Roman Army Pilum Spear Reconstruction & Testing Plans
A little discussion about some Roman pilum javelins, how they are made, types and some plans we have for reconstruction and testing different types.
▼3 extra EXCLUSIVE videos each month on PATREON, which make this channel possible:
https://www.patreon.com/scholagladiatoria
▼Facebook & Twitter updates, info, memes and fun:
https://www.facebook.com/historicalfencing/
https://twitter.com/scholagladiato1
▼Schola Gladiatoria HEMA - sword fighting classes in the UK:
https://www.swordfightinglondon.com
▼Matt Easton's website & Pinterest:
https://www.matt-easton.co.uk/
https://www.pinterest.co.uk/matt_easton/_saved/
▼Easton Antique Arms - antique swords for sale:
https://www.antique-swords.co.uk/
#romanempire #soldier #military
today I'm visiting will Sherman of
medieval arrows and I'm talking to him
about my
pum hey folks Mattis here schola
Gladiator and will Sherman of medieval
arrows I'll stick a link below um if you
want to check out what will does now
you've probably seen him before on my
channel and also on Todd Todd's Workshop
Channel as well now uh years ago many
years ago now actually I did a bunch of
testing with the Roman pum now I should
mention this example here is not made by
Wilt this is made by Fabrica cacti who
make really good Roman stuff now when I
did my testing this was before Todd
subsequently did his testing with uh pea
uh and came up with lots of interesting
uh data on results if you haven't
checked out Todd's videos please do CU
they're awesome and also if you haven't
seen my videos on the pum with my far
more Amer throwing uh but nevertheless
against various different types of
material check those out as well I'll
stick some links below but I got to
thinking I have been meaning to reprise
my um testing of the Roman pum for a
while now because I think we need to
look at different types of peum and we
need to look at different constructions
and we need to look at different uh
materials of being thrown against armor
and other things so um the first things
first this is basically an introductory
video to hopefully something that we'll
be going forwards with but um will I
wanted to talk to you about the
possibility of creating a new head or
adaptation or new shank for this peum
for one specific reason when I was
originally testing this and I can't
remember if I made this public knowledge
I discovered that these heads are made
of essentially raw ir/ mild steel they
are quite soft at the tip now that's
obviously a problem as you've known from
the arrows versus Armor thing if you
shoot something with a soft tip into
something something hard the hard
material usually wins uh The Only
Exception is with things like bullets
where they're traveling so exceptionally
fast that they can travel through the
harder object anyway but that's not the
case with a hand thrown thing like this
or even with a with a an arrow or
crossbow bult so what I found was this
was compressing curling bending at the
tip we're not talking about the shaft
here when it was impacting things like
steel plate or iron plate so how would
you go about creating a weapon like this
where you want essentially a soft chank
but with a hard tip that is more able to
go through something like Laura
segmentata armor uh you do it in a
couple of different ways one would be to
keep that the cheap soft material I
don't know how important it is for that
to bend I that's a theory isn't it but
yeah and my conclusion was they Bend
sometimes and I think that's Todd's
conclusion as well they Bend sometimes
and that's anecdotal in the sources that
this sometimes happens but they don't
need to bend and the primary purpose is
for this to pass through the shield and
hit the person behind Okay so I would
make that out of iron yeah in a
traditional way yeah and I would scarf
weld a steel head onto the end mhm so
that's that's ending your iron about
here yeah forging a scarf into it taking
a chunk of hardenable material like
steel yeah scarfing the end of that
Forge all of them together and then
you've got this area which you can
Harden sharpen to whatever you want to
and you've got this area which isn't
expensive steel which is more time
consuming to work with as well yes
that's cheap that's soft that's quick to
forge yeah very small amount of
hardenable material on the end yeah
that's how I would do it good so so
something I found in my researches as
well is there is uh as some of you might
know from watching uh other related
channels where they' talked about the
Roman peum there's actually quite a wide
variety in peela they don't all look
like this so you might be used to seeing
pum that look like this because they've
been featured in movies they've been
featured in TV shows documentaries and
they'd be featured even in asterisk uh
and they pretty much always look like
this but there are a whole bunch of
archaeologically found pea which don't
really look like this for a number of
reasons they have different shaped heads
they have different length shafts
different thickness shafts some of them
even have barbed heads they have
different wooden shafts they have
different attachment points there are
socketed ones and tanged ones and they
have even additional weights on them
sometimes as well so hopefully in the
future I'm going to be looking at some
of these different types of peeler um
but one thing I wanted to ask is uh will
from your point of view would there be
any mileage in trying to add a steel tip
onto one of these somehow yeah that's
the other way of doing it would rather
than doing it in two pieces you do the
whole thing in Iron mhm and then you
could you got two options you could then
Forge weld a very small amount over that
iron point so a sleeve kind of well like
a like a staple right so like so you
forge it into into that shape and you
forge it over like a horseshoe like a
horseshoe yeah the great thing about
that is you've got steelway you want it
on here and you've got barbs coming off
the end yeah which is quite a cool way
of doing which we see on angun and and
some arroe heads which construct
Arrowhead is exactly what that is you
got iron core and then you Forge World
your steel edges to it and whatever you
want to them you can cut them off or you
can bring them out into barbs which is
yeah so so basically you know I have a
pair of these um peeler and they've got
IR am mild steel things I I would like
to get some hardened heads for them I
figured well you know I know where he's
not that far away from me he makes
things that are similar to this although
I don't think you've ever done AUM
before or you've done an done angone the
entire thing was iron with iron and
layer steel head the entire head was a
separate compon okay cool um but you
know I think it might be an interesting
new project and maybe something that you
guys might be uh interested in seeing
unfold so there we go that's all we're
going to say about it for now uh however
if you are viewers who have particular
interests in the Roman military or
archaeology and you know things about
the Roman pum and you know examples that
we could maybe use as inspiration for
the shape and design of the head do you
know anything about the Metallurgy as
well do you know if any analysis has
been done I know that there are books
and you can't always believe what you
read in history books unfortunately
because when we start looking at the
actual archaeological data we often find
the history books are wrong um but I
don't know if any analysis has actually
been done of the heads of Roman peer so
if you know please let us know in the
comments down below and this will be an
ongoing and future project and this is
really just an introduction to the
concept of it and hopefully Will's going
to be helping me bring some of this to
realization and we will be testing PM in
a variety of different ways and against
various different targets anyway thanks
again to will for having me over we've
done lots of really cool stuff today I'm
very tired from forging um and uh yeah
we'll look more at the Roman pum soon
but if you've got anything to contribute
or ask or suggest then feel free to do
so in the comments down below okay
thanks a lot and thanks to well no
worries Cheers Cheers folks
bye

