FECM Project Briefing: Four Corners Carbon Storage Hub: CarbonSAFE Phase III

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Sep 13, 2024
The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management (FECM) hosted a virtual briefing on the Carbon Storage Assurance Facility Enterprise (CarbonSAFE) Program. In this virtual briefing, FECM program managers and project leads shared more details about the Four Corners Carbon Storage Hub: CarbonSAFE Phase III Project, one of the selected projects.
All right, and thank you and welcome everyone. We're so glad to see so many folks who have been
able to join us today for this briefing. We're here today to discuss the Four Corners Carbon
Storage Hub project. This is an effort being supported by the U.S. Department of Energy's
Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management. We're here today for a number of reasons.
This is an opportunity to connect with both the Department of Energy as well as the project team,
and most importantly, to be able to hear from all of you as members of communities that are near to
the anticipated project sites. So we want to hear from all of you today. We also want to convey some
important information related to the technical nature of the project, its community benefits,
commitments, and the project management, and opportunities to engage as well. So thank you
so much for being here. Next slide, please. Before we begin, there are a few more logistics that we
do want to discuss. So this briefing is being recorded, and after this briefing concludes,
a recording will be posted to the FECM website. There will also be a second recording posted,
which will include a Navajo language translation of the entire proceeding, the entire meeting.
Any of the presentation materials that you see today will also be shared on the FECM website.
And if you registered for this event via email, then expect to receive a follow up
with the presentation information as well. If you have a question at any point in time
for any of the presenters today, or regarding any of the information that's shared,
there is a Q&A button on the control panel in Zoom at the bottom of your screen.
If you click that button, you'll be able to type in and enter a question. We're going to be
reviewing that list of questions later in this briefing. And we'll try to provide answers to
as many questions as possible. And also live captions are available. So that is another
feature that you can utilize if you prefer. Next slide, please. I'm going to quickly just
review our agenda for today. So we're going to start with an overview of the fossil energy and
carbon management program, you're going to be hearing from some folks within FECM,
we'll share information generally about the office, as well as the carbon safe program,
in particular. And then we're going to hear directly from the four corners carbon storage
project team, they're going to provide an overview of the project and talk a bit about
its community benefits as well. After these presentations, we're going to have our Q&A
session. And again, we're going to be using the questions that you submit in the Q&A module
to help to lead and to guide that conversation. We really do want to hear from you and we do hope
that you submit questions today. I'll also note that in the Q&A module, if there are questions
that other people have asked, and you think that we should prioritize them in the discussion,
you do have the option to hit the like or the thumbs up button to indicate that those are
questions that we should prioritize. After the Q&A session, we'll receive some next steps and
some closing remarks from the team at DOE. Next slide, please. I want to quickly provide
the folks from FECM with an opportunity to introduce themselves. These are some of the
folks that you're going to be hearing from during the presentations today. And so Sarah,
we'll start with you. Good evening. I'm Sarah Forbes, and I am the Director for the Office
of Carbon Management Technologies. Good evening. My name is Tracy Rodosta,
and I am a Senior Program Manager for Carbon Transport and Storage.
My name is Bill Aljo. I am the Technology Manager for Carbon Storage Infrastructure,
working for FECM, but at the DOE's National Energy Technology Laboratory.
And I'm Kelly Romer. I am on the Carbon Management Engagement Team,
and looking forward to talking with you today. All right. Thanks so much, everyone. And so now
we're going to hear from Sarah Forbes, who's going to tell us more about FECM.
Thank you. So the Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management, or you've already heard
Emmanuel call it FECM, is divided into two main areas, carbon management and resource
sustainability. The project we're going to talk about today and the team that you'll be
hearing from are on the Carbon Management Team. And we are working at research level,
doing engineering studies, bench scale research, small pilots, and demonstrations of carbon
management technologies. So carbon management, what is it? It's a system of technologies.
It includes point source carbon capture and carbon dioxide removal. So taking carbon dioxide
out of emission streams from industrial sources, or removing it directly from the air through
carbon dioxide removal. The captured carbon dioxide then needs to be transported for either
conversion into useful products, such as fuels, chemicals, plastics, cement, building materials,
or put in permanent geologic storage. Next. This is an organizational chart of our office.
