Lecture 32 : Stress Concentration and Notch Sensitivity (Part 1 of 2)

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Nov 9, 2024
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to the next lecture on stress
concentration and Notch
sensitivity when we talk about load
getting applied on a structure or on
your
part we always expect the load to be
uniformly
distributed many of times it gets
converted into a
point so once it gets converted into a
point the concentration of the stress
increases this tries to create a major
failure or an early
failure of the part so the service life
of the part or the product gets
reduced so in order to get out of the
problem we are trying to initially when
design itself we take care of
that so the importance of this topic is
going to be enhancing the service life
improving the Rel reliability of the
part or product by understanding this
concept on stress concentration and not
sensitivity if you go back and look at
our previous slides we were discussing
about fracture toughness test so there
we made a notch
intentionally so now you will see why is
this Notch very
important in this lecture we will be
covering the basic concepts then stress
concentration in different geometries it
can be a flat geometry it can be
cylindrical geometry why are always
components made in a cylindrical fashion
why is it not made Flat why is it not
made Square so we look into it stress
concentration in different geometries a
small analytical method in understanding
the stress concentration then
experimental determination what you have
designed for and when you do experiments
is it matching then not sensitivity and
material Behavior it is not going to be
the same for varying materials for
example polymer has
ductility the not sensitivity of it will
be different Ceramics have a brittle
failure so their not sensitivity is
different then we will see a not
sensitivity Factor called Q then stress
concentration and fatigue design
strategies to minimize stress
concentration case study and finally we
will try to
recap stress concentration stress
concentration refers to the localized
increase in stress around
discontinuities increase in stress
around
discontinuities such as holes Notch
sharp corners or crack Edge itself
within a given material so you can see
here there is an Abrupt change of stress
flow lines crowded happening at a high
stress concentrated point so now how do
we change this we change this by giving
a radius so you see here we are giving a
radius so when we give the radius in
manufacturing we always say fillet give
a small fillet at the concentrated Point
such that the stress flow lines are
distributed without abrupt change so
this is abrupt change and here it is
smoothening change such discontinuities
cause A disruption in the uniform
distribution of stress resulting in
higher stress levels at specific points
compared to the average stress across
the material so when we have a same
shaft material or when we have two
different material this can be one this
can be two when we have two materials
when we try to press it inside or when
we try to heat it and press it inside so
all these things when we do we always
will try to see what is the stress
concentration happening should there be
a fetting given right so if you look at
it there is a stress flow lines are
there there is a hole so you see that
how does a stress flow lines go around
the
hole significance in mechanical design
stress concentration is a critical
Factor because it can lead to localized
failure particularly in brittle
materials that have limited ability to
plastically
deform wherever you have a ceramic
material we are more interested in
trying to manage the stress
concentration so you can see here these
are the flow of the force or the stress
and these are the flow lines and the
flow lines pack together in the area and
stress concentration occurs so here it
would have been like this there is a
packing Engineers must account for
stress concentration when designing
components especially those subjected to
dynamic or cyclic loading to ensure
safety and
durability so whenever there is a static
load to a large extent it is okay
whenever you are going towards a dynamic
load or a cyclic load the stress
concentration plays a very very
important role the significance in
mechanical design the stress
concentration Factor s c f
quantifies its effect and is defined as
KT it is a factor KT Sigma Max divided
by Sigma nominal what is Sigma Max Sigma
Max is the maximum stress at the
discontinuity and sigma nominal is the
nominal stress in the given material
this factor is typically determined
using experimental methods or finite
element analysis or empirical formulas
to get these
values so you can try to use experiments
you can do empirical see many of times
experiments are very expensive or we do
FM
FEA finite element analysis and then try
to get the KT
Factor not
sensitivity not sensitivity is a
material
property that indicates how much the
presence of your notch or a geometric
discontinuity affects the material
strength and fatigue life it describes
the material tendency to amplify stress
concentration which can lead to
premature
failure
so not
sensitivity the depends on
factors such as
ductility
toughness
and the nature of
load static SL
CYCC brittle materials
has high
not
sensitivity so this leads to
