Lecture 31_Alkalinity & Acidity: Applications

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Dec 4, 2023
Environmental Chemistry,
Prof. Bhanu Prakash Vellanki,
Civil Engg. Dept.
IIT Roorkee
Calculating the concentration of different compounds by VMINTEQ when the pH and alkalinity of the solution and total concentration of any component is known for both closed and open system.
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
so hello everyone welcome back to our
latest lecture session right so we have
been discussing I believe acidity in
great detail in the last class and prior
to that we discussed alpha T so
obviously you know we are going to look
at the applications right as in how we
are going to you end up using
calculative mostly we will have maybe a
minor application with respect to STD so
primarily today's session we are going
to try to understand how to apply a CT
with respect to various scenarios right
so let's get right down to it so
initially you know what have you been
until doing until now you know in our
acident based systems what kind of
problems have we been looking at prime
the recipe problems right recipe
problems as in you know what did we look
at let's say I considered different
examples or all the examples that we
looked at so far have been you know I
know what it is I'm adding initially as
in let's say I know the amount of acid I
am adding initially our amount of base
I'm adding initially and I'm using women
tech or the component balance approach
you know solving it out manually to be
able to calculate the relevant species
at equilibrium right so what have you
been up to so let's look at minor
example let's say you know I know h2 co3
not present initially or any 2 Co 3 not
present initially right so from that we
are trying to be calculated either H
total or Co 3 total and a near-total and
either we use women take right or by
hand or comprehend bounce
right and then what did we solve for
primarily we are trying to find out what
will be the equilibrium concentrations
right so this is what you know we
discussed in general so this will work
fine whenever you are looking at
engineered systems right you know let's
say I'm conducting an experiment I know
what it is that I am putting it
initially I want to know the pH that
would that I would expect or the
ultimately that I would expect or sed I
would expect and so on right so that
will help with your engineered systems
but let's say if I am looking at say
let's say natural systems or real world
systems are the different kinds of
problems you would routinely face what
are they for example you know let's say
I have water quality analysis right what
parameters will they have
they'll have let's say pH alpha t
expressed as caco3 or equivalence but
rarely equivalents people end up in
India anyway using the units of as caco3
right and then we need to end up
estimating let's say or we might need to
end up estimating what are the relevant
concentrations of the species for
example I'd say you know if you look at
a water quality report let's say what
would you have let's say let's say we'll
certainly have pH and other than the
physical parameters let's say you will
also have alpha T and let's say you will
also have phosphate but it's not
phosphate right its total phosphate that
people end up measuring right so you
have let us say what now pH alpha T and
total phosphate but let's say I want to
be able to understand what are the
concentrations of the relevant species
at equilibrium right or what are the
different species present and what in
what concentrations how do I do that
because here let's say we are not saying
we are inputting so-and-so solutions and
then I want to calculate what they are
not calculating estimate modulus right
what the equilibrium concentrations are
going to be here let's say I have a
solution and the pH alkalinity and the
relevant total component concentrations
of various what do we say components are
given for example in this case I
mentioned total phosphate right how do i
estimate the concentrations of the
diluent species so that's what we are
going to look at
in greater detail so this we are going
to look at as water quality problems
until now we looked at recipe problems I
know I mean I know what it is my recipe
is as in the recipe solutions you know
one example is what we looked at when we
added h2 co3 or any to see what we
initially and I wanted to know okay what
are the concentrations of h2 co3
head 0 3 - 0 3 2 - P H etc at
equilibrium this is what we calculate
until now right yes but in general what
do we face we face scenarios let's say
where we have let's say pH we have alpha
t given right and then we also have
let's say for this example X total but
let's say one example can be it total
phosphate present right and then let's
say we are trying to estimate let's say
what are the various species at
equilibrium right so obviously we are
going to look at our committee in this
particular case and then we are going to
move on to more complex systems but one
step at a time I guess so this is the
case again so again as we know I guess
