Gujrat earthquake, temporary shelter construction, Kashmir earthquake, Boxing day tsunami, Tsunami recovery, participatory approach, NGOs, traditional shelters, livelihood, recovery, rehabilitation. To access the translated content: 1. The translated content of this course is available in regional languages. For details please visit https://nptel.ac.in/translation The video course content can be accessed in the form of regional language text transcripts, books which can be accessed under downloads of each course, subtitles in the video and Video Text Track below the video. Your feedback is highly appreciated. Kindly fill this form https://forms.gle/XFZhSnHsCLML2LXA6 2. Regional language subtitles available for this course To watch the subtitles in regional languages: 1. Click on the lecture under Course Details. 2. Play the video. 3. Now click on the Settings icon and a list of features will display 4. From that select the option Subtitles/CC. 5. Now select the Language from the available languages to read the subtitle in the regional language.
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to the course disaster recovery
and Milberg matter my name is Ron Satish
I'm an assistant professor in Department
of Architecture and planning IIT Roorkee
today I'm going to talk about temporary
shelter construction in India so in this
lecture I'm going to cover a wide
variety of examples and my own personal
interaction with all these three case
studies which I'm going to discuss about
the Gujarat earthquake starting in 2002
and - this one - and then the tsunami
recovery programs in 2004 tsunami and as
well as 2005 at the quake in Kashmir in
the Pewaukee Pakistan Occupied Kashmir
so these are all my some of my personal
interactions with these or various other
various aspects of my work and as well
as my study and and the early 2000 2002
when the whole disaster has been struck
in Gujarat earthquake so catches the
district which has been majorly affected
and that is one of the major 7.5 major
earthquake and it has a huge vast
devastation both an urban level as well
as the rural level and this is one of
the you know the layout of reconstructed
villages the map of the reconstructed
villages in the catch district which has
been developed by the Gujarat disaster
management project project we call the G
s deem D and P and this is a time
Gujarat state has actually taken a very
active initiative of the community
participation and as well as developing
certain guidelines the GSD ma regulatory
aspects the retrofitting process so it
has looked at providing them guidance in
how to reconstruct and how to retrofit
these buildings so that is where the
technical aspects also come into the
picture and many NGOs have shown
interest in looking at the participatory
approaches advocacy for example
shayla's and NGO and Catholic Relief
Services so there are many NGOs who have
actually advocated participatory
approaches in Gujarat earthquake so
today what I'm going to discuss with you
is it is about the immediately after a
disaster before coming into the
permanent reconstruction stage and just
immediately after relief stage this is
where the transition shelter you know
there's a temporary shelter which they
have been provided for them and how they
gradually shaved into or progressed into
a permanent shelter process so this is
the stage which I'll be talking about it
and from this map you can see the amount
of damage which has occurred in the cut
and the amount of reconstruction and
through so many NGOs Catholic Relief
Services who mashaallah Caritas there's
many angels which came to Gujarat to
give their helping hand so these are all
some of my primary case study you know
evidences like then this what you can
see is the the modern house which has
RCC construction and which is a brick
and concrete construction has completely
damaged and this is a pakka house and
which has completely damaged where as
you can see these traditional shelter
forms in local language they call also
the boom gas which is normally they are
in circular shape and in some cases they
are in a kind of rectangular shape so
here what you see these have resisted
these are some of immediate I'm talking
about within a span of one year the
evidences which you are seeing is that
these houses with traditional shelter
forms have resisted the earthquakes and
why they have resisted because that is
where the structural form within you can
see that there is a vital endowed
constructions it has you can see that
these weeds the Vatel has been embedded
like a mesh so acts like a reinforcement
is a buying
and then the cover with the mud and this
is a circle Asha because they believe
that the circular shape is the best at
equator of street form because all the
forces are not coming at the corner
because most of the damages which we see
is at the corners of a house you know
that is where the load aspects also play
an important role but and also this is
how in the moment struck the circular
form they believe that this is smaller
circular shapes they resist earthquakes
and this battle and dobkins which acts
as the vertical and the horizontal bands
and which can protect the houses from
the severe earthquakes and the Scotch
zone catch area this falls in the fifth
to John John five in the earthquake
joning and what you can see here this is
called a plough so in gujarati language
so here you can see that there's a small
just exposed platform that just
informally has been raised so this
defines some a kind of semi living space
