Lecture 23 : Intergranular Corrosion: Knife Line Attack and Prevention Methods

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 4, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
let's start lecture 23
so this is the course on corrosion
failures and analysis
and we discuss ah inter granular
corrosion and today
will conclude this inter granular
corrosion and next day onwards will
start discussing crevice corrosion ok
so the course is ah
and if we recall our discussion
ah in last two lectures
we talked about
the mechanism of intergranular corrosion
which relates to the chromium depleted
zone formation
due to chromium carbide precipitation
along the grain boundary
in case of
ah three zero four stainless steel
and that chromium depleted zone acts as
a narrow anode and all other areas are
large cathodes
so
so that is what it becomes a serious ah
galvanic corrosion along the thin strips
where chromium depletion happens along
the grain boundary and that initiates
inter granular
corrosion
now at the same time we talked about
weld decay in case of weld decay what
happens you start with
homogenized
304
stainless steel where chromium
is all over the matrix as well as grain
boundary
are unif is uniformly placed ok so here
everywhere it is 18 percent which is
sufficient for a very good passivation
to achieve
now during welding of two components
what happens in the weld zone
the temperature is maximum but away from
the weld zone
at a zone
we have shown by putting thermocouples
that in that zone the temperature
reaches
temperature is between
ah 850 to ah
around in that temperature zone 500 to
850 degree celsius the material stays
for a longer period and that initiates
chromium carbide precipitation in that
zone only
rest of the zones we do not have any
problem either chromium carbide
dissolves and it homogenizes
ah or if the temperature is higher than
850 degree celsius which is
between those zone and
the weld pool
as well as if you have move away from
that zone ah you will get the
temperature does not reach to that 500
degree celsius so there is no problem of
having chromium carbide precipitation
in the zones away from those that
particular ah temperature section where
ah material stays for longer period at
five hundred to eight fifty degree
celsius
so that is called weld decay
and now ah question is ah how to stop
that well decay
there are three
processes
one is ah so we we talked about control
about control of
ah sensitization
or you can say well decay
so there are three processes in first
process
we have solutionization
treatment
by chance if the material
has sensitization has has has got into
sensitization mode
one can heat it to around thousand fifty
degree celsius where chromium carbide
dissolves and makes it homogeneous
distribution of chromium
so the problem is resolved and then
after heating there for some time once
chromium dissolves then you quench it
quickly so that chromium carbide does
not precipitate anymore when the
temperature when during cooling when the
material goes through that 500 to 850
degree celsius since its quenching
though not much of time
is
available for chromium carbide formation
so the problem is resolved and then
solutionization treatment and another
part is you do not this is let us say
one and let us say you time and
temperature both are
important
so this is 500 to
850 degree celsius and this time you can
say that time for
ah c r
23 c 6
is should be
greater than time of residence
particular temperature zone so then
chromium carbide does not precipitate so
now this two are interrelated
ah
so interrelated in the sense that during
solutionization you have to heat it
higher than this temperature zone and
then dissolve chromium carbide
or other way around that you do not go
to the during welding itself first stage
your cooling should be fast enough so
that when it passes through that
temperature zone time is not available
time is short enough so that chromium
carbon does not precipitate so this is
ah
part one
second is one can use low carbon
we have also seen with the help of time
temperature sensitization diagram that
if the carbon content goes below zero
point zero three percent the time
required for precipitation of chromium
carbide would be very high around close
to six to seven hours
in case of 304 stainless steel if you
reduce the carbon below 0.03 percent
so that case
there is no question of
sensitization because
whatever cooling you employ you do not
usually keep it that long in that
particular temperature range so no
question of sensitization so that can
stop it
now in that regard ah let us say if you
have
two sections
one is
three zero four
ah let us say zero point zero three
percent carbon so where ah this is
considered as l and then another one ah
block let us say another thick plate you
take three zero four which is normal
0.08 percent carbon
now if you weld them
you would see that sensitization would
be experienced
in case of three zero port zero point
eight percent and this part
this entire part would remain ah
unsensitized
and this is sensitized
fine so this situation you can come
across and the third process what we
done what we have thought that we put ah
niobium
or titanium into the metal in a small
amount so niobium about one percent
titanium around zero point seven percent
so that they take care of carbon ah
and then doesn't
they don't allow sufficient carbon
availability for chromium to get
chromium carbide precipitation to have
chromium carbide precipitation now ah
this is added in case of zero point zero
eight percent carbon steel carbon carbon
stainless steel ah that means here you
