Obscure Weapons! ANCIENT CHINESE SWORD AND BUCKLER... with a difference

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
4 Video Views·May 2, 2025
Hey folks, Matt Eason here, scholar gladiator. So I've got a treat for you now, this is part of my
obscure weapons series and these are two weapons that are obscure only to modern audiences,
certainly modern western audiences. In their time they actually would have been very well-known
objects but they are really really not well-known today, hence I think they fit into the obscure
weapons series. Now both of these are replicas and both of these are from LK Chen, the
manufacturer of historical Chinese weapons. So there you go, so firstly they're both Chinese
weapons and these are both things that existed at the same time and were used together and that
might literally blow your mind. Okay so the first one is a sword. Now many people will be familiar
through my channel with western swords like this sabre here or various types of basket hilt which
have developed hand protection and we often talk about the kind of evolution of swords from a very
kind of European point of view but if we go to China what we find is all the way back around
1AD essentially, so in the Han dynasty, there were lots of things that existed which then didn't
exist again until much much later in some cases in Europe and this is certainly one of these as
an example. The other one actually has a parallel in India which I'll talk about. So the first thing
we're going to talk about is a sword and this is a type of jian. Now a jian is a straight double-edged
Chinese sword, you all know what a jian is, I've shown lots of types of jian on my channel and
they're fairly well-known swords, they're certainly not obscure, but this type is not well-known at
all. Now that's right, it has a massive hand guard on it. Now the Han dynasty, when was that? So we're
talking about approximately 200 BC to 200 AD, so sort of the Roman era if you want to think of it
like that in Europe, and additionally, so 2,000 years ago, and additionally this was I believe the
second imperial period in China. So the Han dynasty was incredibly powerful, developed, very high
technology for the period, but there were lots of things that came about during the Han dynasty in
China which we don't really see again until later in other periods in other places in the world,
and one of those things is fencing schools, that's right. So in the Han dynasty fencing was a very
popular activity and to some degree fencing weapons diverged from typical battlefield weapons, so
and this applies to both objects I'm going to show in this video. So indeed we see specialised swords
developed around fencing. Now when we're talking about what do we mean by fencing? Well essentially
we mean swordsmanship schools, so there were professional swordsmanship teachers, different
lineages, different schools, just like we see in later periods in Europe or in Japan or various
other places, India, so there were different lineages of fencing instruction and the swords,
and also duelling as well, so there was a duelling culture and those two things often go hand in hand
because as you'll know from any kung fu film or kind of Akira Kurosawa, you know, samurai movie,
when you get people practicing lots of martial arts a lot of those martial arts students then
go out and fight each other, it's just kind of something that happens, and this happened in
medieval and renaissance Europe as well, very well documented, and was one of the reasons that fencing
schools in certain places like England and France were during the middle ages regulated because they
were often places where trouble started, so often, you know, a fight between two rival martial arts
schools might break out into a riot and boom, you know, the powers that be, the monarchs and
their officials were having to deal with the fallout of it, so simply when you get these
rival martial arts schools, not only do you get a culture of duelling, which we see right the way
through Europe's medieval and renaissance period, equally you see it in Japan, particularly in the,
shall we say, the not so much the 16th but more the 17th and 18th and 19th centuries,
and that happened in China as well, so obviously it's not hugely well documented, so we don't know
a colossal amount, we don't know, for example, as far as I know, we don't know anything
about the Han dynasty actual fencing teachers or the different systems or their schools,
no treatises or manuals survived from that time unfortunately, so it's all reconstructive
kind of experimental archaeology if you want to call it that. Now let's look at the sword, so
this was a divergence from the mainstream jian in a number of ways, so first of all, as you can see,
it has a rapier-like blade, in fact if I just grab a rapier off the wall here,
okay, so this is modelled on an English rapier of the middle of the 17th century,
you'll notice the blades are similar lengths, similar widths, similar distal taper, similar
weights, they move quite similarly, there is a lot of parallel certainly in the blade between
this 2,000 year old jian design and the 17th century European rapier, just hang that back up,
there we go, so first of all the blade seems to be quite specialised towards civilian duelling,
optimised for using the thrust but also can deliver an effective thrust, and I tell you this
is a sharp blade and I absolutely wouldn't, you know, some people say rapiers can't cut, well
it depends on the type of rapier, it depends whether it's sharp or not and what the cross
section of the blade is and the width of the blade and blah blah blah, but the fact is that
you absolutely, you can probably hear the swoosh from that, would not want to get one of those,
you know, wearing normal clothes, wearing your typical dress and without anything protecting
