Lecture 11 : Hardness, Toughness, Impact and Creep

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Aug 6, 2024
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to the next
lecture here we will try to cover
hardness
toughness impact and creep all these
four are
mechanical property related to
material in the last couple of lectures
we have been time and again talking
about stress strain
graph uniaxial tensile
testing compressive load tensile load
and Shear
load on top of this hardness toughness
impact and creep plays a very very
important role these four
properties can be derived after doing a
stress strain curve
test but independently there are
instruments to measure these
properties hardness
is a very fundamental property as a
common man we always try to scratch and
see some
material we scratch it using a nail or
we scratch it using uh a very hard
point a broken glass or through your
nail in the finger we scratch it and
then we say oh the material is very hard
the hardest material known to us is
diamond or what happens many of times
when you see in the basketball court
around the post they would have put a
toughen material because the players
come with so much of speed they try to
they might try to bang against the
surface so when they bang it should not
be a damage for them so they always have
covered with a rubber material so rubber
material there is a tough material where
in which the energy is absorbed without
deformation
toughness impact is when I drop the
water bottle when I drop this water
bottle down will it deform when I drop
this pen down will it deform so that is
impact a glass tumbler when it falls
down shatters a stainless steel tumbler
when it falls down does not shatter so
that is nothing but
impact then comes the
creep let's see the content of today's
lecture I will little bit introduce
mechanical properties then I will try to
move into
hardness
toughness impact and
creep mechanical properties are the
fundamental characteristics that
describes a material's behavior and
performance under applied force or load
so you see here a mechanical property
when it is done what are all the
characteristics you can talk about one
is stiffness you can talk about strength
ultimate tensile strength elasticity
plasticity
ductility
malleability hardness brittleness creep
formability castability and weldability
all these properties can be found out by
doing a mechanical testing imagine inine
you are building a bridge you would not
use the same material for the delicate
suspension cable as you would for the
sturdy support beam that's where
mechanical properties come into
existence they are the fundamental
characteristics that describe how a
material reacts to the external Force
like pulling pushing twisting or bending
so you can see here this is plasticity
this is brittleness this is elasticity
and this is sheer strength a same
material is expected to do all these
functions for example when you sit in a
plastic chair the plastic chair has to
have resistance to Shear because you sit
and glide in the chair second thing is
the chair should have compressive
strength the chair should have little
bit of flexibility to accommodate a
heavy person and a light person the load
has to be taken by the chair's leg the
chair's leg will be stiffened sometimes
they give a metal strip inside or
sometimes they add material in the leg
so they do all these things to manage
the application so so for doing so you
need to understand the mechanical
property as I told you why is it
important it will help in bringing out
safe and reliable
design by knowing the material strength
stiffness and other properties an
engineer can design structure machines
and components that can withstand
intended load with without failure so
design
for design for
safety designed
for
failure are something which are very
important when I take this water bottle
the lid is designed for failure when you
apply a torque it has to fail so that it
gets opened design for safety is when I
construct uh a or when I construct a
building it should withstand heavy
Breeze and sismic waves so all these
things are very important to understand
mechanical properties material selection
is very very important recently I was
traveling at a tea shop they gave us a
tea kettle the tea kettle was
the tea kettle was made out of stainless
steel here it had a beautiful neck and
here it was made out of
copper in order to have symmetry in the
object they have used also copper here
now think of it when you heat the kettle
the heat of stainless steel thermal
conductivity and copper conductivity is
completely different so when I wanted to
hold the kettle by hand I cannot do it
so what are the possibilities I will
have a handle and on top of the
handle I will try to put some material
which is
insulating right and now the other Big
Challenge was how do I weld copper to
stainless steel because they have
varying thermal conductivity properties
that's a big Challenge and the neck
whatever it is when I am trying to pour
by chance if it tries to touch with your
hand or finger it burns right you look
at it the improper selection of material
has made the application very very
difficult finally the tea kettle had to
be changed by the t- shop
so material selection is very very
important when you are trying to choose
material you have to choose material
such that it can absorb energy or it
does not absorb energy for example the
wind shield what is placed in the car
bus they are all using toughened glass
there are two glass layers and in
between they will also have an adhesive
layer when a stone hits from a from a
preceding vehicle at a very high speed
the from the tire it comes and hits your
windshield the windshield should not
shatter so here what we do is we try to
choose a right material if you try to
choose a very hard material what will