And you can see it's divided into two primary areas. So my office, the Office of Carbon
Management Technologies, includes five research divisions. We do research on hydrogen with carbon
management, carbon transport and storage, carbon dioxide removal, carbon conversion,
and point source carbon capture. We also have a component of our office that's focused on
engagement, policy and analysis, and partnerships with other federal agencies. I included this slide
to give a picture of the cycle of research and development. It's core to the way we think about
things at DOE. I want to just take a minute to talk about it. Emerging technologies are low
in technical maturity. That's where universities and laboratories do foundational science and
discovery. Once a technology matures, it may move on to applied research and development and
activities that de-risk the technology. If that's successful, it will move forward to
pilot scale and validation. If that's successful, then large-scale demonstration. And finally,
at-scale deployment. Today, if you look across our research and development activities
at the Department of Energy, we've invested across this continuum. With the passage of
the bipartisan infrastructure law and the Inflation Reduction Act, we're seeing increased
investment in pilot demonstrations and hubs across clean energy technologies, including carbon
management. The Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management recognizes that for federal investments
and projects to be successfully deployed and meet our net zero emissions goals,
a broad understanding and meaningful engagement and participation of local communities and
stakeholders, particularly those with environmental justice concerns, will be critical.
Our engagement office is working to scale up engagement efforts that include things like
developing educational materials and resources so that communities have information they need
to evaluate a potential project, and developing social considerations and impact guidance,
implementing community benefit plan frameworks across the department. It's an exciting time,
and meeting with you all tonight is part of that. Next. So, from a DOE perspective,
we understand and value the importance of doing this, of doing engagement.
The Department of Energy teams, including our team from Fossil Energy and Carbon Management,
have been engaging around the country where project development is expected to occur
to increase awareness about carbon management technologies, the community benefit plans
requirements, to ensure community and stakeholder participation are possible, and to learn about
community questions and concerns. Over the last year, we've hosted and sponsored several engagement
opportunities that integrate these principles. Last year in November, we sponsored a carbon
management dialogue in Houston, Texas, and this past April, we had a carbon management workshop
in Pueblo, Colorado. We're planning to continue a series of community engagement workshops this
year in other areas of the country where project development is being considered, and we're
committed to hosting one of these workshops in northwest New Mexico in early 2025. For more
information as it comes, please keep an eye on the FECM event calendar or send a note to the
engagement email, which will be in these slides. And with that, I will conclude my remarks and turn
it over to Tracy to share more about the Carbon SAFE program. Thank you all. Thank you, Sarah.
Next slide, please. Thank you. So, as I mentioned, Fossil Energy and Carbon Management, or FECM,
has had more than 20 years of experience following a methodical approach to scaling up
carbon storage. We've developed and validated technologies, and then through the regional
carbon sequestration partnerships, pictured on this slide here, we've demonstrated the readiness
for commercial-scale storage. We started with the regional characterization to understand storage
potential and carbon emissions throughout the U.S. Then we moved to the small-scale projects,
validating regions with the most promising storage opportunities. Next, large-scale
projects were then conducted to verify risk assessment and mitigation processes. These
projects also included stakeholder engagement, validating monitoring technologies, and optimizing
operational parameters. In 2017, FECM initiated the Carbon Storage Facility Assurance, or Carbon
SAFE program. It began conducting commercial-scale site characterization that was required for
developing the storage infrastructure for the future carbon capture facilities. Next slide, please.
Now, this site selection and characterization process, or this process, there are several
critical components when planning a CO2 storage project. These include some like subsurface
geology, the CO2 emissions, transportation, and community involvement. A key consideration, though,
is the subsurface characteristics. For example, the types of rocks underground and their properties.
These characteristics can vary from region to region. Some regions have suitable rocks and
properties for permanent storage of CO2, while others do not. So the subsurface data collection,
as you can see at the left side, begins at the basin scale, and then smaller subregions are
identified. And as more data is collected, the project will move until a site is selected.
