Massive Fraudulent Enrollments in California Community Colleges: What's Happening?

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
47 Video Views·Aug 30, 2025
California’s community colleges are contending with widespread enrollment fraud that has prevented real students from getting the classes they need and disrupted campus operations.
More than 1.2 million fraudulent applications were filed in a single year, affecting about 80 percent of campuses across the state.
The problem, first seen during the shift to online learning, has persisted despite efforts to contain it. In this episode, Dr. Jeannie Kim, president of Santiago Canyon College, and Marvin Martinez, chancellor of the Rancho Santiago Community College District, explain how campuses are responding and the steps now underway to safeguard access for genuine students.
1.2 million fake applicants applied last year to community colleges in California.
And right now there are a number of fake students out there in our community college system
to the point where kids cannot take their classes because these fake students are taking their spots.
Our guests today are Marvin Martinez and Jeannie Kim who are community college leaders.
They're here to tell us what they found in their campus and how these fake students are
What's made this situation of fraudulent enrollment so different than anything
that I've seen before in my 36 years in higher ed is that it's happened on a massive scale.
It's happened in almost 80% now of the campuses. That means 90 colleges at least
have these issues in these situations.
I'm Simeon Karami. Welcome to California Insider.
Marvin, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you. Thank you so much.
And Jeannie, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you.
We want to talk to you about a phenomenon that's happening in California right now.
About 1.2 million fake students applied last year to community colleges.
This is almost 30% of new students that are applying.
What's happening?
Having fraudulent enrollments is again, it's nothing new. It's been going on for a long time.
What made it catapulted and what was the springboard to a lot more was really when COVID happened.
So when COVID happened, community colleges, not just our district,
but many other districts throughout the whole state,
I would say about 80% of our courses were face-to-face, just like we are right now.
And maybe 10, 20% were online. And in some campuses, it was 10% or less.
That was before COVID.
After COVID, we began to experiment with Zoom.
So the number in many ways shifted where 80% of our courses were now online,
as opposed to being face-to-face and 20% or less were face-to-face.
So the world in many ways in education changed completely over a span of three to four years.
So what that change created is that if you have students who are online,
they could take the class from anywhere from where they live.
We have students who are taking our classes throughout the whole state,
Eureka, Fresno, Sacramento, as well as this local area.
We have students taking our classes from other states.
And because of the quick change, no one was really prepared
for these fraudulent actors to just triple in size.
Because if you look at the numbers prior to COVID, it was basically zero.
You know, we didn't really have...
Because you would see the students face-to-face before you...
Exactly. It was the old school, right?
Old way where you come to the class and you ask, you know,
can you, are you present? And you say, you raise your hand.
And yes, I'm here.
That was the way that it basically was done.
But that changed.
So we no longer do that in that manner really at all.
At Santiago Canyon, we saw the shift in the fall 2024 enrollments.
So we knew that there were fraudulent actors that were in the system.
And as the chancellor mentioned, it has been around for a long period of time.
So by fall of 2024, we'd already endured it for over four years, right?
And in fall, what we started to notice is that we had great enrollment growths.
More students had come in.
So our increase in headcount was up.
Our FTES, our accounting for how we account for the students in the classrooms.
All of our enrollments were up.
And we were excited. We were celebrating, right?
Everybody was absolutely thrilled.
We were up 10, 12, 13%.
And as those numbers went up, we became even more elated.
Then the first week of classes come in.
And the faculty members get into those classes.
And they see that these are not real students.
They have questions.
They're wondering why are they not behaving the way that a student is supposed to behave
in terms of these online classes, right?
And so they discovered that a lot of these students were just fake.
They had said that they were students.
They'd enrolled in the class, et cetera, down the line.
Some didn't actually show up.
Others of them did show up,
but they didn't necessarily complete work in the first week of class.
And so we started to, you know, the faculty members started to filter out these students.
So where we were at a high of 10 to 12%, 13%, we went in the opposite direction
because our faculty had this reaction to all of these fraudulent actors that were there
and saying, these aren't real students.
I need to kick them out because that was their responsibility at that point
because the classes had started.
So they started dropping all of these students, right?
