Lecture 39 : Environmental Impacts of Recycling

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
21 Video Views·Oct 4, 2024
Greetings, I welcome you all to this new lecture of this course, wherein we are now going to
discuss the environmental impacts of materials recycling. And we will be seeing how it is
important to pay attention to the important factors that are present in a recycling process,
so that when a process is being carried out or a product is generated from a waste stream,
what really happens and what are the implications that people have observed that happen on the
surrounding environments. So, it is not always the case that whenever
we are looking at a waste material, we can just, we can just go ahead and recycle it.
Not just recycling, it we have to take care about what are the economic and environmental
impacts of a recycling process. So, we will be focusing on various methods that have been
devised by studying the environmental properties, impacts and how to quantify it. Now, essentially
quantification of impact itself is a very difficult task, because we cannot generalize the impacts.
So, there have been studies to address this issue, so that we can take into account of various
parameters, the effects of various parameters. For instance, let us say what happens if we are
using a furnace or what happens if we are using a reagent, chemical reagent or what happens if
we are using both. So, when we are thinking of these process parameters, what are its impact
on the environment. We will be focusing on these outputs and then we will be generalizing on what
are the key challenges that people face when they are thinking of environmental impacts of metallurgical
and electronic waste recycling. So, let us begin materials recycling and by materials recycling
right now we are looking at a very generalized term. So, materials recycling is becoming a common
practice, but this is a common practice where it is not a common practice in most of the economies,
but it is a common practice in large scale and progressive industries.
Because industries are conscious about what are the resources and liabilities. So,
they are conscious about the resources and liabilities. So, they would definitely want
to invest on materials recycling which would in general mean that they are also investing in
twofold growth energy and materials. Because if you are recycling materials you are in turn saving
energy also. So, that is the way progressive and large scale industries invest. So, there is a
need of utilizing the natural resources, need of resources and this need of resources is covered
by recycling materials. Now, in this course we have already covered the two major categories
of materials. So, we have seen metallurgical wastes and key wastes and we have seen the
internal divisions so many times. So, now the most important aspect is we need resources and
how do we recover our resources if we are not recycling it. So, this is a major part of our
concern that at times we are supposed to continue the generation of newer products and at times we
are losing resources. So, one has to think of recent developments and we have already seen
so many different developments in so many different aspects seeing various industries
and their industrial wastes. Now, what are the environmental impacts? This is a general outline
but what is the environmental impact? There are some important questions that we need to answer.
Those questions are related to environmental impacts. These questions are like this. What
if we are not able to recycle wastes? What if the wastes are not recycled? So, a general answer is
that the exponential growth, it is extremely large. So, the growth of the wastes of the generated
waste, the growth of the generated waste from so it will come from two ends, industries and
consumer ends will be so large that it becomes beyond the scope of landfilling. Now, you cannot
even think of landfilling and it is what it is going to do severely affect the environment.
We have already seen so many times what are the key challenges when we are thinking of
environmental repercussions. So, if you are looking at let us say aluminum industry or
copper industry or if you are looking at steel industry and we have also seen batteries and
WPCBs. So, if we just dump a given waste in the environment, the chemical composition is such
that it is going to pollute the environment. Now, this is not a way by which we should be
handling. So, a general idea is we should be devising a recycling strategy, but then comes
the next question. What if, this is the second question, when we are recycling waste, the wastes
are recycled, but not efficiently. So, what this question really means is we have a strategy. So,
it means that we have a strategy, but it is not efficient. So, if a process is not efficient,
then we can easily foresee that let us say we have a strategy, it is going to recover some
waste, but secondary wastes are also generated. When we think of secondary waste generation,
that has to have a separate route of recycling. So, for instance in most of the pyrometallurgical
processes, let us say smelting or any other process, we know that we have a very good rate
of production, and it is one of the most favoured route of production and recycling as well. So,
we are more inclined to use it, but at the same time we also know that slag generation is always
observed, almost always it is observed. So, one has to think about slag recycling,
because it is almost inevitable. Now, it is fairly possible that recovery of valuable materials into
the hot metal stage, hot metal phase is can be optimized, which means the loss of valuable
materials into the slag phase can be reduced, but that, but such optimization requires lots of trial
and error, and it has to be a very much of a conscious effort. Generally speaking, many a
times it has been observed that if the processes are not properly optimized, lot many valuable
materials are lost in the slag phase as well. This means that we do have a recycling strategy,
we do recover some of the valuable materials, but it is not as high as it should be. So,
ideally speaking it means that all of the waste materials should be recovered in the way that
most of the valuable materials can be extracted as much as possible. That is an ideal condition,
but in reality what really happens is we get let us say a major fraction of valuable materials,
and some fraction is also lost as a secondary waste. So, we will write that.