A specific site characterization that occurs is a very thorough evaluation, and a lot of
subsurface data is collected and analyzed to demonstrate to the Environmental Protection
Agency, or the EPA, that the site will contain the CO2. So you're probably wondering what types of
characterization activities occur at these sites. Next slide, please. So we wanted to show you what
some of these characteristic activities are. This slide shows all four phases of the Carbon SAFE
program, and the pictures you see here represent some of the activities conducted during each of
the four phases. For example, during the storage feasibility phase two, you will see a drilling rig
collecting core samples, and a picture of the core samples is shown underneath the phase two
on this slide. And during the site characterization and permitting phase, or phase three, you may see
these large trucks conducting a 3D seismic survey. And these surveys use sound waves to create an
image of the subsurface, like you see in the picture below with the wavy lines underneath
phase three. And you may also see additional drilling rigs come in to drill additional wells
to verify the extent of the storage reservoir and the sealing rocks. All of this information
is integrated to develop computer models that will predict the extent of the CO2
storage underground. This is called the area of review for CO2, and the area review is that area
that will be monitored over the life of the project. So if you look at the bottom of the
slide, you also see that community benefit plans are required across all phases of the project,
from feasibility through site characterization and construction. And my colleague, Kelly Romer,
will speak more to those plans in a few minutes. But first, my colleague Bill Aljo will provide
more information about the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA, and class six permitting
processing, including where the community can engage. Thank you, Tracy. The one thing I should
mention about the carbon safe program, particularly its phased approach, there is no construction
until phase four. So the project you're going to hear more about tonight, the Four Corners project,
is a phase three project. So it is not actually going to construct a storage facility on this
project. It will have to get a separate award for construction if construction of the facility is to
ever occur. But what I'm going to explain here is the National Energy Policy Act, or NEPA,
process as it applies to a phase three project, which, as Tracy mentioned, is simply the site
characterization and acquiring permit. And part of this phase three process is getting approval,
or not necessarily approval, having an analysis done by the federal government under the National
Energy Policy Act of the whole project through phase four, with the idea that if they ever
intend to construct, they have to have a NEPA analysis of their entire project. That analysis
of the entire project is done during phase three. However, the project itself in terms of
construction is not done until phase four. I want to make that clear up front. So what I want to do
here with this flowchart is walk you through some of the public engagement opportunities that may
exist during the course of the phase three project, which is the project we're speaking about tonight.
And this is a general approach, not for the specific Four Corners project. It applies to
all phase three characterization and permitting projects. It starts out with the application to
the Funding Opportunity Announcement. Every applicant submits what's called an environmental
questionnaire, or an EQ, for every single work site at which work will be done under the phase
three project. These environmental questionnaires are fairly extensive. They're about 30 pages long.
They ask what are the attributes of the site, sites at which work will be done, and the nature
of the activities. Most of the work in phase three is going to be office space. So the impacts of
that work is fairly small. And they usually get what's called a CX or a categorical exclusion
from NEPA activities. And a CX doesn't mean we don't, we ignore things. A CX means that the
activity under question is well defined. It's been done many, many times before. And the DOE
has a very good understanding of what the impacts are. In most cases, there will be a categorical
exclusion. A couple exceptions would be for activities that occur in the field. In many
phase three projects, it's drilling a well, or doing a seismic survey. Those specific activities
still can and do receive categorical exclusions. However, the level of information that has to be
provided is much greater. And it can take several months or more before the full impact can be
assessed and the NEPA office can decide whether or not a categorical exclusion is warranted.
The project can actually be awarded while this process is going on. The recipient of the award
will just not be able to undertake those activities at sites for which a NEPA determination
or a categorical exclusion has not been obtained. If it is decided that a categorical exclusion is
not warranted, it goes to an EA or an EIS, which I'll explain in just a minute. Anyway, the next
step in the process is that the award recipient submits what's called an EIV or environmental
information volume. Now, that covers the entire carbon capture and storage operation
from the beginning of capture through the end of storage and in the post-closure period.
The recipient's best estimates of what that project will be from soup to nuts.
Even though not all that work is being done in phase three, the environmental information volume
has to cover that. And because it stems from the NEPA philosophy that if we do not build this
storage site, we're going to assume for the moment that it is going to get built under phase four.
Every action that occurs because of the existence of that site has to be considered and the impacts
of that have to be considered. So it's a fairly extensive analysis. And anyway, the NEPA office
reviews the information in the environmental information volume and makes a determination.
Is this an EA or an environmental assessment? Or does this warrant an environmental impact statement?
An environmental assessment is a still fairly thorough review, but not as extensive as an
environmental impact statement. And the federal law says that an environmental assessment has to
be completed with one year and an environmental impact statement has to be completed within two
years after this determination is made in the green circle on the right. And that those are
events that occur in the first year of the project. If it is decided that an environmental
impact statement is needed, the public has a chance for involvement during what's called
the scoping period, whereby the award or let's call it the award recipient or the project proponent
and DOE and the public decide what should be the scope of this environmental impact statement.
