noc18-ae07 Lec 18

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
Topics covered Under this lecture:
1) Effect of variation of CG location with Hand Launched Glider experiment
2) Static Stability
Dear friends, welcome back. So, this is a wing, it is a symmetric wing we were discussing
in the last lecture. Do you want to see how it is going to fly? So, does it fly? Is it
going to fly or not if I throw this as it is? So, let us have some marking on this like
as I told you this is of 0.23 meter span, I mean the chord is 0.23 meters and a 1 meter
span. I request Himanshu, my TA to help me with this. So, sorry he is my researcher.
So, this is approximately 0.23 meters, you can see here this is 0.23 meters or 23 centimeters
is the chord of this. So, what will be the aerodynamic center for this configuration?
So, this is about it is a rectangular wing. So, the chord remains same lambda is 0 in
this case. So, what you have is two third of 0.25, the c bar will be c r and the aerodynamic
center will be 0.25 times of this. So, 23 by 4 is approximately 5.75. So, this particular
marking here is 5.75. So, this is my marking. What about this side? Can we mark it again?
This again is 5.75 meters. So, if I draw a line representing the mean aerodynamic chord
of this, can we do that? Yes, where is that? Can you hold this? You come this side. So,
this line which is connecting the aerodynamic center from tip to tip. So, this line is going
to represent the aerodynamic center of each and every aerofoil and the entire wing.
Now, let us mark this as AC of wing which is at a distance of 5.75 centimeters from
the leading edge of this wing. This is your aerodynamic center. Now, let us measure the
weight. It is approximately 150 grams and let us throw this as it is. Let us see what
it is going to do. See, it just flipped. Shall we do it again? I am just throwing it. It
is flipping. It is continuously flipping. Let me do a small magic or a trick say. This
is a molding clay which I borrowed it from UAV lab here. So, I have attached this molding
clay to this rod here which is connecting the wing. Now, let us see how it is going
to fly. Should I throw it? It is better, right? So, as soon as I add this molding clay to this,
it started gliding. It is not flipping the way it behaved in the first case. Let us take another
wing. So, this is a cambered aerofoil. It is a wing of 1 meter span. So, both of these have
same plan form geometry if you can see. So, both the models have the same plan form geometry,
but what is the difference between these two wings? It is a cross sectional profile. We
have used different aerofoils. So, the one in my right hand is with a symmetric aerofoil
and the one here is with a cambered aerofoil. The one in my left hand, you can see it is
a cambered aerofoil. Now, I have already attached some clay here, molding clay to
this particular configuration and I am going to throw this and again both of them are with
similar chord. Let me mark down the aerodynamic center of this. So, it is again 23 centimeters
chord. It is a rectangular wing. So, the mean aerodynamic chord is again 23 centimeters. So,
23 by 4 will be my aerodynamic center which is 5.75 approximately. So, this is my aerodynamic
center. So, how about this side? So, I have marked aerodynamic centers on the other side.
So, let us join these aerodynamic centers. This line represents your aerodynamic center. It is
a cambered aerofoil. The wing is with a cambered aerofoil. See the glide. It plays a crucial role
in this. So, what is the reason it started flying as soon as I attached this clay? What must be the
reason? So, we have not changed the wing. All we did is shifting the CG. That means,
say with this clay, how to measure the CG in the first place? CG of this wing? Either you need to
have two balances like this. Say you place it on one balance here. You have another balance at an
offset. You take m1 x1 plus m2 x2 divided by m1 plus m2. That is one way. The simpler way here is
our case. See, so about CG, the model will exactly balance. Let us say if you take a
horizontal rod and if you place this model on that horizontal rod, so about CG, this model
will be balanced exactly. So, that location you can consider it as CG location. So, in this case,
about this location, the model is exactly balanced. In this case, this is the location
about which the model is exactly balanced and this location is along the aerodynamic center
of this wing. So, if I am shifting the aerodynamic center towards the, I mean,
CG of the wing towards the aerodynamic center, then it started gliding.
