Lecture 51: Managerial challenges of compensation management -1

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Aug 13, 2024
This lecture explores initial managerial challenges in compensation management.
[Music]
[Music]
in this particular session we will talk
about the the challenges of the company
comp ation and we will be covering the
other aspects of work compensation that
is what are the job analysis processes
well doing jobs and the pay survey and
we are talking about the job analysis
here I would also like to mention that
is we have to differentiate between the
job analysis and the job evaluation
because we are focusing on the job
analysis so we will not be talking about
the evaluation of the job rather than
how job is to be analyzed we I would
like to take the case study here of the
Bridging the Gap in job analysis for
enhance the Strategic alignment so Tech
NOA a leading Technology Solutions
provider fa the significant challenges
in aligning their job roles with the
company's strategic goals now you see
every organization has to do the job
analysis with the connector of the
different roles are there and therefore
in that case when we are talking about
these different challenges we will be Al
aligning the job roles with the specific
the organizational strategics and then
the departmental Strategic go goals and
then the individual strategic goals also
so despite having the detailed job
descriptions and discrepancies between
the expected duties and the actual Tas
performed by employees led to the
inefficiencies and the
dissatisfaction now when we are
integrating the organizational goal with
these individual goals with the job
goals and the different roles of that to
be done by the the job then in that case
it it is very very important that is the
there are certain dos and do Nots with a
particular job with the which an
employee has to understand but that is
in spite of the detailed job description
that is that job completely has been
described in spite of that sometimes it
happens that is the expected Duties are
not have been fulfilled and the actual
task which is required to be performed
by these employees that is not completed
so naturally it will lead to the
inefficiencies and the definitely the
job dissatisfaction for the employ also
and for the organization also so
Additionally the company struggle with
the high turnover rates if the employee
is not happy with his job and then by
performing that particular job task then
definitely there will be discrepancy
into his the expected goals and the
achieved goals which will lead the job
uh dissatisfaction to the not only to
the employee but organization will also
take the action and as a result of which
the employees turn over with will
increase the company struggled with the
high turnover rates and skill gaps are
there now when we are talking about that
performing a particular job then every
job requires whether it is a skilled
semiskilled or unskilled job it requires
a certain ways to do the job and
especially for the semiskilled and
skilled jobs there is a particular set
of the skills which are required and
this when they it is not matching then
Rising the concern about their
competition Ness in the industry is
there so it will not be only the
challenge to the employee but it will be
also challenge to the organization
because the organization is not able to
match that particular requirement by
particular job and integrating that
particular job role with the
organizational goals so here it becomes
very very important that is organization
has to take the action so first and
foremost forem thing which is noticed is
the tech recognized that to achieve a
strategic goal objective user they
needed a thorough understanding of the
Ki relationship and responsibilities and
requirement of the each role unless and
until you do not connect the
responsibility and accountability with a
particular job if you recognize that and
then assign to the employee then
definitely the efficiency that will be
increasing so there is a need and which
the technova has done so technova has
make by understanding this type of the
skill Gap STS immediately they given the
key responsibilities and Define those
key responsibilities to the employees
and as as a result of which the every
role which was classified under a
particular job that was also assigned
with the certain responsibilities so
there is no mismatch there is no Gap and
as result of which what was happening
that every employee has understood that
is this is my job role these are my
duties and I have to perform in this
particular way so in HR Analytics tool
was employed to map out the job duties
and ass says how they can contribute to
the company's goals so here the HR
analytics was used and that has helped
that is how they contributed to the
company's goals and the individuals
performance the analysis reveal that
many roles were not fully aligned with
the Strategic priorities many times it
happens in the organization that is the
the work is done into the isolation in
watertight compartment as a result of
which they are not
interconnected the same thing was
observed here when hi analytics was done
then it has been found that is many job
roles were not fully aligned with the
Strategic priorities they were not
connected with the what was the strategy
of the organization so particularly in
emerging Technologies and The Innovation
driven projects where the new things are
to be done and that there has to be a
proper sequence of the doing the jobs
and this this was the area which has
been identified by the tech NOA and
