Lecture 47 : Weldability of Carbon and Alloy Steel - I

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Jan 11, 2024
Weldability of Carbon and Alloy Steel - I
foreign
[Music]
hello I welcome you all in this
presentation and you know we have seen
that the to look into the weldability
aspects of a metal we have to see the
properties of the weld metal as well as
the properties of the heat affected Zone
to see whether they are sound or not or
the kind of properties which are
available with the heat affected Zone
and with the weld metal
so ah
like say especially with regard to the
steel welding
you know is steels
ah is an alloy
of carbon and iron
so when only the carbon content is
controlled it is called
carbon steel but when other alloying
alloying elements like aluminum chromium
molybdenum
is also added in control way apart from
the carbon then it is called
l y
Steel
so in this
topic basically will be initially
talking about the weldibility of the
carbon and
carbon steel and l y
Steels since both are of the ah
hardenable metal systems means the
Harden ability means herniable
metals
ah which means when ah whenever they
experience the well thermal cycle this
show such kind of the metallurgical
Transformations where increase in
hardness of the metal ah takes place
ah so ah however the hardenability of
the metal will depend upon the
composition of the
Steel
ah low carbon
Steels are of the low hardenability
while high carbon Steels are of the high
hardenability similarly alloy Steels are
of the higher hardenability than the
simple ah low carbon Steels or
ah so to have the combined effect of the
carbon as well as alloying alloying
elements present in the steel
we consider the combined effect of the
different alloying elements present in
the steel through the
carbon equivalent so carbon equivalent
is a factor which includes the effect of
the carbon as well as other allowing
elements on the hardenability of the
steel so higher the carbon equivalent
greater will be the hardenability so if
the alloying element concentration is
less carbon content is less than the
Harden ability will be low on the other
hand if the carbon content is high
alloying element concentration is also
High then it will be leading to the
higher hardenability this is very
simplified format of the hardenability
so most of the Steels show the carbon
and alloy still show the hardenability
and that is why
ah there are two important aspects that
are looked into to see the validability
of the steel one is the
the cleanliness of the weld metal
which is all about the slag kind of the
slack which is present in the
weld metal or if it is free from the
slag ah and another one is the kind of
the
ah the heat affected zone property
variation these are the two important
aspects and in addition to this if the
metal is really very sensitive for the
defect and discontinuity formation then
we have to see the discontinuities being
formed in both in both weld metal as
well as heat affected zone so as far as
the weldability of the steel is
concerned we will be looking into the
cleanliness of the weld metal with
regard to the slag inclusions and
then the heat affected Zone properties
so the cleanliness of the weld metal
depends upon the affinity
of the guesses atmospheric gases Like
Oxygen Nitros hydrogen nitrogen
etcetera these are present during in the
welding environment and when at a high
temperature these these interact with
the metal in the molten State they react
and form the
their oxides nitrides hydrides so these
impurities must be taken care of and for
that normally we use fluxes these fluxes
when react with the impurities these
form slag more the impo greater the
Affinity of these gases Critical with
the impurities formation grid will be
the slack formation so creature will be
the slag inclusions
entrapment tendency and which in turn
will be reducing the cleanliness of the
weld so greater is the Affinity of the
gases with the metal in the molten State
Great rule with the slack formation
tendency and so the red so that it will
be reducing the cleanliness of the weld
metal some types of the slacks which are
formed during the welding they can be
easily detached easily detached but
there are few types which ah show the
poor a detachability and when the slag
is not detached properly from the belt
weed then it may remain attached and
that can lead to the formation of the
slag inclusions so the slack
detachability and amount of the slag
which is being formed both affect the
cleanliness of the weld metal
as far as the heat affected zone is
concerned ah even in case of the Steels
which are having the higher
solidification temperature range they
show the Liquidation in the neck in the
region next to the fusion boundary like
this ah if the
ah we know that the if when the steel is
welded any Zone which is heated above
the liquidus temperature will be brought
to the
molten state but thereafter there will
be a Zone which will be a musty Zone and
that will be fall falling in the
solid liquid region ah and thereafter
there will be a solidus so the Zone
which is falling between the liquidus
and solidus will be having the ah both
liquid as well as the solid phases so
