How did MEDIEVAL SWORDS survive? What can their condition tell us? With @RoyalArmouriesMuseum

Ancient Edge
3 followers
35 Video Views·Dec 6, 2024
Discussing with the @RoyalArmouriesMuseum Curator of European Edged Weapons, Iason Tzouriadis, how ancient weapons survived, and how we can read their history from their condition.
So a couple of weeks ago I was at the Royal Armouries in Leeds with curator of European
edged weapons Yassin Tsouriadis. Now that gave me a fantastic opportunity to film some additional
material with him. The reason I was actually there is because of the launch of the second
batch of the Royal Armouries Windlass Matt Easton collaboration line of replicas and in fact I'm
going to stick a link down below to those here and also to the Royal Armouries socials. They've
their own YouTube channel and all sorts of socials you should follow so I'm going to stick a load of
links down there to that stuff. But what we're going to look at here in this video is an interesting
topic around the survival bias and survival conditions and the way that different ancient
weapons survived down to the present day. Now obviously on this channel I sometimes go to
museums and I sometimes go to auction houses and things like that and I'm often looking at
medieval sometimes even older weapons or indeed things like these Renaissance rapiers and side
swords and things like this from the 16th 17th centuries all the way through to 19th and 20th
centuries and we find many different weapons survive or don't survive. Why is that? And the
way that they do the patina, the corrosion, the pitting and what does this tell us? It's a really
really important thing. What does this tell us about how they were used and how they survived
to the present day? So I hope you enjoy this video with Yassin Tsourialis at the Royal Armouries.
Hi folks Matt Easton here at School of Gladiatoria and I'm here with Yassin at the Royal Armouries.
He's the curator of European-Edged Weapons and so he's the perfect person to be talking to you
about these three swords. Now you will hopefully by this point realise that these are the next
three swords that have been replicated for the second batch, the first half of the second batch
of the Royal Armouries Windlass Plus Me collaboration and there are going to be videos
about each of these really in-depth videos on the Royal Armouries YouTube channel which I will link
down below. But given that we've got these three swords here I thought this is a really rare and
valuable opportunity to talk about preservation and condition of swords, medieval and renaissance
swords and what we can establish, presume, assume or kind of work out about how they might have
survived and where they might have come from. So generally speaking where do medieval and
renaissance swords come from? I guess they can be found in armouries? Yeah yeah like they can
survive in personal or public collections, they can survive in
usually in people's attics, you'd be surprised by how many are privately owned, but more than
often these are found in muds or water deposits and we'll talk about this a bit later,
sometimes in churches in the context of England. So very simply I think we've kind of got
archaeological or kept by people, so basically kept by the earth or kept by people.
So what's interesting here is we've got two weapons, one that we know was kept in
an armoury for a very very long time, one that we can assume was kept in some type of
collection house or something, and one which might possibly have come from a church and we're going
to explain why we think that might be the case. But we also have swords in the museum here which
are Castillon swords which came out of a river, the river Dordogne at least we believe so,
and you've also got swords which came out of the ground as well haven't you? So let's talk about
those. So should we start with in a way the easiest one? So this is one of the Alexandria
swords isn't it? Thank you. So how were these kept? I mean it depends on the conditions of
the armoury and then we have examples because the purpose of this video is how do we look at
the surface of a sword and can this tell us anything? And I have to sort of perface this with
my knowledge on this is superficial, like I'm on this from a curatorial perspective,
I have a background in archaeology but I'm not a conservator. No. Which I think in the,
to get like the final opinion on this you need the help of a conservation team and we have a
very good conservation team here in the armoury. Sure. So you can see that the first thing that
you look on the surface of the blade and because we look, when we're talking about late medieval
early modern swords, they are made of a ferrous metal which means that it corrodes quite easily
if exposed to certain conditions and that creates a certain patination and certain marks on the
surface. In the case of the sword from the arsenal of Alexandria I think it's an interesting example
because you can see it has been preserved in such a good condition which means possibly a
dry environment, not much collected rust. There are some traces of clean rust here but we do not
know when that was. I have to check the records in the museum because this rust could have been
modern. So you see examples of this in many collections with several objects that have been
there for a couple of centuries. If there's proper conditions and they're not moved and they're aired
decently there's not much corrosion on the blade. There's only slight patination sometimes.
So what this tells me is it was either based on the conditions of the quillons as well.