techn NOA align all the Strategic
priorities for this type of the job
roles to get insights into the how
employees spent their time and the techn
NOA conducted a Time motion study using
Advanced
analytics and this study highlighted
significant discrepancies between the
job descriptions and the actual tasks
well here now what was required an
action was required that is the those
employees those who are conducting a
particular time period in a particular
machine and the organization the
technova they have conducted a Time
motion study and while studying the time
motion study by these Advance analytics
they come to know that is what are the
significant discrepancies are there
because the employee is on the job he's
performing certain operations but if the
inefficiency is there or the output is
not there then definitely we have to
make the analysis and identify that is
what is the job descrip
and what is actual task and there if
there is any Gap then with the help of
these H analytics we could find out that
is what are the gaps are there for
instance software developers spent a
considerable amount of time on
maintenance work rather than on new
development projects a very beautiful
example is given here in this particular
case study that is the for software
developers what they supposed to do they
supposed to spend the more time on that
considerable amount that is on the
maintenance they were spending rather
than whatever they are supposed to do on
the new development projects if your
business through software developers is
about to developing the new and new
businesses new and new projects and then
if they are not doing rather than they
spending most of the time on this
maintenance then definitely there is
something which is required to do
because this is a contrary to the what
their job discrepancies
indicated so this misalignment was found
to be a source of frustration among
employees and a contributing to low
moral and high turnover rates are there
the software developers which were
supposed to develop that particular
software in spite of that they were more
busy on the maintenance of that machines
and as a result of which and how they
could find out they could find out with
the help of that is a Time motion study
and as a result of which the software
developers they were having the low
moral and the high turnover rates are
there the HR team used the skills
assessment tools to identify gaps uh
within the workforce and it was found
that many employees led the Proficiency
in key areas such as cloud computing and
the cyber security we have discussed so
far that is how important the this cloud
computing is there and if the software
developers if they are not working on
this particular these the functions then
definitely they will be the lack in the
efficiency of the employees so here many
employees lack the Proficiency in key
areas such as cloud computing and the
cyber security so it was cre critical to
the techn of the Strategic initiatives
now the organization like here the
example is of the technova that requires
to focus on this particular gaps to
identify that what were the issues which
are there there was l in the Proficiency
in the cloud computing and the cyber
security to address these gaps the
company launched the targeted training
programs and recruited new Talent with
the required expertise now this is also
possible that is they are having this
type of the G because of the their
employees are not expert and the techn
NOA they identified that is which are we
the critical issues to take no further
strategic initiatives in address these
gaps the company launched the targeted
training programs and recruited new
Talent with the required expertise as
soon as the expertise Gap was found
skill gaps were found that is the
current employees they cannot have this
St of this expertise so then in that
case they were given the as the training
programs and the new recruiters were
hired by the organization so that that
skill gaps can be filled to address
these gaps the company launched the
targeted training programs and
recruiting at the new talent and as
result of which they have been developed
the new employees those have been
developed and accordingly their company
and they have ensured that is that
neutral lent with the required expertise
is hired so that there is no Gap in the
job roles this proactive approach am to
ensure that employees had the necessary
skills to drive the company's growth so
what was required and what they were
performing in the actual task that
particular gap which was identified with
the help of the HR analytics and those
gaps were then fulfilled uh here when we
are talking about the like the software
developers so therefore they have been
given the training programs and they
their new recruited the young these
talented with the required expertise and
as a result of which this particular
problem that has been solved here this
Pro to approach which is a to ensure
that employees had the necessary skills
that has helped organization
to increases his efficiency and the
knowledge base take no compare their job
roles with industry standards using the
comparison and benchmarking data for pay
surveys and the job analysis reports now
if you're going for the talent
acquisition Talent hiring with the that
new SK skills development or with the
those who are already have acquired
those new skills then definitely there
is a there will be a certain burden on
the organization financially also and
non-financially also so these standards
of these benchmarking data from the
preservant job analysis reports this
