Lecture 34 : Carbon Accounting Model (Part-1)

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Sep 6, 2024
[Music]
welcome to the week8 of the course
carbon accounting and sustainable
designs in product life cycle Management
in the last 7 weeks we have discussed
the concept of the product life cycle
management and connected carbon
accounting to
it I have discussed regarding the
PLM its
component its
levels its
integration integration with
Erp and
Mees and then we talked about facility
and consumer where does
Consumer stand when we talk about the
facility
design that is facility consumer
connection we talked about and we talked
about levels of manufacturing within
facility out of the
facility manufacturing
levels and in the last week I talked
about connecting the carbon ad business
data carbon and business
data and there we had different layers
there was a functional layer in which
product design process design was there
and Manufacturing agation system had
been there in the system layer how do
these layers connect with the carbon
layer to capture the data now this
capturing of data we will learn in this
week in this week I will try to give you
certain models where we will work within
facility I'll keep on using the
words
facility
Workshop
Factory or a
firm manufacturing
firm in changeably which means we are
talking about a facility where tangible
products are developed because we are
talking about product life cycle
management I will give you introduction
to service life cycle management to
Applications life cycle management like
you develop applications for Windows for
iOS for Android you develop systems for
services so those also we will discuss
in the end of this week or in the coming
week but right now we are talking about
the product when we're talking about a
product product has to to be
manufactured we talked about the credle
to grave flow of the product and we are
now talking about within facility within
facility means when the product is under
development it is from the design to the
manufacturing after manufacturing goes
to the user that also flow we have
season now within facility how do we
capture the carbon footprint this we
will discuss in this week and I will
talk about manufacturing facility and
its granularity
decomposition and this is the same
decomposition that we discussed in the
last week that is product design was
there and product design different
functions were there different functions
had different parts then we try to talk
about the process design and uh whatever
is there in the product and process
design and facility that will be more
detailed other Concepts like order
management the equipment monitoring
systems the scada those part would be
little out of the scope of the this
lecture
regarding the carbon footprint of a
manufacturing facility we will try to
see
some models when I say models we try to
talk about mathematical
models so there were lot of
relationships lot of equations in this
lecture and uh you might have to go
through some broad equations like for
example carbon footprint total for the
visil is the sum of common footprint
direct and indirect indirect could be
further divided for the material for the
energy and for the waste disposal or
waste treatment so those small equations
you will see and also some detail I will
go into the equations that the
mathematical models when I'll talk about
the part layer and product layer in the
part layer or the product layer I'll
talk about different processes that is I
will talk about
the cutting processes that is
Machining I'll talk about other than
cutting I'll will talk about casting and
forging and some quick introduction to
welding as
well like any product that is to be
manufactured or any component that is to
be fabricated using the cutting process
cutting process is removal of the scrap
from the material and to come up with a
shape whatever is designed so those we
will discuss through this lecture and
then we'll try to talk about the
facility layer carbon fo print this I
will cover first facility layer
footprint and process of manufacturing
facility we will again try to cast a
quick glance upon that we discussed in
the previous weeks as well the
manufacturing
facility quantitative model is the major
part I will cover here
and when I will try to talk about the
facility I will also try to talk about
for
assembly wherever the components are
fabricated finally these are to be
assembled to be a single final product
we'll talk to talk about this in the
context of material energy and waste
disposal and we will see how do we have
the carbon
emissions connected to all of
these so let me start with my layers
that I mentioned in the content slide we
have equipment
layer then we have part
layer then we have
product
layer and complete we have a facility
you call it a facility or call it a
facility layer or
umbrella so we have a manufacturing
Workshop so I'm talking about part layer
if you say I'm only talking about
say part one right this part one let it
be some part that comes from the very
raw material I will say I have a Billet
here right from the buet there are
certain processes the process layer if
you
call the process one then we have
process two and after two process this
converts into a
part and this
part then goes to an
assembly I'll call it
assembly process
one this enters here that is part one
then for all these
processes to work on a
Billet bi L T process one process two we
have equipment in parallel right I would
have on the blet a cutting
equipment I will put a cutting machine
then I have uh processes one and two
which could
be cutting which could be maybe
finishing or anything that is maybe non