We thought were students, but they were fraudulent actors.
There were some real students that were caught in that mix,
which was part of the reason why we had to put in other measures.
You know, it was hard for the faculty members
to really determine who was real and who wasn't real, right?
They're just going based on their gut instincts
and whether or not they were turning in enrollments, et cetera, or homework, et cetera.
So two weeks go by and our census is completed.
And by that point, we're in the opposite direction by another, by negative 10%.
So we went, we basically lost 20 to 23% of the enrollment within a two week timeframe.
So everything that was up went down in the opposite direction.
And that equated to somewhere between 10 to 12,000 enrollments.
And there was a smaller head count that's associated with that
because what we found are the bad actors were in multiple classes.
So each enrollment could have been, you know, five enrollments per one bad actor.
So they were just filling up space.
And the problem with this was that they were taking up space that students needed,
real students needed in order to graduate, to be able to complete their degree,
to complete their certificate.
And that's what really called us to action, right?
And so our team went into action and said, they started investigating.
And sure enough, we figured out who was fraudulent, who was real.
But at that point, we were very limited in our resources.
So then we went out to look for an AI resource that happened to fall into our lap.
Literally, I was at a conference, heard the speaker at,
because they were deploying it at two of the colleges up north.
And they were about to start a third and a fourth college.
And we signed on.
I literally walked up to the CEO and said, I need your product.
This is how much money I have.
Shake on it.
And I need you here next week.
And that's how it happened.
No fashion way.
At the end of the day, it's about shaking someone's hand and getting that going.
How did your teachers find out that these students are fake?
They weren't behaving like actual students.
They weren't behaving like real students.
So there was similar kinds of assignments being turned in.
There was no response, or it seemed like a fake response.
So our faculty are experienced faculty.
They've been teaching for long periods of time, whether they're adjunct or full-time.
And they know that when a student, the student behavior patterns, right?
Because this is their craft.
And they were noticing that there was an aberration in that behavior pattern of
engagement or interaction, or complete non-engagement whatsoever.
So the student was there, but they weren't responding to anything.
They weren't turning in the homework, et cetera.
And if they didn't turn in the homework within those first two weeks,
then they were dropped.
Because why would they be there and not complete homework?
And why are they taking up space that they shouldn't be in, in the first place?
So our faculty really went into action and cleaned their rosters
to a point where it impacted our enrollment with a 20, 23% decrease, right?
And so the faculty then came back to us and said, we need help.
And where we heard the additional cry was from our counseling faculty.
Because in those first two weeks, what's happening is that students
are looking for classes to enter into.
And our counseling faculty couldn't find classes for our students to actually enroll in
because they were all being taken up by these bots.
And our students who were going through it by themselves also couldn't find classes.
And so they were coming in, trying to schedule more counseling sessions
to figure out if they can get a class.
And the counselor was like, I don't have anything for you
because this class is completely full.
They make a phone call over to our director of A&R or dean of A&R.
And is this really true?
Is this class really full?
They start an investigation process and they find out, you know what?
No, these are bots.
You can actually enroll that student.
But they can't enroll because the technology component
doesn't let you over enroll that class, right?
And they had started in the bot arena.
They started figuring out how to get on our waitlist.
So they weren't just in the classroom.
They filled up our waitlist.
And in one situation with our anthropology faculty,
the dean and that faculty member actually sat down together
and they lifted the cap, the course cap by 30 every day to see what would happen.
Because there's no way historically that they're going to fill immediately
because it's never happened before, not in the 25 years of our institutional history.
So they started increasing it.
And every day, the second they opened it, the next hour, it was 100% filled to capacity.
They went all the way up to a 90 or 120.
And they were like, these are not real students.
And so they closed it all down, figured out which ones were real students.
And it turned out that there were only 12 to 15 real students in that class,
even though it was filling at that rate.
So yeah, it's been hard.
I was going to say that, you know, even though I do remember, of course,
when Dr. Kim had to cut all that enrollment, and that's devastating.
Because, you know, the way that we are compensated
in order to pay for all the bills is through enrollments.
So when you cut 20, 23% from your enrollment base,
that's a lot of money that you're losing.
So on the one hand, it was devastating.