Say, in this case, without any clay, so the CG is somewhere here, almost close to this point. This
is at this particular location. The CG in this case is at this particular location which is
at the aerodynamic center here. That means, let us say if I make CG 2 ahead of this aerodynamic
center. To do that, what should I do? I mean, if I want the CG ahead of this aerodynamic center,
I need to add more weight here. Say, there is some more molding clay. Now, the CG is at this
particular location which is ahead of this aerodynamic center. So, during the, if I fly,
if I try to glide, I mean, throw this wing with this particular CG setting, let us see what
happens. There is a nose down, immediate diving. There is no glide. It started diving down.
See, with this particular CG setting, this model started diving down. Let us say I reduce this clay
again. I am bringing that CG back. What I am trying to do now is bringing close to aerodynamic
center here. Now, it is behind the AC. So, right now, I am able to balance this model about the
aerodynamic center. So, this is my aerodynamic center. I am able to balance this model. Now,
let us see how it is going to behave. It is able to fly. Shall I repeat this? It is a glide.
Now, let me remove this clay again. So, let us see where is the CG, location of the CG. It has
definitely shifted backward. So, this is the point about which I can balance this model. So,
this is your CG location. This is your CG location right now, which approximately,
this is your CG location and this is aft this aerodynamic center. If I throw this,
so it flipped. It is a somersault. Let me do it again. I am not trying anything different
compared to earlier cases. It is automatically flipping. Let us see whether it repeats or not.
Whatever the angle that I am trying to do, but it will flip. So, it cannot be too ahead or too
behind. What do we infer from this? It should not be too ahead or too behind. That means,
you need to figure out what are the limits of this CG. Right now, we do not have a tail. What
happens if we add a tail? How far this CG traverse can be allowed? We will discuss this in this
lecture. Now, to do this, when the CG is close to this aerodynamic center, in this case for a wing
alone configuration. So, that too for a cambered airfoil. So, we see a smooth flight. Smooth in
the sense, so it was actually the intended path, which I was trying to or say it should be the
intended attitude of the flight. So, it should glide. That is the whole idea why I am throwing,
but when the CG is behind, it started flipping. So, what is the difference in between these two?
In the first case, it has something called, we call it as a stable flight. In the second case,
which is unpredictable. At the same time, unstable here. It started flipping. And in
the other case, where the CG is ahead again, it is diving down. So, we check the, I mean,
in one of the flights where the CG is near to the aerodynamic center, we witnessed a stable flight,
which let us say we consider it as a reference. And in other cases, we witnessed an unstable or
offset flight conditions. So, what are the parameters that govern this stable and offset
flight conditions? We use something called stable flight. What is stability? So,
stability is a property of a system or the nature of the system to come back towards some reference
that you consider, when disturbed, when it encounters a small disturbance about that
reference. So, this reference in our case or in general is an equilibrium. So, now we should
talk about, when we say a stable flight, first we need to understand what is stability of a system.
Let us talk about stability. Now, with the help of the concepts of stability, let us see how do
we design the tail and how do we find the limits of the CG traverse and what should
be the size of the tail and the offset between the tail and the wing. So, all these parameters
comes from this stability analysis of the system. So, what is stability? It is a tendency
of the system to attain equilibrium, once disturbed from it. What is this equilibrium
again? It is the state of the system about which resultant forces and moments are balanced.
That means, the forces and moments are balanced or there are no resultant forces and moments.
Forces and moments are balanced. That means, sigma F bar is equals to 0, sigma M bar is
equals to 0. So, about equilibrium of a system, the forces and moments are, resultant forces
and moments are 0. There are no resultant forces and moments.
So, there are many examples you might have studied in your earlier courses, where you
consider a simple pendulum. What are the equilibrium points of it? That is minus pi by 2 and pi
by 2 at theta is equals to, say this is your 0 inclination, this is your pi by 2 and this
is your minus pi by 2 at this. So, there are two equilibrium points of a simple pendulum
about minus pi by 2 and pi by 2. Now, consider the case where it is at minus
pi by 2. So, this is your pivot point O and let M be the mass of the system. Now, you
display this mass by an angle theta, where L is the length of this. This is your theta
and you displace this mass to an angle theta here. This will still remain L. The length
will remain constant here. So, as soon as you leave it, what happens? This bob will
try to come towards the equilibrium. This mass will try to come towards equilibrium
and because of its inertia, it will start accelerating. Till here, it will accelerate.