failure on the opposite side ductile
materials distributes
distributees
stress and so less
sensitive so this is why if you see in
all the martial
arts they try to break ceramic material
right because all you have to do is
create a notch create a impact that's it
so not sensitivity like you have uh the
stress concentration Factor not
sensitivity is also found out there is a
Formula not sensitivity Factor
that is called as q q can be written as
KF minus
1 by K T minus
1 what is KF KF is nothing but the fatig
string fatig
strength and
KT is stress
concentration Factor through this we try
to calculate Q so when we try to
design we have to always look at KT
factor and Q factor for any given
material why this will try to increase
your service
life of products
that's why you see many of the products
are made out of polymer today is only
because their stress concentration level
and not sensitivity are factors are very
good so let us see some of the
applications many of times if you see
gear when you see a gear you see how the
stress gets
distributed wherever it is red it is
relatively
higher stresses are getting acted when
gear Gear meshes there will always be
stress concentration at the end of the
teeth when it is getting attached with
the gear right so this portion will have
a huge stress concentration in gear the
stress concentration occurs at the base
of the teeth due to small radius of
curvature at the root
so now people what they do is they have
a
gear now this radius is very important
when we go for the next gear next teeth
right this
radius is called as a root radius okay
if the radius is too small then you will
have more
concentration because once the radius is
smooth the flow lines will be easily
getting changed
so once it the flow lines are getting
there is no not much of accumulation of
stress flow lines so because of that the
failure does not happen this area is a
common site for crack initiation under
cyclic loading when the gear keeps on
meshing and going like nowadays the
gears run at 5,000 10,000 50,000 you
have spindles which are running today at
1 lakh RPM 5 lakh RPM so when we are
doing so there will be gears which are
Mach with another gear when it is mesing
happening it's a cyclic load so under
cyclic load making it a critical factor
in gear design and material selection
shafts when we look at shafts we always
try to see a cylindrical
shaft sometimes when see cylindrical
shafts are are always done because it's
manufacturing also easy sometimes
because of assembly limitation what we
do is we try to make a shaft like
this right so that means to say this
portion the Shaded portion will be
removed will be
removed so then what you have will be
something like
this so when we have this there is a
discontinuity so when we do a shaft
design we have to be careful why are we
doing a shaft Des design and where is a
shaft exhaustively used when we have
your motor the motor rotates right this
motor will always have the output of the
motor will come to a
shaft this shaft in turn will be
attached to a coupler and then you will
have a mechanical component getting
attached so there the shaft design
becomes very very important so for
locking with the coupling and many other
applications the shaft design uh is
always a
important Rule and on top of it if there
is a coupler if there is a shaft which
is rotating this is a rotating part this
is a cylindrical part so there has to be
some locking mechanism only for that we
always make a keyway so keyway is a slot
on the shaft and then on the keyway you
put a key so this will try to have a
positive drive so positive drive is it
tries to communicate the rotation to to
the other end the next end where both
rotates right shaft with features like
keyway ho or shoulders experience stress
concentrations at these
discontinuities keyway
is you have a shaft so you have a keyway
made right you have a
shaft you have a hole made
right you have a shaft you have a
shoulder
made so at these places there will be
discontinuity in the proper design and
finishing are essential to prevent
fatigue failure particularly in rotating
shafts subjected to cyclic bending or
torsional load cyclic bending means it
goes up and down up depend on on torsion
means the resistance right torsion
rotation torsion load so this comes
exhaustively sir nowadays the shafts are
made out of plastic the coupler is made
out of plastic shafts are made out of
steel coupler are made out of plastic so
all combinations are coming up today
such that they make sure that the stress
concentration uh is not transferred uh
to the shaft aircraft structures so when
we aircraft components such as fuse
large
spanel wing Spar ribs often have cutouts
or rivited
holes which are the source of stress
concentration rived holes these are
called are the spots for stress
concentration these areas are carefully
analyzed and designed to prevent crack
initiation and progression
so when the hole is there the crack can
form like this this crack can go on
driving
it so crack initiation that's what they
say crack initi prevent crack initiation
and crack progress this is
crack and the direction is
progression under various loads the
stress concentration in various geometry
you can have a v
not un not V not these are sharp angular
inundations in the component thus that
causes a significant increase in the