happen is it will be hard material many
of times is brittle so it will shatter
so you have to choose a right material
for a right job mechanical properties
guide this decision making process for
example a lightweight yet strong
material might be ideal for aircraft
Wings it has to be as lightweight as
possible it has to be as ductile as
possible as malleable as possible
because you're going to make a complex
profile it has to be as light as
possible because any small weight you
take and then fly it's all going to be
on your mileage right so it has so life
weight yet strong and then strong here
room temperature or at the airport the
temperature can vary in Indian
conditions it can vary from uh 12° or 6°
C it can go up to 48° C at the land
condition and once it starts flying it
can move from 48° C to minus 20 or 30°
CSUS huge temperature difference right
so look at it so you have to make a
right choice and then when you are
trying to make a material for gear gears
are very important because they are
going to transmit energy from one point
to the another so when we use gears we
always try to use a huge load to rotate
just a simple example you can take sugar
cane juice making machine so you can see
here people will be applying so much of
torque to rotate it's a heavy gear where
there has to be a lot of crushing has to
happen the juice has to be extracted the
gear has to be as strong as possible
here we don't choose a lightweight we
choose a heavy material or a denser
material here we always choose mild
steel or stainless steel gears let's
move from this profile to a lower
profile we want
toys the toys also has gear these gears
have to be smooth and has to have very
low friction the toy has to also very
light the toy has to be used for a
longer time because the kid would love
to use the toy so here the gear will be
lightweight and it will be with lower
friction so aluminium cannot be thought
of but po polymer will be thought of the
proper selection is very important when
we want to do performance optimization
we always try to take the material
property and and uh see how the material
responds to the stress allows engineer
to optimize the performance for instance
knowing a material's fatigue resistance
helps to predict how long it can last
under repetitive loading conditions so
optimization is very important
optimization we can reduce the material
or try to improve the process parameter
now let us look into the another
mechanical property which is hard
it is the fundamental mechanical
property that
describes a material's resistance to
localized plastic deformation so if I
wanted to Define hardness I can write it
like this
hardness is the
resistance of your material
to
deformation
particularly permanent
deformation scratching
cutting
or
abration the difference between cutting
and abration is cutting the cutting tool
is a solid big material abration means
the size of the tool tool is basically
the counter which is there so it is
abration amount of material removal is
small amount of material removal is Big
so hardness is the resistance of a
material to deformation particularly
permanent deformation like scratching
cutting or abrasion it is a critical
parameter in Materials Science and
mechanical engineering providing insight
into the materials wear resistance
ductility and strength generally what we
do is in order to find out the hardness
of a given material we try to take the
material and indent the material with a
hard
substance applying load if you don't
apply load you can just do scratching if
you apply load and don't move that is
called as hardness testing so you can
try to use an inder inder is a is a hard
material the process of inder striking
against the material will be called as
inundation and you apply load so here we
try to apply load maybe from 1 Newton to
100 Newtons depending upon your
requirement and see what is the material
response by looking at the inundation
you can also try to talk about the
elastic and plastic deformation hardness
is important because it directly affects
a material's ability to resist wear and
tear a harder material will generally
last longer and show less wear under
friction or repetitive contact it also
helps us in maintain its shape a hard
material will better resist permanent
inundation or deformation to the applied
load protect against scratches and
damage hardness is crucial for materials
used in protective coating tools and
other applications that experience
regular contact so if you wanted to make
a SC scratch proof material we will
always go for coating paint is a coating
right so like that you can also try to
coat with material for example you can
have a solid rod and then coat it with
another material where in which the
friction can be reduced to a large
extent so hardness right so in hardness
there are several methods one is called
as brenal hardness testing brenal
hardness testing is again a hardness
testing machine here in which we use a
ball to indent it is well suited for
testing harder materials uh which is
made out of the process of casting and
forging so casting and forging in the
olden days they always used to make a a
large
volume
products okay large volume products both
in terms of material volume and I am
also talking about numbers so here it is
very difficult for you to go and do
mechanical testing so what we do is we
always go and do a hardness testing so
uh in the olden days they had ball as
the IND under so the ball has a diameter
D and then when you apply force it tries
to make an index dation the inundation
diameter is di then there is a Formula
through which you try to find out what
is the brenal hardness generally the
ball which is used is tungsten carbide
and the load which is applied is up to
3,000
kgf measures the diameter of the
resulting inundation to determine the