right what is it about you know what is
our approach about it's about more or
less being able to calculate the total
components right but here if we look at
this system we have pH and alcala t but
we are we don't have the relevant
components there or a total components
pardon me but we obviously have one
other total component we have phosphate
total here let's say or X total in this
particular generic example right so how
do I go about estimating the equilibrium
concentrations right so what am I
missing here obviously if you understand
what is that we have been up to we were
earlier trying to transform the recipe
concentrations and express them in terms
of the total component so here we do not
have that we have pH and alpha T so what
can I get from them or what information
can I clean from them right so obviously
we are looking at component balance we
obviously need to try to find out the h
total and co 3 total
y alpha t in general we look at it in
terms of the carbonate system and test
we are going to look at Co 3 total right
so first we will try the manual approach
as in how to express you know or how to
let us say calculate see what the total
given pH and outfit it's relatively
simple
obviously and then we will also see how
to use women tech which obviously no
cuts down on the time required right the
first aspect is that you know it's a
closed system right when you have no
exposure of the relevant solution to the
atmosphere right
no gaseous players present so here we
are going to consider a case where we
have pH alkalinity and X total and what
am I trying to calculate I am trying to
calculate the equilibrium species the
concentration I guess the concentration
of various equilibrium species so how do
I go about that first manually I guess
right so alchemy tea
what's our equation with respect to
alpha T now we know that it's going to
be equal to what sit here please or H -
right and the other bases are hco3 minus
plus 2 Co 3 - - minus h plus right and
how can we simplify this further let us
say we are trying to express everything
in terms of variables such that we can
end up with H total and see what 3 total
so obviously I need them in terms of h
plus and see what three total right so
let's see how I can transform that so
alpha T is given right alpha is given in
our particular case and P H is given so
I want express in terms of H + H - we
know is KW by h plus and where does this
come from because you know the water can
dissociate into H+ and OH rich - and the
water dissociation constant is going to
be equal to H + into or H - right again
just to know refresh our memories
fundamentally what is it KW equal to
activity of H+ right and activity of H -
by activity of water but activity of
water right and this dilute systems is
going to be equal to 1 and we are
approximating the activities by
concentration so right so that's where
we end up with that's how we end up with
this particular equation and - H+ right
and how can i express hco3 minus and - 0
3 2 - in terms of
CEO three total now and obviously as we
know right we looked at the ionization
fractions so alpha naught is nothing but
h2 co3 concentration by Co three total
and similarly the first second and third
ionization fractions in this case are
what are they
hco3 minus by Co three total and Co 3 2
minus by Co three total right again
just to refresh your memories we talked
about this you know I guess quite some
sessions ago this has been the
ionization fractions so what do these
ionization fractions you an idea about
obviously as we just try to jot them
down we understand that each ionization
fraction will give you an idea about the
relevant pretend Rd pertinent form in
terms of the total acid concentration
right so for example the relevant
species for us our hco3 minus n 0 3 2
minus so how can we express their mass
alpha 1 equal to h 0 3 minus by co 3
total and alpha 2 is 0 3 2 minus y see
what the total and what co 3 total now
now in general co 3 total if you write
it down in this case should be equal to
h 0 3 minus plus h 2 Co 3 plus co 3 2 -
right total acid concentrations in this
case a yes so anyway let's try to use
that here so that's then going to be
equal to how do I transform these two
variables going to be equal to alpha 1
plus 2 times of alpha this is alpha -
pardon me right alpha 2 into and from
this set of equations you know into see
what it total right so what do we see
here given that you have the alpha t and
given that you have pH or H+ you can end
up calculating the co 3 total right you
know that alpha naught
pardon me alpha 1 + 2 alpha 2 or you
know constants for a given pH so you can
calculate them they are more or less
constants given that you know the pH and
the relevant system which in this case
is carbonate system so here with the pH
and affinity right
we end up calculating the co3 total and
once we have that we can also calculate
H total right so once we have h total
zero three total annex total we have the
relevant total components right so once
we have this obviously what can we solve
for we can solve for the species or the