On the other hand, it was okay in a sense that you can't get paid for fake enrollments.
So it's better to make that cut up front than at the end.
Than find out a year later.
Exactly.
But I do remember, of course, when all that discussion was,
even though I think we talked about that, it still makes you feel bad.
But I think, you know, in many ways, you know,
the actions that were taken by Dr. Kim and the campus to just deal with it now,
let's take out that enrollment, I think was a good move.
Because otherwise, you know, either you're going to pay up front or pay in the end.
So, you know, they chose to pay up front,
get it done and not, you know, get themselves compensated for fake enrollments.
Because the state will compensate the school based on the enrollment.
Exactly.
What do they want, these fake students, fake bots, what do they get?
Is it the financial aid dollars?
Good question.
You know, we still haven't defined specifically what they want.
We anticipate that what they want is a number of things.
One is, sure, they want to tap into financial aid, into the Pell Grants.
That's no doubt, I think, a motivation.
Another motivation is to basically tap into the information of that student.
Maybe get access to the social security number,
maybe get access to the information that they could use for any other type of criminal activity.
So we don't know specifically what they want, but we do know that they obviously want information.
And possibly they can tap into the Pell Grants.
They could, you know, they want those dollars that are there.
The problem, though, is because we don't know exactly who is doing this.
We're not seeing real action yet from the federal government, you know,
from the Department of Justice or the state attorney general's office.
They're pursuing anything legal because I don't think they found who they want to go after.
Our understanding is they don't even live in this country.
They could be working from other countries around the world.
So how do you pursue them?
How do you go after them?
I actually attended community college for a couple of years.
And when I attended for the tuition, you had to pay a small amount when you're from the state.
Do these fake students pay for the classes?
So when the COVID situation happened,
we had opportunity to be able to suspend that tuition aspect of it.
And so we've been able to roll that in slowly.
And then as that also started to take shape,
we also started to bring in programs like College Promise,
which actually then covered the tuition for the students, etc.
So between a number of those different factors,
all of the systems for that tuition payment haven't all been put into play.
At least for us, we have not fully put that into play.
And as a result, we need to close that door.
And so the plan right now is to close that door completely starting in the spring of 2026.
And so because our students over this time period
have been accustomed to not having to be chased down for the payment.
So majority of our students pay.
So let me not make people alarmed in the sense that our students are not paying.
Our students are paying.
There are some that do have a hardship, etc., down the line.
And they're putting in reasons for why they can't, etc., all of those different pieces.
So there is a broad base of reasons why students may not pay right by that due date.
So when that is happening, we do start to drop the individuals.
And what we're trying to do is to make sure that they are real students.
And if they have real issues that we need to help mitigate
to ensure that they continue with their education.
Or if they're fraudulent, then yes, of course,
we close that door and slam it shut as hard as we possibly can.
So it's been that balance, you know, over since COVID times.
And so I do think that we have to get stronger in that arena.
But that comes with pros and cons, right?
And what I mean by stronger.
Because it would cut off the students that might be struggling.
Exactly.
Now, how do they register?
Do they come with a fake ID, fake identification, fake name,
fake information, and they just get into the system and register?
Yes, that's exactly what they do.
But they have made it so real that our technology has not been able to pick it up.
So we had to be very smart about it.
We had to develop certain types of methods to be able to really investigate it
and begin to see, is it real or not?
I was going to say that, you know,
but also what's made this situation of fraudulent enrollment so different
than anything that I've seen before in my 36 years in higher ed
is that it's happened on a massive scale.
Sometimes it happens on one campus, right?
Remember, there's 116 colleges in the state of California.
So if it happened on one campus too, it's not a big deal.
But it's happened in almost 80% now of the campuses.
That means, you know, 90 colleges at least have these issues in these situations.
However, you know, what usually happens is that
it's usually one or two, three campuses who take the lead
in identifying that technology that will help them.
So no doubt, Dr. Kim, she took action early.
Some will say she took a chance.
I don't think so because the numbers were so high.
She mentioned the number of enrollments were 20% plus.
So she had to take drastic action and to a certain degree,
take a chance and take a risk.