The other information or public input I would like to mention, it goes back to, for example,
if there is a seismic survey or if there's well drilling, there have to be permits issued by
at the county and local level. The federal government doesn't have any say in that,
but some county and state and local permitting regulations will require public notification and
perhaps a public involvement. It all depends on the locality. So that is another opportunity that
I didn't put on this slide. If you move down then to the bottom of the slide, going from now from
right to left, DOE is responsible for preparing a draft environmental assessment document or an
impact statement document, again, relying on input from the project recipient to develop that
document. When it is finished, the public comment period is 30 days for if it's an
environmental assessment or 45 days and a second public hearing if it is an environmental impact
statement. I should mention another opportunity in the lower right. While the draft environmental
assessment or EIS is being prepared, the federal government, DOE, is responsible for conducting
consultations with other federal agencies that may be affected by this project and any tribes that
may be affected by this project prior to the release of the draft EA or EIS and prior to the
overall public comment period. After that public comment period, DOE takes all those comments
and responds to every one of them, incorporates the input as needed into the final EA or EIS,
and then that information goes into what's called a FONSI, which is a finding of no significant
impact. That means that it's basically a DOE declaration. It's not a decision per se,
but it is information that will be used in combination with other
factors to determine whether DOE goes ahead with the project. If the impact is found significant
and if it is an environmental assessment, the decision can be made, you know what,
we need to do an environmental impact assessment. We can't find that the impacts are not significant,
therefore, we're going to proceed to a full environmental impact statement.
Now, during this whole process of draft EA or EIS preparation and DOE's decision
or final resolution of the document, the project may submit a Phase 4 application. However,
the Phase 4 construction award may not be started or signed until either a record of decision,
if it's an EIS or a finding of no significant impact, has been signed by DOE. So, they can
apply for a project, but they can't start until the NEPA process completed, which is with a FONSI
or an ROD. And the color coding at the bottom gives you an idea of the time frame. The first,
the light blue is in the pre-award stage, years one and two are the green, years two and three
are the second and third year, and years three is the purple. So, next slide. The other opportunity
is sort of independent of the DOE process, but it is something that the project recipient has
to go through with the Environmental Protection Agency, which is to obtain a permit for every
Class 6 well, every well that they plan to use for CO2 injection. And how that applies to the
Phase 3 project is first, the applicant submits a permit application to EPA, a permit application
to construct. EPA does a sort of a paper review saying, are all the parts here? And if it does,
it moves on to a technical review, which can last up to 18 months. And typically, the carbon
safe Phase 3 activities that are covered under the DOE award is for this technical review period.
Then EPA prepares a draft permit, and then there's a public comment period of 30 to 45 days
after the draft permit to construct. Again, this is not a permit to inject, it is simply a permit
to construct the well. And then public comment period occurs after the draft permit to construct
has been issued. Then all the public comments that come in as part of that public hearing process
go into the final permit. And then after that, there is a period, during construction,
there are a lot of tests that EPA makes the project proponent go through, and a lot of tests
that they make them, and it's all prescribed by EPA. And then finally, and only then do they have
authorization to inject. The thing to remember is that projects cannot apply for a Phase 4
construction award until the class, until that application is at least in the technical review
process. But they cannot receive a Phase 4 award until that final permit is complete, until EPA
has incorporated all public comment and says, okay, you have a permit to construct, only then will a
Phase 4 construction award under carbon safety be issued. And I hope that didn't take too long.
And I'll be glad to take any questions that happen after that. I'll pass it on to Kelly
Romer, who will talk about community benefits. Thank you, Bill. And thanks everyone for tuning
in this evening. Again, my name is Kelly Romer. I support the implementation of the
Community Benefit Plan guidance across our office's portfolio. So what are
Community Benefit Plans, or CBPs? They are a set of plans that aim to address societal
considerations and impacts in federally funded projects. These plans are submitted alongside,
as part of a project's application package, alongside technical elements.
They are reviewed by both internal and external experts who have subject matter expertise
or practitioner experience in the topic areas related to engagement, labor issues, diversity,
equity, inclusion, and accessibility, and environmental justice. And for carbon safe
projects, CBPs make up to 20% of the application's overall score. Next slide, please.
