Lecture 29 : Various conditions favouring pitting corrosion I

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 2, 2023
So, let us start lecture 29, the course is corrosion failures and analysis, and we will
discuss pitting corrosion. If you recall our last lecture, we started discussing about
pitting corrosion, and we saw that if it is a passivating metal, pitting corrosion tendency
becomes very prominent or becomes very obvious sometimes, not all the time remember, but
passivating metal has that pitting tendency. Stagnant solution is a problem, because that
leads to pitting, and also we have seen that the pitting happens on a flat surface, we
do not need any crevice in case of crevice corrosion, we need to have a crevice to have
crevice corrosion, but pitting it can also happen on a flat surface.
And many a times before it is realized that the pitting has happened, the pit might have
grown a very deep into the metal, and in fact would come to see as the mechanism, we when
we talk about the mechanism of pitting, we would see that pitting stops when the entire
material perforates through that particular pit. And sometimes pit dimension is so narrow
from the width part of it, not the depth part of it, it is very difficult to recognize.
And interestingly some of the times that pitting at the pit rust forms, and that rust might
be colorless on, so that time that might cover up the pit, and that covering up the pit might
lead to another confusion that whether there is a pit or not.
So, there are many issues with the pit, and it is basically a very sometime it becomes
very confusing that whether it is a pit or not. For example, sometimes you have a rust
layer even in case of steel, rust recognition is bit easy, because the rust color is absolutely
different, it becomes a kind of brownish color rust, sometime it becomes little darkish,
but mostly it is brownish, because of the ferric oxide. Now, that brownish rust can
cover up the entire surface, and if you remove the rust you might see that there would be
some sort of pits, and if you do cross sectional analysis, let us say you somehow expect that
the pitting has formed. So, you can do cross section, and see under the microscope you
might see that the pit has grown quite deep inside the material, so that becomes very
difficult whether the pit has formed or not. Of course, there is a technique which is called
cyclic polarization that might give you that whether the pit has formed or not, from the
understanding of potential called E pit, we call it potential corresponding to pitting.
But the best way to recognize that whether the pit has at all formed, even if it is a
metastable pit by the E r p, which is called I will talk about that E r p is basically
the repassivation potential. So, that E r p can tell you that below that if you can
maintain that potential below that particular E r p potential, the pit formation would be
very very minimized can be very minimized. But if the potential goes beyond E r p, there
could be possibility of metastable pit, what do I mean by metastable pit that some pit
can form, and then again re recover from pitting that can only happen in case of in case of
passivating metal. So, that during passivation metastable pit
forms that means, it is locally some passive layer has got damaged, and then the pit initiates
there, but because of the strong passivating nature that pit can again cover up or can
recover from pitting. So, that particular tendency is visible till it reaches to the
potential corresponding to E pit, which is potential corresponding to pitting, then only
the pit starts growing. So, that pit would not get recovered, would not be would not
cover up or would not the passive layer cannot cover up that pit, the pit will continue to
grow. So, those kind of things we will start analyzing.
So, the course is on lecture 29 and topic pitting corrosion. Now, first of all let us
see some of the conditions which would favor pitting. First is of course, passivating metals
and alloys like steel, and in the steel if we want to specifically mention then stainless
steel fine, then nickel, copper, aluminum. So, those are the cases where we can expect
passivation and pitting can happen. Now, and if pitting forms, pit forms in case of passivating
metal, and if the metal is in the passive state, it can be serious, it can grow quickly.
For example, why? It also involves little bit of galvanic corrosion. So, let us see
for example, let us say this is a surface, and this surface is already passivated. Now,
by some means there is a small segment where the passive layer is broken. So, now, that
passive and let us say it is in neutral medium, and of course, there are some sort of chlorine
ion present. Now, if that small part gets broken, then that small part becomes anode,
and you can mention small microscopically, microscopic brick in the passive layer.