your head and that kind of, and hands and that kind of stuff, you absolutely wouldn't want to
take a cut from this very fast moving, very sharp blade, very similar to lots of rapiers,
similar to certain types of spadroon as well later on, now the unusual part about this is really the
hilt, okay, so we do find blades like these on some battlefield or warlike jian, but then we
normally only have a small guard on those swords, for a number of reasons probably, probably largely
because you're going to be wearing the sword most of the time and your main weapon is going to be a
bow or a spear or perhaps a halberd, glaive type thing, but primarily this is a sidearm so you want
to be able to wear it, now you'll notice this is quite inconvenient to wear and in that sense it
has some parallels with things like basket hilts which are fantastic hand protection but they're
not very nice to wear and so things like sabre hilts which are open at the sides are a good kind
of compromise because you've got a good amount of hand protection and open sides, but one thing I
should say is we don't have an awful lot of these surviving, they appear in Hand Dynasty art and we
do have some archaeological surviving examples, this is based as far as I understand on one
particular one that was found archaeologically which has a large plate, this is pretty much the
most protective type, we'll talk about the actual plate in a minute, there are other types of these
which just have a knuckle bow, okay, but nevertheless a knuckle bow is, we'll just grab a sword with a
knuckle bow, so here's an 18th century hunting hanger with a knuckle bow, a knuckle bow is something we
think of coming about in Europe in the 15th century and then gradually loads of swords have knuckle
bows in the 16th century and from then onwards and again a knuckle bow is a good compromise between
having a, you know, something at the front of the guard to provide more hand protection
but it still being quite easy to wear and not adding much weight and not getting in the way,
this is more akin in some ways to a sabre guard in that it has a large plate on the front but
you will notice because of what was normal for the design of swords and technology at the time
we still have a cross guard in here, so we've got a cross guard and then the plate is attached at
the front and actually links down to the grip, on the archaeological examples this bar seems to go
under here on the front of the tang, so this is sort of different in that we've got a plate added
onto the front of a cross guard, now what's funny actually is that on certain other types of hill,
if I just grab the hunting hanger again, often on European swords the added protection is on the
side, originally side rings or the nagel on a langmesser which becomes a shell guard and on
something like a dusak for example becomes a plate on the side, now that actually tells us
something about the swordsmanship style practiced, the fact that the Chinese Han dynasty
one of this has a plate on the front rather than a plate on the side possibly tells us certain
things about how these swords were being used in their fencing systems and which parts of the hand
were vulnerable, that being said having this large plate on the front does still provide quite a lot
of protection to the side but we should also mention that they were perhaps more commonly
didn't have this plate they perhaps more commonly just had a knuckle bow, okay but nevertheless
it's added hand protection and this is a specialized thing we see in the Han dynasty
2,000 years ago specifically associated with civilians dueling fencing schools, any parallels
with the rapier there that you can think of? So it's almost like really 1,500 years earlier,
so one and a half thousand years earlier in China a lot of the same design choices and decisions
were being made in China with these swords as had been as were going to be made in Renaissance Europe
later. Now I mentioned there were two objects here's the other and this is also it goes with
this often paired with it in the Han dynasty we think according to some of the artwork that
suggests that and it is a specialized object used by civilians as far as we know there are
some limited there is some limited evidence they were perhaps carried by lightly equipped troops
in war as well but we think the current thinking is they were primarily a civilian dueling implement
to be used with a sword either with this or a a dao or a simple jian without the added hand
protection and it's a buckler but it's not just any buckler it's a I think it's called a gorang
if I'm pronouncing that right please correct me if not and it's a very specialized buckler now I'm
going to put the sword down I'll talk about the two together in a minute but it's a very specialized
buckler the first thing you'll probably notice about it is these two iron horns or bars almost
like a sort of buffalo horns on the end now this has some parallel with various other shields that
you can find around the world at the end of the day it might actually originate from what are
known as parrying sticks they use the aborigines in Australia used them for example where essentially
you just have a long stick of wood and you put a hole through the middle of it a bit like a dusak
handle and then you hold it in the middle and that enables you to certainly against spears even
thrown things or even shot things like arrows to knock them off from the side in various different
ways but if you add a buckler in the middle you now gain the ability to more effectively
directly go into cuts that are coming in and engage those cuts like you would do with a shield
so what you've now got is the benefits of a parrying stick with a shield in the middle a
