We had a hot summer in California,
the utility bills are significantly higher than last year.
And in California in general,
our bills are significantly higher and the rates are higher
than the rest of the country.
Today we sit down with a number of experts in this field to find out
why California utility rates are much higher.
We're literally operating an airplane while we're
fixing it. That is so true is what we're doing with our electric grid.
I'm Siamak, welcome to
Welcome to California Insider.
Okay, let's get started. Please introduce yourself,
one minute about yourself and your background.
My name is Jeff Ball.
I am the President and CEO of the Orange County Business Council.
We are the regional economic development engine
for the County of Orange, which is the
sixth largest county by population in the nation.
Good afternoon, my name is Louis Ting.
I'm the Director of Power Resources for Orange County Power Authority.
We're a community choice aggregation
or aggregator within the California state, a joint power authority,
and we're one of 25 CCAs within California,
and we serve mainly the three, four cities
coming with Mountain Valley,
so essentially City Irvine, Buena Park, Fullerton as our members.
Good afternoon, everyone.
I'm James Mai, the Vice Mayor of the City of Irvine,
also the Vice Chairman of the Orange County Power Authority.
Hello, I'm Chris Ellis. I'm the vice president general manager
for Coso Operating Company.
We're the third largest geothermal company in the country
and in the state. We actually do
business with three different CCAs. Excellent.
Thank you for being here today. This is a very
important topic for Californians.
Electricity bills have gone up significantly, especially
Actually, this last summer, some people are complaining.
They're wondering what's happened.
Now, the question is, why the electricity bills in California
are significantly higher than the rest of the nation?
That is an absolutely true statement.
So we look at commercial electricity prices on average and
data I'm working with is from last year, 2025.
California, 26 cents per kilowatt hour is what
we show as the average commercial electricity price.
In comparison, the U.S. average is about
13 cents. So we are double the national average.
We're also about three times higher than Texas.
So why? Why are we so much higher?
And there's a few things that we can point to.
that create that situation
and I think a lot of our conversation today is going to come back
to basic supply and demand. Obviously the demand is there.
You talked about the high power bills
during the summer. We had some excessively warm months during
the summer and so the utilization
of energy was much higher so you had much higher demand.
But on the supply side we are often
limiting ourselves from a state policy perspective.
We're not allowing ourselves to expand
our production the way that we could.
All of those things contribute to having a higher cost
and a lot of it attributable to the regulation
that we have through our state policies.
If I may, in addition to that,
I think in order to understand where we are today in terms of
power pricing, we really have to look back historically
at some of the things that have
happened to change the landscape.
And a lot of them are policy related. One of the things we
talked about earlier was the fact
that we've shut down two nuclear power plants. And it seems like
Like, not that long of a period of time,
but it's, you know, it's been nearly four.
40 years, but we only have one still operating,
and it's on its last leg.
It keeps getting extensions,
and there's a public sentiment against nuclear, obviously,
but it certainly is what I've always called
the original renewable energy source.
So there's still a lot of legacy contracts out there,
not necessarily what they call
PPA contracts or standard offer for contracts,
if anybody's familiar with those, but there
are incentives that have been offered.
And then if you look at your power bill,
you can look at the breakdown of what it is.
And there are a lot of things that go
into power pricing other than just energy.
So on the power side.
You have the energy component,
you have a capacity component, which is called resource
adequacy, and then there's
also what's called a renewable energy credit if you're dealing
with a renewable company.
Those things add up on your bill.
It does cost more money than just natural gas
or nuclear to implement some kind of renewable
energy, and that's a push of California.
So all of those things work together.
And then when you talk about wind and solar, those are.
35 to 50 percent resources.
You still have to build grid infrastructure to accommodate
all of those megawatts. So that's expensive.
You add on wildfire costs, which are our new costs,
and then the relative,
the sheer size of California and the infrastructure that's
required to maintain that.
And that's where you end up with these big costs.
I wanted to contribute also on this is when we look
at the cost of things in comparison to the national average,
California costs 65% more for our power.
$34 billion of that is wildfire mitigation or liability.
One of the things that we have to consider also
and one of the major contributors to pricing is wildfire,
not just the mitigation of it, but also the liability issue of it.
