Lecture 54- Failure Analysis of Steel: Improper Case Hardening Treatment

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 20, 2024
Hello, I welcome you all in this presentation related to the subject failure analysis and
prevention and you know we are talking about the failure analysis of steel components and
in this particular presentation we will be talking about the failure analysis
of a component which failed due to the faulty case hardening heat treatment and secondary processing.
Okay, so in this presentation first of all we will try to understand the various approaches
methods which are used for the case hardening and also the special heat treatments which are
carried out for a better manufacturing for improving the performance.
Okay, so as far as the content is concerned in this presentation we will be talking about
the stress relieving heat treatment. Okay, during the manufacturing and during the heat treatment
variety of the heat treatments are during the manufacturing a process like casting, welding,
forming lot of heat a lot of residual stresses are induced. So, it is good to relieve the residual
stresses to improve the performance. So, the stress relieving heat treatment we will be
talking about first and then in process annealing. This annealing is primarily done for inducing the
ductility in course of the rolling or the forming processes which are done under the cold condition.
So, that the desired ductility can be induced. So, basically the rolling wire drying kind of
the processes where things are done in the lot number of stages. So, after the initial stage
materials get hardened. So, to induce the softness the in process annealing is done so that the
material can be formed continuously without development of cracks. Case hardening is one
where the surface layers are hardened while the core properties or the properties below the surface
are maintained or they do not get affected and this is especially needed when we want one set
of the properties in the core say this is core and at the surface we want a different set of properties.
Okay, so in this case we want the case hardening heat treatment. So, a range of the case hardening
heat treatments are there which are simply based on the heat treatments or controlled
plastic deformation or modifying the composition of the steel surface layer. So, that the desired
structure and properties can be induced for developing the desired set of the properties.
Additionally we will be talking about one case study where the faulty case hardening
heat treatment followed by the machining led to the failure of the crank shafts.
Okay, so and also the relevant failure analysis observation and findings will be covered in this
presentation. So, starting with this the special purpose heat treatments are like
stress relieving heat treatment in process annealing for. So, this is for reducing the
residual stresses, this is for inducing the ductility, percentage elongation okay and
reducing the hardness being introduced due to the work hardening.
And the surface hardening or case hardening heat treatments are done like these are the
three approaches one is where only controlled surface layer deformation is achieved using
methods like friction stir processing, burnishing, okay shot peening. So, these are the methods where
controlled surface layer deformation is used for enhancing the surface properties.
And then controlled heating and cooling like in case of the laser hardening, flame hardening,
induction hardening. So, these are the methods which are particularly applied for the high
carbon hardenable steels okay. So, that the controlled heating and cooling gives the
increased surface layer hardness for improved wear resistance, improved the tensile properties,
improved fatigue properties okay. Third method and third approach here is like
composition of the surface layers is modified okay these are the surface layers. So, up to certain
depth we will be introducing the unique elements near the surface layers. So, they form their
either compounds or they help in achieving the desired phases near the surface layers
in order to modify the properties while the core remains unaffected okay.
So, that is the approach of the compositional modification for controlling the surface
properties through carburizing, nitriding, cyaniding, aluminizing, boronizing lot of
other approaches are also there depending upon the element which is being introduced in the surface
for achieving the desired phases and desired properties in different kind of the
surface modification methods are there by changing the composition.
And we will be taking up one case study related to the faulty heat treatment or the incorrect
the case hardening heat treatment followed by secondary processing.
So, as far as the stress relieving is concerned you know whenever a component is subjected to the
localized heating, localized plastic deformation. So, then this whether it is casting,
welding or forming this leads to the development of the residual stresses.
Residual stresses are those stresses which are present in the component without application of
external stresses. So, if the residual stresses are tensile in nature then they compromise
residual tensile stresses they compromise their ability to take up the tensile load
or ability to sustain the fatigue conditions of the tensile type. So, the fatigue resistance and
the static load carrying capacity under the tension is compromised when the tensile residual
stresses are present when under the conditions when either localized deformation is done
or when the localized heating and cooling is done ok.
So, this will be leading to the development of the residual stresses if those residual
stresses are tensile then they will be adversely affecting the performance of the component under
the tension. So, what we do we try to either induced using other methods try to induce the
residual compressive stress. So, that the performance of the component can be enhanced
and the adverse effect of the residual tensile stresses is neutralized.
So, what is done this is the temperature range you see the component is subjected to the heating
below the lower critical temperature. So, that the locked in strain resulting in the residual
stresses can be eliminated. So, this one heat treatment approach the heat treatment which is
done for relieving the residual stresses is called stress relieving heat treatment.