After that, it will decelerate and attain a orientation theta prime, where the terminal
velocity here is 0. Then, it will start coming back and it will go forth and back and finally,
it attains equilibrium. If there is enough friction in the hinge as well as there is
a friction in the surrounding atmosphere, air friction or the fluid friction. That means
once you disturb this particular object from its equilibrium, it will try to come back
towards its equilibrium. So, this particular equilibrium is known as stable equilibrium.
That means the system is finally attaining its equilibrium. So, let us consider a case
where there is no air resistance and say this connecting rod has negligible mass and there
is no friction. So, you are performing these experiments in a vacuum chamber. So, what
happens is this will keep oscillating. We can say the system is still trying to attain
the equilibrium, but it will not reach equilibrium because there is no resistance. There is no
damping to that oscillations. There is no damping in the system. It is trying to oscillate
about this equilibrium. So, although the system tries to come back
towards its equilibrium, but you cannot say the system is stable in that case. Why? Because
it is ultimately not coming back to that equilibrium. After a while, it should come back towards
that equilibrium, but it has a tendency to come back towards, but it is not attaining
that equilibrium here in this case. Even in that condition, we cannot say the system is
stable. That means when you are talking about stability, you are talking about two conditions
here. One is the tendency to come back towards this equilibrium and finally over a time period,
you are looking at the behavior of the system and commenting whether the system is coming
back towards that equilibrium or not. So, there are two cases for this stability.
One is the initial case is static stability. So, at any instant, you see the pendulum is
here trying to come back towards its initial equilibrium position. That talks about your
static at any instant. Does it have this tendency or not? That is a static stability. The study
about such condition is the static stability, whereas if you are looking at the time history
of this motion and say how long it is going to take to come back towards its equilibrium.
If it has to come back towards its equilibrium, what should I do? How should I increase the
damping or what should be the time to half these oscillations? So, the study related
to this time history of this motion once disturbed from its equilibrium is a dynamic stability.
So, dynamic stability talks about the time history of motion of the system once disturbed
from its equilibrium position. Now, consider this. See we have another equilibrium point
which is at pi by 2. So, assume that pendulum now is at the other equilibrium point which
is pi by 2. So, this is similar to this case where you are holding a stick. At some point,
this is stable here. When you place it on the table vertically, it is stable. When you
place this pen or the marker vertically on this table, this is also equilibrium point
because if there is a resultant force, there will be a motion and moments, it will try
to rotate resultant moment, but here the resultant force and moments are 0. That is why it is
at rest right now, but whether this position is stable or not, let us say if there is a
small disturbance, it has attained a new equilibrium. It has not come back to its previous equilibrium.
Let us say in the other case, if I hold at the top of this marker, say if I give some
additional external force, it will start oscillating and coming back towards its equilibrium. So,
this particular equilibrium is a stable equilibrium. So, the one at pi by 2 is an unstable equilibrium
because it is not coming back to its initial equilibrium once disturbed from it. The same
thing here. So, you see right now since I am holding it, I can vary the friction here
or the frictional force. So, say if I disturb this, it may not go down. Say if it is a proper
hinge, any small disturbance will definitely take it away from this particular equilibrium
which is unstable equilibrium here. Now, what are the conditions here? So, in this case,
in case of a pendulum, see if the CG is beneath the hinge point. So, this is your CG. If your
CG is beneath the hinge point, it is a stable equilibrium. The equilibrium in which the
CG is beneath the hinge point is a stable equilibrium. The equilibrium in which CG is
above the hinge point is an unstable equilibrium. So, similarly, do you have something in the
aircraft? But in this case, the CG and the hinge point are in the vertical axis. So,
what happened to the aircraft? So, we have lift from the wing, lift from the tail and
CG acting at some other location. The hinge point and CG are in the straight line here
in both the equilibriums, in the vertical axis. So, but in that case, there is an offset
where the CG as well as the aerodynamic forces act. So, we need to see where should I locate
the CG so that the system is automatically stable. See here, you are not controlling
the system. Once you disturb from its equilibrium, there is no need for any external control.
