Lecture 21 : Intergranular Corrosion: Sensitization and Weld Decay

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 4, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
welcome back to the course corrosion
failures and analysis
today we have lecture twenty one
and will continue our discussion on
inter granular corrosion
and if you see
that last lecture we
realized that
the chromium carbide precipitation along
the grain boundary
and then subsequent
chromium depletion zone
along the grain boundary which is
adjacent to the grain boundary
that region becomes highly anodic
because
its chromium content goes down to even
less than less than two percent which is
in weight percent of course
but rest of the part of the
alloy or the soft alloy surface
contains 18 percent chromium which is
sufficient for passivation to take place
so that become passive stainless steel
at the same time along the grain
boundary you have all those
network of chromium carbide which is cr
23 c 6 kind of chromium carbide so they
will also get passivated so the narrow
zone which is the depleted in chromium
which is basically depleted in chromium
that becomes anode
and that anode is
highly narrow region and surrounded by a
large cathodic regions because
passivated ss or the passivated
stainless steel
would be
noble as compared to the
ah
those active stainless steel part
so
the courses
lecture 21
topic
inter granular corrosion
now
as we have discussed in the last lecture
we took
one microstructure of austenitic
stainless steel which is eighteen eight
and then we saw along the grain boundary
we have chromium carbide precipitation
and it forms a network
and this narrow zone
this zone basically
are actually depleted with chromium
and that creates
a section which is highly anodic because
12 percent chromium is needed
for
sufficient
passivation to achieve so the 12
chromium
should be required in order to make it
stainless steel
okay or stainless
now around
this zone
which is huge
area of the green
that contains the hair we contained 18
percent chromium
so they will passive it
but
even
the narrow zone of grain boundary
it is cr 23 c6
so passive it
sufficient chromium for passivation to
take place
but this zone
which is the depleted zone where
chromium is less than two percent
will be active
it will not passivate now as per
galvanic series
if you go back to the galvanic corrosion
galvanic series
in salt solution
nacl solution or sea water
ah passivated
three zero four
stainless steel
is sitting at a very high level in the
galvanic series
as compared to the
active
three zero four
stainless steel so that means this zone
will act as cathode
and this zone will also act as cathode
and the narrow section which is anode
so now there will be galvanic effects so
this lead to so these two
and this one they will have
strong galvanic effect
since these are lying
further apart in that galvanic series so
this is cathode
and this is anode
thats what it is taking place
now at the same time there is one more
effect that is coming into picture
area factor
since cathode here
has large area
and anode here
which is the depleted zone this blue
part
is a small area
and since it cathode area is large so
the cathodic reactions
have more
area
and that is what larger number of
cathodic reaction would take place which
require electron
and that electron would be supplied by
this narrow anodic region and that is
what
the dissolution
of this zone
will take place aggressively
aggressively and it leads to
inter granular
corrosion in stainless steel
now coming to this particular phenomena
that
precipitation
of
c r twenty three c six kind of
precipitate
along the grain boundary
so that process
we call it as
when this happens then only
this depletion
happens along the grain boundary
adjacent to the grain boundary actually
that blue region
so that time we call that the steel has
become
sensitized
sensitized steel
and this process is called
sensitization
now
for this sensitization
we need
precipitation of this particular phase
which is actually
a nucleation
and
growth controlled
fine and whenever it happens that means
its basically
temperature
and
time dependent
fine
so if something is temperature and time
dependent
that means
for this
sensitization to happen
we have two
factors for
sensitization
one
temperature
and this is more or less universally
proven that in case of
eighteen eight
stainless steel which is
and rather most of the stainless steels
ah where this eighteen eight close to
that eighteen eight ratio is maintained
so there we have that particular
temperature zone where chromium carbide
precipitation is
enhanced so that is around five hundred
to
eight fifty degree celsius this
temperature can vary ah from either side
ok so it can also reach to around 900
degree celsius
but this is a kind of general range
