Lecture 53: Compensation Analytics – 1

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Aug 13, 2024
This lecture introduces foundational concepts in compensation analytics.
[Music]
[Music]
dear participants in this session we
will learn some of The Matrix related to
the compensation right so how a manager
can use these Matrix in order to take
decision related to designing of the
compensation right determining the
various factors related to the
compensation how much we should pay
which factor like what should be the
base rate what should be the long-term
incentives for which position you need
to have more long-term incentive
shortterm incentives right so such kind
of decisions that you will see every day
that HR manager has to take place at the
workplace right related to the
compensation so in today's session we
will discuss some of the metrics which
may be useful for the HR managers to
take the decision related to the
compensation so let us start with the
content of the day what we will learn
today so first thing that we will learn
pay mix policies so as I was saying as
as a HR manager you need to take a
decision how much you should pay the
base how much should be the shortterm
incentive how much should be the
long-term right so that analysis that we
will do it Department wise right why it
is important that is what also we will
discuss next thing that is what we will
discuss job evaluation point right so
you would have learned how to evaluate
the job right and give the certain
number to the each scales so whatever
job that is are available first you have
to define the job you have to categorize
right and then related to the each job
you have whatever skills are there you
have to identify the skills and for each
skill you need to pay you need to give
certain point so skills which can be
paid so like compensation that we are
deciding so for one organization which
pays for certain skills only we cannot
say that for all skills that
organization makes the payment
organization makes the payments only for
few uh skills right that you have for
example in a teaching field if you know
how to take a class on the basis of that
you will be paid so you will be paid for
teaching training research consultancy
and administration if you are having any
other skill other other than that it
which may help you indirectly to do
these all activities but organization
may not pay pay you for that so for the
each job you have to identify the skills
which can be paid for doing a particular
job right and then you have to develop
the then you have to calculate the job
birth how important this job is in the
organization and accordingly you need to
decide the compensation for that
particular job so for example sometime
you may see that that job position is
same assistant general manager marketing
assistant general manager HR assistant
general manager operations right all
people are the assistant general manager
but you may see the difference in their
compensation right because the worth of
job that is the different from one job
to another job in the organization so
that's why you will see a difference so
how to calculate that Worth right so I
hope till now you would have got the
idea to decide the points so each
organization will decide the point for
this particular scale how much points
that you are giving So based on that you
will be able to calculate the worth of
the each job which is available in your
organization and then according to the
birth you can divide these all jobs into
the categories right so that is the
importance of the job evaluation so
related to this whatever statistics is
there whatever that number count that we
can use it that is what we will discuss
in this session right next is the impact
of performance rating on the salary
right so how this performance rating if
inflated so in a performance analytics
we had discussed about the rating if
they are inflated if they are deflated
so how it impacts so how these r impacts
the salary of the employee within the
organization right so that is what we
also we will understand why this
analysis is important that is what also
we will discuss next that we will
discuss every year that you can see in
every organization that salary hike is
there right so on what basis we should
increase the salary hike and how it
impacts the employee right that is what
we will do it next based on this
compensation we will try to understand
who is the Key Human Resource within the
organization right so based on this
compensation for example in any academic
Institute faculty members are the Key
Human Resource right so if Key Human
Resource are underpaid as compared to
other jobs which are available in the
academic Institute this may be a problem
within the organization because you are
saying worth of that person is very high
but that that payment that you are
giving that is not aligned with worth of
the job then it could be a problem in
the future so that is what that concept
also we will understand in the similarly
we can take the example of the it
organization so in it organization if
this IT professional who are the Key
Human Resource if they are not paid very
high right then organization May face
some of the problems because if you are
saying they are the backbone of the
company but they are not being paid the
highest salary so they may not be
satisfied with the salary structure so
how you can understand the various
Factor related to this key human
resource by analyzing their salary
structure that is also we will discuss
in this particular session right so this
is the content for the day so these are
the things that we will discuss in this
particular session so let us start with
the first pay mix policies so whatever
