Is Pumpkin Pie More American Than Apple Pie? | Delishtory

More Than Recipes
100 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 4, 2024
As American as apple pie? Not anymore! Kae Lani talks about the history of apples and pumpkins in the United States, and makes the case that the humble pumpkin pie better represents the spirit of America.
0:33 - Apples in America
1:02 - Apple Cider
2:01 - Johnny Appleseed
2:58 - Pumpkin Pie
3:32 - American Cookery
4:33 - Conclusion
Delishtory brings you a tasty exploration into our favorite food obsessions. It's delicious, it's history - it's Delishtory!
Kae Lani Palmisano is an Emmy Award-Winning television host, food and travel writer, recipe developer and home cook who loves to explore the journey that food takes to get to the plate.
Delishtory is a production of WHYY.
Apple pie, an all-American dessert,
a slice of patriotism a la mode.
But what if I told you that there was a better candidate
for America's number one pie?
A pie that better captures our nation's spirit.
One that embraces a multitude of cultural influences,
making it uniquely American.
I'm talking about pumpkin pie.
Now hear me out.
What do we really think of
when we think of American as apple pie?
The apples we use for cooking and baking
aren't originally from America.
Yeah, North America has crab apples,
but the culinary ones that we use
were brought to North America by English colonists.
Not only was the apple a tasteful home,
but it was also a commercially viable crop.
Though the apple pie did exist throughout Northern Europe
since the Middle Ages,
a lot of apples grown in America
were used for apple cider.
And I'm not talking about apple juice.
I'm talking about apple hooch.
At the time, settlers were reportedly drinking
about 10.52 ounces of hard cider a day.
To give you an idea of how buzzed these settlers were,
the average American today drinks
about 20 ounces of water in a day.
Sounds like half of your liquid consumption is just booze.
So there was a huge demand for hard apple cider,
which meant that there was also a huge demand for land.
Apples became not just an economic opportunity
to increase apple cider production,
but also a means of westward expansion.
To encourage frontiersmen to settle undesignated land,
private investors created first-come, first-served land deals
to anyone willing to set up a homestead
and help expand the U.S. territories.
They would then be rewarded with a generous parcel of land.
The deal that the Ohio Company of Associates set up,
for example, said that a settler would get first bids
on land if they were able to prove their homestead
by planting 50 apple trees and 20 peach trees
within a three-year span.
This is where the story of Johnny Applete,
or more formally known as Johnny Chapman, comes into play.
Throughout the early 1800s,
Chapman traveled throughout Pennsylvania, Ohio,
Indiana, Illinois, and northern West Virginia,
planting apple orchards, and in doing so,
claiming thousands of acres of land.
He then sold those tracts of land to settlers
and made a fortune.
The problem with these land deals
was that the land was already occupied
by Native American tribes.
Settlers didn't see Native Americans as owning the land
because they weren't using it or maintaining it
in the same ways that they were.
To American settlers, land ownership meant
putting up a fence and cultivating the land.
This idea of land maintenance equating to land ownership
is purely a European concept.
So if by American as apple pie,
we mean as American as coming here from another place
and calling dibs on land that wasn't ours in the beginning,
then yeah, apple pie can totally be considered American
by that logic.
But that's not the only way to define America.
That's why I propose pumpkin pie
as a replacement for America's symbolic pie.
♪ Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey ♪
The pumpkin is in the same family as squash and gourds,
and they're originally from North America,
coming from Mexico over 7,500 years ago.
When European settlers arrived,
they were greeted by a bounty of foods
that were already here, like corn, potatoes, beans,
and of course, the pumpkin.
But Europeans weren't familiar with North American foods.
Their agriculture techniques weren't accustomed
to cultivating these native plants,
and they weren't familiar
with how to prepare these foods either.
That is until 1796, when Amelia Simmons
published one of America's first cookbooks,
American Cookery.
It's right after the Revolutionary War,
and America is in the beginning stages
of establishing its own identity.
We're no longer part of England,
so in addition to creating a new country
and a new government,
we need to create a new culture,
a new culture that sets us apart from the English.
And that meant defining an American cuisine.
Simmons' American Cookery helped to define
early American cuisine
by taking European cooking techniques
and applying them to foods native to North America.
Included in this cookbook is a recipe for a dish
that closely resembles a pumpkin pie,
seasoned with sugar, mace, nutmeg, molasses,
allspice, and ginger,
a spice blend that will later be known as pumpkin spice!
Yeah, pumpkin spice life!
It's not technically the first record
of pumpkin pie in America.
The only reason colonists even knew how to use the pumpkin
was because Native Americans taught them
how to cook the pumpkin over 100 years prior
to American cookery even being published.
But the pumpkin pie is indicative of American cuisine.
Like our Constitution,
American cuisine adapts over time
to reflect the people that are here.
It takes what's already been here
and integrates ingredients and cooking techniques
from other cultural influences
from other places around the world.
As more people from more cultures come to America,
they bring with them their foods from their homelands
that continue to add diversity and deliciousness
to our culinary landscape.
American cuisine isn't like the apple pie,
bringing something from another place
to replace what's already here.
American cuisine is more like the pumpkin pie,
which takes the best that everyone has to offer
and creates something new,
making it American as pumpkin pie.