So Community Benefit Plans must address four key priorities that emphasize early and robust
engagement with community and labor stakeholders, high quality jobs and investments in workforce
development, diverse and equitable participation in both employment and other economic
opportunities, and the implementation of the Justice 40 initiative to ensure that benefits
are directed to disadvantaged communities. Next slide. So as Tracy noted, the CBP requirements
applies across technology types and phases of project deployment. So therefore, in projects
and programs like Carbon Safe that are designed in phases, community benefit activities, a lot like
the technical aspects of projects, are expected to build on the engagement and the work from previous
phases. So the scope of the projects that we're discussing today are focused on feasibility and
site characterization and do not include commercial construction during this funding period.
So for these phases, the CBPs emphasize activities that are necessary to establish
that foundation of meaningful engagement and a plan for robust community benefits.
So activities that we emphasize and want to see in CBPs look like dedicating time and resources
to conduct the research, analysis, environmental justice assessments to better understand the
project area and conduct that early engagement with community and labor stakeholders.
It is really important to establish those two-way engagement mechanisms or processes
for incorporating public input into project design and implementation.
And it's just so important that this work happens early in project development because
developing those strong formal agreements that reflect authentic partnerships and community
priorities takes time. And so that was a quick overview, but happy to return to CBP questions
during our discussion. And next, I'll turn it over to William to present an overview of the
selected Carbon Safe Phase 3 project, Four Corners Carbon Storage Hub, that we anticipate being
awarded soon. Thank you. Yeah, thank you, Kaylee, for the quick introduction of our project. So
the title of our project is the Four Corners Carbon Storage Hub, that is Carbon Safe Phase 3.
I am Dr. William Mpuma, a professor at New Mexico Tech and also a research engineer at Petroleum
Recovery Research Center. Please, next slide. I'd like to introduce our team that forms the CBP team.
So we do have, starting from the top left, we do have Mr. John Mision, who is a CBP coordinator.
He's leading the effort, and he's also at New Mexico Tech. We do have Dr. Rinalda Tosi. She's
a professor, Environmental Science Department at NMT. And also, we do have Mr. John Elkasi,
who is also a session head, Industry Outreach at Petroleum Recovery Research Center. We do have
Ms. Jennifer Rainey. She's a deputy director at Petroleum Recovery Research Center here at NMT.
And also, we do have Mr. Wiley Dragmester. He is a contractor on the project, supporting us
on community outreach, and he's with Path 3 Marketing. We do have Dr. Robin Balch. He's
the director of Petroleum Recovery Research Center, and he's the project manager for this project.
We do have Dr. Jenny Schemack. She's economics professor at UNM. We also do have Dr. Shruti
Mishra. She's a social scientist at Sandia National Lab. We do have Mr. Steve Gray. Mr.
Steve Gray is also from the Navajo Nation, and he's supporting us on the community engagement as
well. And I'm William Ampuma. Next slide, please. So, we do have quite a big team that consists
of academic institutions, which is led by New Mexico Tech. New Mexico Tech is the primary
recipient of this award. We do have other universities in the state of New Mexico,
specifically University of New Mexico, UNM, participating with that environmental justice
effort as well. Can you let me move on? Okay, thank you. Let me move on. So, what is the overall
project objectives? Our project is to develop a storage hub within the Falconers region,
and we are going to perform comprehensive site characterization for three sites,
different sites within the San Juan Basin. And all of this is to help to accelerate the
deployment of integrated CCS technology within the region. We are, as part of the comprehensive
site characterization, all the data that we will collect as part of the characterization, and also
the environmental analysis, we are going to put all this information together to prepare, submit,
and attain a UIC-class experiment from the EPA. And in our case, with regards to the three sites
that we're looking at, two of them is on the Navajo land. So, it is going to be through
Region 9, EPA Region 9, and we do have a private land, which is going to be through EPA Region 6.
And each site should be able to store at least a minimum of 50-millimeter tons of CO2.
And we are, as part of the project, we do have extensive saltwater disposal in the basin,
and then also we do have the existing carbon safe project in there. So, we have to do a cumulative
impact effort with regards to all these activities that is going on, and see if we can still be able
to store the CO2 within the three different sites. Next slide. And then also, we have to perform
the environmental information volume. We need to submit that to DOE NEPA for them to make a
determination whether we get a EA or EIS. And once the determination is made, our project team
is going to support DOE-selected contractor to be able to put in a documentation for either EA or
EIS. Now, let me say that since we are operating on the Navajo land, and as Bill said earlier on,
we did not get categorical exclusion for our site characterization efforts. So, that means that there
has to be an additional scrutiny with regards to our environmental efforts to be able to even perform
the site characterization work as part of our event characterization phase three project.