This could have been hanging from the pommel, from the quillons but I do not think that it
laid somewhere for centuries on the same spot because usually that would leave marks on something
and we have examples of certain swords that have been touching something even for a couple of
decades and a horizontal line forms on them. And you know just moisture gathers there,
condensation, it's a cold morning condensation gathers in nooks and crannies and that's where
you get. And even a famous thing is a lot of Victorian swords that I actually get through my
hands have come out of wall displays either in stately homes or people's private homes or pubs
surprisingly. Pubs used to have guns and swords up on the walls when they were less worried about
crime and in those situations what you often get is one side of the blade is a completely
different colour to the other side and in the case of homes or pubs it's often because of
smoke in the air. So cigarette smoke, smoke from a fire, people's just sweat and breathing and
oxidisation and often the side which is against the wall will actually be better or would be
lighter. And it has to do with the material of the wall as well because it depends on if it's against
stone or wood you'd get or even fabric even worse you'd have like a very very different result.
So this tells me that this the conditions of this were mostly even and possibly not lying on the on
the blade for that long really. And again we can only speculate about this. Although we do know
we know for some of its life because in the 1880s there were photographs taken at the Arsenal of
Alexandria so this sword in the around the year 1420 if I remember correctly was passed into the
Alexandria Arsenal. We know that because very kindly they put inscriptions on lots of the swords
that came into that arsenal. So this was transferred or taken from the Kingdom of Cyprus.
We don't know if they were given, sold or won. But we know that they made it into
the Arsenal of Alexandria in the possibly in the early 15th century. It's an interesting
sword but to go back to the condition of these instead of I know we did the other video on the
on the history of this. But I do find this fascinating because it is very early it's in
a very good condition and for something that doesn't even have a handle it still remains in
a very good condition overall. I think that the pommel is possibly the one that has suffered the
most damage of it but it's interesting because you can see on the quillons and on the pommel you
can still see the file marks that were probably part of the making process. You can also see
abrasions which to me look like subsequent cleaning. So my interpretation as an
antique person would be that at some point this has had a light surface rust on it and now we know
So the Royal Armouries at the moment, we're in Leeds in the Royal Armouries but
traditionally the Tower of London held this collection and there was someone actually
employed there to basically sand all of the collection wasn't there at some point because
I know there are certain armours. Honestly I'm not entirely sure how that happened but it was
not uncommon. I think it was quite common with most big collections to do this and
interestingly there are armours that we know that were black from the smithy or even blades
that were only subsequently polished even though originally they would have been left black
because again it has to do with the perception of the public of blades and armour being shiny.
So basically this is in about as good a condition as you find medieval, in this case late 14th
century, swords because it has stayed in basically the same place since almost when it was made and
has been more or less looked after and probably cleaned. And even though there are stains of
cleaned rust and so on it doesn't have the patina caused by extreme rust or water.
Now if we move to the Cinque Terre, although this is a 16th century sword and that's late
14th century, I would say that this is in poorer condition in terms of pitting. Now pitting is a
result of rust so the rust essentially eats into the iron, converts the iron into corrosion and
then when that's cleaned off you're left with a pit. So we do have some areas of pitting up here
and light pitting in the rest of the blade. Now overall for a 16th century sword that's in good
condition but it has obviously been subjected to moisture at some point hasn't it? And mind you again that
this whole surface, the reason that it's in such a good quality, I mean the quillons look
incredible on this. There's no pitting, there's no signs of even
heavy clean rust. This would have been in a worse condition at some point if it was polished and
cleaned thoroughly but not in a way that it would disrupt the overall form and we know this because
of especially how the marks look. Yeah that's true, they're very crisp actually aren't they?
Yeah and so I think that the heavy pitting was towards the tip here and you can see this if you
turn around Matt as well on this side on here. So again like from an initial point I would say that
this was laid down on something and or something was on top of it. Can I tell you my guess?
So this is based on lots of 18th and 19th century antiques that come through my hands so I'm going
to grab the replica at this point and I'm going to grab the scabbard. So royal navy swords often
exhibit very similar corrosion to this and the reason is because you have a metal shape and
then a leather or wood wooden leather scabbard and so the moisture especially if they're stood
on the ground comes up here and gathers around here and moisture runs down here and it stops
and so with royal navy swords that have corrosion it's often all around this region here so if we
look at the Cinque Terre we've got corrosion all around there on that side and all around there
on that side so I might not be correct but I think there's a good chance that this had a metal shape
that came up about that high and that's where the moisture. So you're saying that it gathered above
the shape? Yes just above the shape because it's exactly what you see on leather scabbards.