brenal hardness number HB finally there
is a dial here this dial tells what is
the number and based based upon the
number you can try to find out what is
the
hardness so it is relatively simple and
a quick test is this hardness testing
good for measuring overall hardness it
is particularly beneficial for materials
with nonuniform grain structure or
potential surface inconsistency we
always go for this hardness testing and
the next one is it is applicable to a
wide range of material in this brenal
hardness we have a scale and then in
this scale we also have materials so
moment we do the scale number we can try
to find out what is the material and to
some extent you can also try to find out
what is the material's composition so
all could be done by a simple test of
hardness testing the disadvantages large
indentation might damage the work piece
so after you do an indentation
predominantly
there is a plastic deformation so you
will have to scrap that part and in
today's scenario scrapping a part is
costly so we will try to see how do we
make sure without doing a large
indentation but still to get the
hardness value and the second thing not
ideal for thin materials it's always
used for thick materials because the
force you will use up to 300 kgf right
so it glass and all cannot be thought of
using it so non ideal for thin materials
and brittle materials Force selection is
very crucial suppose you choose a wrong
Force the load is very minimum you will
not see any inundation so you can't have
an interpretation saying that the
material is hard so a proper load uh
application or the force selection is
very very important the next important
property is toughness the toughness
property can be found out from the
stress strain graph from the start of
yield to the fracture point the area
under the curve is called as toughness
here the material
deforms but it does not break the energy
within that is called as
toughness toughness is a crucial
mechanical property that describes a
materials ability to absorb
energy and plastically deform before
fracture for example let's take two
simple examples you have your Rod
suppose you have a rod you wanted to
bend the rod and make something like
you or you want to make a hair pin which
women use so you want to bend it and
then make so what you do is you hold it
in a vice and then try to keep the rod
you hammer it and then you bend it you
bend it a straight line into a
u so now when you try to hammer it it
absorbs energy when it absorbs energy it
easily helps you in bending otherwise it
if you if the toughness is poor it does
not absorb energy it fails so that is
why you see many of the holding like gem
clip okay and uh the paper clips all are
made out of Rock
or wire where in which the toughness is
very high okay for when you go into
polymers it is much higher there is a
terminology which is used for during the
resistance uh during the area under the
curve only under the elastic limits is
called as
resilience sometimes in the examination
they can ask Define resilience here you
will try to say the area under the curve
within the elastic limits is called as
resilence within the plastic region it
is called as
toughness okay so this in simpler terms
or simple
terms simpler
terms it
tells
us how much
a
material can
bend stretch stretch is also part of
it stretch or
twist without breaking is
toughness for example on top of a
compound wall you will see Twisted rods
it gives you a very good aesthetic
appear
so Twisted rods that is all basically
toughness and if you cannot do it in the
cold State room temperature State what
we do is we slightly heat it and then we
twist it so in simpler terms it tells
you how much a material can bend stretch
or
twist this is found out by a charp test
charpie test the purpose is to measure
the energy absorbed by a material during
fracture so here there is a Asm standard
according to the ASM standard we prepare
the sample when we prepare the sample we
initiate a crack in order to find out
exactly what is the toughness of the
material energy it can store we initiate
a crack and then or a notch and then in
the opposite side we try to hit so here
what we do is we try to have a load and
that load is moved to a distance from
there it is allowed to hit it is impact
so it swings and hits and then it the
energy is absorbed here and the rest of
the energy allows after breaking it
allows the end of The Twist based upon
the swing the values here we try to find
out what is the toughness the procedure
is a notched specimen a notch this is
called as a
notch a notched specimen is struck by a
swinging pendulum the energy absorbed in
Breaking the specimen is calculated from
the height of the pendulum reached after
the fracture so here is the height so
from here it swings it hits the material
and it goes here so this is H1 this is
H2 from this they do a calculation and
try to say what is the energy absorption
so the orientation you can keep the
sample like this or you can keep the
sample like this orientation of sample
is also important the specimen is
supported horizontally and the notch
faces away from the pendulum or it can
be on the other way around significance
provides insight into the materials
ability to withstand Sudden Impact
particularly used for evaluating the
brittleness or ductility at different
temperatures you can also use it for
varying temperatures that means to say
the sample will be heated and then you
can try to do the test so this
particularly tries to tell you what is
the ductility man ability things
possible in the process for example in
forging you wanted to deform material to
a large extent so how much energy you
should apply or is the material able to
withstand the force what you apply at
room temperature and at higher
temperatures charp was one test we also
