitic state okay.
In addition to that there are other lines like this is the tempering temperature line
or this is the range also for the our stress relieving conditions.
So the tempering temperature means say around 200, 250 degree centigrade to below the lower
critical temperature that will help in tempering the martensite and inducing the toughness
improving the ductility okay and say around 600 from 200 to 600 degree centigrade also
the heating is done for the stress relieving treatment purposes.
So that the residual stresses can be reduced say 400 degree centigrade is the recrystallization
temperature for iron and the steels.
So say when the steel which is having say basically the iron and carbon and depending
upon the other alloying elements say other alloying elements if they are there it can
have the variety of phases like alpha ferrite, alpha iron, ferrite then we can have the cementite
Fe3C plus alpha ferrite iron that is in form of say pearlite okay and then there is a possibility
depending upon the alloying elements there is a possibility of alloy carbides okay.
So initially these are the constituents which are present in the steel at room temperature
what happens when the heating is done then as a function of time alpha iron, pearlite
and alloy carbides in if there are alloying elements and their carbides are being formed
then above the upper critical temperature how the things change as a function of time
okay if we take a high temperature then these phases starts getting dissolved earlier like
say this is the so initially alpha iron, pearlite and alloy carbides.
So this pearlite will be transforming into the austenite alloy carbides will be there
and alpha iron will be there thereafter on further continuous heating means for further
longer soaking time our the alpha iron will also be transforming and then into the austenite
and then will be left with the alloy carbides and thereafter heterogeneous because alloy
carbides whenever they will decompose alloying elements will get will be segregated near
these carbide locations.
So what will happen it will be forming the heterogeneous austenite.
So it further requires the higher temperature to get the homogeneous austenitic state.
So these are the different stages through which the various constituents will be transforming
into the austenite okay.
So if we take the higher temperature like this it will be taking shorter time if we
take the lower temperature like this then it will be taking longer time to achieve the
homogeneous austenitic state okay.
Once the homogeneous austenitic state is achieved will be imposing the different cooling rates
to achieve to obtain the different phases.
These phases may be in form of like coarse pearlite, fine pearlite or this can be bainite,
this can be martensite or mixture of martensite plus pearlite like this.
So these are the various phases which are obtained depending upon the kind of phases
which have been achieved and their proportions what will be having high pearlite low high
ferrite low pearlite will be resulting in the soft means the low strength, low hardness,
high ductility and fine pearlite, fine ferrite and fine bainitic structure will result very
good combination of the strength and the toughness and ductility.
High yield strength is achieved when fine pearlite, fine bainite and fine martensite
is there high fine martensite bainite and pearlite is there for high yield strength
and high hardness is obtained when we have high martensite and cementite and high toughness
is obtained when fine pearlite, fine pearlite and the fine bainite is present okay.
So here idea is to achieve the these phases as per our requirement of the properties.
So this the first diagram is the triple T diagram that is the temperature time transformation
diagram and the second one is the CCT diagram which is continuous cooling transformation
diagram.
So CCT triple T diagram what it shows what happens to the austenite when it is subjected
to the constant temperature as a function of time.
So at high temperature the transformation of austenite starts into the pearlite at this
time and then it ends at this time when the exposure is given at a constant temperature.
So what it will be resulting in the coarse pearlite okay.
When the steel is subjected to the lower transformation lower temperatures then what
will happen say this temperature Ts2 say another temperature a lower temperature then transformation
will start earlier and then it will end earlier and it will be resulting in the fine pearlite.
The further lower temperature say this is the nose of the diagram and here what will
happen that transformation will start at the earliest and then it will end earlier okay.
And on further lower temperatures then this will start getting delayed okay and will be
ending late.
So this is why it results in the C shape structure okay.
So and this is the nose where the transformation will be starting earliest and will be ending
earliest okay.
So what is happening initially we get the coarse pearlite then fine pearlite then we
get the coarse bainite and then fine bainite.
These things happen at a constant temperature of the transformation of austenite into the
other phases okay.
So accordingly you see this will be increasing in the hardness you see the minimum hardness
is achieved when the coarse pearlite then somewhat greater hardness when fine pearlite
then further greater hardness when coarse bainite is achieved and further higher hardness
is achieved when the fine bainite is obtained.
On further cooling at lower transformation temperatures lower temperatures what will
happen we will be having so there are two lines one is the Ms that is the martensite
start temperature and martensite finish temperature say this one okay.
So if we quench directly the steel from austenitic state to any of these temperatures then accordingly
the temperature at which we are quenching will be having combination of austenite and
martensite.
Above the Ms temperature there is just austenite and below this there is a just martensite
and in between the Ms and Mf there is a austenite and martensite.
But these transformation indicate the transformation of the austenite into the other phases at
a constant temperature okay.
