Macht Annalena Baerbock eigentlich einen guten Job als Bundesaußenministerin? Seit Ende 2021 macht die erste Frau in diesem Amt ihren Job bereits und wurde seitdem vor einige Herausforderungen gestellt. Sie selbst stellt vor allem die feministische Außenpolitik in den Vordergrund ihrer Politik. Doch, hat sie ihre Ziele erreicht? Konnte sie das umsetzen, was sie sich auch wirklich vorgenommen hat?
Marvin Neumann ist Redakteur und Journalist. In Deutschland lebend, berichtet er über gesellschaftliche und politische Themen. Mal aktuell, mal Vergangenes, aber immer mit Respekt und Anstand. Der Drang nach Ausgewogenheit und Fairness ist fundamentaler Bestandteil der Inhalte. Für geschäftliche Anfragen folgende E-Mail verwenden: [email protected]
________
Netiquette-Kommentarsektion: Die Kommentarsektionen unter meinen Videos oder Community Tab-Posts sind dazu da, um mit euch zu kommunizieren und zu interagieren. Immer respektvoll, mit Anstand und Blick auf die Gefühle des Gegenüber. Kritik darf, soll und muss geäußert werden. Letztere Aussagen/ Kommentare müssen aber auf Grundlage des deutschen Rechts stehen, als auch international vereinbarte Menschenrechte wahren.
Ich behalte mir vor bei Nichteinhaltung eines respektvollen Umgangtons oder rechtswidrigem Verhalten Kommentare zu löschen oder einzelne Kommentatoren zu blockieren.
Respekt ist Grundbaustein für eine nachhaltige und gesunde Diskussionskultur. Bitte beherzigt dies! _________
Patreon-Unterstützer:
Achim Reiser DrRush Mr. Koalabär Torsten Scheithauer Andre Rütgers Mathis WIchmann David Sophie Walther Der Fellmacher Emilia Kirner Christopher Stahl Emilia Kirner
It's crazy when you think about it. Annalena Baerbock is the first German foreign minister ever.
In the last 150 years, there has never been a woman in this or a similar office.
Neither in the German Empire, from the end of 1871 to 1919, in the Weimar Republic from 1919 to 1933, in times of National Socialism, neither in the GDR nor in the Federal Republic of Germany.
Since 1951, there has never been a female foreign minister.
And in fact, in Germany, in spite of the overwhelming approval of the Ampel federal government, she is still one of the most popular politicians in the republic.
At least in comparison to the other politicians at the moment.
So, does Annalena Baerbock do a good job? Is she successful in what she has set out to do? And are there any points in which she is having a hard time?
That's exactly what we'll take a look at in this video.
And for my research on the topic, two articles from SPIEGEL, among other things, have come to me.
On the one hand, a critical analysis by Sabine Renefans, which shows how undiplomatic Baerbock appears from time to time.
And another article that shows that this is exactly what is quite good for foreign journalists.
By the way, both articles are really worth reading and normally only people with SPIEGEL plus subscription can read these articles.
But because I work with SPIEGEL as a cooperation partner, the colleagues there have set them free for you.
So that you can just read them without SPIEGEL plus subscription.
So feel free to click on the links to the articles now. You can find them pinned in the comments or in the description box.
And if you still want to have a free SPIEGEL plus subscription for a month, there is one for you too.
And you can also find the link in the description box or in the pinned comment.
And of course I am aware that the question of whether Baerbock does a good job depends on whether you like their demands for more international measures, for example climate protection or feminist foreign policy or not.
Nevertheless, this is of course also an analysis based on different points of view.
We will therefore go through together how the German population perceives it, whether it has achieved its own goals or not, whether it has an impact internationally and how it is perceived within the Greens.
Okay, I think before we look at the numbers, we first have to clarify what the core task of Baerbock is.
The Foreign Office itself defines it as follows, for example.
The Foreign Office represents the interests of Germany in the world. It promotes international exchange and offers Germans protection and assistance abroad.
