Lecture 54- The Financial and Economic Impact of Service- Part 3

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Jun 22, 2024
This lecture discusses the key drivers of service quality, customer retention, and profitability, effective nonfinancial performance measurements, the relationship between customer equity and return on marketing, and the role of technology in achieving cost-effective service excellence and global customer satisfaction measurement.
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
welcome to this npdl online
certification course on service
marketing integrating people technology
and strategy and now we will talk about
module 54 and as you can see that we are
talking about the financial and the
economic impact of services so that was
started uh in module 52 and it will
continue in this module 54 and this is
part three of this the issue of
Financial and economic impact of
services and these are the things that
we will cover in this module so first we
will start with understanding the key
drivers of service quality customer
retention and profits and then we'll
move on to understanding effective
non-financial performance measurements
and the relationship between customer
equity and return on marketing then we
will discuss how technology helps in
cost effective service excellence and
how customer satisfaction is measured
worldwide so now let us look at the key
drivers of service quality customer
retention and
profits understanding the relationship
between overall service quality and
profitability is important but but it is
perhaps more useful to managers to
identify specific drivers of service
quality that most relate to
profitability which will be shown in
figure
54.1 doing so will help firms understand
what aspects of service quality to
change to influence the relationship and
therefore where to invest resources so
we have understood that there
is between service quality and profit
affability but what are the drivers of
service
quality so unless we understand what are
the drivers of service quality we will
not be able to to manipulate the service
quality and thereby we will not be able
to manipulate the profits so these are
the key drivers of service quality
customer retention and profits so you
you see that these are the various
service encounters
that affect service
quality and behavioral intention and
customer intention and therefore the
profits and these are the various
service attributes that are affecting
each service encounter most evidence
from this issue has come from examining
the effect of specific aspects of
service and there are five aspects of
service that we have talked about
earlier also responsiveness reli
liability
Assurance tangible and
empathy on overall service quality
customer satisfaction and purchase
intentions rather than on financial
outcomes such as retentions or
profitability service is multifaceted
consisting of a wide variety of customer
perceived
dimensions and resulting from
innumerable company strategies such as
technology and process Improvement in
research exploring the relative
importance of service dimensions on
overall service quality or customer
satisfaction the bulk of the support
confirms that
reliability is the most crucial so out
of those five dimensions of service
quality reliability is the most
important but other researchers have
demonstrated the importance of
customization
and other factors also because the
dimensions and attributes are delivered
in many cases with totally different
internal strategies resources must be
allocated where they are most needed
some companies and researchers have
viewed the effect of a specific service
encounter on overall service quality or
customer satisfaction and the effect of
specific behavior within the service
encounters marri hotels conducted
extensive customer research to determine
what service elements contribute most to
customer loyalty and they found out that
four of the top five factors come into
play in the first 10 minutes of the
guest stay those that involved the early
Encounters of arriving checking in and
entering the hotel room so those first
10 minutes were the most
important other companies have found
that mistakes or problems that occur in
early service encounters are
particularly critical because of failure
at early points results in greater risk
for dissatisfaction in each ensuring
encounter IBM found that the sales
encounter was the most critical of all
in large part because interactions with
salese people establish customer
expectations for the remaining service
encounters another way of looking at the
problem based largely in the operations
and management literature involves
investigating the effect of service
program and managerial approaches within
an organization on financial meas
measures such as profitability now let
us look at what are the effective
non-financial performance measurements
according to field research conducted in
60 companies and survey responses from
297 senior Executives it was found that
many companies do not identify and act
on the correct nonf Financial measures
one example involves a bank that only
surveyed the satisfaction of customers
who physically entered the branches
rather than all customers including
those who banged by phone or ATM a
policy that cost some Branch manages to
offer free food and drinks in order to
increase their scores according to
various research done in this domain
companies make four major mistakes with
regard to using non-financial measures
the first mistake is to not link Majors
to a strategy companies can easily
identify hundreds of non-financial
measures to track but they also need to
use analysis that identifies the most
important drivers of their strategy
successful organizations use value
drivers map the tools that lay out the
cause and effect relationship between
drivers and strategic success in figure
54.2 that will be on the in the next
slide we will show the causal model
developed by successful fast chain to
understand the key drivers of
shareholder value the factors on the
right were identified as most important
in leading to the concepts on the left
and the sequence of Concepts from top to
bottom shows the
relationship among company strategies
such as selection and Staffing and
intermediate results such as employee
and customer satisfaction that result in