And temperature for a stress relieving heat treatment can range from say 200 to the 700
that is below the lower critical temperature. So, that the residual stress magnitude can be
minimized maximum residual stress magnitude can be equal to the yield strength ok.
So, when the exposure is given say in x axis we have the temperature here say 100, 200, 300, 400,
500, 600 like this and it can go to say 700 usually and here we have temperature at which
the exposure is being given. So, here in this side residual stress the maximum magnitude can
be equal to the yield strength. So, say 100 percent residual stress then 80 percent then
60 percent 40 percent residual stress left 10 percent and 20 percent say 10 percent and 0
percent. What happens when the exposure is given to the high low temperature the residual stresses
are high. So, say no exposure means the residual stresses will go like this.
So, when the exposure is given say for 1 hour then residual stress come down in this way ok.
Increasing temperature means reducing the residual stress how much 80 percent of the
yield strength 60 percent of yield strength 40 percent 20 percent and 10 percent of the
yield strength. So, that is the left out residual stresses due to the high temperature exposure
it may be absent also it may be completely relieved. So, what happens when the temperature
is increased yield strength of material comes down whatever log distance are there they get
relieved and so the residual stress is relieved ok this is one case. So, when the exposure is
given for when exposure is given for longer time then how we can see its effect that is what we can
see in the form of another line. So, this is for 1 hour say if exposure is given for 2 hours then
it will be going like this means greater reduction in the residual stress will be happening
for same exposure of the same temperature of exposure say.
So, if this is the 200 degree centigrade is temperature so this is the drop at after 1
hour and this is the kind of drop which will be taking place after the 2 hours of exposure.
So, it is important not just the temperature but the time for which the exposure is being
given is also very crucial for stress relieving. Longer the time of exposure at a given temperature
greater will be the relieving of residual stress. So, if the residual if the heat treatment is not
done properly then there is a possibility like lot of residual tensile stresses are left and
they will compromise with the performance of the component ok. So, it is very important to select
the time and temperature for residual stress relieving.
This is what we can see directly the effect of residual stress on mechanical performance of the
component ok. So, say there is a permissible limit up to which the component can be subjected to the
stresses and say maximum limit without any factor of safety it will be the yield strength
beyond which it will deform ok. So, here it is the combination of like
applied stress plus the residual stress. If the combination of these 2 is equal to the
yield strength then material will fail it will deform ok. So, if we have the higher residual
stress then applied stress magnitude can be reduced will be reduced ok. So, given applied
stress is say this much that is equal to the sigma y. So, when residual stress is 0 means
externally applied stress can be as high as yield strength theoretically.
If we apply factor of safety then accordingly our externally applied stress will be reduced.
But just right if we try to understand the effect of residual stress then we can see is directly
increasing the residual stress will be reducing the externally applied stress.
So, maximum magnitude of the residual stress can be equal to the yield strength and thereafter we
cannot apply you see in this stage we cannot apply any externally applied stress because
it will material will tend to deform immediately ok. So, it is important that for higher for
ability for increased ability of the component to take up the service loads higher service loads
it is important that like sigma r if sigma y is equal to sigma r plus sigma a that is the
applied stress then to have the higher value of the sigma a it is a externally applied stress
sigma r must be low and this can be done through the stress relieving.
We need to eliminate or minimize the residual stresses as much as possible. Now we will be
talking about the 3 different types of the methods which are used for the for improving
the surface hardness. So, the one method is the flame hardening this is particularly applied
in case of the high carbon like say greater than 0.5 percent carbon ok high carbon steels
having high hardenability ok this is the pre-decrease high hardenability.
So, that on heating you see this is the surface when heat is applied through the suitable heat
source it can be induction it can be laser it can be flame anything when the heat is
applied near surface layers are heated to the austenitic state that is the above the
upper critical temperature. So, that near surface layers get austenitized followed by
you see the heat source will be moving followed by the jet of water.
So, that austenite is cooled rapidly to transform the austenite into the
martensite and enhance the surface hardness this is the logic.
Transformation of austenite into the martensite will be easier when the hardenability is high
and this is particularly when the carbon equivalent carbon content or carbon equivalent
is greater than carbon equivalent is greater than 4.4 the carbon equivalent is carbon content is
greater than 0.5 ok. So, this is one typical example where the surface hardening is being
done through the flame ok. So, there is a flame oxyacetylene flame, flame is used for the heating
the substrate say this is a zone which is being heated and heated to the temperature of upper
austenitic upper critical temperature. So, that the austenitic state can be achieved
followed by application of the water jet. So, that rapid cooling of the austenite
transforms the austenite into the martensite resulting in the high hardness ok.