But that risk has paid off because now it started with three or four colleges.
Now you have 83 colleges who are using this technology.
But it just goes to tell you how big this problem is.
And that's what's made it so different.
And it's happened so quickly.
We're talking about over a span of 12 to 18 months or maybe even less.
So that, you know, we're a big state and we're a big higher education system.
We don't react quickly.
And in many ways, you know, we're easy prey for these kind of situations.
But we are reacting, you know.
And now you have, you know, 80 plus colleges of 116
who are beginning to utilize this technology.
But just one last thing.
We know that this technology, you know, will need to keep updating it
and making it better and making it stronger.
You can't rest on your laurels because people out there,
the fraudulent, you know, actors are really good at this stuff.
And they're really good at technology.
So it's going to be part of our everyday lifestyle.
We're going to have to improve this technology all the time.
What was it like to take action for you?
Relief.
You know, at that point, the faculty were just, they were so distraught, right?
Because what was happening was, is that their class sizes
were just eroding in front of their eyes.
They thought that they were going to have classes of 20 plus, 30 plus, 50 plus students.
And it would dwindle down to, you know, the teens.
In some cases, single digits.
So it was really, really devastating for them.
And it was devastating for the students who couldn't get into those classes, right?
So meanwhile, you have some students that couldn't get in,
but then the fake ones that will be in the class that would have to get kicked off.
Yeah.
And so then the faculty members are looking at their classes and their whole,
you know, they teach because they love teaching, right?
They love their discipline and they're doing that work.
And that's their craft.
And they're not really able to do that for the audience that they were going to be
able to do previously.
And so there's that piece of it.
There's an emotionality to it.
But the other part of it was, is that, you know, for everybody,
it was relief to be able to put something in place.
Something that was going to help us catch these individuals,
the bad actors that were causing this level of chaos within our entire system.
And again, what it really came down to for us was,
is that real students were being hurt by this.
Real students were not able to get their courses.
They were not able to get the classes that they needed to graduate.
They weren't getting the classes that they needed for their degrees
and to continue to matriculate.
And that was devastating for us, for the counselors,
especially as they watched the crust-fallen faces of our students.
Like literally we heard story after story on that.
And the students were upset, you know, and they were concerned
because also in the enrollment arenas,
we have a cost factor, right?
So if your class only has six students,
and we're paying for a full faculty member to actually teach that class,
it's not efficient.
Which means that it's costing us more to educate those six students for that class
because it's not at the level of the numbers that it's supposed to be at.
Because we have to balance the budget in some way.
And so students were coming up in the town halls and saying,
are you going to let this class go?
It's only got seven students in it.
If I don't have this class, I don't have a way to graduate next year.
And so we had to make some decisions.
And so we made the decision in the favor of the students.
So we went and let low-enrolled classes move forward
more than we would ever normally do.
And so that was a double whammy in relation to our budget, right?
So to say that there was a sense of relief when we put the solution in,
it's really an understatement in that regard.
And when we really started to see it work,
there was a level of confidence that came back for our faculty members.
They knew they were no longer alone in this.
They weren't having to figure it out for themselves.
They weren't doing it as individuals
because that's what was happening at that moment.
And so for intersession, we applied the AI solution.
And as a result of applying it,
one of our faculty members in art,
it starts with A so they get hit faster.
He was walking across campus
and he walked up to one of our student services folks and said,
oh my gosh, I have a clean roster.
They're all real.
And he was ecstatic.
So it's sad and it's elation all at the same time, right?
Like to think that that's what we're dealing with right now.
It's a little bit of like, okay, here's the reality piece,
but it's a one-two punch all the way through and through.
And so we've been able to carry that forward.
We did it with spring.
We got hit again in summer.
We scrubbed again in summer.
We got hit again for fall.
We scrubbed again for fall.
And we're just constantly doing it.
So we have a practice of when we're dropping,
we call, text and email every single student.
The phone call is really critical.
They have an option to answer that phone, right?
But what's happening is, is that it's going to, you know,
carnicerias, it's going to taquerias,
it's going to Home Depot, businesses that are out of business.
Like, I think some of these bad actors have like,
some, they think it's funny
because these phone numbers are, you know,
just random weird places, right?