The Foreign Office therefore promotes intensive exchanges with the world in economy, culture, science and technology, environment, development issues and many other topics.
And Baerbock is of course currently the chief diplomat in all these matters.
And, quote, diplomacy often means that you link relations to other states, come to them in order to be able to make demands in the event of a conflict.
And under these conditions, Baerbock works.
And in two really, as I just mentioned, highly exciting articles, it is also described, quote,
Often she seems to take it upon herself to hit others in the head. And she is also, quote,
After a year, controversial and rhetorically sharp.
By the way, this is what foreign journalists who follow German foreign policy say.
Another quote from the linked article.
So we have clarified Baerbock's framework.
But how popular is Annalena Baerbock with the people in Germany now?
I already mentioned it earlier, Annalena Baerbock is one of the most popular politicians in Germany at the moment.
She is at the forefront of almost all politicians' top ten lists.
At the ZDF Politbarometer, the research group for elections, she is currently in third place.
Behind Defense Minister Boris Pistorius and Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz.
She stayed there for a while, or has remained so far, unlike her party colleague Robert Habeck,
who has often led this list in the last 16 months, but is now slipping away.
However, it must be said that this entire top ten does not shine precisely because the politicians are average popular.
Because actually only Pistorius and Scholz are in the positive rating range.
Baerbock is rated with a 0.0, so pretty neutral and balanced.
And as Federal Foreign Minister, this is actually worse than her colleagues in office in recent years.
Especially in the first 20 months after taking office.
And I already mentioned it in one of my previous videos.
Federal Foreign Ministers stand out because they have historically always been one of the most popular groups of politicians,
compared to their colleagues in other offices in the federal government.
Also because they have to deal less with internal political issues and disputes.
And since the German reunification, there has actually only been one foreign minister who slipped into the negative range in the first time.
And that was the former and now deceased FDP chief Guido Westerwelle.
Let's take a closer look at that.
The Federal Foreign Minister before Annalena Baerbock, i.e. Heiko Maas of the SPD,
was compared to his predecessors in office, i.e. Frank-Walter Steinmeier, Sigmar Gabriel or even Joschka Fischer.
Initially also not a flyer, but only at the end of his term of office, i.e. mid-2021, he slipped into a negative range.
But before that he was also in a positive range.
However, compared to Baerbock, he is also more positive than she is currently.
So, conclusion.
Compared to Annalena Baerbock, it is currently running more or less average in the survey technical area.
If not even worse than with many, many other Federal Foreign Ministers before.
But question to you.
What grade would you actually give Annalena Baerbock?
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6?
So drop me that in the comments below.
Also with reasons, then we can discuss it.
But please stay respectful.
Respectful? Respectful.
We come to the third point, her goals.
And here we travel together in the year 2021, in December 2021.
When the Ampel recorded her government work,
Baerbock emphasized very strongly that the EU is the turning point of foreign policy
and that Germany and France will forever belong together.
Two things that are not really different from what their predecessors did.
Here, a quote from her.
Even if the Ampel coalition is new for Germany,
it remains dependent on our country.
That's what she said back then.
European Union, transatlantic alliances and also, quote, foreign policy, clearly positioned.
That's how she framed it back then.
Nevertheless, there are above all three major differences in the goals of her predecessors.
First, she wanted to give international climate policy, quote,
the place it deserves on the diplomatic agenda, namely at the top.
Second, to promote feminist foreign policy.
Third, to develop a new China strategy.
And in fact, there is a fourth, smaller goal,
namely to make the Foreign Office more female-oriented and climate-oriented.
So what happened to that?
And which goals could she implement or pursue well?
It is also logical that a lot has changed since her office visit at the end of December 2021
and priorities have shifted with the Russian attack on Ukraine.
For example, Baerbock also changed her stance on arms supply by 360 degrees.