And also, we have to do the CO2 feasibility study to make sure that the source that we picked is
able to produce the amount of CO2 that is required to be injected in the three sites that we've
selected. And also, a pipeline fee study to connect the CO2 source to our storage site. We need to
also do a feed study on that as well. And also, we need to have a risk mitigation plan, especially
when we have multiple activities ongoing in the basin, in addition to the three sites that we
are proposing. So, certainly, we're going to work on a risk mitigation plan. And also, we have to have
a storage flow development plan where we are summarizing all the efforts that we've done
to be able to show that all the three sites do have the maximum capacity to store the amount of
CO2 that is available, whilst minimizing risk. And then also, describing the elements of the
storage facilities and the cost for the proposed project life as well. And also, there has to be
a business and financial plan documentation that needs to be developed as well. And above it all,
the project will execute a community benefit plan. And this will consist of a targeted community
outreach programs to educate the public and promote energy and environmental justice to
ensure that the project benefits are realized by the local and also the regional communities,
including the disadvantaged communities. Next slide. Let me use the slide to show
the interdependencies of what is actually going on right now in the basin with regards to storage
projects that New Mexico Tech is leading. So, I will start with the deep blue triangle.
That is the existing Carbon Safe History Project, where we've already submitted our UIC class
experiment to EPA, and it's currently under technical review. Now, the light blue is one
of the sites that we've proposed to store at least 50 million metric tons of CO2. And also,
the purple or the mauve triangle is the site for – that is also another site, and that site is
divided into two. So, as you go down from where we've located the Four Corners Power Plant, which
is the main source for our project, right within that vicinity, that is where we do have one of
the sites. And as you go to the south, we do have another site as well. And also, Enchant Energy
with ENTEC, also working on the Four Corners Power Plant Integrated CCS Project, which is a
fee-steady project. Now, I must say that with all of these activities going on, the CASP, Four
Corners Regional Initiative Project, brings all of these together, looking at how each project is
impacting the other. So, with this, we can come together – with all this come together to form
the Four Corners Carbon Management Hub within the San Juan Basin. Next slide. So, the question
that will be asked is that, do we have a potential storage within the San Juan Basin? We've started
working in the San Juan Basin since 2020, especially for the carbon save, but our Bureau of
Geology has been working in this basin for a very long time. So, on your left, I'm showing you the
stratigraphic column of the San Juan Basin. If you look at all the way from the top, Oahu Alamo
Sandstone has been identified as the lowest, most USDW, mostly in the areas that we are creating,
which is around 800 feet. And as you go down, we do have existing oil and gas producing zones,
which includes the Foodland Formation, the Pictured Cliff Sandstone, Menifee Point Lookout.
We also do have the Upper Mancos Hill, the Gallip, and then the Dakota. Those are the
predominant gas production zones within the San Juan Basin. Now, our activities is looking at
a saline aquifer that can store the amount of CO2 that we're looking for – that we are looking at.
We've identified as part of our first carbon save project that the Entrada Sandstone Formation
do have enough capacity to store CO2 right at the site where we have the San Juan Basin
carbon save project. We do have the opportunity to extend that, use the information that we got from
or we've learned from this particular project to the other sites as well.
Now, the San Juan Basin, this formation is quite extensive. So, it expands throughout
the area that we are targeting. The Toledo and then the Somerville is going to be the cap rock
that will make sure that the CO2 that we are putting into the Entrada stays in place.
We also do have the Camel, which is beneath the Entrada, to also provide additional sealing
beneath the injection zone as well. Now, as part of this project, the Entrada is our main
injection zone, but we do have the Bluff Sandstone, which could be classified as a secondary
injection zone as well. But most of our efforts is all concentrated in the Entrada Sandstone
Formation. On the right, I'm showing you the geological complex, you know, how complex the
geology in the San Juan Basin is. We do have the yellow shaded region to be the central part of
the basin where most of all our activities are focused on. But there is a hug back structure
that is on the edges of the central part of the basin. And that requires us to be able to
steady the basin to make sure that we can store CO2 successfully without the CO2 moving through
all the way to the hug back, which is more or less exposed to
the surface. And there are some additional geological features that need to be steadied
for us to be able to de-risk the basin to make sure that we can successfully store CO2
within the basin. And we've done some work. We've done quite a number of work through the support
that we received from DOE on our fair site, and we do have the opportunity to extend that to
the other three sites. Next slide. So let me focus on the Four Corners Storage Hub.