because for them they can cook the heck
and some people have some outdoor
kitchens to it some people can have a
washing area some people and if it is
and they also believe in kind of family
clusters you know like 2-3 people live
in a cluster and they raise the whole
platform as the okhla has been raised
and that demarcates that family
belonging from the ground and this is
how the traditional patterns and in many
of the boom does you have the low eaves
you know because of the desert climate
and also the windy aspects of it so it
can protect from the wind as well and
you can see this kind of Orenda and
where they have the kitchen has been
made a small partition and there's a
stone wall you can see and how the
inside of the boom glass you know it has
all it has a very low height wall and
then what they do is if it is a conical
shape
so in some of the boomers it will have
also the central post you know to
support this kind of low Eve which can
protect from the harsh climatic aspect
and here
this obviously forms as a kind of racks
which they can display they can keep
their functional aspects like you can
see that the storage boxes are embedded
within it and then they can I mean the
indigenous ideas of how a small space
could be functional enough for the
family you know for everyday activities
so even a small wall makeup itself
frames everything that their whole
products can fit within it you can see
that the clothes their offenses you know
and this everything has been managed
within that small space also the typical
bath bed they have a kind of outdoor
batting areas like we have a semi-open
bath spaces and also this is in payal
pokai village near booj and this is a
kind of again a raised platform about
one feet six inches and then there's a
wooden construction which has been made
for a small commercial entity which is
scattered to the local needs of that
village or nearby villages that is how
the pattern like looks like and in this
particular disaster many of the communal
buildings also have been damaged not
only the communal buildings the historic
buildings have been damaged public
buildings have been damaged so this is
one example it has been partly damaged
the old community hall of the village so
it is very unsafe to live and the mosque
which has been repaired and because that
is the religious entity where they feel
so that is how they immediately
retrofitted their son they immediately
made a mosque here and in Bush visited a
many places of these damaged areas I'll
just show you a glimpse of what all
things have happened immediately after a
earthquake and how what are the
destructions and what kind of property
has been damaged what kind of built
environment has
brain damaged so now this is a kind of
industrial go down which has been
damaged so when we talk about the
industrial go downs and which has to do
with the livelihood of certain sector of
the people obviously they will lose
their employment for some months maybe
years so so it has not only the godown
or also the built form which has been
collapsed or damaged but it will
indirectly affect the livelihoods of the
poor people who are working in that go
dance or the industrial segment there's
also the historic buildings which has
been damaged and the brackets have been
falling down and the railing have fallen
down so it's become very unsafe you know
it has to talk with the Heritage and we
also discuss about heritage in disaster
context and many aspects like I uthia
will be discussing on and we also
discussed on Karuna aspect and as I said
to you if you see this was a traditional
house with a brick and concrete house
the wall has actually collapsed inside
the invert collapse so that actually
talks about you know the wall makeup and
bonding and even how we can actually
make a slant imagine if you are making a
roof like if you are making a wall like
this obviously the pressure acts this
way and as things might tend to fall
down here but effective us and also the
corners most of the corners during the
view in the openings at the walls the
junctions these are the most crucial
places you know where the damage occurs
and also the water tanks the chance
because this is where they used to store
the water and obviously it got damaged
so how because these are some basic
needs one a community relies upon so
these are and whereas brick and concrete
house has fallen but as the boom they
have resisted this is one of the
important examples surviving examples
and similarly and Burgesses when a large
infrastructure has been damaged like
roads also some of the bridges some of
the hospitals
schools which has been unlock some some
in the urban areas a huge house many
houses have been damaged some apartments
have been damaged and this is one good
example of how it has partially been
damaged so being a hospital do you think
now how it will affect the whole health
sector and which is serving the
community when we say hospital has been
obvious it is very difficult to carry on
the regular activities and how it has to
serve the local communities health
conditions and what about the employment
of those people who are working for
government Hospital if it is servants
were working government servants who are
working for them at least they have some
benefit that they will be supported but
what about the temporary workers who are
depending on their daily wave daily
labor or daily wages so for them if
there is no work what happens to the
livelihood these are some of the
important questions and due to the hot
summers you can see the whole lake in