And they're local or they're everywhere?
They're all over the place.
And then the other part of it is, is that, you know,
even with all of this, I think to date,
we've actually only got 20 to 25 cases of actual identity theft.
And so we have identified 20 to 25 individuals
whose identities were stolen.
And when we called them up and they're like,
yeah, that's me.
Yeah, that's me.
And that's my information, et cetera.
Who the heck are you?
And why do you have all of that?
And then we have to provide the information
and then send the information to the U.S. Department of Education
and have them then follow up in relation to the identity theft
and put in all the measures.
But we're basically the bearers of bad news
in some of those phone calls
because sometimes it does go to a live and real person
who has no idea that their identity had been stolen.
Is it clear who's behind this and who is benefiting?
No, that's the problem.
It's not clear.
And if it was clear, then obviously,
then you would have the Department of Justice,
you would have the Attorney General's Office
suing somebody or pursuing some type of action.
But we're not seeing that.
And I think we're not seeing that
because no one really knows who is doing this.
And maybe that's not the way to approach it at this point.
You know, I think the way to approach it at this point
is to deal with it locally,
the way that, you know, that Dr. Kim has done it.
Because that also has forced the other colleges
throughout the whole state to also deal with it locally
and not depend on someone to come and bail them out.
But figure it out, work on it,
and try to resolve it locally.
So I think in many ways,
it's been an empowering exercise for everybody
that, look, let's not depend on anybody.
We've got to take care of ourselves.
And I think you're beginning to see that action
duplicated now at 83 colleges
when you started out with 304.
So yeah, so we like where it's going.
But as I said earlier,
you can't rest on your laurels.
These people are good at what they do.
They're going to change and they're going to change it.
They're going to figure out what we're doing
and we're going to have to figure out a better way
to take care of it.
It's going to be part of our everyday life.
And the reason is because we have accepted
online education as a wave of the future.
You know, we've accepted that.
So we have no choice,
but to also deal with everything that comes with it.
What if they use AI
and they're using that probably, right,
to do homework and other things?
Oh yeah, and we've caught some.
So the use of AI in the classroom,
I know it can be debated around, you know,
honesty, academic honesty
and all of those kinds of things.
But it can also be used as a tool, right?
The problem with the bad actors
is that they're using the AI for really bad intentions.
They're having it do its homework.
They're giving the prompt into whatever agent
that they're using.
They're turning out a homework piece
and then they're submitting it as if it's their own.
And that's the worst case that we can possibly have.
Now, the other thing that we found funny though
is that we've had cases
where we identified as a fraudulent enrollment
because they submitted the same homework assignment
to two different faculty members,
but they thought it was two different faculty members
and it turned out it was the same faculty member
and said, no, you can't submit the same homework
to both classes and think
that you're gonna get credit for it.
And so then we figured out that that wasn't a bot, right?
It was a fraudulent actor in the mix.
And so we have, you know,
all of those kinds of situations
and I'm sure so many more
that are going to start to occur.
And as the chancellor mentioned,
we've actually already modified the programming
around the AI agent that's helping us.
The company Light Leap AI and the end-to-end solution,
they have actually now taken in
all of the information throughout the state
for everybody who's participating
in identifying fraudulent enrollments
because prior to the AI solution coming in,
we were doing some things already.
So we had some systems in place
using ID.me and all these other criterion
that we were using.
And so we were trying to do it locally
and just with human intervention.
And with the AI piece of it,
they put all of this information in,
but the beauty of it is,
is that with the end-to-end Light Leap solution,
we're able to actually consume all of the data.
So now with 83 campuses or the 116
that are reporting through various different channels,
we're basically consolidating all of that information.
And what we thought was happening was definitely there.
The same bad actors, same fake IDs
are being used at multiple institutions around the state.
And so we got another list back
of saying these are potentially fraudulent enrollments
or they were identified as fraudulent enrollments
in other parts.
The bad actors.
Correct, correct.
So it's being generated on a constant basis now.
So we're able to do some of this stuff
and that's the normal logical step, right?
But we are putting in other things
that I won't talk about on camera
because we're trying to stay ahead of the game
because the technology is constantly changing.