the this region which is very thin
ah where partial melting
due to the application of the heat takes
place is called liquation
and this liquidation is known to reduce
the
mechanical properties
and increase the cracking tendency of
the Zone next to the fusion boundary
which is partially melting or ah where
liquidation is taking place so the
detervation in mechanical properties as
well as increased tendency in the region
next to the fusion boundary ah
especially in case of the high
solidification temperature Steels ah
this one is formed ah apart from the the
Liquidation in the region next to the
fusion boundary ah whenever Steels which
commonly have the perlite ferrite benite
in the phases which are completely soft
phases when they are subjected to the
unfavorable well thermal cycle these
lead to the formation of the martensite
and the formation of the martensite in
the heat affected Zone coarse grained h
a z
and the formation of the martensite this
leads to the
ah this leads to the hardening of the
heat affected Zone increased hardness
reduces the toughness reduces the
ductility so ah means impact resistance
of the heat affected zone is reduced and
when the metal is subjected to the heat
affected zone is subjected to the
tensile residual stresses it shows the
great cracking tendency as well
ah some of the metals or some of the
steels
like a steel which is being welded in
quenched and tempered condition
so obviously its properties will be
corresponding to the quenching and
tampering corresponding to particular
temperature say steel has been quenched
and tempered at 400 degree Centigrade so
during the welding the heat affected
Zone will be formed and any region which
is heated above 400 degree centigrade
that will be over tempered
and we know that over tempering
invariably leads to the softening
so q and T Stills even in case of the
laser welding and other welding
processes leads to the softening
and this localized softening especially
in the region away from the fusion
boundary ah sometimes leads to the
weakening of the joint and forms the
location of the fracture ah in case of
the dissimilar metal systems
dissimilar steels
where there is a great variation in the
percentage carbon per percentage of the
alloying elements
ah in that case like one side we are
having the very low carbon
ah is steel system like point zero five
percent carbon in austenotic stainless
steel and on the other hand we are
having simply ferritic Steels having
like say 0.2 percent carbon so whenever
these are the fusion welded what we will
notice that ah there is a movement of
carbon from the
high carbon Zone to the low carbon Zone
due to the concentration gradient and
this kind of the ah diffusion of the
carbon from the high carbon ah Zone to
the low carbon Zone leads to the
depletion of the carbon
this depletion or deficiency of the
carbon leads to leads to the softening
of the steel next to the fusion boundary
and on the other hand it leads to the
enrichment of the carbon on the osmetic
stainless steel side and this kind of
the enrichment leads to the formation of
the unfavorable chromium carbide and
which in turn reduces the corrosion
resistance and sometimes hardening of
the steel is also caused due to the
localized carbon
enrichment ah apart from ah these
undesirable effects like liquidation
hardening softening carbon migration
there is another ah undesirable feature
or unexpected Behavior which is shown by
the heat affected Zone Steels in the
heat affected zone is the in case of the
carbon Steels like medium carbon stage
when they are subjected to the welding
what we notice that the heat affected
Zone
whatever is formed it experiences very
low toughness
especially under the low temperature
conditions for example if ah if we
notice this ah this is ah temperature
zero degree Centigrade 20 degree
Centigrade 40 degree centigrade and on
the other end minus 20 degree Centigrade
minus 40 degree centigrade and if the
the toughness or the impact resistance
of the heat effector zone of medium
carbon steel which has been subjected to
the welding if its a
ah impact resistance is measured as a
function of temperature then we will
notice that on reaching to a particular
value of the temperature there is a very
sharp drop in the toughness so in
initially at a high temperature
toughness may be of say 100 Joule but ah
with the reduction in temperature it may
come down to 10 to 15 Joule so such a
load level ah toughness may lead to the
Imperial may lead to the fracture under
the impact loading ah so ah this kind of
the behavior is more frequently shown is
shown by the heat affected Zone ah of
the Steels which show the hardenability
and this kind of the drop in the impact
resistance ah at lower temperature is
characterized in terms of the ductile to
brittle transition temperature it is
always expected that at this d v t t
will be on the lower side so that there
is no drop in the toughness
under the service temperature conditions
ah then ah there is a ah like as far as
the heat affected zone is concerned many
unfavorable phase transformations in the
heat affected Zone can take place ah in
the steel and one of them is like in the
Steels like stainless Steels especially