Bush has been dried many rivers have
been dried out so it has become even the
water scarcity they insure that
particular region this is a house near
by a village where they have different
class societies there's no chaos there's
the Chow hands and there's our Muslim
communities so there different caste
hierarchies existed in the catch area
and this is one of the rich class and
which has been destructed during the
earthquake now there's one single house
which is having like two or three
families together they made one single
house having different partitions and
this whole house has been damaged but
then if you look at the sociological and
psychological aspects why these houses
are located here on the top of the ridge
or the top of a in a slightly higher
area it's not a mountain area but no
slightly but if you ever looked from
their rich houses villages you will see
the whole entire village so this is
where the the traditional the landlords
or the rich people who used to settle
down on the top so it shows the
significance of the status of that
particular community and who try to look
at the
village and including in some villages
the even the entry point of a different
community also from the external side it
depends on the untouchable so this is
the condition social systems which has
been prevalent in these areas and now
what happened to these houses so people
who were not having any house to live
there so when these people have migrated
to a different place because they could
able to offer somewhere and equitable to
live somewhere else so that is where
this unsafe houses has become a shelter
for the corridor between these two
families has become a shelter for the
shell in the homeless people so but the
question is is really safe to live there
because aftershocks might keep coming on
and there might be a possibility that
you can see that whole damage has been
occurred so there is a great possibility
that this may also collapse and the wash
areas has been damage to the back behind
and the toilets but you look at it the
wealthy class of the village they have a
detached toilet system and detergent
washing systems at the towards the rear
side so which means though the
independent families are segregated by
wall and the common corridors at the end
like you have the three families living
like this but they have a common toilet
so together at the rear space and at the
same time they have their personal
demarkation of their space so this is
how the whole and this is completely
treated in one unit to represent one
family belonging so this is the story of
immediately after the earthquake but now
I'll just read out a poem which has been
written by natraj grantee and it was at
the moment of that quake impacts he
talks shattered dreams awful screams
nothing more nothing more shaken floor
fallen door nothing more nothing more
silent boys deserted toys nothing more
nothing more tumble stones
broken bones nothing more nothing more
so this was on the wake of this disaster
of my friend natraj he has written this
kind of narrative of explain the pain
and agony of the families and what
happens to their dreams what happened to
their flows what happened to their
belongings
you know how the are how the people the
children can become orphans when the
shield parents died and you know how
people die what kind of panic situation
it was that is and in such kind of
situations obviously one of the
important aspect is the schools like as
I showed you some Community Hall
infrastructure even these kind of
infrastructure has been affected so many
of these schools were damaged and many
of the community halls community centers
have been damaged so this actually says
that you know they are afraid to go to
school so that is where the schools have
been stopped for about one year any
early one year so how about education
you know what to do how we can engage
the community and the children because
you know that is also needed what
happens to the school education and
where do we provide the school
facilities and this is where many NGOs
have came forward many development
agencies have came they collaborated in
different forms as I am NOT going in
detail about how differently they have
collaborate but at least some of them
the sponsor did some of them they worked
independently some of them they
collaborated with partnerships so these
are some of the examples you can see
that the weave of the classrooms this is
a school a temporary school which has
been constructed to provide some
education facilities for the people who
doesn't have school I mean at least from
the neighborhood areas and you can see
that the kind of linear clanton has been
organized to organize the school and
this is the interior of a bamboo
classroom but now the question is yes
they are good at least bamboo has been
supplied and it has quickly erected to
make a sim because it's very easy to
build bamboo you just have to make and
of panel based and make some starts make
the structure of the with the poles and
then tie
then what you see here is this is a
gravel you know the gravel they put the
gravel on the top so that even if the
rain comes it doesn't become dirty and
because it's hardly any level difference
it's hardly five centimeters to 10
centimeters level difference and even in
case when rain happens so that is where
they put the gravel so that the water
can percolate and this whole school has
been established so here then people the
local teachers or the local educated
graduates they started volunteering