salary that anyone of you is getting in
the organization specifically at the
managerial level so in the managerial
level that you will see first component
of the salary would be the V rate second
certain benefits that employee will be
getting now you can divide these
benefits into the two categories
short-term benefit and long-term benefit
that is what you can do it or separately
you can write the benefit and then
short-term incentives and long-term in
incentives right so this incentives
based on performance so if your
performance is high then what would be
the short-term incentives and what would
be the long-term incentives right and
what are the employee benefits are there
like you will see sick leaves are there
paid leaves are there ear leavs are
there right and health insurance are
there so such kind of benefits are there
so how much we are paying what is the
component of these benefits in the total
salary that we are drawing so what you
can do first
you can identify the department and job
position for a job position let us say
manager in any department manager is the
marketing right manager so let us assume
10 managers are working in this
department right so what is the base
rate for them what are the how much the
benefit and how much the long-term and
how much is the short-term incentives so
now you can make a one bar graph or pie
chart based on these component to
showcase how much that contribution in a
salary is how much of a each component
right so for example you can see let us
assume your salary is per month salary
is 1 lakh
rupees right and in 1 lakh rupees the
contribution 25,000
comes through because of the base salary
is there and 25,000 so 1 lakh rupees
that I'm talking about CTC right without
any deduction this 1 lakh Rupees is
there and 25,000 comes through the
benefit and long-term incentives just
10,000 and shortterm incentives are
40,000 per month right so this is the
composition of your salary of a manager
so now what you understand here constant
pressure is there because base rate is
fixed it cannot be reduced this is the
fixed amount right employee benefits are
also fixed whether your performance goes
up or down it is not going to impact
your base rate and it is not going to
impact your benefits right but if here
you can see this long-term incentives
and short-term uh incentives both type
of incentives will be impacted by your
performance whatever performance you
have but here you can see the 40% salary
component that you are drawing that is
coming through the sort in incentive so
it indicates that constantly you have to
focus on your performance because if you
will not focus on your performance then
your salary May decrease immediately
right because 40% of the component is
coming so the constant pressure on a
manager is there to perform right so it
shows the priority of the organization
because this compensation gives the
signal to the employee also right so
here you can do the compon component
analysis of the each position so which
will tell you which component should be
high and which component should not be
high right so according to the nature of
the job right if you believe that all
manager need to perform on short-term
basis and like day-to-day basis they
have to perform right so then you can
increase the short-term incentives if
you believe their long-term performance
matters a lot right initial failures and
performance May compensate the long-term
performance also then you can increase
the long-term incentives second thing if
you believe that atrion rate is very
high in your organization now you want
to reduce that attration rate right so
then you in that case also you can
increase the short-term incentives right
and you can increase the long-term
incentives and you can reduce the
short-term incentives so people may be
staying for a longer period of time in
your organization because they are keep
on performing now they want the return
of their performance so they may stay
for some more time in your organization
they can take and then they can leave
the organization so what I'm trying to
make you understand here each component
of the salary gives some signal to the
employee what this organization wants to
do right for example here if you will
see the Ben employee benefits are very
high but base rate is not that much High
employee benefits are very high like
kids school fees is refunded medical
reimbursement is refunded right housing
allowances are given on time so such
kind of benefits are very high right so
it shows that that organization is
having the caring nature for the
employee right so employee benefits are
very high and are paid on the time right
so that is what I'm trying to make you
understand this component analy is
salary component analysis or pay mix
salary structure that that is there in
the organization right it will help you
to understand which component should be
given more which should be given less as
per the employees requirement right it
is not necessary for all employees you
should follow the same pay structure
right for all employee it is not it is
not necessary so you can divide certain
jobs into the category and according to
the job you can design the compensation
right so these are the monetary benefits
in addition to this you can if we talk
about the total rewards so in that
non-monetary benefits are also there so
you can think about the non-monetary
benefit and then you can make the to
reward total rewards and then you can
offer to the employee so this analysis
will help you to understand which
component is playing role and which
component is giving which signal so
sometime you can reduce one component
and you can increase another component
salary is same but still that employee