have I isad so isad impact test the
purpose is also measure the energy
absorbed during fracture similar to
charp this is the other thing so here we
hit the material and then we record we
record the reading hit and then we
record the reading procedure is the
specimen is clamped vertically with the
notch facing the pendulum earlier it was
against now it is towards the pendulum
here the
pendulum
strikes the
specimen at the
Notch and the
energy absorbed in breaking
the
specimen is
measured okay so this is a difference
between isad and
charp the orientation and the notch
position the vertical clamping and the
notch orientation differentiates it from
the charpie test significance commonly
used assess the toughness of polymer and
plastic as well as metal so that is done
by charpie test so examples Steel in
construction industry suppose or the
purpose is structural steel must be
tough to endure impact and dynamic
loading so the real world
example is going to
be the steel beam
the steel beams and
column need
to absorb
energy
from
Impact and cyclic load
so suppose if there is a machine inside
or uh if there are a lot of people
walking if there are a lot of people
jumping so it is
impact so the advantage of toughness is
it improved safety it improves ductility
versatile in application enhance energy
absorption what are the disadvantages uh
higher materials uh cost increased
weight uh manufacturing challenges and
brittle Behavior at low temperature so
the these are the things which help us
by doing the toughness suppose toughness
means you want to absorb lot of energy
you increase the weight if you want to
have higher toughness okay so that is
the thing which is laid down here impact
impact is impact strength also known as
impact toughness is a crucial mechanical
property that describes a material's
ability to resist fracture under sudden
and high velocity load uh impact is uh
when you are trying to keep a tank on
top of your roof and then you open water
right and the water falls from a certain
head so that is also an impact load a
student jumping impact load right so
impact toughness is very very important
it is
essential it essentially tells
us how
well your material
can be
handled a sharp
blow
or impact
without
breaking we do a crash test in the car
as soon as the car is developed we do a
crash test and see what is the impact
when we travel at 60 kilomet 100
kilometers per hour what is the impact
uh to the human when will the airbags
open so all these things are impact test
right it is a measure of the materials
toughness under sudden loading condition
reflecting how much energy it can absorb
during your highspeed impact the
significance of impact test impact force
it could be anything from a hammer blow
to a car collu or a dropped object see
impact force is very important we are
trying to work on a project where in
which a old man or a lady weighing 80
kgs slip down how do we protect them so
that is impact so impact force is very
important shock loading this refers to a
sudden application of large Force such
as an explosion or a rapid change in
pressure for example a blast of a
pressure vessel a blast of a cracker
it's an explosion where in which light
is there huge pressures are there energy
is dissipated and suppose you put put a
a cracker inside a bottle and then blast
it just shatters the bottle right so
that is explosion we use this when we
want to to clad two materials we keep
the two sheet of materials and then keep
a dynamite at the bottom we explode and
they have take the shape so dissimilar
material joining is also used by
explosion Dynamic loads these are loads
that changes rapidly with respect to
time putting additional stress on the
material compared to a static load shock
load and dynamic load Dynamic load means
changing with respect to time so charp
impact test is done for it a notched
specimen is struck by a pendulum hammer
and the energy absorbed during fracture
is measured in outcome the energy
absorbed indicates the material's
toughness and resistance to impact use
case commonly used for materials and
polymers to determine the behavior under
a sudden loading condition so the
procedure is similar to charp test but
with a specimen clamped vertical and
struck at a notch the outcome is measure
the material resistance to impact with
different Notch orientation uh use cases
frequently used for plastic and
materials to compare the impact
resistance so impact finds lot of
application in automobile engineering
and also in safety equipment a person
trying to climb uh a wall uh and all of
a sudden he slips so there is a impact
load the cable whatever he has tied
around him should protect him from
falling same way with respect to lift
when the lift is going up elevator is
going up all of a sudden if there is a
power cut there will be your immediate
arrest of the cable moving up or down so
at that instant there is a huge impact
load which comes to the cable so
automobile components essential for
parts that need to absorb uh collu
energy to protect passengers and reduce
vehicle damage the car bumpers and
crumbles zones engineered to absorb
impact Force the safety equipments as I
told you critical for personal
protection equipments that must protect
from huge or a very high impact Force
helmets and protective gears designed to
absorb and dissipate impact energy when
we use polycarbonates today we are using
polycarbon polymers are getting replaced
uh or metals are getting replaced by
polymers polycarbonate is finding out
lot of application today known for his
high impact resistance it is suitable uh
for applications where transparency and
toughness are required for example glass
or when you go to museums when you walk
through the museums there are
transparent partition which which
partitions between you and the fish tank
or something like that so there there is