themselves to teach to the children and
similarly some just cool office some of
the office buildings and they have also
developed in the laminated paper pipes
you know you will also see that from the
Tadao Ando's work and the temporary
shelters which will actually provide
with the laminated paper pipes and this
was about in those days I'm talking
about two prong tool which has cost her
about twenty seven thousand rupees per
unit so which was very reasonable amount
of cost whereas the dining hall which is
completely built with the canvas
material so that itself has costed about
eighteen thousand material but then if
you talk about the durability or if
there is any kind of rain accursed and
obviously this may not so better and
this is little better than the canvas
aspect of it what they do is they had
this walled structure and they put a mat
on it the tarpaulin sheets or some kind
of waterproof materials so that it can
actually protect as a roof and some of
the hotels because a lot of energy was
coming forward so where do they stay you
know there's many offices coming here
and going and doing lot of
reconstruction work so the lot of
movement is going on this work and this
is where they also developed some kind
of residential aspects of it that is
where they built till the sill level
with the stone wall with a random rubble
masonry and then this is a kind of
wooden material or a tin material and
then this is the traditional tile
pattern roof where the terracotta tiles
and
the doors and windows are made with the
plywood the plywood material wishes and
made about three feet six inches
Stonewall and this bamboo construction
was about 20,000 rupees so if you
compare the cost that Terracotta was
27,000 and this one was bamboo was
20,000 and the canvas was about 18,000
so the more the material we are
improving there obviously and this is
about 12,000 you know because that is
where you are using the stone and as
well as the plywood material into it and
this all temporary structure for a
period of two years and because for one
year they completely abandon the school
education and many NGOs came forward how
we can actually generate some
alternative livelihood items you know
like the woman how they can be educated
the unemployed youth how they could be
provided with some kind of alternative
skills because like tailoring saving
embroidery or any craft making so this
is one of the so what they did was they
had a stone wall and they made a vault
and they have a truss the metal stress
and has some places they have also had
this asbestos and the tin sheet the tin
sheets as well and the galvanized sheets
and they put it on the top and that way
because being a hot place they also have
kind of some places there and from in
little insulation sheets you know the
materials which can make and the
flooring it has again a kind of mats
which has been laid out in classrooms
through the normal mats and as well as
and this is a computer lab you know it's
a air conditioned computer labs which
has a semicircular truss roof and this
is again a prefab prefabricated truss
roof and here they have actually
established a training center even
computer training center as well and
this is all about the temporary housing
but then when we moved on how in these 2
years how we have to invest for the
permanent housing because the land
allocation issues way to relocate and
how to find the land how to get the
money how to get the collaboration
all this becomes big questions you know
and these are challenging issues and
here's where the technology transfer
also has been adopted in Gujarat case so
where Center for at unit and our Oval
Center has actually transferred from
lamda and as well the compressed
stabilized C we call it as C as EB
compressed stabilized earth block so
these are basically a kind of
interlocking bricks and this is the
workshop in that name earlier the
present owner shala
it's called kuch nom nom on a beyond and
now it is called Hana shallow foundation
but this was the workshop of so where
they used to make these interlocking
breaks or they used to make these kind
of rough applications making these live
models of the houses demonstration units
and the here based on the silt content
and the clay content of 60 to 64 bit of
sand 10 to 15% plays 15 to 20 percent
gravel is about other gates are about 10
to 15 percent and sanity should not be
greater than the 1200 ppm and pH value
not less transfer so that is a kind of
composition through which they developed
these stabilized eight blocks which are
about in a square shape and this is
called Orem fence and basically what
they do is they they actually repaired
the mixture of this mixing with the
cement 5% to 7% of the cement and to
stabilize it and then they actually this
is a mild process so they keep that and
then the press it and then these mouths
will come out of it and this is where
the interlocking breaks because these
are very helpful for having a vertical
reinforcement at the corners or the
junctions so they can have some vertical
reinforcement there's a male and female
coupling of it so how these two things
has to match and then the reinforcement
is kept whether it is a pipe inserted or
a 8mm rod has been settled into it
so what they do is once they prepare
these braids that will fire these bricks
what they do is they cover with a kind
of plastic sheet for two days and then
they leave it for about the cure it for
21 days in the hot stone and then they
directly use it to the building material
although there has been some prefab