concentration of species smaller species
means what are they the compounds
present at equilibrium right so we are
able to solve that this is manually the
right but again solving that manually is
obviously going to take some time right
so let's look at one particular example
or such where we are going to use women
tech but you know we should always be
able to understand the basics behind it
and we will see why later on when we
look at a minor example I guess right so
here we are going to start looking at
women Tech right and let's say let's
take a particular case let's say when pH
let's say is seven right and alpha T
let's say is 30 milligram per liter
expressed as caco3 right and let's say
my X total in this case let's say people
4 3 minus total is equal to let's say
0.01 molar or molar units which we are
approximating is equal to mole all units
in women take if required we will change
this later but for example let's take
this down so you can either use the
units of alpha natee as caco3 we will
see how right or we can transform that
and how do we transform that is equal to
30 milligrams of caco3 I try to express
them in terms of the relevant compounds
so that it is easier to understand per
liter of water right if I want to
transform that into equivalence per
liter so I am going to divide that by I
know that it's going to be 50 middle
grams of caco3
per one equivalent I guess right so
where did we get this from calcium
carbonate the molecular weight is 100
I guess right 40 plus 12 plus 3 times 16
is I guess 48 right 48 plus 12 60 yes 60
plus 40 that's equal to 100 but we know
that you know it's co 2 + & co 3 2 - if
they can dissociate into that right so
more or less we end up with 2
equivalence right per 100 grams of caco3
right so there is more or less one
equivalent per 50 grams of caco3 right
and that's the what do you say
background here so that we end up with
30 into 10 power minus 3 by 50
equivalence per liter so that's equal to
3 by 5 is point 6 or 6 into 10 power
minus 4 equal and Spur liter right so
that's something that we just have as a
background
so let's now switch out to women take
write and understand the system so again
what do we need to do
let's switch Mac what do we need to do
here so we have the pH we have the
affinity right
women take can't calculate whatever it
is that you want randomly so what do we
need to do initially we obviously need
to calculate what is the co 3 total
right so how do we do that let's look at
that so let's switch
so here what was our pH I think we said
pH was 7 so the pH I'm going to fix it
at okay 7 that's the value that we
already have here and we know we have
alpha knitting's so let's go to
specifying alpha t as you see here you
have different units as milligram per
liter of hco3 minus 0 3 2 - caco3 or
milliequivalents per liter so I did not
have transformed the units from
milligram per liter of caco3 to milli
colons but anyway for understanding we
did that so that's fine
so we transform that into equivalence
per liter right so and that we end up
with 6 into 10 power minus 4 which is
0.6 milli coolants right hopefully I am
right and normal will go through this
particular case later again page 4.5 is
because you
titrated to ph 4.5 and normal definition
here you can understand the difference
if you want to so I plugged it in so and
now I run women take number of
components is equal to the number of
fixed species okay obviously I see that
there's an issue there because you has
expected right so let's go back to the
women tech menu and we were at list so
let's say something else needs to be
given here right so I need to give back
to main menu let's say and also let's
say I'm going to have any a plus
and act yes I will try to see if we can
let the system guess okay again a visual
mean take a species including the input
file as fixed possible finite or was not
or exclude was not in the thermodynamic
database so I think let me understand
the system here no okay
so Co three two - enye plus back to main
menu let me add H plus I think that's
the reason why we are ending up with an
error let's see where is H + you okay
add to the list you at least let me try
if this should hopefully solve this
issue or I think I still need to add the
CL - we'll come back to that anyway one
good ways to learn by what do we see
what we are up to
so anyway looks like because I did not
have h plus or deleted h plus by error
we end up with an issue right so where
do we have the spoiler let's look at
species distribution once so pH 7 you
would have assumed that or you'd expect
that everything would be present as hco3
- so that's what most of it as of co 3
total is present as has Co 3 and that's
what you see here 81 or 82 percent is
present as what was hco3 minus and hash
- 0 3 is 18 percent of the co 3 total
right that's what you would expect when
the pH is 7.2 main output menu and now
here let's say where can I get the co 3
total here please so I can go back to
species distribution not really now I
can sum up the co 3 total from here
right co 3 total will be equal to Co 3 2
minus h2 co3
