What is a HALF BASKET HILT sword and what is it FOR?

Rune Slicer
2 followers
1 Video View·May 1, 2026
Looking at HALF BASKET hilted swords from the British Isles and beyond, and asking WHY DID THEY EXIST?
Basket hilted swords offer fantastic hand protection and were used by a few specific
nationalities quite famously between the 16th century and the 19th century. In fact they're
even used for parade purposes today. Particularly notable are the British, that is the English,
Scottish, Welsh and Irish, and in the British Isles basket hilts were particularly popular.
And a basket hilt, it completely encloses the hand. We've looked at these in a lot of previous
videos. But what is a half basket hilt? Well in this video we're going to be looking at a couple
and why they're like that. Hi folks, Matt Heaton here, scholar gladiator and eastern antique arms.
Now I'm very lucky in my profession as an antique arms dealer I get to handle, buy and sell and own
lots of wonderful antique weapons. Now recently I have obtained a couple of swords relating to the
era of the Jacobite uprisings in the 17th, in the 1700s rather, in the early to mid-18th century,
between the 1710s particularly and the 1740s. Now for anyone who doesn't know, maybe we'll
do a deep dive on this in the future, but essentially the the Jacobite uprisings are
primarily Catholic uprising against primarily Protestant establishment in the British Isles,
mostly focused in Scotland, but it went beyond that as well and expanded obviously to Ireland
and even abroad in some cases, further afield. But really it was to do with a royal challenge,
a royal dynastic challenge, because the monarchies of England and Scotland since the time of the
Stuarts, and let's be honest going all the way back to the Anglo-Saxon period, the monarchies
of England and Scotland and in some cases Wales and Ireland as well, were inextricably
intertwined and it was a very complicated political situation. Now without going too
much further into it, just to say the Jacobite uprisings, contrary to popular belief, are not
simply a matter of England versus Scotland, in fact Scots of various types fought on both sides,
in some cases English fought on both sides and in many cases Irish fought on both sides as well,
so it was a very complicated situation. But nevertheless at the end of this period in 1746
we start to get a period widely known as the Highland Clearances and during that period
many basket-hilted swords or weapons in general were forbidden from being owned and carried and
kept, we'll come back to that later in the video, including even Highland Targes, so Highland Targes
around shields were made very widely in the 1740s but pretty much stopped being made in 1746. Anyway
the typical type of basket-hilted sword that we see here, and this is one of the middle of the
1700s from Scotland, so this is a Scottish basket-hilted sword, are essentially symmetrical.
You will notice that the hilt on one side has all the same bars and decoration and enclosure
as it has on the other side. Now one of the great benefits of this is you can be left-handed,
okay, we'll come back to this point a little bit more later in the video, but fundamentally this
is a symmetrical hilt. Now the advantage of a symmetrical hilt is obviously it protects the
outside of the hand as much as it protects the inside of the hand, great amount of hand protection,
and it gives a certain amount of symmetry and balance to the sword. Now what do I mean by that?
Well every sword has an edge to cut with, some of them have two edges. Now when we're cutting with
the sword there is a natural motion through the air of the sword moving and if a sword is more
weighted on one side or the other it can, doesn't always, depends on the grip and how you hold it
and how you move it, but it can lead to slightly twisting or overbalancing in one direction and
meaning that when you cut you don't cut with a true edge and obviously if the edge is not pointing
in exactly the right direction at 90 degrees to the thing you're hitting if it's 95 degrees off
one way or the other then it's going to foul cut and lead to a poor cut. This was a topic which
really fascinated military strategists in the 19th century when they found that lots of cavalry,
not just in Britain but in places like America and France and Spain and Italy, had problems
actually cutting the targets they were aiming at and a lot of this was to do with poor swordsmanship
training but a lot of it was to do with poor edge alignment and this led to certain sword
designers trying to build hilts which balanced more equally on either side. So the typical type
of highland basket hilt or indeed various other basket hilts and back swords that went before and
after this are equi-balanced as it's sometimes termed, that is they equally balanced on left
and right, can be used by a left or right hander and they don't theoretically twist in the hand
when you use them. So you might think therefore that an equally balanced on left and right hilt
was the natural form of the basket hilt, that's how it started out and somehow it was corrupted
or devolved from that point to lead to an asymmetrical hilt. Well that would be the opposite
of the truth and sometimes theory doesn't marry up with what we actually find in history and if
we look at the earliest forms of the proto-basket, the beginnings of the basket hilt, just in the
British Isles but you could extrapolate this to southern Germany or parts of Italy or even Spain,
what we see in the late medieval period is we start to see the start of the very beginnings,
the very sort of genesis of the beginnings of what became a basket hilt and here is an example.