will perceive the different thing from
about the organization because each
component gives the different masses to
the employee right I hope this much you
would have learned when you must have
learned about the compensation each
component of the salary gives the
certain masses to the employee now which
message that you want to give to your
employee after doing this analysis that
you can decide so how you will decide
which message that you should give what
is the mission and vision of your
organization think about it and then
think what message that you should give
according to your salary so then you can
say that is it is the Strategic HRM
because you have aligned the
organization compensation strategic with
the organizational strategy right I hope
this pay mix policies analysis is clear
to you based on this you can decide the
component how much should be the which
component right as per your organization
and as per the nature of the job right
so let us discuss the second Matrix that
is the job evaluation point right so if
you remember in compensation Matrix so
if you remember just in first Matrix
that I was discussing two component of
the salary core compensation and
benefits right so core compensation that
is the fixed whether your performance
goes up or it goes down it will not
impact your core compensation it is
going to remain the same right but in
the case of benefits your performance
will may impact so the type of benefit
that I already said some benefits that
you have to give to the all employees
because it is the government nor
and these government Norms vary from one
country to another country right so
there is no fixed government Norm across
the world right in India government
Norms are different in UK us that
government Norms are different so some
fixed benefit that each organization has
to give if that employee is the
full-time employee in your organization
and for part time also some other
government rules and regulation may be
there right so what you can do through
this so This Job evaluation point right
so first thing that you have to do if
you remember there are many methods are
there related to the J job evaluation so
relative grading method is there Point
method is there so most of the
organization use the point method to do
the to evaluate the job so when I was
introducing this session what is the
content in that I clearly mention how to
evaluate the job right so first thing
that you have to do you have to identify
the jobs which are available then you
have to categorize those jobs for each
job you need to identify the skill set
and for each skill set medium high low
level you have to give certain points by
giving those points you have to give the
points to the all jobs for example
assistant manager is there am is there
senior manager is there manager is there
general manager is there in the same
Department any same Department in a
marketing right so now you can say these
employees have to do the same any
assistant manager also has to increase
the sales senior manager also have to
increase the sales Mark manager also
have to increase the sales and general
manager also have to increase the sales
so how their salary will differ and how
their job worth Will differ right
because each of them have to increase
the sales of the department right so but
in the case that depth of the skill or
the expertise of that particular skill
is required so skill variation will be
there right so let us assume that
communication skill is there right so
when you are a general manager your
level of communication skill should be
very high right so so on high medium and
low based on that you can give certain
points if the skill is high then job
worth is high right certain points are
high so that point how much point that
you will give so that you need that each
organization has to decide like for this
particular skill for low level these
many points are there so that is how you
can decide the job worth of each
position right and why what I'm trying
to make you understand so job worth that
you have decided right for example for
one manager you decided the th000 points
for senior manager you decided just 1,00
points right so this is the job worth
that is what you have calculated now but
in a in the case of salary there is a
huge difference 40K and 80k right so
what I'm trying to make you understand
through this analysis there is no big
difference between the job worth of
senior manager and manager as per your
job evaluation but there is a huge
difference in term of their salary right
so this may create dissatisfaction
within the
organization you have evaluate the job
after the job evaluation the worth of
the job is very very close right but
salary differentiation is very very high
right so if if you get such kind of data
then it is the alarming situation for
the organization right you need to think
about it so what I suggest here and we
will discuss the other component of the
salary also but the whatever way that
you have calculated the job worth
whether it is the point method whether
it is the relative grading method you
have calculated so then if points are
difference of the point is also very
less then you have to reduce the salary
component also or you have to Define for
one point how much salary will be paid
are you getting it what I'm trying to
make you understand right so for 1,000
points are there so for one point how
much salary this organization pays for
one job evaluation point if you are your
job is worth equal to one point then how
much salary is there so simple thing
that you can do you if your job worth
point is 300 11100 multiply by that so
you will get the salary four salary
component and similarly you can decide