units such as ferro-cement channels so
you have the ferro-cement channels which
are mouths so and similarly these are
mostly used for toilets as well so this
is how the roof structure is like so it
couples one over the another and then it
forms as a kind of roof and not only in
terms of this earthquake but also the
previous past earthquakes there has been
some efforts by different agencies by
development alternatives in Delhi near
mythic interests in Hyderabad this is
one another model where they talk about
the you know the precast frames you know
these are all the precast technologies
in housing so this is a frame which has
been developed by an aromatic indras
like a door frame but then this is a
hollow brick model of roofs what they do
is these things will embed it into this
frame and that becomes into the roof you
know so each panel is fitted with these
kind of blocks and then it composed as
one panel so this is one technology and
also they developed one more technology
of having a diagonal bracing and the
concrete ballz you know so there all of
inif earthquake comes and shades
obviously the building can only you know
tilt a bit so that it will not affect
much damage so this is also one of the
technology which near midi Kandra have
developed and following various
guidelines which we showed by the GSD MA
and all others is codes
Kershner near mana beyond of that time
has developed many of the models of
Quakerism
one is GPS one model one is imitation of
the Bunga what you can see is the plinth
man sill band on the roof band so
following these codes as well as the
guidelines which has been issued by the
authorities so they also demonstrate
that how the transfer of thieves
technology can be implemented like the
upgradation of the Bunga roof so that is
where they're talking about the
octagonal conical roof with the help of
truss fabricated drafts also some of the
circulant models which is a
hemispherical dome this is completely
done with the bricks you know with the
mud blocks and the ferro-cement channels
which I showed you just now how they are
fabricated and some of the houses were
also constructed on that and as well as
some toilets you can see that these are
the precast toilets your toilet units so
these are some of the interventions some
ideas because this whole disaster
becomes the follow-up of this becomes a
kind of place a laboratory of different
ideas and experiments so even some
incorporation of traditional technology
like bamboo how we can make use of
bamboo and embed that in the shelter
forms and touch so there's a combination
of both these CSP blocks
Ramnath as well as the catch rules so
there's different works and similarly in
the hospital what you can see is that
they're building some units of the
geodesic domes which has known for its
earthquake resistant structure and which
will have less area and more volume so
this is the earthquake resistant model
built by pneumatic Endre as I said to
you the diagonal bracing in the
foundation with these circular balls
where the building can bear the forces
of the earthquake forces as well and the
same Community Hall the Catholic Relief
Services has taken the reconstruction
activity of the biker village and here
you can see that this whole community
hall which has been damaged has been
reconstructed and using the CSLB blocks
on the manglu tiles and similarly you
can see that houses they are giving
about 35 square meter area of a house
where they have a small open space and
sometimes using the previous dose if
they have and here in this village what
they did was they have not designed
any liam but what they did was just our
descent to the house where they already
have an existing house just our descent
to it
they have like imagine you have a house
here so I descend to it they have built
it so that the structure remained the
structure of that layout remained as it
is and like now today you see that the
crossroad is like this where the
community center in the center and
gradually things have developed later on
but now what you are seeing is a view of
the village which has been reconstructed
at the same places like you can see a
small bundes next to it where they were
living temporarily and there's also some
earthquake resistant models which were
developed by Curtis cavity but these are
very not even relevant to this area but
they are very uniform and standardized
forms of the concrete models where
people showed their reluctance in not to
stay in these houses when I started
interviewing them they said no we cannot
stay in these houses and some of them
there's 100 cruel hospital projects
which can at least resistant 9h of scale
so in that way they try to progress to
resistance aspect of it and what are the
responses of this community so now you
can see a community has been given this
house by an NGO next to it the community
themselves have built this house by
using the stone they know that they have
a stone is an unsafe material but they
have built with their own for their own
needs for their own so this is where we
have to learn that what community needs
and what come into demands and now to
give them some guidance even if they are
wishing to go with the stone how safe it
is but what are the better ways to
construct and what are the rightful ways
to construct using these materials you
know what are the codes you have to
follow is where the technicality has to
be addressed in some support system for
the community to build themselves so
these are some of the examples from the
Gujarat earthquake
whereas in following the Gujarat we have