Although Baerbock was already a candidate for chancellor in mid-2021,
determined against projects such as Nord Stream 2,
but until the attack on Ukraine by Russia,
Baerbock rejected arms supplies to Ukraine.
Let's start with international climate policy.
Did she fundamentally shift it more to the foreground?
First of all, she managed, or rather, she caused it,
that climate foreign policy moves into the Foreign Office.
Quote,
With the new approach to climate foreign policy,
she has put the responsibility of the German delegation from the Ministry of the Environment in her ministry.
With Secretary of State Jennifer Morgan as special envoy,
she made her ex-Greenpeace boss the head of the delegation.
Her first major intermediate goal was the World Climate Conference in November 2022.
Instead of more and more binding measures for climate protection, however,
Baerbock and the Greens were already happy that
at least the 1.5 degree target has not been moved internationally.
For example, there was no binding agreement
when the world community would like to exit fossil fuels.
On the other hand, as Foreign Minister, she has to explain to her international colleagues
that Germany is putting more money into coal again in the wake of the energy crisis.
Quote,
It was a lost year for climate protection, says Michael Bloss,
climate policy spokesman for the Greens in the European Parliament,
who was there for the EU delegation in Egypt.
So at the World Climate Conference.
At that time, Baerbock had planned more than really got around.
And that even though Baerbock made international climate protection the boss's business.
Now, however, Baerbock is also making a strong point
that more renewable energies should be built in Africa.
For example, she also wants to solve this with climate partnerships,
which, however, have already been introduced before her term of office.
For example, the previous government decided on such a partnership with South Africa
At that time, there was a sum of 700 million euros in the room
to support South Africa in the descent or exit, better said, from the flow of coal.
Okay, but what does that mean in terms of Baerbock's success in international climate policy?
To be honest, it's not that easy to answer.
On the international stage, she is rather disappointed with her own goals
and actually wanted to achieve more.
On the other hand, for the first time ever, there is a compensation fund
in which the big economic nations, including Germany, should pay,
which is then paid in part to developing countries,
which, unlike the industrial states, are significantly less responsible for climate change.
So again, a small success, which of course not only goes back to Baerbock,
but for which she has also made herself strong.
Admittedly, I would say that Baerbock's climate balance is still up for debate.
So here I personally give her a neutral.
Next point. Feminist foreign policy.
And please let us take the outrage out of the debate,
if you hear the word feminism.
As for what it is about feminist foreign policy,
I have already explained in another video,
which you can find linked up here, but in short,
this kind of foreign policy only describes that,
above all, human rights are defended by, quote,
so far largely excluded groups and put them in the foreground.
In addition, one wants to strengthen the representation of women and girls around the world
and promote social diversity.
In addition to equal rights, this kind of foreign policy also strives to
solve conflicts, quote, without violence of arms.
Admittedly, the last point is, with regard to Ukraine,
a rather difficult undertaking.
And yet, after a little more than a year in office,
the Foreign Office and Annalena Baerbock presented
the ten guidelines of German feminist foreign policy at the beginning of March 2023.
Here are two examples.
Guideline number one, quote,
We are integrating the perspective of women and marginalized groups
into our worldwide work for peace and security.
We are changing the agenda of women, peace and security
and developing it further.
We are committed to greater participation of women and marginalized groups
in inclusive peace processes.
We are fighting sexualized and gender-specific violence
in armed conflicts.
We are strengthening humanitarian arms control
for a safe world without nuclear weapons.
Or here, guideline number seven.
We work for equality, diversity and inclusion in the foreign service.
We evaluate our internal structures and processes regularly
and adapt them if necessary.
Within the federal government, we contribute to the further development
of diversity and participation.
We are constantly increasing the number of women in leadership positions.
We support members of our service in individual biographies.
Our staff planning takes into account the needs of our employees.
According to its own statement, the Foreign Office has set an ambitious goal.
By 2025, 85% of the project funds will be allocated
so that the needs of women and marginalized groups are taken into account.