In the state of California.
Let's say SCE, PG&E, or whichever power provider,
they are responsible for any damages that are within their realm,
even if it's outside of their realm, even if they are not at fault,
they have to be responsible for that.
So what do they have to do to protect themselves
is to create forms of mitigation to avoid those
issues in terms of protecting the grid,
protecting the infrastructure, protecting
wildfire. They have to prevent it
because they're going to be liable for it. But that cost comes
down to the consumer as well.
So it's not just, hey, it's an insurance issue. Yeah, sure, there's
a liability issue, but they're going to be at fault.
So they're doing whatever they can to
protect themselves. But then the end user
is the one that is going to be paying for this.
We are basically subsidizing insurance policies
for problems in the state.
And this is a major contributing problem to the infrastructure.
We have to protect the grid as well.
So I'll just sum it up a little bit.
And thank you, Jeff, for bringing it up to 26 cents, because about
a decade ago, that's where the residential rates were in California.
And now it is significantly higher for residents
because, again, typically the.
The commercial, industrial, C&I customer typically
are afforded with lower rates because of, again, volume.
What I want to level set real quick is that from a utility
person perspective, we're about reliability and dependability.
I think that's something that everybody,
including myself, take it for granted at times.
We want to make sure that when we flip the light switch,
it's on, light turns on, TV's on.
And we want to make sure that our fridge doesn't go out
in the middle of the night, right?
So those are the assumptions that we're actually paying for.
That's what it's really about.
And for grid reliability to work,
and what Vice Chair Meyer here mentioned very well,
is that we have to make it more sustainable, but also hardened.
So wildfire is definitely one of the issues.
And now there's a safety power shutoff because of it.
And those are kind of things that the utilities try
to mitigate on the delivery side.
If you look at your electric bill,
there's really three components to it, three major components.
One is the mandatory charges, or I call them fixed charges.
One of them is generation. One of them is delivery.
And most of the charges that increase went to the delivery side
because of, again, wildfire mitigation.
So that is something that's been kind of came up.
Throughout the years, many years ago,
and it started to become a major issue.
And again, that issue, my understanding is,
I'm not an attorney, but there's only two
states in the nation that has this strict liability
or inverse condemnation law.
California is one of them.
And that's why, like Vice Chair mentioned very well,
that we're becoming an insurance
company for the liabilities.
That's what James was talking about
was in that it often defers to the utilities where
whether they're at fault or not, they're picking up liability.
And as a result, somewhere that has to get paid.
It either comes through the shareholders
or it comes through the rate payers.
But we have to remember.
As we target these investor-owned utilities,
we're dependent upon them for a lot of the
infrastructure investment that needs to be made.
And so to the extent that we push liability on
them, it increased their capital costs,
which therefore increases the cost of being able to
get that infrastructure developed.
So eventually they will end up on our bill.
Well, it's got to get paid somehow, right?
And so they pursue rate relief.
And wildfire rate relief varies based on the investor on utility.
So PG&E has the highest.
Theirs is around 24%, 25%.
I think for Edison, it's around 13%.
But again, this is an important component of the bill,
which is driving up the cost.
It's one of those three buckets.
And it's a bucket that continues to increase.
And that's irrespective of.
Now, in terms of the generation side,
so the fire is a big component, maybe it's a third of this?
Fire is a component, but fire is, so when we think about it,
there's basically three different components.
You've got your supply.
You have the transmission and then you have the distribution.
So for most of us here in Southern
California, Southern California Edison is our distribution.
If you're buying energy through OCPA,
it's getting distributed to you through Edison.
We also have a few cities that
happen to have their own utilities,
but let's just focus on the one for now.
But when we're talking about supply, that's where,
you know, we're talking about power plants.
We're talking about, you know,
different sources that we have to be able to generate electricity.
And there are a variety of sources that we have.
You know, from our perspective at OCBC,
we need all different forms of energy.
Another sector that's really under attack right now is natural gas.
Natural gas is about a third of our supply statewide.
So, just like with nuclear,
if we're going to take that offline, what do we have as a
substitute that can come in?