stress at the notch tip V not are common
in keyways and
Slots when you have a
shaft they are always try to have a v
Notch when you have a shaft they try to
have a u Notch V Notch is easy to make
because the tools are sharp and you just
cut across you can do your uh shaping
operation you can do a Milling operation
you get but uh U uh has Advantage
compared to V U Notes so you see here V
we always specify all these things what
is the angle which is there and what 2
Beta is the angle and uh this also we
specify what is the angle L KN we
specify and then we try to do the
geometry these are all important for
stress concentration un Notch these have
a rounded bottom causing less stress
concentration compared to V Notch they
are often used where some stress
relieving is desired without removing
the material so sometimes what we do is
we also try to do an operation called as
burnishing
burnishing so we try to press the
material or we try to do uh
pening sometimes we do roller burnishing
with some geometry we try to do pening
so all these things what it does is it
tries to create a radius and also
introduces compressive string so the
Machining process plays an important
role of introducing compressive stress
on these element ments holes can also be
thought of look at it here different
geometries we studied in V Notch un not
then we are trying to look at circular
hole elliptical hole circular hole are
commonly made because we have a drill we
make a hole so you get this geometry
common in structural components for
weight reduction or passing bolt and
revers circular holes cause a moderate
stress concentration around their edges
because they don't have an edge so they
always try to create a very small
moderation on the stress concentration
so we always try to do a
whole uh in the component elliptical
hole they are very difficult to make
these have a higher aspect ratio because
it is an
ellipse and results in Greater stress
concent ation compared to Circular holes
particularly at the end of the ellipse
where do we use we have very particular
applications for elliptical holes to be
made but generally we do it with
circular holes grooves these are
grooves circumferential groups found in
shafts and other rotating Parts these
are used for retaining rings or sleeves
the stress concentration is influenced
by Gro depth and width this is Gro
depth and width so this is so you see
that there is a D minus D will give you
the
depth right uh and then this
radius R will try to give you the width
axial groups are also there these are
axial groups so groups these run
parallel to the axis of the
component often reducing its effective
cross-section area leading to higher
localized stresses these are also axial
grooves are also there fillet is one
thing which we always give fillet is
nothing but radiusing we give internal
fillet external fillet internal fillet
these are rounded Corners at the
junction between two flat surface used
to reduce stress concentration at the
sharp Ed so there is a change of
geometry this is a sharped so here in
order to avoid the sharped we always try
to give a filler used to reduce the
stress concentration at sharp Corners in
components like crankshaft and
connecting
rod external fillet or rounded they are
applied to the outer edge of the
component such as the root of the gear
teeth and smooth transition and reduce
uh stress concentration two to smooth
transition and reduce stress
concentration effect of on
stress distribution V Notch and U notch
in V Notch and un Notch the stress
concentration at notches
results from the disruption of the
uniform stress flow in a material the
sharp notches cause significant stress
concentration due to their angular
geometry leading to high local stress at
the
tip tip which can
cause crack initiation U notches with
their rounded bottom reduce the sity of
the stress concentration and distribute
the stress more
evenly V versus U un not with its
rounded bottom reduces the sority of the
stress so the stress concentration can
happen
anywhere right severity of the stress
concentration and distribution of the
stress more
evenly when we talk about holes two
types of holes circular and ellipse
holes uh the introduction of the hole in
a component causes a redistribution of
the stress around the hole for circular
holes the stresses at the edge can be up
to three times the nominal stress in the
material for elliptical hole the stress
concentration is even higher
particularly at the ends of the major
axis major
axis right
ellipse so we will always prefer un Nots
we will always prefer circular
holes grooves so increase in stress in
the material around the group the sharp
and deeper the group the greater is the
stress concentration this is critical in
component subjected to fatigue loading
when even small grooves can result in a
prematured failure this one fillet
fillet helps in smoing so this fet of
the sharp Corners reduce stresses and uh
stress concentration by allowing a
gradual change in the cross-section the
radius of the fillet plays a very very
significant role this makes fillet
essential in high stress areas such as
Junction of a beam and flange at the
root of a gear tooth so when we try to
design we have to be more careful we
split and we take into next
lecture so thank you very much
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
