------------------ 📣"Green policies" are devastating our farmers. We know because we talked to them personally - from the Netherlands to California. Now you can help us share their stories! 👉https://www.epochoriginal.com/nofarmersnofood
I think it's fair to say that by now, most people around the whole world are pretty familiar
with the narrative that our planet is facing a dire crisis due to rising temperatures.
The general premise of this narrative, it was laid out fairly well in January of last
year when Al Gore was giving a presentation to the World Economic Forum and he said the
following, quote, greenhouse gas emissions are now trapping as much extra heat as would
be released by 600,000 Hiroshima class atomic bombs exploding every single day on the earth.
That's what is boiling the oceans, creating these atmospheric rivers and the rain bombs
and sucking the moisture out of the land and creating the droughts and melting the ice
and raising the sea level and causing these waves of climate refugees.
Likewise, 13 months after that gloomy speech in February of this year, you had the same
doomsday apocalyptic message being echoed by the United Nations Secretary General who
said this during this year's United Nations Environment Assembly, quote, our planet is
on the brink, ecosystems are collapsing, our climate is imploding, and humanity is
to blame.
Now, here's the thing, though.
Despite the ubiquitous number of articles that have been published saying that there
is definitely a universal consensus in the scientific community surrounding this climate
narrative, well, not all scientists agree.
And the ones that don't are not quacks.
Case in point, you have Mr. John Clauser, who won the Nobel Prize in physics back in
the year 2022.
And Mr. Clauser, he sees the data differently.
Speaking last year about the topic, here's what he said, quote, the popular narrative
about climate change reflects a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's
economy and the well-being of billions of people.
Misguided climate science has metastasized into massive shock journalism pseudoscience.
In my opinion, there is no real climate crisis.
And so a good question at this point would be, how can there be such a vast discrepancy
on the topic that is so extensively researched, such as climate?
There isn't just a small difference of opinion.
I mean, these are two completely different views on something very fundamental.
Well, we here at The Epoch Times, we were able to speak with Mr. Steven Koonin.
He's a former physics professor over at Caltech.
He's currently on faculty at NYU, and he was previously the undersecretary of science in
the U.S. Department of Energy.
And having studied the production of climate related data for the last several decades,
well, Professor Koonin, he told us the following, quote, I've watched a growing chasm between
what the politicians, the media, and the NGOs were saying, and what the science actually
said.
Nobody has an incentive to portray scientific truth and facts.
Now, Professor Koonin published a book three years ago titled Unsettled, what climate science
tells us, what it doesn't, and why it matters.
That book went on to become a bestseller.
And what it essentially did was to analyze the process by which climate data goes from
these dense thousand page scientific reports into headline news for public global consumption.
And one of the most ubiquitous sources of this top line climate data comes from an organization
called the IPCC, which stands for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
This organization was established back in 1988 by both the United Nations as well as
the World Meteorological Organization.
Now, according to its own website, the IPCC is a, quote, collection of scientists and
government appointees that are dedicated to assessing the science and climate change.
And as just a practical matter, the IPCC, it functions as both a scientific body as
well as a political body, quote, the IPCC doesn't conduct its own research, but rather
assembles teams of hundreds of scientists and working groups that collect reports from
scientific journals regarding climate change, its effects, and what should be done about
it.
About every seven years, an IPCC working group called Working Group One synthesizes the latest
reports into assessment reports, often several thousand pages thick, which are then reviewed
and edited by government appointees from 195 member nations.
Now, last year, in the year 2023, the IPCC released their sixth assessment report.
You can see it up on your screen.
However, the information compiled in this report, while seemingly objective, is perhaps
less so, quote, the information on which the assessment reports are based often has a bias
from the start, critics say, because research grants typically fund studies that support
the prevailing narrative on climate change and because scientific journals often avoid
publishing studies that suggest climate change is not dire, meaning that because scientific
journals have fallen in line with the prevailing position regarding climate change, papers
that don't conform to that position have a hard time getting published.
And actually, even further, those papers have a hard time even getting off the ground and
getting funded, given the fact that research grants are typically not doled out too easily
on studies which might poke holes in the climate change narrative.
And so even if you wind up compiling thousands of these types of studies, you might assume
that you're getting an accurate picture of the science.
However, because there is distortion at the level of the journals themselves, all the
underlying conclusions in the studies have fallen into a type of group thing.
For instance, describing the situation, Professor William Happer, who is a professor of physics
over at Princeton University, he told us here at the Epoch Times the following, quote, any
literature that supports alarmism is promoted and any that does not is rejected.
The source of much of today's climate data comes from centers whose generous funding
would cease if climate hysteria were to abate.
Likewise, you have Professor Richard Lindzen, who is a professor of meteorology over at
MIT and who actually served as one of the scientists in Working Group 1 over at the
IPCC, and he told us here at the Epoch Times the following, quote, the IPCC itself is only
studying anthropogenic man-made climate change.
