Lecture 22 : Intergranular Corrosion: Control of Sensitization - Weld Decay

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 4, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
lets start lecture 22
for the course ah
corrosion failures and analysis
we have been talking about inter
granular corrosion and we talked about
oil decay ok which is the problem that
is experienced in case of
three zero four stainless steel welding
and that time we saw that weld decay or
the sensitized zone forms little away
from the weld zone
in the base metal where the temperature
profile
keeps the metal
during cooling stage within the
temperature within that magic
temperature zone which is 500 to 5 850
degree celsius where precipitation of
carbide can take place along the grain
boundary leading to
chromium depleted zone and subsequent
sensitization
now
so this is
courses corrosion
failures
analysis
lecture
22
and topic
ah inter granular
inter granular corrosion fine so we
talked about weld decay
old k
which happens if we see this
this part and this part
ok
now you have
this is the weld part
which is going
little
inside the
base metal
and then little away from
the weld part
we have a zone narrow zone
which has chromium carbide
precipitation
fine so this kind of precipitation
happens
ok
so that is what it becomes and this
precipitation happens along the grain
boundary
along the grain boundary and leading to
sensitization
and in fact
if you have this kind of situation and
if you dip it in
fuming nitric acid or
boiling nitric acid so you will see that
that zone will get corroded and heavily
and there could be a possibility that if
it is a thin sheet
there could be possibility that it can
leak through that
now question is we know that why it
happens because it is a chromium carbide
precipitation so now we have to see that
how we can stop it
so that
brings into the
part which is control
of
sensitization
ok
now as we have explained in the last
lecture
that
three factors are important one is
temperature
second is time
third is carbon content
ok
now that means
this is 500 to
850 degree celsius
by any means
if you do not take the metal to this
temperature range and hold it
so no holding
this is one part
not taking
the steel
to this temperature and no holding so no
problem
when that no problem starts because if
you
make the alloy take it to a high
temperature let us say around twelve
hundred and thirteen hundred degree
celsius where chromium carbide dissolves
because we know that around thousand
fifty degree celsius chromium carbide
dissolves so once it dissolves and
homogenized then you quench it to the
room temperature it will not have any
time for the precipitation to happen
because the time of retention during
cooling
in this temperature range will be very
very small which will be less than the
time required for precipitation
no problem fine
but interestingly
sometimes
you have that
that particular steel which is stainless
sometimes you have to take it to high
temperature now one possibility is
welding ok so welding you have to do
welding because when you have make a
component you have to sometimes instead
of instead of using fastener you have to
weld it so that time you have to take it
there
so when you take it there within the
temperature zone you have to make sure
the time of retention should be less
time
spent there
in this temperature range
should be as small
as possible
as small as possible fine so then of
course
you are not having any problem ok
even if you do welding so how you can do
that for example you have to use some
welding process
so it leads to the
welding process
which
allows
lesser time
for welding
welding
one is lesser time second is
for example
if you
somehow do a multiple
welding for example one layer of welding
then second layer of welding so that
multiple welding pass if you do
so then of course it will spend more
time so then also there is a possibility
so lesser time
less
lesser number of
multiple
passing
pass
so then of course there is a possibility
that the time spent in that temperature
zone will be less so you can avoid that
so which are the holding processes if
you do gas welding its a problem
because the gas welding takes long time
for heating and their heat intensity of
the gas welding process is less compared
to the arc welding arc welding heat
tension intensity is very high so that
it melts quickly and quickly it joins so
that you do not have to hold that
weld ah that particular torch longer
in that weld pull gene region
so you can take it out quickly
so that heat dissipates quickly and does
not have time
for retention
within the temperature zone even if
there is a heating and then cooling
process the cooling would be faster if
the heat intensity is very high less
time spent for the welding cooling would
be faster okay so that time you do not
have that problem so that is what
we always use arc welding
r welding fine
but now this arc welding could be quick
and less number of pass if it is a thin
section to be welded but if it is a
thicker section then you cannot avoid
doing multiple passes
ok so that time you have experience you
would
experience
this precipitation of carbide again so
thinner section this is fine so thinner
section
section
less number of
passes
but thicker section
you have to use more number of passes
that time the steel can be subjected to