What are some of the things that we are going to do? And as Tracy talked about, all the site
characterization that goes through phase one, phase two, phase three. So our project, what are
we going to do? As I said earlier on, we are developing, we are performing detailed site
characterization on three sites within the San Juan Basin. And the Four Corners Power Plant,
which emits at least 10 milliametric tons of CO2 per year, is our main source for this project.
With all the data that we are going to collect, we are going to prepare and submit UIC class
experiment for the three sites to EPA. And as I said earlier on, within our study area, we do have
one region. We do have the Navajo Nation site, which will be permitted through EPA Region 9.
And then also, we do have a private land, which will be permitted through
EPA Region 6. As part of our project, we will meet all the environmental requirements
for the characterization work, and then also for the integrated project. And also,
we will prepare the storage field development plan for the future project activities. And we
will execute the community benefit outcome and objectives as well. So what are the characterization
efforts that we're going to do? We are going to drill two characterization wells to prove
the sites that we are proposing. We are also going to re-enter an existing well to acquire
well locks information to also prove the third site, meaning we are not drilling three wells
to prove three sites. We are drilling two wells, and then also utilizing an existing well within
the basin to also prove the third site. With the two wells that we are going to drill, we are
collecting a combined core of 1,000 feet. And also, we will sample the drilling curtains. And
then also, we will perform or acquire advanced well lock information. We also acquire fluid
sampling to prove that the entrada that is our main target do have a salinity that is more than
10,000 ppm. Other than that, US EPA classified that as an underground source of drinking water.
We will also acquire a 29 square mile, 20 mile square mile 3D seismic on two sites. And we also
license about 50, more than 50 mile 2D seismic lines. And all of this to help us to prove the
sites that we are trying or we are proposing to be able to store CO2. And it's all de-risking
the basin or the sites that we've chosen to make sure that successfully we can store CO2
without any problems or let's say without any potential leakages or any issues contaminating
the underground source of drinking water. All this information and all the analysis, all the data,
we will perform laboratory sieves experiments on the core and also the fluids that we collect
from the subsurface. And we'll incorporate all of them to perform the numerical models.
And that is going to help us to prepare the UIC class experiment applications to be submitted to
EPA. Next slide. So, why the Four Corners Power Plant? And this slide is from the NAV Energy,
which is a part of the ENTAC. And why ENTAC wants to still make sure that this plant continues to
be in operation. The mine and then also the Four Corners Power Plant contributes to 42%
of the Navajo Nation's general fund, specifically in 2022. This mine provides stable jobs and then
also consistent energy resources to the community. And also, the mine and then the
Four Corners Power Plant, as I said earlier on, accounts for significant contribution to
the nation. So, if this plant is to shut down, all these jobs are going to be lost.
And all these resources that is available to the Navajo Nation is going to be lost. So,
definitely, we have to, as scientists, you know, as a university, university tech and all our
partners, our role is to make sure that we can find a home for the CO2. And we are grateful for
DOE for giving us that opportunity to do that. Next slide. So, let's talk about the CBP milestones.
What are we planning to do in terms of our community benefit plan? I've broken them down
into the four categories. So, the first one, the four areas, the first one that I want to talk about
is the community and labor engagement. As part of our project, and if you look at it, we do have
the budget period one, budget period two, budget period three activities that we plan to perform.
We hope to have a community benefits agreement. And in our budget period one, we are going to
look at the parties. And then also, we are going to define the scope. We will identify the scope as
well. And in our second year of the project, we want to be able to have a final agreement drafted.
And the agreement is going to be signed in our BP3. And also, there is a collective baggaging
agreement between the operating jobs. We will identify the unions within our first year of the
project. And then we will report the engagement with the unions. And then also, there is a project
labor agreement. We will identify the parties in our first year. And the scope will be identified.
Initial discussions and the meetings will be held in our second year. And then we will report on
that in the last year. There is also a community workforce agreement that will be in place.
We will identify the parties and also we will identify the scope. We will have discussions.
We will make contacts and then have a stakeholder list. And based on the discussions that we will
have, we will finalize a report in our last year. We will develop outreach materials which will be
provided to the communities, areas that are being impacted by our project to educate them
about the significance of our project. So, there will be annual project meetings. And then also,
we will have a website that will provide more materials about our project to the community as
well. And then also, we will have a community feedback and data incorporated into our project.
