Exclusive
Change of a Century: Discussing the Impact of the Rebrand | The Epoch Insights

The Epoch Insights
337 followers
1K Video Views·Nov 21, 2024
In this episode of “The Epoch Insights”, we explore the impact of the rebranding of a century long organization from “Boy Scouts of America” to “Scouting America”.
This decision has sparked significant backlash from scouts and parents alike. We discuss in depth of the situation, with an article from the Epoch Times, which discusses the emotional impact the rebrand has had on the author.
We show examples of the positive impact the Organization has had in media. And share some personal opinions on the situation from formers scouts. Join us as we dive into this issue of significant cultural impact.
Welcome to Epoch Insights with Tiffany.
When you want to find out about something that's happening in the world today,
where do you go for news?
Do you look at social media or your emails?
Do you turn on the radio?
Not many people turn to the newspaper anymore.
It seems like such an antiquated thing from the past.
However, there are many reasons why it's worthwhile
to open up a newspaper and flip through the real pages,
if it's the right publication.
Many of the biggest publications are now turning to online only,
like the New York Times, LA Times.
You can still find an occasional print paper,
but they're going almost exclusively digital.
However, there's one paper I always like to read in a physical copy,
and that's the Epoch Times,
because it has so much interesting information
that isn't just about the latest news.
It has more deep insights.
An article I've been reading, it is called
Vespers for the Boy Scouts of America.
Now, this is from Lance Christensen,
and he's talking about the death of a good friend of his.
He begins the article by saying that he recently read an obituary for this friend.
However, he goes on to describe that this isn't a person.
The friend he's describing, who is now deceased,
is the Boy Scouts of America.
Like many boys and men in the United States
during the past 100 plus years,
he had some wonderful experiences as a boy,
camping, tying knots,
sitting around the campfire and bonding with other young men.
He has some very fond memories of those experiences.
However, it felt to him that he'd lost that good friend
when he learned about the recent news regarding the Boy Scouts of America.
On May 7th, the Boy Scouts of America announced
that it is officially changing its name to Scouting America.
This change will go into effect on February 8th, 2025,
which will be the organization's 115th birthday.
Now, this has caused a great deal of commentary
from people from all walks of life.
All over social media, you see people saying
it's a good thing, it's a bad thing,
mourning, celebrating, false claims of hundreds of thousands of boys leaving.
However, there are many people who have left already,
or who are saying that they don't want their sons to be involved.
Now, this isn't really a sudden change,
and it's not that surprising.
In this article, Mr. Christensen is commemorating this event
by talking about the good things and the wonderful experiences,
but it wasn't that quick of a change, as he notes.
Mr. Christensen says his church left association with the group,
and he realized that not all of his sons would be involved
because the policies had changed,
and this change to be more inclusive
has happened gradually over the last several years.
In 2017, the Boy Scouts announced
that they would be allowing girls into their ranks,
and of course, it seemed a little unnatural for girls to be called Boy Scouts,
so the next year, they implemented a policy
that the main category for children ages 11 to 17
would no longer be called Boy Scouts.
Instead, it would be called Scouts BSA, or just Scouts.
Now, although this seems so inclusive to some people,
one group was very unhappy about that change,
and that was the Girl Scouts.
If the girls are joining the Boy Scout,
it would really hurt their own numbers
because then girls wouldn't join the Girl Scouts.
They also didn't like the use of just the term Scouts,
or Scouting, with no boys attached,
because they claimed that that infringed on their territory.
It actually became quite a court case,
but eventually, a judge ruled that it was unfair and unlawful
for the Girl Scouts to claim any kind of patent on the term Scouting.
He said that both organizations had the use of the word Scouts and Scouting.
Now, the Girl Scouts haven't made any official comment
after this May 7th announcement about the change to Scouting America.
When I found out about this, I was curious to know what average people thought.
I'm hearing what celebrities are saying,
I'm hearing what the people in charge are saying,
but what does the average person think?
So I put a little post on my Facebook page
and asked my friends for some unbiased comments.
Out of all those comments I received, around 11,
I was very surprised to see that only two of them
were anything other than extremely negative about this change.
I was also surprised because not all my followers or friends are conservative.
Many of them are very liberal,
as fellow Californians or people in the arts industry.
However, people from a very broad background
said that they thought this was a bad decision.
One person commented it would give boys a sense that they have no place to be
because the Girl Scouts still exist in their existing form,
but now the Boy Scouts are also a place for girls.