At the end of the day, the market should determine where
these most effective sources of energy
supply will be coming from.
And we're not in any position right now
to cut off our supply from any source because
of the large demand we have given
the sheer size of our economy in California.
Now, is there any thoughts on how much
of the cost is going to renewables?
One of the things we haven't talked about is time of use rates.
So the customer, believe it or not,
pays a different rate depending on what time of day they use the power.
And so during the day...
Power's pretty cheap because we've got an overbuild of solar.
And then what we have is as solar starts to go offline,
we see power prices come up.
And that's when you see natural gas and battery storage kick in.
And then you've got gas turbines that are filling in that gap.
And then wind will typically kick in.
There's a lot of wind that kicks in between three
and the overnight period.
Period.
Period.
You can look at the power and demand cycles
Period.
Period.
But...
and so everybody turns their air conditioners on when they get home,
demand goes up right when solar is going off.
So how does that factor in?
So renewables actually help you during the day.
Solar helps you during the day.
Solar PV, there's not as much of a premium on solar PV,
so that's actually cheaper power.
But then you've got other types
of power out there that's getting subsidized,
and there's those legacy contracts that are very expensive.
Those will go away over time.
But it's an important distinction here on the different...
Components of the bill. Yes.
And how they contribute to the affordability concerns. Right.
So and in each of the three segments, there is upward cost pressure.
But we have the ability to produce the power that we need.
We need the policies that will allow us
to be able to produce that when it's needed.
Uh, and technology will continue to improve
and nuclear is one area where we're seeing
tremendous improvements in technology
and in fact we actually had a bill that actually
passed the state this past year that allows us
to explore further some of the different
options for nuclear at smaller scale,
but technology improvements are going to factor
into this as well when we think about
our different sources of energy supply.
If I may take a step back,
I think both of you have mentioned real well that the legacy
contracts are very expensive.
And I want to just use a very quick analogy,
and I don't want to repeat the obvious, but
Jeff said it well, that when you deploy capital,
somebody's had to pay for that, whether through
a 30-year bond offering
or whether through a commercial bond offering or just investor
investments.
Either way, somebody has to pay for that return.
And we can talk about how that all work out,
but the financing cost is expensive.
The way I like to kind of...
Give a quick analogy is that, you know, if I remodel my house,
and that's what we're doing with our infrastructure today,
with our power infrastructure, it's aging.
A lot of power plants are old. A lot of the grid is aged.
We've been using this for over 100 years.
So some of these power plants and also grid needs to be remodeled.
Okay. And that capital has got to come from somewhere.
So one famous quote that I always use
is that we're literally operating an airplane while we're fixing it.
That is so true, is what we're doing with our electric grid,
because of the fact that we're shutting down older plants,
whether it's policy-driven, infrastructure, aging-driven, whatever
the drive or cost-driven, but while we're building new technology.
Some of the older contracts are getting really expensive still
because the price is fixed for
the duration, the tenure of the contract versus some
of the technology that's been improved upon
and the prices have dropped significantly
because of advancement of innovation technology.
But then again, while we're doing all this, we got to remember
all of our legacy contracts that we're still paying for.
I will say government did something
right recently when they passed a bill
That created something called R.O.
Um, is it W E R O W
E different areas generate different types of power.
This allows for a smarter wholesale marketplace.
So for one region or one state generates more solar,
another one generates more wind.
We can actually trade with other states in the Western region
and buy at a different
cost because some people may have a surplus.
You'd obviously want to buy the surplus
and we can trade or buy at a cheaper rate as well.
So that's very exciting.
That is going to potentially lower.
Wholesale costs for individuals.
That takes place in January of 2028.
So there are things that are happening
in terms of the policy side that are helping
or they're going to be helping as well.
Just add to that the pathway initiative that...
Our vice chairman mentioned very well
is that that is going to connect the grid more succinctly.
Now, there's a lot of issue to be worked out.
But at the end of the day,
other states have shown significant amount of interest with
California because they understand what the demand is.
They have the supply.
So if we can get that supply
and demand more balanced instead of being imbalanced, the
market prices will be more stable.
Do we lose a lot in transmission?
So if we're buying from different states
and we're selling to different states?