where this precipitation happens
and this precipitation temperature also
depends on
function of carbon content as well as
chromium content
why
because
for this phase to form you need both
chromium and carbon
but chromium you cannot reduce
because chromium is in the range of 17
to 18 to 20 percent
ok so this is 18
to 20 percent so this is essential
because that chromium actually gives you
the stainless property
hence
ah that carbon is becoming
important because chromium is fixed this
is fixed
this is fixed so the carbon is
can be varied
can be varied mainly
if we have higher carbon so then of
course chromium carbide precipitation
would become easier because it has much
more solute content
for the precipitation to for the
accumulation of carbon and get this
particular to come out as this
particular precipitate
but if carbon content decreases of
course that precipitation kinetics
slows down
ok so
so that means second part of course temp
this is that means if it is dependent on
temperature
and it is a nucleation for process
and at the same time one more important
factor is why it di in why it finds a
place along the grain boundary because
grain boundary provides
heterogeneous nucleation sites that is
what it actually tries to form on grain
boundary
so
ah
i will come to that part but here this
is one part and then second part is time
more would be the time within this
temperature zone
higher would be possibility of formation
of chromium carbide because it is a time
dependent temperature as well terminal
because
for that you need diffusion
diffusion of both carbon
and
chromium fine so since it needs
diffusion its a diffusion is a time
dependent process so thats what time is
important
now
as i said that more would be the time
spent by that particular metal within
this temperature zone higher would be
the chance of formation of chromium
carbide
now third factor which actually ah
becomes important in the case of ah
stainless steel since we see that the
chromium cannot be changed which is the
fixed content if chromium you reduce
chromium carbide formation will be
reduced but that we do not want so the
carbon can only be controlled so you can
say the corollary ah may be a third
ah factor which control sensitization is
the carbon content
provided there is no ah stabilizing
elements so
just at this moment that there are
elements like titanium or niobium they
try to stabilize
stainless steel so we will talk about
that addition of niobium on titanium
into the stainless steel
for making it stabilized so that is a
falling under control of sensitization
but at this moment
we have these three factors
now
first we will talk about this two part
these two part will be important
now this particular temperature zone we
call it sensitization zone
sensitization job
or sensitization temperature
temperature job
now
this kind of
sensitization
is possible as you understand from this
discussion that if the steel somehow is
taken to the temperature range
and
we
leave it there for some time
now question is if some stainless steel
is made
and then if it is
rapidly quenched to the room temperature
then of course the time spent within
this temperature would be very small
and if that time spent is less than the
time required for the sufficient
precipitation of chromium carbide along
the grain boundary definitely
the problem of sensitization would not
happen so that means
if
we quench
or
rapidly cool
stainless steel or
here the we are talking about three zero
four s s
so that would allow
less time
spent
so let us say this is
t
spent
ok so if this t spent
is
less than
the time required for
considerable
c
carbide precipitation chromium carbide
precipitation
of course
during due to rapidly cooling
when it cools from a higher temperature
within this temperature range the time
spent is de spent and that is less than
the time required for considerable
carbon chromium carbide precipitation
and then by the time it drops to room
temperature no problem of sensitization
sensitization will not be absorbed
but if this time is more than this
so that case this is the case
so this is the case
where you get
sensitization
fine
so this
problem is not there but question is
if you have to have a component made
component made out of stainless steel of
this particular grade of stainless steel
you need to have welding ok that is
joining operation
so the welding
is needed and during welding
of course
you have two parts
this is one part
and the another part is
this is another part
so now here you are doing welding
so the welding is done
welding is done so that is basically the
metal pool
and now
here we have
large heat and the maximum temperature
max temperature
because there only we are putting that
beam if we do electric arc welding that
electric arc is held over there so thats
what that will be the highest
temperature
