AutoRicerca è la rivista (ad accesso aperto) del LAB – Laboratorio di Autoricerca di Base, la cui missione è pubblicare testi (in italiano e inglese) sulla ricerca interiore ed esteriore. Ponendosi al di fuori delle abituali categorie editoriali, AutoRicerca offre ai suoi lettori scritti di valore (articoli, dialoghi, manuali, monografie, racconti…) selezionati personalmente dall’Editore. Questo venticinquesimo numero - tutto in italiano - è interamente dedicato agli avvenimenti pandemici degli ultimi anni.
The 25th volume of self-research, published in 2022, is entirely dedicated to recent pandemic events.
When I wrote the editorial of this volume, an article had just happened to me, published by the Springer magazine Minerva,
entitled Censure e soppressione dell'eterodossia sul Covid-19, tattiche e controtattiche.
This work reminded me that the advent of this infectious disease has given rise to numerous controversies,
where the numerous doctors and scientists who contested the official position of the health and government authorities
were without means censored.
The study highlights the central role played by media organizations and information technology agencies
in suffocating debate on pharmaceutical and non-pharmaceutical measures aimed at combating Covid-19.
In this generalized attempt to silence the voices of dissent,
not only the weapon of censorship was used, but also that of the tactics aimed at damaging the reputation and career
of those doctors and scientists who expressed critical opinions.
And this regardless of their academic or professional stature.
In other words, instead of an open, passionate and intellectually honest discussion,
we witnessed its exact opposite, with decisively negative implications
both on the exercise of medicine and science in general,
and on the promotion and preservation of public health.
This has been the climate that has characterized the emergence and development of the great PAN-madness.
A climate that we all, whether we like it or not, have experienced and suffered to varying degrees,
and that deserves a careful deepening.
However, you will not find in this volume of formal scientific analyses,
but rather informal testimonies of voices out of the choir,
which, through the instrument of social media,
have generously commented on the events in their unfolding,
expressing states of mind, formulating reflections, considerations, provocations,
and, when necessary, playing the siren of alarm.
It is particularly interesting to observe how the gaze of these witnesses has evolved over time,
recording the passage from reasonable prudence to the unacceptable crushing,
in the name of the management of the state of emergency, of numerous fundamental human rights.
An abuse, the latter, which could be carried out through the use of the powerful lever of fear
and the support of emotional hammering that the great media have made themselves available to carry out,
becoming, except for a few exceptions, real propagators of disinformation.
You will understand, I am very critical of what has happened,
and risks happening again if we are not more than careful.
Not only in future health emergencies, but also in emergencies of another nature,
such as ecological and climatic.
For this reason, the traces of thought of those who, with sufficient cognitive autonomy,
have moved away, when necessary, from the dominant monopensiero
that has been spread everywhere,
both externally, on social media and on journalistic headlines,
and internally, that is, in the minds of individuals,
transformed, through a wise use of fear,
into capillary repeaters of the great enchanting litany.
But let's come to the content of this volume.
Five very different authors have contributed to its writing.
The first contribution stands out in the form of the rest of the volume,
since it assumes the appearance of an article, instead of a more colloquial narration.
It is a decisively provocative text written by the artist and researcher Olivier Aubert,
which, with its sharp humor and artistic sense,
touches on the vast theme of the so-called evidence-based policy.
The corresponding expression in English, evidence-based policymaking,
was first used in the United Kingdom in the 1990s,
by Tony Blair's Labour Government,
who made this concept famous through the slogan
What Matters is What Works,
which we can translate into What Counts and What Works.
The idea is to make politics scientific,
that is, to compare political measures
to real medical treatments administered to the socio-economic body.
This leads to the need for such subsidies to be validated by rigorous tests,
just as should happen for pharmacological substances
and other medical treatments before they are authorized and subsidized.
Aubert therefore participates, with this singular writing,
in the great debate on scientific evidence in politics,
from the perspective of his Placebo Party,
a proposal whose primary vocation
is to provoke a process of autonomous and creative thinking
so that nothing is ever taken for granted.
We live in a time when we are at the risk of epistocracy,
which assigns science the role of undisputed leader of political decisions,
with all the risks that this entails.
Especially if we consider that science is a perfectly corruptible human activity,
especially when it goes hand in hand with the big industry,
sometimes without shame,
absorbing power or even becoming part of it,
thus feeding the great political-ideological polarization
that is today de-empowering the functioning of our democracies.
There was a time when scientific articles were written
with the aim of communicating new discoveries
on the functioning of the world and its nature,
the result of a research mainly driven by love for the truth.