comparison revealed that their roles
were broader in scope but often like the
depth seen in computer competitive
organizations so it was observed that is
this comparison that the roles were
identified and the training program was
given and the new hire was uh taken into
the organization so this all has they
brought scope but what was Ling is that
is Led in the depth seen in the on the
competitive organizations for example
project manager at techn NOA had a wider
range of responsibilities but less
Authority and fewer resources to execute
their projects effectively so in the
techn NOA when there was a requirement
of the wider responsibilities because we
have now the new structure new roles and
additional roles were there with the
every particular job after the HR
analytics then the challenge was that is
how they will be adopting those new
skills and new expertise so this range
of responsibilities and the few
resources execute their projects
effectively aligning job roles with
industry standards was identified as a
crucial step towards the improving the
operational efficiency and employee
satisfaction so here it has becoming
very very important that is the job
roles with the industry standards which
has been ident identified with through
the HR analytics and there were the
certain crucial jobs also and then all
these they have taken towards the
improving the operational efficiency
because as we have seen in the beginning
of the case study that is that because
of the skill gaps and the job roles the
organization was having the inefficiency
and the less productivity but as with
the help of the H analytics this has
been identified and now these Executives
managers these positions these jobs they
were able to fulfill those all
requirements as a crucial step towards
improving the organizational efficiency
and as result of which not only the
turnover was reduced but employe
satisfaction was it was also increased
so HR analytics were also used to
analyze turnover rates and identity
patterns indicating job dissatisfaction
so one side we have clued the job roles
deficiency improving job roles and then
getting the job done and higher
efficiencies so another side the HR
analytics also helped to identify that
is a pattern what is the pattern of the
dissatisfaction is there now you see for
any organization the cost of the
employees hiring is very high and
therefore in that case if you are able
to reduce that particular cost with the
help of the HR analytics by identifying
that is what are the reasons for the job
dissatisfaction and you want to reduce
the employees turnover automatically
there will be the cost saving so it was
found that roles with the highest
turnover rates where those where job
responsibilities were most misaligned
with the employees expectations and
strategic goals naturally the employees
turnover was increasing because of the
it was the job was not meting the
expectations of the employees and
especially the young employees nowadays
and therefore the job employees and
turnover that becomes very very high so
here it becomes was important by doing
this H analytics we organization the
techn was able to manage the employees
expectations and aligning them with the
Strategic goals for example customer
support role and that had a high
turnover due to the mismatch between the
required skills and said the nature of
the task performed and by realigning the
job roles and announcing Clarity in the
job
descriptions so if you are matching this
the between the this required skill set
and the nature of the task then
definitely the organizational
performance that will be announcing and
by realigning the job roles and
announcing the clarity in the job
descriptions take no to reduce the
employees turnover and improve the job
satisfaction this way job analytics that
has become a very very important role to
reduce that employees turnover and as a
result of which it has been seen that is
what was the mmch
between the performance of the job of by
the employees and the job goals
expectations organizational expectations
organizational role and that with the
help of the H analytics the Gap was
identified skills were filled and the
new jobs new roles they were having the
fully equipped and skilled employees and
as result of which the employees
satisfaction was more as soon as
employee satisfaction will be more
employees turnover will be less and the
take over that they has reduced that
Manpower over a basis of this jobs
satisfaction among these the the
software developers and the other jobs
which were performed by this particular
organization and here the questions
arises which we have to understand what
are the key responsibilities and
requirements of each role now I would
like to mention here that whenever we
are talking about the job analysis and
job descriptions then in that case we
have to must understand that job
analysis that manual which has been
prepared by the
organization that is required to be very
much perfect when you are having this
job analysis and you are using the HR
analytics then definitely in that case
you are improving the job roles if you
are improving the job roles then it is
coming as a feedback for the job
satisfaction now this job description
which has been mentioned by the HR
manual there also you can use this HR
analytics because this job description
is designed on the basis of the survey
which has been done by the another
competitor organizations and there we
find out with the help of these H
analytics that what what is the job
analysis is there but in spite of that