do not go for low carbon
you have normal carbon content what is
there in three zero four you add
titanium and ibm so problem will be
resolved because
they will take care of this carbon
and they will form nibbium
carbide or titanium carbide
and they do not allow chromium carbide
to form because there is not much of
carbon available so if chromium carbide
does not form the chromium distribution
would be homogeneous and it will be in
solution it will lead to strong
passivation of the stainless steel and
thats what we need
for stainless steel to have stainless
property ok so these are the ah three
major routes where ah through which we
can
avoid sensitization now question is we
talked about one particular situation
that knife line attack
okay so in case of three zero four zero
point eight percent the sensitization
happens because of weld decay but knife
line attack is also related to inter
granular corrosion
corrosion but
it is
in
[Music]
niobium
or
titanium containing
stainless steel
and this particular process we call it
stabilization
stabilization why it is stabilization we
are actually stabilizing carbon and
making ah we are actually taking taking
carbon and then making the stainless
steel stabilized against sensitization
now this is
this inter granular corrosion in knife
line attack
they are interrelated and this also
related to chromium carbide
precipitation
chromium carbide precipitation now
ah interesting part is
when we talk about
this chromium carbide precipitation ah
that means it must be related to that
situation that niobium and titanium
carbide
they do not form
rather chromium carbide form
specifically so that means stabilization
action is totally
lost
so we have to understand that mechanism
of knife line attack
mechanism now first thing this happens
in case of thin sheet metal
ok around 1.16 inch
thick
those kind of sheet metal when you
unsweet metal of definitely ah let us
say 347 which is a stabilized
stainless steel or three two one ok so
three two one contains titanium three
four seven ibm
now
second part is
ah this is related to welding again
third part is
it happens so if you consider weld decay
as well as ah let us say you have a
thick plate of three four seven
and
that is
two three four seven
and these are thick plate thicker than
ah let us say ah
two inch one inches thick or something
like that so that time ah if you weld
you do not experience any
well decay ok but if it is thin enough
then what happens
ah if it is thin so then that particular
knife line attack happens very close to
that
weld part ok very close to that well
part in fact the main difference between
weld decay that is observed in case of
three zero four and the knife line
attack that had that happens in
stabilized steel the world decay happens
ah
quite a substantial distance from the
weld pool and the knife line attacks
happen very close to the very adjacent
to the well pool
that is the main difference and
interestingly one more thing let me just
since this particular picture is also
there
so if you take instead of three zero
four if you take three four seven in one
side the another side is phasor four
zero point zero eight percent and this
is also zero point zero eight percent
carbon
fine so both have same carbon level but
still the situation would be same the
the three zero four zero point eight
percent carbon would get sensitized in
that well decay portion but in three
four seven will not experience in well
decay ok ah so that this is again a
welding ah again but the difference is
it is also a kind of weld decay you can
say
but this decay happens very very
very close to
weld pool
ok
and this is much closer than what we
experienced in case of oil decay normal
thicker plate of three zero four
fine so this is ah
and this happens in stabilized steel
for example in this example we have one
side stabilized and one side ah three
zero force steel but ah since it is a
thicker plate ah knife line attack does
not happen in three four seven but well
decay happens in three four zero three
zero four so this is the
main
ah
point in case of night line attack
and white knife line attack because this
particular failure happens in a very
sharp
manner ok so its a very sharp manner so
it looks like a sharp needle like a
knife which is going through the sheet
metal ok so thats what this name comes
knife line
now
ah in order to understand the mechanism
ah we have to see keep see about this ah
welding part we have to carefully
observe this welding part
since its a thick thin metal sheet so
let us say this is the
let us say this is a kind of drum
one is making out of this thin sheet
metal
ok this is a very thin sheet metal
ok so this is the drum one is making so
now after that you have to join here
let us say this is welding
since its a thin sheet ok so the welding
has to be performed very quickly
why
just to avoid
burn through
ok
so now this is done very quickly second
thing is
let us say if it is 347 stainless steel
it is not a very good conductor of it
very good conductor of it so that means
once you do the welding of the thin
sheet the heat is actually centered or
constricted in that center in the weld
pole section it does not spread through
okay and it quickly
quickly cools also because it is a thin
sheet so you have lot of surfaces
available so heat dissipation to the air
is very easy
now thats what this particular zone
which is very narrow zone of that
particular section
narrow zone of the particular section
which cools very fair quickly at the
same time the heat is actually centered
around that zone it does not go away to