weld decay or sensitization around that
zone of zone away from the
whirlpool so when we have such situation
how to prevent that
so now we have to get to the third
factor which is carbon content fine
now the carbon content
if we see the the the diagram related to
time temperature sensitization diagram
simatically we can have a diagram like
this
this is you can also people have
actually studied it quite substantially
and then they have seen that this is
temperature
and this is time
fine
and now just like a ttt diagram you know
time temperature transformation diagram
so that diagram looks like a c curve ok
so similarly you can also have
time temperature sensitization diagram
which actually has a direct relation to
that temperature zone and chromium
carbide precipitation
as we have said in the previous lecture
the carbon is a factor chromium we have
to keep fixed 18 to 20 percent
so carbon if you increase or if you
decrease there would be change in this
kind of time temperature sensitization
diagram which is similar to
ttd diagram so now if the carbon content
is high
so the graph
shifts upward
and
moves to the left
let us say this is zero point zero eight
percent carbon
if it is
zero point zero six
it goes to the right
and drops down
ok
if you go to this is 0.06
if you go to 0.04
then it again shifts to the right
and then
moves down
ok so then again you can go to 0.03
it drops down
and go to the right so like that way the
diagram shifts to the this is 0.03
if you further down then it will also
go to the
left so the right and this peak point
or the nose point we call it nose point
of a ttd diagram that also that is the
minimum time
for the transformation into a
sensitization mode so this particular
temperature range also let us say this
is around 900 degree celsius
900 degree celsius and let us say here
it ends around close to 500 degree
celsius fine so in that particular
temperature range we have to see that
when cooling
ok its not a problem during heating
unless unless unknown unless until you
see the point c in the if you go to the
previous lecture you will find that the
point c where we put thermocouple
that one during heating as well as
during cooling during heating it does
not reach beyond 600 degree celsius
and during cooling it also comes back
and that means the time of retention
within that 550 500 to 850 degree
celsius is quite quite lengthy ok so in
that case of c is the is that problem
but during heating if the temperature
goes beyond
ah 850 degree celsius rather beyond ah
thousand fifty degree celsius chromium
carbide even if it precipitates it will
dissolve ok so the during heating is not
an issue ok but during cooling its an
issue because during cooling depend on
the cooling rate if the cooling rate is
slow then of course the time of
retention would increase during in that
particular temperature round now
question is
if you see 0.08 percent carbon
the time where the nose point is
actually very close to the
has having a very less time so this is
in log scale
log scale so this could be a very small
time maybe couple of seconds
now as we go
right down right towards right since it
is in log scale even if there is a small
change in the
in the in the small change in that
particular length in the log scale there
will be huge change in the time because
the time would increase
that nose temperature that is the
minimum time required for that
sensitization
now here
as you see 0.06 still it has a chance of
getting sensitized because the time
minimum time is sufficiently
small
now
here as we go to 0.04 the time is
actually going further further towards
the right side so that means the time
required you have to spend this much
time
this much time for the precipitation to
happen in case of 0.06 this much time
you have to spend considering the
minimum point zone and here also this
much time but here if you see this is
the time and this is the time ok so that
much as you decrease the carbon lets say
this is 0.02
as you decrease the carbon content
the entire sensitization ttt curve is
actually shifting towards rice though it
is also going down if it goes down that
means the diffusivity as we decrease the
temperature diffusivity also decreases
or the diffusion coefficient is also
actually increases in diffusion
coefficient actually ah
also decreases ok so that decrease
does not allow that chromium carbide to
precipitate out
ok as you increase the temperature
diffusivity increases as well as
diffusion coefficient also would
increase so that allow easy diffusion
and easy formation of chromium carbide
that is what this nose point is shifting
towards left
ok but at the same time if you increase
carbon that means carbon activity you
are increasing and that carbon activity
increase in carbon activity allows
chromium carbide to precipitate out fine
so thats what it is also
as the carbon content is increasing it
is going up because the diffusivity
increases and it also goes down goes
goes to the left that means the time
required for chromium carbide
precipitation is less so that allows
easy precipitation
but as you decrease them decrease carbon
content precipitation of chromium
carbide becomes difficult because
diffusivity is less because it has
dropped down in the temperature axis at
the same time it has go to the right
side in the time axis the time required