It doesn't do anything regarding natural climate change.
And that's a severe technical shortcoming because you can't do things like attribution
unless you know what natural variability is.
Now here's perhaps the most interesting part.
Despite all that, Professor Koonin, he told us that, quote, when you read the assessment
reports, focusing mostly on the science, they're actually pretty good.
The data presented in the assessment reports is a relatively sober analysis.
However, it provides little support for the narrative of climate catastrophe, at least
as far as what has been observed to date.
And as a concrete example of what he means by that, if you look at chapter 12 of the
most recent assessment report, the one that was just released last year, you will find
the IPCC's assessment on the impact of extreme weather events.
And the tables that they provide in that chapter, it shows that extreme weather events that
have already emerged are limited.
Furthermore, it states a low confidence for any increase in floods, rainstorms, landslides,
drought, fire weather, cyclones, hurricanes, tornadoes, sandstorms, dust storms, hail,
sea level rise, coastal flooding and erosion.
It also indicates a low confidence regarding a decrease in snow, glaciers, ice sheets,
as well as lake, river and sea ice beyond the Arctic region.
Furthermore, it's worth noting that these assessments from the UN's IPCC are actually
supported by findings from other organizations as well.
For instance, the NOAA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, they conducted
a 30-year analysis of tornado trends and they found that, quote, the number of strong
and violent tornadoes hasn't varied much since 1970.
Likewise, there was a report published in Nature magazine in the year 2022 and it found
a, quote, declining tropical cyclone frequency under global warming.
On average, the global annual number of tropical cyclones has decreased by 13% in the 20th
century compared with the pre-industrial baseline, which is 1850 to the year 1900.
Likewise, the drought severity index that's published by the US government's EPA, it shows,
quote, no material increase in droughts in the United States between 1895 and the year 2020.
All right, just to pause here for a super quick moment, listen, it's obvious that the
financial system is not looking too great.
After being pumped up with trillions of virtually free government dollars for many, many years
now, well, the stock bubble might actually burst in the near future.
And in that process, unfortunately, it could take away the nest egg of anyone who happens
to be exposed to it.
And so consider taking this opportunity to diversify into something which is beyond the
grasp of Washington, D.C.
and Wall Street, physical gold and silver.
And the best company to use, in my opinion, is the sponsor of today's episode, American
Hartford Gold, who I should mention is also my own personal gold and silver bullion dealer.
And besides myself, they have thousands of five-star reviews from other Americans and
they also have an A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau.
And working with them is rather simple.
They have a huge selection of coins, bars and rounds to choose from.
They have super friendly staff who you can call and they can set up either gold delivery
directly to your doorstep or they can even set you up in a gold IRA.
And lastly, best of all, if you tell them the Roman sent you, they will throw in a free
gold coin with your first qualifying purchase.
So give them a call. The number is 866-242-2352.
That's 866-242-2352.
Or you can simply text Roman to 65532.
I'll also throw a link to their web page.
They'll be down there in the description box below.
So given this reality, you might ask a very logical follow up question.
If all these different analyses, including the analysis by the UN themselves, say one
thing, why are news reports inundated with the our climate is imploding and the oceans
are boiling narrative?
And the answer to that question appears to be twofold.
Firstly, the public statements from both the IPCC as well as the UN often diverge dramatically
from what their own reports actually say.
And then secondly, the predictions of a dire future are based on models rather than an
observation.
Because, you see, alongside each one of the assessment reports, the IPCC, they also release
a summary for policymakers.
This summary, it distills down the large amount of data in the full report to just a short
list of bullet points.
Furthermore, to make it easier for news outlets to report the correct narrative, the IPCC,
they also produce headline statements as well as press releases to provide a concise narrative
on climate change.
Here's how Professor Kunin describes the effect that this ultimately has.
The assessment report gets boiled down to the summary for policymakers.
And while it's drafted by scientists, a small number of them, the governments have to approve
the summary line by line.
And so you already have the potential for, let's say, non scientific factors entering.
The summary for policymakers itself is 20 to 30 pages.
And the media have to cover that.
And they typically will cherry pick the most extreme parts of it.
So that's how we get the distortions.
And then that is exacerbated by the politicians seeing opportunity in distortion and the NGOs.
And as one example of how this actually plays out in the real world, despite observing no
increase in tornadoes, cyclones, droughts, wildfires or floods attributed to climate
change.
Well, the most recent IPCC headline statement, it warns that, quote, there is a rapidly closing
window of opportunity to secure a livable and sustainable future for all.
And that right there actually gets to the heart of the matter, because much of the basis
for climate alarmism, it comes not from observation, but rather from computer models, models that
are thought to be highly accurate.
