Why were FLANGED MACES ACTUALLY USED by Medieval Knights?
In the last year I have started thinking about flanged maces differently. Here is a new take on why I think they were used by medieval knights. Also check out @dequitem
▼3 extra EXCLUSIVE videos each month on PATREON, which make this channel possible:
https://www.patreon.com/scholagladiatoria
▼Facebook & Twitter updates, info, memes and fun:
https://www.facebook.com/historicalfencing/
https://twitter.com/scholagladiato1
▼Schola Gladiatoria HEMA - sword fighting classes in the UK:
https://www.swordfightinglondon.com
▼Matt Easton's website & Pinterest:
https://www.matt-easton.co.uk/
https://www.pinterest.co.uk/matt_easton/_saved/
▼Easton Antique Arms - antique swords for sale:
https://www.antique-swords.co.uk
#knight #medieval #history
the flanged mace in the age of plate
armor was I completely
wrong hi folks Mattis here scholar
gladiatoria so this is a flanged mace
that is it has flanges on it a fairly
famous type of weapon if you go to
museums like the Metropolitan Museum of
Art or the wallet collection or the
Tower of London you will see weapons
like this from Mostly from the 15th and
16th centuries but the flange mace did
actually come around in the well earlier
in the 14th century really so I've made
a lot of videos in the past talking
about different types of weapons such as
the flanged mace or indeed the famous
Warhammer here which we might refer to
later in this video and I have to say
that you know you live and you learn and
the fact is that um I made certain
assumptions about flanged maces based on
my limited experience with them I'm
primarily a sword and poleaxe and Spear
and Dagger instructor I haven't really
used used maces very much in combat at
all because they're not very safe to use
but some people I know have one of those
people who's kind of turned around some
of my thinking around the place of maces
in the age of plate armor so we're
talking about 14th 15th 16th centuries
here is decm the channel decm and I'll
stick a link below down to his channel
so Leonard over
ATM has a lot of armored fighting
experience and he has experimented with
lots of weapons including these flashed
Maes and I've had some interesting
discussion with him um as well directly
and um the fact is that I it has turned
me around to looking at the place that
flanged maces play in Warfare
particularly in the 15th century cuz I
think that some of the assumptions I had
made were actually a little bit wrong so
what I'm going to summarize here is some
of my thoughts based on the latest
research discussing with people like
Decat and also looking at period artwork
from the 15th century paintings
manuscript things like this and also
some written sources as well looking at
where I think the role of the mace
particularly the flanged mace is in the
15th century that is at the height of
plate armor and the fully harnessed
plate armored Knight so the very first
piece of context I want to set out
before going on is that indeed maces
have been around since prehistory far
far back into prehistory um and in fact
if we look at developed Maes with where
you've got a shaft of one material and
ah head of another material they were
famously used by the Egyptians for
example um and they were issued to
infantry but they were also used by um
pharaoh and monics and stuff like this
so maces either with a stone head or a
metal head have been around since time
in Memorial and definitely they are very
effective weapons I don't want what I
set out in this video to give you the
impression that the mace is a useless
weapon blah nobody should ever use it
within certain contexts in certain
periods it's extremely effective weapon
but here's the headline it doesn't seem
to have been a particularly popular or
effective weapon in the era of full
plate harness we'll go into why in a
second but we'll also go into well why
did the flange mace exist who used it
and why so fundamentally those two
things yes maces and clubs extremely
popular through throughout human history
and prehistory um but while they were
around in the 15th century they do not
seem to have been particularly common
weapons and they don't seem to have been
particularly effective and of course
those two things go hand in hand so
briefly why weren't they very effective
in a nutshell deam has set this out very
well on his channel and that is because
flange Maes don't do an awful lot I'm
not saying they don't do anything but
they don't do an awful lot against a man
who is in full plate harness and that is
a very particular thing and that's a
particular type of armor that only a
particular type of person War so
high-end men at arms and knights the
really the richest people in society the
top 1% um and it's they were only around
for a relatively small amount of time so
we're talking 14th 15th 16th century so