Financial results such as sustained
profitability and shareholder value the
study found that less than 30% of the
firm surveyed use this causal modeling
approach so this is figure
54.2 the measures that matter the most a
causal model for a fast food company
show the critical drivers of performance
and the concepts that lead to
shareholder value so these are to start
with selection and Staffing employee
satisfaction employee added value and
customer satisfaction so it moves from
top to down now in a staffing and
selection new hires their education work
experience in employee satisfaction
supervision support and fairness in
employee value added accountability and
empowerment and customer satisfaction
quality timeliness and shopping
experience they are important factors
that determine correction and Staffing
employee satisfaction employee added
value and customer satisfaction
respectively now from this from here it
goes to customer buying Behavior and the
sustained profitability increases
shareholder value now customer buying
behavior is determined by the frequency
the retention and the referral sustained
profitability of each outlet over time
and how much better it is than the
competition shareholder value growth
earnings and free cash cash
flows the second reason is not
validating the links only 21% of the
companies verify that the non-financial
measures lead to financial performance
instead many firms decide what they are
going to measure in each category and
never link the categories many managers
believed that the relationships were
self evident in instead of conducting
analysis to validate the linkages in
general it is critical that companies
pull together all their data and examine
the relationship among the categories
the third reason is not setting the
right performance
targets companies sometimes aim too high
in setting Improvement targets trying to
make all customers 100% satisfied might
seem to be a desirable goal but many
companies expand far too many resources
to gain too little Improvement in
satisfaction for example research found
that it commun that a telecommunication
company aiming for customers who were
completely satisfied was wasting
resources because these customers spent
no more money than those who were 80%
satisfied so now the question is do we
keep on satisfying customers who are
already 100% satisfied or we should look
for satisfying customers who are 80%
satisfied the next reason is measuring
incorrectly companies need to use
metrics with a statistical validity and
reliability organizations cannot measure
complex phenomena with one or two simple
measures nor can they use inconsistent
methodologies to measure the same
concept such as customer satisfaction
another problem that companies May
encounter is trying to use quantitative
metrics to capture qualitative results
for
important factors such as leadership and
Innovation one example of non-financial
measure is the balanced School SC card
which involves measuring four main
aspects of a business one is learning
and growth second is business processes
third is customers and the fourth is
finance balance scorecard allows
companies to pull information in a
single report to provide information
into service and quality in addition to
financial performance and to help
improve
efficiencies creating a balanced
scorecard in and off itself does not
improve performance companies will not
reap the benefit of techniques such as
balance scorecard unless they address
these four issues now let us talk about
selecting profitable customers so the
first thing is how can existing
customers we identified in terms of
profitability to accomplish this firms
need to do two things first they must
align information database around the
customers using customer identification
files
rather than around product as in the
traditional approach instead of data
files being organized by products with
customers listed several times if they
buy several products example a back
customer might be listed in a checking
account file saving account file a home
loan file Etc the data files must be
organized by customers with the products
and Affiliated revenues is stored by
customer the second necessity is to
understand record and store the cost
associated with each customers in their
customer files a daunting task for
service forms while the accounting
approach of activity based costing is
useful in many cases the allocation of
service cost to customer is arbitrary at
best ultimately it is necessary that the
management information system include a
summary profitability figure for each
customer that can be accessed easily how
can potential customers be identified in
terms of profitability as identifying
existing customers is in terms of Prof
profitability it is even more difficult
to identify potential customers who will
ultimately be in the top tiers
developing a profile of the potential
potentially profitable customer will
likely require a combination of
demographics and psychographic variables
that predict profitability and create
and testing strategic approaches to
obtain and qualify customers how can
customers be tiered in terms of
profitability ability Enterprise
softwares that links company information
such as perceptual usage and financial
data will be invaluable for companies
that want to segment customers on the
basis of profitability companies would
likely need to identify three or four
profitability segments or TI and then
make choice about how to serve them
differently to reflect their lifetime
profit uh contributions to the company
at times this segmentation May reveal
one or more segments that are not
profitable to the company and therefore
needs to be examined for ways to deliver
service to them more efficiently next is
what demographic and psychographic
variables are most effective in
categorizing profitability tiers once
Farms identify profitability segments
they need to be able to characterize
these segments into identifiable
measurable and accessible group of
customers this is particularly true with
companies who deal with end consumers
for these companies most look out at a
vast array of potential customers and
decide whom to Market to and whom to
focus on once they have a set of
customers now we will talk about
customer equity and return on marketing
although the marketing concept has been