Of course, I am idealizing it,
but we can observe that today we have touched, in many cases,
the exact opposite of this ideal,
that is, that of a science married to the ideologies of the moment
and more simply of the god of money
that comes up to the maximum shame of the manufacturing of evidence on measure.
All this, thanks to Covid-19,
has been somehow placed under a powerful magnifying glass
so that everyone could see,
well, at least those who were willing not to turn around and pretend nothing happened.
But let's come to the contribution of the other four authors.
They are a chemistry and food science teacher, Giuseppe Nangioni,
a human rights expert journalist, Sara Chessa,
a theater and gnosis student, Roberto Rini,
and a theoretical physicist that you know well, which is me.
These four people offered their thoughts
through social media and other online platforms,
commenting on some of the events as they happened.
Giuseppe Nangioni's contribution differs from that of the other authors
in an important way.
As a teacher who chose not to bow to the charm of the vaccine obligation,
he lived on his own skin the strongly discriminatory policies
implemented by the Italian government,
which for a long time no longer allowed him to teach.
Roberto Rini, as an independent scholar,
while living in Italy,
was only moderately affected by the various measures.
The same goes for Sara Chessa, who resides in England,
and for me, who lives in Switzerland.
These last two countries have in fact faced the pandemic
in a very different way compared to Italy and France, for example,
with more pragmatism and a sense of measure, one might say.
Giuseppe Nangioni's brief testimony,
which tells us about his personal experience,
gives an important contribution to this volume
as it represents the voice of the professional categories
brutally reached by the orders of Berticide
and by all those who, after being praised for their efforts and courage,
let's think of doctors and members of the health care system,
were then badly ostracized or forced to close their activities.
Coming to Sara Chessa's contribution,
her interventions offer us not only some acute observations
and considerations on the subject of our fundamental rights and freedoms,
but also tell us how the London situation,
and the United Kingdom in general,
has rarely been objectively told by Italian media,
demonstrating how many journalistic heads during the pandemic
have turned into propaganda organs in the service of the truth.
Among other things, I take this opportunity to point out
her recent book published by Castelvecchi on the case of Julian Assange,
which I highly recommend you read.
After Chessa's contribution,
Robert Torini's reflections follow.
You will notice that the tones and accents of his interventions
can vary significantly,
going from ironic to reflective,
from irreverent to analytical,
from caustic to satirical,
remaining, however, always incisive,
generous and intelligently provocative.
In this his liberatory theatricality,
the observation of the real always takes place from a high perspective,
also trying, possibly,
to show what is behind the scenes of the great pyrotechnic show.
In the last part, finally, you will find my posts.
For my obvious professional deformation,
you will see here a more scientific style,
for example in the choice of some of the themes touched,
sometimes also with the help of some formula,
for example in the attempt to explain
how really predictive a diagnostic test is.
Also in my case, you will notice
that my gaze has changed significantly over time.
If the initial lack of information
led me to remain very prudent
in commenting on the various news that emerged
and to accept to a good degree
what was happening, for example, in the very first confinements,
my assessment then gradually changed
until we reached the full realization
that we were witnessing something more similar
to a social experimentation
than an honest attempt to get out of a crisis
with the least possible damage,
constitutional rights included.
This change of perspective,
noticeable in the texts written by all the contributors,
perhaps represents the most relevant aspect of this volume,
as it offers the possibility of observing the evolution of thought
when faced with a complex and stratified situation,
with all the difficulties and often contradictions that this entails.
That said, regardless of the vision and understanding
of those who will go through these pages,
which obviously allow various reading paths,
my wish is that this collection
can be helpful for a more mature and articulated reflection.
For some readers, these pages may appear
perhaps biased or too warm in terms of criticism.
Others, on the other hand, will judge them
as obtusely hostile to progress and conspiracy theories.
Others, I hope the majority,
will see them simply as stimulants
in their function of aid to reflection.
In addition, they certainly want to be
pages of denunciation
towards everything that should never be accepted.
Because, as Albert Einstein wrote,
the world is more threatened by those
who tolerate or encourage evil
than by those who actually commit it.
Expressing one's own thought in a clear, critical and free way,
without hiding behind a finger,
is certainly a way of expressing one's own intolerance
towards evil.
And on this thought I conclude,
wishing you a pleasant reading.
By the way, for those who do not know Autoricerca,
I remind you that the PDF format volume
can be downloaded for free with a simple click.
However, open access to the electronic version
does not exclude the possibility of ordering the paper volume
for those who love the scent and music of paper,
which is also a way to support the magazine's mission.
Thank you.