The Bauernwehr: Up and Close With a 16th Century Peasant's Sidearm. Or Tool. Or both?

Ancient Edge
3 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
In today's video, we go for an in-depth examination of an original 16th-century Bauernwehr from my private collection. We analyze its unique features and compare this specimen to established examples in historical literature.
oh hello I didn't see you there well welcome you're in time for something
quite interesting I think you'll have noticed I'm not in my usual environment
the background is quite different I'm in a hotel I'm figuring out a whole bunch
of stuff related to housing so you don't need to know but I'll tell you we've had
big renovation issues our contractor went bankrupt we have a whole big
problem so now I'm back in the Netherlands in a hotel figuring out how
to move on with the house but I figured in the meantime while I was here I'd
show you a piece I got quite some time ago but I just got to get my hands on
now when I came back to the Netherlands for this I'm having to wear
non-scientifically approved Dexter's mom gloves and this is because I don't I
forgot to bring or I don't have with me the usual ones I use but I had these at
hand so these were easy to find so I have these and what I'm going to show
you is this I'll try and get a good angle of it but this is a Bowen bear
essentially we've talked about it in a few previous videos I've measured some
with Julian in the museums in the people of the Swiss National Museum he's
measured a few more so he has quite some experience with these and I'm lucky
enough that knowing Julian and knowing James Elmsley I have quite a decent
network of people who are quite into this kind of weapon and know quite a bit
about them so this one I was lucky enough to pick up for sale it was part
of a collection that was being dispersed I suppose I don't know though whose it
was I don't have any information on its provenance in terms of well neither
archaeological nor collector wise so the only information I have is kind of
morphological important detail so shape and features of the Bowen bear so if you
haven't if I'm wearing gloves by the way because well this is considerably older
than most of the pieces I have in my collection in general so I want to treat
it a bit more carefully but also because while I have the chance to handle it now
it's gonna go in storage for a while as I figure out my home renovation issues
so I don't want to risk leaving some trace on it and then you know putting it
away for six months or something and then coming back to it all rusted so if
I had it constantly under supervision I would be maybe a little more willing to
touch it without gloves as well probably shouldn't though but you get what I mean
anyway I had a chat with James about this so I'm gonna put James on the spot
here it's not an official identification or anything so he has no
responsibility for it but let's say the general vibe looking at pictures looking
at its features looking at close-ups says that this is probably some kind of
a late Bowen bear so likely 16th century is I think James used the words probably
16th century so we're going to look at it in quite a bit more detail close-ups
and we're also going to see some damage that was done to it not so much by the
passing of time and centuries but by attempts to clean it which when we talk
about being careful with cleaning it's important for all objects of course but
it's more important probably for kind of presumably semi archaeological finds
rather than you know late 19th century briquette for instance because what you
remove from something old really old or something of which you don't have any
provenance at all can really kind of delete any chance of getting to know
more about the object so anyway what is about in there check out Julian's videos
because he I think dives deep into them but essentially they're a middle way
between a knife and weapon that was used by late medieval peasants or citizens or
just general people you would have had usually fairly strict laws in terms of
length size and type of blades you could have carried for example with you if not
for like war like purposes and a way to kind of bypass these rules perhaps but
also if you didn't expect to be using a weapon like you weren't a mercenary or
a soldier you would want to have something that was useful both as a tool
so you could cut stuff with it and use it but also strong enough and big enough
that in if need be could be used as a weapon normally what kind of defines
this mixed use is the presence of a knuckle so this would be that protruding
section it has various different shapes and everything but it essentially acts
as a very minimalistic hand protection so the presence of a knuckle usually is
the sign of this being kind of one of these hybrid weapon slash tools rather
than a pure knife like just a random knife that was used of course you could
use a knife in in a pinch anyway but let's say this is a kind of more
specialized type of object they come in a whole bunch of different sizes shapes