So, idea here is to increase the surface hardness. So, that our wear resistance is enhanced.
This is the another approach of surface modification where controlled surface layer
deformation is used for enhancing the surface properties and inducing the residual stresses
as well. So, what happens in this case say this is the surface layer. So, we will be deforming
the surface layer in controlled way plastically. So, this plastic deformation used with the help
of a roller that is a burnishing tool which is forcefully rolled see the burnishing tool is
pressed and traversed across the surface. This component is subjected to the rotation just like
in turning and then burnishing tool is pressed against the rotating tool. So, what happens
surface irregularities get collapsed near surface layers get elongated surfaces get a smoothness
and surface plastic deformation of the near surface layers induces the residual
compressive stress. So, this burnishing surface layer deformation does multiple things you see
the one controlled plastic deformation which causes work hardening or a strain hardening
which in turn increases the hardness this is one. The second is the structures usually structure
gets refined and elongated in particular direction and third is residual compressive
stresses are also induced residual compressive stresses are induced in the at the surface.
So, this is what we see turned surface may have high residual stress of positive that is the
tensile type near the surface layers but when burnishing is done it induces the compressive
stresses and it also. So, you can see up to the 300 micrometer depth this surface layer modification
is observed that will be leading to the variation in the residual stress level.
Likewise the shot peening is also done. So, in the case of the shot peening the surface is this
and the steel balls are directed at very high speed say steel balls of say 2 to 3 mm in diameter
directed at like say high speed of 500 meter per second. So, they are directed very high speed
towards the surface the impact will be leading to the formation of impression and this impression
will be like this. So, this kind of the impression formed or the surface this leads to the surface
layer plastic deformation that is what we can see here due to the impact of the shots
this kind of the geometry is formed. So, there is a zone at the surface which is
plastically deformed and below that there is elastically deformed zone. So, elastically
deformed zone tends to regain its dimensions and that in turn sets the residual compressive
stress at the surface. So, it is not the plastic deformation which is setting the
residual compressive stress it is the elastic deformation of near surface layers is responsible
for development of the residual compressive stresses. At the same time this plastic deformation
of course it will be causing the strain hardening that in turn will be increasing the hardness.
So, the shot peening will be doing the two things one you see increased surface hardness
due to the strain hardening occurring due to the plastic deformation of the near surface layers
and development of the residual compressive stress. So, these two things are very much
favorable for enhancing the performance of the component under the tension and under the fatigue
conditions. Friction stress processing is the another solid state method which is used for
modifying the surface layer properties. So, the approach is shown here initially
the component may have the structure like this where the constituents are coarse one and they
are needle shaped. So, the coarse constituents with the needle shaped geometries they offer
very high stress concentration at the tip and edges. So, because of the stress concentration
at the tips and at these edges our load carrying capacity is compromised. Coarse and sharp edged
needle shaped constituents these two reduce the percentage elongation that is ductility
these reduce the toughness these reduce the strength as well.
You may get the higher hardness it is fine but because of the coarse structures and the
fine needles they adversely affect the mechanical performance in general. So,
what if you want a very good combination of the high hardness and the good ductility
and or the improved properties at the surface then what is done near surface let us say this
is the component with a lot of coarse grains like this needle shaped structures. So, what we do
using the suitable FSP tool say this is the shoulder and this is the FSP tool pin
and this will be rotated, plunged, rotated, plunged and then traversed across the surface.
So, all these coarse constituents are broken down and they get refined. So, that is what we can see
these big needle shaped structural constituents they get refined up to certain depth depending
upon the tool pin depth below that the structure will remain unaffected. So, this is what is done
actually in case of the FSP this is the tool this is the shoulder and this is the pin.
Pin is plunged and rotated and so in one pass it will be covering like say in the top if you see
the pin is here the entire zone will be covered then the pin will be inserted here then another
zone will be covered that is how the number of passes are given. These passes most of the time
are the overlapping so that is why it happens in case of multi pass friction stir processing.
