Did you miss the latest Ramsey Show episode? Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered! Get all the highlights you missed plus some of the best moments from the show. Watch entertaining calls, Dave Rants, guest interviews, and more!
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
We're going to Courtney who's joining us in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Courtney, how can we help?
Hey, thank you for taking my call.
You bet.
So, we just completed a very significant home repair, very unexpected, for about $270,000.
Oh my gosh.
What are you doing?
Hold the phone.
What was this?
You took the phone and you rebuilt it?
We were actually victims of fraud.
Oh no.
There was significant water damage, termite damage, a lot of issues that were hidden.
Oh, so they sold you a house that was just a disaster and you didn't know it.
Is that what I'm hearing?
Yes.
Oh my gosh.
But $270,000, did you just gut this thing down to the studs and start over?
Basically.
Yes.
Oh, bless your heart.
Oh my gosh.
And you have no recourse here?
We actually do.
We are pursuing that path, but we are of the mindset that we are in control of our destiny.
And so, we want to consider any levers that we can pull to accelerate getting out of this
mess.
We were lucky to be able to cash flow about $150,000 of it, but we had to take out some
loans, a 401k loan and a home equity loan to just get through it.
So my question is, should we sell the house and be able to accelerate this mess by probably
a year, year and a half?
So what is your total consumer debt?
Put the home equity loan aside, the 401k loan aside, do you have any other consumer debt?
We do.
We did, stupid, and went to buy two cars before all of this, before knowing anything about
the house.
So we have a student loan for $9,000 and then two cars for $45,000.
So a total of about $54,000 in consumer debt in addition to the 401k loan and the home
equity.
Okay.
And what is remaining on the 401k loan and the home equity loan?
$12,000 on the 401k loan and $97,000 on the HELOC.
Is that on top of your mortgage?
Yes.
Oh dear Lord.
Okay.
What's left on the mortgage?
$350,000.
And what's your household income?
It's about $200,000.
Okay.
Good.
We've got a good shovel to work with here, but goodness gracious, we've got a pile of
debt.
So what could this house sell for now that you fixed it up?
I imagine you did not ROI in the lease bid on this.
We did not.
We weren't even considering selling it at that time, but we met with our realtor and
he thinks we can get $600,000 for it.
Okay.
So you sell it for $600,000, you get rid of the 401k loan, the home equity loan, the mortgage.
You'd get rid of all of your debt completely and still have a little bit left over to start
with.
Correct?
Yes.
Okay.
I mean, here's the thing, selling a home is a last ditch effort for me, but this feels
like one of those situations where I go, you guys aren't going to be able to breathe
at night.
And I imagine the emotional turmoil you've experienced just rebuilding this place, it's
kind of given you the ick.
It is, especially my husband.
I think there's more, the mathematics make sense behind it.
I think we're just dealing with the emotional side of should we sell it and just move on.
Does he resent the house?
Because I resent this house and I've only known about it for four minutes.
He very much resents this house.
And I almost always agree with George, and that's going to swell his head.
I disagree that this is last ditch in this situation.
I think this is option A. I would sell the house.
Oh, I see what you're saying.
Clean slate.
Yeah.
It's been a massive pain in their rear.
It's just nightmarish, as you say, to try to dig out of this.
They can.
But why not just get free and clear of it all?
If you got a rent for a year, you got an income where you could get up a nice down payment,
you go into it fresh and you go, we learned a lot.
This is one of those, sometimes you win, sometimes you learn.
And they don't lose if they sell and they get out.
And they're so much more educated, but they're free of all of this.
I don't know, George.
The hardest part is going to be freeing yourselves of the guilt, the shame, the stupid tax, the
sunk cost fallacy.
All of that is going to be the hardest part.
The numbers we can deal with.
You guys have a great income.
You can clear your debt and still walk away with probably, what, 50 grand?
I would do it tonight.
And then we'll restart.
I'd have a sign in the yard within five minutes of this phone call if it were me.
This is a no brainer.
Is that where you all were leaning before you called?
Yes, because the home can no longer give us what we want.
We bought it before having kids and now we have a daughter and the location just isn't...
There's not a lot of younger families in our area, so it's great for what it is, but it...
This is one of many reasons.
Yeah, there's extra reasons.
Courtney, for the benefit of the audience, can you explain how this fraud happened?
Did you not get an inspection?
How did you get swindled here?
We did have an inspection.
It was a result of flippers coming in and flipping the property.
They had done some work on it, but we later found out that they did not do honest work
on it and really tried to spend as little as possible to just make sure it didn't fall
down before the sale.
But the inspector caught nothing.
The inspector was like, this house is in tip-top shape.
Go for it.
Yes.
The inspector needs to be sued at this point.
That's insane.
Have you gotten back in touch with the inspector and said, here's what we had to do?
We have, yes.
What did they have to say about it?
They've pretty much thrown their hands in the air and said that they're not liable.
Is it stuff that they couldn't see in the general inspection, meaning behind drywall?
Yeah.
So you discovered it only when you started doing some renovations?
Yeah, pulling back the siding and realizing what was underneath it.
Okay.
Not to defend the inspector, but Stacey and I had this happen in the home we're in now.
George, you've been there.
Yeah.
In the front room, we were putting shelves in and so we saw some mold on the drywall
underneath some trim.
So not everything can be seen like that.
So again, not trying to defend the inspector, but sometimes that can happen.
There was a leak where rainwater was getting in a small crevice in an area of brick up
against the house.
Anyway, the point is that can happen.
I'm so sorry, Courtney.
But hey, listen, I'm glad that they can get out of it.
So thanks for the call.