the other part the what it have what
happens in case of a thicker plate
so since it is constricted there now
definitely during welding the
temperature goes beyond ah the melting
point of that metal lets say around
close to fifteen hundred or sixteen
hundred degree celsius
fine ah and then during welding so the
temp during welding temperature
definitely goes much beyond that around
close to 2500 degree celsius so it melts
but around that region
also the temperature can go up to the
level of around close to 1300 to 1500
degree celsius
now due to that temperature
uh in the beginning the steel was
entirely stabilized only chromium
carbide precipitated no chromium carbide
chromium was homogenized
now since that heating has happened in
that narrow zone and the temperature
reaches beyond 1300 degree celsius in
that narrow zone chromium carbide is not
there at all but niobium carbide what
was there what was giving stabilization
action of that steel that also dissolves
so that means in that narrow zone you do
not have
niobium carbide
do not have
niobium carbide or
ah let me just put it nibm carbide
or chromium carbide
fine
both are not there
now when you quench it or when you cool
it fast
ok because cooling of course happens
very fast because of the thinner section
now in this zone you do not find any
nibm carbide or chromium carbide but
rest of the zone you have chromium and
niobium carbide present and chromium is
all homogenized
now once it happens
then
if you do not do anything to that it
will not create any problem because
there is no question of having chromium
carbide formation in that narrow zone
even
because
you have cool it very fast you have
cooled it very fast so there is no
question of formation of chromium
carbide event nym carbide doesn't form
again because it cools fast
but rest of the part chromium is
homogenized here also now the chromium
is homogenized so no problem it
absolutely fine it will work absolutely
fine because there is no question of
sensitization
chromium carbide is not there no
question of sensitization now the
problem happens somewhere else during
stress relieve operation because it is a
thin sheet and there could be lot of
stress inbuilt because of that quick
cooling after heating to a very high
temperature of the thin sections there
could be a possibility of warpage
because thin shed welding always leads
to a little bit of warpage so thats what
its better and there is lot of strain
here there is not much of strain here
not much of strain here but here there
will be lot of thermal strain so thats
what one has to do a little bit of
stress relief
so the stress relieve operation
after welding
that creates problem
so now before stress relieve operation
what are the stages
welding
and then rapid cooling
because of the thin sections
so all over the places you have chromium
homogenized
and niobium
homogenized
in the narrow portion
narrow region
covered
by
green line green line
fine
and rest of the part
so this is
second part welding and then second part
now the rest of the part
rest of the seed
nibium carbide
present but
chromium
is homogenized
because it is a stabilized steel
now during stress relief what happens
the temperature is taken to
temperature
for stabili for stress relief
temperature is around close to around
seven hundred to eight hundred degree
celsius
or sometime you can also have it six
hundred
now
you have to keep it there for some time
in this temperature and this temperature
you could see that this is
that sensitization temperature
sensitization temperature so then
chromium carbide
from forms
alone
grain boundary
where it forms in this particular joule
because rest of the zone you have nibm
carbide no problem you do not have
carbon for chromium carbide formation
even if you hit it there
but in this zone chromium and niobium
both are in solution
so once you heat it there the chromium
carbide has
the formation ability in that
temperature zone is much higher the
kinetics of chromium carbide formation
is much higher in that temperature zone
nibmium carbide does not form there so
it forms here so in order to understand
this it is better to draw a semantic
plot for the temperature
ah ah where chromium carbide forms
dissolves as well as nurbm carbide forms
and dissolves so in order to do that so
let us see
a kind of
a semantic plot
let us say this is temperature
fine so let us say this is 500
degree celsius
let us say this is let us say 850 degree
celsius
then you have around close to ah
let us say 1200
or 1250 degree celsius and then of
course ah you can go up to around
fourteen hundred degree celsius like
that
now if you see
the ah possibility of chromium different
carbides formation as well as the
dissolution
below that temperature
nothing happens
so no
chromium carbide
and no
niobium carbide
i am talking about the
overall behavior because if you start
with the homogenized
homogenized steel where niobium and
chromium both are there so if you heat
it to 500 degree celsius nothing happens
and beyond 500 degree celsius
chromium carbide
starts forming
or precipitating along the grain
boundary but
niobium carbide
does not form
now if you go beyond 850 degree celsius
the chromium carbide
starts
dissolving
and around thousand degree celsius it
dissolves very quickly
so dissolving but
dibium carbide now
starts forming
so this is
to starting material is homogenized
three four seven
stainless steel
now beyond twelve fifty degree celsius
chromium carbide already has dissolved
now
niobium carbide
starts dissolving
ok so this is the situation now what
happens
due to that stress relief operation