It will automatically come back towards its equilibrium. It will automatically come back
towards its equilibrium once the perturbation is done, once the external force is removed
from it. So, here the system will come back towards
its equilibrium automatically once there is no external force acting on it. So, another
example that you may consider is, take a bowl. These examples you might have studied already.
So, you take a bowl placed at this location, at the bottom location of this bowl. It is
a concave bowl. Now, you displace this to a particular location here, either this side
or this side. It will start moving towards the initial equilibrium. So, in this case,
the resultant forces and moments are 0. So, once you displace and leave it, it will start
oscillating about this particular equilibrium. So, it will start oscillating about it and
finally attains this equilibrium, which we can say it is a stable equilibrium.
So, if you take a convex bowl, if you place a bowl here, what happens is, as soon as you
perturb this, it will either go this side or this side. It will not come back towards
its equilibrium. So, here in the first case, we are not controlling any, we are not imparting
any external forces here. It is automatically coming back towards its equilibrium. So, similarly,
the UAV should have the initial, the tendency to come back towards its equilibrium. Then,
we can say it is a stable UAV. So, even while varying the CG, what we witnessed is the stability
of the system is changing. So, let us see how this stability changes as the CG varies.
So, again in this pendulum case, in this particular equilibrium location, where it is minus pi
by 2. So, at this equilibrium point, we say this is a stable equilibrium. If there is
a friction and a friction, that helps this pendulum to come back towards its initial
equilibrium. So, in this particular case, we consider it as a stable equilibrium. Why?
Because it is attaining its actual equilibrium, but how? What is helping? Why not in the other
case? Yes, mg, even gravity is there in the other side as well. There is a component of
this mg, mg sin theta and mg cos theta. So, this mg sin theta is what driving it towards
its equilibrium, but this force about this particular point, hinge point is creating
a moment. This is into l, mg sin theta into l is a moment that is created about this hinge
point. That means, there is a moment that is restoring its equilibrium. That moment
is known as restoring moment. Now, to have this equilibrium stable, I mean if you need
to say if a system have to be stable, then there should be a restoring moment.
So, we know aircraft have 6 degrees of freedom here. It can translate as well as rotate along
the 3 axis here of this body frame. So, it can translate along x, y, z and rotate along
this 3 axis. So, the rotation along the body x axis is known as roll, pitch and yaw. We
have roll, pitch and yaw of the system. So, the pitching moment is about y axis. Now say
let m be the moment here which is given as half rho v square s Cm into C bar. Half rho
v square s is the force dimensions of the force and C bar is the dimensions of the length.
So, force into length is a moment. It is a moment arm. You can say C bar and Cm is a
non-dimensional pitching moment coefficient. So, Cm is twice the pitching moment divided
by rho v square s into C bar. Now, this is the moment that we are talking
about. Even in the pendulum there is a moment because of the force. So, this is the moment
because of the aerodynamics. So, there in the pendulum case we have that moment due
to gravity. Here we have a moment. This Cm is a moment that is due to the aerodynamics
here. So, consider the Cm variation with angle of attack. Since we mentioned it is an aerodynamic
moment. So, these aerodynamic forces and moments depends upon the angle of attack.
Let us consider this variation of the Cm with angle of attack. So, let us say this is for
the entire aircraft or the UAV. So, say in the first case you have a UAV which is let
us say this is your UAV A. So, this is your UAV B. So, what is this particular point?
So, for this UAV B you have Cm variation. This blue line represents the pitching moment
coefficient variation with angle of attack. For the UAV A, this pink line represents the
pitching moment variation with angle of attack. So, what is this particular condition? This
is an increasing alpha. So, this is your positive and this is your negative. What
is positive pitching moment? So, we discussed right hand thumb rule stretch your thumb along
the positive axis. Positive axis and the corresponding curl of I mean the curl of your fingers will
give you the corresponding positive moment. So, for this Cm is about pitching moment is
about y axis. So, stretch your thumb along the positive y axis of this UAV and the pitch
up is considered as positive and pitch down is considered as negative.