if the job analysis is not properly done
with the surrounding managerial
practices then definitely in that case
that job role will not lead to the job
satisfaction so first question arises
that is a key responsibilities and
requirement of each role this job
description and how they align with our
strategic goals are there now here when
we are classifying the jobs so there
will be the organizational goal there
will be the departmental sectional goals
and then there will be the job roles so
matching of these all
aspects that will be the answer that is
the what will be the key
responsibilities and requirements of the
each role if they are well defined then
they will be well aligned with the
Strategic goals of the organization if
you are able to do that then definitely
in that case you will find that is you
are able to match that particular
requirements which are required to be
done by the
organization the second question arises
how do employees currently spend their
time and are there any discrepancies
between the job descriptions and the
actual Duty is performed here I would
like to take the help of this particular
case study in which we have discussed
about that is the hi analytics has help
to understand where they are spending
their time so for example these software
developers they were spending the more
time on the maintenance as compared to
the creating any new ideas so there here
it was required that is this job
description and the actual duties
performed by that particular employees
they they are required to develop that
particular analysis HR analytics which
will give you the time
management and then when you find your
employes are not able to focus on the
time management of the productivity and
then they are busy in the supporting
activities of their particular job then
definitely the debt is to be controlled
and here we are talking about the HR
analytics what are the skill gaps in our
current Workforce and how can we address
them through the training or hiring is
there with the help of the H analytics
we have identified those gaps and when
when we have identified those gaps then
that we required that is the how we can
reduce their maintenance time and when
we can increase their production time
and when when we are increasing their
production time then definitely in that
case we identify those areas where they
require the training and development and
accordingly you are the internal
employees those who were already working
and were not able to perform an
employees turnover as high then you
train them and external employees those
who are talented employees those who
were able to acquire that particular
skills uh though they were get the
higher positions now the another
question arises that how do our job
roles compare with the industry
standards in terms of the scope and
complexity because we are taking the
help of the HR analytics so naturally it
should lead to make a successful job
roles and what is the turnover rate for
the each role and are there any patterns
indicating dissatisfaction with the job
responsibilities so this turnover rate
for the each role are there the
indicating that there there employees
dissatisfaction and the job
responsibilities uh if you are matching
them with their appropriate job roles
then that efficiency will be increasing
and the job dissatisfaction will be
decreasing now the second part that is
about the valuing the job jobs how do
you valuing the jobs are there here I
would like to take the case study of
ensuring the fair and strategic job
valuation at fintech Solutions so
fintech Solutions a rapidly growing
Financial technology firm face
challenges in establishing a fair and
consistent job valuation system and the
inter inconsistencies in the job worth
and perceptions of the unfair valuation
negatively impacted employee moral
productivity and the diversity within
the organization so fintech has
especially was facing the that
particular challenge related to the job
valuation systems so jobs were not
having the proper valuation as a result
of which the performance the assignments
and then the monetary benefits that all
were to be considered in their
particular aspects so internal
inconsistencies in the job worth and the
perceptions of the unfair valuation
negatively impacted employee model
productivity and as a result of which
the HR team at fintech Solutions
conducted an internal audit using HR
analytics and the H analytics to
evaluate the worth of the various roles
across the
Departments as we have seen in the first
part of the job analysis that is the how
the HR analytics was done and the
analysis revealed significant
inconsistencies in how jobs were valued
and for example Ro in the IT department
were often undervalued compared to the
similar role in the financial department
despite having the comparable
responsibilities and the required
skilles and this inconsistency was
addressed by standardizing the
evaluation criteria across all
departments to ensure a fair internal
job worth hierarchy is there and there
is no discrepancies between the two
departments to understand the employee
perceptions ftech Solutions conducted an
Anonymous survey and that measured the
perceived fairness in the job
valuations the survey results indicated
that many emplo felt their roles were
undervalued leading to the decreased
model and the
productivity by addressing these
perceptions and making the valuation
process more transparent the company am
to boot that employees satisfaction and
engagement at a higher level the
Solutions use the market rate data from
industry specific pay so pay survey to
