Lecture 01- An introduction to corrosion failure and analysis

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 2, 2023
Introduction, materials tetrahedron, mechanical properties variation with cooling rates
Hello everyone, let us start the course on Corrosion Failures and Analysis.
Now, in this particular course as we have introduced that we will talk about different
forms of corrosion, and how those particular corrosion form appears, what are the reasons
behind that, and we will also try to analyze the mechanisms.
And then we will look at some of the case studies, and try to also analyze or propose
corrosion protection routes or methods, so that that particular type of corrosion can
be controlled to a great extent.
And the main intention is to improve the durability of the metallic or alloy components or engineering
structures, and just to make sure that the corrosion effect is minimally felt.
Now, this is the first lecture, and in this lecture this is the first lecture, and in
this lecture we will try to discuss few things.
One is relation between materials tetrahedron and corrosion, and the second part will introduce
different forms of corrosion, rather we will just name those forms, different forms of
corrosion.
Now, if we talk about the first point, which is relation between materials tetrahedron
and corrosion, let me first draw the materials tetrahedron.
So, whoever tries to learn materials, that person needs to go through this tetrahedron,
the four segments, which are basically nothing but composition and microstructures.
Then we have processing, then we have properties, and finally we have performance, and this
is specific to some particular material.
And since we will be talking about corrosion failures and analysis of metals and alloys,
so you can consider that this is either metal or alloy.
In fact, we will also try to look at corrosion of ceramics also, as well as sometimes we
have to talk about corrosion of plastics, but mainly we will talk about metals and alloys.
Now, if you see this, for example, if we consider any metal, let us say steel, particular composition
of steel, you can, that time you are fixing the composition, let us say 0.1 weight percent
carbon steel.
So, that time this apex part will be microstructure, and as you know that this 0.1 weight percent
carbon steel can be processed differently.
If we quench it, we will get martensite.
If we slowly cool, we will get pearlite and ferrite.
Pearlite would be less fraction, fraction of pearlite would be less, because this is
far away from 0.8 percent carbon steel.
So, if we consider the phase diagram only the steel part, so I am just drawing the steel
part only.
So, this is 0.8 percent carbon steel, and 0.1 is coming here, carbon.
So, this is 910 degree Celsius, this is 727 degree Celsius, and this is weight percent
carbon, and this is, you can, some book you will find 1.8 weight percent, or some book
you will find 2 weight percent.
Now, if you consider this particular steel, and if you take a, at a room temperature,
this is room temperature, if you take, this is the pearlite, and that times, if you do
a tie line calculation, this, this much fraction would be ferrite, and only this part would
be pearlite.
So, this is pearlite, this is ferrite, how do we get it?
So, in order to find out the percentage of ferrite, it will be equal to 0.8 minus 0.1
divided by 0.8 minus 0.002, you can say, the carbon content would be very small at this
particular temperature.
So, you can even neglect that particular fraction.
So, this will be the percentage of ferrite, so that means, the pearlite would be very
minimal.
So, if we see the microstructure, so the microstructure would be the triple point, some pearlites
would be there, otherwise mostly ferrite.
So, this is ferrite, we call it alpha iron, and this is pearlite, pearlite is a basically
mixture of alpha and Fe 3 C, which has a lamellar structure.
So, this structure can form, if it is slowly cooled from austenite temperature beyond this
particular phase boundary between alpha and austenite, this is austenite.
So, this particular boundary, this particular boundary, so beyond that you have to take
the steel, hold it there for some time, so that the complete austenitization takes place,
and then you cool it slowly.
So, one way to do slow cooling is, you hold that particular steel sample in the furnace
at that temperature, let us say this temperature is around, let us say 950 degree Celsius,
you hold it there for half an hour, and then leave it in the furnace, put with the door
closed of that furnace, and switch off the furnace, so it will be called as furnace cooling.
Now, that time you can have some spacing between this two cementite lamellae, so let
us say this is cementite lamellae, this is cementite, and this is ferrite, so this distance
can be controlled or can be changed.
If we do the furnace cooling, which is which we call annealing, that time this distance
would be the maximum distance.
Then if you increase the cooling rate from that 950 degree Celsius, your spacing would
decrease.
So, this spacing would become this much, and then again if you cool it faster, it will
become like this.
So, you can say that, you take the sample after doing the austenitization, you take
the sample out from the furnace, and leave it in the air, it cools down, so that we call
it normalized.
So, this is called annealing or we call it furnace annealing, this one we call it normalizing
or air cooling.
And if you decrease the spacing between two cementite lamellae, that time it would be,
we can do it by having a forced air cool, air cool, how do you do that?
You take the sample out after 9, austenitization at 950 degree Celsius, and then take that
sample in front of a fan, which actually forcefully takes the heat out, and you have a higher
cooling rate.
Now, if you take the sample from here, and then quench it in oil or water, which is kept
at a room temperature, at room temperature, we would get martensite, so we call it.
So, when we get martensite, we call it, we have that particular heat treatment called
quenching.