The only thing I would say about this that is very interesting like the only thing I would expect
with this would be more even and something more horizontal. For me this is puzzling because
if we hold it you can see that one of the sides here has been corroded on one side. Sort of eaten
very heavily as well compared to the other side yeah and you can see it here yeah and I find this
puzzling because even with my initial suggestion that this would be laid onto something or
something was on it this does not this justify the erosion on this side yes but this one is a
bit weirder yeah and so if we only had the back side I would say this was laid down on somewhere
or laid against a wall because you know when something is displayed yes often it's not like
it usually is on display like this yeah it was tilted but again we do not have damage on the tip
on this yeah and the other thing to consider is having seen private collections of various people
sure modern collectors might take care more of their objects but if you go to historical
private collections there are swords and objects one on top of the other yeah yeah so when I mean
that something was on top of it I'm talking about somebody's collection that swords swords swords
paperweights yeah yeah I mean I won't name the place but I know one old family home which is
used as a as a wedding venue now but they have a good collection of edged weapons up on the wall
in a room where the doors are left open and where a lot of condensation gathers on them so these
poor these poor swords and knives are very rusty on one side and where the condensation gathers
but overall I would say that this has not been mistreated because we get way worse examples of
as you said 19th century swords so overall this has been looked after I do not remember when it
entered the collection so it might be well the case that this was historically part of the of
the Royal Armouries collection but I do not remember one one final thing about this I think
it's interesting that the pitting's on the blade but as you mentioned not really much on the guard
that could be for a few reasons it could be because of the relative carbon content and perhaps
in the conditions this was in maybe that the sort of higher carbon steel blade attracted rust more
than the probably iron guard did I the other the other thing is maybe the scabbard I was going to
say like maybe maybe your your your speculation there might be because of that and and finally
again this is a bit weirder like we have a heavily damaged well not heavily like a slightly damaged
handle with the plates of the
having been chipped away so this is probably horn this thing I do not know I do not even know
the conditions in which horn deteriorates unfortunately but I bet you that in a museum
context a conservation team will tell you if this this was caused by condensation if it was caused
by uh force and so on because even frost frost even probably could be also something yeah there's
the the other thing to consider is that a lot of the damage on swords we'll see this in the
third sword yeah um is we we get often on blades several nicks of um in a variety of shapes and
sizes um there might be very small as if he has as if he has received a different blade yeah or
it might be larger yeah um I've heard more than often that this has is a result of blade and blade
combat combat yeah that's because it's glamorous and people want to um yeah but I think even when
something is displayed people wanted to be this but the the truth is we cannot know it might be
unfortunately curator might have dropped the object well yeah we're not saying this happens
nowadays yeah accidents happen accidents do happen though and that's what we have insurance for
but um no like all jokes aside now we're very careful with these things but the the procedures
in the past and I mean imagine that a lot of these things were part of private public collections for
centuries so a hundred years ago uh the caretaker or curator of a collection might have been a bit
more cavalier about this and we have examples of famous American curators wearing armor and
British curators wearing armors holding the swords and so on and so on um and if we move now to the
third sword yeah so I thought before we look at because the third sword's really interesting in
terms of its possible preservation let's just briefly mention um archaeologically found so
river versus ground found so we don't have an example here to show and maybe we could look at
that in in the future when we get together again um but generally speaking swords which are found
in the ground as far as I've seen are the worst condition swords that you're going to find um so
if you look at you know anglo-saxon frankish graves where they've been buried you know pre-Christian
where they've been buried with a sword or francisco or a shield it's going to be a corroded mess
because it's it's a bunch of different uh uh bio conditions plus plus humidity yeah
pressing pressing against everything constantly so you get the heavy pitting yeah across the
surface that that takes away a lot of material even on the ground like and and occasionally
it might rub against something for for decades yeah before you settle somewhere and a lot of
what you get left although it might look in the shape of a spear or a sword isn't technically
any more iron it's been replaced by the corrosion product so those generally speaking are the worst
condition but they're still amazingly informative so you know if you find something that's come out
of an anglo-saxon grave for example it will still have its non-ferrous hilt components if it has
them if they're like gold or silver if it's organic material it will be gone so this usually