buckler so you can use it as a buckler you can use it for trapping and controlling an opponent's
weapon whether it be a sword a spear or whatever and additionally in the case of this and some of
the surviving ones we have a projecting point here as well which of course you know that you
find on certain types of buckler you find a point usually in the middle more or indeed on a highland
targe and obviously because of the way that the bar grip is constructed that is presumably a
convenient place to put the spike rather than having it in the middle because you can perhaps
make it of one simpler construction having it up there so you've got several different options and
as mentioned these were used with swords and they're shown in artwork being used with swords
and we believe that 2000 years ago in china these were popular dueling instruments so in much the
same as in medieval europe we find sword and buckler and then later on sword and dagger
rapier and dagger it seems like this was the most popular pairing either using the sword by itself
which is probably actually more common or if you wanted to carry a buckler around like this and
this was possibly used by lightly equipped troops perhaps civilians who were in military service
militias and things like that because remember we've got battlefield weapons we've got civilian
weapons they can be specialized but often civilians have to go to war and so they take their civilian
weapons with them and we see the same thing in europe with what we typically class as more
civilian type swords things like the cinco de or certain types of rapier and the small sword which
was undoubtedly specialized really for dueling but the small sword was nevertheless taken to war
so we do see weapons which we might describe as more civilian taken to war anyway okay it happens
so these two weapons incredibly unknown to most people these days but 2000 years ago in china
incredibly well known and in fact probably if there was more documentary evidence if there
were more archaeological examples if it wasn't so damned long ago you know if this was 500 years
ago we're talking about or if they were still using these in the 19th century we'd probably
all know about these but i think it's just amazing that we see parallels and i did mention india
incidentally about these shields so you'll notice there is a strong parallel between this and the
indian madhu shield the madhu usually actually uses horns from a type of antelope i believe
with spikes on the end and has a buckler in the center but in effect it's a very the madhu is a
very very similar object and it even makes me wonder given the uh relationships particularly
if we go back into antiquity between india and china it does make me in both directions
incidentally a lot it's believed that a lot of the martial arts stuff that we see in china
it does make me wonder if these shields used in china were perhaps influenced by early forms of
madhu in india or if the madhu in india was influenced by these chinese shields it could
go in either direction it could be that there was a convergent evolution and they're not connected
at all but in the end they are quite similar objects and i believe used in quite similar ways
the only real notable difference is the chinese version is very clearly hooked at the end whereas
the indian version is more like a stabbing point so um there we go fascinating objects
and i think you should know about them and appreciate them these examples happen to be
from lk chen but they are based on archaeological examples and examples in art from 2000 years ago
amazing things and who would have thought that something like a rapier blade and something
functionally a bit like a saber hilt existed already 2000 years ago and these shields are
super cool and yes in due course i am going to be using i've actually got a pair of these shields
we are going to be using them in sparring in my club now that we're training again we've been
reopened for about three weeks so yes absolutely we're going to have a go at playing with these
with our swords and see what possibilities open up for them i think they're fantastic and i think
they have lots of advantages over a simple buckler the big disadvantage and the obvious reason why i
think they wouldn't catch on most places in most times is they how on earth do you wear it one of
the great things about buckler it's not as good as a shield but a buckler you can wear and carry
anywhere i don't really know how to wear or carry this doesn't seem very convenient at all but this
seems a huge improvement functionally on a normal jian hilt and i do wonder if the systems that
they were practicing must have changed and adapted for the fact that they've got these
massive hilts now i suspect they probably use these more similar to what we see in some of the
back sword and single stick systems in europe in the 17th and 18th centuries and a lot of the
ways that we see the jian the jian typically being used surely if you're just dueling and
fighting for sport or fighting for for honor blood whatever if you've got this hand protection it's
going to change how you fence to a certain degree we do arguably see that in europe when more complex
hand guards start coming along anyway fascinating weapons i hope that they have been interesting for
you and open up new areas of reading and research and and just your general knowledge about what was
around in china 2000 years ago and any of your thoughts any of your further knowledge clarifications
improvements on my pronunciation are welcome right below here in the comments i hope you're
subscribed please give me a like and i'll see you really soon back on the channel for another video
cheers folks thanks for watching we've got extra videos on patreon please give our facebook a like
and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