So, this is water oil quenching, so now you could see that, if you fix the composition,
the microstructure you can change by changing the processing, because you see that you are
doing furnace annealing, normalizing, forced air cooling, quenching, you can change the
microstructure, and that is possible by doing processing.
And when we do processing, so the each one would give you different properties, for example,
if I consider only the hardness part, only the hardness part, so let us say processing,
then properties, and here I am composition, I have fixed it, 0.1 weight percent carbon
steel.
Now, processing what I am doing, furnace cooling, furnace annealing, normalizing or air cooling,
and forced air cooling, and the third one, fourth one we are doing, oil quenching let
us say fine.
So, now if I see the property, and let us say hardness, and let us say this is Rockwell
sea scale, where we use 150 kg load.
Now, you will see that hardness would be the lowest, and here it will be the highest,
and in between it will increase, it will increase further.
So, now you see the hardness as you go down, hardness increases, so it we can also check
the hardness, if we have a hardness tester, but the value is not the important, the logic
here is, as we the main aspect here is, as we change the processing condition, the properties
also changing, same would be true for tensile property.
For example, in this case if I see the tensile property, in this case the tensile strength
would be lowest, but the elongation would be highest, and in this case tensile strength
would be the highest, but elongation would be lowest.
So, like that way the property would change, as we change the processing, if we fix the
composition, and that is possible only by changing microstructure, changing microstructure.
And interestingly each one would have a specific purpose to give, for example, if it is a furnace
annealed structure, as well as if it is a force air cooled structure, same cannot be
used for a specific purpose, we have to choose accordingly.
For example, if we consider this rebar or reinforced bar, they are mostly air cooled,
so there we need a kind of optimization of properties, and air cooling is easily possible
industrially, because also it takes, you know furnace cooling would take long time, but
air cooling would take less time, compared to furnace cooling.
So, that way we can also meet a specific performance, which is to be obtained from that particular
structure.
So, now you can see that, you could see that this particular material tetrahedron, so this
is nothing but the material tetrahedron, and we can see that everything is correlated,
everything is correlated, all those sections are correlated.
How come, composition fixed, microstructure changes, processing I can change to get the
different properties, so properties is in dependent on microstructure, processing changes
the microstructure, and entire thing properties processing and composition, as well as microstructure
would finally give you a specific performance.
So, that means, they all those arms are related, integrally related, now coming to our purpose,
our purpose is we have to see the corrosion part, corrosion part, now does it have any
effect or any relation with the material tetrahedron, material tetrahedron, now let us see that,
with our experience what it talks about.
Now, coming to materials let us say, let us say composition, first let us talk about
composition and let us take a magnesium.
We know that magnesium is a very active metal, but in spite of that magnesium is promising
in the sense that, it has a extremely low weight or density is less, that is what it
can be used in some applications like automobile, where we need less weight in order to have
higher fuel efficiency.
And if we see that it meets the strength requirement, I think we are fine with that, magnesium alloys
have those specific use, because they have high strength to weight ratio, because it
has a very low density, but at the same time magnesium has a very high activity means in
terms of corrosion tendency, because it can corrode heavily and that is what you must
have heard about magnesium anodes.
So, magnesium alloy can be used in automobiles, because they have a very low density so that
means, the strength to weight ratio can be very exciting in order to reduce the total
weight of the car body and that would definitely increase the fuel efficiency.
But now in terms in the magnesium, let us say I take a pure magnesium, pure magnesium
and let us say and magnesium with ppm level impurity, which is nothing but iron.
Now, if we try to compare the corrosion rate, this is almost about close to around thousand
times higher.
So, now ppm level addition of presence of iron can increase the corrosion rate of magnesium
to a great, great extent.
Now you could sense that the composition has a huge implication on the corrosion behavior.
Even in magnesium alloys, we will talk about that magnesium alloys in details later that
addition of a specific elements can improve the corrosion resistance.
Not only that we have to also talk about the microstructure development, so that we get
a quite a good corrosion resistance, so that it can be used in that automobile applications.
But if we take this example, pure magnesium has a fairly good corrosion resistance.
But if we consider this Cr means corrosion rate and please remember that if I use Cr,
do not take it as a corrosion resistance, it should be taken as a corrosion rate.
And if it is a corrosion resistance, then I will definitely write full sentence, full
words corrosion resistance.
Now if I talk about pure magnesium, its corrosion rate is low compared to magnesium with ppm
level of impurity which is iron.
So now you could sense that just by changing the composition a little bit, we get huge
change in the corrosion properties.
Now if we talk about let us say an example, let us say stainless steel, let us say 18-8
stainless is very popular and this is nothing but austenitic stainless steel.
And here the carbon we have 0.01 to 0.08 weight percent carbon can be present.
Now in the commercial grade austenitic stainless steel which is also called 304 stainless steel,
so there the carbon content is around of the level of 0.06 to 0.08 weight percent.
And there if we change the carbon content from 0.08 to 0.01, there will be huge implication
on the corrosion rate.