and hat co 3 minus so I can sum up these
three values and then I will end up
calculating my co 3 total right so
that's what I can see from here a new
species distribution pardon me
display saturation illnesses this is
when we have to look at let's say
saturation or precipitation and
dissolution which we don't go into right
now so now from this particular graph I
can end up calculating not graph pardon
me from this particular set of values I
can end up calculating the co 3 total
right
CEO 3 2 - h2co3 and has su hco3 minus
the sum of them will give me my CEO 3
total so i inputted pH at 7
alchemy D at point 6 equivalence per
litre and I can calculate my see what 3
total right for sake of ease let me just
take it as this is what we said tamper
okay six point hco3 minus e is let's say
this is six I'll say it's seven point 2
into 10 power minus 4 you know let's say
you know bigger 7 point 2 into 10 power
minus 4 let me take that and then try to
plug in the relevant values it's not
equal you can use the Excel and get the
relevant values right so again what are
we up to here I'm trying to calculate
the component balance in terms of co 3
total and because Excel are pardon me
women take can't do that
by itself we plugged in pH and in
parameters we plugged in aqua T in the
terms of equivalent per liter units and
then looking at the relevant species I
can calculate the co 3 total right so
let's come back to this obviously I can
print it to XL and get the relevant what
do we say species concentration so if I
go back to main menu view at list so
earlier I made their rough you know
having inadvertently due to the H+
that's why we looked at an error right
and where are the output files okay here
the output file so you can look at the
relevant concentrations here and
calculate that so now I'm going to
change it such that how do I change it
that I want to also put in phosphate
total right so let's see how I can go
with that specify alpha t let's say now
I'm going to say no there is no alpha T
specified in the solution right view
edit list and now see what three total
is going to be relatively what was it I
think seven point four right 7 point 2
into 10 power minus 4 right so let's
plug that in here see what the total
back to main menu and see what three
total
and the key let's say I will use
millimolar so if I use millimole all I
just need to plug in 0.72 millimolar
writes and so here I'm going to plug in
zero point seven two point seven two and
add that to the list and what else do I
have here please
I also have phosphate and what was that
that we said was 0.01 molar that's a bit
of a high concentration so let's look at
that little so now pH is not fixed in E
for let's say calculated from mass
balance let's say let's see if that will
work out not really I leave the pH at
seven because I know it's at seven and
po4 3 minus people for three - and I
said I'm going to use it at a molar
concentration of 0.01 right or to make
it you know relatively similar I'm going
to change it so that it 0.001 or 1
millimolar right otherwise it might be
way too high so here I have zero point
zero zero to H and so on that main menu
and pH is fixed at 7 so now I can
calculate the relevant concentrations of
the relevant species which are h2 po4
h3po4 hpo4 - - which I was unable to do
earlier so I look at the relevant
species distribution right so co 3 2 -
its present obviously at 82% in has Co 3
- and people for 3 - is present as hpo4
- - and h2 p o4 - right so let's just
summarize what we were up to right back
to input menu so keep in mind that we
change this but value to make it similar
so again manually we saw how to do that
so again let's summarize pH and outlet e
we plug them in initially right and then
we end up from this particular
information calculating Co 3 total and
we already have pew of worth total right
and using this in
formation right and also fixing the pH
at the given value which was pH 7 I then
ended up calculating all the species
concentration and what were they has
three people four right h2p were four -
hpo4
- - and people four three - and so on
right so this is what we can do so
obviously we need to transform it such
that we get the first component that we
need to look at and then go through
right so this we are done with this for
now so let's move on to an open system
right and where's that so open system I
guess and what is this about
so when this case is when you have your
particular system here but it's you know
open to the atmosphere or the gaseous
phase let's see right and here you can
have what do we say as we know transfer
of carbon dioxide or co2 total between
the gaseous and the aqueous phase so for
this we looked at the relevant what do
we say transformations and search
earlier obviously we are not going to go
through that but we are going to look at
relevant applications I guess right so
let's let's see so obviously here
instead of CO three portal right which
we did in the closed systems obviously
we are going to try to express our terms
our outfit in terms of partial pressure
of carbon dioxide so let's see how we
can do that I think we might have looked