So, there are going to be three workshops in budget period one, two workshops in budget period
two, and an additional two workshops in budget period three. Next slide. With regards to investing
in job qualities, as Bill and Kelly pointed out, as part of our project is not construction.
It is a characterization phase. So, there is no construction jobs that we have identified.
But we are going to have commitments to support workforce education and training.
And as you see our team that I introduced today, we do have a professor from the Navajo Nation.
She's going to attract talents from the Navajo Nation to be part of our project
as students. And we also do have discussions with NTU, San Juan College, where we are going
to partner with them to develop training program to also enhance the community to be able to take
advantage of this opportunity that is coming in the area. So, in our year two, we are going to
develop three project fact sheets. And I'll show you one that even though we've not started a
project yet, but whenever we go for some meetings that we've been invited, we hand them over as
well. And we also perform, we also develop training materials as well. We will have assessment of the
economic impact and job creation. How is our project going to impact the communities that
are going to be affected by our efforts? In our second year, we'll have initial white paper on
economic and job creation impact. And it will be revised and a final paper will be delivered
at the last year. Next slide. With regards to diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility,
we definitely would have to revamp our local recruitment efforts. And then also ensure that
local communities have access to the jobs that are going to be created as part of this effort.
And how do we do that? We'll make sure that the jobs, especially the drilling of the well
that we are going to drill, even the NEPA work, the EIV that needs to be done,
the permitting, we are using a company from the Navajo Nation to help us with that.
So, we are going to make sure that we advertise the project in the local communities to make sure
that we attract the local people to do the work in their local community that this project is
going to be impacted on. We are going to report our efforts to create partnerships with training
and placement programs for underrepresented workers as well. And there's going to be the
targeted recruitment efforts. As I said, we're not already engaging to recruit a student from
the Navajo Nation to be part of our project. And we'll continue to do that. We do have
undergraduate students that are also from the Nation that will recruit and train them. And
they will be part of the project, you know, for them to be able to explain the importance of the
project to the community as well. So, we'll certainly report on the efforts to create the
partnership with training and placement programs for the underrepresented workers as well. And
we'll partner and also we'll contract with MSI or the business majority owners controlled by
the underrepresented people as well. So, in our first year, we'll have MSI and underrepresented
business. We will identify them. And then also we'll engage them in the second year as well.
We'll also advance diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility. We will define a list of the
specific topics to be covered. And then also we'll present a DEI focused topics during the team
meetings and discuss and also get a feedback. And we'll report this one in our last year. Next slide.
Now, with regards to justice 40 and environmental justice, we will as part of this project
identify the benefits and then also the impacts to the disadvantaged communities. This is something
that we did as part of our application. And we'll continue to do that throughout the project.
And also, we will work on an increase in job quality creation. Definitely, once we're able
to capture the CO2 from the power plant, then it's going to be a clean job, a clean energy option
for the community as well. Also, we will do the energy and environmental justice baseline
assessment as part of our project. And Professor Janisha Mark and Shruti, they are going to lead
that effort. And we'll report on the energy and environmental justice baseline assessment.
And then as we go through the project, we are going to look at the impact assessment as well.
And at the end of it, we're going to have a white paper delivered in the last year. Now, this is going
to be my last slide in addition to the project facts. So, we've already started doing some
community engagement and stakeholder outreach activities during the time that we're working
on the proposal. And even when DOE selected our project for an award, we try to have good
relationship. You know, we have meetings with the Navajo Nation's resource development committees.
We've attended several Navajo Nation-related activities or programs. We've done outreach
to some of the chapters. We've participated in original CCS symposiums. We've also developed
good relationship with NTEC Helium subsurface group that are going to help us with the permitting.
And then also some efforts with regards to our drilling activities as well.
We also participated in the Navajo, we also participated in the NGO meeting recently in Farmington as well.
Next slide. So, whenever we go out for meetings, you know, we've created fact sheets for all our
projects. And this one is the preliminary one that we've created for the Corcoran Storage Hub.
Whenever we go out there, we hand this over to the community to explain the importance of our
project to the communities. If you have any questions about our project, feel free to reach
out to me. I do have my email down there and I'll be happy to respond to your questions.
Thank you. I'll hand it over to Kevin. Thank you.