the formation of the chromium carbide at
the grain boundaries this kind of the
chromium carbide formation lowers the
corrosion resistance and this is also
called
weld decay
ah and this leads to the ah reduction ah
intergranular corrosion and premature
fracture due to the localized corrosion
taking place along the grain boundary ah
then another undesirable phase
transformation is the formation of the
sigma phase
ah in case of the high chromium
systems ah Sigma phase is formed which
lowers the notch toughness
no toughness lowers the fatigue
resistance Rovers the ah ductility of
the heat affected zone so formation of
such unfavorable phases and
intermetallic compounds in the heat
affected Zone ah sometimes leads to the
ah reduced performance of the ah of the
well joint ah and reduced reductility ah
reduced availability ah of the metal due
to the in unfavorable metallurgical
Transformations apart from these
phase Transformations there can be
formation of the martensite ah there can
be formation of many inter metallic
compounds and unfavorable carbide
formation so formation of the martensite
leads to the
embrittlement of the heat affected Zone
and formation of the intermittently
compounds and the carbides ah leads to
the ah or it promotes the various kinds
of the cracking like typhoid cracking or
the reheat cracking
so all these will be reducing the
validability of the metal ah or
weldability of the Steels if such kind
of the unfavorable metallurgical
Transformations ah take place
in the steel ah as far as the
discontinuity development ah is
concerned in the steel weld joints ah
the common ah the discontinuities which
are observed in the steel weld joints
and dictate the weldability of the steel
is the porosity
porosity is primarily ah observed in
case of very
low carbon steels
very low carbon Steels ah and those and
when the welding
ah process is not well controlled then
the the gaseous pockets are formed in
the weld metal
and thereby these lower the validability
ah inclusions of the various types like
slag inclusions
or the in the impurities trapped in the
weld metal
impurities
trapped
in the weld metal all these lower the
ah all these will be there as a
discontinuity and may lead to the
rejection of the weld metal and once the
weld joint developed is rejected ah then
of course the metal will be showing the
reduced depth weldability the steel
wedge ones show various types of the
cracking Tendencies like the first one
is the solidification
cracking
solidification cracking is typically
observed in the
World Center Line at the weld Center
Line in the Steels which show The Wider
solidification temperature range in
austenitic stainless steel it is
observed when the Delta ferrite is very
limited so
ah the the weld Center Line immediately
after the welding will show the cracks
in the well joint and that will lead to
the frequently rejection of the of the
belts and that in turn will be reducing
so all types of the cracking of the
steel weld joints will be reducing the
validability as it will require the
increased precautions during the welding
to avoid such kind of cracking so if the
solidification temperature is is very
wide or the Delta ferrite formation
tendency in austenitic stainless steel
is very limited then we have to use the
suitable filler so that the Str is
reduced or the Delta ferrite formation
tendency is increased so that we have
five to ten percent Delta ferrite in the
weld metal in order to avoid the
solidification cracking tendency so we
need to take extra care to avoid such
kind of the cracking tendency then the
liquidation correct liquidation cracking
is observed in the region next to the
fusion boundary wherever the ah the the
two phase zone is found both solidus as
well both solid and liquid phases are
present and this is the
basically the musty Zone which is ah and
this machine will be wider in case of
the Alloys having the wider
solidification
temperature
range then the heat cracking is will be
occurring due to the unfavorable
ah metallurgical transformation ah in
form of a like very fine carbide
precipitates along the grain boundary
and it happens ah after the welding ah
when the joint is reheated either for
the stress relieving or it is heated to
the high temperature during the service
ah such kind of the
carbide formations ah lead to the ah
reduced ability of the grain boundaries
to sustain the external stresses during
the service and which in turn promotes
the cracking the delayed cracking is
observed in case of the
hardenable
steels
ah like all medium carbon steel high
carbon steel and alloy Steels wherever
the tensile residual stresses develop ah
the yield strength is high ah the
welding is being cons performed under
very high restraint conditions and the
hydrogen concentration in the weld metal
and the heat affected zone is high so
those will be leading to the delayed
cracking or the cold cracking cracking
of the
a well joint of the steel is also
observed ah on in the corrosive
environment when we ah either apply the
external tensile stresses or the
residual tensile stresses developed in
the metal so the metals which are
sensitive to the corrosion as well as
they are experiencing the tensile