at a minor transformation earlier so we
know that alkalinity is equal to alpha 1
plus alpha 2 alpha 1 plus 2 alpha 2
because 2 times 0 3 2 - in to see both
Rito ttle + KW by h + - h plus right
and a what is this equation though this
equation is when we have output
initially I guess you know this is the
alkalinity equation for initial case but
let's say now you have carbon dioxide
that's in equilibrium with your
particular system so well what do we
need to do now I guess so that's the
case so here we have our PT here
and we have let's say partial pressure
of carbon dioxide so how do I go about
this particular case now right so again
the key aspect that we need to consider
here is that from what we discussed a
couple of sessions ago we know that
Almaty does not change when you
introduce carbon dioxide into the system
or remove carbon dioxide from the system
right so how was that or why do we come
up with that alchemy T was equal to what
now which - and the other bases are hco3
minus plus 2 Co 3 - - minus h + right
and we saw that when we bubble carbon
dioxide you can go to h2 co3 or H+ and
hit Co 3 - Orkin directly let's say also
go to 2 h plus and C were 3 2 months so
if you plug in the relevant K variables
we see that you know to 0 3 2 minus and
minus h plus or hesse or 3 minus and
minus h plus so they cancel each other
out right so again if you remember what
we discussed introducing or removing
carbon dioxide from your particular
solution will not affect ultimately
obviously the pH is going to change
right but it's not going to change the
Alpha T so this is the key here as in
the al-khatib before and after
equilibrium with your gaseous phase is
going to be the same right so let's use
that so let's say if I assume that if
equilibrium with C what - is achieved
right
the Alcon T is still going to be the
same right alkalinity is same but
obviously I want to transform Co 3 total
into what do we say partial pressure of
co2 so C would 3 total I want to express
it in terms of partial pressure of co2
right so in this case we looked at one
particular aspect earlier so I think we
talked about h2 co3 right and that it
was equal to what now in terms of co 3
total it was alpha naught into co 3
total right and
we talked about the Henry's constant KH
right and then we tried to solve for it
Henry
Henry's constant what will that give me
an idea about partial pressure of co2 by
concentration of h2 co3 in the aqueous
phase right so that's going to be equal
to partial pressure of co2 by alpha
naught into C were three total right
this is something I believe we looked at
previously so KH is going to be equal to
P Co 2 by alpha naught into see what
three total right but depending on the
units let's say if it's K - Shh we're in
it's the units are moles per atmospheres
this is then going to be equal to alpha
naught into C were three total by
partial pressure of co2 again the key is
that the units are going to be or can be
different right so you need to look at
the units whenever you are looking at
the Henry's constant right again to
refresh our memory we are just trying to
use Henry's constant to get a
relationship between a partial pressure
of co2 and co 3 total right and what
does Henry's constant give us an idea
about it gives us an idea about the
concentration in the gaseous phase of a
compound to the concentration of the
compound in the aqueous phase in this
case we are talking about co2 so we say
that Henry's constant depending on the
unit's is either going to be the partial
pressure of co2 in the gaseous phase to
the concentration of h2 co3 in the
aqueous phase or if the units of the
Henry's constants are you know vice
versa as in or the inverse let's say as
in F its moles per liter per atmospheres
it's going to then going to be Henry's
constant or K - H is going to be equal
to h2 co3 concentration by partial
pressure of co2 right so I believe we
use this particular term earlier so I'm
going to continue using this so how can
i express alchemy t here so alpha T is
now going to be equal to alpha 1 plus 2
alpha 2 and 2 right where do I have that
so I have Co 3 total so Co 3 total in
this case is equal to K - H into partial
pressure of co2 into alpha naught so
that's going to be
equal to CO three total is equal to K -
H into partial pressure of co2 by not
into alpha naught divided by alpha
naught obviously right partial pressure
of co2 by alpha naught plus KW by h plus
minus concentration of h+ right so in
this way we can simplify the particular
system further and you can solve for the
relevant aspects right so again we just
try to this is the manual approach so we
are obviously going to look at how to
get the done effects what do we say and
the if you are trying to use vim intake
right so again what have we done here we
just try to express you with the total
in terms of partial pressure of co2 and
why is that so because this is a open
system as in the what it says your
solution is open to the gaseous phase
and there can be a transfer of co2 or 0
3 total obviously right from the gaseous
to a liquid or liquid to the gaseous so
