Gladius VS Spatha - Why Did The Empire Abandon The Gladius?

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
4 Video Views·Nov 16, 2024
If the famous Gladius/rectangular Scutum combo had proven to be so effective for so many centuries why did the Late Empire Romans choose to abandon it in favour of a spatha/round shield combination? Here is what I think.
So today we will be addressing a topic which I find to be particularly interesting and intriguing
and that is the reasons why the Romans actually decided to use a short sword namely the gladius
rather than a long sword for such a long time. So to be specific in this video we will have
two main questions that will be addressed or will be answered hopefully. The first one being why the
chose to use a short sword in the first place and then secondly we will be talking about why
the Romans eventually in the late empire will actually stop using these
and will change into it and start using the significantly longer spatha.
Now we know that at first the Romans used swords which were a lot closer to Greek swords but with
time the Romans will change their weapons and from the new designs we will have the famous
Roman gladius. The Roman gladius was a very effective sword particularly good at stabbing
but we do know that the gladius is also perfectly capable of cutting and we do have literally proof
of that as during the Macedonian wars Livy tells us that the Macedonians were horrified to see
dismembered bodies suggesting that the gladius was also perfectly capable of cutting and chopping.
But regardless of all this the gladius' primary function was that of close combat quarter
situation and the reason why the Romans chose to use this weapon is because the main target
that Romans were trying to hit and that they were trained to hit was the lower abdominal region.
The reason for that is that most of the times a stab to this part of the body will be lethal.
Also another thing that we need to keep in mind is the fact that when you stab and this is
something that I have addressed more in detail in a dedicated video that I have not to gladius but to
knives in general it's called knife fight be aware of lies I think it's got like 370 000
views at the moment and it's quite a good video so I suggest you to watch it but in that what I
say basically in that video is that although I am talking about knives there specifically
stabbing with a shorter pointy weapon is one of the most difficult attacks to defend from it is
very effective it's lethal so if the Roman had chosen to use a longer sword their effectiveness
at stabbing or thrusting wouldn't have been as good and that was what the Romans were mostly
trained to do. Also we do need to keep in mind that one of the reasons that Romans chose stabbing
was not only the fact that it was very very effective and very difficult to see particularly
when keeping the gladius back and covering yourself with the scutum was very very difficult
for the opponent to understand where your point was going to to go because we do need to keep in
mind that although the Romans were encouraged to thrust this area of the body they were also
trained to take any possible advantage so they were also trained to thrust an opponent in the face or
on the thighs but another reason is that Romans fought in close formation what that means is that
while you are in a formation if you've got soldiers on your sides if you start swinging your sword
like this you will most likely end up stabbing your friend in the eye which is definitely not
going to be a very pleasant situation so that was also something that Romans had to keep in mind
close tight formation doesn't allow you to move freely with this sort of movements. The gladius
was a very effective weapon also because not only was made of steel and this is something that many
people get wrong many people think that since for example the Roman Republic or Repubblica Romana
flourished during the iron age that many people think that gladius were made of iron but when we
say iron age as I have said in my dedicated video Roman armor iron or steel when we say iron age
mostly it's called like that not because only iron was available but because most tools were
made of iron but please let me underline this tools as far as the Romans were concerned most
if not all gladius were made of steel the Romans were already very capable of making steel although
and what it's interesting is that sometimes in some gladius what we find is not only a gladius
made with pattern welding but also we find different levels of carbon or percentage of
carbon within the same blade and some of which for example are very interesting because they have
a higher carbon percentage in the core and low carbon edges. The second question is though if the
gladius scutum combination was such an effective combination then why changing it because we do
know that eventually the Romans will stop using gladius not entirely but most of the infantry will
move to the longer spatha well what most people don't understand when they start trying to
comprehend this change that occurred in history is that you don't if you really want to understand
this you shouldn't focus on the equipment alone if you just look at Lorica segmentata gladius
heavy infantry and compare it with the subsequent Lorica hamata spatha and rounded shield version
of heavy infantry which will replace the traditional imperial Roman legion then if you
focus only on the armament then you will not see what is really going on to understand these changes
you need to understand the whole historical economical and political context within which
all these changes will take place we already have mentions from Tacitus of the spatha in the
first century but this new version of this longer version of sword will start replacing the gladius
in heavy infantry troops towards the end of the second and third century so we are indeed in the
late empire now what characterizes the late empire now one of the things that characterizes the late
roman empire is the fragmentation continuous invasions in the frontiers civil wars and military
anarchy it was a time completely different from the wealth and splendor of the old roman empire
during this time it's easy to see then that from a financial and economical point of view
making hamata was a much better choice and then producing lorica segmentata which was harder to
produce required specialized smiths and was definitely harder to repair but what about the
weapons isn't making a longer sword more expensive and less cost effective than making a short sword
in a situation where short swords actually worked well you see at this time
Rome has a completely different approach to war it's moving from offensive only to defensive only
and considering Rome was constantly being attacked and invaded from lots of different places it
needed to rely on something that had been almost forgotten for centuries cavalry
so if you look at a late roman empire legion you will see that you will find a lot more auxiliary
troops but with time with all this increase in auxiliary forces mixing with citizen troops
the spatha will completely replace the gladius in heavy infantry so late roman empire heavy
infantry will also use spatha and the gladius will be relegated to light infantry only now of course
one of the first things that we can immediately understand as being one of the advantages of the
spatha is the extra reach so for some reasons Rome now has decided not only to use a different kind
of armament both easier to find and more familiar with the auxiliary troops that it was recruiting
but they were also choosing some other different kinds of tactics we need to understand that most
likely one of the reasons why the romans wanted more reach as opposed to the of the close quarter
combat gladius is because most of the barbarian enemies that they were facing were moving into
onto a cavalry based warfare fun fact there was an actual difference between the sort of the kind
of spatha that roman or auxiliary cavalry was using and roman heavy infantry was using infantry
spatha would be pointier as they were again using for thrusting only where a cavalry version of the
spatha will have a rounded tip so it was only used to slash and cut and the rounded point was also
there to make sure that the horseman would not stab his horse or his feet by mistake so the final
question for this video is if you could choose between wielding a roman spatha or a roman gladius
which one would you choose to bring with you in combat please let me know in the comments below
me probably i'm too much in love with the splendor and glory of the old roman empire but i would
choose a gladius any day all right then i hope that you enjoyed this video if you did please
remember thumbs up and subscribe to my channel for more content from the metatron please consider
to share this video on your social network to help this channel grow and remember the metatron
has spread his wings