Now, rest of the part which is passivated, which is cathode, which would become cathode,
and so that cathode area if you see, so if you compare the area of this one, and area
of this one. So, this small segment is the anode, and rest of all the area is cathode
fine. So, it becomes a favorable area consideration for rapid corrosion of that anode area. So,
this, so the cathode area is very very large, anode area is very very small, if you compare
the area factor, area of both the regions. So, that leads to rapid dissolution of anode
portion, and remember this is microscopic, this is microscopic. Interestingly, when it
happens because this actually galvanic corrosion takes part, and let us say if oxygen is there,
that means dissolve oxygen is there, and if it is a neutral media, so this is the cathodic
reaction, and let us say if it is some metal M minus 2 e equal to M 2 plus, this is anodic
reaction. So, these are the two reactions. Now, interestingly that might lead to a kind
of rust, which is M OH whole 2. So, this is the rust that can form due to the reaction
between the cathodic product, cathodic reaction product, and anodic reaction product, and
So, this rust because surrounding area is passivated, that rust may not spread, that
may not spread from the region of anode, and if that cannot spread, and at the same time
the entire metal surface provides the area for cathodic reaction. So, to meet the electron
requirement for cathodic reaction, so this reaction has to happen quite large number,
because this electron will be provided to this particular reaction. So, and the rust
is not able to spread out, so that means corrosion will be concentrated in that small microscopic
area, and corrosion means dissolution or metal dissolution. So, that means this reaction
has to happen in a depth direction, rather than in the lateral direction, because it
cannot spread, because surrounding area is covered with a very strong strong passivated
layer, and that also provides area large area for cathodic reactions, to meet that electron
requirement the depth in the depth direction it should grow.
So, this particular growth would happen in the depth direction, and at some point of
time this will go till to the end of the bottom surface, and then it becomes leaked
or perforated fine. So, that means finally, it is the growth along the depth direction,
and final part is leak or perforation ok, because why, because lateral growth is hindered
by strong passive layer around that particular pit, around the pit. So, now you could realize
that if that particular small pit is microscopic, it will be very difficult to observe to make
a die. So, that means you could see that here also galvanic corrosion comes into picture,
because that is basically the galvanic corrosion is the start or the initiation of you can
say you can say the initiation of pit ok. Of course, to start where that particular
pit will start that will be decided by many other factors ok, but corrosion start will
be decided by the galvanic corrosion ok. So, now this is first part which is a passivating
metal, second one is presence of halogen ions or presence of halides ok.
So, this halogens ions are nothing but chloride, bromide, iodide. So, these are the ions which
can lead to in fact these elements are actually helpful in breaking the passivity, it acts
negative or opposite to passivity or it actually hinders passivity. So, that is what that will
help passivity. So, this is helping pitting and this one also helps to start pitting.
For example, on a surface let us say this is a surface. So, let us say this is the surface
it is exposed to the chloride ion, let us say at some point of time chloride concentration
goes up at some location ok. And let us say that chloride ion concentration covalent concentration
reaches critical amount to break passivity ok. So, once that passivity is broken. So,
this is the same as the situation what we have explained here ok. So, that particular
part will create a small pit ok. So, that means and of course, there is a every
halogen ions, anogen ion has got about for example, chloride, bromide or iodide. So,
they have they must have the must be around that the presence of that chloride ion should
be a critical amount that will initiate pitting ok. So, we will talk about this presence of
chloride ion on polarization plot ok. So, now if we try to look at passivity for example,
if I try to look at polarization drag diagram for passivity, let us say this is E, this
is log I, the polarization plot of for a passivity two different kinds of passivity
can be observed one is spontaneous passivity. So, like this one is this another could be
like this. So, like this. So, this is spontaneously passivity or you can say spontaneous passivity
and this is active passive active passive transformation to achieve passivity fine.
