Lecture 07: Economic Models I

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
In this video, we will talk about Economic Models, which in Hindi we can also call Arthik Pariroop
and we will talk about methodologies.
In the previous video, we said that economics is a science that has its own methodology.
So our focus in this video is on that methodology.
So what is this methodology?
In economics, two types of things are very important.
One is the theoretical model.
Under the theoretical model, we study different things.
And the second is empirical analysis, which is called experiential analysis.
So let us first understand this theoretical model.
So model, as an example, we have put three models here.
One is this model, which is used in aerospace engineering.
In this, we are looking at a plane which is kept in a wind tunnel for testing.
This is a prototype of a plane.
It is a small version.
It is on a 1 by 10 scale or 1 by 20 scale.
But this is a small version of a real plane.
The second image we are looking at has a double helix of DNA.
How molecules and how DNA is arranged is shown in this picture.
And the third figure is coming from economics.
Its name is MONIAC.
M for Monetary, MO for Monetary.
N for National, I for Income.
A for Analog, C for Computer.
To tell the monetary system of a country or a country, an analog system was developed by Philips,
who was an economist from New Zealand.
He was in LSE.
He developed how we can study national income through this.
But the model of economics is slightly different today.
And why do we try to understand it?
The model of economics is made up of a mathematical formula.
In Hindi, the theoretical model of economics shows a logical and mathematical relationship between two lines.
So why are we not making a physical model like in aerospace?
Why are we not making a physical model like MONIAC?
The problem in our economics is that our subject matter is very complex.
And it is very difficult to show it through such a physical model.
You can see that MONIAC has a cistern, a hydraulic model, how will the water flow?
A lot of things have been tried to understand.
And our subject matter is human, firm, country, world.
It is a very complex subject and it is very difficult to make it physically.
So here we try to define these things through mathematical variables and numerical functions.
And talk about it.
The next technique is experiential analysis, empirical analysis.
So whatever model we make, the model will tell something.
It may be right, it may be wrong.
How do we understand whether this model is telling the truth or not?
So we do its analysis by using data in empirical analysis.
So if we take an example of how a model is made.
We take this example from the outside of economics.
We take it from the physical world so that it is easy for everyone to understand.
This is what we do in economics.
So let's say we need to understand what time the sun rises in the east.
And for religious reasons and other reasons, it is necessary to know
what time the sun will rise tomorrow, day after tomorrow or any day in the morning.
So how can we meditate on this?
One way is to wake up every morning before the sun rises.
And see the time of the clock, what time the sun is rising, note it down.
Write it down.
And if we have enough data for a year or two,
then we can see it and tell what will happen next year.
But there is a big problem in this.
One problem is that if you are seeing in Kanpur at what time the sun is rising
and you have done this data collection in Kanpur,
but this data collection will not help you in Patna, Delhi or Cochin.
So for that, you should try to understand
what can be the reason for the rising of the sun,
what can be the reason that affects the rising time of the sun.
So you may think that how good we are,
this will tell you what time the sun will rise.
Or we are in so many countries,
this will tell you what time the sun will rise.
How high we are from the bottom of the sea,
this can also tell you what time the sun will rise.
Or if someone is behind a mountain,
then these physical and biological features can also affect the rising time of the sun.
So let us say that you have made a formula for this.
You have made a formula such that the rising time of the sun is S
and this is a function of height from sea level.
And you have made various factors and you have made a formula.
So this has become a theoretical model to tell you
what time the sun will rise.
Now, if anyone can make any kind of formula for this,
it is also important to know whether this formula can really tell the time of rising of the sun or not.
So for this, you can see from the data you collected earlier
whether this formula is able to tell the time of rising of the sun correctly or not using data.
If this is working in Kanpur, then it is fine.
If you collect such data in Patna and put it in this formula
and see whether it is able to tell correctly or not,
then also it means that the formula is working correctly.
And if it is not able to tell correctly, then the formula is not working correctly.
So what will you do after that?
If the formula is not working correctly,
then there may be another factor x, which you did not take,
then you will bring that factor and you will modify this formula.
In this way, the theoretical model moves forward.
So this is NIRCHARO.
So these variables A, B, H, X,
the logical and mathematical relationship between them,
this mathematical model is telling you.
Of course, in economics, it is not about rising of the sun.
So we will have a slightly different model in economics.
It is possible that we are making a mathematical formula for what a firm does for profit maximization.
So that will be our mathematical model, theoretical model.
So now let's move forward.
The model we make requires a few things.
One is the need for simplification.
There are many factors that affect the time of sunrise.
But if we start writing all the factors here,
then our formula will become very complicated.
So we also have to keep in mind that our model should be simple.
Then we take an example, which is not from economics,
but it will help you understand.
If I want to go from Kanpur to Delhi and look at the Google map,
then the map will not tell all the features around the road.
That you will go ahead from here, a house will come,
there will be a yellow house in front of that house,
there will be a blue house in front of the yellow house.
So much detail is not in the map.
In the map, it will tell you where to turn from,
it will tell you which important landmarks are there.
But not everything will be explained there.
Because if everything is explained, the map will become very complicated.
It will be difficult to take a printout and it will be difficult to understand.
So there is a lot of need for simplification.
The economics model we make,
we do not try to make the model completely remove the reality.
Because reality itself is a complex model.
To understand it, we need to simplify it.
That is why the model is a simplified version of reality.
We have already talked about the verification of the economic model.
Whether it is telling the truth or not.
There are two ways to test it.
One is that when you are making a model,
you have some beliefs, some assumptions.
You can test those beliefs whether they are true or not.
And if there are true beliefs,
then that model has been developed in a logical way.
So if the assumption is correct, then the conclusion will also be correct.
But it is very difficult.
Again, I think you can understand things from the example.
That is why I am giving you examples again and again.
So let's say there is a firm that wants to maximize profit.
So what model can this be?
The profit denoted by pi is the total revenue minus the total cost.
And we will say that a firm tries to maximize it.
This is a simple model of a firm.
So how do we check its assumptions?
Does the firm really try to maximize profits?
If you do a survey of various people in the business world,
is it possible that many people say that
No, no, we are not after maximizing profits.
We are after doing good for people.
So if you try to verify it with the results of that survey,
then you may not get the right guess.
So in this way, in this direct way,
which is the test of beliefs, this can be very difficult.
The second way is indirect, which is more important.
What do we do in that?
Any model gives some conclusion that it is a good model.
Such things are happening in that firm.
So it means that these things should happen.
As you will see that the firm maximizes profits.
So you will see that the input material in it,
the input material in it,
there is a decrease in its use when the value of the input material increases.
We have not assumed this.
There is an assumption of this model,
which you do not understand now,
then it does not matter, we will go into detail about it.
But you understand that there are some assumptions of the model
which are beyond assumptions.
And that assumption can be checked for results.
It can be checked whether it is happening correctly or not.
And if it is happening correctly,
it means that the model is more or less telling you the right things.
And this model is good in a way.
So we can test like this.
Now we understand the form of economics models.
How does it happen?
We were talking about profit maximization.
So say that profit maximization is a model.
Profit maximization is like a model.
And in this, some variables,
internal variables,