And as the chancellor mentioned,
we have to stay ahead of it as the best we possibly can.
But again, higher ed doesn't move very quickly
as he mentioned already,
but we are doing our very best
because at the end of the day,
this is about public dollars.
Public dollars that are supporting public institutions
to ensure that our students and our community
are educated for the future of California.
We're here because we want to be the economic engines
of our regions.
We're here because we believe in the mission
and the equality that comes with having knowledge
and skills and being able to have a wage
that gives you a standard of living
where you can live in California.
And that's what these fraudulent actors
are taking away from our students.
And so that's why this mission is so very critical
in terms of addressing it and maintaining the technology
and moving all of this forward
because it's hindering our primary mission.
It's literally keeping real students out of those classes.
It seems like a big headache.
And how much does this cost you guys?
What's the cost of all these tools
and time and energy and systems?
Actually, my handshake deal with the CEO
was not that expensive
because that was all the money that I had at the moment.
It did not approach 100,000, I'll tell you that.
And so I was able to do that handshake deal.
And now that the system has adopted his solution,
that company solution at the system level,
it's actually gotten even a little bit
more affordable for everybody.
So I wanna say, I think it's typically less
than about $75,000 for each institution
to be able to participate.
The cost in the future will eventually come
from us having the staff that's needed,
all the computer science techies,
and we're gonna need to have more.
We're gonna need to ensure
that they are the best at what they do.
But here's the challenge.
If you're good at computer science,
you're not gonna work at community college
because we don't pay well.
You're gonna work somewhere else,
at another technological Tesla,
whoever that may be, and make a lot more.
So we're gonna have to adjust
in order to be able to bring
those type individuals on board.
Yeah, so the impact will be
not so much in the technology,
but in the staff.
And we're gonna need the staff
because when you're a college president,
Dr. Kim has a lot of other things to do.
She doesn't have time to pay,
look at every detail
that relates to fraudulent enrollments.
And that's where the staffing comes in.
Before we move on to the rest of this interview,
let's take a look at some key headlines
in our newspaper, Epoch Times, this week.
What's happening right now in California,
the state is changing its policies
toward oil and gas.
There was a meeting a week ago
in the legislature,
and the governor has asked the legislature
and California Energy Commission
to come up with rules
and change their policies toward oil and gas
so more refineries can stay in California.
There's a new poll in California
with gubernatorial race.
Everybody was wondering,
who's going to take Kamala Harris's votes?
Now this poll is showing that Katie Porter
has gotten about 21% support
and Chad Bianco, who's a Republican,
is the second in place
with 15% of the voters.
We're gonna be watching the gubernatorial race
here in Epoch Times and California Insider.
LA just busted a multi-million dollar ring
of cargo theft,
and cargo theft nationally is up 27% in 2024
compared to 2023.
Some people have complained to us
about the issues in LA with burglaries.
LAPD just busted a group of burglary suspects
that had hit 92 homes,
and it looks like LAPD
is now going after these rings.
This is just a handful of interesting stories
from our California section.
We have many other stories
that cover national issues,
international issues,
China issues,
and we have other sections
like mind and body health.
They have amazing stories.
Make sure to check out our newspaper.
You can click on the link below.
You will get a deal $1 a week
for the first four weeks.
And tell us what you think
of the Epoch Times newspaper.
You mentioned all this started
because you went online.
And is it worth it?
Or do you think things will go back
to more in person?
Yeah, I think it's worth it.
It's worth it because we're providing access.
It's about providing access
to individuals who can't come to the campus,
who want to be enrolled in the program
that maybe only Dr. Kim has on her campus,
but they happen to live in Fresno.
So it gives access.
And so to me, that part is good, you know,
and we have the ability
and technology to do it.
We should.
However, obviously,
I think this has happened so fast
that we had fraudulent actors
who I'm sure saw that
and they took advantage
of our vulnerability.
But now I think every campus
has in essence awakened
and they've gotten smarter about this.
But again, as I keep saying,
the challenge is staying ahead of it,
you know, and sometimes,
you know, because we're such a big system,
we're not very good at it.
We just react, react, react.