For instance, the USDA, they conducted a study of climate models during a 50 year period
from 1970 up until the year 2020.
And here's what they said they found, quote, observed changes in temperature and precipitation
have generally been consistent with the changes projected by earlier models.
The accurate projections of future climate and hindcasting of past climate makes us confident
that models can reliably project changes in the climate.
Now, that, of course, sounds very definitive.
However, if you look beneath the surface of the climate modeling industry and you peel
back a few layers, well, it really becomes questionable how reliable these projections
actually are. Speaking about the IPCC models, here is what Professor Kunin told us here
at The Epoch Times, quote, the IPCC draws up its predictions based on averaged results
from dozens of models which disagree wildly with one another.
The average surface temperatures generated by the models in the IPCC reports vary among
themselves by around three degrees Celsius or three times the amount of warming observed
throughout the entirety of the 20th century.
The assessment reports downplay this embarrassment by focusing not on the actual temperature
predictions where models diverge, but rather on the predicted change in temperatures where
models are more likely to coincide.
Then on top of that, you have the process of tuning the models, quote, the models typically
divide the earth up into grid cells, each a few tens of square miles.
These grid cells are tuned in a process of hard wiring the results from the cells to
manually account for more random elements like cloud formations, storms or humidity,
which the models can't predict, but are material to temperature changes.
Professor Kunin then outlined some of the problems present with this tuning process,
quote, there are hundreds of such parameters because the climate system is complicated
and has many different dimensions.
And so as people tune the parameters differently, they get different results.
Tuning also helps the models show results closer to observed data, but this highlights
another shortcoming of the models.
While purporting to predict the future, they often fail to reproduce historical temperatures.
They also struggle to separate human influence from natural phenomena, all of which elevates
the uncertainty of model predictions regarding human behavior.
If you're trying as a politician or NGO or company to promote a narrative, you don't
want to talk about the uncertainty.
You just want to say it's going to be five degrees warmer and the world is going to hell.
But here's the thing.
And you already know this if you follow the news to any degree.
If you question the official narrative or if you say there's a lot of nuance in this
discussion, you are apt to be labeled as a climate denier.
As just one example of thousands.
At the end of last year, here's what Joe Biden said, quote, anyone who willfully denies the
impact of climate change is condemning the American people to a very dangerous future.
The impacts we're seeing are only going to get worse, more frequent, more ferocious and
more costly.
And so outside of the bias of the scientific journals and the difficulty of getting grant
funding, you also have the leader of the world's most powerful country repeating the model
conclusions as state of fact and labeling anyone who willfully denies those conclusions
as essentially a danger to our future.
However, here's the thing.
If you take away all the hyperbole and the political threats, here's what the underlying
data actually shows, at least according to Professor Kuna, quote, we've had modest warming
since the 1900s, 1.3 degrees Celsius at the global level.
Despite that, by whatever measure you want to use, lifespan, nutrition, GDP, death rates
from extreme events, it's all going in a positive direction.
Sea level rise is continuing at just about a foot a century.
But the actual and projected economic impacts of warming are in the noise.
Even the IPCC says it's small compared to many other things that determine human well-being.
And of course, in regards to the economic impacts, there is the other side of the coin.
According to a report published by the Heritage Foundation, quote, modeling the costs and
benefits to the United States of complying with the Paris agreement and meeting the Biden
administration's goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions to 52 percent below 2005 levels
by the year 2030 predicts these policies would reduce global temperatures by 0.5 degrees
at the end of the century.
Even with theoretical efficiency, we find the cost of the policy to be staggering.
The economy would, in aggregate, lose $7.7 trillion of GDP through the year 2040, which
is $87,000 per family of four.
Now, that's pretty bad.
But consider that that's what the developed world will suffer.
In terms of the developing world, depriving them of fossil fuels will have absolutely
severe consequences.
At that point, Professor Lindzen, the professor from MIT, he told us the following, quote,
the billions of people who don't have energy, who don't have modern conveniences, they will
be condemned to perpetual poverty.
CO2 has played an important role in increasing agricultural productivity.
So we'll see everyone paying more for food and more people starving.
You are already seeing tragic consequences, even in the United States, where a whole generation
of kids has been told that they have no future.
They're not having children themselves, because what's the point of having children in a world
that's going to self-destruct?
However, questioning the underlying narrative that's leading young people to not have children
might have you branded a climate denier.
If you'd like to go deeper into this story, I'll throw my reference notes, the links to
all the reports we went through, as well as a phenomenal, comprehensive article that was
published in The Epoch Times by Kevin Stockland.
You'll be able to find all those links down in the description box below if you're the
type of person that likes to dig into the weeds.
And then until next time, I'm your host, Roman from The Epoch Times.
Stay informed.
Most importantly, stay free.