which is done within this temperature
range
within this temperature range and since
niobium in that green colored covered
area which is close to that weld zone
is also in the solution during cooling
stage
so the first chromium carbide comes out
no neobium carbide comes no nibble
carbide forms
and then after that what you do you
quench it
okay
and then
not quench it even you cool it slow
because you are doing ah stressfully
when you quench it again you quench it
there will be little bit of strength so
you cool it slow now when you cool it
slow
then there is no question of nibm
carbide in that narrow zone
close to that
oil pull
and there chromium carbide has formed
along the grain boundary so then
this particular region this particular
section will go to sensitization
but rest of the part we have
niobium carbide because it is already
stabilized
so that is what
the sensitization problem will be
experienced with a narrow zone across
that weld pole
and if we keep fuming nitric acid
nowhere things will happen because no
corrosion will be observed in other
places other than narrow zone of that
weld pool
but there since its a highly
concentrated sensitized zone
we have serious
chromium serious ah
intergranular corrosion happening there
and that leads to a very sharp ah
failure in the form of knife line ok so
that is what this is called knife line
attack so that is the basic reason why
knife line attack happens and that
happens in case of stabilized state so
if you take three two three two one
which is titanium stabilized stainless
steel still it will experience the same
lifeline attack
so now coming to this point that in
order to avoid tight line attack so how
what should be done
let us say ah even if you go for stress
relieve operation the stress relief see
if that is essential
the stress relieving
should be done beyond
beyond around thousand degree celsius
ok so
what is the advantage
at that time if you see this diagram ah
beyond thousand degree celsius chromium
carbide
dissolves niobium carbide forms so in
the narrow zone around that well pool
nibium carbide
forms
so once the ibm carbide forms
the narrow zone is
oil pull
is stabilized
once it is stabilized there is no carbon
available for chromium carbide formation
after that you can cool very very slow
ok you just leave it outside it will
cool down nothing happens because there
is no question of chromium carbide
formation there is no carbon in there
because its the entire
ah tank is stabilized now even with that
narrow zone also it is stabilized so
that should be the practice and then
cool it very slow
so even if you cool slow does not happen
doesn't doesn't make any sense maybe it
not does not make any problem because
ah
when it goes through this zone
carbon is not available for chromium
carbide so sensitization is completely
avoided so that should be the ah
that should be the ah control
fine so ah
let me
stop here
this is about sensitization and
related to
intergranular corrosion and we have also
seen that inter granular corrosion
happens in case of aluminium alloys also
we have given one example of aluminum
eight zero nine zero alloy
now before i end i just would like to
indicate that
sometimes it will be very difficult to
find that chromium carbide along the
grain boundary even with the help of a
very high high resolution acm it will be
very difficult but
recently we have found out a smart way
of
understanding whether the chromium
carbide forms along the grain boundary
and that leads to stabilization that
leads to sensitization so this is the
work we have recently done
at iit kanpur so what happens this is a
three zero four stainless steel and we
have heated to this temperature and
twenty four hours because of that that
material got sensitized and this is the
ah
sensitization curve means the depth of
ah attack along the grain boundary and
this is the micrograph what we did we
took optical ah profileometry the
optical profileometry also gives you the
undulation on the surface and
interestingly if you notice that
wherever it passes through the grain
boundary so these are the portion where
it passes through the grain boundary
this is the portion you will see that
this is the zone where
ah grain boundary that line is passing
through the the line of measurement of
the optical profileometry is passing
through the grain boundary and then that
leads to you see ah
in the grain boundary region its there
is a sharp dip the sharp tip means that
particular portion has got attacked very
aggressively even if you consider this
particular portion so this is particular
portion where is this is lying here
ok so that portion is actually
gone very deep and if you see
that
up to 24 hours the material was heated
to 600 degree celsius and it is simple
three zero four and you see that the as
you heat it and as you measure this
particular depth profile along the grain
boundary the grain boundary
the depth is gradually the local attack
is gradually increasing
and
this indicates that the material is
sensitized and this happens because of
the chromium carbide precipitation so
this is one
indirect way of proving that the
material is getting sensitized
and that is actually due to chromium
carbide precipitation along the grain
boundary so let me stop here with this
particular ah
explanation and now you see this paper
you can go through this is the reference
of that particular paper where this data
is there so you can learn more from this
particular paper so let me stop now ah
will continue our discussion in the next
lecture onward we will talk about
crevice corrosion thank you
[Music]
do
[Music]
you