And this situation is going to,
we're going to have to be in the offensive
as opposed to just being
on defensive all the time.
It's hard enough for one campus.
Think about it for 616 colleges.
And the largest community college system,
not only in the country, but the world.
It is a massive undertaking,
but that's OK.
We only worry about our campuses.
I think that with online education,
as the chancellor said,
it's about access
and it does provide that.
I think that,
but if you remember back
in the early 2000s,
so I was actually teaching online courses
back in the 2000s.
I was one of the early adopters,
one of the very first
to actually teach online.
And I was doing it as adjunct faculty
at Cal State Fullerton.
The thing was,
was that the technology
that I used back then,
much to my chagrin,
had not changed any
when we were in 2020.
And I was transitioning
another district from face-to-face
into the online environment.
We hadn't made any changes in 20 years
in relation to the technology
and in the ways
that we were doing online education.
It hadn't been given thought
or development,
not to the levels
to which we're currently
using it right now.
So we've only got a five-year history
right now with online education
in reality.
And I would say
maybe even less than that
because we didn't really get it
under our belt
the first time out the gates.
It was really hard.
And faculty actually resisted.
So now, though,
faculty like the online environment
because there are benefits
to it as well.
And so there is this balance
that we're trying to create.
But what we're still seeing is,
is that, you know,
the way that we've taught
the in-person methodology,
we know it works.
We've tried it for literally
hundreds of years
in multiple areas
around the world, right?
Face-to-face works.
The online arena
and online education,
it's truly only been tested
for the past five years.
And again,
not necessarily very well.
There are some institutions
that have really gone full force
and they're doing excellent at it
because that's what their whole
unique proposition was.
And that value proposition
paid out for them,
but they changed
their entire organization around
in order to make that happen.
We haven't, as higher education,
actually done that as a whole.
We're still struggling through
all of these different pieces.
So if you look at
some of the success rates,
et cetera, down the line,
it all depends on the faculty member,
their level of technology adoption,
their knowledge level,
how much are they keeping up?
All of those become factors
in terms of whether or not
these courses are truly
the best for that student
at that moment in time.
So we have all of those kinds
of evaluations
that we still need to do.
But at the same time,
we're not going to walk away
from online education
because of the access aspect of it.
There's too much value in that.
So just one more issue in that,
you know, we used to be
primarily focused
on high school students.
That was our main pipeline of students,
but that's gotten smaller.
So in many ways,
how are we closing that gap
of the students who are,
you know, who are not coming as many,
meaning the high school students?
That gap's being caused
by adult students.
So who's an adult student?
Well, it could be a person
who's 30, 35, 40 years old.
They're probably married.
They have a mortgage.
They have a full-time job.
They have kids.
They're paying bills.
They can't go to school full-time
because they're working,
but they can go to school at home.
They can take the class
on their laptop.
They can, you know,
that's what's also changing today
is the number of adults
has just dramatically increased
in our campuses.
In fact, in both of our campuses,
both Santiago Canyon College
and Santa Ana College,
the number of adult students
has catapulted
non-credit education
to be higher than credit, right?
For the most part,
I remember there were,
like 90% of our enrollments
were students who were
primarily high school students
who were in classes
so they can transfer
and that who was in the classes.
Well, that's begun to change.
And so how do we keep that up?
Well, we're going to need
to make it accessible to an adult
who's working,
who's a parent,
who's paying bills.
They can't go to school full-time.
So that's why I think
it's just here to stay.
If you look at this
from the perspective of Sacramento,
don't need to maybe budget more
and increase the amount of resources
that we're getting
so that we have the resources
to be able to support
our technology needs,
our staffing needs,
so that we can stay ahead of this.
Because if it doesn't happen,
then we're going to be losing money
and we have to go back
to Sacramento anyway.
I think the future of bread
and butter is going to be
how do we deal
with the fraudulent actors?
And they're going to have to rethink
how they want to fund us
and how they want to give us resources.
And that's part of my job
as part of Dr. Kim's job,
to go to Sacramento,
help legislators
understand what we're doing,
help the governor's office
understand what we're doing
so they can really support
the needs that we have.