tsunami and immediately after tsunami
the Kashmiri earthquake and in the
Kashmir at
I was working in a company in UK and I
was immediately after the post Kashmir
earthquake a lot of agencies work
working towards it and they were looking
for a quick technologies quickly build
houses so at that time UN WTO has also
approached our company and I was
actually designing some kind of prefab
houses from Britain and their September
frame houses where we can do a flat-pack
approach what you can see is the panels
here and there all this is not the house
exactly built-in and the provoked you
but this built elsewhere but I don't
have the photographs so I'm trying to
show some similar models of it
so here the trusses the roofs everything
is a flat-pack approach so in a uniform
and standardized format so that we can
reduce the waste by design and we pack
it from the factory we will ship it to
the pier ok and as well as then we send
to few Labour's there and they erect it
on spot so here that is where I say that
I realized the villains role as a
designer sitting in my desk I have never
been to the site I never been to the
context I never introduced to the
context I'm not knowing who are the
beneficiaries what do they need what was
a livelihood and this is where I was
playing a villain role and that is where
I looked at my further research of how
we can actually take the research what
are the gaps how to reconcile in between
the gaps between the development groups
on the beneficiary groups then before
that Kashmir earthquake we have the
tsunami and what you can see is a drying
tsunami which has been destructed the
manic and the Indian Ocean tsunami in
2004 the Boxing Day tsunami and it has
affected the Tamil Nadu the southern
state of Tamil Nadu especially in the
Naga putih naman of course the callaloo
and the east coast of the Tamil Nadu but
the epicenter was somewhere near Sumatra
and the waves have traveled almost in
this direction so now immediately after
the post tsunami when I will strike the
place the important issues all the food
security you know there how to get there
Asians because they are all after the
relief stage when there
settle somewhere so their daily needs
this is where every ration shop is full
of kills every water facility because
their infrastructure has been damaged
because of the tsunami where do they get
the drinking water you know and their
livelihood is in threat so this is where
in the fishermen set up you have the
boat owners you have the fishermen of
the traders and everything used to
cooperate with each other and use to
work and the traditional houses you know
the and their indigenous knowledge how
they oriented their houses their
climatically efficient how would soothe
their livelihood needs and different
typology of houses his entering embody
and how different layouts of these
houses like a joint family house is a
nuclear family house and their public
places how they were damaged this is a
huge infrastructure has been damaged but
one has to look at it but if you look at
the evidences if a correct information
has been passed down to these places
it took hundred and eighty minutes which
is about three hours to reach to get
these waves into the mainstream you know
to the mainland so if that information
has been passed on the right way we
would have saved many lives we would
have actually save some important assets
there is always a relief stage as a
rehabilitation stage which goes for a
few months and the final is the
reconstruction stage there's a lot of
actors working from the government
international NGOs local NGOs and the
community groups which work on these
aspects so I am talking about the
transitional shelter so what did it was
a immediate requirement for them as
where to live many of them lost their
houses so many I was visiting develop
autonomy village the longest fisherman
village and you can see that I've taken
a lot of questionnaires and a lot of
semi-structured interviews they got the
tin sheets immediately and they have
lived here for about two years and what
you can see is up a barracks of the tin
shields in fact the familiar kind of
housing has been provided in a mnemonic
Oberoi silence and the tribal
communities they have
these houses they're boycotted these
houses so this is where material also
plays an important of course it was very
quick to deliver but one has to
understand that they have to stay here
for a few more months and how to work on
it and after the following disaster the
basic infrastructure the toilets where
do they go for the toilets where do they
get the water services and this is aware
the time where people have some
professional Minds come together they
started showing some choices yes we
provide this option now you can decide
we try to facilitate you know what they
decide so their different process which
starts actually following the transition
stage but the most important challenge
is not only about them it should not be
narrowed them only at the built form but
one has to look at how this transition
stage has to gradually go into the
permanent stage and there's issues like
how this material could be used and this
two years what are the things we have to
address schooling is children schooling
the community's health facilities
comment is livelihood how they can
regenerate on all these ok so these are
some of the evidences which I want to
bring to the students notice that yes
some challenges in the transition phase
as well okay I hope you understand that
thank you very much
[Music]