that's the reason we looked at alpha T
and again why alpha T because alpha T
does not change when there is any
exchange of co2 between the gaseous and
aqueous phases right so let's try to use
women take and try to look at a
particular scenario pardon me
so let's go back to vm intake and see
how we can go through with that
so now let's edit the list from what we
were up to earlier right so i'm going to
view at the list i'm going to delete
this i'm going to delete this for now
and back to main menu and so i'm going
to say there is ph and our committee
right enter ph and alpha t specify
affinity and there is alpha t now and
let's say it's present as 30 in my case
30 milligram per liter as caco3 which we
looked at earlier right so okay and ph
is going to be fixed at 7 let's say for
my example right and we were at list
okay so it already obviously calculated
the case for that back to main menu and
then run min tick right ph 7 and so on
yes
and we can get the CEO three total from
here h2co3 and such so obviously from
here what can I calculate I can
calculate so by plug-in pH and what is
it please
affinity I can then end up calculating H
total and co three total right from
women take a game and now what I'm going
to do I'm going to enter Co 3 total H
total and now give a partial pressure of
CO 2 right let's do a random value there
and then we can come up with our
particular you know case I guess so
instead of calculating the aspects I'm
going to you know go ahead and get that
done with some random values obviously
you can calculate hashed total and co 3
total here so back to input menu and you
at list so you hopefully this should
even might turn to be the same and what
next here we are trying to input see
what the total has stored and pco2 so
strictly speaking I need to calculate
that from the previous particular women
tech output but I'm going to use random
values and see how we can go through
right so hatch total Co 3 total and pco2
let's go back to that so here now
parameters I'm going to say there is no
more affinity now right because I'm
going to input Co 3 total right but
gases I know that I need to specify
gases how do I do that and pressure so
I'm going to change it let's say that
it's going to be 2 times let's say then
what I would expect in the atmosphere
what is this tab here so it says specify
the fix-it co2 partial pressure and
atmospheric co2 pressure is given you
know which I'm going to say is constant
but in my case I am going to say the
partial pressure is 2 times what I would
expect in the atmosphere so that's what
we see here enter the partial pressure
of co2 as a multiple of X 0 so I am
going to say it's going to be equal to
twice of what I would expect or let us
say go with thrice of what I would
expect in my atmosphere you know this is
a hypothetical example I'm looking at so
I'm going to click Add and back to main
menu so I need to also give the
oh three total right Co three total
where is that Co three total and let's
say now I'm randomly going with 0.001
add to list right
you added list yes back to main menu and
run min Tech okay so because the charge
is not balanced so it's going to take CL
- that particular concentration and now
I can end up with my relevant you know
aspects after pco2 is taken into case so
as you see pco2 is now present at this
particular partial pressure at
equilibrium right so with that I'm going
to end today's session again the crux of
the issue is we transform using pH and
outlet e we end up calculating Co three
total and then use the relevant aspects
in the closed system but in the open
system what were we up to we calculate
pH and Co three total part Mitch total
and Co three total from pH and alpha t
and then use that to have the partial
pressure of co2 why is that because it's
an open system and then calculate the
relevant species obviously in this
example I did not plug in people for
total so I could have plugged in people
for total and so on and so forth but
here one case is that you know if I
remove the pH because let's say pH is
not going to be constant when partial
pressure is let's say changed calculated
from mass and charge balance so I run
that so obviously as I see here this is
something that should have done earlier
the pH is not going to stay the same
which was the initial case earlier but
the pH is going to fall why is it going
to fall because I increased D or
introduced a new variable in terms of
partial pressure of co2 as and let me
just clarify that so earlier the pH was
7 right and there is a given out finiti
and then I end up calculating you know
the relevant Co 3 total and hich total
which I assume random values I guess
right which may be given time we will do
that later and then I plugged in the
value for partial pressure of co2 and
then ran women tick and what did I get I
got a pH of around 5.3 right but if I
calculate c-13 total or not co2 total
pardon me the alkalinity should still be
the same right so that's what we see
here and
with that I'll end today's session and
thank you
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Music]