articulated a customer centered
Viewpoint since the 1960s marketing
theory and practice have become
incrementally customer Centric for
example marketing has only recently
decreased it its emphasis on short-term
transactions and and increased its focus
on long-term customer relationships much
of this
refocus is stems from the changing
nature of the world's leading economies
which have undergone a century long
shift from the goods sector to the
service sector because service tends to
be more relationship based this
structural shift in the economy has
resulted in more attention to
relationships and therefore more
attention to customers the customer
centered Viewpoint is now reflected in
the concepts and metrics that derive
marketing management including such
metrics as customer value and voice of
the customer for example the concept of
brand Equity is fundamentally product
centered concept and now being
challenged by the customer centered
concept of customer Equity defined as
the total of the discounted lifetime
values summed over all the form's
customer in other words customer Equity
is obtained by summing up the customer's
lifetime value of the form's customer in
fast moving Industries which involve
customer relationships products come and
go but customers remain customers and
customer Equity may be more Central to
many firms than than Brands and brand
Equity although current management
practice and metrics do not yet fully
reflect this shift the shift from
product centered thinking to customer
centered thinking implies the need for
an accompanying shift from product based
metrics to customer based metrics now
let us see how to go about using
customer equity in a strategic framework
consider the issues facing a typical
marketing manager or customer oriented
CEO so the first issue is how do I
manage my brand the second is how will
my customer react to changes in service
and service qu quality the third is
should I raise prices what is the best
way to enhance the relationship with my
current customers and the fourth is
where should I focus my efforts
determining customer lifetime value or
customer Equity is the first step but
the more important step is to evaluate
and test ideas and strategies using
lifetime value as the measuring
stick at a very basic level the
strategies for building customer
relationships can affect the basic
factors like the retention rate
referrals
Sales Direct costs and marketing costs
researchers have developed an approach
based on customer Equity that can help
business Executives answer these
questions in this context customer
Equity is an approach to marketing and
cooperate strategy that finally puts the
customer and more importantly is
strategies that grow the value of the
customer at the heart of the
organization researchers have also
identified the drivers of customer
Equity that
are value Equity brand equity and
relationship equity and explain how
these drivers work independently and
together to grow customer Equity
Services strategies are prominent in
both value equity and relationship
Equity within each of these drivers are
specifications that are the levels that
the firm can take to enhance the form
overall customer Equity why is customer
Equity important for most firms customer
Equity that is the total of the
discounted lifetime values of the F
customers is certain to be most
important determinant of a long-term
value of the firm although customer
Equity will not be responsible for the
entire value of the firm for example
physical assets intellectual property
research and development competencies
the firm's current customers provide the
most reliable source of future revenue
and profits and provide a focal point
for marketing strategy although it may
seem obvious that customer Equity is key
to long-term success understanding how
to grow and manage customer Equity is
much more complex growing customer
Equity is of utmost importance and doing
it well can lead to a significant
competitive Advantage now we will look
at how to calculate return on marketing
using customer equity return on
marketing which enables companies to
look at all competing marketing strategy
options and trade them off on the basis
of projected Financial return this
approach allows companies to not just
examine the impact of service on
financial returns but also compare the
impact of service within the impact of
branding price change and all other
marketing strategies using the customer
Equity model that will be shown in
figure 54.3 Farms can analyze the
drivers that have the greatest impact
compare the drivers performance with
that of the competitors drivers and
project return on investment from
improvements in the drivers the
framework enables what if evaluation of
marketing return on
investments which can include such
criteria as return on quality return on
Advertising return on loyalty program
and even return on corporate citizenship
given a particular shift in customer
perceptions
this approach enables firms to focus
marketing efforts on strategic
initiatives that generate the greatest
returns so this is the customer Equity
model so let us start from the bottom so
these are marketing actions that drive
each of these loyalty programs Affinity
Community knowledge building and they go
and add to relationship
Equity marketing actions Drive each of
these what are the marketing action that
dve brand awareness brand ethics and
brand perceptions and these three then
go and add to Brand Equity what are the
marketing actions that will dve service
quality price and
convenience all three then go to add to
this and value Equity plus brand Equity
plus relationship Equity is equal to
customer
Equity so this is how it start in from
here a company is able to develop
customer Equity increase customer Equity
then comes the cost effective service
Excellence through technology in
addition to affecting the top line by
increasing revenues companies across the
globe are taking a hard look at what
they can do to make bottom line
improvements by enhancing productivity
making processes more efficient and
innovating
systems among the approaches that are
effective in bottom line improvements
are reducing waste in the service system
standardizing service behaviors and
actions Shifting the service boundary by
having customer perform more of the
service and substituting technology for
