Lecture 12 Tables and captions

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Jul 29, 2024
In this lecture, we explore the significance of utilizing tables, examine their various components, and provide guidance on crafting effective captions for tables and figures.
[Music]
[Music]
hello everyone namaskar and welcome to
the new discussion which we we are going
to have under this technical
communication for engineering for
engineers course and that discussion we
will concentrate on uh how to present
tables and captions because captions are
equally important as tables and also
captions are equally important in case
of figures also so we will try to touch
all these aspects in this discussion as
we know that tables and figures are used
to display quantitative information I
would repeat the important point is try
to display as much as figures instead of
table if a data can be represented in
terms of simple figures or graphs one
should prefer that one rather than
presenting in form of table but
sometimes the and certain data you don't
you may not be having a completely
numeric data or a data is all together a
different type which cannot be displayed
in any form of graphs or figures then it
is fine so preference should always be
given to graphs charts figures because
what they are basically uh bringing out
the quantitative information in a
understandable easily understandable
manner sometimes as we have also
discussed in case of Scatter Plots or
pie charts or bar graphs that they also
brings the relative information a table
one has to go through a line by line and
row by row and then only one can
understand some variations of some
relationship between the data instead of
tables figur should be uh preferred but
depending uh whether if you are having
that possibility or not second point is
whenever we are trying to represent or
bringing technical information to
readers then uh we know that it is easy
to you know to provide ease for
understanding to the reader we should
use the visual elements and uh the same
saying that a Picture Tells thousand
so that is what the that kind of
Advantage we should take sometimes
figures and tables do not replace
technical information but rather they
make easier for readers to understand
large quantities of data so uh they are
not really replacing your technical but
they are bringing large quantity of data
in a just one plot or one figure so now
while we organize the data few important
tips or points one should remember and
the first one if the results can be
stated in one sentence no visual is
needed unnecessary over visuals are also
not good or under visuals under figures
are also not good a balance has to be
struck so if it is possible that you can
write in one or two sentences then you
do not require any uh figure or graph if
the numbers are more important than than
the trend use a table if you don't want
to show the trend but numbers are
important H use a table and if the trend
is more important then the numbers use a
graph so here uh both possibilities are
there that use a table because the trend
can be shown very clearly very easily
using graphs and we also know that even
for preparing a graph we have to feed
the data in the Excel so that that is
Excel is a table or worksheet that is
nothing nothing but a table so these are
quite easily constructed using word
processor table function or a
spreadsheet program such as Exel and uh
then uh because in word or similar kind
of word processor softwares a lot of uh
you know analysis of the data sorting of
the data and other things cannot be done
it is only possible uh in the uh
worksheet programs like Excel so one has
to see that what kind of plotting he is
going to have if that is required it is
fine but only for tables then you need
not to go for Excel just uh do create a
table using the but processors whatever
the one you are having now but there are
few key elements of table and those are
like a legend you should have a legend H
for the table or the title I would say a
more preferable word here then uh column
titles The Heading of the column should
be there or in case of excel we say the
field values so what is whatever the
column is there what is the meaning of
that column and so that field values are
there and then table body that is the
quantitative or qualitative data
whatever is there and that should come
in different rows and columns so the
first row will be devoted completely for
the column title and at top of the table
you should have a legend and title one
practice which is followed in almost all
Publications thesis project reports and
there that the title of the table would
always come at the top or caption if I
make it very simple caption of the table
would come on the top whereas caption
for the figure will come at the bottom
or a graph will come at the bottom but
the title one can still have for a table
or graph and that is inbuilt in the
graphics itself so uh further they these
tables also can include subheadings or
footnotes as per the requirements now it
is further important to think about
organization of table as it think about
the organization of paragraphs the uh as
they are referred into the text or body
of the text the same way they should be
organized and uh uh within a table the
data should also be properly organized
and that you may have a kind of sorting
for the year if I'm saying or minimum
value maximum value likewise so the
organization uh of the table is very
very important and uh if a table is well
organized which will then allow the
readers or audience to grasp the meaning
of the data presented with ease very
easily because while you you are making
a presentation using PowerPoint you
don't have much time to discuss a table
so you just so the main points
associated with the table or main data
and therefore well organized table would