There's always an advantage to being able to source the energy
as close as possible to where it's utilized.
However, we have advanced significantly
in our transmission capabilities.
How much is that loss?
Transmission loss can be anywhere from 1% to 2%
in rest of its distribution.
There's a petition going on around right now in LA
And people are frustrated with the...
Their bill's going up significantly during these hot times of summer.
Can you explain the tier pricing?
Like, why there are different tiers based on the consumption?
Their petition is challenging the LADWP,
which is a city-owned utility kind of provider.
What are your thoughts on that?
So, time-of-use rates has been implemented over a decade ago.
And the reason being is because renewable energy tend
to generate more certain time
and certain time of the year, time of the day and time of the year.
So solar, obviously, from 7 a.m. maybe to 5 p.m. today.
But then after that, you know,
something else got to kick on to supplement that.
And again, there's base load,
meaning that there's something that got to generate 24-7
because some of the commercial industrial customers need a 24-7 power.
So those are kind of things,
if you add all the supply stacked up, there's always a base
load that's needed by the state, but everything else is variable.
When a customer wakes up in the morning,
the electricity spikes a little bit.
When they go to work, it goes back down because nobody's at home.
Back to minimum.
But when people go back home, turn everything on,
again, that's the curve that you can kind of think of.
However, a commercial industrial may be flat all day long,
maybe that peak during noontime.
So therefore, time of use rate came around
mainly because of supply versus demand.
That supply, there's significant amount of supply
during the day where there's no demand.
And so the rate is supposed to trigger a price signal where people say,
well, maybe you want to use a little bit more during the day,
but then you've got to diminish your return after that.
There are still some public-owned utilities
or municipally-owned utility in the states.
If you look at the rates of certain smaller utilities,
if they haven't spent any money on upgrading their system
or updating their system because they don't need to,
then their rates will maintain lower.
And IOUs, investor-owned utilities,
because of wildfire mitigation, because they own such
massive amount of infrastructure that they had to upgrade,
those costs on the delivery
part of the bill has significantly
increased compared to the generation.
There's two components.
You mentioned the TOU piece, but there's also the usage component.
So you'll find, if you look closely at your electric bill,
you'll have basically a baseline
rate that takes you into the next tier, the next pricing tier.
And so if you exceed this amount of
usage, you go to the next tier, the next tier, and the next tier.
And I think what people have
seen, and possibly it's due to the excessive heat here
and the more AC usage. And so what's happened
is, oh, I was using 500 kilowatts a month or whatever it is last year,
but this year I used
a thousand and now I jumped through two tiers
and now I'm paying 65 cents a kilowatt hour
instead of paying 15 cents a kilowatt hour.
And so I think that's on an individual basis
what people should look at their bills
and see how is their usage affecting their bill.
So the question they have is,
is the power company making a lot more money
when their bill is jumping from $1,500 to $2,700?
And where does the money go?
If you can clarify that, that would be very good.
No, because as was described in terms
of the cost of the power within those times.
And so it's providing a consumer choice,
right, of when you consume your power.
Part of the problem that we have is it's a lag from when you utilize it
to when you actually get the bill.
So, you're running your air conditioning all day long to stay cool
when we have this massive
heat wave, and then all of a sudden you get
this surprise with the bill.
Now, I will say our utilities have done
an excellent job in offering programs that allow
people to just pay stable rates through the year,
that then gets adjusted based on their
past utilization.
And so, that can help in terms of that spike.
But why the rate goes up?
The rate goes up because of the time when it's utilized,
because if you're using it during the
peak periods, it's basic supply and demand, right?
So if you're utilizing energy at a time where
there's the highest demand and less supply,
it's going to be more expensive. And that's what that
tiering does, is it allows for the consumer
to make more choices. And as suppliers...
We want to see that choice.
We want to have that price incentive so that we reduce the demand.
Because remember, we have to be able to supply energy,
not just for what's utilized, but
we also have to have the capacity
for what could need to come into play.
We all expect that light to come on when we flip the switch.
But if we all flip that switch at the same time,
that's a huge rush on the grid.
The grid has to be able to match that with the supply.
So it's a pricing incentive so that people utilize power.