sometimes you might get remains but usually the grip and the scabbard are gone you might only get
fragments and the iron blade is essentially corrosion product but x-rays can sometimes
give you a better idea of what the blade looked like for example pattern welding before the
water found swords can vary a lot okay so we've got at one end you've got the mary rose
where the salt water basically dissolved almost everything made of iron but at the other end
you've got the cast ion swords i mean like but we're not we do not entirely know the conditions
of no or how they were preserved like and if they even were per se water found and things
no but i would say then we could say the river thames yeah we've got some river thames and
daggers and so on yeah um and i think the visually the characteristic uh the most characteristic
thing about river river and uh water finds is the black patina you get for for fresh water
yeah so you get like on um on them um so just just sorry to cut in but just one thing to make clear
the sword isn't for the most part preserved because it's just sitting in water it's preserved
because it's in the mud of the riverbank yeah so that's what there are certain rivers and thankfully
the river thames is one of them and it seems that certain rivers in france as well are very good at
preserving iron because they are essentially anaerobic they you know the the the sort of
convergence of of factors in that mud stops them from being completely rusted away
unfortunately salt water um you know particularly where the mary rose is found for example
where you've got a lot of movement as well so not only is the thing in the water being
corroded by salt water but it's also being tossed and turned around by the by the tides and
everything else is just very very destructive so from the from the mary rose we only have
despite the fact we have something like i don't know a hundred and something
bollock dagger hilts and we've got like about a hundred long bows we've only got i think about
five swords remaining or bits like traces of five and and and it's it's interesting to sort of
because you mentioned the castilian swords and as as a group it has been debated as to how precisely
they were preserved historically it's so that they were in a barrel or barrels and so on and
then that was in the mud yeah the pause of the river but again that would preserve something
better than being exposed yes uh directly into everything in the movement yeah yeah but we're
not entirely sure this one is it's a bit of um not an oddity but we can speculate about its
conditions and we had a very nice discussion again always on a speculative level as to what
caused this because there's there is pitting on it um spotted which is again uh these are the
remnants of previous now now removed rust anyway um especially on one of the two sides and we will
go into it later i think a bit more yeah so i have to say with my sort of 19th century is an 18th
century hat on um if we turn to the well either side really the pitting that we've got on here
considering this is a sword from the late 15th possibly early 16th century is really not that
bad i see swords from the 19th century with worse pitting than this just because they've been sat in
someone's shed so however this was kept and preserved it wasn't that bad i mean it was
in fact it's mild enough that we can still see engraved decoration which is under that yeah
which is really lightly done on the ricasso um as we spoke in the previous video this
is it is possible that is linked to a tradition that was popular in england
and it has to do with the deposit of armaments in churches yeah um the link is uh both direct
because of the style that we can say uh with some confidence that this is likely english um
but uh also because of its proximity in form to the westminster abbey sword
that we know that it was a church deposit um the the patina on it um also sort of
can conform to that idea that this was um uh located or deposited in also in a church
environment at some point in its life we do not know unfortunately we do not know the maker the
owner or the conditions but we can only speculate um but if we suppose that this was uh hanging
and the and the beams above a certain grave or against especially against the stone of a humid
church uh for a couple of centuries i think this is very consistent or on the wall on the wall yeah
this is very consistent with us and and uh swords and helmets uh above graves or cenotaphs um it's
a practice that uh is even observed in uh in english churches even to the present day in
certain in certain cases we had a very good we have a very good display of funerary um
achievements and helmets especially um here in the royal armories in leeds but
you we do have other known examples and it's a practice that it was very popular in england and
i do not think it was made with any consistency and again i might be wrong in this but i don't
think so i think i think it's england has the the most distinct tradition for this and it was so
well established that even as early as the black princes too there were things being specifically
made or altered purely for that purpose they didn't just take the person's helmet and the
person's sword and put them above or in or around the tomb in some cases they got a helmet out of
the armory and had a crest made for it specifically for that occasion um and for example the black
prince's gauntlets we think probably were just made as funeral yeah there's no sign and we have
many helmets uh modified or specifically made yes for that or adapted and we see yeah we see 15th
century helmets old 15th century helmets adapted in the 16th century to be used as a funeral
monument so this might be one of those and what are the clues and and uh i mean you pointed