be easy for the audience to understand
very very easily otherwise uh if you put
too much data in one table and sewing in
one slide in a PowerPoint presentation
that may create a confusion among the
readers or audience and uh you will miss
the point now the title of the table
headed by a number followed by a clear
description title or caption caption is
very much required and before that if
there are more than or even there is one
table that table number will come and
then it is referred whenever in within
the text so therefore a number has to be
there and uh in case of thesis a number
the table numbers will come according to
the chapter so if it is the table is
coming in the chapter 2 then and there
are various tables so that would be two
2.1 and so on so forth so whenever
somebody opens the thesis if he finds a
table 2.1 it can very easily be assume
that this this table belongs to a
chapter 2 similarly the title will let
the reader know that what is the table
about through this caption or table
title and how it has been organized and
that information about the organization
of the table or data in the table can
also be mentioned within the capson now
I always prefer to provide as good
information as possible within the
capson and that makes things very clear
to the audience or readers so one should
always try and the same case in case of
figures also that the caption which we
write in the below describe the figure
as much as possible and the caption may
be lenier but it is really very very
useful for readers see the whenever
somebody's evaluating or going through a
document or thesis report what they do
as also said in earlier that they read
the title if they find interesting they
read the abstract keywords introduction
and then they start seeing the figures
and if they find any figure interesting
they will read the caption of the figure
so if figure doesn't have much
description of that it is not good that
the reader may lose the interest in that
one and therefore it is as per the
requirements provide as much as
information within the caption of a
table or figure so this length and other
things as I have already mentioned uh
should be as per the requirement but
preferably more detailed information is
always good descriptive it should be
descriptive explanatory and whatever the
interpretation of data is there that can
also be provided in the capss and see
the good practice is to see examples
from publish papers public books and I
will give you a example from a published
book that is by S Drury remote sensing
geology and if you open his book you
would find that every figure image is
having quite good descriptive good
explanation about figure or image and so
you just read the see the figure read
the caption you know what what he would
be talking in the text and if I am
further interested then I will read the
text which is printed in the surrounding
or a previous page or later page so
tables are read from the top down and
remember this thing therefore title
should go first in the body of the table
that is why the Capon of the table comes
in the top caption for a figure comes at
the bottom now the goal of column
heading
that is the field headings field
declaration and that is simply and
clarify the table if it is a given say
one column is having age then age is
days in months or years that unit should
also be there and uh so that the reader
can understand uh these things or the
details or columns or components of a
table quite easily and so the title
should be of course this applies for
everything and should have units all the
time if uh the data is having units must
mention units in the uh column of the uh
table for each column and uh uh or the
characteristics if you don't have the
numeric data then you can write the
characteristics of the uh you know
heading for the T column and so now
about the remaining part of the T table
so it should be the body of the table
that it should be organized in a way
that helps the reader to understand the
significance of the data and of course
uh first you think that how reader will
compare and will interpret will
understand that table and accordingly
you should uh try and the best practice
is try two three times to prepare table
or organize the data within the body of
the table and see which one is more
convincing
and to is going to be more convincing in
the users because what we are trying
between different columns we will be or
the reader will be comparing the data so
in that way one has to organize the body
of the table and if a numerical data is
there if it is possible to plot prepare
a graph if it is not then one has to
make if it is in decimals having some
certain Precision say two places of
decimal then each row values should have
the same decimal you may have even
0 something like but they will look a
more organized way rather than just you
know Hazard way and in some case you are
typing just one place of decimal value
but in some case you are not typing in
some case you are typing two uh decimal
places this is not good keep the
consistency H within this Precision of
your number numeric value and uh if if
there are whole numbers means no real
numbers without any decimals then whole
numbers should be lined up on the right
side of the column and sometimes table
may be more appropriate for displaying
data than a graph sometimes only I
always prefer that if it is possible to
present through a graph one should do
better that tables are great for
displaying multiple variables specific
values and comparing C atories but if
you are having too many rows then again
tables are not uh preferable and uh also
table will often require an audience to
lick up specific information to
understand the data so picture is more
or a graph would be more logical to put
rather than a table but again it will
depend on what kind of data you are