Quote,
It makes a difference whether women can participate
when, for example, a village destroyed by Boko Haram is rebuilt in Nigeria
and their needs are taken into account.
And when we talk about feminist foreign policy,
we also have to talk about Iran and mention the women's rights movement,
which we have seen there for some time.
People who take to the streets there,
protest and fight for gender equality
and therefore endanger themselves from the cruel violence of the ruling regime,
but also from their own, sometimes fellow citizens.
So that's exactly what feminist foreign policy is all about.
And yes, even if Baerbock did not give the right words and the right support in the beginning,
from the point of view of many,
she now promotes the protests,
while the chancellor, Olaf Scholz, basically says nothing and is silent.
That sounds good at first.
So she keeps her principles.
But the sanctions of the EU for the human rights violations of Iran
seem to hit the regime almost not at all
and Iran is still being negotiated with the nuclear agreement
and that would probably also be a priority.
And human rights issues are probably spared at the nuclear agreement.
Quote,
too big the contrast to feminist foreign policy.
So the federal government reveals,
the Chancellery and the Foreign Office,
that feminist foreign policy is nice and good,
but security policy is now more important.
Therefore, the conclusion of feminist foreign policy is probably more neutral to negative.
Last point on our list.
The new China strategy.
Because the federal government and the Foreign Ministry
want or wanted to develop a new China strategy.
In June 2022, Baerbock said this.
Quote,
In dealing with authoritarian states like China, the minister pleaded for more toughness.
The federal government continued to focus on dialogue,
silence, but critical, not death.
It needs a clear stance and language,
even if it is not to accuse itself of double morality.
So Baerbock.
The basic fear and concern of the Foreign Office
is to be repressed by China.
Therefore, the new China strategy is likely to reduce economic dependence on China.
Especially with raw materials,
which are urgently needed, for example in Europe or in Germany,
for the energy transition, Europe is simply very dependent on China.
Therefore, the government and the Foreign Office
want more independence, more economic security
and increase the relevance of human rights.
In the new China strategy.
So you don't want to completely disconnect yourself from China,
you say that yourself, but minimize risks.
But the China strategy is not there yet,
although it should actually be there.
So it actually seems as if,
if you give yourself political observance and faith,
as if the federal government agrees on this issue.
Because not only the Foreign Office,
but also the Ministry of Economy
have internally proposed their own new China strategies.
And it seems as if there are large cuts.
Nevertheless, above all, the tonality is discussed.
We have often experienced that Annalena Baerbock,
as we have just seen or described,
often chooses more direct words and thus often goes head-on.
Which, by the way, also triggered a lot of criticism,
not only by the opposition,
for example, like the AfD or the left,
or even the CDU-CSU,
but actually also internally by the government.
The SPD has often been upset about this,
how Annalena Baerbock,
as we have just heard,
has internationally put other foreign ministers
in front of their heads.
But the plan of the government and the Foreign Office
still leaves a lot to be desired.
Whether you are waiting for the attack on Russia,
whether you still have to clarify a lot internally,
whether you prefer to agree with other EU states,
it's not all that clear.
That's why you can't judge it that well here either.
That's why it's more neutral.
Conclusion
Does Baerbock do a good job now?
According to their own set goals,
you have to say yes or no,
or rather neutral than anything else.
And it feels like the result
that is currently coming to the population
with the survey results, for example.
The people in Germany are less positively
or negatively affected by Baerbock's work at the moment.
I think you just have to wait a little longer
and give it at least another 2023
to get a better look at it,
especially in relation to the climate goals.
Because the next World Climate Conference
is coming up again.
How do you rate Annalena Baerbock?
Write that to me in the comments
with the grade of 1.
6. Please be respectful.
If you don't do that,
you will also be locked out of these comments.
And don't forget to click on the two
SPIEGEL PLUS articles
and dive even deeper into the topic.
Thank you, your Marvin.
See you next time.