Now what is this alpha? What is this point? So, you can see at this particular alpha you
say the moment Cm is zero. That means there is no pitching moment for this particular
angle of attack. Do you accept this? So, which means the moments are zero or a pitching moment
is zero. Cm is zero means of course m is zero. That means it is an equilibrium point.
If there is imbalance in the force that creates a moment but when the resultant forces are
equal there is no moment here. So, about this point there is no moment. We can consider
this as equilibrium. So, this is your equilibrium. Now let us say there is a sudden increase
in the gust or the wind which has increased the angle of attack. So, this particular point
alpha e equilibrium is perturbed by alpha prime. The new angle of attack is perturbed
by wind and the resultant angle of attack at that instant is alpha prime. So, this alpha
prime if I consider the UAV A what happens because of this change? There is a pitching
moment. It is a positive pitching moment. That means the aircraft will have a nose up.
So, this is your positive y axis say this is your positive y, this is your positive
x and this is your positive z. So, stretch your
thumb along the positive y and the curl of your fingers will give you the corresponding
positive rotation here. So, this pitch up motion is considered. Pitching up is considered
as positive. Pitching down is considered as negative. So, with the increase in the
angle of attack there is an increase in the moment. Initially at this particular angle
of attack where the resultant forces and moments are zero, you have zero moment definitely
because that is the definition of equilibrium here.
So, as the angle of attack increase there is a change in the moment and the change is
in the resultant moment is positive which means there is a pitch up moment. So, initially
say this is your angle of attack. This marker represents the angle of attack. So, this is
sorry V infinity and this is your angle of attack the angle between them. So, because
of a small change, so this is the trim condition let us assume because this is your alpha e.
Because of a small change there is an increase in the angle of attack, small disturbance,
external disturbance. So, this increased angle of attack for an aircraft with that pitching
moment curve let us say that is a UAV A. So, this curve represents the pitching moment
variation with angle of attack for UAV A. So, for such UAV what happens? So, this increase
in angle of attack is increasing the pitching moment that is no sub moment. It further increases.
So this further increase due to this no sub it further increases the angle of attack.
So that means let us say this is your alpha double prime. Now the increase in angle of
attack due to pitch up is alpha double prime. So, for this UAV you have CM prime, CM double
prime. That means there is a further increase in the pitching moment which further creates
a no sub and further increases the angle of attack. So, alpha double prime or triple prime
will result in a CM triple prime. This is alpha triple prime. That means you are moving
away from this particular equilibrium point. See here this is your equilibrium point you
are moving away from it. Now in the other case say for the same UAV A if there is a
disturbance that has reduced the angle of attack say. So, initially this is your angle
of attack say at equilibrium. Now this disturbance has reduced the effective angle of attack
here. So, this reduction in angle of attack for this particular UAV with this pink curve
will result in a. So, say this is your alpha prime in the subscript. So, this results in
a CM prime in the subscript. Now which means your pitching moment is negative here. There
is a negative pitching moment which is a nose down. That means this will further decrease
the angle of attack. If you the aircraft will do a nose down automatically and which
eventually result in a reduction in angle of attack further.
So, alpha double prime. So, this will again decrease the pitching moment or gives a negative
pitching moment. So, that negative pitching moment further will reduce the angle of attack.
That means it will go to alpha triple prime in the subscript. So, this will further create
a pitch down moment. So, in either case if you follow a UAV with this pink curve you
will end up moving away from the equilibrium once disturbed from it. Similar to that of
a pendulum case where you have an equilibrium but it is at minus pi by 2. If the CG is about
the pivot point then the equilibrium is not stable. The system is not stable about that
particular equilibrium. So, on the other hand if you look at this
blue curve. So, look at this blue curve that represents the variation of pitching moment
with angle of attack for a UAV B. So, this alpha prime when there is an increase in the
angle of attack there is a Cm prime in the subscript that is a negative pitching moment.