So in the Tudor period or end of the 15th century, beginning of the 16th century, we start to see
obviously we've already got knuckle bows, they'd been around for a little while, but we start to
get side bows and obviously in Germany we've got the nagel, sometimes a side shell on things like
messer, this is the British equivalent of that. Now this is, while you could call this a falchion
or a messer to all intents and purposes, we could also call it a short back sword. It's a single
edged straight sword, almost straight sword, pretty much straight, but it has a side bar. Now
it shouldn't take too much imagination to realise that when we've got a front bar and a side bar we
could add another bar on here, but they didn't, interestingly. They treated the outside of the
hand and the inside of the hand differently and that is because a fist is not symmetrical. Most
of the hand projects on the, for a right-handed person, on the right side and you've only really
got the thumb and the tips of the fingers on the left side. That being the case, that means that
you don't need as much hilt projecting on the inside as you do on the outside. Moreover, when
you're actually using this in swordsmanship, when you're, for example, holding it in the right hand,
it's the right hand side here which is most exposed and if you defend on the inside line here,
if the other person's right-handed, your left hand side of your hand is actually hidden behind the
sword as you turn it to guard the inside line. So for multiple reasons to do with the shape of the
hand but also the nature of swordsmanship and the fact that swordsmanship is asymmetrical by nature,
most people don't need as much hilt projecting on the left-hand side as they do on the right.
This being the case, therefore, we find that swords develop for more protection on the right-hand side
for right-handed swords, that is, be the opposite for left-handed, but they develop more protection
on the dominant or right-handed side of the sword than they do on the left. And it's not just swords,
we even see it on things like left-hand daggers or parrying daggers where the ring, and that side
ring is something we often find on swords as well, is only on one side, not on both.
And so we come to the first true basket hilts. Now, as I mentioned, there are other parts of
Europe where they develop basket hilts, for example, southern Germany and Austria,
also Italy, particularly up towards Venice. However, in the British Isles, we have a very
early type of basket hilt which already starts to appear in 1520, 1530, this kind of period,
and by about 1540 it looks like this. Now, this is one of the replicas from the Windlass Royal
Armouries line, which I obviously oversee and work with, and this is a pretty true-to-form
replica. This is from the next batch that's being released, incidentally. This is a basket hilt,
early basket hilt, so we're talking about the time of Henry VIII, around 1540 thereabouts.
So, similar time to when the Mary rose, his flagship sunk, as it happens with one of these
basket hilts on. In fact, the example that we replicated from the Royal Armouries was not from
the Mary rose, but it's very similar to the Mary rose sword. It's actually bigger than the Mary
rose sword, so it's kind of cooler in that way, I think. But you'll notice it's not a symmetrical
hilt. Most of the protection is on the outside. We do have protection on the inside to protect
the thumb and the tip of the fingers, but it's a lot less than the outside, so it's an asymmetrical
basket. And this, if we discount, well, I mean, we could include or discount the earlier sort of
hangers and falchions which have side bars, but this is what most people would agree is definitely
a basket hilt by this point, and it's asymmetrical. So the earliest basket hilts were asymmetrical,
like this. And as an aside, this also carries over into forms of rapier and sidesword hilt as well,
where the protection on one side is made of a different assemblage of bars and a different
style of protection on the dominant side compared to the offside. So now we come back to the 18th
century, and by this period, the basket hilted sword is one of the standard military swords
in the British Isles. And in fact, across a lot of Europe, there are other types of hilts like
walloon hilts, there's various types of swept hilt which have been in use, and so on so forth, and,
you know, sabre hilts and everything else. But basket hilts were very popular in 17th and 18th
century Britain. Oliver Cromwell had a form of basket hilt known as a mortuary hilted sword,
maybe we'll do a deep dive on those in a future video. But basket hilts were very common, and many
of them were symmetrical. However, by the time we get to the 1730s, 1740s, we start to see asymmetrical,
that is, half basket hilts, make a little bit of a comeback. So the first example we're going to
look at here is this brass basket hilted sword here. Quite an enigmatic backsword as it happens,
it has a blunt back here, has a false edge up towards the tip, primarily a straight, long,
single-edged cutting sword. So this is a backsword, now there is an almost identical example in the
Royal Armouries, dated to around 1742, so just before Culloden era, and this is possibly associated
with the king's own dragoons, okay? Now I won't go into the research of why that's the case,
but essentially it boils down to the fact that it's got a brass hilt. And a brass basket hilt
is quite unusual, usually basket hilts, for strength reasons, are iron or steel, but they
can be made of brass in certain circumstances. So this is possibly a backsword, a cavalry sword,
of the king's own dragoons, dating to about 1742, and you will notice that it has much more guard
on one side than the other. Now you might say, okay Matt, but you've just said that that was
completely normal in the Tudor and going all the way through to the Elizabethan period, and yes,
that's true. However, in the 17th and most of the 18th centuries, symmetrical basket hilts,
like this Andrea Ferrara bladed example here, this Scottish basket hilt, I would say were
numerically slightly more common. Or at least, well we'll come back to that, there's a little
detail, there's a caveat to add. So, however, you will notice that this possibly king's own
version has an open side here. Okay, now we're going to look at another sword before we go into
why. So this is another sword, almost identical in date, this is a much bigger sword, a whopping
great broadsword blade on it. This has a steel hilt, and you will notice again it's open on the
inside. So open on the inside, obviously protected at the front with the knuckle bow and slightly
widened bar there, and then completely protected on the outside. So these are actually following,
although they're very different hilt designs, they're from exactly the same period, they're both
official British government heavy cavalry swords, that's probably Irish dragoons,
that's probably king's own dragoons, they're both open on the inside. So why would you want to do
that? So there's a few possible reasons. So one of them is weight, and you could also say cost.