But most of the time heat treatment is done under the continuous cooling conditions because
it takes very long actually if you see these times are in the log scale so this may be
taking very long to achieve these phases.
So usually heat treatment is done under the continuous cooling conditions so we are just
say continuous cooling conditions are imposed then our diagram is little bit modified we
do not have the lower section here where the bainite is formed because bainite is found
particularly at the constant temperature of the transformation okay.
So let us talk about the CCT diagram so what happens when the continuous cooling is applied
transformation starts at Ts1 and it ends at Tf1.
So these two temperatures are different actually so initially it will be forming the coarse
pearlite and then in the later stage it will be forming the fine pearlite okay.
So the grain size will continuously be changing here in course of the transformation of austenite
into the other phases because the transformation is not happening at a constant temperature but
it is happening at the different temperature.
So if the cooling rate is this then what will be happening a part of the austenite will be
transforming into the pearlite and remaining austenite will be transforming into the
martensite that is why what will be having here pearlite plus martensite.
And when the cooling rate is such that it just touches the nose of the curve then there is no
transformation of austenite into the pearlite only the transformation of austenite into the
martensite starts here and it ends here okay which means you will have just martensite.
This cooling rate is known as CCT a CCR critical cooling rate and any cooling rate greater than
the critical cooling rate will be resulting in the just martensite okay.
So depending upon the purpose and application desired set of the properties are achieved.
We may require just coarse pearlite, fine pearlite or mixture of pearlite and martensite
only martensite okay if you want bainite then different kind of the heat treatment is
performed okay or for the alloy steels also there will be different kind of these
continuous cooling transformation diagram and we may get the bainite also in those cases.
So in simplified form if you want to talk about the heat treatment steps
it involves first heating to the desired temperature that is 30 to 50 degree centigrade
above the upper critical temperature to achieve the homogeneous austenitic state.
This time should be sufficient to achieve the homogeneous austenitic state.
Thereafter low cooling rate is imposed for annealing purpose that will be resulting in
the coarse pearlite and fine pearlite is obtained little higher cooling rate is used for fine
normalizing that will be leading to the fine pearlite and we will be having further higher
cooling rates for achieving the martensite for higher hardness okay.
These are the three most common types of the heat treatment and if the proportion of the
martensite increases of course our hardness and strength will keep on increasing with the
increasing proportion of the martensite but this will be happening at the cost of our toughness
and ductility. So we know that when the hardening heat treatment is done most of the time our
austenite transforms into the martensite and what martensite does is it increases the hardness
okay but badly compromises the toughness and ductility okay.
So to make the components workable for engineering application what is done
after the hardening heat treatment again the steel is reheated. So heating, austenitizing,
rapid cooling this is the hardening heat treatment then again heat steel is subjected to the
reheating and then this reheating temperature will depend upon the property combination that
we are looking for in terms of the toughness and the kind of compromise in strength and hardness
that can be accepted. So accordingly the suitable tempering temperature is selected and this is
always lesser than the lower critical temperature. So what we do we heat the component,
reheat the component in this temperature range, hold it for some time which may range like 30
minutes or 1 hour or 2 hours depending on the section size and then again it is cooled slowly
okay. So again the subsequent cooling will depend on the composition of the steel to avoid the
cracking tendency. So simply air cooling can also be done. So what happens when the different kind
of the tempering temperatures are applied for the heat treatment purposes usually the in case
of carbon steels hardness it comes down very rapidly but in case of the alloy carbide secondary
hardening happens this particularly happens due to the formation of the tungsten carbide, vanadium
carbide, molybdenum carbide. Carbides of certain alloying elements which are formed at a higher
temperature. So the secondary hardening is observed in case of the alloy steels okay.
So this is about the hardness variation and as far as the toughness variation is concerned with
the tempering temperature is like usually the toughness increases with the increase of the
tempering temperature. So depending upon the requirement like say if you superimpose these
two lines then it will be coming like this okay. So what kind of combination in properties we are
looking for like low toughness and high hardness or a high toughness and low hardness. So which
kind of combination is desired for a given application accordingly the suitable tempering
temperature is selected. Ash tempering and mar tempering are these two other important heat
treatments. Ash tempering is done primarily to form the bainite okay. So what is done
the component is quenched just above the ms temperature and it is held at that temperature
for long. So that whole austenite transforms into the bainite followed by air cooling. This is what
the austenite, ash tempering is and in mar tempering things are cooled rapidly just above
the ms temperature then cooled rapidly followed by tempering in case of the mar tempering.