there's a lot of variety and there's a lot of overlap to over time so I'm sure
there are ways to determine specific blade shapes and kind of time them a
little but as far as my understanding has been seeing a bunch of them mostly
literature but a few alive as well a lot of the characteristics kind of ebb and
flow over time so you may see similar blade shapes going from the 15th
century all the way to the end of the 16th for example to give an idea one
thing what we'll talk about it more but one characteristic I think that perhaps
points to this being a later one is the presence of two rivets here at the
pommel cap these seem to be present in more later examples rather than the
the older ones but yeah this is how it looks in hand let's say so it's
essentially what you would see on a big kitchen knife today with the difference
of the knuckle as I mentioned so anyway let's look at some close-ups and kind of
dive through a little bit of the notes I have about it okay so here we have the
Bowenberg so we can I apologize for the light but I'm having to use natural
light I don't have obviously all the lighting rig and I hope this will be
sufficient to enjoy the main features of this Bowenberg so the main source of
information I have for this apart from talking to James Elmsley is Peter
Tchaikovsky's dissertation work so there's a catalog he published it's in
Czech though so let's say in terms of the details I my Czech isn't good enough
to figure out more than let's say looking at images and you know figuring
out date and numerical information but it's a great reference for this kind of
weapon more as well he has a look at a whole bunch of archaeological remains
including swords, dussocks but he goes into documenting pommels as well
naggles for a lot of these in fact I'll show you right away well first thing I
want to show you is that you need to be careful because this is already flaking
quite a bit so it's overall in decent condition you'll see it's not like the
metal is solid and there's still very healthy overall but as you'll see here
as I handle it little flakes come off so this is why you generally apart from the
necessary work you may want to do for measuring or documenting something you
don't want to be just willy-nilly holding it and playing around with it
so this is and I'm not gonna say it's a one-off but let's say I don't count on
handling it too much anyway speaking of let's start looking at the pommel here
so a lot of these Bauernwärters I hope I can get it all in focus so a lot of these
Bauernwärters have kind of integrated pommels so they have flaring out pommel
cap rather than simply an extension of the shaped tang here so what you'll see
here is a very flat pommel section there's a little bit of a shape to make
it ergonomical or to kind of hold the pinky in there to hold the hand in place
but a lot of most of the ones I've seen at least or most of the ones that are
visible in Peter's work are of the kind of flared out kind although there are
some examples of these as well moving on to the construction of the grip here
you'll see that it has all its rivets in place so these are four rivets in this
case two along the grip section and then we have two where the pommel section is
as well and as I mentioned in the intro I don't know if this is a sign of these
being later versions but definitely the two I've seen that have this kind of
double rivet which in Peter's catalog are number 136 and 137 and they're dated
to let's say late 15th early 16th century yeah so the two that have this
double rivet at the end are rather later rather than earlier let's say you'll
notice that the tang here is quite flat overall it has some recess in this
section here you'll see there's like a bit of a groove over here but it's
overall flat again this is something you see in some of the examples documented
by Peter a lot of them though have kind of a concave shape so like they've been
hammered in and they have like a rounded shape like this so this is just
something to note as you'll notice I'm touching I'm holding the knuckle here
and that's because this one is loose so I think it'll be interesting to look at
this is what Elmsley classifies as a group two and two I think yes and two of
knuckles so knuckles come in a whole variety of shapes some are just a bit of
metal sticking out of the side some are angled some are rounded some are pierced
and decorated and some like these and to have this kind of mushroom shape so
these can be flat overall or they can be as you see here curved this one by
the way I hope it'll come through in the light we have available but it also has
some kind of decoration you'll see it has some little notches or longer the
external edge here and it also has some little lines cut into like decorative
lines cut into the side here and then at the bottom as well so it has some
decoration to it I hope it comes through I can't really see on screen
anything so I really hope that this shows in video anyway this kind of
knuckle if you're looking for references is documented again in Peter Zakowski's
work under the catalog numbers 13 31 40 107 159 and 161 some of these are