When there is a greater supply for it, and then,
of course, battery storage can help with a lot of
that. So homes that have a system that allow them to store power,
then you can utilize your store
power during those higher cost periods
and bring the power into your storage at a time when the
rates are lower, like in the middle of the night.
What about the consumption? So if you consumed a
And then you over-consume because it was hot.
And then you are now in a new tier,
and then do you have to pay more per kilowatt hour
because now you're in a new tier?
And would the power company make more money
because you're selling the same?
The answer is actually no.
No, there's more revenue for the power company,
but it's also increasing the capacity requirement
on them, so therefore they have to have larger supply,
which they have to pay for.
So they've got to pay for the supply whether you use it or not.
From the standpoint of having the capacity in case it's needed.
So there is an additional cost for the utility
and that gets passed on to the consumer in the way that you described.
So maybe it's better to understand how the power market works.
The power producer bids in in the day ahead market
a certain amount of generation that they're going to provide.
And the California Independent System Operator...
Takes all of those bids
and has an estimate of how much the entire state of California
is going to consume on an hourly basis.
And so they'll buy that much power in.
And there's a price that's set on an hourly basis for that day.
Then there's the real-time market,
and so what happens is if they do a good job predicting
what the demand is going to be,
then the real-time pricing will run fairly close to what the
day-ahead pricing is.
If they didn't do that great of a job
and then the demand goes significantly higher,
the real-time market price goes skyrocketing.
Now who makes the money?
Well, sometimes it's a community choice aggregator will do very well,
but they take on the risk.
And sometimes it's like if it's a gas plant and they're a peaker,
meaning they just turn
on when demand gets high,
then they make a significant amount of money during that.
But at the end of the day, they sit there
and make no money waiting for that to happen.
So they have all of their overhead costs that are still there.
They have to buy fuel, whether they use it or not.
I think the question also is, no, there's no price gouging.
No.
So there's no price gouging.
But in terms of power, it's not.
So they don't profit more when they charge more.
It just costs more.
And that's why most power companies don't adjust the rates every day,
every hour, or even every month.
Right. So typically a power company or load serving entities,
they adjust the rate based on what the regulators.
Allows them to, okay?
And I can even say further,
there are certain utilities that I know for sure
they haven't changed the rate since 2016.
So 10 years, same rates, right?
So at the end of the day,
they make adjustments based on fuel costs.
They make adjustments based on market conditions, right?
So if natural gas price goes down to $2 MMBtu
versus $5, there's some adjustments there.
Whether or not the utility can absorb it,
that's all based on what the reserve they have.
Now, so when you say a utility makes money,
sometimes they have to absorb that shock.
And that's where that goes.
So again, all of the non-profit utilities,
there is no profit involved from that perspective.
How much resources and capacity does the grid have?
So we had these hot days in the summer.
Was it sustainable?
Based on the California Independent System Operators report,
we survived, not just survived,
we thrived this past summer.
California and CAISO has been very cognizant of making sure
that there's a very plentiful supply versus demand,
meaning that the grid infrastructure
upgrades on the transmission side all
the way to the distribution side, it's been
It's been ongoing, and that's another reason why
the bills keep going up on the delivery side of it.
But also on the generation side, CAISO also needs to balance that.
With the generation that's coming into the state,
along meeting with the renewable portfolio standard,
and also the regulator requirement to meet the renewable energy level.
So all those, it's been doing better, I want to say.
And the upgrade of the infrastructure has led to less outages
or the outages that's not planned, so that we can better plan ahead
on a seasonal basis, monthly basis and daily basis.
I have the opportunity to work with a lot
of different industries and you hear acronyms
and so you have to figure out
so he's referenced CAISO, CAISO's come up a couple of times
that's the California Independent System Operator
that's what that stands for so
as we continue to grow and expand with our economy
we're going to have to be able to increase our capacity
so it's not a substitute for
The increasing demand will always have
to do better in having more capacity.
And as we say, we want all types of sources of energy
that are contributing towards that capacity.
But certainly we as consumers, whether it's commercial or residential,
I think are doing a much better job
in terms of balancing out that demand.
And I think a lot of that has to do with the tiered pricing.