So here in ash tempering we get the bainite and in case of the mar tempering we form the
martensite followed by tempering okay but here quenching is done again just above the ms
temperature. So the temperature across the section is homogenized to avoid the differential
cooling rates being experienced and the different phase transformations and also the to reduce the
distortion and cracking tendencies this is done okay. So this is a kind of the case study where
we will try to see what if the heat treatment is done incorrectly or incorrect type of the
treatment is done then what happens to the component performance okay. So say the component
was made of the low carbon steel say a nozzle the failure of the nozzle used for the spraying hot
water. This is the component having nozzle machine having a nozzle which was being used for spraying
the hot water for a particular application. This nozzle failed prematurely and how it was
judged like the speed of the water jet which was coming got reduced and that in turn affected the
performance of the operation for which this jet hot water jet was being used and therefore the
nozzle failed prematurely within six months of service while the other nozzles were working
successfully even after two years of service. So when the investigation was conducted and it
was found that steel had lesser carbon content than they specified this was one. So incorrect
incoming raw material the steel composition through spectroscopy was analyzed and it was found
it had lesser carbon content than the specified 1.45 which means this would have would be having
high proportion of the ferrite and very less proportion of the pearlite okay as compared to
the one which would be there in the 0.45% carbon steel. Visual examination what it suggested enlarged
hole size okay. So that suggested like the wear of the nozzle has taken place and that the wear
was not irregular initially it was circular but after the erosion it increased. So the dimension
of the hole of the nozzle increased and the shape became irregular okay. When the mechanical
properties of the nozzle were examined it was found that it was half hardness 10 HRC as compared to
the specified 22 HRC. Microstructure study revealed the coarse pearlitic and the ferritic structure
instead of the fine grained structure. This structure suggested the annealing heat treatment
instead of the recommended normalizing heat treatment. So there were two issues one was
like lower carbon content and the incorrect microstructure resulted from the inappropriate
heat treatment okay. So we know that when this the nozzle being used for spraying the hot
water jet during the operation this frequently comes across the cavitation condition and
cavitation how does it occur initially the surface is see what happens like under the
cavitation conditions initially vapour bubbles are formed and they will be busting at the surface
of the nozzle and creating high pressure shock waves. Pressure can go from 1000 to 1500 MPa
this will be resulting the surface layer plastic deformation okay. Continuous pressure shock waves
result in the pits which are smoother at the surface through the removal of the material.
So initially the surfaces may be smooth and there won't be any wear or erosion but after
some time if we see the cavitation and the wear happening due to the cavitation as a function of
time. So this is the time when the cavitation will be starting it is known as incubation period okay
and thereafter the cavitation or the wear will start okay and then will continue to increase.
What it requires like a good combination of the hardness and good combination of the
toughness okay. So a very good combination of the hardness and toughness is needed but these two are
opposite properties if your hardness is high toughness will be low. So what we do we try to
an optimum combination of the hardness and toughness through the fine grained structure
and suitable combination of the various phases which are there. So the further investigation
revealed that there were no defect whatsoever kind in the nozzle means only the surface
irregularities and the cavitation effect was observed at the surface in form of irregular hole
and the enlarged size of the hole entity did not reveal any kind of the defect.
And the operation was also like normal operating conditions were observed without any like
previous repair kind of thing stereoscopy and some images of the worn out surface revealed the deep
craters pits lips and the deformed surface layers these are suggesting the possibility of the
cavitation erosion okay. This cavitation erosion primarily occurs when the hardness is low and the
toughness is also low. So a comparison of the nozzle failed in the initial stages of surface
service with the other nozzles installed almost at the same time that continued to perform even
for the two years this suggested like there is something wrong with that nozzle. So what was done
investigation what it suggested like the percentage of the carbon content in the steel is
low like it was 0.2 instead of 0.45 okay and the structure was coarse pearlitic and ferritic rather
than fine ferrite and the pearlite. So this structure was basically the dominated by ferrite
and the less pearlite otherwise the structure should have been dominated by the pearlite
and less ferrite but fine okay. So this suggested the possibility of incorrect annealing heat
treatment and that was reflected from the coarse pearlite lower hardness thing.
So the incorrect heat treatment resulted in the coarse pearlite and the coarse ferrite
and also the lower hardness. So these were the main regions also the carbon content was less. So
all above suggested that the failure of the nozzle by cavitation erosion due to the improper material
composition lower hardness improper structure and the incorrect heat treatment that was applied
okay. Now I will summarize this presentation in this presentation basically I have talked about
the various heat treatment processes the basics on which the heat treatment of the steel is based
and one case study on the failure of the steel nozzle which had taken place.
So investigation suggested that the carbon content was low the structure was not appropriate and the
heat treatment which was done was also not proper and that resulted in the lower hardness and that
in turn totality resulted in the reduced cavitational resistance and that
in turn led to the failure of the nozzle. Thank you for your attention.
