Wild Flailing with SHARP Swords... How About No?

Ancient Edge
3 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 6, 2024
I'm late to the party on this, but the old safety vs. reality controversy in martial arts is still worth discussion. A couple of years ago the group Holmgang Hamburg drew some attention with videos that show them fight with sharp blades and no protective gear aside from helmets and gloves.
Well, it's a week after Halloween, but there's one more spooky topic I'd like to talk about.
Practice with sharp swords.
So this is one where I'm late to the party. People made videos about this back in
2017, I think, inspired by videos on the Holmgang Hamburg channel, where people actually...
I can't say it. S-P-A-R with sharp blades. You'll see why I have trouble with that word in a moment.
And people asked me about them in the past. Just today, there was another new comment about this
topic. And I figured, you know what, I might as well finally talk about it. Normally, I like to
stay away from drama and whatever, but I think this is useful to talk about. I don't know if they
Anyway, so when seeing stuff like that, it's easy to just think, oh, great, they're just doing this
to bolster their own ego, to feel all macho and whatever. And by the way, recklessness is not a
sign of masculinity. Recklessness is a sign of immaturity, just to point that out. But let's
give them the benefit of the doubt and say they're doing it for more sensible reasons.
There are benefits from practicing with sharp blades. Don't do it, by the way. If you're
watching this and you don't have a lot of experience, if you're not a HEMA instructor,
etc., do not ever, ever practice with sharp blades. Okay, just to get that out of the way.
However, there are some benefits, namely, sharp blades behave differently than blunt ones.
In the bind, when two swords meet, if they are blunt, you can do this all day. You can
slide the edges against one another and it makes pretty sounds. With synthetics,
it's even more obvious. Trying to do binding and winding plays with these is like trying to
stop yourself on a skateboard at full speed by dragging a greasy garlic finger across a wall.
Now, sharp blades, on the other hand, it's a different story. They stick.
I can't just drag the blade. I mean, with light pressure, I can. With light pressure,
I can drag them all I want. But if I actually press, then they're not going anywhere. Which
is why if you want to thrust from bind, for example, you either wind your edge against their
flat or your flat against their edge. The problem is these guys don't seem to know what binding and
winding is. It's not happening in any of the videos I saw, which is very ironic because here's
another issue. Safety, of course, goes out the window if you do stuff like what they do. Even
with the exposed arms in particular, you don't even have the protection from sturdy clothing,
which they would have had back in the day in a duel. There's some level of protection
that clothing offers, especially back then on the 15th, 16th century. That's a pretty sturdy
clothing, so it can be effective against light contact, against slicing cuts to an extent,
whereas bare skin is a lot easier to cut. So the other potential benefit you might get out of this
is the added sense of danger. So if you know that this can seriously injure you if you don't defend
yourself, you should defend yourself better, right? And this is one of the issues in HEMA practice.
People just often kind of rush in, especially in tournaments. If you get an afterblow,
yeah, you may get points deducted, but depending on how they do it in the tournament,
how the scoring system is, it might still be beneficial to land a cut or thrust and then
receive an afterblow. In real life, that's no bueno. If you mortally wound your opponent and
then you receive the same, nobody wins. Everybody loses. But, and that's a big one right here,
they don't do that either. If you look at the videos, they're not really concerned with
protecting themselves. They just just go in, they just try to land a hit. This is where blade
contact comes into play. And it's also something that I recently thought about in a different way,
because until now, I didn't practice a whole lot of binding and winding when I was with the HEMA
school blood and iron. That was just not the main focus. They might have changed it since then.
And we did binding and winding plays as well. But the main focus was on cut parry counter,
basically. And so now the instructor that I'm practicing with now has a different approach.
He's all about work from the bind. The benefit of that is that it's safer for both. Because if
there's blade contact, you just get more information than just looking at what the
opponent is doing. You feel it as well. For example, if you're in a bind with the opponent's
blade and you feel no pressure, meaning they're soft or weak in the bind, you can just go ahead
and thrust in the face, basically, making sure to cross the line so that you displace the sword and
come in for a thrust of your own. If you do feel pressure, if they are strong or hard in the bind,
then you can't do that. If there's pressure going in that direction, I thrust, it's just going to
be displaced and then I might receive a thrust in the face at the same time. So in that case,
I might have to use a disengage, basically. And then I can either thrust, I can do it in various
ways, control the blade, I can dip under with a cut, things like that. So it gives you more
information about what's going on. Also, you're behind your sword. So there's a certain level of
protection there because your opponent needs to get past your blade to be able to threaten you
with a thrust or a cut. And the historical manuscripts are full of that. Once you get into
a certain distance, the Krieg or war, that's a distance where you don't have to take a step to
reach the opponent. You can just keep cutting. This becomes really dangerous if both just
flail like crazy and just try to hit each other because it's way faster. For example, if I'm over
here, I cannot reach you. All right. And by the way, I've never cut my camera. For some reason,
it's one of those very frequent questions. So from here, I would have to take a step forward
to be able to reach, which of course you can see. So this takes longer. Whereas if I'm already here,
boom, this is all it takes. So I can quickly throw cuts from here and it just becomes more
dangerous. And the problem is that was what the guys at Honggang Hamburg were doing.
They would just come in and cut right side, left side, right side, left side, things like that.
And there is no attempt to control the opponent's blade and also no thrusts. Obviously, if you have
a sword with a point, you cannot do this. It doesn't matter how much you think you are.
You can't be running each other through with pointed blades. And that's the other big issue
here. If your main goal is keeping it as close to reality as possible, being worried about getting
hit and all of the implications of real combat with sharp blades, you're not doing it right.
Simply, if you just take out thrusts completely with some weapons, that may be acceptable.