having and what kind of information you
would like to share with the audience or
readers and therefore that should be
done again these points are coming that
neat and logical manner so everything
should be prepared whether it's a table
or graph it is also important that all
raw data should not be added to the
table only the relevant data which has
been discussed in the body of the text
of your manuscript paper or thesis that
data only should come the raw data which
you might have collected but you have
processed the data so don't bring that
data in your table and the same thing is
also for the graphs that one need to
consider the message in the data that to
be communicated what do you want to
communicate what do you want to convince
the audience and accordingly one should
choose if you have done a statistical
analysis and then uh the data may be
performed or summarized uh in the result
section of your work or manuscript paper
and then you can use a again a table to
inform about uh that particular
information now this is another
important thing it is possible nowadays
using our bird processors or whatever so
if if someone has to really present a
large tables then alternate shading
pattern uh for columns and rows uh is
important so that one can really
understand in a very effective manner so
finally for this section of this
discussion the common features of it
table I'm giving an example and that
what we are having and the column heads
are there and there each column is
further divided so they are that
information is there for year-wise and
20145 in row row section you are having
the parameters or characteristics and
then you are giving these values and of
course the numeric values are fed here
also try to see what is the caption of
the table as said it has to come on the
top part and uh this should be neatly
aligned labeled columns with no
guidelines and the units or percentage
whatever is there if required some
information you want to add additional
information then you can have a footnote
for this using an asterisk and then
showing that the footnotes explain the
parameters or statistical significance
so this is one of the good examples of a
showing and data is not cluttered the
entire space has been used and
comparison between 3 years uh between
these characteristics the number of Nest
Nest hatching and other things is coming
quite clearly here so that is one of the
best one of the best B and now once we
see the good example we also would like
to see the bad example I always prefer
to see the good example first and then
bad so that one can really compare what
what went wrong in the bad example so
first of all the the title or caption is
really bad table number one doesn't say
anything so there has to be a colon and
then lot of information related with
this table should have come here rest of
the things are all right but it is
incomplete things are not preferred
secondly uh this the division between
these boundaries should have been sifted
so that we we are having just uh uh one
line row like this and these gaps are
not also light so it's a poorly
organized table this is poor example or
bad example and table legs a complete
title and the sources of information is
not provided the road titles tles two
lines as I have just mentioned each cell
is bounded as if in a spread seed and
the alpha uh alphabetical listing of
regions could have been better uh for
any understanding or searching for the
information so that is also missing this
has been sorted out based on the region
in alphabetical order that should have
been a a better way of representing data
now let's see the almost the same data
is being presented here through a the
information that this is the title of
the table and though the size of font is
different but just I wanted to highlight
this part so the
not instead of just writing table one
and leaving as it is it is giving full
information about the data which is
inside the body of the table so it is
giving the information and then the same
data is represented here in a nice
manner uh so that one can easily
understand and looks also good compared
to the previous bad example now I would
show you the examples from uh published
TBL or data or tables which have been
published in literature this is from our
own uh publication as you can see that
there are multiple columns are there
each column is having information plus
table also say and the details of a
studied earthquakes and then these three
earthquakes have been uh their details
have been shown here the date time they
let long geographic location magnitude
focal depth all these thing so once this
data because this data
cannot be represented easily in the line
graph or pie chart so therefore uh the
decision was to have a table and that
becomes much easier and uh then you can
uh see that what is happening here and
this uh the Sorting is here is with the
less magnitude first and large magnitude
later that has been shown here some
sorting some organization has to be
there another example of uh you know uh
the data is here that we are seing the
thermal infrared anomaly from a
different or the same Publications so in
here we have added the magnitude focal
depth and then pre- earthquake rise the
same earthquakes are here and the title
or caption is also having full details
so this is the best way of showing the
data in form of uh tables so tables may
be H centered on the the page uh this is
what Publications prefers or in thesis
or reports one should do it tables and
figures are numbered independently in
the sequence in which they are referred
in the text and start with table one and
figure one of course and in in case of
thesis there are chapters so if table is
coming in chapter one or a figure then
say 1.1 1.2 and so on so that will
automatically indicate that that table
or that figure belongs to chapter one so