Optimization of process parameters should be done to avoid major losses to the secondary waste
streams, because we know that we have just seen an example of pyrometallurgical processes.
Generation of waste secondary waste stream is almost commonly observed. It means one has to
just optimize the process in such a way that we do not lose valuable materials in secondary waste.
Now, we will go ahead with the next questions. What if what if the recycling process is fairly
efficient? What if the recycling process is fairly efficient? Now, it still has some or
the other environmental effect that is what we need to address. So, it basically means effects.
What are the effects on environment? It means that we have generally speaking the intention
is to have extraction, removal, recovery, removal of hazardous materials, recovery of valuable
materials. So, in both sense I have written removal and recovery of materials, and most of
the times we have been discussing metals, and reduction of environmental burden. This is what
we have been ideally targeting aim of recycling. This generally may not be the case. So, what are
the effects? Let us just write common effects observed for recycling processes. So, when we
think about it like this, let us say we have a general recycling route, which could which could
let us say include some pretreatment operations. So, we have let us say a general recycling route,
what are the observations? So, a positive observation could be let us say reduction
of hazardous effects of wastes, and we have good resource utilization that is one observation.
The other observation is reduction in material property. Many a times the properties mechanical
properties or thermal properties or whatever it is, the properties of materials seem to be
growing lesser in magnitude, and process parameters require optimization. This is very much important
for general method of recycling. So, if you are looking at thermal process, and similarly we will
be looking at chemical process. So, again thermal process and chemical process, we see that in
thermal process we have mixture of wastes, and waste streams basically. These can be can be
processed. Common example of this could be that for instance if we have different waste coming
from different sources, we put them in a furnace. If we find something relatively good, and if we
know that by processing them together, the composition of the products finished products
is not going to get affected much. So, one has to diligently think whether insertion of given
waste stream is really favorable or not. If that is not favorable, then of course this
should be avoided, and the other observation is we have generation of gases. We have gases
and secondary waste. This we have already just seen. Similarly, if you look at the chemical
processes, we have recovery of valuable materials, and we have seen this so many times. If you
are looking at let us say leaching process, then we have good generation of valuable products.
At the same time, we have generation of hazardous chemicals. Because we are using a chemical
route, it is rarely possible that we might get hazardous chemicals, and there is the
issue issues related to scalability. So, when we look at scalability whether it is laboratory
process or pilot scale or industrial scale, the generation of the wastes the hazardous
chemicals, the scale itself changes by large magnitudes. So, that is a good major problem
that we have observed. People have generally observed when they are looking at the environmental
concerns of a given waste recycling process. Now, there is something called echo indicators.
We will write. So, echo indicators are basically some sort of indicators that help in analyzing
the environmental impacts. So, environmental impacts are analyzed by certain indicators.
These indicators are basically numbers, values, some numbers or some values that describe
or they connect to the environmental burden, and this can be related to a process or a
product or a system, and this is a very good way of putting some numeric values to the
processes the recycling processes. So, how do we go ahead and understand the echo indicators?
So, there are some important methodologies. The important methodologies that people have
formulated for the study of environmental impacts are echo indicator 99 method, we have
equalizer 3.0, recipe method, recipe model for L C I A. We know that L C A is life cycle
analysis and we have L C I A here. So, L C I A is L C I A is basically life cycle impact
assessment. So, we have L C I A and these echo indicators are available essentially
for comparison. So, one of the major reasons that these indicators have been developed
is to put some numeric values to the processes and the products, but this does not mean that
these numbers have absolute significant value in reality. These are there for comparison
and the comparison itself is very much important. So, for instance people can compare H 2 S
of 4, the impacts of H 2 S of 4 or let us say generation of energy in a given unit or
generation or power utilization in a given unit, and these can be compared into certain
points. The certain points are basically the burden that the process or product is implying
on the environment. So, lower the echo indicator number value, lower is the environmental impact
and the comparison is very important. So, we will write the echo indicators are available
for comparison and these are for indications only, these are indicators. So, indication
only and comparison is important. So, when we now have understood that people
have devised methods for echo indication by echo indicators and we have methods for putting
numbers to environmental assessment. We would now look at the key challenges that people
have observed when they are looking at materials recycling and seeing the environmental impacts
that it has on during the process itself. So, the key challenges we are now going to
address, the environmental challenges. First one high energy consumption, we already know.
So, for when we look at an example of let us say pyromedallurgy is giving us very high
production, high production rate. So, it is very much of a favored route of production
or even recycling. At the same time it uses high energy, high energy requirement for operations
which means the generation of GHGs, greenhouse gases, GHGs and generation is also very large.