something earlier which i really like as an idea i don't know how how true that is but i i liked the
the discussion we had about the heavy sort of hitting hitting on the one side only yes um and
it sort of agrees to examples like this is from the continent uh this might be a suggestion that
this was not initially something to hang over to but to be inside one and pressing against the
fabric and sort of a decomposing body uh causing this one side and then maybe removed i mean so we
have examples from italy for example and spain yeah and spain yes quite right yes this is very
famous yeah um so spain and italy sometimes swords were actually the person was fully clothed but
they were wearing their sword belt and their sword and later on in the 19th century for the most part
the tombs were opened up um for various various reasons and um they the sword was in there but
clearly the sword is very corroded on one side where it was against the person's body yeah so
like it is possible this this i don't know like without morbid imagination we can easily see this
happening but equally the heavy pitting on one side could have been because it was hanging against
something it could have been because it was left you know even even on a church context or
actual context against something here pressing against something where condensation was gathering
um yeah like an interesting contrast uh in this object much like the cinque derby we can see this
even more is that the condition of the quillons and the pommel are quite different to that of the
blade and as you pointed out earlier that might be because of the different ferric content and
of of these but it might also be because the person who cleaned the sword paid more attention
to the blade because it's an easier surface rather than going inside the the cavity of the wheel and
cleaning this more or if they want to create sort of this distinction in the in the form we or it
was in a scabbard for part of again or it was in scabbard yeah like again since you said this as
well um this would equally sort of feed into that narrative and we have examples of church swords
hanging like in the scabbard yeah from belts absolutely um uh from from uh wooden beams um
i almost from period art i almost think that it was probably more common that they were all
originally in their scabbards yeah um but the scabbards just fell apart and decomposed so just
in this case though the the the pommel and what i i'm not entirely sure is because about this is
because the the pommel and the quillons are even more um eroded than the blade itself um
which really puzzles me because okay like we can say that the water gathered inside the wheel
um concentrated and sat here but i'm not sure and the grip's gone so yeah so so i mean i i would
again with my sort of 19th century sword hat on i have a lot of swords come through my hands where
actually the blade's in good condition because it's in its cavity and the hilt is covered in
rust you know so yeah that would be that would be my if i had to put my money on something my
money would be that it would lived a lot of its time in the scabbard and this just developed a
lot of moisture it's possible yeah and the handle fell apart and it got it rotted from inside from
the wood eaten by various little you know woodworm or moths and it is something that is also worth
mentioning with these two swords here that uh we have a lot of swords uh a bit earlier from
the 15th century and before but the organic material is gone yes yeah and and and that
is a especially in the cases where this is a find because then the organic thing is the first that
goes like it's eaten even even faster um and it's interesting to uh also juxtapose objects such as
these to bronze age swords yeah which are there are finds there because they have no ferric content
bronze does not rust so it preserves perfectly in the shape unless it's bent it's perfectly there
that's one of the wonderful things about about bronze age swords yeah yeah well that's been
fantastic i hope that has been um interesting so i mean you know just to summarize medieval
and renaissance swords tend to be in the best condition when they have been stored in an armory
or a private collection or a house or sometimes a church but church swords tend to be in worse
condition because they haven't been looked after as well usually they're high up in the rafters
or on a wall and churches are not heated and that kind of stuff and then the poorest condition
swords are usually ground found archaeological swords or sea found swords but river found
swords as found in the Thames or possibly the Dordogne can be actually in surprisingly good
condition even to the point where they sometimes even still have their grips as well the organic
material and um i think uh well one of the one of the Castillon swords here has remnants of the
wood remaining on the grip doesn't have the two-hander um and i think one or two of the
others have remnants of leather and or wood around the base of the blade as well i think
but anyway um Yasin thank you so much um it's great being here with these original
things that you know not many people get to handle so i feel hugely privileged i hope it's been
interesting to you thank you Yasin and i hope you'll be back on the channel for something else
in the future maybe we can um well maybe you've got some special requests uh what would you like
to see or hear um Yasin talk more about here but don't forget you can get more of him and
his colleagues on the Royal Armouries YouTube channel which will be linked down below thanks
a lot for watching thank you Yasin thank you Matt see you back soon cheers folks thanks for watching
we've got extra videos on Patreon please give our Facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't
already cheers folks