Now, if you go back to mixed potential theory, you would come to know that how this diagrams
arrive at it is all based on interaction between cathodic and anodic lines. So, for example,
if I try to see that this part. So, now, you have cathodic anodic line is this let us say
this is the anodic line and the cathodic line let us say this one is the cathodic line
ok. So, this is cathodic polarization line and this is anodic polarization line fine
let us say this is the potential. So, now, if I try to look at the polarization plot
if you do if you do make a polarization plot with the help of potential stat. So, now,
the plot will be looking like this plot will be like this if you see this this is the plot
similarly in this case in this case if you want to see the why such kind of plot has
arrived at if this is my anodic plot this is anodic polarization line plot or instead
of line I can say plot this is plot. So, this is anodic cathodic anodic line the
black one this is the anodic line and the cathodic line if I try to see. So, cathodic
line will cut here. So, this is the cathodic line cathodic plot. So, now, if I try to see
the plot nature it will look like it will look like this. So, you see this is exactly
like this. So, this is the interaction between cathodic and anodic plots while considering
mixed potential theory and you can get achieve this kind of lines.
Now, this point where sharp break happens in the passive region. So, you can see that
this is the passive region here also. So, this is the part where the passive film has
grown as you increase the potential passive film actually grows and then pit starts and
that pit starts to grow because of the strong passivity the whatever pit forms small, small
pit forms that will get recovered that will that will recover because of the strong passivity
of the metal or that could be filled up fine, but at some critical potential the passivity
will not be able to cover up that pit. So, the pit starts growing. So, this is the point
which is called EP or we can say E pit and you can also say sometimes this is E break
EB or E breakdown B means breakdown. Remember there is that particular point might
happen without breakdown even if it reaches to the point where oxidation oxygen reduction
starts. So, if you go back for example, if I try to look at some Poivre diagram let us
say this is the Poivre diagram I am looking at this is the Poivre diagram I am looking
at let us say this is the oxygen line this is the hydrogen line you know you recall potential
versus pH oxygen line means we have two reaction O2 plus 4H plus plus 4e equal to 4 2H2O and
then another reaction can happen plus 2H2O plus 4e equal to 4OH minus and in case of
hydrogen line. So, let me draw the hydrogen both the line
like this in blue color, green color. So, these are the two lines and between these
two regions we call water stability region in Poivre diagram and let us say this is M
this is M plus plus this is Mn MOH whole 2. So, let us say that the passive film now this
reaction happens beyond pH 7 and this reaction happens below pH 7. So, there are two other
reactions also for example, below this pH which is acidic in nature H plus 2e equal
to H2 this reaction happens beyond this we have another reaction which is called water
reduction this reaction happens. So, if I try to polarize at this pH for example,
let me take this pH 7 fine pH equal to 7 let us say I try to polarize now at some point
of time the polarization because it is entering into passive region the polarization point
line can this is e log i, i is current density. So, polarization lines can look like this
and if it is a self spontaneous passivating. So, it can look like this because it is entering
into and the pH is 7 because it is entering into as you increase the potential it is entering
into MOH whole 2 which is a passive layer forming on top of metal surface. So, it will
passivate now if that particular passivating metal is very strong that means, the passivation
is very strong the film may not break film there could be pit formation, but the pit
will cover up will get covered up because of the strong passivity MOH will cover up
the pit, pit will not grow, but once it reaches to this potential.
So, at this pH. So, it will it will reach to this potential. So, this is the line I
am doing my polarization this blue line. So, now, if you reach to this potential from
this potential as you go up this reaction starts taking care taking over with respect
to the polarization line for example, if I try to do a mixed potential plot. So, let
us say. So, let us say this is the polarization this is the anodic plot for anodic plot E
versus log I anodic plot only. So, that means, this part from this part onwards this side
is M minus plus 2 E M this side is M minus 2 E equal to M plus 2. So, this if you go
beyond this particular voltage which is corrosion potential. So, this is basically the corrosion
potential. Now, if the cathodic line comes like this cathodic polarization line. So,
then your plot would be fine. So, sorry this is not corrosion potential this is called
this is with respect to the single electrode metal system this particular line could be
over voltage equal to 0. So, some potential corresponding to some potential which is related
to over voltage 0 because if I try to look at cathodic and anodic reactions. So, this
is M plus plus plus n e equal to M of 2 E and this is M minus 2 E equal to M plus plus.