If it is 0.08 weight percent, by chance during operation the temperature goes between the
range between 400 to 600 degree Celsius, what happens that stainless steel loses the
property of stainless stainlessness.
It is going to be extremely bad stainless steel, because there will be huge amount of
inter granular corrosion.
That means the corrosion happens along the grain boundaries, we will understand why.
But even the processing is little bad, I would say the let us say there is a chance
that between 400 to 600 degree Celsius, the steel sample is held for certain time.
And even if the carbon content is less, still the stainless steel that austenitic stainless
steel will not lose its stainless property.
Because there is a inherent nature or inherent tendency of that carbon present in that particular
steel to form chromium carbide along the grain boundary.
And why chromium carbide, because 18 percent is basically chromium and 8 percent is nickel.
Nickel helps to achieve austenite structure, and chromium gives you the corrosion resistance
property.
And the chromium how come it gives you corrosion resistance, because chromium forms chromium
oxide passive layer, so that passive layer would give you corrosion protection.
But there is a problem if you have that particular steel between 400 to 600 degree Celsius, that
is called sensitization temperature range, where the stainless steel gets to a sensitize
state.
And that point the chromium carbide forms along the grain boundary, now if the carbon
content is 0.08 percent, there is a lot of carbon in the steel in the solute solution.
And there is a greater chance of formation of chromium carbide along the grain boundary.
But if the carbon content is less 0.01 percent, since even if the steel is by chance taken
to this particular temperature range, since the carbon content is less, chromium does
not have a sufficient carbon atmosphere to form chromium carbide.
So, chromium carbide does not form along the grain boundary, sensitization tendency would
be less, would be less, but there still will be chance, because if you hold it for a longer
longer period, finally it will form.
But at least the chance of formation of chromium carbide along the grain boundary will be less,
if the carbon content is less.
So, now again you are coming to that fact, that the if you change the composition of
a particular material, you can get a huge implication on the corrosion properties.
Now on this aspect, we will talk about processing part, but at least you could sense that the
in that material tetrahedron, we have a apex which is composition that has an effect on
that.
Now coming to the microstructure, microstructure.
Now we can take this example, we can take this example.
Stainless steel, if we see the microstructure, this microstructure is like this.
If it is all solution condition, that means chromium 18 percent, nickel 8 percent, carbon
0.08 percent, so and this is called 304 stainless steel.
And another part is, if we consider this low carbon 0.01 percent, that time we write this
one as 0.304 L.
So, this is the only difference in the nomenclature, this L indicates, if you find in any stainless
steel grade, that L word is mentioned, so that is nothing but low carbon.
So, in that case, for example, if we take the same composition, if we hold it at a particular
temperature, let us say 400 to 600 degree Celsius, let us say you have heated it to
a certain temperature.
And then while cooling, if the cooling rate is slow, then the time of retention between
this temperature range will be much higher.
So, that time the chromium carbide precipitate would form along the grain boundaries, along
the grain boundaries, rather it forms on the, on the, sorry, let me draw it again.
Actually it forms along the grain boundary, it can form on the grain boundary itself.
So, these are the chromium carbide, if you cool it slowly between, and that time, the
time of retention between 400 to 600 degree Celsius is bit higher.
But if you cool it rapidly, so that the time of retention of that particular steel component
between this temperature is less, the formation of chromium carbide would be less on the grain
boundary.
And this chromium carbide formation along the grain boundary is the sole culprit to
give you a very high intergranular corrosion tendency of that stainless steel.
So, that means you fix the composition, you are changing the processing, you are getting
different properties.
And that, where that effect is coming, because your microstructure is changing, your microstructure
is changing.
Of course, this microstructure change is possible, because of processing, fine.
Even if you change the composition, if you fix the processing, still the microstructure
can change.
But here, I am saying that composition is fixed, the microstructure can only be possible,
change can be possible, if we change the processing.
Here the processing, what is the processing change, we are cooling slowly, you are cooling,
so that is the change.
So, now, here also you are saying that the processing has an effect on the corrosion
tendency, which is manifested in the form of microstructure.
And now, coming to the performance part, as we have mentioned that if you change composition,
if you change microstructure, there will be change in processing.
But now, because of that there is a corrosion effect, definitely the performance is also
going to be suffered, is not it?
So, that means, you are also saying the performance is a compromised, if in case of stainless
steel at least, we could say that performance is compromised.
So, that means, it is very clear that the corrosion and materials tetrahedron, they
are hugely related.
So, while we talk about corrosion, we have to also bring in all those factors, microstructure,
composition, processing, those factors.
But it is not only that, when we talk about corrosion, we have to also bring in another
factor, which is environment.
So, that environment will also combine between these corrosion as well as materials tetrahedron.
So, that means, we will talk about corrosion, materials tetrahedron as well as environment.
There are other issues also.
So, we will talk about that part in our next lecture.
So, for the time being, let us stop here.
We will continue in our subsequent lecture.
Thank you.