So girls now have two places and boys only have one,
but not even a whole place anymore.
Another person commented that instead of changing the Boy Scouts,
it would have been better to add a second division to the Girl Scouts.
You could have the traditional Girl Scouts that have the more feminine qualities,
as well as one for more adventures,
so that girls can learn similar things like tying knots, camping,
without removing the good policy of having boys and girls separate.
One man mentioned that as a boy,
there was something so great about being able to experiment and grow and learn
without the embarrassment and the pressures of a co-educational situation.
I was surprised to see that some of these comments came from a man
who's worked in the media for years, on television as a journalist.
I don't think of him as a very conservative person.
He seems like more of a liberal.
He thought this was a very bad decision and it was more to make a point,
something like virtue signaling,
instead of actually being a good change.
Of course, many people commented that this is another thing happening in the woke agenda.
One comment was from a young man who's in his early 20s,
and he said he enjoyed Scouting himself,
and he thinks that this will compromise the very spirit of Scouting.
Of course, the Boy Scouts themselves, or the Scouting America,
claim that the only thing that's changing is the name.
There have been many statements on their website
and videos made to say things that haven't changed.
Their policies, the Scout oath, the Scout law,
their commitment to traditional values,
all this changed is the name.
However, that seems like protesting a little too much.
When some of the earlier statements made
by the current president and CEO of Scouting America
were things like, this is to create more inclusivity,
and we want girls to feel welcome, we want anyone to feel welcome,
regardless of gender,
that's in direct conflict with some later statements he's made
that the Boy Scouts' core principle is still faith.
Some of these statements he made in an open letter,
talking about faith and commitment to God and country,
sound very different from an organization
which is changing its name to Scouting America
because it doesn't even want to acknowledge
that there should be places just for boys.
This really is a chance and a last attempt
of a failing organization to save itself.
Whenever an organization rebrands itself so drastically,
it's not usually because it's doing well.
It's because it's doing poorly.
For the last couple of years,
Boy Scouts of America has been facing bankruptcy.
This is because of a series of scandals
that have come out about abuse of boys in the Boy Scouts
from Scoutmasters, leaders, and even other boys.
They've had to declare bankruptcy
because the Boy Scouts now have to pay millions of dollars worth of damages
to countless boys and men
who claim that they were abused during their time in the Boy Scouts.
According to some studies, this is nothing new.
Back in the 60s, there were some concerns about this.
Since 1919, there was a list of possible offenders and predators
who could be involved with the Boy Scouts.
When the organization had stronger leadership,
there was less of that,
and they were careful to try to keep such people away from the boys,
but there always is a possibility of corruption
in any organization of that size.
Besides the abuse recently and scandals,
one of the biggest concerns has been dropping numbers.
In 1972, there were over 5 million members.
Now, there are just over a million members.
Here in this article, he mentions
that the boys enjoyed rambunctious adventures worthy of the silver screen.
That's an interesting point,
because very few movies and television shows
have actually been allowed to depict the Boy Scouts of America.
The BSA has always been rather strict
about which groups can depict it in actual name and uniform.
Because of that, many movies throughout the years
have had similar groups, but not with the actual name.
You can tell it's supposed to be the Boy Scouts,
but it isn't really the Boy Scouts.
Like Mr. Smith Goes to Washington from 1939.
They are the Boy Rangers,
and it certainly seems like the Boy Scouts,
but they don't use the actual name.
Mr. Scoutmaster from 1953,
a movie starring Clifton Webb
about a man who finds a great purpose in his life
by helping a group of rowdy boys.
They seem to be scouts, and they call him Mr. Scoutmaster,
but they're not actually the Boy Scouts of America.
One of the few exceptions to this rule is Follow Me Boys,
a 1966 Disney live-action film starring Fred McMurray.
For whatever reason,
maybe because the Boy Scouts of America
thought Disney would do things right,
there actually is a depiction of the Boy Scouts in this film.
Fred McMurray's character is a scoutmaster
in the official Boy Scouts.
And this film had a great influence
on making more people want to join the Boy Scouts,
and it was extremely popular when it was first released.
And when it was later re-released in the 70s,
it had a charming theme song,
the title, Follow Me Boys,
written by the Sherman Brothers.
And it was so popular that for a while,
the Boy Scouts of America considered replacing
their theme song with that song
as sort of an anthem.
It never really caught on,
but many people were considering it for a while.
It just shows the influence that the Boy Scouts have had
and could have in the future.