during that period yes indeed maces were
used but for the most part the onehanded
mace is not especially effective against
armor specifically full plate harness
the next important thing really
important thing to say about Maes in
this period in the 15th century is they
were not used instead of Swords per se
and I think if you're used to the uh
being exposed to something like maces in
something like video games or role
playing games even or perhaps even
movies then you might think of the mace
as an alternative to a sword but it
wasn't the sword was usually present
where Ace was present so pretty much if
we look at Medieval art most people who
had something like this 15th century
flanged mace also had a sword therefore
this is enough no sense a weapon which
is supposed to supplant or replace a
sword it is a weapon that's used in
addition to a sword for reasons that
we're going to look at here and at the
same time I also want to make clear that
the flanged mace was a high status
expensive object it was something that
would cost you as much money as a sword
this isn't a low quality or a cheap
easily obtainable wooden cudel or
studded Club it is a very expensive
difficult to make object and I know
people like fabis ca who actually make
flange Maes and they are a lot of work
we should also be thinking about things
in this context like the PX as well
these are expensive and nightly weapons
that cost a lot of money and make take a
lot of time to make therefore I don't
want you to think that the reason that
someone might choose to use a mace is
because they don't have access to a
sword or because they can't afford a
sword or a poleax or something like this
that is not the case the kind of people
that used flange Maes were the same
people who owned multiple weapons full
plate harness did own multiple swords in
most cases and did own poleaxes as well
they had these maces for another reason
so as always when we talk about Maes one
of the first things that comes up is the
symbology and the status what they
represent and we know if we go back all
the way to um the Bay of tapestry the
Battle of Hastings we look at Bishop Odo
and he's carrying a wooden Club and we
know throughout history going all the
way back to the Roman and in fact going
all the way back way beyond that that
batons and maces are indeed a symbol of
justice and kingly power or Pharaoh
power in case of Egypt so yes they had a
symbolic purpose and in fact so much so
if we look at uh Britain's Parliament or
England's Parliament today you will see
they still carry maces with a symbolic
purpose a lot of uh Mayors and people
like this also have Mas it so uh
generals also carry batons if you look
at even World War II um any of the lead
armies if you look at the German field
Marshals for example They Carried Batton
so batons um scepter maces these are all
related objects and they are symbolic of
power so yes
absolutely sometimes in medieval art we
see someone who is wearing a sword and
carrying a mace and that doesn't mean
that they've necessarily chosen to carry
the mace because it's more effective
than the sword it could could be that
rather than carrying a normal generals
baton they're very unlikely to get into
combat and so they might be carrying a
mace because you can use it for combat
it's more effective than a baton but
it's also a symbol of who you are that
being said they can of course also be
used as weapons and in fact some sources
do talk about the use of Maes as weapons
and we even see them fleetingly in some
treatises as well particularly as we get
into the 16th century interestingly and
we'll come to that a little bit later in
the video so um so mes absolutely could
be used as Weapons of course they are
still a bludgeoning instrument you can
still smash someone in the helmet and it
should be pointed out that head shot
specifically seem to be what these and
things that warhammers were mostly about
um so yes absolutely it is still an
effective striking weapon and in fact
there are some specific peculiarities of
the mace which are mentioned in some
sources and in fact if we go outside
Europe and look at Persian sources they
even describe using the mace to break an
opponent's sword okay so in some cases
this can be used not necessarily because
it's more effective of overcoming plate
armor but because it's good at something
else specific and I'd encourage you to
think outside the box about what do you
think maces would be particularly good
at I know that uh deam for example has
suggested they'd be very good at taking
prisoners where you don't want to shank
someone through the armpit for example
cuz they'd obviously die uh instead you
want to smash them in the helmet such
that they are subdued or dazed and that
you're able to Grapple them into
submission and take them prisoner so in
some cases yes absolutely this could be
a weapon of submission and we know that