This multi pass friction stir processing helps to cover the entire area that is what we can see here
these are this is showing the number of like say 7 passes to modify the surface properties of this
alloy just for an example. And when the FSP is done you can see the structure gets completely
refined many times in case of work hard naval metals it helps in to increase the hardness as
well. But in case of the precipitation hardening metals precipitates get lost and we may get the
reduced hardness as well. So, this is what we can see there is a great similarity in these
structures, structure get refined. If we consider the transformation hardenable metals
then in that case not just the refinement will be happening but the soft phases like ferrite,
pearlite and ferrite they will form the hard constituents like martensite.
And the formation of the martensite will be resulting in the increased
hardness and increased load carrying capacity. So, this is the another solid state process so
if the FSP is not done properly then of course it can lead to the properties that we do not want.
This is another approach where the surface properties are modified by changing the
composition of near surface layers. So, say there are variety of layers we can introduce
number of constituents like we can introduce nitrogen for nitriding, for boronizing,
boron for boronizing, aluminized aluminum for aluminizing, silicon for siliconizing,
carbon for carburizing. This is a substrate so when we provide a particular element rich
environment at the surface at high temperature these diffused elements they can work in two ways.
They can form solid solution one or they can form some kind of the compound through the reactions
or they can help in forming certain kind of the phases which are of the
desired properties. So, that is what is done in carbon in carburizing carbon is enriched
in the low carbon steels and then that helps in forming the high carbon martensite.
In low carbon steels carbon content may be very low and may not be able to form the martensite.
So, carbon is enriched at the near surface layers followed by the
heat treatment that will be producing the high carbon martensite of the desired hardness. So,
most of the time the trend goes in like this where at the surface layer the concentration
of element will be high and on increasing depth from the surface the concentration will keep on
decreasing and below certain level there may not be any presence of the elements that we have
enriched at the near surface layers. So, substrate will remain in that case below
surface layers the component or the substrate may remain unaffected. This is the approach
what we do carburizing is one of the most common carburizing and nitriding are the two most common
surface modification approaches where in carburizing carbon content is enriched in
case of the low carbon steel components having say carbon less than 0.2%.
So, what is done the steel component is heated in the carbon rich environment
then carbon content is enhanced in the near surface layers through the pack carburizing,
gas carburizing etc or liquid carburizing and then it is cooled. Then after cooling again
the component is heated again in case of pack carburizing that is solid carburizing and then
after reheating to the austenitic state it is subjected to the quenching. So,
the first stage in case of the carburizing especially pack carburizing is the carbon
enrichment. Second stage is about the hardening heat treatment. So, reheating to the austenitic
state followed by rapid cooling that is quenching. So, that the whatever carbon has been
introduced at the surface layers that can be used to transform the austenite into the high
carbon martensite okay. If anything goes wrong here then our the desired set of properties
will not be achieved. This carburizing is done usually in the high temperature range of like say
800 to 1000 degree centigrade okay. So, this high temperature is another problem
because it will be modifying the substrate properties. Nitriding is another process which
is a low temperature process. Low temperature means because it is done around 500 to 600
degree centigrade in the ferritic state when the steel is in the ferritic condition. So,
what is done? Carburizing is done in the austenitic state while nitriding is done
in the ferritic state. So, it needs lower temperatures. What is done? Carbon sorry
nitrogen near surface layers is introduced at this temperature. So, near surface layers
get enriched with the nitrogen. Then in case of carbon steels it simply form iron nitrides
but iron nitrides may not be very effective in enhancing the surface properties. So,
what is done? We choose the steel in such a way for nitriding purpose that it is having the desired
alloying elements for forming the strong hard nitrides like chromium, vanadium,
tungsten these kind aluminium. So, these are the kind of elements you see steels having these
elements they will be interacting with the nitrogen effectively and forming their nitrides to
enhance the surface hardness and modify the surface properties okay.
So, but the important thing to be noted is like low this is the low temperature treatment
because it is being done 500 to 600 degree centigrade. Low temperature means it will
take long to diffuse the nitrogen up to the desired depth in the desired concentration
and that is why it is a very long process. It takes tens of hours and maybe even above the
100 hours process since it is being done at the low temperature okay. So, the good part here due
to the exposure at a low temperature is the substrate properties are not compromised because
things are below the at the low temperature and distortion tendency is also minimized cracking
tendency is absent okay. So, these are the elements which if they are present they will be helping a
lot in enhancing the effectiveness because they are a strong nitrate formers they form hard and
strong nitrides. This is what happens in case of the carbon steels when only iron nitride is formed
the increase in hardness is limited. But when we have nitriding steel having the desired chromium,
vanadium, aluminium kind of the and other molybdenum alloying elements then they form very
hard stable nitrides which are good actually for enhancing the surface properties and the hardness
okay. That is why we get very good effective very good and effective results when the steel is
having certain strong nitride forming elements. This is what happens when the nitrogen concentration
is enhanced at the surface nitrogen concentration is very high and that is what we will be seeing
one kind of the needle shaped nitrides gamma nitrides little below that. So, in both these
cases nitrogen will be forming certain kind of the compound and below this further below this
the nitrogen will be there will be another nitrogen diffused zone okay.