cutting just to polish just to paint or
so these are all
again machines or systems here this is
another
layer so this is part one I'm talking
about there will multiple Parts like
those such as this is part one I could
have another part which is made from a
blank blank is a sheet blank maybe I
would say blank 1 to n any number of
blanks are there which in
which
process
one process 2 so
on till
process n makes it to
the part
n this is part n that is procured here
or made here this is
again A Part layer now here I have
layers and this is an assembly
again assembly
process
n there could be assembly equipment as
well so what I'm trying to put here is
different layers in
manufacturing which I will discuss
through the course of this lecture in
which we have a product layer I will put
a product layer
here this I'm talking about a product
equipment layer would be different from
product that is
here this
is equipment
layer and there will be operators there
will be
Manpower I'll just again put it here
they would
be
Manpower
energy or other resources that you have
discussed
in the previous weeks so again down here
we have another layer these two are part
layers so what is my product layer other
than the equipment whatever Parts I am
trying to develop those are the product
layer I will put it in a green envelope
here
so this all
is my product here I am just keeping out
the equipment layer out of it and
complete block that I've have drawn is
our
manufacturing this is my workshop
or facility it could be as I said a
facility work shop Factory firm whatever
you wish to call it and here also we
have other than and here also we have uh
the stock of raw material stock of
Manpower we have logistic
system or we have some uh auxiliary
production systems
auxilary systems I'm talking about
auxilary production systems these all
will be also part of the workshop that
support your equipment and processes to
develop the parts and parts assemble to
make a final product so here I will put
one final assembly that
is my product assembly
product assembly it would be here so
what essentially now is equipment layer
equipment layer is the operation of
equipment operators work
pieces and you need
need operators for them to work on the
[Music]
operations and other energy and
resources so we can divide M flexing
facility into Machining and
non-machining processes Machining
processes may include DET turning
Milling drilling I will show you a video
in the laboratory environment that how
the energy consumption or energy flow
goes when we talk about a machining
setup for non- Machining it could be
anything such as stamping casting
forging assembly anything where cutting
is not happening is non-machining so it
could be I will put it in two
ways Machining
and
non Machining this is one and this is
two this is equipment layer part layer
b as you have seen we are trying to
develop a part through the basic raw
material that is BU entered in part one
blank ended in part n and we are trying
to develop a part which goes through
certain process flows and the part is
processed it could be a machining
process it could be a non- machining
process but specifically for that part
these processes are there so this is
part layer so where I would put a little
detail it
is flow
of
processes then comes product layer
product layer includes all the different
parts and assembly whatever you could
see in the green envelope is my product
layer where collection of all the
products output by the assembly and the
corresponding assembly follow in the
facilities is there the the assembly
processes for each and every product can
include multiple assembly flows multiple
process flows and it only has one target
to come up with the final product here
it
has
multiple process
flows
or multiple
assembly
flows then this all is happening within
a facility or Workshop which contains
all the resources which are being
incurred in development of this product
these resources could be material energy
if you wish to talk about the Manpower
the man hours which are there so that
also could be taken into consideration
so facility layer is the overall layer
that we discussed about where
we have the major I
put
machines manow so it is man material
money material or anything related to
them for example if you talk about
material there would be inventary system
that is holding the material or stock
that I have put here or would be
logistic
systems Logistics inventory I would put
here auxiliary auxiliary means your
uh systems which do not correspond to
the direct carbon emission but it is
there in the facility for example it
could be heating ventil air conditioning
system there could be lighting there
could be the office systems or so
stationary all those part come in the
auxiliary systems here now also in the
equipment itself machines also have uh
multiple inputs in it for example the
lighting in the machine
again the ventilation heating water
supply whatever other things are there
the ventilation
heating water supply and so on I'll just
put
Etc so this is how the layers are there
I'll start from the facility umbrella
for the overall facility how do we
calculate the carbon emissions and what
are the certain quantitative models or
mathematical models of for it and then I
will move to the part layer part layers
from parts to we will try to understand
certain processes and we will then try
to move to the product and try to
understand the overall carbon emission
model for a manuring facility again I
would stress I am talking about a
manfacturing facility in a manufacturing
facility what is happening that we will
talking about that is material when
enters the manufacturing facility will
take as one of the variables material do