law enforcement Ed these and they become
modern police trunions incidentally in
the modern world but think outside of
that as well we know from Persian
sources these can break swords and maybe
some other things other specific uses as
well that we haven't yet thought about
but we are starting to get a picture
that within armored fighting the sword
is a more effective weapon in general
than the maces while both can be used
against noral opponent and you can win a
fight with both weapons generally
speaking the sword which is able to stab
into gaps particularly remember we're
talking about the era of full plate
harness here able to stab into iets of
visors or faces or into armpits and
insides of elbows and around the back of
the legs and places like that this
thrusting weapon is generally speaking
more effective at uh incapacitating or
killing an armored opponent than the
however bear in mind also what I said
about the fact that the person who has
one of these also has a sword and in
fact we do also have some written
documentary evidence for the fact that
the sword was the preferred first weapon
but this would be a good backup why
would you need that you you might be
asking well simply you've got to
remember that within the 15th and 16th
centuries and earlier than that of
course swords didn't always stay in one
piece and we have like colossal amounts
of evidence of many evil swords breaking
in use why would they break in use well
first of all their steel wasn't as good
as ours their heat treatment wasn't as
scientific as ours but secondly they're
smashing them against people in armor
and if you're repeatedly taking it
doesn't matter even if it's a modern
great quality sharp sword and repeatedly
smashing it into hardened steel or iron
armor it's going to get it's going to
get broken at some point it's going to
get damaged at least and there's a good
chance it will get broken so swords
broken use if your sword braks what are
you supposed to do have one these so um
these were carried as backups to sword
particularly in a Cavalry environment
and of course sometimes you might even
drop the sword so having a backup weapon
is always useful and one of the great
things about a mace is it's almost
impossible to break so while a sword
might be great cuz it's got edges in a
point it's far easier to break than a ma
is so as a last ditch weapon as a for a
striking weapon anyway obviously you've
got your dagger as well but as a last
itch striking weapon a maaz is a pretty
reli able last itch weapon even if it's
not as good as a sword you know it's not
going to break on you now I've mentioned
Cavalry a few times and I want to be
absolutely categorically clear with you
on one thing in this video and that is
that these maces seem to be almost if
not 100% almost exclusively related to
mounted use that is Cavalry so these
were backup weapons for mounted men so
indeed their first weapon would usually
be a lance their second weapon would
usually be a sword and their backup
weapon or perhaps sometimes by choice
for some specific reason might be a mace
now these weren't universally carried by
Cavalry there were some Cavalry who
always had maces as backup the Turks
often had maces the Polish copied them
um uh so janisar had them in the Ottoman
Empire also the mamlukes often carried
maces the Persians often carried maces
the Indians often carried maces later on
so these were often backup weapons for
cavalry after their primary or secondary
weapons were expended or for specific
purposes and we'll get into that in a
second but I want you to remember that
this short mace is almost entirely
doesn't matter whether you're looking at
the Islamic world or India or um Europe
is almost exclusively seen as a Cavalry
weapon much like incidentally the short
Warhammer is as well in contrast if
you're fighting on foot certainly if
you're fighting in full plate harness
then of course you'd have a weapon with
greater l and greater reach like the POA
so in many ways this is the
infantryman's mace it does all of the
things well it's everything really it's
a spear it's an axe it's a hammer it's
all of those things and it's got two
ends as well so fighting on foot things
like the poax and the glaive dominated
the mace is really a Horseman's weapon
but why is it a Horseman's weapon I hear
you ask well so combining some of the
points we've made here if this is your
secondary weapon after the Lance is
broken or stuck into an opponent then if
this breaks or this gets knocked out of
your gauntleted hand this is a useful
thing to have as a backup moreover this
is something that can hang via a ring on
the side of your saddle bow on your
horse if you're fighting on foot you
can't easily carry one of these as a
backup okay so we sometimes see people
on foot holding these in their hand
probably for symbolic reasons to