lot of impact load use cases used in
bulletproof glass and protective uh
eyewears providing reliable protection
against impact while maintaining uh
visibility so protective eyear when
there is a impact it has to when there
is a stone hitting it should not
shatter the next uh property for
discussion is going to be creep creep is
a Time dependent phenomena you try to
take a polymer okay an example is many
of times we try to hang a flower pots in
our house uh tied to a polymer to a hook
at some point of time the polymer gives
off and then the the floor part falls
down and crashes what is the phenomena
the phenomena is nothing but the creep
Behavior creep Behavior creep is a Time
dependent deformation because of the
weight the polymer slowly deforms it is
with respect to time it gives away that
occurs in the material subjected to a
constant stress load at elevated
temperature as far as polymer is
concerned we are talking about room
temperature when you talk about Metals
it is at elevated temperature a Time
dependent deformation constant stress at
elevated temperature is creep the
material under goes slow plastic
deformation without any significant
increase in the applied stress so you
can see here turbine blades it under
goes a creep uh phenomena with respect
to temperature or with respect to
pressure or with respect to uh fluid
flow essentially the materials stretches
or deforms gradually under a sustained
load and high temperature whenever a
flight lands the immediately the the
airlines engineer right he just goes
towards the fan of the Aeroplane and
then he checks all the blades whether
there is any visible crack or damage
which is seen because of creep
Behavior the importance of understanding
creep creep is a crucial consideration
for engineers working with materials in
high temperature applications such as
turbine
blades
turbine blades in
jet
engines and power
plant next pressure
vessel in
chemical
processing then
nuclear
reactor
components then you have high
temperature pipelines petroleum
pipelines gasoline pipelines sometimes
they use it so all these places the
creep is a very very important property
to be measured how does it uh being
measured the creep is always done by a
creep test the procedure is the sample
is subjected to a constant load at a
specific temperature and the deformation
is measured over time creep tests are
long duration tests today we have
accelerated creep test uh rigs also data
analysis the test uh result are used to
plot a creep curve showing strain versus
time and to identify the material creep
rate and
stages so here showing strains versus
time
strain this is time you see the property
so creep applications turbine blades
nuclear reactors in turbine blades it's
the purpose is used in jet engines and
uh Power uh generation turbines
operating at a high temperature and
stress material which are used are
nickel based Alloys which resist creep
deformation these are all nickel based
allies are all new latest exotic
materials they develop these materials
to meet out to the requirement nuclear
reactors structural component exposed to
high temperature and radiation stainless
steel and other elements again this is a
material which gets evolved so here it
is like a cycle Manufacturing
and
application it is a process which goes
like this you try to manufacture a
material to meet the application
whatever you do application then if it
is not good you go for this and in
between step comes the property
valuation right manufacturer before it
is found to application you do property
check creep application after the
application is done again on the service
condition here it is uh your specimen
here it is a service condition material
so then you try to improve the
manufacturing so it's a cycle which goes
nickel based super Alloys in turbine
blades designed to maintain mechanical
properties at very high temperatures the
performance is these super Alloys resist
creep deformation ensures the turbine
blade efficiently and safely over
extended period to recap in this lecture
we saw what is hardness how is it
typically measured what are the
different types of hardness brenal
hardness which is ball IND under rock
well which is uh Diamond IND under or a
tip IND under uh Define toughness
explain how it is different from
hardness how does charp test work in
Impact what is the definition for creep
and what type of test is used to measure
creep
properties today you will try to see two
examples which is do it by
yourself first example is or uh do it by
yourself problem first one is you will
try to take a water bottle of half a
liter water
bottle half a liter uh which is
predominantly plastic
which is uh which is sold in the shops
right so plastic bottles and then you
will try to fill the
bottle with 1/
14
half 34 and one for example 1/4 level
1/2 level 34 level and 1 full level you
will fill it up with water and close the
lid and then jump on it
and then jump jump on it see the
response of the material in terms of
impact and in terms of uh energy
absorption right next you will try to
take a plastic
wire right plastic wire or
rope tie it up with a weight
of
maybe uh 5
kgs you have to choose a rope which can
withstand 5 K 5 kgs and then you will
tie it
up then you try to increase the
temperature at the mid level so you are
trying to take a wire you have a weight
which is attached to it and here what
you do is you try to heat it
okay load is there and try to heat with
increasing temperature see what happens
to the entire
response so this will try to give you a
feel for creep okay so these two
examples I want you to try so that you
can understand and appreciate the
lecture whatever we have gone through
these are the references which we have
used uh in this lecture thank you very
much much
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