It's so easy to see scandals in a group,
whether it's in the government, in a church,
in a small town,
or even in the Boy Scouts of America,
and think that it's all bad,
that it always has been corrupt,
and that it's just a recipe for disaster.
However, sometimes that's throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
Many men have been very sadly abused in situations like that.
That still is a fraction compared to the millions of boys
who've had wonderful experiences in the Boy Scouts,
who've learned how to be a man from good role models,
good influences, and just being outside,
celebrating traditional values.
When it was started in 1910,
it was considered as a great way for boys
to learn useful skills and prepare them to be good members of society.
Many of them have gone into the military,
and they've already known useful skills,
such as tying knots, following rules, earning merit badges,
and useful things that they can do throughout their lives.
Even if they go into the business world,
any man can still benefit from those strong values
about decency and helping others.
It's sad to see that this could be the end of Boy Scouts of America.
However, it doesn't have to be the end of scouting.
Many other scouting groups have sprung up in the last few years
since these unfortunate changes to BSA have begun.
There also are some fine scouting groups in other countries.
International ones, we only can hope, won't follow this bad example.
However, it isn't necessarily too late for the Boy Scouts of America.
Perhaps they'll see this change,
and they'll see the backlash they're getting,
and realize that there's no point in staying in existence
if you have to change your core essence to do so.
The reason that Boy Scouts of America has been failing,
I would say, from even the small survey I took,
is that for years, parents, civic leaders, church leaders,
and even young boys themselves,
feel that it isn't the organization it once was.
Like so many things in our country,
if the Boy Scouts of America return to some traditional values,
perhaps it could become successful once again.
There's another interesting article in this issue of the Epoch Times
that was talking about a great World War II hero.
He's 100 years old, yet he still flies.
This man is quite an inspiration,
and a great example of the sort of American ingenuity
which the Boy Scouts have taught boys for years.
John Gleeson was a World War II hero,
and this veteran discusses in this article
why he was such a great hero.
He didn't try to be heroic.
He was just a man who loved adventure,
and he loved serving his country.
At 100 years old, he's still flying
because he doesn't see any reason why he wouldn't be.
He came from a poor background,
but he learned a lot from being in the air.
He said that he viewed many times
when he escaped from near-death experiences as divine intervention.
He's had many interesting experiences since his time in the war, too,
but he thinks that even though you'd think at 100 years old
he wouldn't need to keep flying,
he sees no reason why he wouldn't.
He says, why wouldn't I?
When you fly, you either do things right or you don't.
If you don't, then you're in big trouble.
He says he's always known the risks,
but he thinks that that's what makes it worthwhile.
You've got your life in your own hands,
and there's a certain feeling.
I can't put it into words.
I just like to fly.
He's a great example of the sort of men who are needed
as Boy Scout leaders and other great heroes
and examples to young boys in this country
of how they can be great men and serve their country.
As boys and children, girls as well,
aren't having good opportunities like the Boy Scouts
and the traditional Girl Scouts.
Sadly, they've turned to entertainment
that's strictly digital instead.
For instance, there's an article on banning phones.
This is referring to some new legislation
that is being passed in some states.
Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders of Arkansas
is trying to encourage other legislators
to put a ban on phone use
because American children are facing a mental health crisis.
A policy that she is hoping to endorse
is no smartphones before high school,
no social media before age 16,
phone-free schools,
and more outdoor play and childhood independence.
Groups like Boy Scouts would be a great way
to get children away from their phones
and outside doing real things in the real world
because, as this article notes,
it's creating these digital natives
who know more about using technology
than using the real world,
and it's having quite an influence
on children's minds and education and their development
and not necessarily a positive one.
Above all, I love reading the Epoch Times
because it doesn't just give you the news.
It doesn't give you just a depressing look
on all the bad things that are happening in the world.
It gives you some personal, first-hand accounts
like a man's who enjoyed being in the Boy Scouts.
It gives you some positive things to consider,
like ways we can enjoy being in the real world
and encouraging others.
It talks about life and tradition,
nutrition, good, clean entertainment,
inspiring arts and culture,
and above all, it makes you think for yourself
and think about these real-world issues
and how they fit into your life.
Thank you so much for joining me
for this little exploration of some of the news
in this latest issue of the Epoch Times.
I hope this will encourage you to continue
seeking both sides of every story,
looking for the truth and tradition,
and finding out what you really believe
about what's happening today.