stresses or the tensile residual
stresses they show increased cracking
tendency along the grain boundaries
wherever such kind of the unfavorable
metallurgical Transformations take place
so they will be promoting the stress
corrosion cracking tendency to avoid the
stress corrosion cracking tendency
basically we have to avoid the tensile
stresses
we have to avoid the ah the corrosion
sensitive media so that corrosion as
well as the cracking tendency can be
reduced the lamellar tearing is
basically observed due to the presence
of the inclusions in the in the metal or
the steel plate being welded or
ah it is also observed when the Z
Direction ductility of the steel is
limited Z Direction ductility of the
steel is limited or the weld joint
design is unfavorable leading to the
development of the tensile residual
stresses or it is also having the higher
concentration of the hydrogen so all
these four factors will be promoting the
lamellar tearing and so they will be
reducing the weldability typho cracking
is typically observed in the chromium
molybdenum steel weld joints ah these
are the steel weld joints which
are used in the thermal power plants ah
in the temperature range of 600 to 650
degree Centigrade so when such kind of
the the well joints of these Steels when
they are used
at a high temperature so A fine grain
zone is found find grained hhz zone is
formed ah as well as in this region on
the prolonged exposure at a high
temperature formation of the unfavorable
unfavorable
carbides at the grain bound at the grain
boundaries of the fine grains ah leads
to the
ah promotes the cracking
in the region away from the fusion
boundary where our fine grain June fine
grained heat affected zone is present
under that cracking occurs after a
prolonged
exposure
at high temperature may be 600 to 600 50
degree Centigrade so this is the type of
a typho cracking so the different types
of the crackings will be observed in
different types of the steels
ah now we will see ah that the the
factors ah as far as the Steels are
concerned the factors that affect the
weldability ah like the the most
important factors that are affecting the
valuability of the steel is like
composition because it directly affects
the
hardenability due to the change in the
carbon equivalent ah then the mechanical
properties in general it is it is more
difficult to weld the metals of the high
yield strength so high early strength
will be leading to the lower
validability due to the increased
cracking tendency the Steels having the
lower endless strength will show the
greater tolerance to the discontinuities
and defects they will show the greater
toughness reduced embrittlement tendency
so ah it will be easier to weld the
lower yield strength Steels as compared
to the higher yield strength apart from
the yield strength it is the percentage
elongation
ah the toughness of the steel ah that
will also be affecting the validability
the very important factor that will be
affecting the weldibility of of the
steel is the heat treatment condition
heat treatment condition so like the
Steels can be welded in as rolled
condition annealed condition
normalized condition or quenched and ah
tempered conditions so as per the
condition of the steel its properties of
the heat Vector Zone will vary for
example the steel in anneal condition
after the welding will show the
hardening in the heat affected Zone
while the qnt steel after the welding in
the heat effector Zone will show the
softening
these are the some of the common factors
which ah will be affecting the
weldability of the steel ah of the thin
sections
but when we talk of the weldibility of
the steels for thick sections
um we need to consider the additional
aspects like heat input
ah like greater is the suction thickness
greater will be the net heat input
requirement greater with the width of
the hhz and greater will be the residual
stresses so there will be lot of issues
related with the greater heat input when
the heavier sections are welded ah for
the ah when the suction thickness is
more
it will be ah extracting the heat more
rapidly from the weld metal so the
cooling rates will be high so increased
cooling rate in case of the heavier
sections will be increasing the tendency
for the martensite formation increased
tendency for the embrittlement increased
tendency for the cracking for the steel
of the given
hard enability or of the given
composition further the restraint ah
will also be more ah when the thickness
is more so we need to apply more
controlled preheat preheating and we
need to apply the post weld heat
treatments in order to take care of the
issues related with the residual
stresses in case of the heavier sections
arising from the heavy restraint
conditions ah now here I will summarize
this presentation in this presentation
basically I have talked about the way by
which the weldability of the Steels can
be looked into and how the weldability
of the steel
is affected with the suction size and
the different factors that we should
look into ah to ah to assess the
weldability of Steels like the
composition mechanical properties and
the heat treatment condition thank you
for your attention
[Music]
foreign
[Music]