standalone knuckles and some of these instead are fixed on to knives
what's interesting here is the question of how these are fixed so when it was
this was shipped to me and in the pictures I saw it was facing this way so
with the concave side towards the blade this initially I don't know it didn't
make a lot of sense to me I would have imagined it rather turned in this
direction so like this and it just kind of makes more sense if you think of a
hit coming through on this side like this you would imagine it would make
more sense to hit a smoother surface rather than two edges however holding it
on the one hand it does feel like a good groove for this knuckle to be placed in
but on the other hand you have these sharp edges digging into your hand here
so according to James both orientations are attested so it could go either way I
can't really tell in the sense that if you look at the groove here on the other
side it seems to fit both directions so this is with the edges facing the tang
and if we turn it around this way that's with the edges here with the tips
facing the tip of the blade and you'll see that they kind of fit maybe it fits
a little better this way however all of the examples documented by Petr
Tarkovsky have the let's say the wings or the tips of the knuckle facing the
tip of the blade so this is how I plan to keep it yeah this is the way I think
it should look you'll also notice that the blade has some signs especially here
on the side of the on the edge of the tang here let me see if I hope it comes
through I might have to make another but here you'll see some signs of grinding
or potentially power tool use I'll remove the knuckle because I don't want
it falling here and you see something similar happening along the edge of the
blade unfortunately that's been a little blunted I wasn't sure what this
meant but talking to James this seems to be a fairly common sign of aggressive
cleaning on the part of someone who doesn't really know what they're doing
which is quite sad I I mean I don't want to blame anyone here it could be that it
was necessary maybe there was a lot of active rust who knows but let's say this
is usually not the best way to approach the process and you'll see it especially
here in the tip where you can see a little bit of glistening here that's
where the metal was cleaned up to the steel and that obviously removed any
kind of historical layering or patination so that's gone it might have
even damaged the last millimeters here of the tip so just don't do that if you
ever have the chance to or you ever need to clean a proper historical antique
what I like about this one is that it has this kind of edge here it's the tang
transitions into the blade with a bit of a vertical edge I think it's more
visible on this side yeah like a step which is really really cool I think it
gives a bit of personality to the blade again a lot of these come in all kinds
of shapes or sizes are the ones documented by Peter I have the feeling
that the ones that seem the most similar to me to this shape so what I looked at
here is mostly the general profile of the blade but also how the shoulders
kind of come to be I think numbers 4 48 and 94 are the ones that to me seem like
the most the closest probably 94 being the closest I think when it comes to
blade condition you'll see in Peters work so what I was trying to see here
given the fact that there are traces of later cleaning and everything was to get
an understanding of if there are archaeological documented archaeological
pieces that are consistent with this kind of fitting and stuff and again in
his work a lot of them are in way more relic conditions so you see a lot more
corrosion a lot more damage but a few have this kind of same pattern here and
I think the best examples to look at would be number 56 number 78 I think I
didn't mention the pommel I did mention the pommel earlier but I didn't mention
references so if you some have this same kind of flat pommel that flares out a
little I think number 78 and number 205 if I'm not mistaken were the ones that
gave me the closest vibes to this Bauernwehr so overall just a very beautiful I
think piece of tool and like a not only a piece of tool it's I think in a way
you could consider it a status symbol too so whereas fancy people would have
had Cinque Deas and this kind of stuff this is still a very recognizable and
very like it would define who you are and it would be a part of your yeah of
your recognizable characteristics as a medieval person that's like carrying
this what's cool about this I hope is that I'm going to measure it get all the
precise data and I'm going to work with Giovanni Sartori of Fusina Ferraro in
in Italy to create a accurate replica of this so hopefully in the coming
months we're going to document that as well and you're going to see how this
turns into a modern reproduction which is like complete usable and it has its
grip and everything so we'll kind of see it reborn in a sense so I hope you
enjoyed the video and I'll see you soon in the next one thank you for watching
bye