So let us say there is a disturbance that has increased. This is my equilibrium alpha.
So there is a disturbance that has increased this alpha but with the UAV with this particular
blue curve this change in the alpha will induce a nose down moment here. Cm is negative. So,
this nose down moment will decrease the angle of attack. That means you will start moving
towards this equilibrium point. It will start decreasing the angle of attack.
So, similarly if the angle of attack is decreased say this is your trim angle of attack or the
equilibrium angle of attack. If the angle of attack is decreased due to the disturbance
what happens? So, this reduced angle of attack will induce a nose up moment. From this curve
you can see this reduced angle of attack will induce a positive moment which is nose up.
That means the aircraft will pitch up and go back towards it. That means pitching up
means it is increasing the angle of attack. That means you are moving from here to here
moving towards your equilibrium point. So, what do we infer from this discussion?
That means for a UAV to be statically stable, so this Cm versus alpha has to be negative.
The slope has to be negative. Here the change in Cm dCm with d alpha is negative whereas
the dCm by d alpha in this case is positive. So, for an unstable aircraft this change is
positive. For a stable aircraft the change in pitching moment with alpha is negative.
So dCm by d alpha should be less than 0 or negative. By the way what is this moment about?
This moment we are talking is about the CG but due to aerodynamic forces. So, we are
starting with static stability. So, we discussed that there will be two phases of the stability
static and dynamic. Initially we are arriving at the mathematical conditions for static
stability. If the UAV has to be statically stable the variation in pitching moment with
angle of attack has to be negative. The slope of this Cm alpha should be less than 0. So,
this is a necessary condition but is it the sufficient condition? Let us say you have
the Cm variation with alpha the blue one negative. Let me draw a parallel curve for this with
a negative slope but passing through origin here. This is your Cm versus alpha. So, this
is UAV C. This is the third UAV. So, still even in this case with the change in angle
of attack say this is your equilibrium here. That means you are trimming your aircraft
at alpha is equal to 0, 0 angle of attack. So, at this equilibrium about this equilibrium
when there is a change in angle of increase in the angle of attack there is a nose down
moment that will take you back towards your equilibrium and vice versa. But what is the
trim for this UAV? It is at 0 angle of attack because you cannot trim at positive angle
of attack you will get negative moment. So, let us have a curve which is offset to
this. So, these three are parallel. So, this is your UAV T. So, in this case where is
the trim? It is at negative angle of attack. This is your negative alpha, alpha negative
in this direction. So, the trim is negative here, alpha is negative that means but we
witness CL is equal to CL0 plus CL alpha into alpha. When you have negative angle of attack
you are actually reducing the lift CL that means you will not be able to sustain the
weight at this particular angle of attack. So, it is an inefficient flight if you have
it. The whole idea is to generate lift at minimum velocity and the minimum conditions
power requirement conditions of the minimum what you call minimum fuel consumption.
So, although you have CM alpha curve, CM alpha negative for even for this UAV D but
you cannot trim this at a positive angle of attack. So, the CM0, what is CM0 here? Here
it is 0, here it is positive. What is CM0? CM at which alpha is equal to 0. So, here
it is positive this is for blue curve this is your CM0. So, for yellow curve this is
your CM0 is 0 and for this brown curve it is your CM0 which is negative. This is greater
than 0, this is equivalent to 0. So, for this to trim at positive angle of attack I need
to create an offset here. To create that offset for a flat plate this is how it will
be. We will witness for flat plate what is going to be the CM. So, in order to trim at
positive angle of attack you need to have. So, this is your trim at positive angle of
attack. Trim is an equilibrium. So, in order to trim at positive angle of attack you need
to have positive CM0. So, when this is your negative CM0, this is your positive CM0. This
positive CM0 will help you to trim at positive angle of attack. So, CM0 has to be greater
than 0, CM alpha should be less than 0 or it should be positive for sufficient. So,
necessary and the sufficient condition for statically stable UAV.