Now we will have case study related to the crankshaft. So, crankshafts are subject there
this is a very critical component in many engineering systems automobile is very common
because this crankshaft helps in converting the reciprocating motion in the rotary motion
and vice versa. These are subjected to the fatigue this is one.
So, for the fatigue conditions there should not be any kind of the stress concentration
there should not be defects because these will form the weak zones for easy nucleation of crack
their growth finally sudden fracture okay. So, these are the three stages nucleation,
growth and sudden fracture. If component is having stress raisers or the defects then
it does not require nucleation stage the cracks means the defect crack like defects will
start growing directly okay that is why the fatigue life is significantly less.
So, the crankshafts fail primarily due to the fatigue one and then especially these the failure
tendency extremely high when there are stress raisers. Stress raisers may be in form of defects,
discontinuities or machining irregularities in high stress areas or the assembly of the
crankshaft is not perfect and having the misalignment that will be causing the skewed
loading. Now we will be taking up one case study wherein the failure analysis of the
crankshaft will be taken up. So, the crankshaft of a four-cylinder engine failed prematurely
and crankshaft failed prematurely within the two years of surface which should have worked actually
more than 10 years. When investigation was conducted it was found like alloy steel
composition was there as specified. So, material is perfect okay design is also as per the
recommendations. So, there is no design issues as far as geometry and dimensions are concerned.
Visual examination showed that the component that the crankshaft shows worn out zones
means the wear was one of the mechanisms that led to the failure. The mechanical property study
suggested the lower hardness 700 as compared to the specified 740 HV and the microstructure showed
the normal structure at the core as expected but the very thin layer of the nitride zone
because the crankshaft was subjected to the nitriding and the thickness layer of the modified
zone was less than 20 micrometer than the specified 120 micrometer. So, the crankshaft surface was
modified to just 20 micrometer rather than specified 120 micrometer. So, the case hardening
was not proper the modification of the surface was not up to the desired depth. There was a and
the crankshaft after this modification were subjected to the grinding and it appears like
over grinding was done that there was a possibility for removal of the hardened layer and resulted in
the significant reduced modified depth of the crankshaft okay. So, here further investigation
was done and it was found like there was no defect whatsoever that can be attributed as a reason.
Only issue was there very thin layer of the modified zone surface modified zone okay.
There is a possibility of very thin layer that nitriding was done for very thin layer
up to lesser depth or during the grinding it was removed. Operation was done at a higher
speed than the normal one this was another reason which was identified.
There was no proper lubrication so the deficient lubrication was another reason.
So, if we summarize this so the hardness was low okay the case depth was less than the specified
the speed of operation was high means the relative speed was high and the lubrication was not proper.
So, all these conditions led to the wear of the crankshaft. Additionally the stereoscopy and
scanning electron microscopy suggested the presence of craters pits and abrasion marks
indicating the wear and comparison showed that lower hardness thinner hardened layer
as compared to that of the new one. So, these observations suggest that the crankshaft failed
due to the lower hardness poor maintenance in form of improper lubrication coupled with the
improper nitriding not up to the desired depth and improper grinding possibility of removal of
the nitrided layer during the grinding operation. So, here I will summarize this presentation.
In this presentation basically I have talked about the various approaches which are used for
the modifying the surface properties. There are three categories of the surface modification
properties where one is just heating and cooling is applied for modifying the surface properties
like flame hardening. Then we can also do only the controlled surface layer modification through the
controlled deformation up to certain depth using methods like burnishing, shot peening or FSP.
Then surface properties can also be enhanced by modifying the surface composition by introducing
suitable elements. It may be carbon for carburizing, nitrogen for nitriding or it can be
combination of carbon and nitrogen both for cyaniding like boronizing, aluminizing, silkenizing
there are various other processes and additionally we have also talked about one case study the
failure of crankshaft where it was found that the lower hardness lesser modified depth of
after nitriding and the absence of lubrication due to the improper maintenance and all these
led to the wear of the crankshaft that led to the failure. Thank you very much.