for the chromium carbide precipitation
would be very very large so that means
if it is very large and during cooling
if that time you are not permitting then
it will never have any
precipitation to take place now in that
regard i have taken something from the
literature so if you see this ppt
so ah the way i
told you that
as the temperature as the carbon content
increases in the steel
the sensitization gtd diagram shifts to
the left and moves up
and as the carbon content decreases it
goes to the right
and moves down the similarities so that
time i showed it by simatically but here
it is
some data set and it is taking from this
ok and remember this particular link is
used
just for
teaching purpose its not for any
publication or anything so this is for
teaching just to let people know that
what happens
now
if you see that this point
this
nose point is actually shifting towards
the right
shifting towards right and for example
when you go to 0.03
if you see the minimum time
minimum time it will be of the order of
let us say 6 to 7 hours
ok
now if you go down to
0.019
almost about 0.02 the time minimum time
will be
around
100 hours
100 hours so this is in the 500 range
and this is around 850 range
850 degree celsius
now
point is in that when the carbon content
is so low and if you cool it
you even if you cool it
very very slow you cannot wait for the
hundred hours to have take place or the
spend in that temperature zone because
when you weld your maximum time you can
take maybe 10 minutes or 20 minutes my
maximum because let it let it cool down
cool so completely maximum 10 minutes
so that means within that 10 minutes
time it will never reach that particular
point so it will not have any sort of
precipitation of carbides so that that
makes that particular steel
resistant to sensitization so that is
what even if you consider 0.03 the time
required would be around 6 to 7 hours so
still it is very long time for
precipitation so no problem of
sensitization so that means coming back
to what we are talking so this is the
schematic what i had drawn now that
senses that that gives a sense that if
you can reduce carbon content
sensitization can be controlled so that
is what
the
one possibility is
decrease
carbon content
ok so
so that is what some of the grades like
304 l comes up so there the carbon
content is 0.03 around that level
so the time for precipitation to happen
would be so long
and the time
during cooling would be so slow so so
low
within that temperature range 500 to 5
850 degree celsius there will be no
problem of sensitization okay so that is
what the low carbon is one possibility
now coming back to this
let us say
you have
carbon content 0.08 percent
ok
so that means there is a possibility of
sensitization because the nose
is
coming very close few couple of seconds
so you cannot prevent sensitization
during cooling
if it is sufficiently ah
slow cooling okay so now let us say its
sensitized then how would you prevent it
let us say well decay has happened how
do you prevent it so the one possibility
is
the entire world portion or the entire
object
can be taken to or we can say sensitized
object
can be
taken to
around 1100 or 1100 degree celsius
temperature
and then quench
it will prevent
it will prevent
oil decay
or sensitization
why because beyond
1050 degree celsius around
chromium
c sex dissolves
and if you spend some time over there it
homogenized
and then
no
precipitate
along the
grain boundary
so
sensitization is avoided so now whatever
control i have
with reference to
carbon content temperature time
now there is one more way
ok
and of course there is one see this is
this is ah temperature time temperature
control is you do not take it to that
temperature and even if you take it to
the temperature you do not allow
sufficient time to hold
these are the two conditions time you do
not spend time so you use some welding
mechanisms welding methods which will
have which will be very quick to weld
and
the heat spend that the heat dissipation
would be very fast so no problem in that
because the time retention in the
temperature change which is
sensitization temperature zone would be
very small to have any precipitation of
carbides and then another process which
is carbon content and the the process
what we have said that
this process what we have said that
taking to higher temperature and then
homogenized and bringing back so this is
called
solutionization
heat treatment
so solutionization heat treatment is
similar like in case of age hardening
alloy what you do we take it to a single
phase zone which is alpha zone in case
of aluminium copper system take it to
alpha solutionize it that means
homogenize and take all the precipitates
into the melt so it becomes single phase
and then quench it when you quench no
precipitate forms in the edge hardening
alloy and after that if you hold it at a
little higher temperature then
precipitate comes back again ok because
that time it becomes super saturated but
here its not about super saturation here
its about
allowing those chromium carbides to get
homogenized so that entire steel becomes
free of sensitization fine so this
particular process is that so there is
one more process to control
sensitization
is basically called alloying
fine so this alloying
let us say
we have chromium carbide precipitation