If you look at the budgets
that they're giving us,
it's the same way
they're giving us money 20 years ago.
Look what's changed in 20 years.
Almost everything.
So again, even the state's
very slow to react.
So I keep saying
that we're easy prey.
We're very easy prey
because we just react
from the statewide
to the local level.
We're just very slow to react.
Thank you for watching
California Insider on YouTube.
If you like our content,
make sure to press the like button
and comment
so that the algorithm
can reach more people.
If you're not a subscriber yet,
make sure to subscribe
to our channel
so that we can update you
with the trends and issues
that are going on in California.
Now let's go back to the interview.
If you wouldn't have caught
these fake students
and you would have just sat there
and not done anything about it,
you probably would have gotten
a lot more money
from the state, right?
Well, if we hadn't acted
and dropped them,
yeah, we would have gotten
a lot more money.
Absolutely.
Like 25%, 22% more, right?
Yeah, if our faculty
hadn't dropped the students
in that first fall term,
absolutely we would have
gotten more money.
But that's not something that,
you know, as public leaders,
we can't step into that space.
We are here to have an ethical
and moral compass
when it comes to dealing
with these kinds of issues
because we are public servants.
We're paid by the public taxpayer.
And so I have a moral
and ethical obligation
to do what is right
and have integrity
in every step that I'm taking,
whether the public sees it or not.
And that's the,
that's how we need to operate.
And I do believe that
that is the heart
of the community college system, right?
Because we do this, again,
because we want to educate
the students, our community,
our working adults
who are our primary population right now.
And we need to have the resources
and the supports that are necessary
to be able to do that.
So one of the things,
since the chancellor mentioned it
and the technology budget
that was cut,
was a common ERP system.
That's an enterprise resource platform.
So the community colleges,
and this is a third rail among CEOs,
so I will caveat this.
But for me
and from my personal perspective
and the way that I look
at the way California operates,
there is power in economies of scale, right?
So if we're all on the same common ERP system,
it makes it a whole lot easier
for us to be able
to catch fraudulent enrollments,
deal with reporting,
provide real-time data,
be more responsive to public inquiries
around our access, our success,
our completion,
whatever the question is
from our state legislators.
But if we don't have that,
we do what we're currently doing.
And again, we're reacting,
we're not responding.
And there's a difference, right?
When we react,
we got to do this right now.
If we're responding,
we're supposed to do that intelligently,
comprehensively, cohesively.
And that's the part
that we need to get to at this point.
So just a couple of things.
Dr. Kim mentioned the responsibility
we have to taxpayer dollars.
So just to take it a step further,
we have a fiduciary responsibility.
Me and Dr. Kim to protect that money
and to make sure that money
has been spent correctly.
And if we know there's fraudulent actors
out there and they're taking advantage,
then we'll be negligent
in terms of the people's money.
So that's why, you know,
having that fiduciary responsibility
is critical to what we do.
Just one last thing coming back
to what is the state's responsibility?
Well, they don't know
what the responsibility is yet.
So it's up to us as administrators
to go to Sacramento,
to go to our local legislators
and help them understand
why it's critical today
because they have so many needs.
You know, there's, you know,
this year, of course,
the big issue that Sacramento
was dealing with, you know,
how do we support
all the victims of the fires
and in Pacific Palisades and Altadena?
And should they receive more response?
Should they receive
more of the resources than us?
Absolutely.
You know, they don't have homes.
They don't have the basic needs.
And we get that.
So but still, you know,
our responsibility is to go to Sacramento
and say, we understand that,
but this is also a major need.
And somehow you need to find a way
where you put resources into this
and not cut it and think
that all of a sudden, magically,
all these issues will be resolved.
Luckily, two or three campuses
took the lead and they took the lead.
And now you have everyone else following.
But if those campuses
are not taking the lead,
like Dr. Kim and her campus,
then we have a huge problem to the huge.
Chancellor Marvin Martinez
and Dr. Jeannie Kim,
President, it's great to have you
on California Insider.
Thank you.
Thank you. Appreciate that.
Let us know what you think about
of the phenomena of fake students
in community colleges in California.
You can always email me
at cmik.californiasider.com or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm CMI Koremi.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.
