Lec 24: Effective current for NTV combinational gates - III

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
1 Video View·Aug 15, 2024
This lecture covers the upper transistor switching in a NAND gate and effective current model for that.
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to this lecture this is a
lecture in module two its title is
effective current and logical effort for
near threshold voltage combinational
Gates so we have already done in the
previous lectures we have derived an
effective current model for near
threshold voltage inverter and for a
near threshold voltage nand gate with
lower transistor switching so today in
this lecture we will do an effective
current model for near threshold voltage
nand gate which its upper transistor
switching and then we will discuss how
logical effort is related to these
effective currents and then we will
discuss the how one can consider logical
variability in logical effort in near
threshold voltage regime at an early
stage of design so in the previous
lecture we had discussed the case where
lower transistor is switching and we had
obtained the values of
IH and I which gave so we broke we
divided the entire discharge output
discharge into different regions and in
one of the regions the current is
increasing linearly so there we
identified the end points and therefore
we get the average discharging current
in this region and then we had obtained
the value of this constant almost
constant current and using these two we
had computed the values of effective
switching current from this point where
the output begins to discharge 250% of
the time when output reaches 50% of its
Supply voltage value so in this lecture
we will discuss the upper transistor
switching so now a is at vdd and upper
transistor switches from 0 to
vdd and VA can be given given
by vdt by
TR where TR is the transition time so
what do we observe here the input Rises
prior work before this paper the prior
work was referring that the input when
it reaches 50% output would start
discharging which is not true for near
threshold voltage regime here even when
the even for the balance stage effort
case where the input and output
transition times are equal even in that
case it is not at the 50% of input value
that the output discharge begins but at
a value called V in C which we have
derived and which uh is nearly 75% of
the input transition input voltage final
value 75% of vdd near at so that is
where the output begins to discharge
nearly so here
what we observe is that once the so node
X is initially at 0 volts because this
is at vdd and this is at zero B is at
zero initially once the input begins to
switch to a higher value there is a
current that is that would start flowing
so this case is almost like that of an
inverter now the node X is at0 volts and
like for the inverter the current starts
assuming an important value and the
output begins to discharge only when the
input reaches around 75% or V in C 75%
of bdd or V in C to be more correct so
and this VNC would be the same as that
of the inverter VNC when the output
begins to discharge VNC is the input
voltage value when output begins to
discharge and it it would be similar to
that of the inverter because node as X
is at 0 volts so nearly at 0 volts and
therefore it is M2 behaves just like the
pull down transistor of an
inverter but once M2 begins to discharge
the output there is a current through M2
discharging current and that must also
flow through M1 so for it to flow
through M1 we would find that the node X
must assume a voltage a non-zero voltage
value and therefore noex slightly Rises
after the output begins to discharge
node noex slightly Rises and then during
the entire discharge it rises and during
the entire discharge see till the 50% or
till this point it remains almost at a
constant value so the entire discharge
process is almost at a constant value of
node X that is because if node the
voltage at node X Chang suppose it
increases then vgs of M2 would reduce
vgs of M2 if it reduces then the current
through M2 must reduce okay but the
current through M2 is almost constant
after this point okay when the output
reaches 80% value like in an inverter
the current through M2 is almost
constant so since the current through M2
is almost constant here the
value of vgs of this cannot
significantly
change vgs of M2 cannot significantly
change and therefore node X must remain
at its value or if this changes then the
current through M2 reduces if it
increases suppose node value of node X
voltage value of node X increases then
the current through M2 reduces and
current through M1 would increase
because its VDS is increasing m1's VDS
is increasing so it cannot happen that
that way so this is inconsistent so it
would never happen that way and why is
the current through M2 almost a constant
after the input reaches 80% value as we
see the input now Rises very slowly
because of the back coupling from cm and
the output is falling rapidly so as in
the case of inverter you have a constant
current here so what is the value of I
here I is this value when the input
begins to
discharge ID of an N
mosit for VG equal
to VN C now this is the VNC of an
inverter which is again valid for this
to input nand gate with upper transistor
switching VD equal
to VD d d which is this value v s equal
to
0 VB equal to Z body
voltage
okay this is same as the v in C of an
inverter so what is the value of IX IH
so now we as we had discussed the value
of current voltage VX would remain
almost constant from 80% value of V out
to 50% value of V out and in fact till
the till the time V out is discharging
it would remain almost constant the
reason we have just discussed so for IH
we need to take this is the value of IH
isn't
for IH we would take it as
IDs VG equal to
0.95
vdd this is
0
95
vdd
VD is equal to 0.5 vdd that is the point
point where we are taking IH it is
constant almost constant from 80% vdd to
50%
vdd vs is equal to
0.075 vdd and now this 075 vdd is valid
for all the fan out loads because of one
to one correspondence between input and
output voltage values it could be
slightly different for different pdks so
we need to extract it out once for one