now this heat will be dissipated
and this dissipation would also happen
through
conduction
so the heat is going
either side
so the
base of that particular both the sides
will also be heated up
and interesting observation is
if thus this heating is
somewhat
not very fast
we get to see
a region which is close to
that particular
weld pool but little away from that well
pool
in both the sides
both the sides
we have
a zone
which is forming
say this zone will be susceptible to
inter granular corrosion so this green
zone
this part
and this part
are basically
susceptible
sensitization
and since its taking place due to the
welding operation
we call it weld decay
the sensitized part
both the sides of that weld
of 304 ss is called weld decay now we
have to understand why it happens and it
have it is very normal
that it can happen if we weld 304 ss
which contains this is very important
which contains
weight percent
carbon and eighteen eight this is still
eighteen eight eighteen percent chromium
and eight percent
nickel and this structure is single
phase austenitic ok
gamma iron is basically a gamma iron ok
now
why it happens because
if we try to see in two dimension
how much time i have
oh yeah
now
if we see it in two dimension
so now let us say this is
one part
this is another part
these are the two parts of that
same steel component three zero four
eighteen eight stainless steel
now this is the weld zone
this is the weld part
so this is the weld pool
and now if we put
thermocouple here
so that means this weld pool will spread
some distance here
both the sides because the base metal
needs to be melted also
ok so then only you can have a very good
union
now if we put
thermocouple
at the junction point of the weld pool
and
the base metal
and then at a particular regular
distance let us put another
thermocouple here another thermocouple
here another thermocouple here
so this thermocouple will try to measure
the heat
received and that heat received will
lead to a temperature so actually this
thermocouple will measure the
temperature at that those points
now this lets meme those thermocouple a
let us say this is a part
this is b
this is c this is d
and we can have
temperature time profile of those
thermocouple and of course the center
part which is actually getting those
beam
this is the beam part
beam part so that center part will be
the maximum temperature but away from it
the temperature profile the maximum
temperature would definitely decrease
because heat is actually getting
dissipated by conduction through the
metal
now
if we try to look at the time
temperature profile
let us say
this is my temperature axis
and this is my time axis
and let us say let me just see what
happens and the temperatures are
basically
let us say this is
ah
1300
ah let us say this is
eleven hundred
nine hundred
seven hundred
five hundred
three hundred
like that way
it goes up to
room temperature so let us say
this is room temperature
fine
now
from here
heating is done
since
the heating stage
it will be very steep because you are
actually having that beam close to that
particular weld pool
so heating stage it will be very steep
fine
and since its away from the melt zone so
it cannot reach to the and it lets say
degree celtic it ok cannot reach to the
melting point of that particular metal
fine
if it is little away from that
particular melt job
now
when you
cool let us say you remove the
beam so it will rapidly cool because it
was arc welding
arc
welding is employed
we will discuss why in stainless steel
welding we never use gas welding okay
so the arc welding so the heating so the
cooling would be sluggish because its a
basically ah in normal air it is left so
its a normal ah the way it actually goes
for a normal cooling so the cooling
curve would be somewhat like this
ok
now
then at the b point also we can plot
fine
now the c part c
thermocouple also can you can draw
fine
and the d part
d thermocouple
can show you
and for example this though i have taken
it to downwards so actually it is
starting here fine
so now
d part
ok so these are the temperature profile
fine
ah let us say this is in second
now as we see that the
sensitization temperature range is
around 500
to 900 let us say 850 degree celsius
ok so let us put a boundary there so
this is let us say 850
this is the 850 and 500 is this one
ok
now let us see how much time
a particular thermocouple
is staying
within that particular
magic temperature range where the
sensitization or chromium carbide
precipitation would happen
now if we consider the a part so this is
corresponding to a thermocouple this is
corresponding to b thermocouple this is
corresponding to c
and this is corresponding to
d thermocouple
fine
now in case of d of course that
particular position of that particular
metal
is not able to reach to 500 even it
stops there at around 300 or 250 280.