Okay, so you use less material, but less material also equals less weight, by not having the guard
section on the inside line. And we've already described that you don't need it so much on the
inside line as on the outside line, especially arguably on horseback as well, because on
horseback, and these are both dragoon swords, you're using the sword here on this side mostly.
If you are fighting across that side, you tend to do it with a hanging guard, which again brings that
to the outside here. Sometimes you're going to end up with the inside of the hand exposed to an enemy
horseman on that side, but probably statistically not as much as on this side. So weight, necessity,
you don't really need it so much here. Cost, I think is less important because a bit of steel
doesn't cost very much. But very importantly, wearing. Okay, so when you're, remember most of
your time when, especially in the 18th century, when you're riding around on a horse, most of your
time is spent riding, scouting, all of this kind of stuff, it's not necessarily spent sword in hand
or engaging sword against sword. So wearing the sword is what you mostly do, the sword spends most
of its time in its scabbard, and wearing a sword that's banging against your side on horseback
is going to be far less annoying when you don't have a big basket, where's the basket, oh there it is,
sticking out on the inside line here. So easier to wear, flatter to the body, more comfortable,
less weight. Now it does create a problem of overbalancing as I described, so potentially,
because we've got a heavier guard on that side, the grip is going to tend to turn in the hand
when you cut. As it so happens, the way that they've counterbalanced that with this particular
sword, is this grip is quite flat, so rather than being cylindrical, it's actually quite an ovoid
section, so you can feel the edge alignment in your hand, and actually I don't feel any
likelihood of that turning in my hand when I move it at all, because it's quite flat in the hand.
With the other one, I think it's similar, it's a relatively, yeah, it's a relatively flat grip,
it's much thinner that way than it is that way, so you can feel the edge alignment pretty good,
and it doesn't really make any difference. But there is one final advantage to having
this open section on the inside, and it's actually related to the fact that I mentioned
that a lot of basket helts look symmetrical but actually aren't, so if we go to this standard
basket helt here which looks the same on both sides, some dragoon swords, dragoons being
cavalry, have a ring or loop or open section on the inside line here, and that gives us an
important clue, because that's to put the reins of the horse through. Why would you want to do that?
Well normally you have a sword in one hand and you have your reins of your horse in the other hand,
okay, but sometimes you want to shoot one of your pistols, okay, and in that case you have to,
you don't want to lose the reins or drop them down and have to fumble around and find them again,
so you take the reins, you put them into your sword hand, so you hold the reins in the sword
hand, you pull the pistol out, you fire the pistol, put it back in the holster on the saddle,
saddle boat, and then you take the reins out again. So it's a way of being able to access
your hand and grip things and do things with this hand through a loop in the hilt. So although
they're sort of symmetrical helts, they're actually not because they have this open ring on the inside.
Now you will notice you don't need to do that if you have a completely missing inner section. It
means that you can use your hand on the inside line here, whether you're using it for the reins
of the horse or to cock the hammer on the pistol to shoot it. So simply to say that there are many
potential reasons why you might want to have a half basket hilt instead of a full basket hilt,
and I think I've covered most of those reasons here, but there is a twist to this story and that
twist takes us back to the Battle of Culloden and the Jacobite Uprising. So on paper these
swords carried by government cavalry were used against Highlanders and people from various
bits of Scotland in fact carrying basket hilts like this, but it's not always as clean cut as
that when we come to swords or indeed history or politics, because actually this sword which on
is a British government sword or it's kind of loyalist or whatever you want to call it,
this actually came from a Perthshire family who'd been involved in the uprisings and it came with
something else and it had been with this other thing since those uprisings, it came with this.
So although this was a government sword somehow it probably ended up in the hands of a Highlander
in the Jacobite forces carrying a targe as well. So I hope some of you learned something today,
we've looked at half basket hilts, why they existed in various forms and the fact that they
didn't suddenly appear, they had been around since the very beginning. There are many reasons
why with any kind of basket hilt you don't necessarily want it to be the same on both
sides. Anyway thanks a lot for watching, I have been Matt Easton, will of course continue to be,
and I'll see you back on the channel really soon for another video. Cheers folks! Thanks for
watching, we've got extra videos on Patreon, please give our Facebook a like and subscribe
if you haven't already. Cheers folks!