Long swords, no. Thrusts are an essential part of long sword fighting. And the other issue, and
it's the reason why I grabbed the bronze blade here, is what kind of sharpness are we even talking
about here? Because this right here is sharp in the sense that it has an edge, and I've used it
for cutting. But it's not super sharp, okay? I can lightly drag it across my hand. I'm not going to
immediately cut myself wide open. If I did this properly, yeah, I would cut myself. And if you
throw a cut like this, then yeah, you're gonna cut, but you're not gonna, you know, sever an arm
or cut halfway through it or cut into bone or through bone at least. Things like that. Now, this
on the other hand, there's no way to mess around with this and not get seriously hurt or worse.
Even just this, okay? Just a quick little snipe to the hand would just, it would destroy it.
It would sever tendons. It would cut through the small bones in the hand. It's just, it would be
a disaster. Let alone a cut to the leg, which you see a lot in the videos. If you were to actually
throw a committed cut with this to the leg, it's gone. Just straight up. Even just a slice with
this would be quite dangerous. Now, I will say there is one valuable thing about all of this,
which is it shows that light cuts, even to the arms, are not necessarily a fight stopper. There
was one case where one of the guys got cut in the forearm. I'm not gonna show you that in detail
because otherwise YouTube's gonna flag it as whatever, violent, offensive, etc. But you can see
in the video that the cut was deep enough to gape open and he didn't notice. The other guy had to
point out, hey, you got a cut on your arm. He didn't even realize. So, that did not stop him. He could
still continue fighting. So, this is one of the fundamental challenges of calling hits and scoring
and whatnot. Because sometimes, yeah, it can be difficult to say, was this enough? Either way, any
kind of cut that you receive in historical combat would be bad, obviously. You know, death by a
thousand cuts, all of that. Every injury you receive would hinder your ability to fight. And by the way,
there is a productive way of doing this. I'll put a link to a video down below of actual practice with
sharp blades. But it was done very differently. For one, with protective gear. And two, with the points
removed. So, that way, it is still safe to use thrusts. If you do it in a controlled manner,
it is safe if you have enough experience. Again, please don't do this yourself. What I saw in those
Holmgang Hamburg videos is just doing it wrong in more ways than one. It's not just a safety issue.
It's also an issue of what the hell are you doing. Because it's clearly not based on historical
techniques. None of it. The stances are off. The ways they perform cuts. The lack of thrusts. Again,
whatever it is, it's not historical combat. Or, and this is an important point, it's not skilled
historical combat. Because yes, you do have to keep in mind that not everybody was a master
back then, obviously. There were people who carried swords, who were not terribly proficient with them,
or who didn't receive formal training and just kind of figured things out by themselves.
And so, here's where the value of the formal training comes in. Because if you have two people
assuming their equal physical fitness, and one just is self-taught and has some hands-on experience,
and the other actually knows the actual techniques, there's no way the amateur is going to
have much of a chance. For example, in the bind, if you haven't practiced it, you don't know
what to do. If you suddenly end up in a bind, and your opponent starts to wind and thrust for you,
you're like, what? And that's it. And there are ways to control the fight through subtle framing that
an untrained opponent may simply not realize. For example, again, Zayan, the HEMA instructor that I
currently practice with, has a way of positioning himself in such a way that one angle of attack
is basically closed off. His point is crossing the line and is threatening me. He can easily
perform what is called an absetzen, or setting off, where you catch the opponent's cut on your blade
while thrusting at the same time. So you're defending while threatening them. So you can't
just rush in and cut to that side, because that gets me killed. Your own protection needs to come
first. And there are issues with just going in for a bunch of committed cuts. Now I'm all for
strong committed cuts that can, you know, sever limbs and just end the fight right there.
But I definitely notice against this sort of defensive blade contact oriented fighting style
is very dangerous. Also because of how exposed the hands and arms are. Even if I make sure to
keep everything tucked in and lead with the blade, it still puts my hands forward where they
can be counter-cut. Because one of the safest ways to defend and counter is to simply step back so
that you're out of your opponent's measure and cut to the arms or hands at the same time. Because
then the hands and arms are within reach, but the body is not. So you're not in danger in that way.
Leads me to another point about how long sword fights can last, but I should cover that in a
separate video because it's getting too long. So in short, there are certain benefits from
practicing with sharp blades, but there are obviously also serious risks. And depending
on how you do it, you may not really get the benefits you're looking for. Because here's
the thing. If you want to make it more dangerous in the sense that you discourage reckless charges
and just opening yourself up for counters, there's a way to do that safely with blunt swords,
with protective gear. Hit them harder, basically. If you agree to strike each other harder to
discourage opening yourselves up, that's a way to do it. If it hurts, you're not as likely to just
charge in blindly. Which, of course, is still dangerous. Especially, you can't really hit each
other hard on the head because that can cause cumulative brain damage over time. And of course,
there's also a risk for other injuries, even with blunt swords. The risks and benefits have to be
weighed accordingly. And you have to keep in mind that whatever we do, however much we try to hone
our practice, it's never going to be exactly the same. It's always going to be an approximation.
And we can claim with 100% certainty that we understand exactly how a technique is meant to
be used. There's also the fact that fighting unarmored without any protective gear, not even
helmets or fencing masks or gloves, is different than sparring with gear. And of course, trying to
kill or wound the opponent for real while preventing them from doing the same to you
is just always going to be different from sparring. You can just approximate it and do it as well as
possible. This is not the way. It honestly isn't. That's all I've got for now. Hope you found it
interesting. Thanks for watching and have a good one, folks. Be safe, be smart. Thanks for watching.
Thanks for retching. You might as well retch at some of the stuff that's going on there.