of the F4 and then it is almost the same
for all the fos and body voltage we are
taking to be 0 volts so this is how we
have obtained I and IH now let us look
at effective switching current for NTV
gates for lower transistor
switching this
VNC so this VNC is for is
different from that of the inverter
and for upper transistors switching this
is
same as that of
the
inverter
okay now we have these two values what
is the value of effective current now as
in the inverter's case we have divided
the regions in the same way so from 50%
input value to V in C from V in C to 80%
of the output discharge V in C is when
the output begins to discharge we inced
to 80% of the output discharge 80% of
output discharge to 50% of output
discharge there is a constant current so
there is a linear current increase in
current
from V in C where when the input is v in
C and output is and to the time when the
out voltage is 80% of vdd so there is a
linear increase in the discharging
current it this is same
for inverter for upper transistor
switching in an handgate for lower
transistor switching in in Rand gate
only thing is that the value of VNC
keeps changing for all the three
cases and from 80% of output voltage
value to 50% of output voltage value
There is almost a constant current and
this happens for the inverter for upper
transistor switching in an handgate for
a lower transistor switching in an hand
gate therefore the effective current
model Remains the Same so the effective
current model for nand gate would also
be IH into I +
I divided by
1.9 I +
1.1 i l the only thing is is that IH iil
would be different for inverter for
upper transistor switching and for lower
transistor switching in an and for all
the three cases I and IH would be
different otherwise I effective
relationship with I and IH would remain
the same so how do we compute logical
effort using this effective current
model how do we Define effective current
we Define it as delay of a gate is equal
to
half CL L
vdd okay this is for
50% discharge at the
output divided by
I2 and how do we Define logical
effort so in this we can also refine
this
as
half CP vdd if we want to look at the
total output capacitance as a
combination of logical effort of of load
capacitance and parasitic capacitance we
can also write it as this
so and we know that
CP and I effective both are the
parasitic capacitance and I effective
are both proportional to transistor
width ideally
so therefore this would come out as a
parasitic DeLay So how do we write
logical
effort how do we look at logical effort
so so there
delay is equal
to
g into H which is c l by C
in plus P
par okay
so par parastic delay is the same as
this this is
p okay because this is not changing with
width what about the other term so how
do we optain the value of
G for an
inverter G is equal to 1 for a templ
inverter so let us write
template or reference
inverter G is
one so we would say
that
Delta by C in Delta is the intrinsic
delay Delta by C in should be equal to
vdd by 2 I effective like that okay
now for any other gate so this is for
the template inverter for say nand
gate g is not one so there we would have
g into Delta by C
in nand
that would be equal to vdd by 2 I
effective n isn't that is the way we
would write because there G is not zero
so what is the value of G of the nand
gate this is the same as this G so what
is its
value so it would come out to be I
effective
inverter by I
effective
n
into C
in
nand by C
in
inverter
so what we obtain is that we can relate
effective currents and logical effort
values we can also relate effective
current and parasitic delay values so
how do we obtain The Logical effort of a
so we have discussed how we obtain The
Logical effort of a given gate from its
effective current values for the for
near threshold voltage regime we will
see in the coming lecture that the
inverter template inverter could be
different from an inverter having some
other layout so there the logic we can
also Define logical effort for inverters
having a different layout compared to
the template
inverter we'll discuss that that in the
next lecture presently let us try to
understand how we can include variations
in logical effort or effective current
models since we have defined The Logical
effort and effective current models in
terms of IH and I where we have this V
in C where the output begins to
discharge and that also we have
derived so suppose a change in vdd
variation in vdd is to be accounted we
can account the variation in vdd through
the variation in I IH VNC Etc so all
these three parameters and understand
the variation in compute the variation
in logical effort directly likewise
suppose the threshold voltage changes
then the current how it CH current
relationship with threshold voltage we
know and therefore a change in threshold
voltage how much is it going to change
the value of logical effort can easily
be computed likewise Suppose there is a
variation in the value of Mobility with
Mobility how IH iil change we can
compute and thereby we can compute the
change in logical effort so a change in
parameters associated with variability
in near threshold voltage regime which
are
vdd threshold
voltage Mobility temperature temperature
changes threshold voltage and mobility
and through through the change in
threshold voltage and Mobility we can
estimate the change in IH and IL and
thereby the change in logical effort so
the change in logical effort can be
computed
from change in threshold voltage
mobility and
bdd and therefore also
temperature so pvt
variations can so what is the impact of
these variations on logical effort can
directly be computed using this
approach so in this lecture we discussed
the upper transistor switching in a nand
gate and the effective current model for
that and then we discussed how logical
effort how logical effort is related to
the effective current models and how
using this approach we can include
variations in temperature threshold
voltage mobility and Supply voltage in
calculations of logical effort so once
we can obtain The Logical effort using
simulations and how it varies with these
parameters one can directly compute
thereafter thank you
[Music]