the benefits right so benefit so that is
how you can this method may help you to
calculate the compensation also right
according to the job Worth right
whatever job worth is there and then
based on that job birth you can decide
the salary structure also and if one
more thing that you can do after the job
analysis you can compare the salary if
there is a huge difference among the
employee because of unstructured
compensation people whoever is coming
they how as much as amount they are
asking that as amount is given there is
no fixed compensation policy is there or
policy was there initially when that
organization was started but after 15
year 20 year that review was not done
because of that the salary structure
have changed because the pay rise that
you are giving to the new
employees because of that the pay
structure may get changed second second
thing whatever incentives that you are
giving to your existing employees
because of that to the top performer and
poor performer so variation in that
because of that also there might be a
difference right in the salary structure
so you need to review the worth of job
regularly you can decide that interval
after 2 year after 3 year or after four
year whatever interval that you can
decide and then you need to check the
compensation in your organization so
whether that job evaluation point and
compensation both are aligned or not
aligned or mismatched so if mismatched
are there so that gives the signal for
the parity like job the compensation
parity is not there equal amount is not
being paid right for the deserving
candidate so there such kind of issues
that you may see in the organization
that may occur but if you are keep
reviewing your this compensation Matrix
then you can see some of the then you
can take a appropriate decision at the
time of whenever it is required after
doing so here you can analyze the job
worth and compensation so if you how you
can visualize it right so just you can
make annual salary and job birth all
right and then you can give a market
line so based on market like for which
job how much it is being paid and then
you can calculate at the various types
of Ros so that is what we will discuss
in the next slide right next thing that
we need to understand very well right so
this phenomena that you might have seen
in all
organization existing employees get
dissatisfied because they complain new
employees are coming they are getting
more hike at the time of joining as
compared to the all old employees then
what is the use of staying in this
organization we should move to the
another organization right so in order
to understand this region so if this
region is very high for the Atri in your
organization and like people are leaving
so that attrition analysis that we
discuss in the recruitment so if you
remember if this is the region that is
the prominent reason that you found in
the Atri region for leaving the employee
right then what you can do in order to
understand this problem in depth
what you can do for job position wise
right old employees what is the average
percentage of hike that they are getting
right from let us assume somebody was
the senior manager and became the
manager senior manager became the
manager right so how that person has
become the manager right so that manager
that person has become so that job
position that is what you can see that
job position so because of the job
position that person became senior
manager to manager so what was the
percentage hike that was given to him
right and new employees on the same
position is joining from the outside so
what is the percentage hike that is
being given so let us assume 10 people
have joined from the outside on a
managerial position in your organization
or that according to the job category
that you have decided right right so for
each job category for new employee what
is the average percentage of hike and
for the existing employees after the
promotion right they have promoted from
one level to another level so what is
the average percentage of hike after the
promotion that both things that you can
compare if you found both both averages
are close to each other then you may not
see see this phenomena and you can use
this data to do the internal branding
within the organization so that will
increase the satisfaction level of the
employee within the organization because
generally it is the perception is there
within the organization if I'm coming
from the outside then I will be paid
more if I'm coming within the
organization then I may not be paid that
much right so this perception so if you
want to remove this perception so you
can do the job after the job evaluation
based on the job worth you have already
developed the job category right so job
category for each job category what is
the average percentage of hike after the
promotion a person is moving from one
person to another person so how much the
CTC change is there but when somebody is
coming from the outside right then how
much change that that person is getting
right that's the one thing second thing
whether that person is getting more than
the existing salary right that I'm
talking about the CTC although you have
decided some big grade that is what you
have decided but is still if you found
this person is the talent talented
persons are there so you want to retain
that person and you have increased the
salary so if such kind of culture is
there in your organization in that case
this Matrix may be useful to do the
internal branding right so I hope you
would have understood the impact of this
increase of salary right so I hope you
would have learned the few matrics
related to the
compensation in this session thank you
[Music]
ah
[Music]