represent who they are but generally
speaking you'd have a poleax or a spear
or a glaive in your hand and a sword at
your side and a dagger on the other side
you don't have any space to be walking
around having a mace hanging off your
belt and it's not a very convenient
thing to walk around with so these are
great hanging off a saddle bow the horse
Takes the weight you don't have to worry
about carrying it firstly secondly
almost indestructible therefore if your
sword breaks really good
backup also the mace on Horseback being
relatively short while you're holding
the range of the horse is fairly easy to
use you're less likely to hit your own
horse with it but in addition to that in
terms of the power it offers so you will
notice of course that A A Mace is
balanced towards the head okay so the
point of balance is here unlike a sword
which is balanced towards your hand that
means it can hit with quite a lot of
momentum but now consider you're sitting
on a horse two important things about
sitting on a horse as my friend Zach
Evans will tell you firstly height if
you are striking with a mace on an
infantryman who's below you you have the
additional momentum um of gravity behind
here so if you're striking downwards
especially if you stand up and then
droping your saddle down you've got the
additional Force as well as that mass
and the balance of it and your arm
you've got the additional force of
gravity going down cuz you're above them
but if you're striking another Cavalry
man then you've got momentum of speed as
well so mass times velocity if you're
going along smack with a heavy object on
the end of a short shaft that you can
keep a good hand on handle on you can
hit with an awful lot of forces with on
these from horseback added to the speed
of your horse which is not a factor that
you have on foot on foot these are not
particularly powerful weapons not
particularly effective weapons against
plate armor but on Horseback a lot of
things change because of the power of
the horse now specifically in the
context of the 15th and 16th centuries
you could say the 14th as well actually
there's another thing to think about
when you're fighting on Horseback and
we've already established this is
predominantly a Cavalry weapon not only
is the opponent if you're just fighting
oneon-one or you happen to be fighting
one person in that moment not only is
the opponent a valid Target but of
course the horse is a valid Target as
well and we see this for example in Fury
or talhoffer particularly in Fury he
pretty much one of his first lessons is
to Target the horse instead of targeting
the rider in that case it's with a lance
but he also does it with a sword he
doesn't show maces but absolutely you
could use a mace now horses at this time
weren't always armored but they were
sometimes armored now I offer you you
this against a large meaty muscly
creature like a horse swords are
designed to be extremely effective
against humaniz targets they're not
extremely effective against horse siiz
Targets in fact we know obviously Spears
of various kinds and lances are
effective against horses Swords not so
much so against a horse bearing in mind
you're not necessarily aiming to kill a
horse with one blow or anything like
that but you're aiming to uh
discombobulate the horse so to put it
off fighting and to make make it hard to
control for the rider in that context
Perhaps Perhaps maces and I don't know
any WR evidence for this perhaps maces
smacked into a horse's head have more
effect than a sword thrust or a sword
cut would and of course if the horse is
wearing a chandron and it's wearing
other armor then perhaps the mace is
more effective at putting the horse off
the fight than a sword would it be so I
hope all of this information comes
together to give you a different way of
looking at the makes particularly in the
15th century perhaps even 14th century
as well then perhaps simply going oh
well it's a top heavy weapon and you
break armor with it and it it hurts the
person through the armor it turns out it
doesn't really most plate armor is is
able to withstand the blows of maces
really really very well and in fact you
are at greater risk in full plate
harness against someone with a sharp
pointy sword jamming it in the gaps than
you are from someone just bashing you
with their mace the fact is that armor
is designed to be bashed I mean you can
do pox fighting it's designed to be
bashed with really quite heavy objects
and you to be more or less okay you
might get some bruises you might be a
bit battered around but fundamentally
you'll survive the dagger or the sword
stabbing between plates and into gaps
and into the eyes and stuff like that is
more of a mortal danger to you than
being hit with a mace even on a helmet
okay however taking all of the things
I've just said about it being useful as
a backup weapon it may be being