goes out of the manufacturing facility
that is the distribution that also will
take one of the variables but majorly
what happens within the facility that we
will take in detail in this lecture now
let me try to First understand the
carbon footprint of a manufacturing
equipment layer for four typical
processes that we will keep discussing
throughout the lecture so four typical
processes that we will discuss would
be
Machining then I
have
forging sand
casting and
assembly carbon
footprint input or carbon footprint
emissions of the manufacturing equipment
layer of these four typical processes we
will try to understand that what are the
process types and what are the
consumption patren for instance if I
have equipment
energy this is one of the parameters
that we will discuss we will discuss
about the raw material
consumption we will talk about the
auxiliary material
consumption auxilary material
consumption and when we are talking
about equipment energy we are talking
about consumption of electric
energy so when we're talking about
energy consumption in equipment here we
are majorly focusing upon the electric
energy other than electric lot
non-electric energy consumptions as well
we'll discuss on
them and these are all the inputs
majorly raw material auxilary material
electric energy or electric energy in
the terms of maybe Machining is majorly
electric all of them would be using
electric energy whatever processes we
are talking about there would be waste
disposal
and direct carbon emission some of the
processes also
give here regarding equipment energy
consumption so all the processes would
consume electric energy that is it is
there in Machining it is there in
forging it is there in sandc casting it
would be there in assembly like even if
you are using a drill machine or if
you're using a hand rotter to screw or
unscrew a nut or a bolt so that is also
consuming electric energy that is in the
assembly itself as well the electric
energy or equipment energy would be
there then raw material consumption in
Machining there will be raw material
there will be scrap coming out in
forging also raw material will be
consumed in sandc casting as well the
raw material will be
your assembly would not use raw material
material only it will assemble whatever
raw material is being supplied to it so
this parameter for raw material
consumption would be absent when we will
talk about the assembly processes carbon
emissions auxiliary material consumption
auxiliary material that is the tools The
Cutting fluids Etc so those would be
there in Machining those would be there
in sand casting those would be there in
assembly in sand casting what are the
auxiliary materials we will have
different components of the sand casting
system it could there are fillets there
are sprew or so those are all auxiliary
materials in assembly there will be
certain system for example for uh taping
there would be tape rolls there would be
painting systems Al those will all be
there in assembly in forging we do not
have any auxiliary material consumption
because forging is a process where
material only changes its shape that is
one shape is converted to the other
shape while pressing while stretching or
any other processes like those then
comes non-electric energy consumption in
Machining majorly or almost all the
energy consumption is from Electric
itself here therefore the non- electric
consumption would be nil here and also
in assembly the nonelectric consumption
would be nil what is non-electric
consumption we will talk about when
we'll talk about forging and sand
casting which has non electric
consumption as well waste disposal is
also there in Machining scrap is there
in forging some the waste disposal is
there in casting waste disposal is there
in assembly I will discard the VTE
disposal input because we are
considering that whatever is coming in
is going out and we are not talking
about the quality control systems here
where maybe one or of a million
component is not uh within the
conformance limit and that is taken away
we are just taking in this model
whatever is coming as an input as parts
to the assembly system is assembled and
that makes a product so it therefore the
waste disposal here is nil then direct
carbon emissions so when we are talking
about the non-electric energy
consumption there would be direct carbon
emissions in forging and sand casting
that is fumes would be there because we
are melting a metal or we are heating a
metal there would be air pollution there
would be water for treatment of the
forged or casted components so direct
carbon are also there which are not
there predominantly in Machining and
assembly I think this table would make
you understand what variables are
present in what kind of the
processes these are processes and here I
have carbon emission
source so with this I have developed a
framework where we will try to Now
understand a quantitative model and
we'll try to understand the
relationships that is the mathematical
relationships in these carbon emission
sources and the processes that in
Machining forging sand casting assembly
majorly I would be talking about the
Machining process and what I'm
discussing in this carbon accounting
model is taken from this different
research Publications as you keep asking
in the Forum what is the source so
multiple research uh Publications were
referred majorly you can visit here at
all in the general of cleaner production
and you will find the maximum models
that I'm discussing in this week and I'm
closing this part of the lecture in the
next part we will start discussing the
mathematical models thank you
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