personal contact and human effort in the
upcoming slides we discuss ways that
technology has been used to make service
more efficient and therefore more
profitable now let us look at Robo
powered yogurt k6 delivering frozen
yogurt from from a traditional retail
store is a very expensive Endeavor with
a great deal of overhead to cover the
next stage develop to save money and
allow customization where yogurt stores
where you decide how much yogurt to buy
and how you want to decorate it however
you may not yet be aware of the latest
in automated yogurt the robo powered k6
alen Jones the CEO of the frozen yogurt
kosa concept Robo Fusion claims that the
business Potential from the automat y
yogurt Market was the reason he quit his
job at a chemical company to pursue a
venture in robotically served yogurts
Robo fusions k6 dispense yogurt and ice
cream with the help of robotic arm that
fills the cup adds the topping and
delivers the treat to the customer
through a revolving platform a
touchscreen user interface allows the
customers to select and customize the
product which sells for between 50
between dollar three and do 6 depending
on the size while the company only has
37 Robo Fus and q6 deployed globally at
the time of this uh writing they are
currently in Singapore Brazil turkey
Australia Dubai and the UAE and there
are plans to ship kics to Saudi Arabia
and Mexico a competitor of Robo Fusion
is re and RV's automated frozen yogurt
kosx which allows customers to create
completely personalized creation ations
it can be installed in convenience
stores airport schools and even
Corporate Offices to use the machine
consumers simply choose their size and
style of frozen yogurt they can then
choose from nine different flavor
options and wide variety of toppings the
machine will then create the custom
order while the consumers pay the
process is helf free and energy
efficient using 90% less energy than a
traditional frozen yogurt shop then let
us look at the example of lose the
technology nurse one of the highest cost
of hospitals comes from preventable
30-day readmission which can be high as
4.4 million per year the admissions are
largely due to patients non-compliance
with Hospital instructions about
medication and Home Care the highest
rates are for the heart attacks that is
19.9% heart failures
24.7% pneumonia 18.3% and circulatory
system disorders 10.4 % one of the
newest strategies to ensure that
patients understand post Hospital
instructions is a virtual nurse patients
Advocate named
leus developed by Boston University
Medical Center Le is an animated
character that explains medical
instructions to patients on a computer
screen thereby carefully and fully
communicating Home Care on a laptop Lees
his whe to the patient's bedside and
reviews the discharge packet while also
looking at the paper copy
patients can ask and Reas questions
using a touch screen the studies
revealed that LE helped cut readmissions
by 30% now let us look at the
measurement of customer satisfaction
worldwide so the American customer
satisfaction index that we have talked
about earlier also was created in 1994
by researchers at the University of
Michigan along with the American Society
for quality in mulak wiconsin and CFI
group in anabar Michigan the asy model
was derived from a model originally
implemented in 1989 in Sweden called the
Swedish customer satisfaction barometer
s fornell the chair of husy LLC and CFI
group developed the model and
methodology for both the Swedish and
American versions The methodology from
the American customer satisfaction index
is rapidly being adopted around the
world developers include research groups
quality associations and universities
that participate in as's international
licensing program called Global csis SM
13 countries throughout Europe using
what is called at the extended
performance satisfaction index as well
as Asia South America and Middle East
have created customer satisfaction
indexes of their own National economies
by using Global
cism the Dominican Republic launched
insc the country's First National
customer satisfaction index in 2010 and
plans are underway to add several more
Industries to it over the next few years
Great Britain's NCSI UK National
customer satisfaction index of the UK
which is started in 2007 major 16
Industries representing a broad spectrum
of the economy serving UK households
other countries that have adopted Asis
include turkey Mexico South Korea Sweden
Colombia Barbados and Singapore the
customer satisfaction index of Singapore
was launched in 2008 according to kolin
Lim director of The Institute of service
Excellence Singapore management
University just as ASI has been the
defacto standardized wager of customer
SA action the United States economy
since 1994 csisd was developed using the
same proven and respected methodology to
complement the other traditional forms
of measures of the quantity of economic
output such as GDP to provide a more
holistic picture of the Singapore
economy other countries are evaluating
the implementation of ASI based models
in this trend if this trend continues it
may be possible to create an
International System of customer
satisfaction measurement using a common
methodology to allow cross National
satisfaction and comparisons while
reaching form conclusions is still
premature because most economies do not
yet major customer satisfaction using
this General approach a recent study
reveals interesting cross National
determinant of satisfaction consumers in
self-expressive societies have higher
levels of customer satisfaction than
those in societies with survival
values literacy rate trade freedom and
business Freedom have a positive effect
on customer citiz satisfaction per
capita gross domestic product has a
negative effect on customer satisfaction
so to conclude in this module we have
understood the key drivers of service
quality customer retention and profits
as well as effective non-financial
performance measurements we also looked
at the relationship between customers
equity and return on marketing and
finally we also discussed how technology
helps in costeffective service
excellence and how customers
satisfaction is measured worldwide and
these are the five sources from which
the material for this module was taken
thank you
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
a
[Music]