Our state regulators, every year, they do a forecast.
And this forecast goes now all the way to 2045.
Because 2045, based on Senate Bill 100,
we had to get to 100% renewable energy.
And they actually do a forecast of both demand and supply, both sides.
And they do essentially production cost modeling,
which goes up to stochastics, using those
type of technologies,
forecasting how much demand will be there and how much supply that's
in a pipeline.
And then CAISO, again, started last year, they did a 20-year
transmission line capacity study and also looking at four projects.
See, instead of every 10 years
per the federal requirements, they did a 20-year study.
So those are kind of the projections they will come out
with based on the infrastructure investment requirements.
But also looking at what demands being forecasted from,
again, the latest one is all data center loads.
They're looking at how much data center is going
to be added in California and when and where.
And those are all the forecasts that they publish every year
to ensure that we get that supply demand match.
A couple of things on that.
Number one, forcing ourselves into 100% renewable.
I'll go back to my earlier comment of allowing the technology
and the market to really drive
that timing. When we set mandates like this,
we often put ourselves in difficult pricing positions
and that contributes towards the affordability issue.
The other thing that we have from a mandate
perspective is the forced conversion to electric vehicles
and what that means from an
infrastructure support standpoint,
not just being able to produce the energy that's required,
But also how we distribute that energy
and having enough charging stations that are available.
If you were to imagine something like 10% electric today,
well, you go to 90% electric.
That means it's eight,
nine times the amount of demand that we have right now.
So how do we meet that demand from a supply standpoint
while we're at the same time forcing ourselves into 100% renewable?
Those, in my mind, conflict.
contribute towards a lot of the affordability concerns
that you were addressing at the
beginning here. We are trying to be the voice for you Californians.
And if you like our content
and what we're covering, make sure to check out
the newspaper Epoch Times. Epoch Times is a unique
newspaper which tries to bring people together
by providing content that covers all sides of
the story with respect and with a lot of data and numbers.
Our goal is to bring clarity to independent thinkers.
There is a lot of social media hype
and negativity and emotion in the media right now.
When you read our paper, you get a different feeling.
Make sure to check it out and let us know.
Now let's go back to the rest of this interview.
Is there a way for us to close this gap?
It's like roughly double or triple the national average,
the cost of electricity here.
Is there a way for us to...
make this gap a lot smaller,
because it's impacting the standard of living in California.
And especially if you live in more rural areas,
like off the coast, you have to use air conditioning.
And also businesses, there's impacts for some manufacturers.
I like to keep things simple and limited to three.
So our three would be, first of all,
let's move away from these artificial mandates,
100% renewable by a certain date, 100% electric
vehicles by a certain date.
Let's let the market and the technology, market's response to the
technology, really drive what those are.
The second thing that we would point to is the fact
that we need all supply. So let's not cut off natural gas. Let's not.
Limit certain forms of energy,
let's be open to nuclear and other forms, because actually
nuclear is the most efficient of all
of the different power sources that we have.
And then the third is to find ways that we can
be much more efficient in how we engage
in our infrastructure investment.
Where we're putting so many different requirements on the development
of whether it's on the transmission line improvements
or where we have new sources of energy.
It's the permitting process, the whole,
you know, environmental challenges.
We have to be environmentally responsible.
You know, we were big pushers of Proposition 45,
which unfortunately did not go through.
But it's very easy to abuse the environmental protections that we have.
And all that contributes to cost.
And so just as it's difficult for us to build new housing.
It's difficult for us to build the infrastructure that we need.
So those would be our three policy recommendations
for the new administration and the new legislature
to really help to enhance the supply
and be able to deliver the energy that we have more
efficiently.
I might want to add also is, you know, to what Jeff is saying is that.
Affordability and being climate conscious should
not be mutually exclusive.
I think you can be both, but there
are regulations from the state currently.
For example, when a city joins a CCA,
and it joins a CCA like Orange County Power Authority,
all the new residents
and the residents get automatically enrolled into the CCA.
Automatically enrolled.
Which is the community choice program,
which is competing with the investor-owned utility
system.
Correct.
You have to opt out.
You have to manually opt out.