it is acceptable to abbreviate the word
figure sometimes you be you would find
uh in the text or the title you are
having just fig and number and but in in
case of table tab word cannot be used
because it will give a complete
different meaning so this should not be
abbreviated and labeled with the table
number and description title above the
table which we have also so and
discussed previously that a title and
descripted title has to be there that is
very very useful it is something like a
subject line in case of an email or
letter similarly here this is the
subject line of the table so all columns
should be labeled properly if there are
some units they should be mentioned in
that one H like unit of measurements
time whatever is there sufficient
details should be there against each
column of the the table that will be
always helpful and set apart from the
text itself the text does not flow
around the table so keep table and text
separately and let the publisher fit
text around it or whatever in case of
thesis we we need not to do such things
because these can make reading little
difficult so uh table and text can come
uh very separately very easily now we
come to the about the figures and figure
numbers also and so figure numbers can
be used as figure one or fig one H it is
important that all figures should have
the number all figures should have the
you know they should be referred in the
WR of desertation or rather cited in
that and because we would be providing a
list of figures uh before the real text
of the thesis comes the figure numbers
is used to allowed the audience to find
the figures whiches have referred in the
text so uh proper figure numbers are
must figure title again the same same
conditions that it has to be descriptive
or assertive and uh as much details one
can provide needed that should be there
so the descripted title briefly describe
what figure is displaying but also lets
the reader to identify any Trends or
relationship
and is Guided by the text you include in
the result section because as I have
said the reader might read first the
figure or go through the figure and the
title if he finds very interesting then
he might read the text body of the text
in for much detail another way of uh uh
you know writing a title for the figure
is assertive title can help the audience
uh to quickly identify the key message
cont within the figure but one should be
sure that the title does not mislead the
audience or overstate the results it is
something like the heading in newspapers
that the heading should not mislead so
here what is the heading of a figure we
are talking so that should not mislead
overstate or understate balance has to
be there in all such cases assertive
titles can be used to identify specific
trend found in a graph highlight the key
message of the diagram but sometimes we
may write that there is a correlation
exist between these two variables two
parameters and the audience finds reader
finds that there is no correlation so
that will come under this overstate the
results that is not good so then the
audience May close may not read further
and basically you are losing uh here one
of the audiences so the example
and like a descriptive one is the effect
of dam construction on fish biodiversity
this is descriptive example and the
assertive is the dam construction
results in loss of fish diversity fish
biodiversity so slight change in the
wordings can uh bring a quite good
change between these examples now
descriptive another example is that high
distribution of two eucaliptus grandest
Plantation in land and the assertive one
is uh figure two insects defoliation of
eucalyptus Grand is reduce Kopi heide so
that kind of differentiation is there I
always prefer uh this kind of uh tone
for a caption of the figure but it is up
to you now descriptive caption example
uh of descriptive capson from one of the
Publications which is Ram naan and raana
of 2005
and they are showing that see this
caption you know it starts with Figure 1
14 and there are two maps B first is the
a is the wind patterns in the month of
January B is the regional distribution
of natural anthropogenic aerosol Optical
depth aod and each figure is having
their own Legion like aod is there in
the right figure and here it is having
Legion in the left figure and uh
likewise it is there and this data has
been from where it has been drived that
is also mention dried from moderate
resolution imazing spectro radiometer
that is Modis instrument on board of
Terra satellites December 2002 sorry so
you are providing the uh date also
therefore it is very good example of a
descriptive caption complete relevant
details are here including you are
having markings of A and B no confusion
people can compare people can compare
with the wind directions Ocean winds
direction or ocean currents similarly
they can compare with the Ral
distribution of anthropogenic aerosol
Optical a lot of discussion about the
smog over and Northern India especially
over Delhi and even this year we are
hearing lot about smog over and Mumbai
also and uh so uh if we see the wind
direction so these current directions
how they are influencing why the
concentration of this smoke is mainly in
the endogenic plane and so on so that
kind of comparison uh can be done very
easily if we are having such kind of
plotting and of course descriptive capss
another example is here and this I am
talking from a book uh of Drury I
referred back and see that there are two
images of shown here of different B data
of L set a shows the patches and B again
the band five and this is band seven
very clear full description and uh once
you read the entire description or the
caption of the figure and go through
these images you would be able to
understand very nicely so basically we
are uh ending this discussion uh thank
thank you very much namaskar
[Music]