compare their salaries with those of the
similar positions in the industry the
analysis reveal that their compensation
package were below Market rates for the
key roles such as software developers
and data analysis to remain competitive
the company adjusted salaries to the
match or exceed the industry standards
helping to attract and retain the top
tent the HR analytics tools also
highlighted their job valuations had an
unintended impact on diversity and
inclusion and the role predominantly
held by the women and minorities were
often undervalued compared to their help
what has been held by their the
counterparts recognizing this ftech
solutions implemented a review process
to ensure that the job utions were free
from biases promoting a more inclusive
the workplace is there the analysis
identified critical competencies and
required for the high value jobs such as
expertise in the blockchain technology
and Advanced Data analysis it has found
that the competencies were lacking in
the current Workforce to address the fin
Solutions invested in the targeted
training programs and they recruited the
new Talent with the with these critical
skills ensuring the company remand at
the Forefront of the technological
advancement in the industry here the
relevant questions becomes what is the
internal job worth hierarchy and how
consistently are the job evaluated
across the Departments how do employees
pursue the fairness of their job
valuation and how does this impact moral
and productivity what are the market
rates for the similar positions in our
industry and how do we our salaries they
are compared we have to also understand
how do this job evaluation affect
diversity and inclusion within our
organization what are the critical
competencies for the high value jobs and
how they prevent there in in their now
current Workforce finally I would like
to take the pay service and the htech
incorporation and leading Healthcare
technology company face challenges in
ensuring their compensation packages
remain competitive and fair across
different roles and locations the
company a to Lage external pay survey to
optimize their compensation strategy and
stay ahead in the industry Health Tech
incorporation conducted a thorough
evaluation to identify the most accurate
and relevant external pay surveys for
their industry and the geographical
locations by using HR analytics they
determine that surveys from industry
specific sources such as the healthcare
information and management system
society that is the hmss and region
specific survey
and like the Western compensation and
benefit Association that is the wcba
provided the most actionable data this
survey offered the comprehensive
insights into this salary Benchmark
benefit and the incentives specific to
the healthcare technology sector using
data from this surveys healtech
incorporation compared their
compensation packages with those of the
key competitors the analysis revealed
that the while their best salaries were
competitive their benefits and
incentives L behind for instance
competitors offered more generous chuk
options and wellness programs to brid
this Gap health check incorporation
revamp their benefits package to include
the enhance health benefits stock
options and the professional development
opportunities Healthcare incorporation
identified emerging Trends in the pay
practices through the continuous
monitoring of the survey data Trends
such as the flexible working
Arrangements Performance Based bonuses
and the increased focus on the mental
health benefits will becoming the
prevalent by adopting these Trends
Healthcare incorporation introduced a
flexible and the work hours and they
enance moral health support programs
aligning their practices with the
industry standards and the boosting the
employee satisfaction the pay service
also provided insights into the how
employees demographics affected Market
rates and the compensation expectations
for example younger employees valued the
career development opportunities more
highly than the older emploees who
prioritize retirement benefits by
segmenting their compensation strategy
based on the demographics data Health
Tech incorporations tailored their
offerings to meet the diverse needs of
their Workforce and thereby improving
the retention and engagement Healthcare
incorporation assess the return on
investment Roi for the participating in
various space surveys and surveys that
provided detailed industry specific data
and acable insights were found to offer
the highest Roi for instance the HSS
survey not only helped in the
benchmarking salaries but also in
understanding the broader industry
Trends and best practices by focusing on
the high surveys Healthcare
incorporation ensured they make the
informed decisions uh that align with
their strategic goals now the questions
arises which external pay surveys
provide the most accurate and relevant
data for our industry and Geographic
locations how do our compensation
packages compare to those of our comp
the competitors in terms of the best
salary benefits and
incentives what trends are emerging in
Pay practices within our industry and
how can we adopt to stay the competitive
finally how do employee demographics
example these age gender experience
after their market rate and the
compensation expectations what is the
return on investment for the
participating in different pay surveys
and which ones offers the most
actionable insights these questions will
be raised which are supposed to be
answered with the help of this
particular case study thank you
[Music]
a
[Music]