So, this is anodic line polarization line which is coming from what over voltage equal
to anodic over voltage and cathodic over voltage beta A c log I I 0 is not it this is the Tafel
equation we are using to plot these two lines. Now, A means anodic C means cathodic. So,
if you take A that time you take all those current values A and this is the exchange
current density this is exchange current density. Now, so that time this particular
point corresponds to over voltage 0 and I equal to I naught. So, that means this point
corresponds to because this is nothing but if you extend this these are the two lines.
So, like this. So, now if you try to extend this line which is basically the theory of
passivation that polarization part of the anode it will at some point of time it will
start bending backward and then go upward and then at some point of time it will break
it will just go like this. So, this breaking can happen due to beating at the same time
this can happen due to oxygen reduction process or oxygen evolution process.
So, now if you try to see this reaction this reaction also has two parts. So, this reaction
also has two parts. So, if I try to look at oxygen evolution reaction. So, this is these
two parts log I can be done this is O2 plus 2H2O plus 4e equal to 4OH minus and this is
this reaction and this line would be reverse line 2OH, 4OH minus equal to O2 plus 2H2O
plus 4e. So, now if we go towards this towards this potential if I go towards this, this
oxygen evolution starts if I go downwards oxygen reduction starts.
So, that means that oxygen evolution reaction would happen. Now as we see that once the
potential is reached to this level because this is going like this perfectly fine because
it has entered into the MOH 2 region at that pH 7. Now if I try to see because this particular
plot and this plot are corresponding each other. Now this green line is basically the
oxygen reduction line oxygen reduction line. Now it has also has its own oxygen evolution
line fine because at some point because we are going towards this positive potential
once this particular line this red line come across this green anodic polarization plot
for oxygen evolution reaction. Then immediately if the if there is no pitting
because the polarization the passivation is very strong if there is no pitting then instead
of going upward like this it will take a turn like this. So, the curve will look like
this fine. So, now this point that time is not E breakdown or E pit. So, they can be
synonymous at some time, but sometimes they are not they are different, but now it is
not it is it is not a breakdown because this is basically I can term it as E oxygen line
or oxygen evolution line. This is oxygen evolution potential we can say this. So, this
is not break. Now that pitting happens many a times it does
not without reaching to that particular potential pitting can happen before that. So, that time
this can go like this. So, that time we can say that this is E pit or sometimes we can
say this E breakdown EB. So, that this is the basic difference between oxygen evolution
and E pit. Many a times you have to look for that particular potential and if that potential
matches with the Pourbaix diagram or that particular metal at that pH you can be assured
that that is oxygen evolution line. So, you have to be very careful in deciding
the E pit sometime it confuses with the oxygen evolution potential. So, now coming back
to this chlorine effect chloride effect. So, now let us say this is the pitting breakdown
potential or E pit. Now if we increase the chloride ion that E pit can happen much earlier
and if you increase further it can happen like this. So, that means let us say this
is a chloride ion concentration 1 C C 1 this is C 2 this is C 3. Now you can say that this
is chloride ion concentration. Now we can say that C 3 is greater than C 2 is greater
than C 1. So, that means if we increase chloride ion concentration the pit formation tendency
also goes up for a particular passivating metal. So, that is what this presence of halogen
ions halogen ions are very is very very dangerous to the passivating metal because it breaks
at some local point and it starts creating all sort of pit related problem to the material.
So, let me stop here we will continue our discussion on pitting in our next lecture
also we will try to understand mechanism of pitting and then once we know mechanism of
pitting we can somehow construct some of the protection routes which can prevent pitting.
Let me stop here. Thank you.