effective uh more much more appropriate
on Horseback and a good backup weapon on
there potentially being able to break
other people's blades potentially being
uh useful against people's horses when
they're riding and really being a
Cavalry weapon remember on foot you're
usually going to have something like a
poleax or a longer weapon it doesn't
suit really as a as a foot weapon at all
um with these
proportions however there's another
factor I haven't mentioned so far and
that is historical context so we see
maces being used particularly in
medieval and early Renaissance Art in
areas where they were fighting opponents
who weren't necessarily European Knights
now if we just look around the world and
see where else were Maes popular at this
time we have the North African mamluks
we have the uh Persians we have the
ottoman Turks we have have
Indians so these are people who were
using many of the similar weapons to we
were using in medieval Europe but they
weren't wearing plate armor and here's
the thing I'm coming to the conclusion
that while this might have symbolic uh
meaning in late medieval Europe and all
sorts of other useful um sort of facets
to its existence fundamentally if we
look at the big picture the short
Horseman's mace is really something was
popular in areas where they didn't have
plate armor or didn't have hardly any
plate armor I'm not saying it didn't
exist at all but very very little of it
in other words the opponents were only
wearing a helmet and male or sometimes
lamala the mamuk use Maes as well
incidentally um so if you have Lamela or
male here's the thing if you strike a
breastplate or a pauldron with a mace it
doesn't do anything really at all
however if if you strike someone who's
wearing male or Lamela then the force
transmits through that in a far more
effective way than the bridge or Arch
formed by hard plate armor so European
plate harness perfectly adapted to
receiving blows with a mace however if
you are a German Knight and you might be
fighting some tartars or you might be
fighting some ottoman Turks then a mace
might be really useful now because do
you know what M armor and lamala is
really good for protecting against it's
really good for protecting against Cuts
that's exactly what it was designed to
do it's not fantastic against thrusts um
but fundamentally one of the great
things about a mace on someone wearing
male or Lamela is you can smash them
anywhere and you stand a pretty good
chance of breaking their collarbone or
their shoulder or their arm bone their
forearm bone or their ribs you know
whichever bit their sternum whichever
bit of them you hit so long as they're
only wearing male with a relatively thin
historically layer of padding underneath
um perhaps even just layers of clothing
underneath or Lamar you stand a better
chance of having a immediately disabling
effect with a mace against one of those
opponents than you do a European Knight
and within Europe as well as we go into
the 16th century thanks to gunpowder and
artillery and various other things
happening on the battlefield and large
pipe blocks and things like this there
are fewer people wearing heavy armor if
we call it that so yes kn still existed
yes heavy Cavalry was still a thing but
the majority of infantry if you look at
a standard L connect for example is
wearing less armor in say 1520
1530 than most Billman were wearing in
1470 okay they they are wearing on
average less armor a lot of soldiers
Anyway by this point and therefore the
mace starts to become popular and
effective again and we do see a lot of
Maes a lot of flanged Maes in museums
are 16th century they're not 15th
century the number of 15th century um
flanged maces in art is really quite
rare we start to see it more as we get
towards the end of the 15th century and
into the 16th century and specifically
in certain parts of
Europe where the battlefield conditions
perhaps favored it and made it more
appropriate for Cavalry remember not for
foot soldiers so there we go I hope
that's given you lots to think about
thanks again to deem for all of his
thoughts on this topic because I have to
be honest I had accepted the standard
narrative around maces in the past and I
think what we're looking at now is a far
more informed and nuanced and I have to
say I think more realistic and
believable narrative as to why the
flanged mace existed and why some people
chose to carry them even if they weren't
ever hugely popular thanks a lot for
watching I have been Matt Easton of
course I will be again next time as well
hopefully subscribed if you're not
remember to click that button please
give me a like if you've enjoyed this
video and I really hope I'll see you
back on the channel soon cheers folks
thanks for watching we've got extra
videos on patreon please give our
Facebook a like And subscribe if you
haven't already cheers folks