So, well, you don't have, you automatically get enrolled.
And that's just law by Sacramento.
That's the state law.
You get automatically enrolled into the CCA.
The discussion point is at what level
are people are going to get enrolled in?
Are they going to get enrolled at the base level?
Are they going to get enrolled in the middle tier?
Are they going to get involved at the top tier?
Previously, they were automatically enrolled into the top tier.
That's 100% renewable.
So everyone was being enrolled in the top tier.
What I said is, if we're going to auto-enroll people
because it's legally,
let's get them in the lowest tier so that they have a choice to go up.
Which is cheaper, right?
Which is cheaper, which is the third, fourth tier below that.
It wasn't popular because it costs the power authority.
I represent the power authority, but I also represent the city,
and I also represent the residents.
So out of those three, I have to choose somebody to represent the most,
and I'm going to represent the people
because that's what I was elected to do.
If I'm going to have to get them into something, give them the choice,
the choice to be as far as they want.
If they want to go back up, they should be able to go back up,
but don't enroll people in the most unaffordable tier.
Because you don't know their choice.
Get them into the bottom tier.
Then they can make the choice to go up or go down or remain there.
And that's part of affordability.
We're allowing the choice,
but then also we're being mindful of affordability as well.
The key point is that we need to offer choice.
So at the end of the day, I think there's a lot of benefits to CCAs.
And we're here to serve the communities.
I think that's one of the choices that people can make.
If I could add CEQA.
It is a very onerous process.
Also, tacking on the prevailing wage issue
creates significant additional costs of development.
Again, environmental protection has to happen,
but we've become such a litigious society
that there are actually counsel out there
Basically,
Hold your projects hostage because of CEQA and prevailing wage,
and we pay very, very
well to our subcontractors,
but prevailing wage versus what maybe you might not pay as
a prevailing wage as an operating facility versus
a constructing facility, it can be
two and a half, three times the cost,
and so I'm not even sure how to deal with that
But...
The fact that your whole project can,
you can make a significant investment on the front end of
this and the whole project can be just stopped
because of some legal firm that's just ambulance
chasing, for lack of a better term, is really problematic.
There's two elements to that.
And by the way, in no way are we suggesting that.
Environmental responsibility should be done away
with for the sake of building a power plant.
But we've seen multiple situations throughout
the state where CEQA is waived.
For what is deemed to be a vital project,
an arena in downtown Sacramento, a football
stadium in Inglewood are examples where CEQA was set aside
so that the project could get done. So
my point is, if you have to make an exception to do the right thing,
we probably need to go back
and look at the rule that created the exception.
The fact is that it can be delayed and time is
And it increases the project expense,
which then increases the cost of the power that's being produced.
The other issue that we have is duplicity in the...
permit process and it's not allowed to operate,
it's not allowed to happen at the same time.
So if he's building a new power source
and he has to get certain state permitting and
certain federal permitting,
usually within the state it's multiple agencies,
one agency won't even talk to him until he has
the approval from the other agency
and it just extends the time.
So it takes longer to get these on operation.
And because of those delays, it increases the cost to produce,
which therefore increases the
cost of the power.
So again, I go back to efficiency in our supply and making sure that
we have a reliable system that is able to bring
the power sources to the market in an efficient
manner. And we are not efficient in how we do it in California,
and therefore wonderful that we
We can pull power from other states.
When he is able to build a power plant in California, that's jobs.
That's local jobs.
So we're moving jobs out of state.
When we're making it difficult for them to build
and operate power supply here in California.
And we end up paying for it
in our electricity bills one way or another, right?
I want to respond to your comment there that what can we
do if anything can be done to alleviate this problem.
Realize that this is what happens
when too many government hands are in private business.
It ends up making everything more expensive.
And we need to be mindful of that as well.
Well, thank you so much for being here.
This was a very exciting and great discussion. I learned a
lot from this and I hope Californians will learn a lot.
We really appreciate you guys being here.
Please come back. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Tell us what you think about this discussion
and tell us if you have seen a significant
change to your electricity bills
and what part of the state you live in.
You can always email us at
[email protected] or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siyamak Orami. This is California Insider. We'll see you next time.