reacts and then form
c6 why chromium carbide forms there are
iron also the iron carbide can also form
because iron carbide we know that fe3c
forms which is a cementite
so that means it forms y because iron
and carbon they have affinity
which allows iron f e three c to form
now we have
iron we have nickel we have chromium all
those elements are present in the three
zero four stainless steel
stainless steel so there could be
possibility of chromium as well as iron
carbide but question is who has the
higher affinity to carbon the chromium
has got
higher
affinity to carbon so that is what
chromium carbide comes out
now
let us say
i have another element which is either
niobium or titanium
if we add them in a small amount so this
is maximum one percent and all this is
also around zero point seven percent
seven to zero point eight percent if we
add
then
this two elements have got a huge
affinity to carbon
and if we compare affinity to carbon
between niobium and chromium or titanium
and chromium titanium has
higher
affinity
to
carbon
more
than
chromium
so now
if we have carbon
and if we have
titanium if we have chromium
this will try to join together this will
not because this has higher affinity
so the titanium carbide would come out
now question is
for the chromium carbide to form you
need a critical amount of
critical amount of
carbon
as we have seen that as the carbon
content decreases chromium carbide
formation becomes more and more
difficult because the time
knows time in that time temperature
sensitization diagram goes to the
extreme right
so the time taken would be very very
large
so now its not the problem in case of
low carbon steel
its about the problem in the high carbon
steel where the carbon content is zero
point zero eight percent
let's say around zero point zero eight
to zero point zero seven percent
so that time
it crosses that critical carbon content
so that's what chromium carbide forms
now
if we add titanium
ok if you add titanium into it
so it will curve collect carbon and it
will precipitate out as a titanium
carbide
titanium
carbide in this form it will precipitate
out so what would
what would it what it would do
so chromium atom let us say you have a
collection of chromium atom
fine so you need carbon
to react
with the chromium
now by the time you have taken titanium
around that carbon so it reacts and
joins that carbon so it does not allow
that carbon to go to chromium
okay and by the way the chromium by that
way the chromium the carbon critical
carbon content around chromium atom will
reduce drastically and that reduction
would allow that particular carbon
requirement
very low and that will also allow the
ttd diagram or basically the time
temperature sensitization diagram to to
shift to the right
ok so that means what it happens it
actually
makes the steel
so
resistant to sensitization because of
the addition of titanium or nibbium so
the effect of niobium would be same as
titanium what i have explained ok
in the steel where carbon content is
very high ok in that standard steel so
that means
this particular process of making the
steel resistance to sensitization we
call it stabilization
stabilization ok so the stabilization is
basically adding
strong carbide former
like
nibbium or titanium which will take care
of the carbon and does not allow any
carbon availability for the formation of
chromium carbide now question is the
chromium gives you the stainless
property so if you do not allow chromium
carbide to precipitate out there will be
no question of chromium chromium
depletion zone and so the entire matrix
we have homogenized chromium contain
more than
12 percent and rather it will be
homogenized like 18 percent in the base
metal so it will passivate uniformly all
over and then it will give you the
stainless property all over the surface
ok so this process is called
stabilization and this process is
applied even in case of high carbon
steel
ok
0.08 or zero point zero seven percent so
this is another route by which we can
control strength sensitization in case
of stainless steel and that is what
whenever we add those elements so we
have some grades so those grades are
actually ah like niobium containing
grades
are three four seven stainless steel
titanium containing grades are
three to one ok so these this one
contain around maximum one percent
niobium
and this one contains around 0.07
percent titanium okay so that makes the
steel
devoid of any sensitization fine so let
me stop here in the next class we will
end our discussion on intergranular
corrosion by taking one example which is
called knife line attack
which happens in case of stabilized
steel okay so that means the steel which
has been stabilized by adding that
costly niobium and titanium which will
tackle carbon which will take care of
carbon and
does not allow that chromium carbide to
form
it happens in that particular steel
during welding itself ok and the crack
happens
a very sharp crack happens and that
sharp nature of the crack
that because of the appearance it is
called knife line attack
so we will analyze that particular
problem and then
we will stop our discussion on
intergranular corrosion and then take
two will start discussing gravies as
well as beating corrosion so till then
lets stop here we will
take it up in a in our next lecture
thank you
[Music]
[Music]
you
