Science Is Shattering Our Intuitions About Consciousness | Annaka Harris

Human & Consciousness
3 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 29, 2024
Is it possible that consciousness is a fundamental aspect of nature, present in everything around us? Annaka Harris explores groundbreaking perspectives on the nature of consciousness, challenging our traditional understanding and examining whether science is revealing a deeper, more pervasive reality of awareness.
If you think about it, consciousness is really everything.
Consciousness is everything we know,
everything we experience.
But the mystery at the heart of consciousness
is why in this universe
that seems to be teeming with non-conscious matter
somehow gets configured in such a way
where suddenly it's having a felt experience
from the inside.
Suddenly there's something that it's like
to be that matter.
And there's a lot that's happened in modern neuroscience
that suggests that our intuitions
about consciousness are wrong.
And so if it's possible that we've been thinking
about consciousness the wrong way,
that it's not something that arises
out of complex processing in brains,
is it possible that consciousness
is a much more basic phenomenon in nature
and is essentially pervading everything
so it's much more like gravity,
then we can imagine that all types of processing
in nature could include some type of felt experience.
I'm Annika Harris and I write about
the science and philosophy of consciousness.
I have a book called Conscious,
a Brief Guide to the Fundamental Mystery of the Mind.
And I have a docu-series titled Lights On.
There's no perfect definition for consciousness
in the way that I'm using it here
in the most fundamental sense.
And so it's useful to use Thomas Nagel's description
from his essay, What Is It Like to Be a Bat?
He illustrates a bat that is moving
through the world using sonar.
So it's making sounds, the sounds are bouncing
off the walls and the trees,
and it gets a picture of its external world
in the same way that we get a picture
of the external world through vision.
But you can imagine that the actual felt experience
of that is very different from our experience
of using vision.
So when I use the word consciousness,
I'm not talking about higher order thinking
or complex thought or things that we think of
in terms of human consciousness.
But when I use the word consciousness,
I'm talking about awareness, felt experience,
sentience, interchangeably to talk about
this more fundamental sense of consciousness.
And this can exist without thought.
It could exist in a very simple organism
that is not capable of thought.
But even in our human experience,
we think of a very young child or an infant,
we know that there are still felt experiences,
feeling pressure against the skin,
hearing sounds in the room,
the experience of heat or cold.
And there's clearly consciousness there,
and it doesn't necessarily entail thought.
So the study of consciousness has largely,
if not entirely, been relegated to neuroscience,
which makes a lot of sense because we have assumed
that the organisms that are conscious
are the ones that are most like us.
And we're complex systems.
The brain is the most complex system
in the universe that we know of.
And so we assume that consciousness arises
out of that complex processing.
But some of these intuitions that we're relying on
to make that assumption have been overturned
by modern neuroscience and have been shown to be illusions.
So when we're trying to think more clearly
and more creatively about consciousness,
there are two questions that I think really get
at the heart of where these intuitions are misleading us.
Number one, is there any evidence we can find
from outside an organism or outside a system
that will conclusively tell us
that that organism entails conscious experiences?
And the second question is, is consciousness doing something?
Does it serve a function?
Is it driving our behavior in the way that we feel it is?
And our intuitive answer to both of these questions
is a resounding yes.
But surprisingly, it's easier to puncture these intuitions
or to shake them up than you might think.
Number one, if I go pick up my friend at the airport
who I haven't seen in years and I see a big smile
on her face and she's running toward me,
everything I see in her behavior in that moment
are very good clues that she's conscious.
But we know it's possible for there to be no behavior
coming out of a system, nothing to detect from the outside
when there's a full human conscious experience present.
There was a writer for French Elle,
his name was Jean-Dominique Boby,
and he had a condition called locked-in syndrome.
And this occurs when someone experiences brain damage,
either due to a stroke or to an external injury,
and the entire body becomes paralyzed
so that someone is no longer able
to move any part of their body,
yet they still retain a full conscious experience.
And he was in this state,
although he had one point of mobility,
he was able to move his left eyelid.
And over time, they developed this technique
for him spelling out words with certain patterns of blinks.
And he ended up writing a beautiful memoir
titled The Diving Bell and the Butterfly,
and it took him 200,000 blinks to write that memoir.
It's a great example of a person, an organism,
a system in nature that is having
such a full conscious experience,
as full as I am having right now,
with the ability to write and experience the world,
but with no ability to move or communicate
or exhibit any behavior that would tell us
that this person is conscious.
And so we can wonder if it's possible
that there are other systems in nature
that simply aren't able to communicate
or exhibit behavior that convinces us
that consciousness is present in them.
And our intuition regarding the second question
is that obviously, of course,
our conscious experiences are affecting things.
If we encounter a bear or a lion in the wild,
that the feeling of fear is the thing
that gets us to move so quickly out of the way,
to act quickly, to save our lives.
But what we now understand about the brain
is that the experience of feeling fear
is actually something that happens
at the tail end of a sequence of processing,
and that our bodies begin responding
and moving to a dangerous situation
much more quickly than we become aware of it.
This is what neuroscientists refer to as binding processes.
Binding processes take in all of our perceptions,
all of the information that comes in
through our eyes and ears, through touch,
and give us an experience of a present moment.
So I often give the example of playing the piano.
If you press down on a piano key,
you'll have the experience of feeling the key move down
at the same moment that you see the key move down
and in the same moment that you hear the tone.
When in actuality, all of these signals
move through the world at different amounts of time
to get to your brain,
they each take different amounts of time
to be processed by the brain.
The brain is taking in all of these inputs
that are taking different amounts of time
to reach the brain and be processed by the brain,
and then deliver them to your conscious experience
as one single moment.
And so those intuitions that consciousness
is driving that type of behavior,
we now know to be incorrect.
So if the intuitions that led us to assume
that consciousness arises out of complex processing,
namely in brains, are misleading us,
we really have only two options for a starting place.
Some of these systems are conscious,
that consciousness arises out of complex processing,
or all of these systems are conscious,
that consciousness is fundamental.
What would that mean?
And what kinds of questions would we ask?
And how could we even study something
like this scientifically?
We might wonder if experiences
can be shared between systems.
If you think about Albert Einstein
and the fact that he had intuitions for space time
that no other human being had,
and it took him more than a decade
to explain this intuition through mathematics and language
and to be able to communicate
what he was talking about to other scientists,
let alone start to make scientific progress with it,
is there some future science
where you might be able to actually share that intuition?
We might wonder which types of systems
entail suffering in terms of ethics.
This is something we obviously care a lot about.
We know now that when dogs cry out in pain,
they're feeling something very similar to what we feel.
And so it'd be interesting to learn
what other types of systems
might experience pain or suffering.
Recently, when I was doing plant research,
I went for a jog on this hiking trail,
and I actually ran this little thought experiment for myself
imagining that all the plants along the trail
were not plants, but were some type of creature
feeling the world, moving through the world.
And just that little exercise
gave me a sense of how different we might feel in the world
if we understood that there were many more conscious systems
around us than we realized.
Want to dive deeper?
Become a Big Think member and join our members-only community.
Watch videos early and unlock full interviews.