Because the such operation units would require large amount of energy that energy will be
coming from various sources, let us say fossil fuels, conventional or at times it could be
renewable also conventional sources of energy. So, this would lead to greenhouse gases. So,
energy consumption is very high and it needs GHG generation which is negative impact on
the environment. Second one would be water usage. Now, water is one of the most important
valuable resource in any industry. At times when we are using water for let us say even
quenching operations. We are taking water resources and performing our operations and
when the operation is done, we are mainly focusing on the product itself and not the
water resource that we have used. Now, it becomes an important responsibility
that the water resource that we have used is reused or it is processed in such a way
that it becomes reusable within the industry itself or if it is supposed to be discharged
into the next water body. Then the water body has to be accommodating enough to take in
the waste water that is only possible if we are recycling and treating the water before
we discharge it. Many a times the industries are not able to recycle the waste waters that
they are generating. It is, so it may be due to the lack of facilities for specifically
dedicated to water resources. So, they may have very good recycling facilities for various
other materials, but water waste water generation may be a big problem for many of the industries.
So, water usage is a big challenge resource utilization is very important. So, in connection
to water usage we will just write resource utilization is very important and it is based
on available technology. The third one is basically logistic problems that are associated
with the wastes. What do you mean by logistic problems? Logistic problems are the transportation
of wastes from one point to the other. So, logistics of wastes it is fairly possible
that waste streams may require transportation. And when we do when we think about transportation
we will also think about the fuel consumption fuel consumption in the transportation. And
this also implies we are in turn thinking about greenhouse gas generation. Because many
a times when we think fine we have the waste that is generated in the industry we are going
to recycle those wastes only. That is going to require very less logistical support. However,
if you are thinking of waste that is generated in a different let us say country itself.
So, one has to cross the international boundaries and transport the whole wastes to let us say
a remote location where the recycling facility is available. And there all of the wastes
are being transported to and there the recycling is being conducted. Now, this means that we
are somehow contributing to the generation of GHGs greenhouse gases by transporting the
wastes. So, the intention is correct that fine we are thinking of recycling a waste.
But because we are investing too much on the logistics we are in general generating more
greenhouse gases. We have problem of cross contamination. So, when we think of cross
contamination one can just have only one single way one can think of incineration. The waste
streams cannot be separated that is one way people have been recycling cross contaminated
waste stream. However, it may also lead to generation of
hazardous gases or other hazardous waste streams. So, this means that one should be investing
heavily on isolating the waste streams as much as possible before subjecting it to recycling.
Because cross contamination lot is very difficult to handle and there are only very few limited
ways by which people can address such a lot. There is the problem of down cycling. So,
this means the generation of waste the wastes are used for making lower property products
that is a most viable and common route of addressing this down cycling process.
Because at times we are when we seeing that we are recycling a material we actually are
losing on the properties of the material. So, for instance mechanical properties or
thermal properties or chemical properties. So, those properties are being lost when we
recycle it. It may happen with many of the materials. In such a case we are just going
to down cycle or reuse them to make lower grade products.
So, this is available recycling technology recycling technologies. So, when we have lack
of automation this would generally mean higher exposure of humans or environment to the waste
stream itself which means that the chances of getting a disease or affecting the environment
is lot more higher which means one should be thinking of automizing auto and providing
lot more machines and computerizing the process itself in such a way that the human contact
of the waste or the environmental contact of the waste is reduced as much as possible.
The last one is basically landfilling. This is the one of the most greatest challenge
that people have been facing. It leads to the exposure of heavy metals hazardous chemicals
dioxins and so on so forth. And we have seen so many different wide variety of materials
that are lost to the environment once we think of landfilling. And all of the or most of
the modern and recent advance technologies that are being explored let us say in a laboratory
scale or a pilot scale or that those that are industrially accepted those strategies
avoid as much as possible the idea of landfilling. They may want to bring back neutral materials
but wastes that are valuable are definitely reused as much as possible before becoming
neutral. Landfilling of hazardous chemicals is going to severely and adversely affect
the environment. So, in the today's class we have seen so many different aspects of
environmental assessment and how people are focusing on the environmental aspects and
how much it is of a challenge when we are thinking of devising a recycling strategy.
We have seen some important questions that would require us to think again when we are
devising a recycling strategy and how much it should be compatible with the surrounding
environment. And not just humans but flora and fauna and the resources that are available
air water and land all of the ecosystem that we have around should be made brought into
the consideration while devising a good recycling strategy. In the upcoming class we will be
focusing on the conclusion parts of this lecture series. Thank you.