so since it is not able to reach to that
500 more than 500 it will never
experience this particular temperature
zone okay
in case of d
so d
will not
experience
sensitization
since
this is not reaching to that level of
temperature
now in case of
c
yes if you see that it is entering the
that particular temperature at this
point
and
leaving
that particular temperature at this
point so the total time spent within
that 500 to 850 degree celsius
temperature
is this much
so i put t c
now in case of b
if we see how much time it spends
when it
ah
actually ah
heated and
going back to the
room temperature during during cooling
so during heating it leaves this
magic temperature at this point it
leaves it
and it reaches around 1100 degree
celsius
and interestingly
chromium carbide
type of precipitate
dissolved at around
1050 degree celsius
50 degree celsius
so even if
enters this particular magic temperature
at this point
and leaves at this point
during that time the time of spent
at this level would be very small
because
it is a heating stage and heating is
very quick
so though the time of residence
in that temperature range during heating
is less
even if we consider that there is a
possibility of little bit of chromium
carbide precipitation
still it will not stay there along the
grain boundary because by the time it
leaves here and it reaches to around
1100 degree celsius temperature it will
dissolve so again if it dissolves then
the chromium and carbon will homogenize
again and remember for getting a very
good
stainless property all across the mass
or the body of that particular stainless
steel we need to have homogenized
chromium and homogenized carbon all
across it
and it will homogenize so there will be
no problem ah when we heat it but when i
cool it in the case of b
it enters this particular temperature
here 850 to 500 and leaves here ok so
that means the time of retention during
cooling
is this much
so this is the time so if i try to see
so this is the time
this is the time so which is i can say
time corresponding to d
now during cooling
we have a possibility of chromium
carbide precipitation again along the
grain boundary because the grain
boundary provides heterogeneous sites
now this time we have to analyze ok
whether this time is sufficiently large
for the chromium carbide precipitation
or not now if i try to see a point a a
point corresponding to the thermocouple
a
so that point similar analogy during
heating is can be given just like we
have talked about in case of b
the time of retention and it also
time of retention is less during heating
in that temperature range at the same
time the temperature goes beyond 1300
degree celsius so even if there is a
little bit of formation possibility but
those chromium carbide will dissolve
because it dissolves at around 1050
degree celsius
now during heating we have again see
where it enters so during heating it
enters here and leaves here ok
that a point corresponding to a point so
the time of retention in the temperature
range is this much
so this is t a
now from this picture it is very clear
that you see that t a
t a
is less than
t b
is less than
t c
so here this temperature relation is
very important now if we consider that
the time required for significant
chromium carbide
precipitation ok
if this time
is
more than
t a
but
if this time is
is less than
t b
and t c
then you can easily make out
that
when we have at that point of a the time
of retention is not able to give
sufficient chromium carbide
precipitation
because that time of retention is more
less than
the time formation for sufficient
chromium carbide precipitation but in
case of b and c we could see
that the time required for precipitation
of chromium carbide is less than t b and
t c so we have more time for the
formation of chromium carbide in case of
b and c so in this zone around this zone
so it so you can have to you have to
also put close by thermocouple and then
see so where is actually
just touching this place and where it is
just touching this place so in that case
b will have precipitation c will not
have because c it is not going to the ah
that particular temperature range but
the b will have a sufficient time so
that case only that around a b will have
precipitation so now in this particular
situation whatever ex diagram we have
plotted
so around this zone
around this zone
we have chromium carbide precipitation
so this zone becomes sensitized
fine
because of this condition
and
similarly on the other side you can also
do the mirroring experiment ok similar
experiment and you will see that the
similarly on the other side
if the both the
stainless steels are same of same three
zero four
normal three zero four so that time this
one also will have this temperature
profile like this so where chromium
carbide precipitation can be possible so
here c r 23 c 6 forms
and it becomes sensitized so this is
typical phenomena that is observed
during welding so thats what it is
called decay weld decay ok so this is
called
weld decay
fine
so now
let us
stop here
will
take this matter further in our
next lecture
thank you
[Music]
[Music]
you
