were ancient swords SHORT!?

Ancient Edge
3 followers
Sep 15, 2025
We often label ancient swords as short swords - we say that the Roman Gladius was a short sword, or the Xiphos was a short sword... but is this really accurate?
Are ancient swords actually short? We very commonly describe ancient swords as being
short swords. We say the Roman Gladius was a short sword or the Xiphos was a short sword.
However this isn't quite right. Typically when we're talking about sword lengths being a long
sword or a short sword we're coming at it from a medieval perspective and throwing that back
onto an ancient weapon. We say the Roman Gladius is a short sword because in comparison to a
bastard sword or a hand and a half sword or a great sword it is a shorter sword. However in
that period the Gladius is by no means a short sword it's just a sword. Now that's not to say
that we don't see short swords in the ancient period when in contrast to other more standard
length swords in the period. But to categorize all ancient swords like the ancient Greek Xiphos,
the Koppas or the Roman Gladius as a short sword isn't quite right because we're coming at it from
a lens from another period 1,500 years later. I have three examples here of ancient swords. I have
probably more it's classified as a Koppas, something more resembling a Falcata and a shorter style
ancient Greek Xiphos. To classify the Koppas here as a short sword in the period would not be quite
accurate. However to classify this as a shorter sword or a short sword in the period would be a
bit more accurate. This is a far shorter Xiphos. This is famously called a Spartan or a Theban
Xiphos. This is just an evolutionary path that we see becoming more popular as we get to the later
5th century BC where we see otherwise decently long swords, Xiphos maybe this long in the
archaic period, start to turn into even kitchen knife sized blades coming into the 300s and late
400s. We do see short swords that very much should be classified as short swords in the period.
However to classify a Koppas as a short sword really isn't quite right. This is just a perfectly
well-length sword for the period. Now it is true that we start to run into some historical issues
when we make very long weapons in the early Iron Age in the sense that they have a tendency to bend
and we're actually told of this, I believe it's a Scythian source so don't quote me there, it's a
source basically of these guys who have longer swords and they're having to use their feet to
straighten them again. So we do see that longer swords could be potentially problematic in this
period of metallurgy where they aren't maybe tempered properly and they have a little bit of
bend, they don't spring as much. However again that's not to say that these swords were short
swords, they are just standard length swords. Now yes if you contrast that to a very historically
accurate long sword, definitely not Lord of the Rings replica wallhanger, then you will see a
difference in length. Obviously this is a far longer sword but this is a far later period and
this is designed for a far different use. This wasn't the sword length that was desired in the
ancient period, it's not really favourable, it's actually quite problematic for very up-close
shield wall manoeuvring warfare. This is great for half-swording, this is great for knightly duels,
this is great for the medieval battlefield, and this was designed for the medieval battlefield,
whereas this was designed for the ancient battlefield. And this is perhaps a great
example of how short swords did certainly exist in the ancient world, actually sort of evolving
to a short sword. We typically think of swords evolving from shorter to longer as the periods go.
We do see short swords again, we even see swords shorter than this in the period as well.
But to contrast and label all ancient swords as being a short sword or the gladiators being a
short sword isn't right, because for their period they are not short swords, they are pretty standard
length swords. So that was my pedantic video on sword terminology in the ancient world. I hope
that you enjoyed that, I just thought I'd make a little video on that because it's something that
I think people often confuse. Thanks very much to our channel members for supporting the channel,
truly does mean a lot. If you yourself would like to support the channel more, if you like what I
do here then please consider checking out Patreon or YouTube memberships, and if you can't afford
to do that or just don't want to do that, absolutely no worries at all, just liking,
subscribing, and sharing these videos is a really great help. So thanks very much,
and I'll hopefully catch you in the next one.
